3 views

Uploaded by Nikki Marlo Cruz

are the

- qqq
- 06AppendixE F
- Shear in RC beam
- Goodno Mechanics of Materials Books
- Ahmed Abdel Fattah Mahmoud Ahmed._paper 12
- QLM of SOM
- Design of Pipe Racks
- Design of Beam Aci 11-01-05
- Static-38.pdf
- Diana Solid Model
- Wind Load on Etabs
- Shear Strength of Rc Deep Beam Panels – a Review
- AISC-ASD 89.pdf
- Corbel Design 1
- Masonry Chronicles Winter 2009 10
- art%3A10.1007%2Fs40069-016-0145-8
- IS800 2007 I-Section 1 Detailed Calculation
- sprcompin_01
- HKD_TYPE
- Safety Evaluation of Concrete Structures with Nonlinear Analysis

You are on page 1of 4

Custom Search

Concrete Pavement Membership Bookstore Events & Programs News & Views Contact Us

My Services

Construction Go To

Members: Sign In | Register

What are the strength tests that can be performed on concrete specimens, and how do they relate to

one another? My Locator (Organization, Product, Resource)

Flexural Tests | Compressive Tests | Splitting Tensile Tests | Correlation | Importance of Using Average

Strength | ACPA's Position on Strength

Flexural Tests

The concrete strength used in the design of concrete pavements is based on AASHTO Test Method T-97 or ASTM

C78, Flexural Strength of Concrete using a Simple Beam with Third-Point Loading (see Figure 1 below). These

flexural tests (also called Modulus of Rupture tests or Third-Point Loading tests) are performed using concrete

beams that have been cast and cured in the field, to mimic field conditions. For AASHTO thickness design, it is

important that the third point loading 28-day flexural strength be used use in the AASHTO equation. If the

strength values are measured using some other test method, it must be converted to the 28-day third-point

strength.

Some agencies use the center-point flexural strength test (AASHTO T-177 or ASTM C293) to determine their

concrete strength (see Figure 2). Center-point loading forces the beam to fail directly under the center of the

loading. This may or may not be the weakest point in the beam. In third point loading, the entire middle one-third

of the beam is stressed uniformly and thus the beam fails at its weakest point in the middle one-third of the beam.

By forcing the beam to fail at the center, the center-point flexural test results are somewhat higher than the third-

point test results. Typically, the center point results are about 15% greater. Though this relationship is not exact, it

does provide a reasonable estimate of the concrete's average strength.

Many agencies use compressive strength of concrete cylinders or cores (AASHTO T-22 or ASTM C39) as an

alternative to flexural strength testing (see Figure 3). Click here or alternatively, contact

Jon Smith

National Sales Manager

MULTIVIEW

Office: 972.402.7023 | Fax: 972-402-7035

Email: jsmith@multiview.com

http://1204075.sites.myregisteredsite.com/Concrete_Pavement/Technical/FATQ/Construction/Strength_Tests.asp 1/4

3/1/2018 What are the strength tests?

Splitting tensile tests involve compressing a cylinder or core on its side until a crack forms down the middle,

causing failure of the specimen.

Correlation

There are many papers, articles, and opinions on the correlation between the different strength test types, and

ACPA does not recommend any one test in particular. As for the correlation between the three test types, most of

the following equations can be used, noting that the variance in the coefficients and equations can be attributed to

regional, climatic, and material properties, among others.

Let:

Splitting Tensile Strength = Fst

Compressive Strength = Fc

Flexural Strength = MR (Modulus of Rupture), third-point loading (unless otherwise noted)

Center for Transportation Research / Carrasquillo, R. MR (3rd Point) = 0.86 x MR (Center Point)

MR = 1.296 Fst

MR = Fst + 150

http://1204075.sites.myregisteredsite.com/Concrete_Pavement/Technical/FATQ/Construction/Strength_Tests.asp 2/4

3/1/2018 What are the strength tests?

NOTE: When High-Performance Concrete is used, the above relationhips will not necessarily hold true. The HPC

mixes with very low w/c ratios tend to be more brittle and show different behaviors.

Additional Sources:

Raphael, J.M., "TENSILE STRENGTH OF CONCRETE," ACI Journal, Vol. 81, Number 2, Mar-Apr 1984 pp.

158-165

Popovics, S., "Strength and related properties of concrete: a quantitative approach", New York, 1998.

Grieb. W.E. and G. Werner, "Comparison of Splitting Tensile Strength of Concrete with Flexural and

Compressive Strength," American Society for Testing and Materials, Proceedings, Vol 62, pp 972-995, 1962.

Grieb, W.E., and Werner, G., “Comparison of the Splitting Tensile Strength of Concrete with Flexural and

Compressive Strengths”, Public Roads, V. 32, No. 5, Dec. 1962, pp. 97-106.

The expected actual average 28-day flexural strength (S'c) of the concrete should be used in thickness design

procedures. Using the specified minimum construction strength will cause the design to be too conservative.

Therefore, it is necessary to correct the specified minimum strength to the design strength using the following

equation:

S'c = Sc + z(s)

where:

Sc= Specified minimum flexural strength

s = Estimated standard deviation of the strength

z = Standard normal deviate corresponding to the percent of results which can be below the specified

strength.

To use this equation, the designer must know or have estimate values of:

2. The standard deviation of the strength tests.

The values for z are derived from basic statistics and are shown in the following table:

to the precent of tests below the specified strength (Sc)

z Percent of specimens below the specified value

.841 20

1.037 15

1.282 10

1.645 5

2.327 1

The standard deviation (s) of the strength test results depends upon the variability of the concrete and accuracy of

the testing. Contractors generally use either central-mix or ready-mix plants to produce concrete. These plants are

capable of providing very uniform concrete. Historically, the standard deviation (s) for ready-mix concrete is about

7 to 13 percent of the average strength. The standard deviation (s) for central-mix concrete is from 5 to 12 percent

of the average strength. Generally, records of the standard deviation from past plant operations are available. The

following example demonstrates the above procedure to account for the average, in-field 28-day flexural strength.

Example: Suppose that you want to design a small street project. You know that several local operators supply

most of the concrete in your area using ready-mix concrete. You also know that you will specify concrete with a

minimum 28-day flexural strength of 550 psi (3.79 MPa) and your specification will permit 10 percent of the tests

to fall below that level. What strength do you use in the AASHTO design equation?

Step 1: Estimate the "s" using s = 9 percent of the flexural strength; or, call several ready mix operators to

determine the value. Since you do not know the actual average strength, use the specified value for S'c (it will be

fairly close). The value for s then becomes:

s = 0.09 (550)

s = 49.5 psi

Step 2: Estimate the design strength to use in the equation. Apply the correction for a 10 percent failure rate

(z: = 1.282)

S'c = 550+ 1.282(49.5)

S'c = 614 psi (4.22 MPa)

Note: The same principle applies if compressive strengths are used. The corrected compressive strength would be

converted to third-point flexural strength using any one of the relationships previously shown. In the example, 614

psi (4.22 MPa) would be the value to use in the design equations. For comparison, the average 28-day flexural

strength at the AASHO road test was 690 psi (4.76 MPa) third-point loading.

In 1997, the members of the American Concrete Pavement Association gave their opinion on the preferred

methods of strength evaluation to use for acceptance of concrete pavement. To view this position paper, click here.

Fundamentals of Strength

FATQ - How do I obtain high-early strength concrete?

FATQ - What are the tests that can be performed on fresh concrete specimens?

http://1204075.sites.myregisteredsite.com/Concrete_Pavement/Technical/FATQ/Construction/Strength_Tests.asp 3/4

3/1/2018 What are the strength tests?

Copyright © ACPA, 2013

http://1204075.sites.myregisteredsite.com/Concrete_Pavement/Technical/FATQ/Construction/Strength_Tests.asp 4/4

- qqqUploaded byheherson juan
- 06AppendixE FUploaded byNidDou
- Shear in RC beamUploaded byNyu123456
- Goodno Mechanics of Materials BooksUploaded byMichael
- Ahmed Abdel Fattah Mahmoud Ahmed._paper 12Uploaded bypuppyarav2726
- QLM of SOMUploaded byatulkumargaur26
- Design of Pipe RacksUploaded byDushyant Varshney
- Design of Beam Aci 11-01-05Uploaded byMuhammadMuzammil
- Static-38.pdfUploaded byZuhal Zaeem
- Diana Solid ModelUploaded bypirazor
- Wind Load on EtabsUploaded byWaqar Ahmed
- Shear Strength of Rc Deep Beam Panels – a ReviewUploaded byInternational Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology
- AISC-ASD 89.pdfUploaded byKang Mas Wiralodra
- Corbel Design 1Uploaded bySamarakoon Banda
- Masonry Chronicles Winter 2009 10Uploaded byYoussef Andaloussi Slaoui
- art%3A10.1007%2Fs40069-016-0145-8Uploaded bycdestudos
- IS800 2007 I-Section 1 Detailed CalculationUploaded byJigar Piyush Shah
- sprcompin_01Uploaded bybshahidh
- HKD_TYPEUploaded bysorengbhanu
- Safety Evaluation of Concrete Structures with Nonlinear AnalysisUploaded byhillamng
- Rock MechanicsUploaded bySotiris Triantos
- Beam - Main Beam - Int. Long B-2, GM7Uploaded byFrederickV.Velasco
- PaperUploaded byGCVishnuKumar
- To Study the Behaviour of High Strength Concrete Beam Reinforced with Hybrid Fibre Subjected to Cyclic LoadingUploaded byInternational Journal for Scientific Research and Development - IJSRD
- D790 Flexural Properties of Unreinforced and Reinforced Plastics and Electrical Insulating MaterialsUploaded byHernan Gustavo Ruiz
- 161Uploaded byw1000000
- CBC_design Assisstant_ June 2019Uploaded byG. S. Yadav
- sifconUploaded bybrindaasokan
- A Comparison Study of Pressure Vessel Design Using Different Standards.pdfUploaded byJM
- me_seUploaded bygokul

- TempUploaded byNikki Marlo Cruz
- Ansys - Fluent 12 - Users GuideUploaded bycarlosmtf
- TempoUploaded byNikki Marlo Cruz
- yempdUploaded byNikki Marlo Cruz
- 4 Commentary on Standard Practice for Design and Conbstruction of Concrete Silos and Stacking Tubes for Storing Granular Materials ACI 313-97Uploaded byNikki Marlo Cruz
- Failure of spillwayUploaded byFlorentina Sudu
- MIT18_02SC_MNotes_v4.3Uploaded byNikki Marlo Cruz
- Component 5 Earthquake Risk Analysis Technical Report - Final Draft by GA and PHIVOLCSUploaded byNikki Marlo Cruz
- Topic 02 (VectorAnalysis)Uploaded byCao Xuan Canh

- Basavanna-ChinmaySurpur (1)Uploaded byMahesh
- DIALux Evo ManualUploaded byHerby Beiter Jiménez Peredo
- 02 Investigating Communication. Chapter 2.PDFUploaded bycommunismei
- Essentials of Food Sanitation 001Uploaded byMalleboina Pramod
- Medtronic Morgan Stanley Investor Meetings VFINALUploaded bymedtechy
- Why Christianity is FalseUploaded byIWantToBelieve8728
- Technical Recruiter or Staffing Specialist or Talent AcquisitionUploaded byapi-79081694
- The evolution of general ideasUploaded byombajra
- Chapter 10 SoSUploaded byAnonymous bsDMHEX
- 3054 MarineUploaded byNikole Cueva Cevallos
- TranscriptUploaded bymskhatri3
- virtual assignmentUploaded byapi-273589205
- AggregatesUploaded byzeeshan
- BTS3900 Site Maintenance Terminal User Guide-(V300R008_02)Uploaded byBinh
- sleep dreams spiritualUploaded bypinkdean4u
- Josef Albers Interview Fesci 1968Uploaded by(unknown)
- orpheus and eurydiceUploaded byapi-243077704
- C&IUploaded byRajeevAgrawal
- RootCauseAnalysis[1]Uploaded bySamehibrahem
- EAP_Controller_Software_V2_UG.pdfUploaded bywleung
- Pm lect 3Uploaded byNazish Hussain
- Cummins CELECT Electronic Injector PartsUploaded byRoussel Florez Zuloaga
- Isolation Platelet 1990.PDFUploaded byDavid Seavor
- GenEd ProfEd PracticalBasedFOSUploaded byMay-Ann S. Cahilig
- Decentralizing Education in Transition Societies - Case Studies From Central and Eastern EuropeUploaded byPencho Mihnev
- How to LearnUploaded byJoannaLin
- Teori penuaan 1Uploaded byeka edyawati
- QIP Sanctioned_list of Colleges_31!10!2017Uploaded byrubina.sk
- Media RelationUploaded byhariyu
- Metallic Coated Steel-1Uploaded byradule021