Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Religious Research Association, Inc. is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to
Review of Religious Research.
http://www.jstor.org
148
IDEOLOGYAND RECRUITMENT
IN RELIGIOUSGROUPS*
RELIGIOUSGROUPSSTUDIED
METHODS
For each of the three religious groups, the Christian Scientists, Catholic Charis-
matics, and Baha'is, samples of 50 active members were interviewed during 1978.
All resided in the Houston metropolitan area. Subjects from all three groups were
administered a common interview instrument, consisting of both closed and open-
ended questions, and lasting an average of two hours. Workingthrough the leader-
ship of each group, combined snowball-quota samples were selected. The total
number of individuals active in each group was examined in terms of selected
characteristics (income, education, occupation, age, sex, marital status and length
of time in group) and the final samples were chosen to reflect these distributions.
Core members of each group suggested members to interview whose characteris-
tics matched the quotas.
The study is unique in that we used the same interview instrument in all three
groups. Most comparative studies rely upon secondary analysis of responses to
questions which are not identical across groups (see Snow, Zurcher and Ekland-
Olson, 1980; also, Stark and Bainbridge, 1980). In addition to interview data on
members, we studied organizational aspects of each group by talking to leaders in
the group, studying official documents and, most importantly, doing participant
observation within each group.
Members in each group were asked how they first heard of the group, how many,
if any, of their best friends were members in the group, whether any family
members, spouse, or relatives belonged. These questions focused upon pre-existing
social networks that may have influenced their own conversion. We then asked a
series of questions about current networks in order to determine the potential of
such networks for the recruitment of new members to the group. These questions
focused upon number of best friends now in the group, whether spouse, family,
relatives belonged, and associational networks in non-religious activities.
While all 50 Catholic Charismatics were recruitedto the movement, that is, they
were not raised as Catholic Charismatics, 31 of the Christian Scientists were raised
in that religion and 9 of the Baha'is were raised by Baha'i parentsin the Baha'i faith.
As a result, the number of respondents for which recruitmentand conversion data
were appropriatevaried by group. The fact that only 19 Christian Scientists were
recruitedto Christian Science makes our statistical conclusions suggestive at best.
Because Gnostic sect types emphasize the spiritual importance of extending their
boundaries to permit social participationwith nongroup members, it is more likely
thatpre-existing friendship ties exist for one recruitedto thattype of movement. On
the other hand, the Conversionists stress the spiritual ties and brotherly love that
members are to have toward one another, and the group tends to be more socially
isolated. This allows less opportunity to engage in activities with nongroup mem-
bers. Thus, we predicted that Christian Scientists and Baha'is have more best
friends in the group prior to joining than Catholic Charismatics.
Examining Table 1 we find the above prediction to be true. Prior to joining the
group, a higher percentage of Catholic Charismatics (78 percent) responded that
152
Table 1
none of their three best friends were group members. For Baha'is, 58 percent of the
converts stated that none were members and 32 percent said that one friend was a
member. A similar pattern was found among Christian Scientists in which 53
percent responded "none" and 31 percent said one friend was a member.
One consequence of pre-existing friendship ties is that they can serve as a
recruitment mechanism. Friends, in particular, are the primary way most group
members hear about the group and are encouraged to become involved in group
activities (Lofland, 1965; Snow, et al., 1980). Given the fact thatcharismatics tend
to be more group-oriented, socially isolated, and have fewer best friends in the
group before joining, we predicted that fewer,members would have been recruited
by friends than is true for the Christian Scientists and Baha'is who indicated more
best friends in the group prior to their joining. Table 2 shows how members first
heard of the religious group.
Despite our prediction that Baha'is and ChristianScientists are recruited more by
friendship ties than Catholic Charismatics, our data do not bear this out. In fact,
almost twice as many Catholic Charismatics first heard of the group from friends
than is true for the other two groups.
What explains this finding? The Catholic Charismaticsare evangelistic in thatthe
group teaches that every member has a responsibility to teach the truth and try to
convert others to the "one true Faith." Evangelism, therefore, is a central tenet of
the faith. The fact that members take this mandate seriously is evident in the
language displayed by members not only in conversation with other members but
even when talking to mere acquaintances and strangers. "Praise God," "Glory to
God," "May God be Praised," "Thanks be to God," and "Praise the Lord" are
typical phrases used by Charismatics as greetings and exclamations during routine
conversations. Any social interaction, therefore, manifests one's identity as a
Catholic Charismaticand is a means of proselytizing. The fact that 78 percent of the
Catholic Charismatics indicated that none of the best friends were members of the
group before they joined indicates that it was not intensive, intimate friendship ties
153
Table 2
OF RECRUITMENT
MODE BY RELIGIOUS
GROUP
Religious Group
Mode of Catholic Christian
Recrui tment Charismatics Scientists* Bahai' s*
Recruitment
(N=50) (N=19) (N=41)
Recruited Through
Social Networks
* Only converts are included for Christian Scientists and Bahai's since
nonconverts were raised in the group.
**Numbersin parentheses indicate number of cases.
Table 3
BESTFRIENDSNOW AREGROUP
WHO MEMBERS
Religious Group
NumberWho Catholic Christian
Are Group Charismatics Scientists* Bahai's*
Members (N=50) (N=19) (N=41)
indicates that even before joining, Christian Scientists and Baha'is tended to have
best friends within the religious groups while very few Charismatics were best
friends with other Charismatics. Other interview data supports the finding that
Christian Scientists and Baha'is tend to continue their friendships both with mem-
bers and nonmembers after joining the group while the Charismatics tend to break
off friendships with non-group members and re-establish friendships with group
members. The implication for recruiting is that the former two groups use their
extra-group friendship ties for encouraging friends to join the group while Charis-
matics have closed off this option by becoming more socially insulated in terms of
close friendships.
In addition to questions regarding best friends, we asked respondents who they
tend to associate with in nonreligious activities, that is, day-to-day business and
social activities. We predicted that the more denomination-like the sect, the less
associational ties with members would be. Thus, in the case of nonreligious
activities, Christian Scientists and Baha'is are less likely to engage in nonreligious
activities with group members while Charismatics are more likely to associate with
sect members in such activities.
Upon examination of Table4, we find this prediction to hold for the three groups.
A higher percentage of Catholic Charismatics (48 percent) than either Baha'i
converts (17 percent) or Christian Scientist converts (10 percent) responded that
most of the people they associate with in nonreligious activities are members of the
group. Baha'is and Christian Scientists stated that most of the people they associate
with are not members of their group compared with only 32 percent of the Catholic
Charismatics. The former two groups, therefore, are in more frequent contact with
nongroup members than is true for Catholic Charismatics and, as a result, have
more opportunityto recruitfor the group. Given the data in Table2, however, which
shows that fewer Christian Scientists and Baha'is first heard of the group through
friends, we have evidence which suggests that opportunityfor social contacts does
not necessarily lead to recruitmentof new members.
155
Table 4
ASSOCIATIONAL
NETWORK
IN NONRELIGIOUS
ACTIVITIES
Religious Group
Extra-Cult Catholic Christian Bahai's*
Attachments Charismatics Scientists* (N=41)
(N=50) (N=19)
Snow and Phillips (1980) suggest that structural differences between groups,
such as degree of social isolation, may impact differentially upon the recruitment
process. They suggest that the more isolated the group the less likely that social ties
will operate as recruitmentdevices for the group. We have found, however, thatthis
is not necessarily the case. Rather, the more isolated of our three groups tended to
recruit through casual, acquaintance-like friendship ties while the two less isolated
groups drew members by means of more intimate, primary-type relationships. One
reason for the difference in the natureof friendship ties in recruitmentis the group's
ideological stance toward evangelism. While the Catholic Charismatics emphasize
active proselytizing, the Christian Scientists stress religious upbringing of children
and good example of daily living and the Baha'is emphasize a more general
"acceptance of social principles" ratherthan group membership itself. Therefore,
in the most casual of social contacts with a Catholic Charismatic, one is likely to
realize group identity while the same is not true for ChristianScientists and Baha'is.
Only in more intimate, personal contact with members in the latter two groups is
religious identity revealed. These findings suggest that the natureof friendship ties
as a recruitmentmechanism differs in various types of groups and are influenced by
religious beliefs, especially by a group's teachings regarding proselytization.
NOTES
REFERENCES
Stark,RodneyandWilliamSimsBainbridge
1980 "Networksof Faith:Interpersonal Bondsand Recruitmentof Cultsand Sects."
AmericanJournalof Sociology85:1376-1395.
Toch,Hans
1965 TheSocialPsychologyof SocialMovements.Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill.
Wallis,RoyandPeterMorley
1976 MarginalMedicine.New York:TheFreePress.
Wilson,BryanR.
1959 "AnAnalysisof SectDevelopment."AmericanSociologicalReview24:3-15.
1961 SectsandSociety.Berkeley:Universityof CaliforniaPress.