Job /File No JTP-213-GCW-DR-01-R0

JTP CONSULTING ENGINEERS PRIVATE LIMITED CIVIL &

Divn/Dept STRUCTURAL
CLIENT GCW - ULTRATECH CEMENT PVT LTD Reviewed by MR/SR/MNK

SOLID WASTE STORAGE TRANSPORT SYSTEM Checked by JTP

PROJECT
CONVEYOR - 745BC01 DESIGN REVIEW Date 23/06/2015
ITEM DESCRIPTION OF REVIEW COMMENTS
1)TRESTLE 1
Staad model Review is in hold Staad model / Drawings are not received for TR1
2)TRESTLE 2 & 3

Please Apply Conveyor load in TR staad model as in conveyor staad

Staad model Conveyor load
model.

" Self weight Self weight assignment is missed for few members in staad model

3)Trestle 4 - Drawings are not received for TR4 to check the member properties

4)Trestle 5 - Drawings are not received for TR5 to check the member properties

5)10m conveyor
- No comments.
gallery

6)15m conveyor
- No comments.
gallery

7)20m conveyor Design parameters Design parameter is missed for few members in staad model
gallery

8)Transfer Tower Review is in hold Staad model / Drawings are not received for TT
 Job /File No JTP-213-GCW-DR-01-R0
JTP CONSULTING ENGINEERS PRIVATE LIMITED CIVIL &
Divn/Dept STRUCTURAL
CLIENT GCW - ULTRATECH CEMENT PVT LTD Reviewed by MR/SR/MNK

SOLID WASTE STORAGE TRANSPORT SYSTEM Checked by JTP

PROJECT
CONVEYOR - 745BC01 DESIGN REVIEW Date 23/06/2015
ITEM DESCRIPTION OF REVIEW COMMENTS
 Job /File No JTP-213-GCW-DR-02-R0
JTP CONSULTING ENGINEERS PRIVATE LIMITED CIVIL &
Divn/Dept STRUCTURAL
CLIENT GCW - ULTRATECH CEMENT PVT LTD Reviewed by MR/SR/MNK

SOLID WASTE STORAGE TRANSPORT SYSTEM Checked by JTP

PROJECT
CONVEYOR - 745BC04 DESIGN REVIEW Date 23/06/2015
ITEM DESCRIPTION OF REVIEW COMMENTS
Wind load calculation for
Trestles
The force coefficient is changed to 1.8 instead of 1.0 as per IS875(Part
3)-1987,Amendment No:2
Staad model Force coefficient for single frames

1)TRESTLE 1

Staad model Self weight Self weight assignment is missed for few members in staad model

Detail is mismatched in DWG no. C14.009-IND-CW-004 and C14.009-

Drawing Anchor bolt details
IND-DE-0014 .Please confirm which one is to be used.

2)Trestle 2A & 2B

Staad model Self weight Self weight assignment is missed for few members in staad model

The trestle deflection (across the conveyor direction) is not satisfy by the
" Deflection
code

Detail is mismatched in DWG no. C14.009-IND-CW-004 and C14.009-

Drawing Anchor bolt details
IND-DE-0014 .Please confirm which one is to be used.
 Job /File No JTP-213-GCW-DR-02-R0
JTP CONSULTING ENGINEERS PRIVATE LIMITED CIVIL &
Divn/Dept STRUCTURAL
CLIENT GCW - ULTRATECH CEMENT PVT LTD Reviewed by MR/SR/MNK

SOLID WASTE STORAGE TRANSPORT SYSTEM Checked by JTP

PROJECT
CONVEYOR - 745BC04 DESIGN REVIEW Date 23/06/2015
ITEM DESCRIPTION OF REVIEW COMMENTS

3)Trestle 3 & 4

They sent TR3 and TR4 staad model. And trestles TR3 & TR4 are
Combined in staad model TR3. TR4 Staad model is look like as tower at
Staad model Staad model name
PRE HEATER Building. So we need the Transfer tower and Tower at
PRE HEATER building drawing and staad model for review

" Unsupportd file Staad model cannot run due to UPT file error (For Star section)

" Self weight Self weight assignment is missed for few members in staad model

Effective length factor is missed in staad model (Along longer dirction

" Effective length
of TR)
The trestle deflection (across the conveyor direction) is not satisfy by the
" Deflection
code

"A" Brace system adopt in staad model along the short dirction of the
" Brace
Trestle(3.5m). But "X" Bracing system adopt in DWG.

Few Column member (Star MB600 with 16mm X 230 mm flange plate
" Design intraction ratio
section) is intraction ratio exceed the permissible value.( 1.16 > 1)

Footing F4 Reinforcement Please check the top reinforcement along the longer direction of footing
 Job /File No JTP-213-GCW-DR-02-R0
JTP CONSULTING ENGINEERS PRIVATE LIMITED CIVIL &
Divn/Dept STRUCTURAL
CLIENT GCW - ULTRATECH CEMENT PVT LTD Reviewed by MR/SR/MNK

SOLID WASTE STORAGE TRANSPORT SYSTEM Checked by JTP

PROJECT
CONVEYOR - 745BC04 DESIGN REVIEW Date 23/06/2015
ITEM DESCRIPTION OF REVIEW COMMENTS

Detail is mismatched in DWG no. C14.009-IND-CW-004 and C14.009-

Drawing Anchor bolt details
IND-DE-0014 .Please confirm which one is to be used.

4)10m conveyor
- No comments.
gallery

5)15m conveyor
- No comments.
gallery

6)20m conveyor
Design parameters Design parameter is missed for few members in staad model
gallery

7)26m conveyor
- No comments.
gallery
8)45m conveyor
- No comments.
gallery

9)Tower at Pre heater

Review is in hold Staad model / Drawings are not received for Tower at pre heater building
building

10)Transfer Tower Review is in hold Staad model / Drawings are not received for Transfer tower
 Job /File No JTP-213-GCW-DR-02-R0
JTP CONSULTING ENGINEERS PRIVATE LIMITED CIVIL &
Divn/Dept STRUCTURAL
CLIENT GCW - ULTRATECH CEMENT PVT LTD Reviewed by MR/SR/MNK

SOLID WASTE STORAGE TRANSPORT SYSTEM Checked by JTP

PROJECT
CONVEYOR - 745BC04 DESIGN REVIEW Date 23/06/2015
ITEM DESCRIPTION OF REVIEW COMMENTS
 Job /File No JTP-UTCL-DR
JTP CONSULTING ENGINEERS PRIVATE LIMITED CIVIL &
Divn/Dept STRUCTURAL

CLIENT ULTRATECH CEMENT PVT LTD., Calculated by RA

Checked by JTP
PROJECT PREHEATER TOWER - WALKWAY FOR ATTENDING PLATFORM AT +26.000M LEVEL
Date 24-Feb-16

ITEM DESCRIPTION OF REVIEW COMMENTS

1) Bracket Member ISMC 200 and ISMC 150 are safe

2) Longitudinal and cross beams Long beam MC250 and Cross beams MC150 are safe

3) Existing beam Existing Beam MB300 fails in bending with ratio 1.3 Please add 120x12mm thick plate at the bottom of the beam