Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MOVEMENT
ON THE
SALISH SEA
WISE USE TERRORISM
IN WHATCOM COUNTY, 2013-2017
As Toole remarked,
Concluding, Mr. Toole observed that the public education system is doing a
woefully inadequate job of providing information to students on Indian issues.
The result, he says, is that citizens are increasingly ignorant about treaty
rights and tribal sovereignty. This, he warns, makes them far more vulnerable
to the politics of resentment offered up by the Anti-Indian Movement.
Tsleil-Waututh Blessing Stop
On April 17, the Cascadia Weekly editor published a column titled A history of
violence. On page 4 of the April 17 Earth Day issue of Cascadia Weekly, he
published my letter to the editor, “Givers and Takers”, which connected the
organized racism promoted by CERA to propaganda by the Gateway Pacific
Terminal (GPT) coal export developers. Responding to my letter, Craig Cole,
the PR spokesman for the proposed Gateway Pacific Terminal — located next
to the Lummi Indian reservation — phoned the editor expressing his
displeasure with my op-ed.
Lummi Nation TerritoryOn April 26, 2013, the Institute for Research and
Education on Human Rights (IREHR) in Seattle published a special report by
Charles Tanner Jr. titled “Take These Tribes Down” The Anti-Indian Movement
Comes To Washington State.
On May 13, 2013, it came to my attention that Skip Richards – one of the two
organizers of the April 6, 2013 CERA conference, and a strategist of anti-
Indian campaigns in the 1990s — was scheduled to speak at a May 24
luncheon for the Republican Women of Whatcom County, at the Bellingham
Golf and Country Club. In response to this information, I added the following
background on Skip Richards as an appendix to my April 10 article at IC
Magazine.
For background on Skip Richards, readers might find the following Public
Good Project special reports useful.
Reign of Terror
Common Sense About the Richards Militia Controversy
Militia and CLUE Activity in Whatcom and Snohomish Counties
Skip Richards’ Years of Contact with Christian Patriot Militias
Wise Use in Northern Puget Sound
A Not So Distant Mirror
Profits of Prejudice
Some news articles about Skip Richards’ collaboration with Christian Patriot
militia:
A History of Violence
CLUE and Militias Exploit Landowners
Militia ties haunt campaign
In Whatcom County, Distaste For Government Grows
“I was a witness to the journey and can say with deep conviction that this
journey mattered. It mattered to those assembled, to the travelers, to the
multitudes that read about it in the paper, heard about it on the radio, or saw it
on TV, to landscapes and their lifeforms, and (in my mind), to the unseen
forces within and around us that ask of us only our steadfast faith. This is a
coming together.” —Kurt Russo, Sovereignty and Treaty Protection Office,
Lummi Nation
Horizontal Integration
On June 4, 2013, I came across a link to YouTube videos from the Gateway
Pacific Terminal panel forum, featuring Washington State Senator Doug
Ericksen, Dave Warren of Northwest Jobs Alliance, Whatcom County Realtors
Association lobbyist Perry Eskridge, and realtor Mike Kent, whom I knew to be
the brother of former KGMI radio host Jeff Kent—noted in the Profits of
Prejudice PDF, attached to my April 10 IC Magazine article. As a KGMI radio
host in September 1995, Jeff Kent led Fee Land Owners Association (FLOA)
representatives Jeff McKay and Linnea Smith in an hour-long diatribe against
the Lummi Indians.
Also on October 9, 2013, Cascadia Weekly ran an editorial titled Polar Chill,
noting the editor is “dismayed to see coal export interests laundering large
amounts of campaign contributions” suggesting that “the early promise of coal
export interests to be good corporate citizens was a lie”. The following three
paragraphs of the editorial are worth reading in its entirety:
“It appears that Pacific International Terminals and the Burlington Northern
Santa Fe Railroad have earmarked campaign funds given to the state
Republican Party such that these funds exclusively benefit candidates in
Whatcom County,” Donovan wrote to the state Public Disclosure Commission,
which investigates alleged campaign finance irregularities. Donovan is a
political scientist and elections expert.
“This practice allows Pacific International and BNSF to disguise the fact that
they are a primary source of campaign funds for these candidates and for the
Whatcom County Republican Party,” Donovan wrote to the PDC. “This
practice allows Pacific International and BNSF to spend money on Whatcom
County candidate races in excess of what is allowable under state law.”
Anti-Indian Movement.
Part 2: The Politics of
Resentment
PUBLISHED: JANUARY 11, 2018, AUTHOR: JAYTABER
The Northern Cheyenne Reservation (Bob Zellar, Billings Gazette)
On October 16, 2013, I became aware of a new PAC called SaveWhatcom,
registered by KGMI radio host Kris Halterman and Lorraine Newman.
Halterman is noted in my Anti-Indian Conferencearticle at IC Magazine, having
interviewed CERA celebrity Elaine Willman at the April 6, 2013 CERA
gathering. Halterman had Willman on her March 30, 2013 show Saturday
Morning Live, saying the April 6 conference would teach local officials and
citizens how to take on tribal governments. On Halterman’s November 3, 2012
show, Willman called for an end to tribal sovereignty, stating, “Tribalism is
socialism, and has no place in our country!”
“I have been provided a copy of your recent article, How Property Rights Can
Become Property Wrongs, published in the Whatcom Watch. I was asked to
explain your apparent effort to tie several violent racial events in the past to
current efforts by Whatcom County property rights organizations, including the
Whatcom County Association of Realtors, advocating for property rights
protections in our county.
While the article does not directly accuse the Realtors of some of the more
heinous acts you describe, you do state “Powerful political forces masked in
seemingly constructive organizations like the … Washington Realtors [sic]
Association (including each group’s local level organizations), fund and
interact with property rights groups.” Whatcom Watch, October-November
2013, pg. 8. You continue by alleging that these groups, including the
Realtors, use these groups “to do much of their work for them.” Id. These
statements are not accurate.”
The reference cited in the article by Ms. Robson that disturbed Mr. Eskridge is
from Wise Use in Northern Puget Sound, Appendix II, paragraph 7, which
states, “These groups, such as the Master Builders Association, the various
county chapters of the Affordable Housing Council, the local Chambers of
Commerce, and realtor’s associations, provide the leadership and funding for
creating front groups like the Property Rights Alliance, SNOCO PRA,
Whatcom CLUE and other so-called grass-roots groups.”
In Appendix VIII, source number 167, the Seattle Times notes the financial
contribution from the Washington Association of Realtors to Initiative 164, the
property rights initiative. As noted in source number 170, the Seattle Times
quotes Secretary of State Ralph Munro, who ordered an investigation by the
State Patrol regarding thousands of fake Initiative 164 signatures.
In Trampling on the Treaties: Rob McKenna and the Politics of Anti-Indianism, a 2012
report by Chuck Tanner and Leah Henry-Tanner, the authors examined
Washington gubernatorial candidate McKenna via his career as a public
official opposed to treaty rights, as well as his working relationship with Anti-
Indian activists and organizations. As the Tanners note:
“McKenna’s Anti-Indian policies and ideas, and his willingness to ally his
public office with opponents of tribal rights, should raise a large red flag for all
people in Washington state who support respectful relations with Indian
Nations.”
Educating the
Public
Three summers ago the company that wants to build the largest coal export
terminal in North America failed to obtain the environmental permits it needed
before bulldozing more than four miles of roads and clearing more than nine
acres of land, including some wetlands.
On page 12 of the January 15, 2014 issue of Cascadia Weekly, in an article titled
Draw the Line by Tim Johnson, he noted that the waters at Cherry Point are
home to one of the best crab fisheries along the coast, and that this fishery
sustains many tribal families. In the article, he quotes Jeremiah “Jay” Julius,
secretary of the Lummi Nation Governing Council, a fisherman and crabber
descended from tribesmen who have fished the waters off Cherry Point for
centuries. Featured in a KCTS documentary and related PBS News Hour
piece about the proposed Northwest coal terminals, Julius stated, “The sacred
must be protected.”
Anti-Indian Movement
Part 3: A Free Press
PUBLISHED: JANUARY 12, 2018, AUTHOR: JAYTABER
A Free Press
On February 5, 2014, Gateway Pacific Terminal spokesman Craig Cole
threatened Whatcom Watch with a SLAPP suit, which I covered for IC
magazine in my February 8 article Gateway Pacific Terminal Consultant Threatens
Journalists. In the four page letter sent to Whatcom Watch, Cole accused
Robson and myself of libel, threatening that Robson and Whatcom Watch are
“put on notice”. In a February 19 article Craig Cole Threatens Libel Suit at
Northwest Citizen, editor John Servais made the following remarks:
“We have seen the effects of big money on politics and corporate media, and
now those long arms are reaching into our local media – using lawsuits to
intimidate or bully local citizen journalists away from vigorously reporting what
is happening. Indeed, it has been working! The folks at the Whatcom Watch
are stuck in a defensive crouch over this threat. The Watch has no money
and Mr. Cole has some of the largest corporations in the country behind
him. It seems unlikely Cole would send such a letter without the backing and
encouragement of his corporate clients.
On February 17, 2014, in an Indian Country Today article titled Coast Salish
Nations Unite to Protect Salish Sea, the Lummi, Swinomish, Suquamish and
Tulalip tribes of Washington joined the Tsleil-Waututh, Squamish and
Musqueam Nations in British Columbia in opposing Kinder Morgan’s proposed
TransMountain pipeline and other energy-expansion and export projects that
“pose a threat to the environmental integrity of our sacred homelands and
waters, our treaty and aboriginal rights, and our cultures and life ways.” In
December 2013, Kinder Morgan, the third largest energy producer in North
America, filed an application with the National Energy Board of Canada (NEB)
to build a new pipeline to transport crude oil from the Alberta Tar Sands to
Vancouver, British Columbia, that if approved, would result in a 200%
increase in oil tanker traffic through the Salish Sea. On February 11, 2014,
these tribes and nations collectively filed for official intervener status with the
NEB.
On February 25, 2014, Northwest Citizen (NWC) posted Relevant Documents to
Libel Threat, including Craig Cole’s letter threatening a libel lawsuit against
Whatcom Watch (WW), as well as a link to my article at IC Magazine, noting
that “It is interesting that Cole has not threatened to sue Taber or Taber’s
publisher.” NWC editor John Servais observes it is legitimate for WW to seek
connections between the anti-Indian groups and the corporations seeking
permits to build the coal terminal, saying, “It is called journalism and the
exercise of a free press.”
A Terrible Insult
A ceremony held at Cherry Point, a part of the Lummi anti-coal totem pole journey. 09/30/2013 Photo: Ryan Hasert
On March 28, 2014, Indian Country Today published a feature story titled Anti-
Indian CERA Doesn’t Like the Law of the Land, or Us, Apparently, by Terri Hansen,
in which CERA is described as “The Ku Klux Klan of Indian Country.” On April
2, 2014, federal Indian law attorney Dave Lundgren wrote in his Indian
Country Today op-ed Expose Hate Groups Like CERA that, “They disguise their
fear and hatred with bogus legal arguments designed to rile up local
resentment.”
On April 4, 2014, my Public Good Project editorial Liberal Elite Versus
Democracy discussed the collapse of Whatcom Watch under its new president
Terry Wechsler, who began blaming the messenger Sandra Robson for the
paper’s troubles. In a communication to this author, Wechsler said my advice
to expose, confront and reject organized racism is “counterproductive.”
On June 27, 2014, the Bellingham Herald article Craig Cole’s legal threat against
Whatcom Watch ‘resolved’ claimed the SLAPP suit issue had been amicably
resolved, saying “What bothered Cole more than Robson’s piece was a follow
up by blogger Jay Taber that contorted Robson’s hypothetical scenario into
flat-out reality.” Had the reporter Ralph Schwartz bothered to closely read
Sandra Robson’s extensively-sourced article and mine, he would have
discovered that my accusation of Cole promoting racism was based on
documented facts.
On July 27, 2015, my article Crowing Jesus: Four Square Gospel vs A Sacred
Trust at IC Magazine noted that in a July 21 article at the Los Angeles Times,
Crow Tribe Chairman Darrin Old Coyote called Lummi Nation leaders
“ignorant” pawns of Seattle environmental groups. A supplier of coal, the Crow
are in bed with Gateway Pacific Terminal. As a Pentecostal Christian tribe, the
Crow are challenging Lummi Nation’s “sacred trust” to protect the Salish Sea—
a holy mandate that Earth Ministry, Resources, Unitarian Universalists, and Sierra
Club support.
On March 12, 2016, Northwest Citizen named Sandra Robson the Paul
deArmond Citizen Journalist of the year, saying, “If there were a Pulitzer Prize for
citizen journalism, Sandra Robson would win it.”
Anti-Indian Movement
Part 4: Christian Identity
Doctrine
PUBLISHED: JANUARY 16, 2018, AUTHOR: JAYTABER
Introduction
As we recognize the Anti-Indian Movement on the Tribal Frontier 25-year
anniversary, I recommend reading A Mandate from God: Christian White
Supremacy in the US, which examines the driving force of the movement,
located in Christian Identity doctrine. The Christian Patriots who adhere to this
doctrine, i.e. the militias, are a much greater threat to democracy than the
American Nazi Party or Ku Klux Klan.
As evidence, it was Christian Patriots who blew up the Oklahoma City federal
building in 1995, and Christian Patriots who, in 1997, were convicted in U.S.
District Court in Seattle for building bombs to murder human rights activists
(see Shining a Light). As noted in Part 1, Givers and Takers, Tom Williams
(CERA board member and Minuteman militia member) co-organized the
2013 Anti-Indian Conference in Bellingham, Washington.
My focus on the Wise Use/Christian Patriot nexus of the Anti-Indian
Movement helps readers understand how corporate funding combined with
vigilante violence is facilitated by intermediaries in the Tea Party and GOP. As
implementation of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous
Peoples (UNDRIP) becomes a significant basis for the exercise of jurisdiction
by indigenous nations in Canada and the US, the most virulent opposition will
come from the true believers of Christian Identity.
Understanding this milieu, and how it relates to other sectors of the anti-Indian
movement, is essential to effective indigenous human rights organizing.
Conflict and
Terrorism
As noted by Paul de Armond in A Time for New Beginnings (see Studies in
Conflict and Terrorism, vol 22, issue 2, 1999), Wise Use and Christian Patriots
are located within the American fascist movement, as evidenced by the militia
organizing drive in 1994. In his article, de Armond urged a behavioral
definition of fascism, such as the Reagan administration’s use of the American
extreme right to organize paramilitary action in Central America.
De Armond reminds readers that it was state and local governments that used
armed right-wing paramilitaries like the Klan to attack civil rights activists in
the 1960s, and that there is a continuity of the American paramilitary right that
includes the Klan, Minutemen, Aryan Nations, Militia of Montana, Covenant
Sword and Arm of the Lord. As he observes, there have been three waves of
right-wing militia organizing since the 1960s, and that “It is only in the case of
the most horrifying or politically inflammatory violence that significant law
enforcement resources have been committed.”
In his end notes, Paul remarks that fascism is a rationalization of theft, just as
statism is a rationalization of power, capitalism is a rationalization of
acquisition, and sociopathy is a rationalization of the irrational. “Anti-fascism,”
he observes, “is a form of informational public health, related to
epidemiology.”
Sunlight v
Shunning
As de Armond remarked at Metafilter, 1 October 2010, the sunlight v shunning
debate is an old one. Every time there has been a crisis, he says, the sunlight
approach wins.
As Paul notes, “The worst setbacks to the Tea Party have been due to
exposure, not people trying to ignore them.”
Christian
Identity
The Christian Identity religion began in 1948, when Wesley Swift incorporated
the Church of Jesus Christ Christian in Los Angeles. The central belief in
Christian Identity doctrine is the existence of two races on earth: a godly white
race descended from Adam, and a satanic race fathered by Satan. Swift died
in 1970 and Richard Butler assumed control, moving the church to Idaho,
where he renamed it Aryan Nations.
The white supremacist movement, which seeks to bring about the collapse of
the US, might be unrealistic in its aim to establish a racial nationalist state, but
it is certain they will continue to use all means at their disposal to achieve that
unrealistic goal. These means include bombings, sabotage, undermining
discipline in the armed forces, counterfeiting, tax evasion, bank robbery,
subversion of local governments and law enforcement, fraud, and attempts at
nuclear, chemical, and biological warfare.
Conclusion
As Paul de Armond observed in 1996, the notion of Christian Identity doctrine
as the motor for militant white supremacy is widely shared among experts.
Many of the most violent white supremacist groups have either been led by or
composed of individuals who are identity believers. Recruitment and militant
action by Christian Patriots is in essence a holy war.
Anti-Indian Movement
Part 5: Puritanical
Conservatism
PUBLISHED: JANUARY 19, 2018, AUTHOR: JAYTABER
Fears of Pagan
Socialism
In Bron Taylor’s 20 April 2011 Religion Dispatches essay Debate Over Mother
Earth’s Rights Stirs Fears of Pagan Socialism, he notes that, “Religious and
political conservatives have long feared the global march of paganism and
socialism. In their view,” says Taylor, “it was bad enough when Earth Day
emerged in 1972, promoting a socialist agenda. But now, under the auspices
of the United Nations, the notion has evolved into the overtly pagan, and thus
doubly dangerous, International Mother Earth Day.” With all 192 member
states of the UN General Assembly supporting a 2009 resolution proclaiming
International Mother Earth Day as proposed by the socialist Bolivian President
Evo Morales, American conservatives hostile to environmentalism responded
with their usual religious hysteria.
Everyone seemed instinctively to know what part they played; the endless
rants by a variety of characters full of not only themselves, but also full of a
sense of a divine mission in struggling against unholy forces. The typical far
right meeting is very similar to a service in a lay Christian fellowship of the
more militant fundamentalist evangelicals.”
“Religious hysteria,” says de Armond, “was what I thought I was seeing at the
confluence of the ‘property rights’ and militia movements. In their role as
social critics and collectors of grievances, the ‘Patriots’ and Wise Users are
remarkably acute, but they are unreasonable in both analysis and action —
rejecting a discourse which supplies reasons and appeals to reason and
instead relies on force for persuasion.”
“The prophetae of the militia movement,” notes de Armond, “come from the
Wise Use anti-environmentalists and Christian white supremacists,” and like
the leaders of the medieval social revolutions in Europe, “have been
successful in obtaining political power and influence, and as they become part
of the establishment and decapitated their own movement, their less
successful brethren have repeatedly splintered off into more groups and
become more violent and irresponsible in both rhetoric and action.”
Bringing on the
Apocalypse
Circulating in October 2008 was a discussion among religious scholars about
Palin’s plan for Palestine. The consensus was “incineration.”
The first step in her religion calls for all Jews in the world to be coerced to
emigrate to Israel. The second step is to support the State of Israel in
committing genocide against the Palestinians. The third step is for the US to
instigate nuclear holocaust in Israel thereby incinerating all Jews (agents of
Satan) and bringing on the Apocalypse.
American Zionists (Jewish and Christian) understand this plan, but split over
the practicality of step one and the desirability of step three. Most Americans
are completely clueless about all the above.
Palin’s followers, who believe she has been anointed for this task by God, in
2008 were already discussing the necessity of assassinating her GOP running
mate McCain if he interfered with Palin’s plan. According to the participating
scholars, the October 2008 anti-Muslim hate campaign in the US Midwest was
a warm-up exercise for adherents of Palin’s religion and her domestic
terrorism support base in the Militia Movement.
Spiritual Warfare
Long before Indigenous peoples had to deal with Pentecostals and other
Evangelicals committed to converting them from heathenism, there were the
Puritans. In America, these religious fanatics — who washed up on the shores
of Wampanoag territory and repaid Indigenous generosity with murder —
have themselves undergone quite a transformation.
“The popular image,” it goes on, “is slightly more accurate as a description of
Puritans in colonial America, who were among the most radical Puritans and
whose social experiment took the form of a Calvinist theocracy.”
“The Kenyan preacher shown on the video anointing her as she ran for
governor,” says Goodstein, “is celebrated internationally as an effective
spiritual warrior who led a prayer movement that drove a witch out of his town
in Kenya.”
“Critics,” notes Goodstein, “say the goal of the spiritual warfare movement is
to create a theocracy. Bruce Wilson, a researcher for Talk2Action, a Web site
that tracks religious groups, said: ‘One of the imperatives of the movement is
to achieve worldly power, including political control. Then you can more
effectively drive out the demons. The ultimate goal is to purify the earth’.”
Anti-Indian Movement
Part 6: Players Program
PUBLISHED: JANUARY 26, 2018, AUTHOR: JAYTABER
Hate Radio
As Dena Jensen reports, William Honea, Skagit County senior deputy
prosecuting attorney –in justifying the CERA anti-Indian workshop in Mount
Vernon, Washington on May 20–falsely attributed an incendiary quote to
Swinomish tribal chairman and president of the National Congress of
American Indians, Brian Cladoosby. Given that Mr. Honea–like CERA
celebrity Elaine Willman–was given a platform on KGMI radio to promote
racist resentment, it is perhaps a good time for human rights activists and
moral authorities to pursue having Saturday Morning Live removed from its
programming.
After four years of hosting anti-Indian racists on her show, it’s time for KGMI
to pull the plug on Tea Party leader, Kris Halterman.
You can read more on the anti-Indian movement revival in the Salish Sea
region here.
As the Indian Law and Policy Center reports, termination of Indian tribes as
sovereign political entities is endemic in the current presidential
administration. Taken as a whole, the agenda of key cabinet appointees and
advisors is to finalize assimilation of tribes into the American system of
corporate institutional dominance.
If people of faith want to help defeat White Power on the Salish Sea, they
need to call out the promoters of this interracial discord. Otherwise, they
become yet another instance of white people assuaging their guilt over the
institutionalized mistreatment of Native Americans by indulging in the
consumption of Indian acts of spiritual generosity, without committing
themselves to acts of reciprocity.
As Lummi elder Jewell Praying Wolf James remarked at St. Philip Neri
Catholic Church in Portland, “Talk’s good, but action’s better”.
White Power
The timeline White Power on the Salish Sea puts Dow’s abhorrent conduct in
context.
The
McKinneys
As reported in this March 2017 expose by Sandy Robson, the Whatcom Tea
Party changed its name to Common Threads Northwest. That marketing move
mirrors the November 2017 deceptive campaign mailer sent out by Whatcom
Republican candidates claiming to be non-partisan.
In the March story, Robson reveals two new players in Whatcom politics–the
husband and wife team of James and Laura McKinney–who assumed key
positions in the Anti-Indian, Tea Party network: James as Executive Director
of Common Threads Northwest, and Laura as Director of Operations and
Communications for the Whatcom Business Alliance–an advocacy
organization in support of fossil fuel export at Cherry Point.
End note:
As reported at The Intercept, fascists in the Whatcom County Prosecutor’s
office have declared war on political dissent, in particular by tribal human
rights activists.
[The online version of this report can be read at the following URL:
https://cwis.org/2018/01/anti-indian-movement-on-the-tribal-frontier/]