Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Roy J. Shephard
Aging leads to a progressive deterioration of lung function, including a
decrease of vital capacity, an increase of residual volume, a tendency for
the airways to collapse during expiration, enlargement of all components of
the respiratory dead space, a poor mixing of inspired gas, poor matching of
ventilation with perfusion, a decrease of pulmonary diffusing capacity, and a
substantial increase in the work of breathing. Ventilatory demand is increased
during most physical tasks, but arterial blood homeostasis is surprisingly
well maintained when elderly persons undertake vigorous exercise because
peak cardiac output declines in parallel with the loss of ventilatory function.
However, dyspneaprogressively restricts peak effort as one ages. The exercise
specialist cannot restore aged or damaged pulmonary tissue but can attempt
to reduce the rate of future functional loss by encouraging smoking cessation,
avoiding air pollution, and controlling acute infections. Enhanced fitness,
stronger skeletal muscles, and better coordination can reduce ventilatory
demand. Resisted breathing exercises may also strengthen the chest muscles
and allow a mechanically more efficient pattern of breathing.
Key Words: arterial oxygen saturation, breathing exercises, dyspnea, lung
volumes, respiratory dead space
In the young adult, sustained physical activity is typically limited by the
cardiovascular component of the oxygen transport chain (Shephard, 1971, 1977;
Shephard & Wstrand, 1992). As one ages, a combination of increased ventilatory
demand, an increased oxygen cost of breathing, and weaker ventilatory muscles
may cause dyspnea to become the primary constraint (Killian, 1987; Shephard,
1987a), although in the absence of respiratory disease, arterial blood homeostasis
is surprisingly well maintained through 70 years of age or older (Johnson &
Dempsey, 1991). After considering some of the technical problems that hamper
an evaluation of the aging of respiratory function, this review will examine the
structural and physiological changes that occur during normal aging and will
attempt to assess whether any of the respiratory elements in the oxygen transport
chain become major determinants of aerobic performance in a healthy elderly
person. Finally, the review will consider how far the usually observed age related
deterioration of ventilatory function may be minimized by programs of general-
ized physical activity or localized training of the respiratory muscles.
Roy J. Shephard, School of Physical & Health Education, and Faculty of Medicine,
University of Toronto, 320 Huron St., Toronto, Ontario, Canada M5S 1Al.
60 Shephard
normal, resting ventilation have inevitably escaped the disuse atrophy that is a
common problem of aging in other parts of the musculoskeletal system.
Animal Experiments. Animal experiments allow random assignment to
exercise or control regimes, with the possibility of extensive biopsy or postmortem
study at the conclusion of the experiment. Nevertheless, it is difficult to extrapolate
such data to human aging. The experimental conditions of enforced exercise andl
or restrictive caging with a controlled laboratory diet are not typical of normal life,
and even if such technical problems could be overcome, interspecies differences of
lifespan make it very difficult to compare training durations or observed rates
of aging between animals and humans (Reiser, Hennessy, & Last, 1987).
Human Experiments. In human subjects, aging is confounded with the
responses to such variables as declining habitual physical activity, a decreased
motivation for maximal effort, chronic chest disease, cigarette smoking, and
exposure to urban and environmental air pollutants. Postmortem studies are
supposedly drawn from those free of respiratory disease, but the lungs are particu-
larly vulnerable to terminal pathological changes. Often the subjects who are
recruited to in vivo studies also are atypical of the general population; some have
been health-conscious volunteers or fit survivors, and the pulmonary function of
others has been subnormal because of admission to the hospital for conditions
that supposedly did not affect respiratory function.
There are substantial differences in the apparent rate of aging of lung
volumes between longitudinal and cross-sectional studies (Glindmeyer, Diem,
Jones, & Weill, 1982; Vollmer, Johnson, McCamant, & Buist, 1988). The longitu-
dinal studies cited were of relatively short duration; thus, the findings were
characteristic of the immediate rather than the long-term environment. In contrast,
the findings from cross-sectional studies are affected by secular trends in exposure
to cigarettes, air pollutants, and respiratory infections (Vollmer et al., 1988).
Sometimes (e.g., Johnson & Dempsey, 1991) the young and the elderly have
been matched in terms of maximal oxygen intake, but a preferable basis of
matching is to choose individuals at a similar percentage of age-specific fit-
ness norms.
Other possible factors include the recruitment of health-conscious individu-
als to a longitudinal survey, the progressive learning of respiratory function test
Aging and Respiratory Function 61
techniques by subjects (although Glindmeyer et al., 1982, found their data were
affected little by ignoring the first of five tests), and technical problems of
spirometry that may have yielded less accurate measurements of dynamic lung
volumes 30-40 years ago (Shephard, 1956a). The secular trend to an increase
of adult stature (about 0.1 cmtyear) could cause an apparent aging of absolute
lung volumes amounting to about 9 mlfyr, but unless there is an associated and
major change in the ratio of trunk to limb lengths, it is unlikely to have distorted
the aging coefficients in the usual multiple regression equations based on standing
height and age.
A number of technical problems, particularly the effects of air pollution
and smoking, are cumulative and thus become progressively more important in
older populations. For instance, Milne and Williamson (1972) made a potentially
valuable cross-sectional study of respiratory function in 487 subjects 62 to 90
years of age. However, it is difficult to view their findings as normative, since
92% of the men who were recruited were either smokers or ex-smokers and 33%
of their group had a chronic cough.
Downloaded by on 10/05/17, Volume 1, Article Number 1
The chest muscles, rib cage, lungs, and air passages are somewhat less accessible
to investigation than the muscles, cartilage, and bones of the limbs, and thus
inferences regarding age related alterations of cellular characteristics have often
been made by reference to the characteristics of aging as seen in other organs
and tissues (Shephard, 1987b).
Respiratory Muscles. The skeletal muscles in the body as a whole undergo
a progressive wasting as a person becomes older. The diminution of lean mass
begins at the age of 35 to 40 years. There is commonly a 20 to 25% decrease
of lean mass by the age of 65 years, with a tendency to an accelerating loss of
lean tissue with further aging (Forbes & Reina, 1970). Much of the loss of muscle
protein is due to a progressive decline in habitual physical activity, and it can
be restored by an appropriate training program (Fiatarone et al., 1990). It is
unclear how far the respiratory muscles share in the general wasting phenomenon.
A reasonable inference might be that there is a parallel loss of contractile protein
from the accessory muscles, but that because of constant recruitment, the muscles
involved in normal resting ventilation largely escape such changes.
In part because of mechanically imposed changes in the shape of the thorax,
the chest muscles become progressively shorter in an older individual. This
adversely affects both their lengthttension relationships and their ability to under-
take the mechanical work of breathing (Green, Mead, & Sears, 1978; Road,
Newman, Derenne, & Grassino, 1986; Zadai, 1985).
Biopsies of the limb muscles show a selective, age related decrease in the
average cross-sectional surface (but probably not in the total number) of fast-
twitch, Type I1 skeletal muscle fibers (Aniansson, Grimby, Hedberg, & Krotkiew-
ski, 1981; Aoyagi & Shephard, 1992; Larsson, 1978). Myosin ATPase levels are
reduced, the time to development of peak tension is prolonged, peak tension is
reduced, and the half-relaxation time is extended (Davies & White, 1983). A
deterioration of neural coordination, a change in the electrical properties of both
62 Shephard
fast- and slow-twitch motor units, and a degenerative denervation with subsequent
reinnervation of individual fibers may all contribute to the observed functional
changes (see Aoyagi & Shephard, 1992, for references).
The number of capillaries supplying a single muscle fiber tends to decrease
with aging, but because the average fiber cross-section also diminishes, the
mitochondria1 oxygen supply is not necessarily diminished (Aoyagi & Shephard,
1992; Celli, 1986). The diaphragm seems spared many of these changes, at least
in relatively old (24 month) experimental rats (Gosselin, Bohlmann, & Thomas,
1988). It would seem important to extend such observations to human subjects,
examining the structure and functional characteristics not only of the aging
diaphragm but also of the various accessory muscles of respiration. Particularly
in women, aging is usually associated with a loss of tone and a weakening of
muscles in the abdominal wall; this increases the descent of the diaphragm and
reduces its mechanical advantage.
Rib Cage. One dominant change in the musculoskeletal system is an alter-
Downloaded by on 10/05/17, Volume 1, Article Number 1
ation in the structure of collagen (Boucek, Noble, & Marcks, 1961; Eyre, Paz, &
Gallop, 1984; Hall, 1978; Prockop, Kivirikko, & Tuderman, 1979). Trifunctional
3-hydroxypridinium cross-linkages are formed between adjacent collagen fibrils,
and these bonds seem very resistant to any attempts at remodeling (Last et al.,
1989; Reiser et al., 1987). There is thus a progressive loss of resilience in bone
and cartilage. The major bones also undergo a progressive loss of both matrix
and calcium (Smith, Smith, & Gilligan, 1990). Structural and articular cartilage
show a decrease in the content and aggregation of proteins with chondroitin and
keratin-sulphate side-chains (Grahame, 1978; Hass, 1943a), probably related to
an activation of the enzymes that degrade collagen (cathepsin, hyaluronidase,
and collagenase). There is also a progressive loss of function in the chondrocytes
that would synthesize replacement collagen in a younger person.
The tendinous parts of joints are adversely affected by the aging of elastic
tissue. The synovial linings also deteriorate, with an increase in the number of
villi, a decrease in the vascularity of the joint capsule, and the appearance of
patches where cartilage formation is initiated (Chung, 1966).
The rib cage apparently does not escape these problems. The most striking
effects of aging are a loss of elasticity and an increase in density, these changes
ultimately progressing to complete calcification of the costal cartilages (Edge,
Millard, Reid, & Simon, 1964; Liebow, 1964; Mittman, Edelman, Norris, &
Shock, 1965; Stanescu, 1979). The costovertebral joints also become progres-
sively stiffer, and eventually they ankylose (Edge et al., 1964).
The spine is affected by the age related deterioration in the structure of bone
and cartilage. Osteoporotic collapse of the vertebrae and a flattening of intervertebral
discs that have become less resilient (Edge et al., 1964) lead to a progressive
kyphosis (Semine & Damon, 1975), sometimes characterized as the "dowager's
hump." The anterior-posterior diameter of the chest is increased. The tendency to
a mechanically inefficient barrel-shaped deformity of the thoracic cage (Edge et
al., 1964) is exacerbated by a decrease in the elasticity of the lungs; this in turn is
related to a decrease in the amount or an alteration in the mechanical properties of
alveolar elastic fibers (D'Errico et al., 1989; Pierce & Ebert, 1965).
Airways. Aging does not necessarily change the intrinsic dimensions of
the larger airways at any given alveolar volume. There may be some increase
in the number andlor size of mucous glands (Reid, 1967), although it is hard to
Aging and Respiratory Function 63
draw a clear line between the effects of aging and effects attributable to chronic
bronchitis. There is also a progressive decrease of ciliary function (Puchelle,
Zohm, & Bertrand, 1977),even in nonsmokers (Wanner, 1977), sometimes with a
deterioration of immune responses (Goodwin, Searles, & Tung, 1982; Roghmann,
1987) that leaves the elderly person more vulnerable to both bacterial and vi-
ral infections.
Postmortem specimens from cases of sudden death show a progressive
increase in the volume/weight ratio of the lungs at a standard inflation pressure
(Andreotti, Bussotti, Cammelli, Aiello, & Sarnpognaro, 1983). A progressive
loss of cartilaginous and fibrous support leaves the larger air passages more
vulnerable to collapse during a forceful expiration. However, this component of
the aging response is not clearly delineated from the impact of moderate emphy-
sema (Shephard, 1987b). Early gross analyses revealed little overall change in
the amount of collagen or fibrous protein in the lungs of older individuals
(Pierce & Ebert, 1965), but changes in the elasticity of the lungs suggest a
Downloaded by on 10/05/17, Volume 1, Article Number 1
is around 70 m2.With aging, the lung often shows some disintegrationof interalve-
olar septae (Pump, 1976) and a reduction in the total number of pulmonary
capillaries, both changes shading imperceptibly into the pathology of emphysema
(Shephard, 1976). Because of such changes, the functional area decreases by an
average of 0.27 m2 (4%) per year of adult life, to 50-60 m2 at 80 years of age
(Mauderly, 1978; Thurlbeck & Angus, 1975).
Pulmonary Vessels. Aging of the pulmonary arteries is marked by alter-
ations in the structure of the vessel walls, as in other parts of the circulation
(Hass, 1943b). There is a thickening of the media and increasing intimal fibrosis
(Wagenvoort & Wagenvoort, 1965), leading to a loss of vessel elasticity. The
smaller pulmonary vessels may also show collagen deposition and hyalinization
(Simons & Reid, 1969), although because pressures are low in the pulmonary
circuit of a young adult, age related increases of pulmonary arterial pressures
are less marked than in the systemic circulation (Masoro, 1981).
Downloaded by on 10/05/17, Volume 1, Article Number 1
We may infer from the structural changes described above that aging challenges
the bellows function of the chest through weakness of the accessory respiratory
muscles and alterations in the elasticity of the rib cage and lungs. The alterations
of pulmonary mechanics may also disturb the distribution of inspired gas within
the alveoli, and the matching of ventilation with perfusion in individual alveoli.
Finally, the decrease of gas-exchanging surface hampers the equilibration of
alveolar gas with pulmonary capillary blood. However, much of the available
information is qualitative rather than quantitative. Thus it remains difficult either
to estimate the likely physiological impact of the various changes or to determine
which, if any, threaten the process of oxygen transport.
PHYSIOLOGICAL CHANGES
muscle length and thus initial lung volumes (Otis, Fenn, & Rahn, 1949150; Road
et al., 1986). Furthermore, the observed values depend as much on the condition
of the accessory muscles of respiration as on the muscles used during relaxed
breathing. Early studies suggested a small decrease of peak expiratory pressures
in men and of inspiratory and expiratory pressures in women >55 years (Black &
Hyatt, 1969). A more recent study also found a trend to lower peak ventilatory
pressures in those >70 years, although because of interindividual variability and a
fairly small sample size, the overall effect of aging was not statistically significant
(McElvaney et al., 1989).
Respiratory muscle fatigue has been inferred in young adults from a decline
of maximal eucapnic hyperventilation with time (Freedman, 1970; Shephard,
1967), an increase of blood lactate with maximal voluntary hyperventilation
(Cobley, Cooke, Freedman, & Moxham, 1981), a decline in maximal voluntary
ventilation and peak pressures following a marathon race (Loke, Mahler, &
Virgulto, 1982; Maron, Hamilton, & Maksud, 1979), a decrease in the glycogen
Downloaded by on 10/05/17, Volume 1, Article Number 1
content of the rat diaphragm with prolonged exercise (Gorski, Namiot, & Giedrojc,
1978; Moore & Gollnick, 1982), and a decreased electromyographic response to
phrenic nerve stimulation after performing a maximal treadmill test against added
respiratory resistance (Levine & Henson, 1988).
One might anticipate that as subjects became older they would find it more
difficult to sustain a high level of ventilation during prolonged exercise. One
study of very fit 69-year-old subjects (a maximal oxygen intake averaging 204%
of age-predicted norms!) found no decrease of peak inspiratory pressures over
3 min of all-out exercise (Johnson, Reddan, Seow, & Dempsey, 1991a; Johnson,
Reddan, Pegelow, Seow, & Dempsey, 1991b). However, there is a need to repeat
these observations on more typical old people during longer periods of exercise.
Compliance and Static Pulmonary Gas Volumes. Static pulmonary gas vol-
umes are determined by the compliance of the respiratory system (the change
of volume per unit of applied pressure). The overall compliance of the respiratory
system C (and thus the functional residual capacity, FRC, observed when the
chest muscles are relaxed at the end of a normal expiration) is found by reciprocal
summation of respective compliance values for the rib cage (Cc) &d the-lungs
(C,):
The greater stiffness of the chest wall, discussed above, doubles its elastic resis-
tance to ventilation in those over the age of 60 years (Mittman et al., 1965).
Viscous resistance is also probably increased, although precise figures are needed.
These two factors together place an additionalmechanical load upon chest muscles
that may have already been weakened by aging (Rochester & Braun, 1976).
Rigidity of the rib cage encourages and eventually requires a much more complete
reliance upon use of the diaphragm during vigorous breathing, particularly at
lung volumes below the functional residual capacity. In the eighth decade, changes
of chest circumference account for only about a quarter of the resting tidal volume
(Rizzato & Marazzini, 1970).
The loss of elastic tissue from the aging lung leads to an increase of
pulmonary compliance in both men (Martin, Chihara, & Chang, 1977; Murray,
1981) and women (Gibson, Pride, O'Cain, & Quaglioto, 1976). However, the
66 Shephard
increase in stiffness of the rib cage tends to offset the increase of CL.Thus there
is only a small age related increase in total lung compliance.
The resulting pattern of age related changes in static lung volumes is well
accepted. There is an increase of residual gas volume (RV), whether expressed as
an absolute volume or as a fraction of total lung capacity, and a corresponding
decrease in the expiratory reserve volume (the difference between the FRC and
the RV), but little change of FRC (Cotes, 1979; Culver & Butler, 1985; Murray,
1981; Shephard, 1987b). A decrease of vital capacity roughly matches the increase
of RV, without much change of total lung capacity (TLC) (Burrows, Lebowitz,
Camilli, & Knudson, 1986; Morris et al., 1971), whether the TLC be measured in
vitro (Berend, Skoog, Waszkiewicz, & Thurlbeck, 1980) or in vivo (Cotes, 1979;
Jones, Overton, Hammerlindel, & Sproule, 1978; Niinimaa & Shephard, 1978a).
There remains some disagreement on the magnitude of aging effects in
healthy adults. Part of the difficulty lies in the definition of normality, since there
is a subtle shading from normality into emphysematous disease (Pump, 1976;
Downloaded by on 10/05/17, Volume 1, Article Number 1
Shephard, 1976). Other possible factors increasing the apparent rate of aging are
cigarette smoking (Wilson, Meador, Jay, & Higgins, 1960), previous respiratory
disease (Anderson,Brown, Hall, & Shephard, 1968), and exposure to air pollutants
(Rokaw et al., 1980, but not Buist et al., 1979). The cumulative loss of function
seems to be much smaller in healthy, physically active nonsmokers who have
held white collar jobs than in sedentary hourly workers who have been exposed
to pollutants through their occupation, their area of residence, and cigarette
smoking (Morris et al., 1971; Niinimaa & Shephard, 1978a). Changes are also
larger in cross-sectional than in longitudinal studies (above).
Residual Volume. The direct impact of the enlarged residual volume upon
the steady-state gas exchange of a "young-old" person (age range 65-75 years)
is quite small, even during vigorous exercise. To the extent that the expansion
occurs in the terminal alveolar ducts rather than in the alveoli proper, there is
an enlargement of series dead space and thus a slowing of diffusional gas mixing
between inspired air and alveolar gas (Shephard, 1956b).
One possible disadvantage of a larger resting alveolar volume is that its
gas composition responds more slowly to an increase of ventilation. Thus the
increase of alveolar oxygen pressure normally seen at the beginning of vigorous
exercise develops more slowly, with a potentially negative influence upon the
oxygen consumption on-transient. From the viewpoint of gas exchange, greater
importance attaches to the indirect effects of the enlarged residual volume (a
decrease in mechanical efficiency of the chest muscles, a restriction of vital
capacity, and a resulting tendency to dyspnea).
Vital Capacity. Many of the commonly used equations for the prediction
of lung volumes at various ages have assumed a linear loss of function over the
span of adult life, continuing steadily from 20 to 60,65, or even 70 years of age
(Cotes, 1979). But in practice, vital capacity and many related volumes continue
to increase until about the age of 24 years (Anderson et al., 1968). There is then
a relatively linear loss of function through middle age and an accelerating loss
of function in the final years of life (Schoenberg et al., 1978). The cross-sectional
survey by Morris and associates (1971) found that in successive decades from
25 to-75-years of age the vital capacity of nonsmoking men decreased by 19,
33, 17, 68, and 82 mllyr. Such data would not be well represented by assuming
a linear loss of 44 mllyr throughout the period of observation.
Aging and Respiratory Function 67
2.93 Llmin, or about 38 ml/(kg.min) in a man weighing 77 kg, a little above the
peak oxygen intake of 25 to 30 ml/(kg.min) usually observed at 65 years of age
(Shephard, 1978). A ventilatory equivalent larger than 30 L/L might be anticipated
in the frail elderly because of weakness of the skeletal muscles, an early accumula-
tion of hydrogen ions (Kay & Shephard, 1969), a poor distribution of inspired
gas, and an enlargement of physiological dead space. Let us assume that by the
age of 85 years the ventilatory equivalent becomes at least 35 L/L.
According to the cross-sectional data of Morris and associates (1971), the
loss of vital capacity from 65 to 85 years of age might average 70 mllyr; this
would reduce the vital capacity of a healthy 85-year-old to 3.0 liters. Even in
the unlikely circumstance that such a person could still utilize 50% of his or her
vital capacity, the peak respiratory minute volume would probably be no more
than 60 Llmin, and a sensation of dyspnea would restrict oxygen transport to a
peak of about 1.71 Llmin, or 22 ml(kg.min). At this stage of life dyspnea seems
very likely to become the primary factor limiting physical performance.
In practice, shortness of breath may limit function before a person reaches
the age of 85 years (Shephard, 1987b), particularly if the individual uses a large
fraction of his or her maximal inspiratory pressure (Johnson & Dempsey, 1991).
Factors that would be likely to increase the tendency to dyspnea at any given
oxygen intake include an increase of ventilatory equivalent, alterations in respira-
tory perceptions associated with a lack of recent experience of vigorous ventila-
tion, weakness of the thoracic muscles, a poor mechanical advantage associated
with the barrel-shaped chest, collapse of the airways during vigorous expiratory
efforts, and an alteration of sensory input or central neuronal processing linked
to stiffening of the rib cage and an overall increase in the impedance to breathing.
Pulmonary Dynamics. The thickening of the mucosal lining in the smaller
air passages and the decrease of thoracic compliance tend to narrow the small
air passages, increasing resistance to both inspiratory and expiratory airflow
(Johnson et al., 1991a) and augmenting the pressure gradient from the lungs to
the extra-thoracic portion of the airway for any given flow rate. Collapse of the
airway occurs if the alveolar/intrabronchial pressure gradient substantially ex-
ceeds the opposing force of elastic recoil (Davis, Campbell, Openshaw, Pride, &
Woodruff, 1980; Shephard, 1982). This situation does not arise in a young adult
Aging and Respiratory Function 69
at sea level, even with maximal exercise. However, it becomes a likely scenario
in the elderly patient, since an increased pressure gradient along the length of
the airway is coupled with the loss of elastic tissue and thus a reduction of the
recoil force that maintains patency in a younger individual (Davis et al., 1980;
Shephard, 1982).
Aging progressively increases the likelihood that an exerciser will reach
the effort-independentportion of the expiratory flow-volume curve, where more
forceful expiratory efforts merely increase collapse of the small airways without
augmenting airflow (Johnson & Dempsey, 1991). The end-expiratory lung volume
is increased in an attempt to minimize this effect, at the cost of a diminished
mechanical efficiency of the inspiratory muscles. Dynamic compliance also de-
creases, as the subject uses the unfavorable segment of the pressure volume
diagram (extreme inspiration).
Under resting conditions, narrowed airways and expiratory collapse of the
air passages lead to a progressive decrease in various indices of dynamic function
such as the maximal voluntary ventilation, the peak expiratory flow rate, and the
Downloaded by on 10/05/17, Volume 1, Article Number 1
1-sec forced expiratory volume (Moms et al., 1971; Shephard, 1987b). Data for
the forced 1-sec volume show a faster age related rate of deterioration than that
usually reported for vital capacity (Burr, Phillips, & Hurst, 1985; Coe, Watson,
Joyce, & Pride, 1989). Thus, cross-sectional surveys show that the proportion
of the vital capacity expired in 1 sec drops from about 82% to perhaps 75% in
65-year-old men, and from 86% to about 79% in women of the same age
(Anderson et al., 1968; Shephard, 1978).
As with forced vital capacity, the apparent rate of aging of the forced
expiratory volume depends on the extent of the cumulative insults the lungs have
received, but even in nonsmokers living in an area with little air pollution the
annual loss over the span of working life is about 32 ml in men and 25 ml in
women. Likewise, the decrease in peak expiratory flow rate amounts to about
25% over the span of working life, the annual rate being 4 Llmin in men and
2.5 L/min in women (Gregg & Nunn, 1989).
The magnitude of these changes is no greater than the age related decrease
in maximal oxygen intake. It is thus unlikely that bellows function is imposing
a major direct limitation upon oxygen transport in the healthy "young-old"
person. Nevertheless, Johnson and Dempsey (1991) noted that a limiting expir-
atory flow was reached over 40 to 90% of the tidal range in fit 70-year-olds,
and that many of these individuals were unable to increase their ventilation
further if carbon dioxide was inhaled during maximal exercise. Other negative
consequences are a heavy increase in the oxygen cost of breathing, dyspnea
associated with an overloading of the inspiratory muscles, and an increase in the
lung volume at which airway collapse becomes inevitable during expiration (the
"closing volume").
Gas Distribution. By the age of 65 years, at least the final quarter of the vital
capacity range is affected by airway closure (Anthonisen, Danson, Robertson, &
Ross, 1970; Frank, Mead, & Fenis, 1957; Gibson et al., 1976; LeBlanc, Ruff, &
Milic-Emili, 1970). For hydrostatic reasons, ventilation becomes restricted mainly
in the dependent parts of the lungs (Davis et al., 1980; Kronenberg, Drage, Ponto, &
Williams, 1973). Unfortunately, a large fraction of the pulmonary blood flow is
distributed to the lower third of the lungs; thus, airway collapse leads to a progressive
worsening in the matching of ventilation with perfusion.
70 Shephard
ducts and the alveoli, or from one alveolus to another (Shephard, 1956b); this
is particularly important in older adults, in which a loss of elastic tissue leads
to an expansion of the terminal alveolar ducts and an inhomogeneity of time
constants (Kitamura et al., 1972). Thus, whereas vigorous exercise usually de-
creases the vertical nonuniformity of ventilation (Gledhill, Forese, Buick, &
Bryan, 1978; West, 1962), it may increase nonuniformity in the horizontal axis
(Shephard, 1982; West, 1962).
Alveolar Ventilation. The dead space of the respiratory system comprises
an anatomical component corresponding to the volume of the conducting airways,
plus a physiological component due to diffusion across the alveolarlairway inter-
face (the series element) and a parallel element (due to a poor distribution of
gas and a poor matching of ventilation with perfusion).
There is inevitably some increase of the total respiratory dead space with
aging. The dimensions of the major airways vary in direct proportion to alveolar
volume (Shephard, 1982), so the average volume of the anatomical dead space
increases with the development of an expanded, barrel-shaped chest; Cotes (1979)
has estimated the change at 10 mlldecade. Nevertheless, the main cause of the
increase in dead space probably lies in the finer structures of the lung. The age
related expansion of the terminal alveolar ducts and alveoli leads to a less complete
diffusional mixing between inspired gas and alveolar gas, increasing the series
element of the physiological dead space (Shephard, 1956b).
Airway closure and any bronchial disease causes a selective impairment
of ventilation of alveoli at the base of the lungs, and unfortunately these alveoli
typically receive a large fraction of the total pulmonary blood flow (Davis et al.,
1980). The reduction of the pulmonary capillary bed also leaves a large number
of alveolar spaces that are ventilated but poorly perfused. A small increase of
pulmonary arterial pressure may facilitate perfusion of the upper parts of the
lungs, and thus improve ventilation/perfusion ratios (Holland et al., 1968). How-
ever, marked pulmonary hypertension has a negative effect on cardiorespiratory
function, restricting peak blood flow and eventually progressing to cardiac failure
(as in the emphysematous patients known as "blue-bloaters").
Some researchers have argued that aging should lead to a substantial wors-
ening of the matching of ventilation to perfusion (Davies, 1991; Wagner, Lara-
Aging and Respiratory Function 71
vuso, Uhl, & West, 1974), augmenting the so-called parallel component of the
physiological dead space. Nevertheless, experimental data in elderly, healthy
nonsmokers show surprisingly normal resting ventilation/perfusion ratios (Hol-
land et d., 1968; Kronenberg et al., 1973). To the extent that exercise leads to
a greater uniformity of both ventilation and perfusion of the lungs (Shephard,
1982), the problems of the elderly person are likely to be even less severe during
vigorous exercise than under resting conditions.
The overall impact of the various dead space elements can be assessed in
terms of the dead spaceltidal volume ratio. Johnson and Dempsey (1991) noted
that although the overall dead spaceltidal volume ratio was 15 to 20% larger in
elderly than in younger subjects, the importance of this handicap decreased
progressively during exercise.
Pulmonary Diffusion. The efficiency of gas exchange between the alveoli
and the pulmonary capillaries can be examined in terms of diffusing capacity or
alveolar-arterial pressure gradients. The diffusing capacity of the lungs (DL)is
usually measured in terms of carbon monoxide uptake and comprises iwo compo-
Downloaded by on 10/05/17, Volume 1, Article Number 1
nents: the diffusing capacity of the alveolar capillary membrane (Dm)and the
rate of reaction between carbon monoxide and pulmonary capillary blood (OV,):
Resting values for D, decrease in subjects older than 40 years, and there
also seems to be a decrease of pulmonary capillary blood volume, particularly
after the age of 60 years. Expressing diffusing capacity in the traditional units
of mllmin per mm Hg partial pressure gradient, the annual loss of resting function
has been estimated at about 0.15 ml/min/mmHg (Georges, Saumon, & Loiseau,
1978; Horvath & Borgia, 1984). As with many other body functions, there is
thus about a 25% loss of resting function over the span of normal working life,
corresponding roughly with changes in the functional area of the gas exchange
surface (Mauderly, 1978). Nevertheless, the score for the standard test of diffusing
capacity is based on an averaging of the driving pressure of CO across well and
poorly ventilated alveoli. The observed value is thus not a pure measure of
diffusional exchange, and much of the age related loss reflects a worsening of
gas distribution rather than a loss of actual diffusing surface.
Vigorous exercise increases the uniformity of gas distribution and also
increases the number of perfused alveoli. The effect of aging on diffusing capacity
thus tends to diminish during vigorous physical activity. Indeed, Niinimaa and
Shephard (1978a) found that healthy and relatively fit 65-year-old subjects had
almost as large a maximal diffusing capacity as young adults. More data are
needed on the maximal diffusing capacity of the elderly, but it seems unlikely
that pulmonary diffusion limits oxygen transport in healthy seniors.
Alveolar-Arterial Gas Pressure Gradients. The alveolar-arterial oxygen pres-
sure gradient reflects mainly the effects of incomplete equilibration of alveolar
gas with pulmonary capillary blood, poor matching of ventilation and perfusion,
and frank venous-arterial pulmonary shunts.
Young adults show almost no gradient of oxygen partial pressure between
alveolar gas and the blood leaving the lungs in the pulmonary veins. This suggests
that neither the pulmonary diffusing capacity nor its interactions with ventilation
and blood flow offers any appreciable barrier to oxygen transport (Shephard,
72 Shephard
1977, 1982). Endurance athletes are one exception to this generalization. When
such individuals engage in maximal exercise, a large cardiac output leads to a
very rapid passage of red cells through the pulmonary capillary bed, and the
transit time in some of the shorter pathways may be insufficient for a complete
equilibration of alveolar and blood gas pressures. Dempsey, Powers, and Gledhill
(1990) argued that an alveolar-arterial oxygen pressure gradient of 20-30 Torr
could develop, causing the oxygen saturation of pulmonary venous blood to drop
below 90%, although this interpretation has since been questioned (Warren,
Cureton, Middendorf, Ray, & Warren, 1991).
It might be anticipated that the age related decrease of the pulmonary
capillary bed would exacerbate any problems of transit time and thus equilibration
between alveolar gas and pulmonary capillary blood, particularly during vigorous
exercise. In practice, any effect from the decrease of pulmonary vascular bed
seems to be offset by a smaller peak cardiac output (Niinimaa & Shephard,
1978b; Shephard, 1987b), thus the time available for gas equilibration is no
shorter than in younger people.
Downloaded by on 10/05/17, Volume 1, Article Number 1
The classical view has been that even under resting conditions aging is
associated with a 6 to 25 Ton decrease in the partial pressure of oxygen in
arterial blood and a significant widening of the alveolar-arterial gradient (Kanber,
King, Eshcar, & Sharp, 1968; Kitamuraet al., 1972; Monis et al., 1971; Needham,
Hogan, & McDonald, 1954; Sorbini, Grassi, Solinas, & Muiesan, 1968; Ward,
Tolas, Benviste, Hansen, & Bonica, 1966). However, this is not invariably the
case; Johnson and Dempsey (1991) found that the alveolar-arterial gradient of
fit 70-year-old subjects was only 2 to 5 Torr greater than in young adults, and
this small gradient was thought due to poor matching of ventilation with perfusion
rather than to problems of gas transfer in ventilated alveoli. Even during maximal
exercise, alveolar-arterial gradients had a negligible impact on oxygen transport;
in only 4 of 19 subjects was the arterial oxygen pressure less than 75 Torr and
the arterial oxygen saturation less than 92%.
WORK OF BREATHING
the oxygen cost of all forms of effort. For instance, the net mechanical efficiency
of cycle ergometry drops from 23% in a young adult to about 21.5% in the
average 65-year-old person (Shephard, 1987b; Sidney & Shephard, 1977). There
is also an increased oxygen cost associated with an augmentation of respiratory
work, to be discussed below; and the age related rise of systemic blood pressure
and heart rate at any given intensity of exercise increase the oxygen consumption
of the heart.
The decrease in elastic recoil of the lungs, measured at a fixed 60% of
total lung capacity, averages about 0.25 mm H,O per year (Murray, 1981). One
might thus anticipate that an older person could sustain a given ventilation by
applying smaller forces to the thoracic cage, with a corresponding reduction in
the elastic work of breathing. However, this potential advantage is offset by an
increase in the rigidity of the chest wall. With the increased tidal volume of
exercise, a substantial amount of elastic energy is stored in the chest wall during
inspiration, and much of this energy can be recouped during expiration (Shephard,
1982). Thus, during vigorous exercise some of the theoretical disadvantage of
increased elastic work against the rib cage disappears.
Airway collapse and a stiffening of the rib cage both augment resistive
work, so that the total work of breathing is likely to be much greater in an old
person than in a younger person. Unfortunately, measurements of the oxygen
consumed by the chest muscles are extremely difficult to make during vigorous
exercise, since they are greatly overshadowed by the oxygen demands of the
skeletal muscles. A young adult may well divert as much as 5 to 10% of the
total maximal oxygen intake to the mechanics of ventilation (Shephard, 1966).
Johnson and Dempsey (1991) estimated that the respiratory cost increased from
an average of 6% in young adults to 13% in fit 70-year-old men.
Many elderly people have some emphysema, and Chemiack (1956) noted
that in this condition the respiratory muscles consume 10 to 20 times more
oxygen than in a healthy young adult. The magnitude of the respiratory oxygen
consumption is in no way revealed by the individual's maximal oxygen intake
score, since the observed total maximal oxygen intake includes not only the
oxygen that is available to the skeletal muscles but also the oxygen that is
consumed by the respiratory and cardiac muscles, together with the oxygen
74 Shephard
PREVENTIVE MEASURES
opening up collapsed areas of lung. However, in practice such effects seem slight
(Wolff, Dolovich, Obminsky, & Newhouse, 1977) or nonexistent (OlsCni &
Wollmer, 1990) in normal subjects, and equally controversial in patients with
bronchial hypersecretion (Oldenburg, Dolovich, Montgomery, & Newhouse,
1979; OlsCni, Midgren, & Wollmer, 1992). If indeed there is any benefit, the
increase of mucus clearance seems less than could have been achieved by encour-
aging bouts of deliberate coughing (Camner, Mossberg, & Philipson, 1973;
Oldenburg et al., 1979).
Cross-sectional studies have shown that very fit elderly (maximal oxygen intake
50 ml/[kg.min] at an age of 65 years) have vital capacity and dynamic lung
volumes up to 20% larger than their sedentary peers, with smaller advantages
of maximal pulmonary diffusing capacity and a comparable alveolar-arterial
Downloaded by on 10/05/17, Volume 1, Article Number 1
oxygen partial pressure gradient despite a much greater peak oxygen intake
(Hagberg, Yerg, & Seals, 1988; Johnson & Dempsey, 1991).
Aerobic conditioning may also yield small increases of dynamic lung
volumes in healthy elderly subjects; for example, Williams et al. (1984) noted
a 7% increase of 1-sec forced expiratory volume over a 12-week, thrice-weekly
program. However, once lung function has deteriorated, even rigorous general
conditioning can make only a marginal difference to either static or dynamic
lung volumes (Mertens, Kavanagh, & Shephard, 1978). The best method of
reducing disability at this stage is to decrease the overall oxygen cost of a given
activity and the ventilatory demand associated with this oxygen consumption.
A combination of specific exercises to strengthen the main skeletal muscles
(Lake, Henderson, Briffa, Openshaw, & Musk, 1990; Mertens et al., 1978; Schols,
Mostert, Soeters, & Wouters, 1991; Simpson, Killian, McCartney, Stubbing, &
Jones, 1992) and an improvement of general physical condition may improve
the patient's coordination, so that the energy cost of a given task is reduced
(Paez, Phillipson, Masangkay, & Sproule, 1967; Vyas, Banister, Morton, &
Grzybowski, 1971). As confidence improves, even a simple task such as treadmill
walking may be performed more efficiently (e.g., by increasing stride length).
Strengthening of the skeletal muscles may facilitate their perfusion during vigor-
ous exercise (Kay & Shephard, 1969) and increase local capillarity, mitochondria1
density, and the concentration of aerobic enzymes (Saltin & Gollnick, 1983),
thus reducing the accumulation of lactate and the resultant drive to the ventilatory
centers (Casaburi et al., 1991).
Some researchers have argued that breathing exercises can teach the patient
to adopt a more relaxed usti tin-& Ausubel, 1992) and/or a more efficient pattern
of breathing, although this hypothesis needs critical evaluation. For instance,
because of rigidity of the chest cage, maximal use of the diaphragm will probably
reduce the respiratory work rate. If premature airway collapse is occurring, the
adoption of a slower expiration or expiration against closed lips may reduce such
a tendency. This will not only be helpful in its own right but will also reduce
the work of breathing and thus ventilatory demand (Shephard, 1976).
Finally, it is important that the patient accept the sensations of vigorous
breathing. Much of the functional limitation observed in the young-old or middle-
old individual is related to anxiety and fear of dyspnea rather than to a true
76 Shephard
SPECmC TRAINING
an expiratory collapse of the airways, but it might allow the patient to take a
faster inspiration; this in turn would permit a slower expiration, reducing the
likelihood of airway collapse. However, there is a need to evaluate such a tactic
carefully, particularly with respect to any negative impact on gas distribution. If
the chest muscles were strengthened,they would also contract at a smaller fraction
of their maximal voluntary-force. This would reduce the perceived respiratory
effort (Redline, Gottfried, & Altose, 1991) and might also facilitate perfusion of
the chest muscles (Kay & Shephard, 1969; Royce, 1958), reducing the tendency
to local muscle fatigue. There have been suggestions that such fatigue can contrib-
ute to dyspnea (Killian & Jones, 1988), although there remains a need to evaluate
the adequacy of local perfusion and the tolerance of sustained effort by both the
diaphragm and the accessory muscles of breathing.
Conclusions
Aging is associated with a progressive loss of respiratory function. The bellows
function diminishes, the respiratory dead space is increased, and pulmonary
diffusing capacity is reduced, but arterial homeostasis is generally well maintained
even during vigorous exercise. The main limitation of performance, and thus of
peak oxygen transport, commonly arises in the link between ventilatory mechanics
and respiratory sensation. A substantial component of the observed oxygen trans-
port may be consumed by the muscles of respiration. An exercise training program
cannot reverse structural changes in the chest and lungs, but it can reduce the
oxygen cost of a given task and may also allow development of a larger peak
oxygen intake by desensitizing an old person to dyspnea.
References
Anderson, T.W., Brown, J.R., Hall, J.W., & Shephard, R.J. (1968). The limitations of
linear regressions for the prediction of vital capacity and forced expiratory volume.
Respiration, 25, 140-158.
Andreotti, L., Bussotti, A., Cammelli, D., Aiello, E., & Sampognaro, S. (1983). Connective
tissue in agi+> lung. Gerontology,29, 377-387.
Aging and Respiratory Function 77
Aniansson, A., Grimby, G., Hedberg, M., & Krotkiewski, M. (1981). Muscle morphology,
enzyme activity and muscle strength in elderly men and women. ClinicalPhysiology,
1, 73-86.
Anthonisen, N.R., Danson, J., Robertson, P.C., & Ross, W.R.D. (1970). Airway closure
as a function of age. Respiration Physiology, 8, 58-65.
Aoyagi, Y., Shephard, R.J. (in press). Aging and muscle function. Sports Medicine.
Austin, J.H.M., & Ausubel, P. (1992). Enhanced respiratory muscular function in normal
adults after lessons in proprioceptive musculoskeletal education without exercises.
Chest, 102, 486-490.
Belman, M.J., & Mittman, C. (1980). Ventilatory muscle training improves exercise
tolerance in chronic obstructivepulmonary disease.American Review of Respiratory
Disease, 121, 273-280.
Berend, N., Skoog, C., Waszkiewicz, L., Thurlbeck, W.M. (1980). Maximum volume in
excised human lungs: Effects of age, emphysema and formalin inflation. Thorax,
35, 859-864.
Downloaded by on 10/05/17, Volume 1, Article Number 1
Black, L.E., & Hyatt, R.E. (1969). Maximal respiratory pressures: Normal values and
relationship to age and sex. American Review of Respiratory Disease, 99,696-702.
BossB, R., & Rose, C.L. (1984). Smoking and aging. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
Boucek, R.J., Noble, N.L., & Marcks, A. (1961). Age and the fibrous proteins of the
lungs. Gerontologia, 5, 150-157.
Buist, A.S., Ghezzo, H., Anthonisen, N.R., Chemiack, R.M., Ducic, S., Macklem, P.T.,
Manfreda, J., Martin, R.R., McCarthy, D., & Ross, B.B. (1979). Relationship
between the single breath N, test and age, sex and smoking habit in three North
American cities. American Review of Respiratory Disease, 120, 305-318.
Burr, M.L., Phillips, K.M., & Hurst, D.N. (1985). Lung function in the elderly. Thorax,
40, 54-59.
Burrows, B., Lebowitz, M.D., Camilli, A.E., & Knudsod R.J. (1986). Longitudinalchanges
in forced expiratoryvolume in one second in adults. American Review ofRespiratory
Disease, 133, 974-980.
Camner, P., Mossberg, B., & Philipson, K. (1973). Tracheobronchial clearance and
chronic obstructive lung disease. Scandinavian Journal of Respiratory Disease,
54, 272-281.
Casaburi, R., Patessio, A., Ioli, F., Zanaboni, S., Donner, C.F., & Wasserman, K. (1991).
Reductions in exercise lactic acidosis and ventilation as a result of exercise training
in patients with obstructive lung disease. American Review of Respiratory Disease,
143, 9-18.
Celli, R. (1986). Respiratory muscle function. Clinics in Chest Medicine, 7 , 757-784.
Chemiack, R.M. (1956). Physical properties of lung in chronic obstructive lung disease.
Journal of Clinical Investigation, 35, 394-404.
Chung, E.B. (1966). Aging in human joints. E. Joint capsule. Journal of the National
Medical Association, 58, 254-260.
Cobley, A.J., Cooke, N.T., Freedman, S., & Moxharn, J. (1981). Increase in blood lactate
following maximal voluntary ventilation. Journal of Physiology, 315, 35P.
Coe, C.I., Watson, A., Joyce, H., & Pride, N.B. (1989). Effects of smoking on changes
in respiratory resistance with increasing age. Clinical Science, 76, 487-494.
Cohn, J.E., & Donoso, H.D. (1963). Mechanical properties of lung in normal men over
60 years old. Journal of Clinical Investigation, 42, 1406-1410.
Cotes, J.E. (1979). Lung function. Assessment and application in medicine. Oxford:
Blackwell Scientific.
78 Shephard
Culver, B.H., & Butler, J. (1985). Alterations in pulmonary function. In R. Andres, E.L.
Bierman, & W.R. Hazzard (Eds.), Principles of geriatric medicine (pp. 280-287).
New York: McGraw Hill.
Davies, B.H. (1991). The respiratory system. In M.S.J. Pathy (Ed.), Principles andpractice
of geriatric medicine (2nd ed.) (pp. 663-681). Chichester: John Wiley.
Davies, C.T.M., & White, M.J. (1983). Contractile properties of elderly triceps surae.
Gerontology, 29, 19-25.
Davis, C., Campbell, E.J.M., Openshaw, P., Pride, N.B., & Woodruff, G. (1980).
Importance of airway closure in limiting maximal expiration in normal man. Journal
of Applied Physiology, 48, 695-701.
Dempsey, J.A., Powers, S.K., & Gledhill, N. (1990). Discussion: Cardiovascular and
pulmonary adaptation to physical activity. In C. Bouchard, R.J. Shephard, T.
Stephens, J. Sutton, & B. McPherson (Eds.), Exercise,fitness and health (pp. 205-
216). Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
D'Errico, A., Scarani, P., Colosimo, E., Spina, M., Grigoni, W.F., & Mancini, A.M.
Downloaded by on 10/05/17, Volume 1, Article Number 1
(1989). Changes in the alveolar connective tissue of the ageing lung. Virchow's
Archiv. A. Pathological Anatomy and Histopathology, 415, 137-144.
Dill, D.B., Hillyard, S.D., & Miller, J. (1980). Vital capacity, exercise performance and
blood gases at altitude as related to age. Journal of Applied Physiology, 48, 6-9.
Edge, J.R., Millard, F.J.C., Reid, L., & Simon, G. (1964). The radiographic appearance
of the chest in persons of advanced age. British Journal of Radiology, 37,769-774.
Eyre, D.R., Paz, M.A., & Gallop, P.M. (1984). Cross-links in elastin and collagen. Annual
Review of Biochemistry, 53, 717-748.
Fiatarone, M.A., Marks, E.C., Ryan, N.D., Meredith, C.N., Lipsitz, L.A., & Evans, W.J.
(1990). High intensity strength training of nonagenarians. Journal of the American
Medical Association, 263, 3029-3034.
Folinsbee, L.J. (1990). Discussion: Exercise and the environment. In C. Bouchard, R.J.
Shephard, T. Stephens, J. Sutton, & B. McPherson (Eds.), Exercise, fitness and
health (pp. 179-184). Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
Forbes, G.B., & Reina, J.C. (1970). Adult lean body mass declines with age. Metabolism,
19, 653-663.
Frank, N.R., Mead, J., & Ferris, B.G. (1957). The mechanical behavior of the lungs in
healthy elderly persons. Journal of Clinical Investigation, 36, 1680-1687.
Freedman, S. (1970). Sustained maximum voluntary ventilation. Respiration Physiology,
8, 230-244.
Georges, R., Saumon, G., & Loiseau, A. (1978). The relationship of age to pulmonary
membrane conductanceand capillary blood volume. American Review of Respiratory
Disease, 117, 1069-1078.
Gibson, G.J., Pride, N.B., O'Cain, C., & Quagliato, R. (1976). Sex and age difference in
pulmonary mechanics in normal non-smoking subjects. Journal of Applied
Physiology, 41, 20-25.
Gilbert, R., & Auchincloss, J.H. (1969). Mechanics of breathing in normal subjects during
brief, severe exercise. Journal of Laboratory and Clinical Medicine, 73, 439-450.
Gledhill, N., Forese, A.B., Buick, F.J., & Bryan, A.C. (1978). Va:Qc inhomogeneity
and AaD02 in man during exercise: Effect of SF, breathing. Journal of Applied
Physiology, 45, 512-515.
Glindmeyer, H.W., Diem, J.E., Jones, R.N., & Weill, H. (1982). Noncomparability of
longitudinally and cross-sectionally determined annual change in spirometry.
American Review of Respiratory Disease, 125, 544-548.
Aging and Respiratory Function 79
Godlee, F. (1991). Air pollution 11. Road traffic and modem industry. British Medical
Journal, 303, 1539-1543.
Goodwin, J.S., Searles, R.P., & Tung, S.K. (1982). Immunological responses of a healthy
population. Clinical and Experimental Immunology, 48, 403-410.
Gorski, J., Namiot, Z., & Giedrojc, J. (1978). Effect of exercise on metabolism of glycogen
and triglycerides in the respiratory muscles. Pfliigers Archiv., 377, 251-254.
Gosselin, L.E., Bohlmann, T., & Thomas, D.P. (1988). Effects of age and endurance
training on capillary density and fiber type distribution in rat diaphragm muscle.
Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 20, S9.
Grahame, R. (1978). Diseases of the joints. In J.C. Brocklehurst (Ed.), Textbook of geriatric
medicine and gerontology (pp. 528-550). Edinburgh: Churchill-Livingstone.
Green, M., Mead, J., & Sears, T.A. (1978). Muscle activity during chest wall restriction
and positive pressure breathing in man. Respiration Physiology, 35, 283-300.
Gregg, I., & Nunn, A.J. (1989). Peak expiratory flow in symptomless elderly smokers
and ex-smokers. British Medical Journal, 298, 1071-1072.
Hagberg, J.M., Yerg, J.E., & Seals, D.R. (1988). Pulmonary function in younger and
Downloaded by on 10/05/17, Volume 1, Article Number 1
Killian, K.J. (1987). Limitation of exercise by dyspnea. Canadian Journal of Sport Science,
12 (Suppl. I), 53s-60s.
Killian, K.J., & Jones, N.L. (1988). Respiratory muscles and dyspnoea. Clinics in Chest
Medicine, 9, 237-248.
Kitamura, H., Sawa, T., & Ikezono, E. (1972). Postoperative hypoxemia: The contribution
of age to the maldistribution of ventilation. Anesthesiology, 36, 244-252.
Kronenberg, R.S., Drage, C.W., Ponto, R.A., & Williams, L.E. (1973). The effect of age
on the distribution of ventilation and perfusion in the lung. American Review of
Respiratory Disease, 108, 576-586.
Lake, F.R., Henderson, K., Briffa, T., Openshaw, J., & Musk, A.W. (1990). Upper-limb
and lower-limb exercise in patients with chronic airflow obstruction. Chest, 97,
1077-1082.
Larsson, L. (1978). Morphological and functional characteristicsof the aging skeletal muscle
in man. A cross-sectional study. Acta Physiologica Scandinavica, (Suppl.), 457, 1-36.
Last, J.A., Summers, P., & Reiser, K.M. (1989). Biosynthesis of collagen cross-links. 11.
In vivo labelling, stability and turnover of collagen in the developing rat lung.
Downloaded by on 10/05/17, Volume 1, Article Number 1
Rokaw, S.M., Detels, R., Coulson, A.H., Sayre, J.W., Tashkin, D.P., Allwright, S.S., &
Massey, F.J. (1980). The UCLA population studies of chronic obstmctive respiratory
disease. Chest, 78, 252-262.
Royce, J. (1958). Isometric fatigue curves in human muscle with normal and occluded
circulation. Research Quarterly, 29, 204-212.
Saltin, B., & Gollnick, P. (1983). Skeletal muscle adaptability; Significance for metabolism
and performance. In L.D. Peachey (Ed.), Handbook of physiology: Skeletal muscle
(pp. 555-631). Washington, DC: American Physiological Society.
Schoenberg, J.B., Beck, G.J., & Bouhuys, A. (1978). Growth and decay of pulmonary
function in healthy blacks and whites. Respiration Physiology, 33, 367-393.
Schofield,J.D. (1979). Connective tissue aging: Differences between mouse tissues in age-
related changes in collagen extractability. Experimental Gerontology, 15, 113-119.
Schols, A.M.W.J., Mostert, R., Soeters, P.B., & Wouters, E.F.M. (1991). Body composition
and exercise performance in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.
Thorax, 46,695-699.
Semine, A.A., & Damon, A. (1975). Costochondral ossification and ageing in five
Downloaded by on 10/05/17, Volume 1, Article Number 1
Vyas, M.N., Banister, E.W., Morton, J.W., & Grzybowski, S. (1971). Response to exercise
in patients with chronic airway obstruction. Effects of exercise training. American
Review of Respiratory Disease, 112, 219-249.
Wagenvoort, C.A., & Wagenvoort,N. (1965).Age changes in muscular pulmonary arteries.
Archives of Pathology, 79, 524-528.
Wagner, P., Laravuso, R., Uhl, R., & West, J.B. (1974). Continuous contributions of
ventilation-perfusion ratios in normal subjects breathing air at 100% 0,. Journal
of Clinical Investigation, 54, 54-68.
Wanner, A. (1977). Clinical aspects of muco-ciliary transport. American Review of
Respiratory Disease, 116, 73-125.
Ward, R.J., Tolas, A.G., Benviste, R.J., Hansen, J.M., & Bonica, J.J. (1966). Effect of
posture on normal arterial blood gas tensions in the aged. Geriatrics, 21, 139-143.
Warren, G.L., Cureton, K.J., Middendorf, W.F., Ray, C.A., & Warren, J.A. (1991). Red
blood cell pulmonary capillary transit time during exercise in athletes. Medicine
and Science in Sports and Exercise, 23, 1353-1361.
Weibel, E.R. (1964). Morphometrics of the lung. In W.O. Fenn & H. Rahn (Eds.),
Handbook of physiology: Respiration (pp. 238-306). Washington, DC: American
Physiological Society.
West, J.B. (1962). Regional differences in gas exchange in the lung of erect man. Journal
of Applied Physiology, 17, 893-898.
Williams, M.A., Maresh, C.M., Aronow, W.S., Esterbrooks, D.J., Mohiuddin, S.M., &
Sketch, M.H. (1984). The value of early out-patient cardiac exercise programmes
for elderly on comparison with other selected age groups. European Heart Journal,
5 (Suppl. E), 113-115.
Wilson, RH., Meador, R.S., Jay, BE., & H i m , E. (1960). The pulmonary parhologicphysiology
of p o n s who smoke cigznettes. New England Journal of Medicine, 262,956-961.
Wolff, R.K., Dolovich, M.B., Obminsky, G., & Newhouse, M.T. (1977). Effects of exercise
and eucapnic hyperventilation on bronchial clearance in man. Journal of Applied
Physiology, 43, 46-50.
Yasuoka, S., Manabe, H., Oaki, T., & Tsubura, E. (1977). Effect of age on the saturated
lecithin contents of human and rat lung tissue. Journal of Gerontology, 32,387-391.
Zadai, C.C. (1985). Pulmonary physiology of aging: The role of rehabilitation. Topics in
Geriatric Rehabilitation, 1, 49-57.