Shub-Niggurath and Her Thousand Young

Shub-Niggurath’s Dark Young by Michael Bukowski

Frequently, Shub-Niggurath is described as the Black Goat of the Woods with a Thousand
Young. This reference to her thousand young and her association with sexual reproduction
has historically made her somewhat easier to understand relative to some of the other
extra-dimensional Lovecraftian beings. Indeed her association with successful birth and
increased fecundity must make her an attractive entity or god to worship for humans and
other species within and even out of our space-time. Obviously, having healthy children and
no mortality of the mother during childbirth would be something that primitive humans
would pray for and desire.

In addition, increased fecundity associated with crops and livestock was also a desired
outcome and could mean the difference between life and death in both temperate (harsh
winters) and equatorial (dry seasons) regions of the planet. Indeed for primitive humans the
representation of the goat may not have any association with Satan or devils but more of a
symbol of the successful reproduction of both the community and their agricultural
resources.

Therefore, of all of the strange, extra-dimensional entities, the one that would be most
attractive, filtering into the minds of humanity and other species is Shub-Niggurath.
 Shub-Niggurath by Barguest

So what does Shub-Niggurath get out of being worshipped by these strange, fragile bags of
cells and tissues, confined to three spatial dimensions and one temporal dimension? I
hypothesize that the relationship between Shub-Niggurath and humanity, and possibly
other species, is a form of commensalism.

There are a variety of ecological relationships among organisms (e.g. predation,

competition) and commensalism is one where one organism benefits from the relationship
but the other receives no benefit but is not negatively impacted as in predation or
parasitism. One of the most commonly referenced examples of commensalism is between
clown fish and sea anemones. While the clown fish lives among the sea anemone’s tentacles
for refuge and protection against predators, the anemone itself does not appear to receive
any advantage or benefit with this relationship.

Another example of commensalism I am more familiar in my line of work is the case where
hair fungi (trichomycetes) grow attached to freshwater cladocerans such as Daphnia. The
fungi get a substrate to attach to and increased availability of nutrients / organic material as
the Daphnia feed on algal and bacterial cells (Symbiosis: An Introduction to Biological
Associations, 2nd edition by Surindar Paracer and Vernon Ahmadjian, 2000). In contrast, there
is not measured benefit or disadvantage with Daphnia being “infected” with the hair fungi. I
propose that a similar commensalism relationship exists between Shub-Niggurath and
humanity.
 Trichomycete (hair fungi)
attached to a freshwater cladoceran (Daphnia sp.) as a form of commensalism

The benefit to Shub-Niggurath from this relationship is to receive infusions of DNA or other
biological materials (e.g. proteins, cells, tissues) from the residents of our space-time.
Ancient cult sacrifices are frequently associated with worshipping Shub-Niggurath, which
involve blood sacrifices of animals and sometimes even humans. I hypothesize that such
sacrifices provide Shub-Niggurath with the biological material from our space-time to either
phase into our reality or, more than likely, produce progeny who can survive, thrive and
reproduce in our space-time. This I believe is the origin of her Thousand Young, also known
as the Dark Young.

As proposed above, the outcome of this “infusion” of biological material from our space-
time into Shub-Niggurath is the development of the Dark Young. It should be noted that
while HPL used the term “black goat of a thousand young,” he did not refer to them as Dark
Young.

Based on The Encyclopedia Cthulhiana, 2nd edition (Daniel Harms, 1998), Peterson and Willis
were the first to describe the Dark Young as the spawn of Shub-Niggurath (Call of Cthulhu
Rulebook, 5th edition, 1992), although these entities were also described by Robert Bloch in
the tale “Notebook Found in a Deserted House” (first published in Weird Tales in 1951). The
Dark Young are described as having large black bodies with a series of thick, ropey tentacles
coming off the top of their bodies with hoofed feet and large mouths filled with sharp teeth
in their mid-section (see below).
 Summoning Shub-Niggurath from S. Petersen’s
Field Guide to Cthulhu Monsters (illustration by Tom Sullivan)

More than likely the Dark Young are members of the Thousand Young but more than likely
they are not the only representation (or species?) of the thousand young. While they appear
to be true manifestations of matter, created within our space-time, they are clearly extra-
terrestrial and more than likely also extra-dimensional entities. Thus, in a sense, they may be
similar to the Whateley twins in The Dunwich Horror.” That is, they are extra-dimensional
hybrids. This is the benefit Shub-Niggurath receives by being worshiped by human cultists
(and possibly other species). The biological material is used to produce her Dark Young who
in turn are provided with the opportunity to manifest and successfully breed in our universe.
To date, the Dark Young have not been successfully established, at least in our corner of the
universe.
 Dark Young of Shub-Niggurath by Azriel Mordecai

To conclude, while Shub-Niggurath may be thought of as the “mother” of matter in our

universe, she is still trying to reproduce and seed our universe with her direct lineage.
However, as with Cthulhu and Yog-Sothoth, since she is from outside of our space-time she
has a difficult time manifesting herself in our universe in a stable form for extended periods
of time. Thus, while Cthulhu’s means of entering our universe is based on influencing the
dreams of lower entities to opening the way, Shub-Niggurath focuses more on seeding our
universe with her thousand young. To do this she needs to use our biological resources.
However, what do humans receive from Shub-Niggurath? I propose nothing. While she may
influence their dreams and stimulate their imagination to unconsciously persuade them to
worship her and thus provide sacrifices, there is no evidence to suggest that the cultists are
provided with provides any benefit (evolutionarily or otherwise). This is why I hypothesize
that this relationship is more a form of commensalism and less of a form of symbiosis. In
fact, her influence on entities in our space-time, to obtain the biological resources may be a
form of “extra-dimensional biological instinct” on her part. Thus, these actions may possibly
be part of a large, grand life cycle that may run over the course of billions of years.

Dark Young of Shub-Niggurath by Khannea Suntzu