Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Main-Contractor
:
Document Number:
IEC
□ □ □
Engineer
REJEC
DATE BY APPROVED NA COMMENTS
TED
Present document is property of Owner and it is prohibited any copy and/or convey of its original copy with any means, before the written
confirmation and approval of the Company's legal represents.
Detailed Investigation ISSUING DATE: 14/12/2017
Revision: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 2 of 35
1 TABLE OF CONTENTS
PURPOSE .................................................................................................................................................................4
2 SCOPE .............................................................................................................................................................4
4.1.9 Investigation of Method of Anchoring the Hydraulic Winch for Derrick. ..............................7
4.1.10 Investigation of Method of positioning and anchor points of the Derrick during Incident. ..7
4.1.11 Investigation of Method of Anchoring of the Steel rope and Steel Pulleys on the steel
elements of the Tower during lifting operation. ....................................................................................7
..............................................................................................................................................................12
..............................................................................................................................................................13
..............................................................................................................................................................14
..............................................................................................................................................................15
..............................................................................................................................................................16
..............................................................................................................................................................18
..............................................................................................................................................................19
Revision: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 3 of 35
..............................................................................................................................................................20
8 CONTRACTOR ORGANIZATION...................................................................................................................... 22
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 4 of 35
PURPOSE
To prevent measures about health and safety incidents in the feature regarding assembly of erection of
lattice steel towers required for construction of 1x400kV & 2x400kV transmission lines for OHL
2 SCOPE
This Detailed Investigation procedure establishes description and guidelines for investigation of root of
incident after incident about Lifting operation failure. It explains the the consequences of the incident,
Health Safe and Environmental Obligations prior works started., and the the final conclusion about this
incident.
Definitions
IEC – ClientEngineering Construction
CPM – Country Project Manager
TD – Technical Director
Tehno-Control –Authorized HS Company according to Montenegrin Laws
3 INVESTIGATION REFERENCES
COMPANY HSE Plan
QA/QC Plan
EN norms
Methodology Statement s
4.1 Requirements
Before Contractor will start performing the tower erection activity there is some requirements that
became completed.
1. All the crew became trained for such activity.
2. Equipment became in good condition and all safety devices functional and active during all the
time.
3. Tools must become in good shape and not damaged or modified.
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 5 of 35
4. Visitors or vendors must have permission to get in on site, they must attend a brief about the
HSE rules and sign the attendance sheet.
5. Housekeeping and clean working area.
6. Communication.
7. Working time.
8. Work organization and team coordination.
9. Grounding
10. All the equipment’s will be inspected periodically from HSE Department of COMPANY D.S.D
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 6 of 35
Equipment became in good condition and checked periodically (Techno Control Reports about
Machineries and equipment’s.
Operator of Hydraulic Winch became use the machineries and to he be shore that the
equipment to be well maintained.
Lifeline referred to COMPANY HSE Plan became be used for Tower erection only when the half
of the tower will be erected.
Rescue Plan for falling from heights became everyone was informed about the way of rescue
plan.
4.1.4 Housekeeping
On site the working area all the workplace was in good shape. Ground level was flat and free from
holes, mud, and ice. Also materials were stored in the proper way. Timbers, tools or any other material
was being store in order to have batter access and aggress.
4.1.5 Communication
According to witness communication with the team one by one during the activity the communication
became with Hand Signals.
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 7 of 35
During Site Inspection our Engineers has clearly show the conditions of method according to Hydraulic
Winch as follow;
The Hydraulic Winch was anchored in the form of a Vehicle Type Range Rover that was around 3.000kg
and was used us counterweight, the position of the vehicles.
4.1.10 Investigation of Method of positioning and anchor points of the Derrick during Incident.
During Site Investigation Inspection of our Engineers has clearly show the conditions of method
according to positioning and anchor method of Derrick during Lifting operations at T 91i.
Our Site Engineer has decelerated to HSE Department that Derrick according to witness of Foreman and
workers was fixed to 3 points on the body of the Tower because at this moment the was trying to fix the
Cross arm.
4.1.11 Investigation of Method of Anchoring of the Steel rope and Steel Pulleys on the steel
elements of the Tower during lifting operation.
During Site Investigation Inspection of our Engineers has clearly show the conditions of fixed method
according to positioning of steel ropes and steel pulleys and they decelerate as follow ;
1.The steel rope was cutter at the lever around 18m after of Derrick Hook. Attached Pictures of
Investigation date 05.12.2017.
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 8 of 35
2.The body of the Tower near to the cross arm was deformed. Attached photo of the Body of the Tower
91 I at Date 05.12.2017;
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 9 of 35
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 10 of 35
3.The Cross arm was on the ground deformed as a result of the fall;
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 11 of 35
4.The hydraulic Winch was anchored to the vehicle and was fixed with Ropes and everything was in
safety conditions. Attached Picture of the Hydraulic Winch date 05.12.2017;
During the Investigation our HSE Department has review and check all the documentation regarding
technical specification of machineries, equipment’s and accessories that are used to site T91 I during the
incident.
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 12 of 35
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 13 of 35
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 14 of 35
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 15 of 35
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 16 of 35
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 17 of 35
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 18 of 35
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 19 of 35
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 20 of 35
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 21 of 35
HS Measures;
All the Foreman of the Teams are informed about this incident and in the feature if they had such
situations during lifting operations they will secure the cross arm with double rope in order to not fall
from height.
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 22 of 35
8 CONTRACTOR ORGANIZATION
Counetry Project
Manager
Site Project
Manager
Mechanical Engineer
Mechanical
Engineer
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 23 of 35
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 24 of 35
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 25 of 35
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 26 of 35
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 27 of 35
Residual
Degree of
Degree of
Risk
Activity and Risk
Location Hazard and/or Who Person
Risk Degree
Risk Degree
Ref Result Control Measure(s)
Probability
Probability
Responsible for
ClientProject occurring of risk Effected
Severity
Severity
Control Measure(s)
Montenegro
1. Transportation Improper loading Drivers, 5 4 20 High Risks - Qualified and trained operators 3 4 12 Foreman, Site
of materials with or unloading Workers, only Engineer, Site
boom truck Pedestrians - Safe loading of vehicles on the Manager, HSE
load capacity Repres.Techno-
- Using proper equipment for Control
loading and unloading
- Check the loads if had moved
during transportation.
2. Transportation Overturn of Drivers, 4 5 20 High Risks - Qualified operators only 2 5 10 Foreman, Site
of materials with vehicles Operators, - Speed limits on site Engineer, Site
boom truck workers - Safe loading of vehicles on the Manager, HSE
load capacity Repres.Techno-
- Secure the loads during Control
transportation using certified
rigging equipment and in
accordance with CE standard
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 28 of 35
3. Transportation Collapse of Operators, 4 5 20 High Risks - Qualified operators only 2 5 10 Foreman, Site
of materials with materials workers, - Secure the loads during Engineer, Site
boom truck pedestrians transportation using cerfitied Manager, HSE
rigging equipment and in Repres.Techno-
accordance with CE standard Control
4. Transportation Materials fall on Operators, 5 5 25 Intolerable - Using proper PPE (hard hats, 3 4 12 Foreman, Site
of materials with personnel Workers, safety shoes, gloves, visible vest) Engineer, Site
Risks
boom truck Pedestrian - Using warning signs on the Manager, HSE
working area Repres.Techno-
- Prevent unauthorized person to Control
access to the working area
5. Lifting operation Effects of wind Drivers, 4 4 16 High Risks - Only trained operator 3 4 12 Foreman, Site
with boom track speed Operators, - When wind velocities are above Engineer, Site
All workers 40 km/h, the rated load and boom Manager, HSE
lengths shall be reduced Repres.Techno-
according to manufactures Control
specifications Refer to HSE plan
6. Lifting operation Bad positioning Drivers, 5 5 25 Intolerable - Trained and qualified operators 2 5 10 Foreman, Site
with boom track of boom track Operators, Risks - Position the boom track on solid Engineer, Site
All workers ground Manager, HSE
- Extending outriggers on both Repres.Techno-
sides when performing a lift Control
operation
7. Lifting operation Overhead power Drivers, 5 5 25 Intolerable - Visual control by the operator 2 5 10 Foreman, Site
with boom track lines and cables Operators, Risks before starting work. Engineer, Site
All workers - Use warning signs. Manager, HSE
Repres.Techno-
Control
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 29 of 35
8. Lifting operation Bad weather Operators, 5 5 25 Intolerable - Weather condition shall be 2 5 10 Foreman, Site
with boom track condition workers Risks regularly monitored Engineer, Site
- Work must be stopped during Manager, HSE
bad weather condition Repres.Techno-
- Wear proper PPE Control
9. Lifting operation Lifting gear Drivers, 4 5 20 High Risks - Only trained and qualified 2 5 10 Foreman, Site
with boom track failure Operators, personnel Engineer, Site
All workers - Inspect and determine whether a Manager, HSE
rope or other piece of lifting Repres.Techno-
equipment is damaged or not fit Control
for purpose
- Use certified lifting gear and in
accordance with CE standard
10. Lifting operation Collapse of the Operators, 5 5 15 Intolerable - Only trained and qualified 3 4 12 Foreman, Site
with boom track load due to all workers Risks operators Engineer, Site
improper rigging - Operators should be able to Manager, HSE
& slinging determine the weight, centre of Repres.Techno-
gravity and characteristics of the Control
load.
- Tool Box Talk
11. Lifting operation ,Anchoring of Drivers, 5 5 25 Intolerable - Only trained and qualified 3 4 12 Foreman, Site
with Hydraulic hydraulic winch Operators, Risks operators Engineer, Site
Winch All workers - Tool Box Talk Manager, HSE
-Anchoring of hydraulic winch will Repres.Techno-
be by Concrete blocks of similar Control
solutions as anchoring on the
trees etc.
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 30 of 35
12. Working at Falling from All workers 5 5 25 Intolerable - Only trained and qualified 2 5 10 Foreman, Site
height height due to who works at Risks workers Engineer, Site
slips & trips height - Fall arrest methods such as Manager, HSE
lanyards and fall arresters
Repres.Techno-
(Blocks) or vertical lifeline shall be
used. Control
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 31 of 35
14. Working at Falling from All workers 5 5 25 Intolerable - Only trained and qualified 2 5 10 Foreman, Site
height height due to who works at Risks workers Engineer, Site
negligence of height - Don’t smoke, eat, drink or use Manager, HSE
workers the phone during working at Repres.Techno-
height. Control
- Fall arrest methods such as
lanyards and fall arresters
(Blocks) only up of the middle of
Tower
15. Working at Object falling All workers 5 5 25 Intolerable - Don’t work below the workers 2 5 10 Foreman, Site
height from height Risks who work at height Engineer, Site
- Barricaded area with white & red Manager, HSE
tape Repres.Techno-
- Wear proper PPE (safety Control
harness, hard hats, safety shoes,
gloves, visible vest)
- Tool Box Talk
16. Working at Bad weather All workers 4 5 20 High Risks - Weather condition shall be 1 5 5 Foreman, Site
height condition (rain, regularly monitored Engineer, Site
thunderstorm) - Work must be stopped during Manager, HSE
bad weather condition Repres.Techno-
Control
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 32 of 35
17. Working at Electrical storm All workers 4 5 20 High Risks - Weather condition shall be 1 5 5 Foreman, Site
height regularly monitored. Engineer, Site
-Tower must be grounded before Manager, HSE
start the work. Repres.Techno-
- Work must be stopped during Control
bad weather condition.
-Safety harness will be used
during all the time
-When towers erected in the midel
of the body then all the workers
that are working at heights will use
Lifeline.
18. Working at Improper type of All workers 5 4 20 High Risks - Visual check of the tools before 3 4 12 Foreman, Site
height with tools starting work Engineer, Site
hand-tools - Remove all damaged tools Manager, HSE
- Use proper tools Repres.Techno-
- Wear proper PPE (safety Control
harness, hard hats, safety shoes,
gloves, visible vest)
- Tool Box Talk
19. Working with Improper storage All workers 5 4 20 High Risks - Store all materials & tools in 3 4 12 Foreman, Site
hand-tools of materials & proper place Engineer, Site
tools - Tool Box Talk Manager, HSE
Repres.Techno-
Control
20. Emergency Accident or All workers 5 4 20 High Risks - All the crew must have a first aid 3 4 12 Foreman, Site
response, incident cured on person for any accident or incident Engineer, Site
First Aid team. site case that might be on site. Manager, HSE
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 33 of 35
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 34 of 35
PROBABILITY SEVERITY
1 (VERY SMALL) Almost no 1 (VERY LIGHT) No loss of work time, can only be eliminated immediately, requiring first aid
2 (SMALL) Very few (once a year), only abnormal situations, 2 (LIGHT) No loss of working days, outpatient treatment without permanent effect
3 (MEDIUM) Under (a few times a year) 3 (MEDIUM) Slight injury, inpatient treatment / injury
4 (HIGH) Often (once a month) 4 (SERIOUS) Serious injury, long-term therapy, occupational disease
5 (VERY HIGH) Very frequently (once a week, every day), and under 5 (VERY SERIOUS) Death, permanent incapacity
normal operating conditions
RESULT ACTION
Intolerable Risk The work must not be started or ongoing activity must be stopped immediately till
(25) the defined risk is reduced. Although the activities carried out are not possible to
reduce risk, activity must be avoided.
Important Risks The work must not be started or ongoing activity must be stopped immediately till
(15, 16, 20) the defined risk is reduced. The risk relates to continue to work; emergency
measures to be taken and as a result of these measures should be decided to
continue the activity.
Mid-Level Risks The activities should be started for reducing of defined risks. The reduction
(8, 9, 10, 12) measures of risk may take more time.
Acceptable Risks The identified risks may not be necessary to eliminate additional control
(2, 3, 4, 5, 6) processes. However, these controls should be continued and maintained existing
controls be inspected.
Unimportant Planning and control processes carried out to eliminate the risks of identified
Risks activities may not need to keep records.
(1)
State of issue: 00
Incident Report ‘’ Page 35 of 35