The Institute of Canine Biology Search

HOME Blog Breed Preservation Projects Courses Health Data Resources About Us more...

An update on the genetic status of the Doberman Pinscher

RSS Feed
3/12/2017
Archives
By Carol Beuchat PhD
January 2020
The Doberman Pinscher is in serious trouble. About 60% of the breed is afflicted with dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM), with 13%
affected by the time they are 6 years old and more than 40% by the age of 8. The disorder has an autosomal dominant pattern of October 2017
inheritance, but the causative genes are unknown. August 2017
May 2017
April 2017
March 2017
February 2017
January 2017
December 2016
November 2016
September 2016
August 2016
July 2016
June 2016
April 2016
March 2016
February 2016
January 2016
December 2015
November 2015
October 2015
September 2015
August 2015
July 2015
June 2015
May 2015
April 2015
DCM is fatal. The heart fails, sometimes in the absence of any symptoms of a problem, and the dog simply drops dead - in the March 2015
middle of a game of fetch, during a run on an agility course, or while the family is away during the day at work and school. Most January 2015
dogs die in their prime and even younger.  December 2014
November 2014
(In the first graph below, the data are divided into age cohorts and no animal appears in more than one age group.) October 2014
September 2014
August 2014
July 2014
How long do they live?
June 2014
May 2014
February 2014
December 2013
October 2013
September 2013
July 2013
March 2013
July 2012
April 2012

Categories

All
Behavior
Border Collie
Herding

Search
Where did this horrible problem come from?

We have good data about the history of DCM in the breed. In 1990, the incidence was already quite high, with more than 25% of
dogs affected. Since then, DCM has increased essentially linearly by about 1.5% per year.  At this rate, by 2040, 100% of the
Doberman breed will be afflicted with DCM.

Clearly, the efforts made by breeders over the last three decades to decrease the incidence DCM have had no effect at all on the
prevalence of the disorder. Not even a little.

I wrote last summer about the tragedy of watching this noble breed go extinct before our very eyes (see Are We Watching the
Extinction of a Breed?).

What are we doing to deal with this problem? Breeders are routinely monitoring their dogs for the electrical abnormalities that are
signs of DCM. They are trying to select from lines that appear to be less afflicted with the problem.

However, the question nobody seems to be asking is whether it is even possible to rid the breed of this problem through selective
breeding. Can better monitoring and ever more selective breeding reduce the incidence of this horrible problem in Dobermans? Is
there enough genetic diversity in the breed to "breed away" from DCM?

What is the genetic status of the Doberman?

In my earlier post, I presented a summary of data for genetic diversity in various dog breeds, including the Doberman. There are
now additional data that give us a broader picture of the genetic status of the Doberman.

First, this graph is the up-to-date summary of the genetic diversity in Dobermans that have been examined by MyDogDNA. The
color scale at the bottom indicates the ranges of high and low diversity. The data include dogs from the US, Austria, Russia, the
United Kingdom, Finland, Australia, and Ukraine. The median heterozygosity for this group is 26.6% (blue), which is less than the
median for other pinscher and schnauzer-type breeds (34.2%; green) and for all dogs (34.6%; orange). 

Below I have graphed the data for genetic diversity of all dog breeds analyzed by MyDogDNA on their website. In the top panel,
the Doberman, with a median heterozygosity of 26.6%, is indicated by the arrow. Below that is a graph that includes all of the
breeds they have measured. (These graphs are taken from  my earlier post.) For reference, the green line is the average
heterozygosity for mixed breed dogs (43%), and the red line is the median heterozygosity for all dogs in the MyDogDNA database.
Higher heterozygosity is better; if a dog was heterozygous at all loci the value would be 50% using this method.
We now have new data from a separate study (Dreger et al 2017) on a different cohort of dogs (see Inbreeding of Purebred Dogs
Determined from DNA). They used a different method for estimating the proportion of the genome that is homozygous called
"runs of homozygosity" (ROH). This method identifies blocks of consecutive homozygous loci, then adds the total length of these
blocks and divides by the total length of chromosomes covered by markers to produce the inbreeding coefficient. Lower values of
inbreeding are better.

The hand thing about this estimate of inbreeding is that the value indicates two things: 1) the probability that an animal will inherit
two copies of the same allele from an ancestor (i.e., homozygous for that allele), and 2) the fraction of all loci that are
homozygous. 

From this study, the average inbreeding coefficient of the Doberman is 43% (red arrow on the enlarged graph on the left, blue on
the graph for all breeds on the left). This means that 
on average, nearly half the genome of a dog is homozogyous, with two copies of the same allele;
the risk of any particular locus being homozygous for the same allele - whether good or bad - is 43%;
on average, 43% of the genomes of any two dogs are the same.

In addition to the data on inbreeding and heterozygosity of the whole genome in Dobermans, we now also have information
specifically about the genes of the immune system.

The immune system protects an animal from all manner of outside invaders, from bacteria and viruses to fungi and parasites. It
must be able to recognize a bewildering diversity of pathogens as foreign, then marshall the specific cellular defense mechanisms
necessary to destroy them. At the same time, it must be able to distinguish "self" from "non-self"; failure to do this is the cause of
autoimmune disorders, in which the immune system attacks one of the body's own tissues.

The genes for the immune system in the dog are called the "dog leukocyte antigens" (DLA). They tend to be inherited as blocks of
genes called haplotypes. There are two types of DLA haplotypes called DLA Class I and DLA Class II. Like single alleles, an animal
can inherit two copies of the same haplotype or they can be different (i.e., homozygous or heterozygous).

In most animals, the genes of the immune system are the most diverse in the entire genome, and in wild animals there is strong
selection to keep them that way. In purebred dogs, however, inbreeding, strong selection, bottlenecks, and genetic drift have
reduced the genetic diversity across the genome, including the Class I and Class II DLA.

Take for example these data for DLA diversity from UC Davis in nine breeds of dogs (see  Inbreeding and the Immune System:
Unintended Consequences). The graph shows the number of haplotypes found in a survey of each breed, separated into Class I
and Class II DLA.

You can see that the breed with the highest number of haplotypes, the Standard Poodle, has about 45 Class I haplotypes and 28 of
Class II. The Poodle suffers from many autoimmune disorders, including Addison's disease,  sebaceous adenitis, immune mediated
hemolytic anemia, immune mediated thrombocytopenia, chronic hepatitis, temporalmandibular myositis, Evan's syndrome,
immune pancytopenia, and chronic thyroiditis    (Pedersen et al 2015). Even as it has the highest DLA diversity of the particular
breeds in this study, it suffers from a compromised immune system as a consequence of strong selective breeding and genetic
bottlenecks (Pedersen et al 2015).

Unfortunately, among the other breeds that were tested, the Doberman fared the worst, with less than 10 DLA haplotypes for
either Class I and Class II. Even if DCM could be eliminated from the breed, the Doberman would still suffer from issues realated to
the poor health of the immune system.

This is the assessment of Dr Niels Pedersen, who is conducting a study of genetic diversity in Dobermans at UC Davis.

1) "This study of 71 Doberman establishes a desperate need for breeders to search the world for pockets of
genetic diversity that does not exist in the present population, just as was done by Standard Poodle and Italian
Greyhound breeders. Eastern Europe and more isolated areas of Western Europe would be ideal places to search
for such diversity. Genetic introgressions <cross-breeding> with similar dogs may be required, but such
outcrossing must be based on sound genetic knowledge and careful monitoring of new diversity to see that it is
not lost by backcrossing or contained to only a fraction of the breed."

2) "In the case of diseases such as DCM, the genetic traits responsible for the disease may already be fixed in
certain varieties of the breed, reminiscent of hyperuricosuria in the Dalmatian. A lack of genetic diversity greatly
limits the ability to find reasonably unrelated mates, but when this lack is combined with the need to select
against a large number of heritable traits, the ability to identify genetically suitable mates becomes even more
difficult."

The bottom line

The Doberman has the lowest diversity in the DLA genes of the immune system of any of the breeds studied to date by Pedersen's
lab at UC Davis. This, together with the high level of inbreeding documented from multiple studes and the overall relatedness of
the dogs in the population, leaves breeders with little ability to circumvent the multiple genetic diseases in the breed. Furthermore,
some deleterious genes could be fixed in the breed - that is, the normal, non-mutated version of the gene is no longer present in
the gene pool and therefore are not available for selection.

It is highly unlikely that the desperate genetic situation of the Doberman can be improved by selective breeding within the closed
gene pool of the breed. It should be made very clear to breeders that they will not restore health to this breed by selecting against
health problems. Furthermore, trying to select less related parents in an effort to improve diversity in the offspring is a bit like
pushing your peas around on your plate; you might look like you're accomplishing something, but with little effect.

The only hope for this breed is the initiation of a sound, comprehensive cross-breeding program, under the guidance of population
geneticists, that will introduce new genetic diversity into the breed. The longer it takes to begin genetic rescue, the more difficult it
will be and the less likely it is to be successful.

A final word

We have a moral obligation to restore the noble Doberman breed back to health, and this effort needs to begin immediately. 

I repeat what I said in my earlier post:

DNA testing does not make someone a "responsible" breeder. Caring for the heritage of your breed does not make you a
 "preservation" breeder. Pride and love and dedication are all terrific, but they will not prevent the heartbreak that awaits thousands
of Doberman owners in the future. Breeders need to DO something about this. We need to step up to the plate and acknowledge
that continuing to breed dogs that are likely to die of a genetic disorder is irresponsible, unethical, and inhumane. That is certainly
how the average, everyday dog lover feels. This is also how I feel.

REFERENCES

Pedersen NC, L Brucker, NG Tessier, H Liu, M Cecilia, T Penedo, S Hughes, A Oberbauer, & B Sacks. The effect of genetic
bottlenecks and inbreeding on the incidence of two major autoimmune diseases in Standard Poodles, sebaceous adenitis and
Addison's disease. Canine Genetics and Epidemiology 2:13. DOI 10.1186/s40575-015-0026-5.
 

See also these posts about the Doberman:

Beuchat C. 2016. Are we watching the extinction of a breed? (or, Why are we focused on consequence instead of cause?)

Beuchat C. 2016. Are we watching the extinction of a breed? (part 2)

Beuchat C. 2017 Are preservation breeders preserving the Doberman? (No.)

Check out
ICB's online courses

*******************

Join our Facebook Group

ICB Breeding for the Future
...the science of dog breeding
*******************

Visit our Facebook Page

ICB Institute of Canine Biology
...the latest canine news and research

Like 10K Tweet

Comments are closed.

Blog

News

About Us

Contact Us

Copyright © 2012-2017 Institute of Canine Biology