Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI 10.1007/s00216-004-3018-y
O R I GI N A L P A P E R
Received: 16 July 2004 / Revised: 9 December 2004 / Accepted: 9 December 2004 / Published online: 15 February 2005
Springer-Verlag 2005
Abstract Fourier transformed-Raman (FT-Raman) and sely-related herb oregano—called wild marjoram
attenuated total reflection-infrared (ATR-IR) spectra of (Origanum vulgare L.)—has similar uses, and is sold as
essential oils obtained from marjoram and oregano oregano spice, although other species of the same genus
plants by hydrodistillation are presented. It is shown may also be offered under the same name in the market.
that the main components of the essential oils can be Its flavour is similar to that of marjoram but slightly less
ascertained through both of these complementary tech- sweet. Both plants marjoram and oregano belong to the
niques, using spectral information from the pure terpe- family Labiatae and the genus Origanum. However,
noids. Spectroscopic analysis is based on the these names are frequently misread and as a conse-
characteristic key bands of the individual volatile sub- quence their generic names Majorana and Origanum are
stances and therefore, in principle, these techniques al- often interchanged [1].
low us to discriminate between different essential oil Both herbs contain essential oil, located in glandular
profiles from individual oil plants of the same species trichomes, which consists of various volatile terpenoids,
(chemotypes). The combination of vibrational spec- alcohols, esters and aromatic substances. The term
troscopy and hierarchical cluster analysis provides a ‘‘essential oil’’ relates to the method of preparation,
fast, easy and reliable method for chemotaxonomy namely the distillation of plant material at atmospheric
characterisation. The spectroscopic data presented here pressure. However, changes in the composition of the oil
correlate very well with those found by gas chromatog- may be observed during the distillation process as a re-
raphy (GC) analysis. sult of elevated temperature and the hydrolysis reaction
in the acidic solution [1–3]. It is well known that the
Keywords Essential oil Æ Marjoram Æ Oregano Æ NIR- main components of marjoram oil, cis-sabinene hydrate
FT-Raman Æ ATR-IR Æ Hierarchical cluster analysis acetate and cis-sabinene hydrate, which are responsible
for its sweet-fruity flavour [4], can partly rearrange to
form terpinen-4-ol as well as a-terpinene and c-terpinene
[1–3]. The flavour of oregano oil is generally strongly
Introduction phenolic due to the presence of thymol and carvacrol as
the main components in the essential oil [4]. However,
Sweet marjoram (Origanum majorana L., syn. Majorana there are different chemotypes among the same subspe-
hortensis Moench), is an Old World perennial aromatic cies, which differ in the chemical compositions of their
herb cultivated for use as flavouring in foods. The leaves essential oils, and this may cause additional problems
and stems yield an essential oil which, in the past, had when classifying the plants. Two chemotypes for mar-
several applications in folk medicine, but has been used joram essential oil—the cis-sabinene hydrate/terpinen-4-
more recently to perfume cosmetics products. The clo- ol type and the carvacrol/thymol type—have been
reported [5–8]. However, only the first type is derived
from the ‘‘sabinyl’’ biosynthetic pathway responsible for
M. Baranska Æ H. Schulz (&) Æ H. Krüger Æ R. Quilitzsch marjoram quality, while the latter is related to the ‘‘cy-
Federal Centre for Breeding Research on Cultivated Plants (BAZ),
Institute of Plant Analysis, Neuer Weg 22-23,
myl’’ pathway typical of oregano [9]. Likewise, various
06484 Quedlinburg, Germany chemotypes have been reported for oregano oil, such
E-mail: H.Schulz@bafz.de as thymol, caryophyllene, sabinene, c-terpinene and
M. Baranska b-cubebene [10] as well as carvacrol [2, 4, 11]. Although
Faculty of Chemistry, Jagiellonian University, many different chemotypes are reported in the literature
Ingardena 3, 30-060 Krakow, Poland for marjoram and oregano essential oils, there are still
1242
some discrepancies and some confusion between them lowing oven temperature programme was used: starting
[3–16], which also occurs with commercial names of the at 60 C and then rising at 4 C/min to 220 C. The
products. So, additional work is required to find a fast carrier gas was nitrogen, with a constant flow rate of
and reliable method for classifying these oils. 1 mL/min (split 1:40).
Determining individual components of an essential Identification of the compounds detected was based
oil is usually achieved by performing gas chromatogra- on their relative retention time in comparison to the pure
phy combined with flame ionization detection (GC-FID) standard substances. The percentage composition was
or mass spectroscopy (GC-MS). Alternatively, some computed from the GC peak areas according to the
spectroscopic methods (NIR, IR and Raman) have been 100% method without using any correction factors.
successfully applied to identify the main components of
the oil and to distinguish different species/chemotypes of
various spice plants [17]. Whereas NIRS data can only Measurement procedures
be interpreted through the application of statistical
methods, IR and Raman spectra (in most cases) present Near-infrared Fourier transformed-Raman
characteristic key bands of the individual volatile frac-
tion and therefore, in principle, allow us to discriminate The Raman spectra were recorded on a Bruker Spec-
between different essential oil profiles from individual oil trometer RFS 100 with a diode-pumped Nd:YAG laser,
plants of the same species (chemotypes) without needing emitting at 1064 nm, and a germanium detector cooled
to apply any chemometric algorithms [18, 19]. with liquid nitrogen. The instrument was equipped with
In the present work, near-infrared Fourier trans- an xy stage, a mirror objective and a prism slide for
formed-Raman (NIR-FT-Raman) and attenuated total redirection of the laser beam. Compared with the stan-
reflection-infrared (ATR-IR) spectroscopies are suc- dard vertical sampling arrangement, the samples were
cessfully applied to perform quality control of marjoram mounted horizontally; approx. 3–5 lL of the essential
and oregano essential oils. These techniques are used oil sample were placed in the middle of the metal ring.
with the aim to distinguish between the main oil com- The spectra were accumulated from 128 scans measured
ponents of different Majorana and Origanum chemo- with a resolution of 4 cm 1 in the range of 1000–
types. Additionally, hierarchical cluster analysis was 4000 cm 1 with a laser power of 100 mW supplied by a
applied to establish a model for fast identification of nonfocused laser beam.
different chemotypes.
Attenuated total reflection-infrared
reference GC-FID values (standard error of cross-vali- ters (see Fig. 1, clusters 1–3) are close together in the
dation (SECV). All data in the calibration set were spectra, and their main components (terpinene, terpinen-
preprocessed by multiplicative scatter correction (MSC) 4-ol and cis-sabinene hydrate) belong to the ‘‘sabinyl’’
and carefully checked to detect and eliminate outlier biosynthetic pathway, they can be classified as marjoram
samples. essential oil. On the other hand, phenolic monoterpene
isomers such as thymol and carvacrol, arising from the
‘‘cymyl’’ pathway, are typical of oregano (clusters 4 and
Results and discussion 6). Essential oil samples with high levels of 1,8-cineole
(cluster 5) can also be classified as oregano oil, despite
Hierarchical cluster analysis of essential the fact that these oils are commercially traded as
oil composition ‘‘marjoram oils’’.
Fig. 3 ATR-IR spectra of carvacrol (A), 1,8-cineole (B), thymol Fig. 4 NIR-FT-Raman spectra obtained from marjoram and
(C), c-terpinene (D), trans-sabinene hydrate (E), terpinen-4-ol (F) oregano essential oils of different chemotypes (A, carvacrol type;
and a-terpinene (G) standards B, 1,8-cineole type; C, thymol type; D, c-terpinene type; E, cis-
sabinene hydrate type; F, terpinen-4-ol type)
Table 2 Main components of marjoram and oregano essential oil chemotypes, as measured by GC
Chemotype numbers (according to the classification of clusters presented in Fig. 1) are given in parentheses
1246
References
21. Schulz H, Drews H-H, Krüger H (1999) J Essent Oil Res 24. Lösing G, Degener M, Matheis G (1998) Dragoco Rep 45:180–
11:185–190 187
22. Schulz H, Quilitzsch R, Drews H-H, Krüger H (2000) Int 25. Lin-Vien D, Colthup NB, Fateley WG, Grasselli JG (1991) The
Agrophys 14:249–253 handbook of infrared and Raman characteristic frequencies of
23. Steuer B, Schulz H, Läger E (2001) Food Chem 72:113–117 organic molecules. Academic, San Diego, CA