2/27/2018 Five Theories on the Origins of Language

Humanities › Languages

Where Does Language Come From?

Advertisement

Five Theories on the Origins of Language

SHARE FLIP EMAIL

Ariel Skelley/Getty Images

by Richard Nordquist
Updated April 09, 2017

What was the first language? How did language begin--and where and when?

Until recently, a sensible linguist would likely respond to such questions with a shrug and a
sigh. (Many still do.) As Bernard Campbell states flatly in Humankind Emerging (Allyn &
Bacon, 2005), "We simply do not know, and never will, how or when language began."
https://www.thoughtco.com/where-does-language-come-from-1691015 1/9
2/27/2018 Five Theories on the Origins of Language

It's hard to imagine a cultural phenomenon that's more important than the development of
language.

Advertisement

https://www.thoughtco.com/where-does-language-come-from-1691015 2/9
2/27/2018 Five Theories on the Origins of Language

Advertisement
And yet no human attribute offers less conclusive evidence regarding its origins. The mystery,
says Christine Kenneally in her book The First Word, lies in the nature of the spoken word:
"For all its power to wound and seduce, speech is our most ephemeral creation; it is little more
than air. It exits the body as a series of puffs and dissipates quickly into the atmosphere. . . . There
are no verbs preserved in amber, no ossified nouns, and no prehistorical shrieks forever spread-
eagled in the lava that took them by surprise."

The absence of such evidence certainly hasn't discouraged speculation about the origins of
language. Over the centuries, many theories have been put forward--and just about all of them
have been challenged, discounted, and often ridiculed. Each theory accounts for only a small
part of what we know about language.

Here, identified by their disparaging nicknames, are five of the oldest and most common
theories of how language began.

The Bow-Wow Theory

According to this theory, language began when our ancestors started imitating the natural
sounds around them. The first speech was onomatopoeic--marked by echoic words such as
moo, meow, splash, cuckoo, and bang.

What's wrong with this theory?

Relatively few words are onomatopoeic, and these words vary from one language to another.

https://www.thoughtco.com/where-does-language-come-from-1691015 3/9
2/27/2018 Five Theories on the Origins of Language

Advertisement

Advertisement

For instance, a dog's bark is heard as au au in Brazil, ham ham in Albania, and wang, wang in
China. In addition, many onomatopoeic words are of recent origin, and not all are derived from
natural sounds.

The Ding-Dong Theory

This theory, favored by Plato and Pythagoras, maintains that speech arose in response to the
essential qualities of objects in the environment. The original sounds people made were
supposedly in harmony with the world around them.

What's wrong with this theory?

Apart from some rare instances of sound symbolism, there's no persuasive evidence, in any
language, of an innate connection between sound and meaning.

The La-La Theory

https://www.thoughtco.com/where-does-language-come-from-1691015 4/9
2/27/2018 Five Theories on the Origins of Language

The Danish linguist Otto Jespersen suggested that language may have developed from sounds
associated with love, play, and (especially) song.

What's wrong with this theory?

As David Crystal notes in How Language Works (Penguin, 2005), this theory still fails to
account for "the gap between the emotional and the rational aspects of speech expression."
Advertisement

The Pooh-Pooh Theory

This theory holds that speech began with interjections--spontaneous cries of pain ("Ouch!"),
surprise ("Oh!"), and other emotions ("Yabba dabba do!").

What's wrong with this theory?

No language contains very many interjections, and, Crystal points out, "the clicks, intakes of
breath, and other noises which are used in this way bear little relationship to the vowels and
consonants found in phonology."

The Yo-He-Ho Theory

According to this theory, language evolved from the grunts, groans, and snorts evoked by heavy
physical labor.

What's wrong with this theory?

Though this notion may account for some of the rhythmic features of the language, it doesn't go
very far in explaining where words come from.

As Peter Farb says in Word Play: What Happens When People Talk (Vintage, 1993), "All these
speculations have serious flaws, and none can withstand the close scrutiny of present
knowledge about the structure of language and about the evolution of our species."

But does this mean that all questions about the origin of language are unanswerable?

Not necessarily. Over the past 20 years, scholars from such diverse fields as genetics,
anthropology, and cognitive science have been engaged, as Kenneally says, in "a cross-
discipline, multidimensional treasure hunt" to find out how language began. It is, she says, "the
hardest problem in science today."

In a future article, we'll consider more recent theories about the origins and development of
language--what William James called "the most imperfect and expensive means yet discovered
for communicating a thought."

https://www.thoughtco.com/where-does-language-come-from-1691015 5/9
2/27/2018 Five Theories on the Origins of Language

Source
The First Word: The Search for the Origins of Language. Viking, 2007

CITE

Advertisement

Theories on the Origin and Evolution What Does a Dog Say in Japanese?
of Language

Where Did the Goths Come From?

What Is a Holophrase in Language
Acquisition?

What Is the Oasis Theory?

https://www.thoughtco.com/where-does-language-come-from-1691015 6/9
2/27/2018 Five Theories on the Origins of Language

Advertisement

Grammatical Terms: Displacement

Observations on the Nature of
Language

How the Solar System Got Started

Did Mary Queen of Scots Invent the

Word 'Dormie' for Golfers?

This Book By Charles Darwin Changed

How We Think of Life

https://www.thoughtco.com/where-does-language-come-from-1691015 7/9
2/27/2018 Five Theories on the Origins of Language

Advertisement

What's the History of the Hebrew

Language?

Dark Legacy - the Origin of the What Is the Indo-European Family of

First Crusade Languages?

The Origin of Name Nunavut

Delving into the Origin of the Universe

In ation Theory: How the Universe

Expands

https://www.thoughtco.com/where-does-language-come-from-1691015 8/9
2/27/2018 Five Theories on the Origins of Language

Advertisement

Learn Something New Every Day

Enter Your Email SIGN UP

Follow Us

Science, Tech, Math Humanities

Arts, Music, Recreation Resources

About Us Advertise

Privacy Policy Careers

Contact Terms of Use

https://www.thoughtco.com/where-does-language-come-from-1691015 9/9