Your ref: Tel: +27 (0) 41 506 3267

Fax: +27 (0) 86 482 4943

Our ref:
PO Box 215, Port Elizabeth, 6000
Date: 13 March 2018 Republic of South Africa
Who deals with this: Ms A Hoffman e-Mail: pamayor@mandelametro.gov.za

Dear Julius

It’s been a while since we last spoke. In fact, our recent meetings have all been
centered around the discussions about coalitions and co-operation post the 2016
elections and the management of these relations.

I remember how impressive you were during these negotiations. You were
strategically pragmatic, yet resolute that you would not enter into a formal coalition with
the DA. You were determined to maintain your independent identity yet at the same
time you wanted to expose and hold the ANC to account for its corrupt ways. You
defined the EFF apart from any coalition arrangement and refused to be associated
with any political party. This principled decision to create clear definition of the EFF
and unambiguous distance from any other political parties was an astute political
decision, I thought.

What left a more impressive and enduring impression upon me was the fact that when
you gave your word, you stuck to it. This is a quality that I admire greatly, especially
amongst politicians.

They say that, “a week is a long time in politics”, well, the past 19 months have felt like
a lifetime. In this time we, [DA Nelson Mandela Bay] have been in coalition with three
other parties and have co-operated on a level of growing trust with the EFF. We have
made extraordinary strides in improving governance and service delivery in Nelson
Mandela Bay. In fact, the latest Bustech survey shows us going from being the 2nd
least trusted to the 2nd most trusted Metro in the Country in just one year in government.
We have also done especially well in exposing and stopping corruption.

All this has happened whilst working with a competent, confident and hard working
group of EFF Councillors who have played their part as opposition Councillors

1
exceptionally well and have outshone all the other opposition parties in this regard.
We have also recently appointed one of your Councillors to Chair the Municipal Public
Accounts Committee.

In all the time this coalition has been in government, you have not once visited Nelson
Mandela Bay as far as I am aware, this perforce means that you would have no first-
hand experience of what is actually happening in this City. However, you do
acknowledge that our working relations have been good, that I have not, “Stolen any
money and that I am not doing a bad job”.

What is confounding then on the strength of the above is that you have unilaterally
decided to punish the DA, myself, this coalition and the people of Nelson Mandela Bay
ostensibly because we hold a different ideological position to you on land and the
offensive colour of my skin. These two things have been unchanged and self-evident
since the first day of our discussions post the 2016 elections. In fact, you stated that
you chose to co-operate with the, “better of two devils”.

From one political leader to another, I think that you might have made a mistake with
your latest threat and that you might have misread the national mood. If the DA had
changed its position or my skin colour had changed, you might have had reason for
your change of heart, this has however not happened.

I believe that ordinary South Africans of all colours want to be united behind a vision
that promotes national unity, through non-racial integration and good governance. Our
Country has not been better in this regard since before President Mandela’s
presidency and since his retirement. I believe that our people want to work and live
together, get rid of corruption, grow the economy to create decent dignified jobs that
provide independence from government and to receive proper service delivery,
especially at local government level.

I have felt welcome in every community in NMB because the people’s priorities are
clearly not racial division and hatred, they are about better government and improved
service delivery. Nobody wants to, “cut the throat of my whiteness”, nor do they want
to return this City to the very people they voted out of the office in 2016.

2
If the people of our Country really and truly embraced your radically divisive rhetoric,
your political party would have got more than 6% nationally and 4% locally. In fact,
your performance in by-elections recently shows that the people of our Country do not
espouse this racial invective.

So now instead of preparing to govern as an independent political party with your own
identity, you appear to want to hand this City back to the ANC which they had tried by
every means possible to ruin as per the candid expose in Dr Crispian Olver’s book
entitled, “How to steal a City”.

You used to call the EFF, “the government in waiting”, now you want to give your arch
political foe the city that rejected them, on a platter. This looks much like a peace
penance and perhaps the path back into the party fold that you once swore never to
leave.

Ours is a resilient nation that has experienced the worst and the best that humanity
has to offer. It is in this spirit that I extend an invitation to you to visit Nelson Mandela
Bay to show our people that you really understand and care for their issues and hear
from them yourself whether they want the ANC back in government in their City.

Anti-apartheid activist Helen Suzman used to say, “go and see for yourself”.

Until you have come to see for yourself in Nelson Mandela Bay and until you have
explained yourself why you want to give this City back to the ANC, your intentions will
remain anathema amongst the people whose political wishes you intend to disrespect
by imposing your will upon them.

End.