Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Executive Summary
Every CIO wants to know if their infrastructure will handle it when data growth reaches 40 zettabytes by
2020.
When data sets become too large, application performance slows and infrastructure struggles to keep
up. Data growth drives increased cost and complexity everywhere, including power consumption, data
center space, performance and availability.
System availability is impacted as batch processes are no longer able to meet scheduled completion
times. The “outage windows” necessary to convert data during ERP upgrade cycles may extend from
hours to days.
Other critical processes such as replication and disaster recovery are impacted because more data is
just harder to MOVE and COPY.
Left unchecked, data growth may also create governance, risk, and compliance challenges. HIPAA, PCI
DSS, FISMA, and SAS 70 mandates all require that organizations establish compliance frameworks for
According to data security and compliance.
Gartner, data
growth is the We know the value of data declines with age because it becomes less
No. 1 infrastructure active. Enterprise data must be managed so inactive data doesn’t clog the
challenge for infrastructure and impact critical processing.
data centers.
On the other hand, enterprise data is no longer confined to enterprise data centers.
Business critical data grows outside of the firewalls — with social media sites, blogs, hosted CRMs, etc.
Enterprises must manage these data sources in order to stay relevant in the competitive world.
Enterprise applications such as ERP, CRM, and HCM represent an excellent opportunity for improving
performance and reducing costs through application tiering with Apache Hadoop.
Source: Solix
Effective use of social data is vital in delivering a high level of customer satisfaction.
A first class passenger on an international flight tweeted about the bad food on the plane. This tweet
was read by a ground crew member who relayed the feedback to the flight crew within minutes. This
passenger, a high value customer with a lot of social media “followers,” was pampered for the rest of
the flight, prompting a glowing review of the airline to his followers.
Proactive tracking and management of social data was critical to rectifying the concerns of a
high-value social influencer and improving the Net-Promoter-Score.
4
Source: Solix
Solix is the only vendor today with a solution that provides comprehensive ILM for all enterprise data —
structured and unstructured.
Source: Solix
5
While unstructured data archiving is relatively simple as Apache Hadoop tier 7+ years
it is primarily based on age, structured data archiving is
Apache Hadoop is the ideal platform for a grand
complex requiring that multiple criteria be factored into
archive because it offers the lowest cost solution for
the process.
bulk data storage. Hadoop provides a point-in-time
The best way to improve the management of enterprise snapshot of a business record. Because the data
data is to create tiers of data based on value. Our represents a complete business object decoupled
recommended ILM best practice is to leverage four from the application, data no longer must be
processing tiers integrated with Apache Hadoop: upgraded in synch with the application. Big data
analytics tools — text search as well as traditional
Production Tier: 0 – 1 year structured query tools — provide enhanced access
Highest performance infrastructure is reserved for high to the data.
value, active data. Large flash arrays manage OLTP
Source: Solix
processing loads in-memory for maximum performance.
Source: Solix
6
Apache Hadoop is a free, open source computing framework designed to operate powerful, low-cost
infrastructure at a lesser tier while still delivering massive scalability and performance.
Using the MapReduce programming model to process large data sets across distributed compute nodes in
parallel, Hadoop delivers highly scalable workload performance and very low-cost, bulk data storage.
All this means that Hadoop offers dramatic cost savings over traditional tier one infrastructure.
Consider the following comparison: According to Monash Research, the cost of tier one database
infrastructure is more than $60,000 per TB. At the same time, 1TB of S3 bucket storage at Amazon Web
Services is $30 per month according to their recent price list.
Recent Gartner research states that by 2017 enterprise archiving will represent
25% of the information governance efforts in enterprises. By 2016, 75% of
enterprise archiving solutions will incorporate support for big data analytics.
$ 1,080 $ 60,022
Source: Solix
Source: Solix
7
The Solix Big Data suite provides the framework The suite is highly scalable, with an extensible
for an ILM continuum that ensures CIO’s don’t connector framework to ingest all the enterprise
have to choose between application performance, data. The integrated suite allows seamless
operational efficiency, and cost. archiving, retirement, and flexible extract
transform load (ETL) capabilities to improve the
Gartner says, “Any organization speed of deployment, decrease the cost, and
optimize infrastructure. Solix also supports on-
thinking of simply applying existing
premise and cloud-based deployment on a variety
information governance practices to of Hadoop distributions.
big data will likely fail — not least
because much data is ungoverned; The Solix Big Data Suite harnesses the
capabilities of Hadoop to create a comprehensive
or governed by others according to a and efficient platform that creates unified and
different set of objectives.” cost-effective ILM and BI infrastructures for all
data, requiring smaller teams with fewer IT skills,
The Solix Big Data Suite provides the first true
while allowing quicker rollouts and faster results.
ILM continuum that addresses the complexity of
governance in the Big Data world while ensuring
The Solix Big Data Suite includes:
governance for core enterprise applications is not
sacrificed. • Solix Enterprise Archiving to improve
enterprise application performance and reduce
The Solix Big Data Suite’s ILM framework manages infrastructure costs. Enterprise application
the data within HDFS and HBASE. The Solix ILM data is first moved and then purged from its
framework also provides an integrated retention- source location according to ILM policies
management and legal-hold capability for data to ensure governance, risk, and compliance
within Apache Hadoop. objectives are met.
Structured and unstructured data from other data • The Solix Enterprise Data Lake reduces
sources are migrated into HDFS/HBASE with full the complexity and processing burden to
data-validation and audit reports. These reports stage enterprise data warehouse (EDW) and
provide the necessary defensibility and chain of analytics applications and provides highly
custody for compliance and data governance. efficient, low-cost, bulk storage of enterprise
data for later use when it is needed. Solix Data
This extensive ILM framework allows the Solix Big Lake provides a copy of production data and
Data Suite to create a unified repository to capture stores it “as is” in bulk for later use.
all enterprise data and optimally organize it for
analytics tools offered through the Solix App Store. • The Solix App Store offers pre-integrated
analytics tools for data within Enterprise
Archiving and the Enterprise Data Lake.
8
Source: Solix
Source: Solix
9
Conclusion
The landscape of Enterprise data is changing
with the advent of Enterprise Social Data,
IOT, Logs, Clicks. The reason this is called big
data is because this exceeds the processing
capacity of conventional database systems.
The data is too big, moves too fast, or doesn’t
fit the strictures of your current database
architectures. To gain value from this data,
you need new infrastructure to manage it,
and that is Apache Hadoop.
Source: Solix
Source: Solix
10
Infographic: Solving the Data Growth Crisis with Apache Hadoop
Source: Solix
11
From the Gartner Files:
FIGURE 1 Magic Quadrant for Structured Data Archiving and Application Retirement
DataVard DCSoftware
DataVard offers OutBoard for SAP archiving. The DCSoftware's Arctools focuses primarily on
vendor has been steadily growing its archiving JD Edwards archiving through the availability
installed base as an outgrowth of its SAP of dozens of predefined purge modules for JD
performance analysis capabilities, its primary Edwards. Arctools supports AS/400 (aka IBM i),
area of focus. OutBoard includes the Erna module, Oracle and SQL Server databases; however, the
which operates as a kind of housekeeper, deleting AS/400 product has a different codebase than
unneeded information and improving system the Oracle and SQL Server products. Its archiving
performance. DataVard is also a co-developer of method is straightforward, consisting of copying
SAP NetWeaver Information Lifecycle Management or moving data from a table in the live system
(ILM) with a focus on database connectivity, and inserting into the same table in the archive.
and improving document and digital imaging Arctools provides the ability to run reports from
processing. In addition to support for SAP Business native applications for both the live system data
Warehouse (BW) and ERP archiving, DataVard and the archive data with little or no modification.
has a growing number of customers for SAP Usually sold as an on-premises solution, Arctools
Hana, and offers a wide range of storage options does have a subscription model that can be
including Sybase IQ, Apache Hadoop, any certified purchased through a customer's service provider of
SAP database and file, and Amazon cloud-based choice.
storage.
Arctools is a solid choice for JD Edwards archiving,
DataVard is best-used in BW archiving scenarios and has several hundred customers archiving from
and production SAP environments, where that platform. Arctools has recently introduced a
containing costs but making data readily available product for Oracle E-Business Suite, but it is still in
(such as in Hadoop-based data lakes) is required. beta as of the publishing of this report.
Moving forward, DataVard looks to expand
capabilities in areas such as application retirement, Strengths
and grow its global presence.
• Arctools has deep knowledge of JD Edwards'
Strengths systems.
• DataVard provides a more open and modern • The product is easy to use, even with limited
approach to SAP with extensive infrastructure knowledge of the system or the archive.
support.
• Data integrity validation options before, during
• OutBoard is priced favorably in a market and after moving data to the archive are robust.
where SAP archiving tends to be prohibitively
expensive. Cautions
• DataVard provides related services in SAP • Arctools does not have granular retention
management, and has strong SAP domain management capabilities.
expertise.
• Arctools does not support data masking.
Cautions
• Arctools is for active archiving use cases only,
• DataVard has no demonstrated SAP application not for application retirement.
retirement customers, despite being a co-
development partner with SAP on the SAP
NetWeaver ILM product.
Delphix EMC
Delivered as a software appliance, Delphix's EMC InfoArchive is EMC's solution for structured
primary use case is focused on testing and data archiving and application retirement,
development through providing virtualized images which it offers stand-alone or with a number
of the database. Delphix Live Archive provides of complementary products. The product can
application archiving by creating a virtualized be used for database table and data, file and
image of the entire stack that can be mounted collaborative application (for example, IBM Notes,
at a future date when access is required. Much SharePoint or EMC Documentum) archiving and
of Delphix's archiving business is driven through decommissioning. Various content and platform
application migration to the cloud, as creating an connectors are available directly from EMC or via
archive image ensures data integrity if needed partners. Data is stored in a unified repository in
during the process and allows for retention an open format using XML, and all content stored
of compliance data that does not need to be can be accessed via granular full text searches,
migrated to the cloud application. In 2014, Delphix Java Database Connectivity (JDBC)-supported
added vFiles, which can archive files and also business applications or, in some cases, native
archive flat files created from an archived virtual applications via partners. The latest version of
machine (VM) image. InfoArchive is tightly integrated with EMC's
Isilon storage platform (including storage-level
In the case of archiving, Delphix is well-suited for retention using Isilon SmartLock and support
shorter-term archive scenarios where licenses for for Hadoop Distributed File System [HDFS]), as
the original database and application are readily well as with its EMC ViPR and Elastic Cloud
available. In the future, Delphix will consolidate Storage (ECS) platforms (ensuring that storage
multiple data warehouse schemas into a single provisioned by these applications will be supported
dataset that can be queried as a single tablespace. by InfoArchive). In addition to on-premises
Expect more cloud options (namely with CSC) deployments, InfoArchive can be run as a service
in 2015, in addition to existing IBM, AWS and using EMC's hosted Managed Services OnDemand
VMware cloud support. offering. EMC also offers Documentum Archive
Services for SAP with support for SAP ILM.
Strengths
EMC has demonstrated an ability to support use
• Delphix's TimeFlow feature allows the archived cases where unstructured/structured requirements
VM to be rolled back to any point and time. converge. Buyers should consider EMC at a more
granular level if the organization has a need for
• Fully integrated data masking allows archive a unified repository supporting multiple data
sets to be used for analysis and test/ types from multiple applications, and has strong
development. retention management requirements.
Cautions Strengths
• InfoArchive's customer base remains relatively • Pricing is a positive for HP, with customers
small, and some customers have faced lengthy charged per source database instance
deployment cycles. (regardless of data volumes). This enables HP
to scale down and enable prospects that either
• Archive Services for SAP is part of EMC don't have a large data footprint or wish to start
Documentum and is not tightly integrated with small.
InfoArchive.
• HP Structured Data Manager has good retention
• A reliance on partners in some cases for management capabilities and the ability to
connector technology means that sales and store archived data in HP Records Manager.
deployment can be complex.
• HP Structured Data Manager is a feature-rich
HP product with support for big data analytics
HP offers HP Structured Data Manager for database through integration with HP Vertica, as well as
archiving and application retirement. HP Structured data masking with multiple repository options.
Data Manager supports a broader variety of
applications like Oracle E-Business systems and Cautions
PeopleSoft, and underlying databases, including
Microsoft SQL Server and IBM DB2. Database-to- • Structured data archiving knowledge and skill
database and database-to-file archiving are both sets are relatively narrow within HP.
supported, and the product is integrated with HP
• HP's customer base comprises primarily Oracle
Intelligent Data Operating Layer (IDOL), enabling
E-Business systems users. Buyers should test
search and retrieval across production and archive
HP's domain expertise in other application
databases. Data masking is provided natively. On-
environments.
premises, private, hybrid and public cloud (such as
HP Cloud Services) implementations are supported.
• HP Structured Data Manager does not provide
Apache Hadoop (HDFS) is supported as an archive
automated data life cycle management/tiering
target. The product is integrated with HP Records
for storage.
Manager for records management. SAP archiving
is supported via SAP ArchiveLink. HP is continuing
to make significant investments to regain market
share in database archiving and application
retirement.
IBM Informatica
IBM InfoSphere Optim has a significant lead Informatica offers Informatica Data Archive,
in market share for database and application which supports a wide array of applications and
archiving/retirement. IBM utilizes highly underlying databases resident on distributed
compressed, immutable binary files (Optim File systems or mainframe platforms. The product
Format, CSV or XML) for archiving. Optim provides also supports archiving from Apache Hadoop,
a significant assembly of application sources such IBM PureData System for Analytics and Teradata,
as Oracle E-Business Suite, PeopleSoft, Siebel, as well as SaaS applications, such as Salesforce.
JD Edwards, Baan and SAP, along with IBM DB2, Informatica includes a capability it calls Smart
Oracle and Microsoft SQL Server at the database Partitioning, which allows administrators to
level. In the spirit of supporting internal systems, relocate related inactive records across tables into
Optim also supports direct archiving from PureData a single database table space, and then effectively
and ships with IBM HDFS. IBM has broad support exclude "smart partitions" from database
for retention and compliance through policy production operations, including queries, reports
management, legal hold and discovery. and nonproduction copies. This "archive in place"
ensures that the database remains intact, retains
IBM InfoSphere Optim is on most RFIs for medium data for compliance and improves performance.
to large organizational archiving and application
retirement initiatives. Expect IBM to continue Informatica Data Archive offers both native
to refine the user interface in 2015. In addition, dynamic data masking and compliance
product initiative and marketing messages will be management, which includes retention policies,
aimed more to the business users going forward. legal hold and data disposal. In 2014, Informatica
IBM is a market leader for Hadoop as an archiving released its Application Retirement for Healthcare
platform — assume more offerings in this area Solution, which includes a patient-centric portal for
going forward. reporting, Audit Logging for HIPAA compliance and
Accounts Receivable Burndown to manage legacy
Strengths receivables as part of its effort to focus on that
vertical. Informatica Data Archive also supports
• Optim is a proven archiving solution for large- SAP archiving. Informatica has revamped its
scale environments. pricing, with the introduction of a Secure Edition
aimed at application retirement that includes
• As part of IBM's Information Lifecycle Data Vault, a repository component providing
Management (ILM) strategy, Optim offers extreme compression, role-based security and
strong business rule capabilities and policy open access. Other product packages are available,
management. including one aimed at live archiving of production
environments, and another focused on application
• Optim offers tight integration with the rest of retirement for vertical applications as well as
the IBM Information Management Systems, historical analytics use cases. The product can
including InfoSphere products such as also be deployed as a customer-managed service
Guardium, FileNet and Atlas. via public cloud storage, such as Amazon Simple
Storage Service (S3). On 7 April 2015, Informatica
Cautions announced plans to be acquired by Permira Funds
and Canada Pension Plan Investment Board.
• Although IBM continually works on
The deal is pending shareholder and regulatory
improvement of user interface and report
approvals, scheduled to close in 2Q15 or 3Q15.
viewing, many users find them difficult to work
Informatica has told customers and partners that
with and cite them as being antiquated.
its commitment to delivering on its roadmap
remains unchanged.
• Pricing and licensing continue to be hurdles for
customers, including pricing based on ingestion
instead of final storage.
Strengths OpenText
OpenText offers OpenText Archiving for SAP
• Informatica's deep data integration heritage
Solutions, including OpenText Data Archiving for
allows it to leverage highly optimized
SAP Solutions and OpenText Document Access
connectivity for archiving use cases.
for SAP Solutions, for archiving SAP data and
content. In addition to the SAP archiving products,
• Informatica has a strong vision with a targeted
OpenText offers the InfoFusion Integration
and focused roadmap, and has delivered on
Center and InfoFusion Discovery Platform for
its commitments in the past. The company
application decommissioning, data archiving and
addresses a large number of use cases
information governance for non-SAP relational
including retirement, compliance, performance
database management system (RDBMS) content.
optimization and analytics.
The products offer consolidated extraction,
transformation and loading (ETL), advanced search,
• Performance optimization is a strong use case
content analytics and connectors to a wide variety
for Informatica. Smart Partitioning is a popular
of structured and unstructured data sources.
choice for active database archiving.
Content from all products is stored in the OpenText
Cautions Content Suite. Active archiving is a strength for
OpenText, as documents like scanned images
• Informatica's customers have cited ease of use and unstructured content can be combined with
of Informatica Data Archive as an area in need archived data in support of business processes
of improvement. and workflow. Retention management includes
support for records management and legal hold.
• With the exception of cloud service pricing, Content can be classified during archiving or
Informatica is priced for clients with a sizable using OpenText Auto-Classification capabilities.
data footprint or large number of applications. OpenText's SAP archiving products are priced per
Its offerings do not scale down in price. named SAP user. InfoFusion Discovery Platform
pricing is based on a combination of connectors
• Pending shareholder and regulatory approvals, and seats for various functions, such as search,
Informatica will be acquired by private equity classification and content remediation.
this year, so funding levels for Informatica Data
Archive are unclear. Strengths
Cautions
• PBS is releasing support for additional nearline • Solix is at the forefront of offering archiving
databases, as well as a new product (EDS for capabilities for and supporting use cases
NAI) — prospects and customers should ensure involving big data, with wide support for various
they are comfortable with levels of support and Hadoop distributions.
feature/product maturity.
20
Cautions Cautions
• Solix is still small enough that it can often be • RainStor's administration tools are command-
spread thin from a personnel standpoint line-driven and need to have a graphical user
interface that can centralize management.
• SAP archiving is a work in progress with a major
release slated for year-end 2015. • Non-Teradata customers who use RainStor
should pay attention to the roadmap as it
• As a platform, Solix requires ample out-of-the- develops to ensure Teradata continues to
box configuration during the setup phase. support their non-Teradata environments.
Market Responsiveness/Track Record: Sales Strategy: The vendor’s strategy for selling
Includes the ability to respond, change direction to its target audience, including an analysis of
and be flexible as market dynamics vary. This the appropriate mix of direct and indirect sales
criterion also considers the vendor’s history of channels.
responsiveness.
22
The Trend Toward Big Data Analytics Most of the IT focus on preparing for and
and Petabyte-Scale Archives responding to e-discovery requests has been
for unstructured data. However, there have
The growing use of Apache Hadoop, increasing been numerous cases where structured data
data warehouse volume sizes and the has been a target for discovery requests. The
accumulation of legacy systems in organizations discovery of structured data presents a warning,
are fostering structured data growth. These factors and organizations want to ensure they can
are leading enterprises to understand how to reuse, respond quickly to requests for information
repurpose and gain critical insight from this data. when that information is not accessible from
Apache Hadoop is capable of storing large volumes its native application. By taking an active and
of data. Thus, organizations are using HDFS to systematic approach to application retirement,
store structured data, as well as information such organizations can purge data that no longer has
as social and machine data that doesn't fit into business relevance, not only to reduce costs
databases. Many organizations are looking to for maintenance, but also to reduce the cost of
add structure and meaning to this information responding to e-discovery requests by making data
repository, beyond just using it as a low-cost more searchable, defensible and easier to preserve.
means of storage. Structured data archiving
vendors have responded by adding support for
Role of SAP in Structured Data
Apache Hadoop as a data source and a target.
Gartner expects to see this emerging requirement Archiving and Retirement
for Hadoop support going beyond baseline storage The structured data archiving market includes
management to include support for more analytic solutions that archive data from applications
tools (for example, from Tableau Software) and such as those from SAP. As is the case for any
other reporting mechanisms, to the point where application, previous SAP instances need to be
the line between archiving and active use will retired and the data managed systematically for
blur. Big data analytic tools will become a baseline cost and governance reasons, with support for
component of structured data archiving tools by ongoing access to data. This trend is accelerating,
2016. The various distributions of Hadoop, such with a steady stream of Gartner clients inquiring
as Hortonworks and Cloudera, are increasingly about SAP retirement as extended maintenance
emphasizing information life cycle and retention will be expiring soon for some SAP applications,
management in Hadoop. This will put pressure such SAP CRM, Supply Chain Management (SCM)
on structured data archiving vendors to innovate and Supplier Relationship Management (SRM)
further in this area; for example, some vendors are 2007. In many instances, vendors such as IBM
beginning to provide integration and support for and Informatica provide solutions for archiving
technologies like Hive to allow for SQL-like queries directly from databases, as well as active archiving,
into the archived data. and application retirement for SAP and other
ERP and CRM applications. Numerous vendors
Growing Importance of Information are certified and support SAP archiving for active
Governance in Structured Data archiving through the SAP ADK and XML Archive
API. Gartner inquiries show that clients are open
Structured data from applications is an easy target to alternatives to this approach, indicating that,
for external auditors. They are experienced in although solutions exist, lack of credible SAP
identifying the relevant applications and lack of expertise and high prices have plagued adoption.
controls that may occur in protecting valuable Like the interest in application retirement, some
financial data. In some respects, it's an easier task vendors have identified these gaps in a well-
than identifying unstructured content, such as established market and are making inroads
spreadsheets that contain financial data that may against long-established players. A new use case
be scattered and managed lightly in the enterprise. emerging for SAP archiving is the need to extract
Auditors may raise a red flag if the legacy data from SAP Hana, as organizations look to
application is so old that it's no longer supported manage older, less frequently accessed data in
or loosely managed. Migrating data to an upgraded lower-cost environments like Hadoop rather than
version of the application or to an alternate with in-memory databases like Hana. As part of
format may mitigate this problem of maintaining the Magic Quadrant for Structured Data Archiving
structured data. and Application Retirement, Gartner evaluated and
identified SAP archiving and retirement solutions.
25
Operations: The ability of the organization to Vertical/Industry Strategy: The vendor’s strategy
meet its goals and commitments. Factors include to direct resources, skills and offerings to meet
the quality of the organizational structure, the specific needs of individual market segments,
including skills, experiences, programs, systems including vertical markets.
and other vehicles that enable the organization to
operate effectively and efficiently on an ongoing Innovation: Direct, related, complementary
basis. and synergistic layouts of resources, expertise or
capital for investment, consolidation, defensive or
Completeness of Vision pre-emptive purposes.
Market Understanding: Ability of the vendor
Geographic Strategy: The vendor’s strategy to
to understand buyers’ wants and needs and to
direct resources, skills and offerings to meet the
translate those into products and services. Vendors
specific needs of geographies outside the “home”
that show the highest degree of vision listen to
or native geography, either directly or through
and understand buyers’ wants and needs, and can
partners, channels and subsidiaries as appropriate
shape or enhance those with their added vision.
for that geography and market.
Marketing Strategy: A clear, differentiated set of Source: Gartner RAS Core Research Note G00266173,
messages consistently communicated throughout Garth Landers, Alan Dayley, Sheila Childs, 16 June 2015
the organization and externalized through the
website, advertising, customer programs and
positioning statements.
About Us
Solix Technologies, Inc., the leading provider of Enterprise Data
Management (EDM) solutions, is transforming information
management with the first enterprise archiving and data lake
application suite for big data: The Solix Big Data Suite. Solix is
helping organizations learn more from their data with enterprise
analytics and achieve Information Lifecycle Management (ILM)
goals. The Solix Enterprise Data Management Suite (Solix EDMS)
and Solix Enterprise Standard Edition (SE) enable organizations to
improve application performance, meet compliance objectives and
reduce the cost of data management across the enterprise. Solix
Technologies, Inc. is headquartered in Santa Clara, California and
operates worldwide through an established network of value added
resellers (VARs) and systems integrators.
Enterprise Archiving with Apache Hadoop is published by Solix. Editorial content supplied by Solix is independent of Gartner analysis. All Gartner research is used with Gartner’s
permission, and was originally published as part of Gartner’s syndicated research service available to all entitled Gartner clients. © 2015 Gartner, Inc. and/or its affiliates. All
rights reserved. The use of Gartner research in this publication does not indicate Gartner’s endorsement of Solix’s products and/or strategies. Reproduction or distribution of this
publication in any form without Gartner’s prior written permission is forbidden. The information contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. Gartner
disclaims all warranties as to the accuracy, completeness or adequacy of such information. The opinions expressed herein are subject to change without notice. Although Gartner
research may include a discussion of related legal issues, Gartner does not provide legal advice or services and its research should not be construed or used as such. Gartner is a
public company, and its shareholders may include firms and funds that have financial interests in entities covered in Gartner research. Gartner’s Board of Directors may include
senior managers of these firms or funds. Gartner research is produced independently by its research organization without input or influence from these firms, funds or their
managers. For further information on the independence and integrity of Gartner research, see “Guiding Principles on Independence and Objectivity” on its website, http://www.
gartner.com/technology/about/ombudsman/omb_guide2.jsp.