Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Banking in
Africa
kpmg.com/africa
The series has the following reports:
Southern Africa 3
Remaining Challenges 10
Conclusion 11
Source of Information 12
“A growing body of evidence suggests Financial sectors on the African continent remain
that financial institutions and financial largely underdeveloped, while banking industries
continue to dominate the landscape in terms of
markets exert a powerful influence total assets and services. Nonetheless, financial
on economic development, poverty sector development has been on the agenda of
alleviation, and economic stability.” African policymakers for some time. Various policy
reforms over the past decade have contributed to
Source: Cihák et al. 2012. an environment more conducive to financial sector
development. Governments have made progress
in introducing much needed legal regulatory
frameworks, information infrastructure and
regulatory institutions. As a result, the depth and
coverage of financial systems, when measured by
the ratios of broad money volumes of bank deposits
and private sector credit to GDP, have improved
over the past two decades 1. Nevertheless, Africa’s
financial sector continues to be less developed
compared to other emerging market regions.
Findings from a benchmarking study commissioned
by the World Bank during 2012 support this
assessment2. Examining various indicators in
relation to financial system access, depth, efficiency
and stability3; the findings suggest that sub-Saharan
Africa (SSA) performed weakest on average.
1
European Investment Bank. 2013.
2
Cihák et al. 2012.
3
The authors distinguish between financial institutions and financial markets when examining the financial systems of various regions. Due to the fact
that Africa’s financial sectors are mostly dominated by financial institutions (higher average financial structure ratio), the findings referring to the latter
is probably more indicative of actual performance.
Banking in Africa | 2
The banking sectors across sub-Saharan Africa highly concentrated at an aggregate level, there
remain highly concentrated. According to the World are subtle but significant differences in relation to
Bank’s Global Financial Development database, the financial sector development between countries and
three largest banks held 78.2% of the total banking within regions. Below we briefly consider financial
sector assets on average across sub-Saharan development in Africa from a regional perspective,
African countries in 2011. This statistic increased while also highlighting key banking sector
to 91.2% when the five largest banks were developments in country-level case studies.
considered. Although the banking sector remains
Southern Africa
The level of financial development is especially fairly developed financial markets in an African
diverse between the various countries within context. Countries at the other end of the spectrum
the Southern African (SA) region. While South include the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC),
Africa is the obvious frontrunner, other countries Madagascar and Malawi.
like Mauritius, Botswana and Namibia also have
Banking in Africa | 4
Regardless, the banking sector in the Southern show significant potential for growth, despite non-
African region has experienced significant growth in performing loans ratio being quite high (around 6%).
the past decade. Even though this has gone hand-in- The reduced level of bancarization (around 25%),
hand with positive credit expansion in most cases, mainly in the interior regions, and the relatively low
credit to the private sector as a percentage of GDP diversification and complexity of products offer a
remains low by international standards. Although, strong potential for growth, although the scarcity of
amongst the regions in Africa, the Southern African qualified staff can represent a real constrain.
median is slightly higher than the median of the East
A significant effort in the Regulatory front has been
African and Central and West African regions (see
observed in the last few years, although the levels of
accompanying figure4). Countries that have made
compliance still lag behind international standards.
significant inroads in this regard, albeit from a low
The Angolan government has introduced tougher
base, include Angola, Mozambique and Tanzania. In
regulations for banks on ownership disclosure,
general, Southern African banks are well capitalised,
auditing and risk management. This intends to
and mostly have lower non-performing loan (NPL)
increase and supervision in the booming financial
ratios when compared to the other regions on the
sector. In addition, stricter rules on auditing, risk
continent.
management, compliance and stress testing will
In addition, the European Investment Bank (EIB) enhance the central bank’s to supervise the financial
notes that many governments in the region are system. Implementation of the new regulations will
assisting financial market development by issuing be required by the end of 2014.
benchmark-setting sovereign bonds, which would
ultimately aid domestic companies in accessing Zambia
foreign finance. There is also better cooperation Zambia’s banking sector is relatively well developed
on a regional level, such as through the Southern in an African context, although the financial sector
African Development Community’s (SADC) remains highly concentrated with the largest four
Committee of Central Bank Governors. However, banks holding nearly two-thirds of total banking
the region still faces major challenges, many of assets by 2013. There has been a steady increase
which are synonymous with broader continent in electronic banking and related services over the
wide issues. Even in countries with fairly developed last 5 years. The structure of the banking sector
financial sectors, services are often mostly comprises of 19 commercial banks, of which 15 are
directed at established businesses and higher foreign owned, three is locally owned by private
income households. In the less developed sub- investors and one is jointly owned by the Zambian
sample, challenges are still numerous and include: and Indian governments. The banking sector has
challenging legal environments, limited information, maintained a strong capital position in recent years,
poor infrastructure, and uneven regulatory functions. which allowed the financial sector to show resilience
in the face of global economic turmoil in 2007-08.
Angola However, a large portion of the Zambian populace in
The Angolan banking system is highly concentrated, rural areas remains unbanked, and vulnerable to loan
with five banks representing approximately 78% sharking activities due to poor access to financial
of total Assets. While the sector has seen rapid services. The government intends to increase
expansion, there is still a high concentration of credit financial inclusion from a current level of 37.3%
in Luanda and coastal regions, as well as companies (as at June 2013) to 50% by 2015. The government
linked to the oil sector. identified branch expansion from the current 351
and increased product innovation as pivotal to
The Angolan banking system has experienced
effective financial service provision. The increase
strong growth over the past two decades, with
in the capital requirement for the Banks effective 31
ROE above 20% on average, resulting mainly from
December 2013 is also expected to have a positive
high interest rate government bonds and foreign
effect on the economy.
exchange transactions, whilst the loan books still
4
The box-plot graph indicates the minimum, quartile 1, median, quartile 3 and maximum values for the respective country credit to private sector
percentages of GDP for each region during 2012. Two outliers were removed as follows: South Africa (151%) and Mauritius (101%).
5 | Banking in Africa
Ivory Coast
As the banking hub of francophone West Africa,
Ivory Coast accounted for 27.6% of total banking
sector assets within the West African Economic
and Monetary Union (WAEMU) region in 2012.
The banking sector consists mainly of French and
Nigerian subsidiaries in addition to state-owned
banks. Although relatively well capitalised, the
Ivorian banking sector also suffers from credit risk
in the form of comparatively high NPL ratios, partly
a consequence of the post-election conflict during
2010, when banks temporarily seized operations.
Nigeria Authorities in the WAEMU region are considering
The banking sector in the region’s dominant the establishment of a financial stability fund to
economy, Nigeria, has undergone substantial support the financial system during times of crises,
transformations over the past decade. Following such as experienced in Ivory Coast recently.
the 2005-06 consolidation, Nigeria’s banking
sector experienced rapid credit growth, as banks DRC
expanded their service offering and started entering In a report released during August 2013,
the untapped retail sector. However, a large share Ecobank notes that the banking sector in the
of the credit originated from high risk investment DRC comprised of 18 active commercial banks
activities, such as margin traders focusing on with a total of 278 branches at the end of 2012.
equities and oil importers not hedging their Total commercial bank assets increased by 32%,
positions. This meant that, in contrast to most of its from around $2.7bn in 2011 to $3.6bn in 2012.
African peers, the Nigerian banking sector proved According to the IMF, only around 3.5% of the adult
especially susceptible to the impact of the global population had deposit accounts at commercial
financial crises. The Central Bank of Nigeria took banks in 2012, up from 2.1% during the previous
various steps in an attempt to rectify the situation. year. Business for commercial banks improved
Firstly was to address corporate governance and after the government began transferring salaries of
removal of boards and CEO’s. The CBN also fixed civil servants through the banking system, instead
and ensured adherence to tenure limits for the board of salary payments made in cash, over the past two
and Chief Executive which resulted in changes at years. This development is likely to increase the
UBA, Zenith Bank etc. This included a guarantee on rate of financial deepening in the DRC while also
all interbank transactions and pension deposits as improving market penetration.
well as setting up the Asset Management Company
(AMC) to swap all NPLs with tradable zero-coupon-
7 | Banking in Africa
A large proportion of the African populace does not global adult population. Put differently, 115 million of
make use of formal financial services. According to the total adult population in SSA – estimated in the
the Global Findex Database , only 24% of the total region of 482 million – had an account at a formal
SSA adult population had an account at a formal financial institution.
financial institution in 2012, compared to 50% of the
African countries with particularly low account Given the opportunities presented by these markets,
penetration rates, where less than 10% of the many financial institutions have been spurred to
adult population had a financial institution account, reconsider the way in which they do business. By
included: Sudan, Senegal, Democratic Republic some estimates, 95% of the adult population in
of Congo, Central African Republic, Chad, Niger, SSA earning less than $10 per day have no access
Madagascar and Mali. The main reason for the low to bank accounts. If this group were to become part
level of financial inclusion in SSA, based on survey of the formalised banking sector, this could lead to
responses, pertains to low income levels in general. a significant increase in new deposits. Also, even at
Closely related to this last point is the fact that lower profit margins, the benefits associated with
survey respondents believed financial services to be leveraging economies of scale should contribute to
too expensive. Other notable barriers included the significant returns on the bottom line.
distance travelled to the nearest point of contact as
well as onerous regulatory requirements.
Banking in Africa | 8
The banking sector on the African continent phones. Mpesa account holders can use their
managed to realise significant growth over the mobile phones to transfer funds, pay bills, and
past decade. Encouragingly, this trend is expected purchase mobile airtime credit.
to continue in the medium term. The Economist
This is widely aired as successful but the success
Intelligence Unit (EIU) states that African countries
has not been replicated in any other African country
“are poised to enjoy a surge in growth in their
to date.
banking systems during this decade”, mainly
driven by high economic growth and improved
performance in relation to financial deepening.
Pan-African Banks
The EIU forecasts total financial sector assets will The growing presence of subsidiaries of major global
expand by around 178% - 248% by 2020 in a sample banks on the continent has undoubtedly improved
consisting of 16 key SSA countries . the availability and quality of financial services in
recent years. However, large banks from well-
However, in order to realise the significant growth developed financial markets on the African continent
potential outlined above, companies will need to have made the biggest impact in this regard. As
find alternative approaches and innovative solutions noted above, these banks mostly have their origins
to the problem of expanding the reach of financial in South Africa and Nigeria. According to the EIB: “at
services to the unbanked. least nine SSA-domiciled financial groups operate
banks in seven or more other SSA countries.”
Use of Mobile Technology
Standard Bank, Africa’s top bank by assets, has a
The advent of modern technology and other
comprehensive Africa presence with the company
innovations have successfully enabled a handful of
operating in around 17 SSA countries. The company
pioneers to provide banking services to a far wider
remains focused on its African strategy, and has
income customer base than ever before. More
indicated that it no longer has ambitions to buy
specifically, the emergence of mobile technology
or build commercial operations outside of Africa.
as an alternative to more traditional banking has
Standard Bank’s affiliation with the Industrial
allowed for services to be provided to lower
Commercial Bank of China (ICBC), following ICBC’s
income households often residing at distant rural
purchase of a 20% stake in Standard Bank in early
locations. This was made possible by the rapid
2008, remains a strategic advantage in terms of
diffusion of affordable cellular technology on the
tapping into Asia’s growing presence in Africa.
African continent. According to a study completed
Similarly, in July 2009, FirstRand Group formed
by the African Development Bank during 2012, “the
a strategic partnership with China Construction
number of subscribers on the continent has grown
Bank (CCB), with the intention to align two leading
almost 20 per cent each year for the past five years.
banks on two strategic continents to facilitate
Mobile telephony penetration in Africa has increased
banking opportunities in the China-Africa corridor.
exponentially from less than 2 million subscribers in
The FirstRand Group’s vision is to be the African
1998 to over 500 million in 2011.” Mobile banking
financial services group of choice by growing its
has achieved the broadest success in SSA, where
franchise in the broader African continent, targeting
16% of adults reported having used a mobile phone
trade and investment flows between Africa,
in the 12-months leading to April 2012 to pay bills
China and India. In addition, Barclays Plc recently
or send or receive money. This is compared to less
combined its operations in Africa to standardize its
than 5% in other regions.
business across the continent as part of its ‘One
One of the most successful mobile banking models Bank in Africa’ strategy. The UK bank increased its
in Africa is considered to be Kenya’s Mpesa, which stake in the Absa Group of South Africa to 62.3%
caters to more than 14 million customers (70% of and consolidated the assets of the latter with that
Kenya’s adult population). Developed by Vodafone of its other African operations and subsequently
and launched commercially by the company’s rebranded the business as Barclays Africa Group,
Kenyan affiliate Safaricom, Mpesa is an electronic although the Absa brand would be retained solely
payment system accessible from ordinary mobile for operations in South Africa. Barclays Africa
5
World Bank: Global Findex Database. 2012.
6
Economist Intelligence Unit. 2011.
9 | Banking in Africa
Group wants to increase the share of its revenue Recognising the importance of NBFI’s for a
originating from outside of South Africa to between large percentage of poor African households, an
20% and 25%, while also aiming to be amongst the increasing numbers of banks are collaborating
top three banks by revenue in its five largest markets with non-governmental organisations (NGOs) to
(South Africa, Kenya, Ghana, Botswana and Zambia). provide some form of new banking facilities to the
Ecobank, with its roots in Togo, has the biggest largely unbanked rural population. These range from
presence in Africa, rendering banking services in 33 promoting a culture of savings and loan facilities in
countries. These banks have assisted in improving poor communities, to increasing financial literacy, to
competition as well as ensuring new technologies the issuance of biometric smart cards as a means
and methodologies are transferred across countries of formal identification so as to provide easier
on the continent. access for rural households to banking services. The
importance of this is significant in that promoting a
Alternative Financing Options culture of savings in poor communities and providing
While banks are and will remain the backbone of some form of financial literacy has the potential to
African financial systems, a number of alternative eventually have a hand in reducing poverty. While
financing options exist, upon which most low- encouraged by progress made, there is still a long
income African households have traditionally way to go to ensure that the majority of Africa’s
resorted given limited access to formal banking poorest are able to engage in some kind of formal
products. These non-bank financial intermediaries financial activity.
(NBFIs) range from post-office savings banks to
credit unions and other financial cooperatives
to other formal and semi-formal microfinance
providers, with their success and longevity
ascribed to lower affordability, eligibility and
product appropriateness barriers than traditional
banks. Another mode of branchless banking that
has received growing attention in recent years
is bank agents, who tend to operate out of retail
stores, gas stations or post offices. By and large
however, the NBFI sector generally tends to
operate below potential.
Banking in Africa | 10
Remaining Challenges
Conclusion
Although the banking sector on the African inclusive, far-reaching economic growth. However,
continent faces various difficult challenges, it to fulfil its full growth potential would require
nonetheless has the potential to realise significant strengthening of regulatory environments,
growth. Indeed the successful expansion of improvements in infrastructure/ including access
financial services into the retail sector including to the intensely tight supervision. Africa has the
penetration of the lower income and ‘unbanked’ potential to leapfrog in select areas e.g. Mpesa
sectors of the population has the ability to be a model in East Africa and innovations will be key to
catalyst for economic growth to ensure more release the growth potential of the least cost.
Banking in Africa | 12
Source of Information
Christine Colyn
Head: Digital Publishing
T: +27218636200
christine@nkc.co.za
Trish Korte
Client Services Executive
T: +27218636200
trish@nkc.co.za
© 2014 KPMG Africa Limited, a Cayman Islands company and a member firm of the KPMG network of independent member firms
affiliated with KPMG International Cooperative (“KPMG International”), a Swiss entity. All rights reserved. The KPMG name, logo
and “cutting through complexity” are registered trademarks or trademarks of KPMG International. MC12305