Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Version 2.0
October 1, 2010
Jennifer L. Boggs
Associate GIS Analyst
The Wilderness Society
Jacob P. Mann
GIS Consultant
Contact information:
Jennifer L. Boggs
Center for Landscape Analysis
The Wilderness Society
655 Montgomery Street, Suite 1000
San Francisco, CA 94111
Suggested citation:
Reed, S.E., J.L. Boggs, and J.P. Mann. 2010. SPreAD-GIS: an ArcGIS toolbox for modeling the
propagation of engine noise in a wildland setting. Version 2.0. The Wilderness Society, San
Francisco, CA.
Version 2.0
October 1, 2010
Table of Contents
7. References ……………………………...…………………………………..18
Appendices
Model Structure
The System for the Prediction of Acoustic Detectability (SPreAD) was originally
developed as a system of worksheets and tables, where the user could enter information
about the sound source and environment and manually calculate noise propagation from
a single point source to a single point receiver (Harrison et al. 1980). Adpating the
SPreAD model to ArcGIS, we automated the hand calculation method to predict the
propagation of noise in all directions throughout the area of interest.
1
Version 2.0 of the model no longer calculates noise propagation for line and polygon sound sources because these
calculations caused too many errors in the terrain effects module. Instead, noise propagation around a linear (e.g., road)
or an area source (e.g., parking lot) can be simulated by modeling each engine noise source independently using Tool #3
(‘Calculate noise propagation for multiple points’). Tool #4 (‘Sum noise propagation from multiple sources’) can be used to
sum acoustic energy from multiple simultaneous sound sources (e.g., several vehicles traveling along a road).
2
The example shown here illustrates noise propagation at 400 Hz from a single motorcycle engine operating in a mid-
elevation mixed conifer and hardwood forest on a summer day with an easterly wind.
5) Terrain Effects
Determines the areas of the landscape that are
primarily influenced by ground effects, barrier
effects, or atmospheric effects, and the decline in
sound levels due to barrier effects from hills or
ridgelines.
Model Inputs
Before running SPreAD-GIS, you will need to collect and prepare several
datasets and parameters that are required inputs for the model. Make sure that all of the
GIS datasets are in the same projection.
3
SPreAD-GIS v. 2.0 was developed using Python 2.5.1.
4
When you run a new noise propagation model, all intermediate data from prior runs of SPreAD-GIS will be deleted and
results for the same frequency band will be overwritten.
Table 1. Background sound spectra. Use the sound levels (dB) in the table corresponding to
measured or estimated A-weighted sound levels (dBA); interpolate or extrapolate as
needed. Reproduced from Harrison et al. (1980).
Measured
Spectrum level (dB)
sound level
Land cover type (dBA) 400 Hz 500 Hz 630 Hz 800 Hz 1 kHz 1.25 kHz 1.6 kHz 2 kHz Comments
Coniferous forest 20 15 14 13 12 11 10 9 9 Trees and ground
snowcovered, no wind
30 16 16 16 14 14 14 12 12
40 34 32 30 28 26 24 22 21 5 to 15 mph wind
45 38 36 34 32 30 28 26 24
25 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2
30 20 18 16 14 12 10 8 6
35 24 22 20 18 16 14 12 10
40 28 26 24 22 20 18 16 15
55 50 47 45 42 40 37 35 32
60 57 55 51 48 45 42 39 36 Loud waterfall
3) Model Extent
The model extent is a dataset – usually, a polygon – that represents the desired
spatial extent for the noise propagation model analysis. The model extent can be
any size or shape, but remember that processing time will increase for larger
areas. Place the model extent file in the source_data folder.
5
Tool #5 (‘Calculate noise propagation for multiple frequencies’) can be used to automate model runs for multiple
frequency bands.
All-terrain vehicle 73 61 62 60 59 56 61 63 64
► 78 66 67 65 64 61 66 68 69
83 71 72 70 67 66 71 73 74
Chain saw 81 65 69 71 70 68 70 70 68
► 86 70 74 76 75 73 75 75 73
Snowmobile 70 50 59 55 51 53 60 60 60
► 75 55 64 60 56 58 65 65 65
78 60 71 63 59 61 70 70 70
83 68 75 68 64 66 77 77 77
Powered 2-stroke 80 70 75 74 70 64 66 66 65
generator, pump, etc.
85 75 80 79 75 69 71 71 70
► 90 80 85 84 80 74 76 76 75
95 85 90 89 85 79 81 81 80
100 90 95 94 90 84 86 86 85
Heavy equipment 76 65 72 66 62 62 64 64 64
(crawler, loader, diesel
81 70 77 67 67 67 69 69 69
generator, etc.)
► 86 75 82 76 72 72 74 74 74
91 80 87 81 77 77 77 79 79
96 85 85 86 84 84 84 84 84
101 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90
Pickup truck, 72 56 61 63 64 62 59 60 58
automobile
► 76 60 65 67 68 66 63 64 62
80 64 64 71 72 70 67 68 66
Helicopter 92 79 87 82 78 80 81 79 77
► 102 89 97 92 88 90 91 89 87
5) Elevation Dataset
You will need to prepare a digital elevation model (DEM) for your study area.
The extent of the elevation dataset must be the same or larger than the model
extent specified above. The elevation values in the ‘VALUE’ field should be
converted to feet, and the cell size of the DEM must be 100 ft (30.48 m). Place
this file in the source_data folder.
Shrubland SHB
Water WAT
The extent of the land cover dataset must be the same or larger than the model
extent specified above. Place the land cover dataset in the source_data folder.
7) Weather Conditions:
Collect representative weather conditions for the time of day and season for
which you will be running the model scenario(s), including: air temperature (°F),
relative humidity (%), prevailing wind direction (°), and wind speed (mph). You
could calculate median or average values for each parameter, or you could run
the model repeatedly for a reasonable range of values.
You will also be asked to provide a general description of the seasonal conditions
for which you will be running the model (e.g., clear, calm summer day); your
response determines the shape of the upwind and downwind areas around the
sound source.
As you begin to prepare data for your first model run, here are a few more things
to think about:
1) Start Small
The SPreAD-GIS model has many geoprocessing steps, and depending on the
size of your study area and your computer’s processing speed, calculating noise
3) Other Troubleshooting
The model, and ArcGIS in general, is sensitive to having input or output data files
open in either ArcMap or Windows. Before running the model, be sure to close
all open data files and windows, including Windows Explorer, and remove any
data layers used in the model from active ArcMap data frames.
When you encounter an error in a model calculation, first take a close look at
your software installation and input data. Are you running the correct versions of
ArcGIS and Python? Are all of your input datasets in the same projection and do
the raster datasets have the same cell size (100 ft)? Have you included all of the
required fields? For example, have you re-classified your land cover dataset to
include the ‘SPREADTYPE’ field? If you are running a model for multiple points,
did you include a unique point identifier field? Once you are confident that your
input data is correct, try re-opening ArcMap and running the model a second
time—sometimes minor errors in intermediate data calculations are overwritten
and the model will work fine.
Both results will appear in the C:\SPreAD-GIS\results folder. When running the
model for a single point source, the noise propagation patterns and excess noise levels
will be named according to the selected frequency band (e.g., pr400 and ex400). If you
run the SPreAD-GIS model multiple times to model propagation patterns for different
sound frequencies, the results will not be overwritten. When running the model for
multiple point sources (Tool #3), results for each point will be located in the results folder
and the filename will start with the point’s unique identifier (e.g., C:\SPreAD\results\
1_pr400). When running the model for multiple sound frequencies (Tool #5), results for
each frequency will be located in the results folder and named according to the
frequency modeled. All results will be in the format of a floating-point raster dataset, with
a cell size of 100 ft (30.48 m) and an extent equal to the model extent specified during
the first module.
Sample Exercise
7) Double-click to open the second tool: 2) Calculate noise propagation for one
point.
a. Fill in parameters as follows (Figure 2):
Sound source location: C:\SPreAD-GIS\source_data\one_point.shp
Model extent: C:\SPreAD-GIS\source_data\model_extent.shp
Frequency (Hz): 400
Sound level of source (dB): 70
Measurement distance (ft): 50
Elevation dataset: C:\SPreAD-GIS\source_data\dem
Land cover dataset: C:\SPreAD-GIS\source_data\nlcd
Air temperature (°F): 83
Relative humidity (%): 26
Prevailing wind direction (°): 285
Wind speed (mph): 8
Seasonal conditions: clear, windy summer day
Ambient conditions dataset: C:\SPreAD-GIS\source_data\ambient400
b. Press OK
Figure 3 Input data and parameters for Tool #3 (Calculate noise propagation for multiple
points)
Jacob P. Mann
GIS consultant
March 7, 2008
Eight sound modeling software packages were surveyed with the goal of developing a spatial
model of noise propagation from off-highway vehicle (OHV) activity in California National Forests.
Reviewed software included domestic and foreign as well as publicly- and privately-developed
packages. Results of the survey are arranged in a spreadsheet matrix for comparison.
Survey considerations included: the original intent or application of the software package; data
formats for model inputs and outputs; the capacity of the model to incorporate various factors
affecting sound propagation in a forest landscape, including topography, barriers, vegetation,
ground surface characteristics and weather effects; options for different types of vehicle noise
sources, including roads, traffic and aircraft; ease of use; compatibility with geographic
information system (GIS) software; cost; operating system; and date of most recent version or
update. Contact information for software distributors is included in the matrix.
SoundPLAN / SP Essential
Developed in Germany and sold by NAVCON engineering in southern California. It has full
functionality, although though compatibility for input and output of GIS data is unclear. Licenses
cost between $3,000 and $7,000, and a discount is possible.
LIMA
German-developed package for evaluating noise distribution for environmental planning, city
planning, preservation of silent areas, and noise reduction measures. LIMA appears to have full
functionality for modeling acoustic disturbances from OHV activity, including GIS compatibility
and direct integration with ArcGIS. We have not yet received a response from the U.S. sales
representative, but estimate the cost will be in the $6,000 to $10,000 range.
shapefiles, tabular and graphic export results in choice of ASCII grid noise maps, animated
Outputs not stated grid noise maps tabular GIS tabular data
results formats: DXF, shapefile, maps flyovers
Ground Effects implied not stated not stated yes yes yes yes yes
yes
yes
Roads / Traffic yes no yes yes yes yes (single point source,
(including user-defined vehicles)
including frequency spectrum)
yes
auto in/out available as a run-time (extension that embeds LIMA into no
GIS Compatibility not stated import/export of shapefiles possible, somewhat archaic unknown not stated
calculation program ArcGIS as an extension or (not spatially explicit)
geoprocessing tool)
Operating System Windows Windows Windows Windows Windows Windows Windows Linux
Last update 2008 2007 unsure early 2000s 2006 2004 2008 1998
yes
Demo Version no unknown free SP Essential unknown unknown free
(1 - 2 months)
http://www.faa.gov/about/office_o
http://www.wylelabs.com/products http://www.navcon.com/SoundPL http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/environm http://www.stapelfeldt.de/framesta http://www.fs.fed.us/eng/pubs/htm
Web Address http://www.acu-vib.com.au/cadna rg/headquarters_offices/aep/mod http://www.noisemap.com/
/acousticsoftwareproducts/nmsim AN ent/noise/tnm/index rte l/98231308/98231308
els/inm_model/
27