Peer Review Checklist

Reviewer____________ Writer_________________

___1. Does the introduction have a thesis? Does it have a plan?

___2. Does each body paragraph start with an introduction? Does it end with
an explanation?

___3. List the main point of each paragraph (Should only be 1-2 words for
each.)

___4. What support do they have for each claim? Is it enough?

___5. What moves do they use to explain their evidence? Are the
appropriate? Do they work?

___6. Is the Works Cited page in MLA format?

___7. Read the paper aloud. Write “awk” wherever it doesn’t sound right.

___8. Fix any spelling mistakes.

___9. List 3 things that are good about the paper.

___10. List 3 things that need to improve.