zoontologies (cary Woe, EditorIn the Shadow of Wittgenstein’s Lion: Language, Ethics, and the Question of the Animal Cary Wolfe Fone of Language, Forms of ie: Witgerstoin, Covel and Hoorno 1 a9, toward the end of bis Plsloephia Inventions, Ludvig “Witenes et don a ne-sentence servation ha night very wel serve aan epgraph othe dbsts ha have ak place ove the past Century on alas, language, and sobjeciy "fa lon cou talk” ‘Wityenstein wrote, “we could at understand isn! This Deping statement bas offen Boe understood —L am not even ste tat ‘derstand itmyself—anditiscomplcared by Wingestnscoteation lure that "To imapne a lngugeit to imagine orm of fe" What ‘an itmean to imagine a language we cannot understand, spoken by» being who cannot speak-—apecly i ight of his reminder tat "The ind of certainty is the Kind of lnguage ams” (Wiest Reader, 9)? And exer ls" Tenet ta oma ut oa ina langue ‘ot undertnad by those potent my thoughts would be iden fom them" (23). Its however, important as earths observation that fone haman being eam be compet enigma to another We ers this ‘when we come into a strange county with eal sage tradsione ‘nd what is mor, ven gens masery ofthe county's ngage. We do ‘ot undesand he people (And not because of not knowing wha they sesaying0 themselves) (22 cayveeo Testhe capac you wl of he mutes of Wiens lon tha ighy xcs the acention of Vek Hearne lt et book Animal agin Taree poet ened ore ie and dog ie td ‘ens suet of the pluospticl nied rns fore Watgecein {tou Stney Cael cal Wegener the ot ine ‘sng ital abot animals that Tare ever come atu” Bree “on do ak tome peopel on snr" ae ders sod (eda abot language tat we il ve season teva) ‘iat interests ber show Witgensten’steanent verb oly ssem+—to body forth ap lo fre conte betes te andy ‘tnsprntinsadjecie human community ont oe eed he tes Ddeskaned teas on eo tr cote nd isa tu eve chat Wages out a tobe, a soe ne, “The rey thigaboutWigenst on tat Wagnntin doe ak ‘ep tsa hats ageless only tht be aig” = ‘ak ta i" pofandty ray acre enue ofall tere joe fer imal pins 23). "The een of thsi secon “isnot te esi abet asec of costes 07 know slg btraherof emendous presen ofl cnaciatars tte at ‘What Hen pots he ga om eect sh fn strane ine sor pose of Wiest "nize" —tthe pores f be ‘face upto theft of “comet been ute ‘pec what leis tached he costes tell oe "tk tht obit ti corcousas informe byte head me ition ofthe wetens the sal” 57). For Hearne, what mas ‘ingest’ inerventionvaoBe is hiro o tence of ‘hesnimal othe tow tobe me apron for uta for he an. ‘a "The human ade nerous wiht wong. es eae without wring he reminds wx "Sa whee gine te et oF ‘utr lieofs create witout hat ul ogi wat ne out Te ituar tats we ain ours emptied of taderanding? (id) Tas Witenes "sh rset ean te emia tht knoadge comes somaines oan ut enn vguey ‘Somewhere ik exlanons, ut immediately fact Grnatieg fern when sh enderstening bowen on don ies pet wrong. geass on, "apn with ope eect ad we Bes ‘runmedneinowdp of otenoran® (9) "Notas somenbere ie explains opting thoy arpa isistance ritakento eve bea Wigs Inte Show cvtgnsonston S| transahto of ptphical spc onebet eidreay Stuer (Gel Forel ourtendenyt we the rece of Wages on ‘Salickofsajesy impor of othing o mech "aur p= Sllteor cout he Independent existence of ter ind tar thats cern ene out our flare tobe god tobe "No One In arte with View fom Nowhere ar Hearas pus i (Zs ck, 25.2) Anthea n tar direst tay at oe Po Sls wecombon gt be Asem wet of tikes ho ke 7 {butucascaanobetaldiobe rly plying wih al beens ‘ot acm oo or arma of what lying wit dl! (a ost lds ti somainer tuto Wises) {inten ea homogenate. he eeu in thom el ro tae fring Spat apd igen an other asc mes a "tt isi paren af mening onsen enh The neni pith tt ly baat ome beg be pont i) pean Gin ere rs soph concep of hapiageanditeeaton oconaonees snd {yt is Witgeses net serand aetna eee pool way. Cael pte Sh wat peewee our undersanding of {aumals—tabe Winget i a ony the ost pea cag “Srautoo nck spb ite (qooteio id) Freel, ‘Ee plop ae tt Witgesen want rote he [ap ids tts problem ofthe otare prose Envingtie enn nn i te ig et rte ‘wa the oppoey mat” anima wheter shes ws won ‘wat wr cone lege 0" (que in isd ena edd.1F efor Wiens Cael ayue,"Ones ot eocuged 10 ooneauchirasemething-f note echans oF am Ese test Feing esgd, aninterpetct—tha exaw cs esh what they al ow he connection made" but aero devine What Keepreach arc gon (wibut ae er ovan Wien n- sc 1 rad us someting to do wah what eden as ep ‘Sinan whit pti aterp defeat cep For ane Witgentcn ot ons hate ni aati pe ‘us cfhow hing st happen shea fr tk ugh hy ‘sete howe athe se pone pue™*4 canine Wiens’ specie nerrento, hens "sepil peo kee hepsi ear pilosa spicier ack on el bck on the human, Hence, te peje of wt ie oflen read st ‘Wingentcomentionlan fina sta prone us da Sel iteiden ofaniverls eaplentins langage Psp hy ‘nu aves scem oan tsi aloud he ne dco. gy of aguage gues, "bt depen onthe sae ft of ngage 8 {do hecthe swan th" sent tad Noa ao moressre the sane of yt sl fee ile oe ng ta ean neath othe wel (la ip) "Heane pu icin an ey on he ano language ener ith Wisoethe chinese, een of wht Wee da, wt ond tio of angage we eden with nota intact problem, ¢ Poole” Ir Washoe uss lngeage and ern dangers dep that Fei sb mnt cecal oe teary howe nd my wan eny Wasboespenoshood an et agg nor than atnondge he it of langage na ok les erly ing poco” (am Ta.) "Ti means in Cavell woe, tht "We gn to eso ought sited hat maybe lnguage (2d endetandng at nage) at ‘pon rey shaky foundations hin et ver an sh (Ci 0), Adit lo an op descpton af wht Witenes hia mind we be say moc tao nog a laagage 9 imagine fe of lia Heasne puss Yoe can hag ut wih ape who peak 0 Engluband lars sometingf which cj tment which worl ‘Whats auch harder = know wt yu have tobe der genial “ings now th oe of postures my ko ha sono ny mens cl ea ot cts ces ‘ced iafrmants nd ch hig wae fk ptm son onset cnde oven ia bed at iCal pp 7) For Cael it sch shade of ens intimation of mening hich alow cern Kn of te dle of eommuniaon: he ‘yanaton tine bu agile Reena who cannot ae word of este in hse as it ouray ye ben your bu peas oto youre (Can 89 ‘Atthis plain he armen the Witenes tobe promising dae for aur aly ecnjuate the tons be teen guns peciyand gut ofthe er ote bese ‘Witgearteis conventional wotld spear a moe oe pea. nel sete the ost ren bebe uae a ata 8 Inte show otitghsLin 5 ferns expe, ves nthe nol aon Wy he pay for ngunge fist. olin tat total ieee it ‘Semstiee a lngunge ht anne ground and maser aos ef oningecy aun a3 sernd by bongo ngage dee ot povde a never he quran “What te ilrece betwee ums niobate ap tha question ive bd open yar Sing het the ferences beeen prtan i specie ngage fet nd hone "ntof thai Sa my eas prof hoe oly {Sten obras betwen teu tschand dena er ches her wers ny loge each nga ch “Wat Viger acount mes pose other wor swat seem als cnvenoals undestuncng othe shared dypamis of 1 yt bag that eed oi pace be ed to pets dine {Son atall Os this acount ote wos But singly aor ens from binge shared frm oe cough parton guage se And inden, tis the drstion fn wich eae bar taken ‘ingens xe aber wating on ho te sae gang of ia ‘ulbing makes posses conten word berren beings wth vasly iret perommcoges Por Hearne, "maining ees the kind of ‘ae al ling ot or ought do —bnowedg fhe op of tenon ac openne ta all nowy: fonda agape” das Tp And the setchinee of te theo hs gue gat rigilookins sient ie thew sor of aevepemori” ots ane tay ria gh amir sas hue— bat hs to Beremembred istht a ren for raga pt el 2 Uogrhamen lenge gee i that i aarpens oad nate of he ‘thins of en of agai, 7 empbasnded)." Wis near with op se contin, "eter maser bee 9 ead lnguope he bar fica euro pps et ot judge beee te healer nt becnne cmpechenble tthe ore {dts be ndentod iatobeopen 9 unrtaningraudhore than iFtoheveshard mental phenome Hiss Wipers gst ‘inst opponent ntrabjeciy depends on ed met pe omens od), What depends on sted ih "Dow of neon, ‘eting,belerng” there eins of oped hoop” nik ‘hy he bebaowst dog wat ol seam tps wl best weal Waepensin a asuming the inporiance of seg the publi nate flange he we dette oc bay up on et [Rhpmachne inarer td at concspraizoton rey cha function ofrnonshir and acnonogements pbc (8),© cay wots ‘Andyet Ia both Harn nd Cavell what wl haa, such too qui hee asa kindof mania «plpble nose foe ‘human curs thought back or see cure he eh al fore ofthe shard oad busing wit sna sein a st shee promised by th aoropriaon of Wien, ering he c= ‘ul ethealy nt phenomenology beaten nde hua ‘ute negated by teense The cnet eyptam af hs eas the sear thor fight Here br, ein pat, fom Cave (nen booms largely rom oy Ras) T pati very schnell he coneetaran ie ld at soa cons often ce thielyasyedo whe wes soi. Te whois ant ‘captor ft cot rey hoe He ‘Neandertal ete ad se ne ‘osc ofan eee lout tha eye ‘he aby wd eral ado aig tc hem ated te wo an i ta et they nso andes he ome hey obi soot sig a sins hey cnn, hy hae nigh how nis at “appears aoa (nme naa oe tye he eon ep) hep he a itm vl pte ‘cine he enn ere of op eta sce otto ry nour dg oa ae at ened ono ease the pa afin my a et hat ‘hes ay aw othe peopl who ae abot wt apn ‘Thi vi desired em Kan ht pounded by Here, ey {0 the leer, in mn eay oil published wader the tle “What ‘ong with Asal His” In der Be nigh ton ih oer he ages, te following mins conditions mt bo" ‘mat hao the person “he peton mat kno "The ria of therepocalpaseive mat py endBotho art ete ie ‘yw conch the right in quotients (inal apne, 09) Tor ee, "idonotown ou 00m 9 Yow thn do aot doe you repudiate you Yow cannot aero igi fn asp {omens we sn sachet (20) ‘Noting isles exe no alr of ort foul ‘ns tha woe onto ne everthing tht she hae pent te bts Patofher eer teachings aboot nonhuman others nde woe te Saw genet an 7 so bat ih hens "To df psteion ave in indi oe ee Slr. doe notion arty we sing the ote. Tabe ‘dogo the grounds that he dog then 9 othe moment ‘lets in ft nthe Gg att ning 0 st goes nt oweing 2 og do at undead yen words wh 147 onthe dogs ‘an therefore do an plese wis a” (08. Or aga ting a et ‘mous Aleta "Drummer an spsk isonet, bat he eann0t ‘peel nora the tit Ttefoe the ste anos tek 0 Drasarcantot bef sate Hens es notan een ornesett ats este i hat in patie the on wa 2 og hts ar pote ‘saint nlgbore thet yay of nape he ower per nitr tedg”(a)OF cour stanton py ‘ning ht al nner lego?” once And hey ae nti at ‘ent dies ti gon ase of seule! were Tne ae proper) citable thn does thi at be to gues ‘heehee poi of ranting ight oe ante wou oily ‘eeogize and pots ft (se 0 wlth be gunship ofthe cd) saint such ab ewer who decd to foe or abrogate for whateer _soson, at ‘ownerip oat In dito th tl objsson anon wit he cotractatan si af ey el Ill Hebi n= momen, ater re nt Inge sayin Cas ae i (adatom eadng of ‘igen concept of omy fie Ig cntat to what heal ie ‘ominant “theta” or borzotal eng of this tet In Witgein, Covel empha tase or eri sete hich “fel ditence betwee the ama i so-eld Toer ighe? ferrcfli ben pols yur od prsps wath ak d paving or eckang at ie Hae—and we wal ern odie it (er dcndonof oes Deady of Heleyger "ibe ance ofthe anand fs spon oumb come it pat of he up tre and ofthe et ree: bat the pee suena and ee of the man boy and of Ue bus Senses abd of the human ‘ice Carls gm rt keine with those ee Wiigenstins ‘Chovestionm aon mtomatc effin of epic edna ‘eH the ery ener thence of martgy a ate Tero pba pope oro the nemo of sting hans o oe dma the exiene of ngage const pro ofthe eine of ‘che (Ts Now, 2a posto tat wou econsonant with he “hard” convensonlst edg of «Ricard Rory or a Stley Fs Instead Cavs empha noon frais, em of tends‘wkend the condos ofthe ws of tei as apple ‘och (bid, 4-4) width grain ct these fo leo scl onsets ta arma ede tens Vitgescss Prisha Inexiations 4] Thee ey Coes eae Sab posting gure tthe hursn frm of West reduce te immannce ena") of lng ames Wits poss yo sot et a bckgronnd agit which hoe ngungegmes (p ‘atropine ay beaded da or antag? We Covet prec of the ordinary being poncho heey iy dei of speci “far of Wena be ght of we oe ‘coming efter or etn ointaton by etn of eg Uyenuting fing ty eng sh ar wade ya ‘Sle (ht Ne ‘Ande the problems ta is momenta for Cav te ‘pent eteaccarpaned bya ong eno he ey mas ‘Gathisphenemenslogcal pecans ha promised 9 ove te be yon. we te seo the ehnaogl comeinali sme af ‘Weegee forms of ia Cee ali ve sur en Weare ed ‘very qt with this ehcl lem: he alancton of guage ‘gute proms to ciromseribe ver moe dg these hae ey oxdl thorn ase Colson ese The veal ‘flingunge games that Witgenti nats onstenptca the shred tthe eof thse wth gunbuoal ath epee weng ‘he ical eam tio te hae wh spe in th tangae (hee ‘Cee’ ses stout Witgenteiscnretonalst cases), ‘Wisasitm art his navy mir of the inguistete ea fii that bth Tetene and Covel telotodace ean gue of he human fara ta om he eral trait in Hn fo camp the linge of asia training provides sare langge geen ‘ene ard ores trier an ln bet clang that mmr of relation as he deci bed by Be rae ‘yn tha ons whe hehe reat of gh prope e red che aes intestine of property even. sl is ‘otst al les ofcourse tat we hae eye dtywhatonee 0 {ose animals with whom we are ot ard aed fr ‘hough tang or eer means Hoe’ contra eo she ol teisforces th syne pre ofthe ehmscentrie we erate whe oi oii woul sa be Dat adds poe ona the oer excl x gtion of he cage an chet ‘pve sess bv futon the gion akccine™ ees oisnsainsLin 8 of ws coin or inh cone Wh wh ‘esta he go halogen, hme ts ly utter drm rnal hi ender nat tas rfl opine ear Sieh fen ten neem ‘hol fiancee ep enon! ‘Sebiepao eae forme of ne bad ‘SSnicour cen dre meee Clg ‘annie bg ves es [sivas mes bg oe oy bene se hin Nevis daf coms or eeoson (Coal es than6 conocer aiigetne mans ‘hn erent url frm ae sn Sittin tao rth hedge cur cro ge Suomen urs he pons Tht ‘Nips nowy htt esa pe pt mo fy st ig gs ig felt witiol mations rape orang a nag Sng kr ysgol Seco, Wocn we ‘The aig Wed fr abd an tor fi bs tye bond oi termes ning ders ate me ‘Denker tn atte ve sllpiny one oe nme ein od k s Only ed eh ha pao epg ah be icp tml Whe wie oe scapes he hn Saran ev wily el pepsin tte hehe yep Setar nel and a ose eo. wet ere aatonicogipry tos mpc Wa i sattenteytrcnnt win ee ot dem ote Eh ‘heone er tlane ik) my hg ttt i foaing rsa Oe uit for employ che sentnces on "hel a spring do othe he quent enrol i ees ftoa— 1 in ie Rewer atv i ei yn ‘ain betwen the hnoreaolgil abd ets nesta end ‘ht we ally det bythe term hua andthe pata el ‘neha of treliion Or ane might paint how pve cht12 oto “sing ttf nnd he age owt a Dace teal econ tne sa pcos vole "ouch dec capa Neat pt we ‘itm iO ene ght eS tt spec ths mbes ary ped oo ‘pha corneal yogi tao open tho dpcing ce sprain cena Deen ee ead ep fea ne ‘caw wo yh hw tg ep cle inti wea on Hern oer ‘Sole tt hel consent ‘Tit ao te nr pay oc onan era aratan yj beaten bea a fuga tater ced ‘ping eo eae ett cay eae ina scony tu it es haan eae oy ‘be Bade ae fer oppor ab ‘Mas ener Nr phone a hing eva a be ‘ya moc sal i gg at pe pat theca pag wey he Fe ung eg Sac coun eprops tins Cs pening ef ‘Schuman ial er ertngcctcene ape ‘Pate eth eh som" Ny es st enn nde pay pn Se he ‘atin iene hs pope haga eC a ire opened lt eed ‘Sherwin fou on rms sete Scene poo apa on ‘nce Scere chernaes ent fein cated wy ema a te eo ee Sig nina ot he ey lp di Bee ie hms ein bes separ ‘hain igh plop erage see “hm ar open ttl tr pean alc meer aed fon Fee the at cin fale aon Ss co “Dosti ors eis weak Inte Shas otpts Lin 3 Rory would adobe ee et argue al of tii dy ‘ards ita Caves ply porphin commitment ein ora ofthe problem of api, Skeptisi ae iowa You Polstheoof h word Rs ee the rc pido newlede fr as Au Cowl ter ofthe Kantian settament ih sepa Ie (Qusofthe Onna see wth epic .tasrearist ed Sow the eisene of the word rate tat wat we understand [vlads ofthe wood te pis Kan aks sto pay st ele ssy ‘Shin tokow te ginal pranthnthamn edge nto things hey ae intestate Yu dono youtube nate Gel stn abou eterna fret” ina womans” hiding astw the Kanton etement ht for Cel, links Witgentin to Heidesge—and ant wlauget ae opens Carl ‘oars of Helge huni, oe Ce Wess oti of tetan is asia plot etn tenets ofthe eon von homin igs Wittgenstein cl erent in foe i ad ‘heey inthe elton beeen unm and wor and hie "eesperion recoupment or rleston othe ching ina) eds the Dingo iby Kat ements at ike Hades ate lovopy with Witgenstetn 5" oncom of thei mong trace ‘uly sina rosea om Kant etme wit te hing ial ‘ec oward ining wo ieson of language—thae oot ‘werd objet ol that ar oar alte andthe nd (i [Nip PorCae moter word both Vga and Hider remincomate though ranted er cosplay 10 fin Imenlagament bebreesheranesraf object of hlgs the wo, Shite grammar of angape pms wd the fora of ie the geen ‘of han hat lle real ea of io he ara {Baris th the ture of ot tons he wld and "ba round bcwand opt ie ptosis they stead ‘What the Vn Gan (Nt) Se: ta (wth Levinas) However spe nd mance he meditations on language, phenome olgyand specie dificece in oe Witgensen/Cne see ad reeset sho at hy are ane need tecoutraing fore of dep nga humans ah work doe propel] ‘hak contrast thar ras wi toe of postr pon, Ibe he ters wily held be nothing ot oso tla ‘Boman haven ming er, pestle work of ear-Fagoit12 Gayot yptard and neuer Ded: Lyotard een of he ight coupling in ie woek ofthe foralanaaoflnguage game to qustonof ew sad sth nthe posi pert of wate lhe ha nd Dera bee no antemporry hort sarod ata more ‘euching epi, reriaton of he qoeion othe ania—ana- ‘ene tara nsomar pot anenngangracig tc ir ota th guano te ania embeded wt thar conc of the teasoseipbetewn portmoderiy and what be ar {sled the nhaman” Ar wel now, n The Pasian Coon {otal Bsr te Witney ofthe anguge pet ‘Ser the ola al ots of psy er wat he pn ‘ess tnt possnodern typeof plurals made publ by the ‘egiimaton of e"wand meureates of modem." Forse, ‘het of ng upea Wiese nein snot onl rade Iris Kantian intense diferencs beteen diet cots (the descrip andthe prescrip fr example) and nt ost there Iystack the leginay of the Score af sclene” (Decne on ‘escenario pc clings sper ae of ra) Wises to real" important carte of poxtmodeniy indeed, Summa otrdn antag perhaps tema important caren "Thea (bya elf ems toda its daneinatinn of langage [pes Teste ond gait bueno wore ihaing teal (Posimodos Conon 40 08 Us view modesty conse" sbuteing of ble” abd "covery of the cof ea of ig” (id 7) hen what ters nw ste postr ves ova is “Ascot of bepostmdr tthe hear the modes ents cea tae pei te dof els ule ia eon eg es. The ena (ead ote pmedna afte eof roca a etl fr prensa tos nh oso an fe swe) et in ope of varythng The empha canbe Peed aon te porate uty bean nia” ‘eminem ate geme eases othe) ‘Whar he breve ofthe meats of merit rope cle fothen ian pening of language gees coat enon nemo bes das Hsberatanavaesan wich oes lene Ino shasw cfgensas on 13 to the heterpensey of tnguage game” (ibid 5-66 7-3) an ‘png "ae preventains ine ats nd eave andy ‘ss wht cal "parlogy—s mode of eat questioning tats tet reduc othe perienatny pringpe’ of essaoeecs under ‘Spal tse tar seoul such phenotena as chs paradox {the is ania ding pus loathe invention ee {sey poding ot ee known but hewn). Wis uputet the perormatity modal of knoe ad legion snd teesreion inthe” gems tesa Wedded {copa ini a tard ely leer he weet Inst bet chner beng ight at tardigine scant Inhoman a antagonse"What if hue Gln in rains seth writer, "were nthe procs of opted i, eg D> man [Whats prope obunasling were toe bed Ute inhaman! famine nd nen ge ih agg ning dion bts ving ita" There en ft wo (feet ponies of tenuate The Shingo [ots earn of he abject tbe "abet of pase fin dows of arate angus came” andcompoaens of Shoe ge ch wh pragmatic recs pect sind each p= [ge olson in patcher—Iocal determin (Psion Cindi Thi dey aneiropocens ene fe [ects i apothen a The ie where yond xis a "phase olen coincide neler with cain of the sal Er wich ‘gue ae ou dos py sand with gute Ania is set here se no gue ges Thee aise to gers ds ous i ane ode fh acc hat tad are yap he "enropoentien” that in general peppy gue ongnoge natura tps wiht ‘comanistont [a « Eshermaan sense and peed fasts oly by thw Pe Sas and antiens of mans “The quota suas before ws, of one, whether dis recon ceptuclanton ofthe sbjet ole uo funder he eatin of guage, etl sd the gueton af the nia In it, Tora his question nin psn, The Difeead—eet ‘har wold sem pec pong ahs omneton ss este ‘naniopocmnsen ech Ale a Ameo hr pas Aik Sse fe char png oft ing oan acto!14 cote ‘ety can bps —Aad te gig dg epee ‘nofacat—nds oy pio Weta pon ebro ht sea ene. lnes le The pct it of te ‘thao eee Figo psf ws cot bom be pin) Ltd woud in etd ene of ngage pein Cote ae pcan ote fete ‘sent hc de ee as oh pouty wen tr eg byte olin ies Tina sgt Sheehan ascend oenienge arb bet neh ‘What sil ee Raman hans he intl eof ec entrap cea ae hich "The tr oe pends pape tare ‘ego The guste oa of novi wr, ‘oe ans me pice a oo eit, Ith were ted bein the al or velo lt whe bao getty uo at ‘ono a poner itching the i of ipotng tem andthe teen fee the pe ‘one Chicas Tanita "ermintonlondprng sth goon Rss consgue feeb abr atonee elle Ine ofan. rnc opp aes Sh eh spicataniag ir bag oreo nee ot he ‘aaa ages at ester cmon he kl ‘ie nan ben sires br ale tha oe ie i byt wc ate eget te mii ale wanes wk ny lh tn ‘That semand ike cls on kin bee mee) ‘ent ug tt "ur contri agnor w ‘Sat whats prope manna ss abe of ding propery. nothingness ors transcendence today the gn no casey ‘at sacha poste "hari and ert e wht afer the ft ad havea tied under dee beatingenor Sigur hep, mee shez orga en 18 ico, ony ing—to roar the unarmonae (The el then nthe ian nese ny hat epost a> ithe moder, nd what ake th snag indy sere wel “heosng he animal tert it poss permanent inet ml ‘py and sa dfeoce nthe very cone of ect as 502 ain ‘ings promis tly extend conteprarywansaatons of he Structr hrrlogy beween chi nd animal rae a at st eed ‘ota’ wos ths sens at is gee wo mark an nance ed caves th usin ofthe somal Fr ban fro wen» Kaun feo sort~ te snimal mai as one omit ros lee wih the Fann Thing nthe feof hie nowedge comes 0 ‘aco Aad in and by hat end thease the humanist model of sh Jevviy ae inerrogeed, Use Cares septic, haweve, Lyotard ‘oernot repli ey nog oe {Hytrin ite poeatie pb er lr More oie ann moe ety pose ems byted oes ot fam sonar Cave spl ane does fr Some repesntiont sTigement bere opistcted, between he rami of langue {emer and he rmanf he word of cores ae Problema ar ne bare see sn Carel eding fie" ese fof Wiggs Torn of Tyo Rowe ths ptesl opening fr thering te sini logof the ea ote seo inte end by he ery Kastan ‘esas wis Cael Ase expla ein Phe ified ina pasage weshoul eri oar wi tbe carer qusion onthe Gg the (eepeted ey and dances phe ‘Thee andra of ngage nt ne ‘Bing i mt ea beatin pes ate be Tae Indes cnc ee pr ioe aes ‘cheapie Taste ee wt ono Vyabalsy the diaeahomehiag’abobeptinerbe ‘ate ag fat ang le ob pn rest Thin he haan bg whe gh hey ce n= fg anne of mci lar Boag te ago Phinvhichasominia lee and ene tc copie enon fener on). hey annoy page at ‘remy oe ae eed ey apo ean {ntey tbe cloned ties it ote (3)18 cae ‘Wha bart nl om tis ther poten weemag eo ‘enone det nba in od ever eng eae {ng tha" be pened an th Kata onto 9 he roe ‘Bisa the bine tat tard devin umf te oe nd aay erie ia The nts Cond he "eng and jure’ of aie tte eet ‘twee fhe jee fay conte some ad she yo peat som (7 an hes pew te ‘gin Eso prcat on je which ig cnn pte sere mucha concn ie hte ds he wal eal a ‘rats buted gett hepa sow sn caga pach ‘ese ene nn Srna ‘ale threat edad sp rn rae a i “carsive rules and inventions, = “ "hath sn problems ft ine prove ving cont forthe ams] ed eign nd sad esi ton ph stern ceria The Dien And he Prot tht om hee“alsoces snd eto” eee ‘tan seein dt fle praupperl tanat sy preseason cuyiag softest ‘Rees fr thea oe oft rad asi Thelen “telingf te mute or azote setae ote ela, be case ina dont power he eapacty opulence fhdelng even ity an resect res fe Soot wtbeling sds ot cr cling dss ad end Souda apo ie etl el he poston of adc ple “Fa eect fem thea acres om sine at am gps eno tt you epakng oat sad aly canoe sy ‘pula wnt arben ware In oa can pe ‘evr cm tand hen nea wat oe gtd ‘tune eps crise petite “Tels et tien? bo wins nd thr comnts prey he fase eda snot dt, cms ope apres in Shestonet of thle hat wc ae eps bone stave een ones epingalnn orien {ema en one aly ng, oy sg tn ch woy one he en of cy fe Bong” Ct amin 5) The ous thao de ft oral per edu oy ypu att bet en Stes nto Shaw goats or 7 th prope ter wef edge. sa: Do wha, ton n- ‘Bion hat Da ck ash wch You do, the ein wat ‘oad alas be vada et se not Seng bere With ete ‘inant whan dso buen nit” Ge) "ee elinge enon atl aon fhe abject ape scan tir very doe wat we nd inthe work of mane {Evinaraconecon tse thie reached ts igh-vate mark in ‘yours wot during the ero ofthe comeastos wih Je-Loup ‘Tada clit der he ile ft Gang” Tere, Lot xis ‘Bait "haere prslging fhe olf ie dre Levins ‘Sate plas whee encthng peed ome at ihre Ta blister ay eed” ()-Wha hiss thatthe Cal"you musts ihe obligation stendant apes te adress be pre Serpe sch cannot "dere fom ras on Ranta ‘om the dept Ando te foly—and in ots eas in form of ertarr—to ti fe rans forthe origin o cote of tthe oblatin “Theo mut Lytard wet "an clips that ‘ims tone dey exprenenosometing tat eds experince sh™ ‘Tee qution the, ie wheter his Levinas sense ofthe ethic ‘mals is onl to nk snow the question othe sonkman sin Fas ewe os conte od erage led" Obs OF Tobby amaniem of the Other Aoi) ha clad this question Tead-on Boy (nthe nore ddd mendes of eins wna) Chename of got wor Levinas wr na eo 975i sic ac lve pate al at propose analogy betwee the haps turns Holst andthe spn animal ene Baby, ‘th seed at the pum cap where eins ad his flow ish rene he theses become nected being teed es “hn rama? cnn ar dog wd, fendsip nd aay tie rope geting them ween fd day ight ees an age [ne al woo repr for than” eonton, he bien Er Lovina csngto Lew ta "Bobby asthe rans ou Secs is mai Hee o0 mpi, rp BODY witht Ings nd tat sy ee without ets since te ete of Eman evnu psaogou oh is finan Kane” Ae Kan ‘Shae in lou experience ear sequined with no Beng which tise capable ofp (tear use cept aan a tee [Eercem hove dy to any being other hen ar (quated ni 50) Ab Hoey ee pin opto, ot Ut he qstin28 canon famously eed by remy Bethan wih rep tamale they fei elevator Ran" nats vie we sek So age lass ab "aural edad sinc hates od ictes ls wel bring asia the mnt "Tt nonbraneimaly hey e ocapcy fr fc ist one tat can be cnn cence aw of mature bese Sach oncpios nico wih What ‘ne kno as nial fom oe owe emece o ing cne[). Ath neti howete, Kan "resin that we a ome rts oly ong that ae Walle nda spre ea reson ibid) Ande Levinas acorn to lena tg are er sorting tha a Kent. Pi cra Levis hth ae ‘eof the smal wecas dice 3 engin, however Sao is sen moray... n Levin ese ofthe worth animales Sex" (4p, became ony bor sheds ean he cel el ofthe fe ord adres to ne by the Other "Thow hl ot ce ‘ply omy restion witha aeahna ther And bere ern ‘versie unambiguoay "0" 34) Scond for Levins" can ‘be dct rspnslies oni tod being hat can sea both “Levine Kane ike Hears) “ego eging Vengo eo ‘ales dh nso many words No ci got tout siege he ‘spogs the sent yng ofthe ico ne fcc” emion ‘tai at wee, etd Kana sexing of lng "alee andthe wining of he phaze tin th end eben | The Dien tna echo of Carls medion onthe Ymane Of ‘he hand ad is apponble thumb "he ope pos aad he pe ‘set forbeven wend in eins tht"The Ota ony oct ded wt sessed in hiss ayers y shan oe ape fh nc (ath fill asonnc fh we wep n a ‘moment in Dera adn of etdggers Hands Aad sgh fr vin chis"wey dota of he fete, pepe ee tude inh expen ofthe ote’ drt ovr meta eons an sv include Bobo any inal wh deprived of Wile reno td begun, ema for al eel papas es) Smita yet. one dos otiaow wha the til cl cl fo, ‘pute cern knw from le ‘Tose ig Won thls 8 eto Vai ine formofan pon bust elon ny nse the ites in pectic cnt a ol a ‘dhyana Thee lo ne gy ore mca fh poi ibe parte pe Be een Inte Shsowetvngaratenbin 39 seco eis conn ven oh et iCralenerinows cag 9) ‘ sein The Dims to te Lyotard’ wet te qution eps in 7 igo dog lhe pre ea fe" come ao sa Je he when ees erin eo hate sd ease Tern tment ita, dig of ei {sw floes ane Some elmore nage ft pon nani on ve ‘cine apo hun Te beoethesinalisrped of be ohio being waranty no eh damage creguee ey maps wong es iinet ps foh Dot itoeraat abbr ess teat trite thee ot en dpe orsrnutu eno eh ‘Gone Thatvy elope evi (i) "Thos we ae earned inte via oan eset ie ‘wemel spliced) busin repuding heel end he ail tnt keno ranted tee often wich, rca oer bes-wiioig th Tning" dt generated ‘aly producti of ot ncadd inthe pousmodern parla tha Tpotrd wane opens ad econ, nthe ein of he eal » Cinmunty of eisoabe eng wae tending groaned inthe ‘Spector lnpuge wheter ved sequen tbe sel ‘Sue ih on asec ry yam of and ees res ayo hnaae inde aw dlr lta Gr ison he pai see een [Era thea ae hae pet ces tine of soma at ‘Poise somes dns orb ho si tht Fang ‘uur Ute onto cre ef ono foe ‘hin denn mitra ‘Sore crapper own lino mapas Dat Siete wine ae ee, Site hums now lap ead co Senet iene saccharate a om wh {lean eine Tn seen yaa ema on Dota wets on coun esr ras etni ‘The Anil, Whats Won" Dee (uth Lovins) Given he shortzoming ofthe Lyotard ame would to tan ‘ow tothe woe oss Dene ower Of Sri: Hedge otse han tse ei ey Sree aerate et ieee amen eetcosim Srnec ee en eer erated Pivnpenaieeenaeenee ipso eter ceca HES etn een xterra eco Soe eee ees joe aiceb memeber iting seein Seemeloragarsrenemnces aetna Societe meen io perha ma actaangecene™ Spier aca ata e Telecine aren gla ma aoe ee wide tpmpegerecnaran esa ce ete suc diome enon SPS pier ales pe Bhs eliingurartoncaterge omer te Seca rat mamas Selina mma aerate esas eens Recedtgerrvenre rs Sin Bt Sardar ase eo" Ribtmeacr cage maha Shatitigreamicnt oe ee Mosc alg inert ee gre ey apenas cae” snake eget wollen eye Sica eres nie Stas mgustans Len 2 deen hiking, very being he and Weisel eer) Init elamen lta ook of taehané rote i ua Tar, ‘hiking {de Bek) fa mans ops andor Ua Faso hase 5 Han Wer (qed ni) ‘thud be seminde eof sir omen Cv sing of hgh ste tenes Tkng anc” etry ‘to mean nt the bad and “antsy ofthe spposble tuts "hough dinar onto te wo bt, aor pln- ty that eeminésusof Heeger iseeton Weer one (otling sind anid veces of Sitchin” oa Ing tough bat we night l "probe conception Whose tothe the ald dominion oftecalgy” (Conon Hendons Shs) noppsiton olf tis rel ds Hedger empbasi on ‘fought ar ecapton snd of wlan, dort y ies input that inion he eration of te word Sng oe ot farthing? iin aks oe gil of ashiog (9) Tico ut up watthisjunsure that Drs tiga of hie -shstr ofp in egg oe ere poled tha Cavell, be faa Cre ar webae see rman a some porn ese apa of ‘Eat mans traon t ch Heder bangs To pot another ‘Caan evo of epee of sepia + Salen stony the aondeconstrtiy ote eppeion be ews gag nod ng Bt ener ofthe arama” Der aes, ‘ant ae rdaable othe sured opposon ef ring and ing in band pan ee gsand iene oop. hess The org ofthese or of um sa stp eal dee taxa tne ony nhl sy hand ig The ren cad [ny eld tan maple th ingrained ante dea witht sc doe atthe hinge what fnitemenc” (la I 3)-Dut ofcoureand beth ier {ez wth Coed" Neth senses Dea bas agued in any ‘robert han he ine Seen gig and ang”). idee ands onan ergecilly rgd te wher in Of pnt wl iq in Heeger "Whe profound eps ‘stl hte sje to rior deconstrecion ade Tortured thesia Fudan Cons of erp hat (1) Te ‘one thot worl bu (2) "Tae ania is poo in word une {Sh Mans who -wor-oring ort ng (4). Dien Fema ta ft look Hike dence elt i dee betwee, {hep the snl ad the ple fhe human lato to22 emmete borings oii pany icin ge tence isn diner) hee ea bere ctw ws naapabin tr oge' ated ntsc Lehn hina odin eae ee “Tasco wo re sil toss peso ‘ails trhnuse"“hckacie narekonescarhone Hewes os pens os porn acisop in pear un) Ts a ee {rsa ha wd ine lavage bet vodbecetiarscna tn atte Sete dr nesses dao ‘nd iio rcs ht stig Denn enn Tibi w ase iy pty gu tem th ppt pene apo ‘atthe penomcnn ne pte sence ee oy ‘rhc netepa thal uot ae oe oe ‘beet ih Portege hey -Towes ro mind Deer ee Danis crete! ecm he wha fee oe re iy of usc) Te wal ao ad cto pt ne rin at eho chaodon oan ‘alr or ct ben Or ‘cmd oom fe de of he nl in eg at Wrage cman oss seg weg okt ‘elope premade cpote ens ‘heed grt Dre ctype ese ‘efomet ts pouepo bathe ont ting cnet cena pe of ty while ning ase ‘ihe ang wll Gi Tneneac ee {dogma an prs of i we age a este “ats” of Helge hn wc Scomes fr Dee ge Stade kon fee pres tt ‘tint hp ete pcs ewe es 2 ese poi hail ep mas ops cr Dr dees ‘ilLennan Thad of seman sche Dende ee "Ger comity ok nase sage og ‘elit npn hee a has ee ‘ro tite tothe hn a monte ag marcas sth con fini in eel st gary an ‘yn ola bend onan Dee socom eee cetera eee gta iat et re gia Siereemetcerge esa erat tna ret’ oer Sorin cncneeetans {Sac wat ote nia py renames ‘Sector scone mance deen ere he Seer neers smear nent eee draernacaltremronate so weeietne cee mona Se ee Se Berane eect ‘nano what eee tpn” beeing of ad sara nena cee aera I en nanrctgetn ware vere et at sin tea ae iscaaae aimee sr gene Sea Scenirneatemnte ceergeete shee error arena ire raronnercan caer cna notte arene ue ache ai sheet gee Siam reece eae ratte eee Sac eee aoa seen siabshinegnienh nee ae ced28 cxywote ‘That Therefore Am — eat cal wanason ofthese of Wigston But hon nda te |nessore thats bound be sup, Deidara he cet ‘uetion amo aed by frery Ben in sespons to Dest ‘he qution with animal ist an heya o in they oon a ‘hey fe *Onsitsprotoe seabed Baie wena sbi gueaon changes evrything” (6) becte rom Artin esate os Desa eel a Heng Levias and Lae singe quion ofthe snimalin emo ete Sng orlagage “etn many thers conceng power capably owing, nd ates eos blag abl having the pone gece ban ons esd to dress co wok talent tecniaue (99) Wt ‘aks Bent estan ofthe gaeton so powell that ey ‘Te guion is diturbed by x cera psy bas inc nal fetingatedysqeston the response ates aun, rp 08 nt beig-ble” “Wha ofthe vant eon tebe ok ‘his inal be continas "What this non. pones thet of ome? What ih shal bearded io To wate donee ‘um as” (6). concer us very yin faa ow os ‘both Heeger an evses—for"Metalty resent no radical mens of thinking the iad that we hace wih caine de ‘orty that belongs tothe ery nt of ifthe capenene of ‘ompusion tthe posi of sang the poly otis cos, ower the ponte his pei the angus oF ss nr ‘yan the vuln f thing (id Teishee ths preci ance tne Dette’ complex eatin: ‘hip with Levins om th questo of ethers rt mt th [yotari— ‘hig condensate tert "seu to Marna and rest haing of hs poe ner ous te sy operate byway of te wa ato osreb wes ‘heres ae ss hte nervous osm abd he sacar ct Itceonment We can ths dere the beara ofa organs os though toe forthe persis nervos cn wih ete tdns ofthe enevament or eh expression of some gol oreted roe Ths dorpdons however; do ot est the open ofthe eto vem il They ae ond ely rhe purposes feos ‘ton among ous obseres (gs) To a as mc con ‘Ent Rowan wl frzable snag” Decase ses tt the palette ae of the nero te a opecaing WARP ‘Setanta the rounding ely” The way Of his ‘Sena they ones undean be ace beeen Ss crcorte ant seo ne bein ob Ns han em a Sore acon wee dsag wt eaten of Sere tide haa april pes tuyere on el cst dns ato ie hee node scm tower ee ay ‘Serene and cri tnt ee Snares ‘onic op usr tdacs we wilpoaete ofthat sae dic. ep gua reason betaine ee ete ie ‘Som he eto tc oe ‘ltl news sini eal gt fag ‘Di sci sWobraon itemee ober ney rg ous an icons Spare Sine eter mt nd of eosin hs cenen Strand apa ‘ein i cio min enigma we ‘ke Thu oe eon hank wea oer ha Soma ‘re copies ops a toma artnet and esc hngOnhe oe hd ncn yet ‘Sonera ws erornstan dace aber eee iNet o ttn pone Sporn nn Sshacinney ict msg cece sre vino then fen ste rg Tepe ‘oi we we mincing gm on comand ‘ht the evpendnen w eaibetrer te ee ne ‘heer an scan bei st oft pent ca ls sonds ce send i pec hi cnt ap vies been he econo stan cory Satan sn Vt an he deenstion of Dri Weng oh ig ‘ny seston” tha eee sete nig ee, ‘net of ans to anaes the aren of nap Marna oad ‘rl sgn at eer a florins fre wo” beak "he inepaaily bern pel wy bg sd howe wad ‘pps Fr usagi igy heat tt Pree to. adding one ote uation of human tne, erly ‘os ace in ngage wich or Stine yo beg human and Selgin ate (a). Ox as Mataren pa it ewer nan pe ily retin xa = Inte Sacrum on 45 coms oasnimon ger ence plone Corey tangent operate tomers ‘Sesriem penn ‘Sheeting hepeonaly Se (Sete eel fe pros de peta be Seep sms pone eine sry nla ‘lpmant ono ene Trstin oe enetmtecona a] permeate nd Erhieg chp mi Soop ey i ac cd ema ‘nyse soe fom cnn én ‘Wht Maarane sd Vie ft ink the ws veo of how asin erie’ uate boro Rodsphe Ges dasactesaton, the condos of port odours reat ae tine condos tf ipostby = Moe ees cnt om thes"Ladependet entttig phenomenal dems tht thas in bg ninar= ‘Svng dt te mare fay Conc es gs bt we x Jo ‘Soalyby meso the phenomenal dana of gps. Fr Mtrana {hale beer and thi, tink cpus the foc of eat ‘Faclzation ofthe concept of the"ece beyond he Nurs forthe reset dcuniortht pbeomenal domain eg "an interop of ‘odie a nen strvctse’ ba doer aot ake ace one of thom A tarns pitino atl of Batson work fn mammalian conaanicatin, has pata reemanes ir Deda Stuence on fe dase aban carer angus o> on by is he byl ther "ewe human eg enter, fur buiphoot hea of ode operstnal interaction fale ‘Spero coerncs hat we eng fh as obser ou xs ton of our opeston” Seen: and Daly Le 4 Hence, bd) ood ota ngunschange accord iothe fo of heelngsg- ‘nan he dow tr bngsaping changes este tthe chang ‘likes bes, Dato he roar Sadingorbndpbood champs donee cordianon of conwn ngusge ee hng hat he ‘hore dos vu buseabelg err atthe kvl oe pea ‘onal esti in biz her boyd nae andthe sme dan? ‘rn hah ier conte dorsing ach the pacea and the “Sheol yn he eomveratioel dans in wih the ae di ‘ingle chase appara beta dierent 43[Gary a Matsa nd Vr he las back oe in _genyfthe ove dino spec ese St an bre se erations consti bythe domain fue uta doh of language ht ot foundsional bene tony teal ae _oitonsry roses et speci arly ing etal and dan observer who, eaters rade tos bdo sbvar already internally oer nd in profound ese “etal” Dt ere Dec empints on the dacoatily ofthe observes ‘oherain woul al on he pada elsionelp ete age ‘he ntl deena namics of egg, fr Martane od la, ‘heemphasaul fT inten the pera lieben ie nerve dicrine elf elerence td holo heroarnce ‘way in thbodhodt te bere antalya the oar ty roitontry emerpne va iharn di and ean ih the prac that ol bn Iie told hye eed ‘0 rovidean explain of how being is coal hee enya io provide a expen oho ing this and 9, Foret the ypontted eatin been "ine" and tee thas mae "aml adifeentl inept dental ecco a Derrida ower he cnet of gs propel us edt ‘yard theme and contingent Mra snd Vn te with environment and src, wot demands an “eigen ast avery el problem forthe topos the onan ‘eo theanerofDera snd of ature nd Veco na ee, ‘nappa dicons Dea rm nest sete at niga probl ofthe ssepodacon ngs he coming of ‘hese and Matsun abd Vares om th cic rem hag aur peblem ofthe oerhlesing cntngeacy and come oe vino the topos ofl ferent opaaon hy cing comply mates bsevation penile Tevouke cpg {sppose fd ia Denis “esc beynd Seuss he opening of radi concept of lngaage silo ‘igloo jst "rteriazton” which wold be Decay ‘ough fc ox Deleans bt mere poitady.n theater moi lof te ving and ay find ine logy ef Mace ‘Virsa ndoigasication of Blog eth nto ete istoclepl poke that ngage "ousting pois, ot ogee ensues and our shin point” ler 26) ut hte on sk ‘at fos ystems theory inode for what makes ceo tote Sato ctepnr ce 47 oc po ae ano pti hat ey) pedi ot {Sopa std em of diet ner on gigs teeta psy en mene own oonarcie Selon ae it et bit ate te lp ‘ewes on absence nd operon aren a tery sb en ta in nur oft Ce en a T-Ricetutie knowledge bon pcs of eraton aot ‘iy ng nd pon ute a tg a ne) cmp here mp meme Ts righ we ca sre tery aren puts i." sin f dn abt ‘Shemp wine Bay toenail ‘etna orn prrnon of iagage guns wd el eas wot wc pth ase yeapectnon ether no ‘thm oberrtn he indo th os ci in: Tm The ot veefoetl dont npgeene ower feral dvs hen tan sind menos oat pe Seay by wing wera feet Ges that Der So Men und Weds edu coulemnng oo ots Aan iin Gara drt fon eel {Spel tat coud ean he expanaen of rain apt pon ‘Shura nd poet srs oom “ats pin ntti Gasing raison onlpe ‘ra hate svn iene tht rea othe ent ‘eons en dog tee yl ne opp" ‘eee te cation sh in nae cn ie fas fect tens. Thi eee a eam Gere a rcs (hss se de (2a) este they havea pert epton i ny. ‘Taken poet nth fon of rengeen tate, ‘Sing ae lng chon dol Mana Sivteut epaton of com many Deh og a he ‘Spohn s+ poem epecin Tex he ‘Soupan ding ht hey ep cotngece ke one herbi ay ap help epi bow we the bilgi Marana sad ‘yarn soundings lt ite the phloophar Dera Auapier and “Caption were hy contend ht“hedaman of comes stds ane poset ep ‘uti oft though doune Beaten oder ‘So deo pone me denny onli ten telco dctpin ele te dering oe ant apts doa ‘hag denne rth aca dewe ‘we wold ave dees. Thay ahoogh i arate es {Wied for peopl en nthing ca be abs eet ‘tans meta eel ee sae "Nothing oud the tet inde ret of coun, eying. cS ee ‘Blachoral, 9) 23 Subset references are given a the tex, Se TAMER are means soba eee oe eee re ieee NEOTEL I meena wR ere Sree a ironies hoe ee Soha ciate yuna wimcroraurmnptiocta "Gabo eh rey fc Po 8 es Go eg hema ro i in Wig ia 2 ‘Sey itis raeing a enna" Seis halos ‘Cnc toma heme 10.Se Daniel Denwt, Counc Fpl Bota tide, rows, ‘shen i dng satow ot wtpata Lin #9 11 Se my“0l Oslin oN Eloy Ani ghd te oe Humane” Basa are 9383 Se mys Fone oan Rh Noss. nd Meda a me! dns at roe 953 2 Sasley Gove Qu fOr Seco Rot (Gag yf Ch Pron 9.3. "Wr Wage ms the Une us yt rs ihcenh ft vars tp ttn be etn sof ‘espn operand eto ain Ice ma the pce cs nym a ei he npr oh fhe pyaar vor he proper ane et [teat intr. Pe Pedr Cin & pot on Krolg {ta Gea Reng oft Mas fewer oy Eee eon [Mme Une oMiat rasp. 0 Suet es ten ea efor pnd eri yt we Te Dens a eer tee pita era cami eli, vc snr ei te Pd epic ae con feline og ity sou endowed Te poise edo or cee be zn of opera eg towns slicker pope noo the nar dewspen chee ls enone puta at cede tay of ale la Eis pong poten welt Northen tempol South sncnglpoet thew pn gnc dean stn ‘con nnn feng) an te btn of te ac ‘eae (Teo net i Fen Mog Toma ‘in lon ean MrT Dan Bary Beets Vie cao Wd eh ence Uses of Mes Ps, shh) 1 es-FanigetaTenmat GafieyBosingon and ‘uci! ov St Cas Sor Une Psp St eens gente "ifs Tei Pr pt Cn Mast re 9h eet eee ae ithe Ae od center at ings olde edn or yh eee hen een ie coi guy ws fra or conta Ioana th prin to Ber uel eso ae We ‘heey of apa ype id haope en eae oe ‘eckon Nhe ny ia bi Pate Thy x ‘beng te "Outi Paneaple Unt of Mi Pres ‘yoterranrae0 caote 12h ih conc sng ts Di ane os ‘seotcin tno Ha le Homan er Roa, ‘pole oot tat" ge wc te meds ‘weed ina ams id man aes oc ‘atten sped cet iy ory {repeats stone han sd ats ‘enim hrs ke hears ns A ‘Sohena“oats tcf than manda ‘nu bende oem —Ly ede th beled {niet amen cnn sey "hes gt amp Ta a oi Wik akc ysl es leap aes sat Fone Stee ne eae "holes oan Sasa Go ssi etl put yan only Coe ron ey ‘elo oft tie eth ft tes on te ter op scmognet rape ah pn ‘tsa aaa net mcrae page "ino aang en ay mel” CDecneracon a gee Dens nt Hosters Pace Deon Pagan 22. Chantal Moule (Londo: sledge 19], 3) fee 2 Ini et gto ec er wi ei a Gain wine ee mena ‘ft oe espa apt con ‘tint are te experince to Tt Ye coach shin ea tem ‘ara fe meet eta Neate oes ‘rpms hr ato sn ef tee $iyeeapne (Nom tr ny ae gd es ‘ofan yd ptt yon ety Ippo nash tan stan ifn dt pe ‘Semen od objet ale Fmt eer {ete evan (isd ee chy aL ‘manele nour) a gt en ode end Jesse bt tron Ltd tte Trem ca of eso oni len ye cy ‘agama ens Aad a oad Coney re ‘iar pees es es re a he ey {ie ex om ont wat sya eats Ber is in bnew esa snc Se fe satovt wanton 81 selene nn epi te pac ps ‘Sisterer ini, ah earns ae Silene yee fin a net opt ‘Stnenetaigsn a Sr om Lima he Ohl Bty ume oe Ober stan rangi oR ben Sen tly {Hooton nant Urey era ob eet fonocen Sanh wd en cone beg a yo sepia Tr Cnefraina g On isp ee ‘Siac pete erie Snyper ml lee ‘Siac wkhdntopit an fon be os {Eid lal Seacrem tm we erie ages tn bean bat esc ao uss lute ero un om nn caret oh eee oh pica) ep agp ean tn ‘mals pee psy cca aoe re Tonner forty “pcan ts ee sett epee rehab jatcc on teeters Parco eect cma ee ep tatbore tr “Groeten ysis tcp te ‘Dew encyatle ts csonny tw tegen oer a ‘Stapociscomlyefpemme Ones Sge Ha ‘tor Toney oil rating se Sifter ono enictltet poction ‘helene Oe ln poi ema to soc (a Terao oe tush ‘Secdeanfepociet orbit aner heey ecient che onde tate” ‘Satan te! ben tbe tf tin tinder roc orn bee ‘Enna cer nn awe et at ‘yond Knit herp ten Wiehe nia een ptr oo ec ur et at athe ae ett ober dm rs ein on of pots neon nS SGN ge accep tem cde does aeShy tne pstmt nde uti ee that prostrate pope So hee Tedd dn en: en nee noob fp dedi Que Cer cing Hat iby Bing Ue Cog P99) Shcpnt ne e tii SD oe perce ssi dbp hat a cute cote le rw a nl ger ‘eee era eae ats Get ee ‘att iy ont Ds oglu pre a ata slo 23 es ey Gen eg ada ey nin Dron nd Phy ose he tayo hag Pen) ea nh pl Ske eon ae fear hon ber at ge’ ge ia eran sper ntnana cae Derr taut ee ek ch ge i sna fa ip ec ane Desde mesos owen own petal opts oc oe ‘wth ened pas ge dt Sissy ned dey eps ee sped eatin of tg eno Ca ee sn hi ona onto) Tet aa pms hore Sedona emimesyig ons utnc ue ac ‘stn bral gnc tether seth 2 On oe yt ope en leer xpi fags pent oo henna fe tho fs eaten eae ps ‘ic met Jt rf el ipl rs Foret iro igi ae soe ‘em dcr beeper dec ao a Seana phen gsi on hpi ee tbe pare ype al es encore ‘ot ein epee ob Inte Snag negates ton 59 thse mater fcure—s nity of cology bn. 21 ‘ero flaring aay eran re igo fone lton of winging heinoeing deci (Seordecof pec inc"oe pentericcly utara thee oes Dey ising We eC of he bein Who a fii sro Cnr et Cea 8 Ls Nace (Sorts oat, So For Den iiss” mae ey he ution fame theme of se ef he he the ‘stat oe ey et recan os be rael—atl petire ‘ht otc rote ch pa tai sk el? estan joven fa (ge moment ven cng 15s yep ofa el for eget ew Ye el ee oom yeaa) nan ee Tonge anh at Deri es ia oe eae ove Doser Ra eg a and ein poor aretha {Soren pdt ee ign ty ene bd ‘alll ep ny in ata tc eng aero hgh is oc expan: hal 9 ek ‘Seve led spony ta pete taba pe ‘omnis el Hageri wect efom fe —Wiee ‘pale ate sia hen (2) Dario ted watt {coven unc inutile ee) ‘ges tt our aie en tee ne raped ‘rot our orc ove psy en ou ee (heh ery bore ie ews "th hes of the oes (bald oft eset palit the ene he ‘Feestonan deen sfenn And tbex mone feist Shep oe tol crying open ome Lee a yr espa Ch ST hace Berth Dede ne alts Leadon: Res, yp bt ence en. Sr Sy ld Ones fr Ne nd Ye Pot Haman ree none Sige ear “ole ott hur Sapo phe pens be ott te When sed eet bow a dra of he aed wih esearch wo utr st of [Rne! Sel Sax" Ar ide Fete Saar” Chie5 coyote 4: Aad ce estou eb te eon afin ce “Theta ates 55 Sn ornpl "Chic "Gch Se Di, Oe log Dien ns. be eed Deri Rar Bre ‘Bind Peggy Fama ers Cb Uiety rap or Levis es Deri hermes eea eve, alg Levinas ah ano em “Chore ‘sme Cis Meanie shone 36 Qed nV Ky, lin Th Sof Capra (Ne {os oat 97). Subset een KAS bee ee 9.1.7. Of as ol Kale Refs Se of ‘ana (Sock Gens rele an got epson oni Rin yew ks Ppa gh em 3K Ba Kody Reon Ni Ltn, Sal is ran Jot ate wth Dt Roar Sf, Ca: Stns Urey ese, ve ‘Der hecanof angugin of th ian eps, ‘na fname nein ea teppei deo oo sg ‘etal eo! ngage ad wold coma hac ‘aon ona mannan casas ha ‘eHow onewnld rst wut toting teed wre ts her of test ound na lana c Huber Aan od cio Vr we fens no oso th bir pte pein tres" ed tig bot Iain "tow meat ed whee ey? —and etre th ich Daria wean Besar wuld ae le piace Resta ca ong coher Line ne ay ot wrt igo tpt ‘mom bse tard woul so preven es aig ‘conspafingsgnh decon presey beefupn aTe Premade Cut oft wins ad pec fy oye v7 dom feommpry deci oll emanation {nd mening vet ae of prersri he ben deepe t Frac Vy The Rant oe Coen yon Tomita Cara Sex inte ec Za ls 30 “Buf oe over a tial fr xe Te Gra pe Pj yay Bend Harn el Cari ed Pe Sage oe ‘ose Mrs rasan porphin iy E | Inte stecn cc eamcans on 8 snopes els 8. Thorn cn Le Mie (Ab Sate ray ofr ak m7 or rsd nc Vel Th of Eevee Te igi ooo ann nani yt Rokr ae TZ oy eS Pema ase eae ey been oii ot ini phon thence we iene hee ately iid Sieben oe pen wore pore omraonet ete ye hdres (ME 8) ene hy Titer ndden one omar i ie ocr ences nh nt vole! bb Stundomanting tii dy redo gsi aie cord ound ar cil geo ents grapes yd pen of merci ve ay YEEE eens tesa non ese ir ‘ncn notch eye eh) “cttw edt eo he cing ay wc. he serrata un pon ig he as "are tne se > ‘Stic ne acy gun icon orn ion prtrme a Fence ng epi ic ey te ht og wh ing pers en ep bt Beirpecepe ala dome oporisc tn por ‘Serco wi ot hogugibep (ty)Whn iy e eied ‘Siilinancrtenmes itm epportaes tr gusts opines 0 ear annem hire oan He Hee eca amcor Santen ae get "Sipe adie id ater ene omega etbet protean tonne peso of pro Seiten ura ven nant man te orion re pip set tin ari TEES teins Become or me! nde he ‘eae ey rs! sn ura Hon mip kot icant hey ita lo ies an Pg Ecc rewire la too Hinde pv wee ey uk ores wit ama aa “eet os ei it Porat et Tecedsoon evince cid a tbe tego Bs Tn of Mea i Sapo By6 canals fd hoe Ne Bt yr). Subgenre en a ‘Ths cig Baton eve may oath ont note nes bene oe chin abe at wo {99nd one igh ald bw fan xml rbre erin the tery eee of wie at ner ach ncn ad pl ‘ie frm emanate exchanger ie anping compare ‘eon edit meg ay scampryng anal ps ‘fore ated dtr wl ew eerinent ‘ee une shown hea in os en aed a {ope ere jean hen td aod nln ‘geet pute ene smn ot pe whi Sechin—oo ht ofthe mariage Ta epee eee ‘est ep cn enone scan ol th ans ow th hppened we dot te preset iodo wh cl. onsite dng the ean of are agus Sma Cesar "© Ring hi thot tl sng Mane sd el ede wing pete xiao rand bbe a ooh ol rp i 9) 3. Ds Demet. Gunes pal (So Lie ow), “ur Sis eee aren ine 51S Ni Creal Boer os ton ete oes sad 7 On Dente id Boys ceo Deas von Coane pid ha patna eb eae hemephennneopal te nthe yh owe pr ‘oreo of eet Aer pas aap Pcieneofhemaneic hear es ih Dra at 0 ‘nmendetal ged anh alu that ding oon uaa ea ang abot te ign Rh ay "Connon ease Sie te ‘Dati Sai, ren They adn Ne at ‘went snd Cnet Sa Cle Ces ring ws 6 Andes airvey day oom pe teeny Seren pal ert rp) a pheuenslagel deme Cain a Mean nd re fom doi ie pe of ei ‘SUiimbers Mwy nen Day Lil The Onley ie cto inn on Reh ok Pee Se Sage ‘bation 5 Sahota oe enn het | I | | ee Shoe otmgnstns ion 87 $4. Reinghe Gch enon of Dilfer: Os gus Dee (Case ‘eg Harel Caeser Se fa ona pts Bt ccs i ine ase ag ork empure cfoenc an sear een 48 nent (vont consis thle tn i tena pana hen acing Nears Stee edifice are ered exes ‘he doen ome mms abd os aa a at whee one {hres orehe uci are Sas ons Couputoe'o ene or Dara ven ee ees crs vcr scrote ore esha of Were ‘Gropp tnt rng ont dane attr of ei '@ {fenmaanay of etn te an ofp Ite of ste ten Selina cand npn of tigre ee of (hte a win the a teen win he we fe isle ies nth polon ward anders permanent ew nota comings hugh deron ad dapeion, hh = ‘om tape tary ppp. cig ass, mee prs off chara some Stn er (dod tpi come ened Te opposite Dei Te ‘Spt? yt form of darn cme it nite (rine dct (8 Cia hut aia Sony No oad 59S banana Desert ae Sean Ot No Bia te 2409997 aan, evn on Madey ens Win Wht (ster Caf Uy Pes 9p) se se mbar Marana odFac Vda, ep and Cp sie The et of he ving Dae Rl bing a9.