Professional Documents
Culture Documents
That both defendants were lying was obvious to everyone in the courtroom.
- "But this does not necessarily mean that both defendants were lying."
(Oskar Garstein, Rome and the Counter-Reformation in Scandinavia. E.J. Brill,
1992)
- Because some people looked like they were lying didn't necessarily mean they
were lying.
"He denied that we had come to the end of our conversation and the end of the
relationship."
(Maya Angelou, The Heart of a Woman. Random House, 1981)
"Anorexic individuals may deny that they are ill, deny that they are thin, deny that
they want to be thin, and deny that they are afraid of gaining weight."
(K. Bemis-Vitousek, "Developing Motivation for Change in Individuals With Eating
Disorders."Challenge the Body Culture Conference Proceedings. Queensland
University of Technology, 1997)
- "He tells me to sit down on the couch. Of course, at first I'm thinking I'm in trouble
as usual."
(Tim Tharp, Badd. Knopf, 2011)
"[S]ince the judge had made it clear that he didn't find any of the key witnesses
believable, there seemed to be little ground for appeal."
(Mary Lou Finlay, The As It Happens Files: Radio That May Contain Nuts. Alfred A.
Knopf, 2009)
- "He had made it clear he would like to be physically separated from the rest of the
firm."
(Barton Biggs, Hedgehogging. John Wiley & Sons, 2006)
"In general, you need to be sure that you understand the repercussions of renting
out your home."
(Danielle Babb, The Accidental Landlord. Alpha Books, 2008)
"We were so sure of the printer's capabilities that we voided the warranty on our
$126,000 Iris by hacksawing off the heads."
(Photography and the Art of Digital Printing. New Riders, 2007)
Francis, [1]the head jailer, [2]a fat Dravidian in a white drill suit and gold
spectacles, waved his black hand.
In each of Orwell's sentences, the appositive could be substituted for the noun it
renames (cells, Hindu, Francis).
Or it could be deleted without changing the basic meaning of the sentence. Set off
by commas, such appositives are said to be nonrestrictive.
In some cases, an appositive might be thought of as a simplified adjective
clause (a word group beginning with who or which). This next sentence, for
example, relies on an adjective clause to identify the subject, hangman:
The hangman, who was a gray-haired convict in the white uniform of the prison,
was waiting beside the machine.
Now look at George Orwell's original version of the sentence, with the adjective
clause reduced to a more concise appositive:
The hangman, a gray-haired convict in the white uniform of the prison, was waiting
beside the machine.
Viewed this way, appositives offer a way to cut the clutter in our writing. And that,
you'll have to admit, makes it a handy little device--a compact grammatical
structure.