You are on page 1of 7

Physiotherapy in Patients With Facial Nerve

Paresis: Description of Outcomes

Carien H.G. Beurskens, PT, PhD,* and Peter G. Heymans, PhD

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to describe changes and stabilities of long-term
sequelae of facial paresis in outpatients receiving Mime therapy, a form of physiother-
apy.
Material and Methods: Archived data of 155 patients with peripheral facial nerve paresis
were analyzed. Main outcome measures were (1) impairments: facial symmetry in rest and
during movements and synkineses; (2) disabilities: eating, drinking, and speaking; and (3)
quality of life.
Results: Symmetry at rest improved significantly; the average severity of the asymmetry in
all movements decreased. The number of synkineses increased for 3 out of 8 movements;
however, the group average severities decreased for 6 movements; substantially fewer
patients reported disabilities in eating, drinking, and speaking; and quality of life improved
significantly.
Conclusion: During a period of approximately 3 months, significant changes in many
aspects of facial functioning were observed, the relative position of patients remaining stable
over time. Observed changes occurred while the patients participated in a program for facial
rehabilitation (Mime therapy), replicating the randomized controlled trialproven benefits of
Mime therapy in a more varied sample of outpatients.
(Am J Otolaryngol 2004;25:394-400. 2004 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.)

This report describes the results of the clin- therapy, and treatment session frequencies
ical application of a modality of physiother- were more varied. Stabilities, changes, and
apy, Mime therapy, in patients with periph- their eventual predictors will be reported con-
eral facial nerve paresis. Pre- and posttherapy cerning sequelae of facial nerve paralysis in-
data from these patients, collected over a de- cluding impairments, disabilities, and quality
cade, were systematically explored for signals of life.
that Mime therapy was followed by an im-
provement in sequelae. Such signals are de-
BACKGROUND
scribed later; they have shaped a randomized
controlled trial (RCT), in which Mime therapy
A peripheral facial nerve paralysis is a
was shown to be an effective tool for facial
paralysis of the muscles innervated by the
rehabilitation.1 The present study, although
seventh cranial nerve caused by a lesion
completed 1 year before the RCT started, is of
located in the peripheral part of the nerve.
interest to clinicians because it replicates the
The cause of the paralysis is in approxi-
Mime therapyinduced changes found in the
mately 50% of cases a Bells palsy. Other
RCT in the setting of an outpatient clinic. A
etiologies of facial paralysis can be herpes
larger group of patients was followed; indica-
zoster, traumatic injury, operative trauma,
tions, previous treatments, commencement of
otitis media, and so on. The incidence of
Bells palsy in the Netherlands, as described
From the *Department of Physiotherapy, University by Devriese et al2 in 1990, is estimated at
Medical Centre, Nijmegen, The Netherlands; and De- approximately 20:100,000 per year. In ap-
partment of Developmental Psychology, Utrecht Uni- proximately 70% of the patients with a
versity, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Address correspondence to Carien H.G. Beurskens, Bells palsy, the voluntary motor function
PT, PhD, PO Box 9101, 6500 HB Nijmegen, The Neth- spontaneously normalizes,3,4 mostly within
erlands. E-mail: c.beurskens@fysioth.umcn.nl 3 months. The other 30% of patients remain
2004 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
0196-0709/$ - see front matter with a paresis with sequelae varying from
doi:10.1016/j.amjoto.2004.04.010 very mild to very severe.

394 American Journal of Otolaryngology, Vol 25, No 6 (November-December), 2004: pp 394-400


FACIAL NERVE PARESIS 395

PHYSIOTHERAPY IN PATIENTS WITH end of the treatment, and the physiotherapist re-
FACIAL NERVE PARESIS: STATE OF THE corded observations and tests at beginning and end
of the treatment. Incomplete files were excluded, as
ART well as files from patients with recent onset of
paresis (3 months) and from patients receiving
Although there have been several reports concurrent treatments.
indicating the success of physiotherapy in pa-
tients with facial nerve paresis, few scientific Mime Therapy
evidence is available. In a review5 covering
1958 to 1991 concerning the effects of phys- Patients were treated with Mime therapy, which
iotherapy in patients with peripheral facial consists of information concerning treatment and
prognosis, automassage of face and neck (a combi-
nerve paresis, only 1 RCT was found among
nation of effleurages, kneading, and muscle
70 articles.6 This RCT showed no significant stretching); and breathing and relaxation exercises.
effect of electrotherapy. The non-RCT studies Relaxing the face requires relaxation of the whole
indicated benefits from exercise therapy, body, and expiration exercises are used to create
biofeedback, low-frequency electrotherapy, relaxation. Specific exercises are taught to co-ordi-
nate both halves of the face and to decrease syn-
and massage. A literature search in Medline
kineses. These consist of controlled executions of
and Cinahl covering the period 1991 to 2001, slow and small movements of the various parts of
revealed 2 RCTs performed by Ross et al7 and the face, exercises for eye and lip closure, letter and
Segal et al8 claiming significant improve- word exercises, and emotional expression exer-
ments using biofeedback and exercise ther- cises.
A mirror is used as a feedback device. The num-
apy.
ber of treatment sessions is on average 10, each
Since 1980, patients with peripheral facial session lasting approximately 45 minutes; the pa-
nerve paresis have been treated at the Physio- tient attends once weekly or less. Follow-up treat-
therapy Department, University Medical Cen- ment is usually planned after 3 or 6 months. Pa-
tre Nijmegen with Mime therapy aimed at the tients have to execute homework on a daily basis,
assisted by a homework book.12
rehabilitation of facial expression.9,10 This re-
port is based on archived data covering a
decade (1987-1997) and consists of pre- and Methods and Analyses
posttreatment analyses of 175 patients treated
Participants and Handling of Archival Data. The
with Mime therapy. hospital archives contained the files of 203 patients
Mime therapy was developed approxi- treated by Mime therapy in the decade 1987 to
mately 25 years ago in Amsterdam by the late 1997. Previous files were not available because
Jan Bronk, mime actor, and Pieter Devriese, they had been destroyed as part of the hospital
otolaryngologist. Mime therapy is a combina- privacy policy. As many patients as possible were
required to have maximal variance in our data set.
tion of stimulation of facial expression, func- However, for only 175 patients was their file com-
tional movements, and relaxation techniques plete; 20 of these patients had a paresis with a
including breathing control.11 The aim of the duration of less than 4 months. Each complete file
treatment is to promote symmetry of the face contained information collected at the first and last
at rest and during movement, the patient be- treatment session concerning 3 groups of variables:
demographic variables (age and sex); medical
ing taught to simultaneously control synkine- variables (diagnosis, affected side and previous
ses or mass movements. therapies); and variables reflecting impairments,
disabilities, and quality of life. For this last group
MATERIALS AND METHODS of variables, information was extracted from a
standardized form in the file containing items
with verbally graded categories scored at patient
Patients Files encounter. At the end of 1997, all graded infor-
mation was translated into numerical codes by a
Physiotherapy files from patients with peripheral physiotherapist (first author) for analysis by
facial nerve paresis, treated with Mime therapy at the SPSS-package (Statistical Package for the So-
the outpatient clinic of the Physiotherapy Depart- cial Sciences, SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL); the second
ment of the University Medical Center Nijmegen author checked a sample of patient codes.
between 1987 and 1998, served as database for this
study. These files contained a letter from the gen- Instruments. The House-Brackmann Facial Grad-
eral practitioner or referring specialist, anamnesis ing System (HB-FGS)13 has been used as an overall
and patient well-being reported at beginning and measure of facial impairment. The HB-FGS classi-
396 BEURSKENS AND HEYMANS

fies facial functioning in 6 levels or grades; grade I files of patients meting the inclusion criteria
is normal functioning and grade VI is a complete were available for analysis. Because of incom-
paralysis. HB-FGS is a reliable and widely accepted
facial grading system.14 However, this instrument
pleteness, 28 files were excluded; 20 patients
is rather coarse; therefore, more detailed informa- with a paresis of 3 months or less were also
tion on facial functioning was collected with a excluded. No patients were receiving concur-
standardized form. This form contains items and rent treatments. Firstly, the general character-
their associated graded answer categories in which istics of the patients will be described; subse-
the therapist had reported at patient encounter the
observations on impairments and disabilities and
quently, patients changes and stabilities in
had noted patients complaints and judgement of sequelae will be reported.
quality of life.
More detailed measures of facial impairment Patient Characteristics
were made as follows: the physiotherapist ob-
served (1) asymmetry at rest (3-point scale: normal
tone, hypotone, hypertone) in 4 facial areas (fore-
Of the 155 patients, 21% were referred for
head, eye region, nasolabial fold, and mouth re- facial rehabilitation after a Bells palsy, 33%
gion), (2) asymmetry during 8 requested facial after surgical removal of an acoustic neuroma,
movements (raising forehead, frowning, eye clo- herpes zoster in 8%, (operative) trauma in
sure, sniffing, smiling, pouting, depressing lower 15%, otitis media in 6%, and congenital facial
lip, and ballooning cheeks) on a 5-point scale (nor-
mal, mild, moderate, severe, gross), and (3) syn-
nerve paresis in 7%. The remaining 10% of
kineses associated with these 8 movements scored the diagnoses was unknown. Diagnosis and
on a 3 point scale (no, mild, severe). These 20 items sex show no relationship (P .11, not signif-
form an item pool that was considered to have icant), and most patients (74%) had had pre-
content validity. A similar item pool formed in the vious therapy (medication, electrotherapy, ex-
mid-90s the basis of a reliable and valid facial
grading system and is known as the Sunnybrook
ercise therapy, acupuncture, speech therapy,
FGS.15 Patients subjective judgment of quantified or surgical treatment) before starting Mime
impairment was elicited orally with respect to 6 therapy. The right side was significantly (right
indicators: pain (9 point scale), stiffness (5 point 99, left 56; P .001) more often affected than
scale), involuntary movements (5 point scale), lac- the left side, both for men and women.
rimation (3 point scale), nasal obstruction (2 point
scale), and sensation (2 point scale).
The age range was 6 to 85 years. Of the 155
Facial disability was assessed on the basis of patients, significantly more women (94) than
patients reports concerning difficulties in 4 fields: men (61) (P .01) were treated. The mean age
eating (8-point scale), drinking (5-point scale), of all patients was 42 years (SD, 18.2), the age
speaking (5-point scale), and hearing (3-point distributions being the same for men and
scale). Similar items now comprise part of the
Facial Disability Index.16 Finally, quality of life
women (t .82, P .41). The median time
was assessed by a quantitative patient judgement between onset of the paralysis and start of the
(10-point scale, 1 very good), a procedure with treatment was 15 months (mean 31.7 months,
accepted reliability, validity, and sensitivity.17,18 SD 34.5, range 4-99). At intake, only 25% of
the patients had a mild form of facial paresis
Analyses (HB score 2 or 3), 50% having a serious pare-
sis (HB score 5 or 6).
All analyses were performed with the SPSS
package. Tests for paired samples were used for
statistical analysis of the pre- and posttreatment
Patient-Perceived Impairments, Disabilities,
comparisons. Because the nature of the analyses and Quality of Life
was descriptive and exploratory, statistical tests
were performed 2 sided.19 If not otherwise men- Patients impairments, disabilities, and
tioned, chi-square tests were used. Stabilities of quality of life were assessed directly before
interpatient differences were calculated with Pear-
son correlation coefficients except for House-
the initial and after the final treatment ses-
Brackman scores, for which Spearmans rank order sion. The mean time between T1 (beginning of
correlation rho was used. treatment) and T2 (end of treatment) was 5.7
months (SD 5.7, range 1 to 40 months, median
RESULTS 4.0). The wide range is caused by the fact
that there were 7 patients treated who had
Of the 203 archived files of patients who undergone nerve and/or muscle transplanta-
had received Mime therapy, 155 complete tion, requiring a long-range treatment with a
FACIAL NERVE PARESIS 397

TABLE 1. Patient-Reported Impairments, Disabilities, and Quality of Life in 155 Patients With Facial Paresis Receiving
Mime Therapy and Their Changes Over the Therapy Period (T1-T2)

1 2 3 4
Changes in Average Correlation of
T1 Mean (SD) T2 Mean (SD) Severity T1-T2 T1, T2 Severity

Impairments
Pain 1.4 (2,2) 0.5 (1.6) Decreased 0.58*
Stiffness 1.7 (1.5) 0.6 (0.9) Decreased 0.71*
Involuntary movements 1.7 (2.8) 0.6 (1.7) Decreased 0.56*
Nasal passage 0.23 (0.4) 0.16 (0.6) Improved 0.80*
Sensation 0.3 (0.5) 0.26 (0.4) Improved 0.91*
Disabilities in
Eating 2.4 (1.8) 1.0 (1.3) Improved 0.57*
Drinking 1.4 (1.4) 0.5 (0.7) Improved 0.60*
Speaking 1.3 (1.1) 0.4 (0.6) Improved 0.52*
Hearing 0.7 (0.9) 0.7 (0.9) No difference, NS 0.98*
Quality of life 3.2 (2.6) 1.1 (1.4) Improved 0.57*

Abbreviation: NS, not significant.


*P .05.
P .01.
A paired sample t test was used.

low-session frequency. The average number of Facial Functioning


therapy sessions was 8, range 2 to 14. Table 1
gives an overview of the average severity of Face at Rest. Facial symmetry at rest im-
sequelae at T1 and T2. proved (ie, asymmetry on all indicators [re-
With regard to the severity of a complaint spectively forehead, eye region, nasolabial
on all 3 sequelae levels, the patients improved fold, and mouth region] decreased signifi-
on average on all indices except for hearing cantly) (Table 2).
problems. Patients differed at intake in the
amount and severity of their complaints. High Face During Voluntary Movement. Both
correlations between pre- and posttreatment the movements and the synkineses variables
measures reveal that such interindividual dif- indicate the presence and degree of severity of
ferences are stable over time. Table 1 (column the sequelae. Table 3 shows the results. Asym-
4) shows that for stiffness, nasal passage, sen- metry in facial movement remains present to a
sation, and hearing, the posttest interpatient substantial degree (columns 1 and 2), but, nev-
differences align quite well with preexisting ertheless, the average severity of this asymmetry
differences at T1. The scores at intake regard- decreases in all movements (column 3),
ing the other impairments and disabilities whereas interpatient differences at intake are
predict to a moderate degree their relative preserved over time (high correlations between
position at discharge. T1 and T2, shown in Table 3, column 4).

TABLE 2. Observed Asymmetry of the Face at Rest and Its Changes During Mime Therapy (n 155)

1 2 3 4
Asymmetry in Facial Areas T1 Mean (SD) T2 Mean (SD) Changes T1-T2 Correlation T1, T2

Forehead 0.7 (0.8) 0.5 (0.7) Improved 0.83*


Eye 1.1 (0.8) 0.7 (0.7) Improved 0.63*
Naso-labial fold 1.2 (0.8) 0.5 (0.6) Improved 0.60*
Mouth 1.7 (1.1) 1.1 (1.3) Improved 0.21

*P .05.
P .01.
A paired sample t test was used.
398 BEURSKENS AND HEYMANS

TABLE 3. Observed Facial Functioning During Voluntary Movement, Severity of Synkineses, and Their Changes During
Mime Therapy (n 155)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Voluntary T1 Mean T2 Mean Change Correl. Synk. T1 Synk. T2 Change Correl.
Movement (SD) (SD) T1-Tt2 T1, T2 Mean (SD) Mean (SD) T1-T2 T1, T2

Raising
forehead 4.1 (1.3) 3.7 (1.5) 0.89* 0.5 (0.7) 0.4 (0.5) 0.75*
Frowning 3.8 (1.4) 3.3 (1.5) 0.87* 0.5 (0.6) 0.4 (0.5) 0.65*
Eye closure 3.1 (1.3) 2.4 (1.1) 0.76* 0.7 (0.7) 0.6 (0.5) * 0.57*
Sniffing 3.9 (1.1) 3.1 (1.3) 0.79* 0.3 (0.6) 0.2 (0.4) 0.63*
Smiling 3.5 (1.1) 2.3 (0.9) 0.76* 0.6 (0.7) 0.4 (0.5) 0.51*
Pouting 3.5 (1.1) 2.7 (1.0) 0.74* 0.9 (0.8) 0.7 (0.6) 0.61*
Depressing
lower lip 4.2 (1.2) 3.5 (1.5) 0.74* 0.4 (0.7) 0.3 (0.5) 0.62*
Ballooning
cheeks 3.5 (1.1) 2.5 (1.0) 0.71* 0.7 (0.8) 0.5 (0.6) 0.67*

NOTE. Lower scores indicate a better function.


*P .05.
P .01.
A paired sample t test was used.

An increase in the number of patients show- for the HB-FGS at pre- and posttest and the
ing a synkinesis was observed for 3 out of 8 transitions between HB-FGS stages.
movements (eye closure 5, pouting 15,
and ballooning cheeks 8). Nevertheless, the Predictors of Changes
group average of severity of synkineses signif-
icantly decreased for all 8 movements (Table Improvements have been reported in many
3, columns 5-7). Interpatient differences in aspects of the patients complaints and ob-
degree of synkineses tended to persist over served facial functioning. Does the possibility
time for all movements (Table 3, column 8). exist to predict these changes on the basis of
objective patient information available at in-
Sequelae Assessed by the HB-FGS. Ac- take? Age, sex, and affected side of the face
cording to the HB-FGS, at T2, most patients might be such predictors. In our analyses,
had a lower score than at T1 indicating im- changes in scores were assessed by taking
provement. Of the group of 155 patients, 41 residuals from the post-pretest regressions.
patients (26%) improved at least 2 stages, 105 For the 10 complaints in Table 1, there were
patients (68%) improved 1 stage between in- no significant relations between age, sex, or
take and discharge, no patients showed dete- affected side and changes in complaints, with
rioration, and 9 patients (6%) showed no
change in the HB stage. Of the 77 patients
functioning at intake on HB-FGS stage 5 or
higher, only 19 remained at these low func-
tion stages at discharge. Prepost-comparison
of HB-FGS scores (which in fact are rank or-
ders) with a nonparametric statistical test
(Wilcoxon signed ranks test) showed a signif-
icant (P .01) difference. The high correla-
tion between pre- and posttest (rho 0.85)
indicates that, although there is change, the
relative position of patients changed mini-
mally between intake and discharge. HB-FGS
Fig 1. Transitions between beginning (HB1) and end
stage after Mime therapy is rather accurately (HB2) of Mime therapy in levels of House-Brackmann
predicted by HB-FGS stage at intake. See Fig 1 Facial Grading System (N 155 patients).
FACIAL NERVE PARESIS 399

2 exceptions: older patients showed less study. No information about interrater agree-
progress in eating and speaking and nasal ment can be given in this study because no
passage improved less in women than in men. data of a second rater were available. The
However, all these effects were small, al- hypothetical possibility of therapist/observer
though statistically significant. Taking HB bias is less plausible given the fact that there
scores as representing a summary of the de- was a considerable convergence in changes
tailed measures of facial functioning in Tables based on the reports from 2 different sources
2 and 3, analyses did not show predictive (patient and physiotherapist) and the changes
validities of age, sex, or affected side in regard found in this study are similar to the changes
to progress in HB scores. observed in the RCT by the same observer
under blinded conditions. Nevertheless, this
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS is a limitation. Assessments of physiotherapy
outcomes in facial nerve paresis performed by
This study aimed at describing changes in a single observer/physiotherapist are also
sequelae of facial nerve paresis during a pe- found in the literature in a pre-experimental
riod in which physiotherapy was given. For study by Coulson and Croxon.21 In the exper-
almost all sequelae of facial nerve paresis on imental studies by Ross et al7 and Segal et al,8
all 3 levels (impairments, disabilities, and the assessments were also done by a single
quality of life), significant improvements were therapist.
observed. The improvements observed in this Many patients showed improvement, but is
rather unselected group of 155 patients shows this sample not atypical? Our group of pa-
concordance with the benefits obtained from
tients can be considered as a sample from the
Mime therapy in 48 patients participating in
patient stream referred to the University Med-
an RCT.1,20
ical Centre Nijmegen for facial rehabilitation
However, some notes of caution are in or-
at that time. No indications were found denot-
der. Could the recorded changes be inherent
ing that the composition of this patient popu-
to the patient or to the measurement proce-
lation has changed over the years. The com-
dure? Assessment of the patients functioning
position of the patient sample in the recently
and therapy were done by the same physio-
completed RCT was similar in age, gender,
therapist (CB). This could influence the valid-
time between onset and intake, and nearly
ity of the data in an adverse way, especially
the change data. This physiotherapist had at similar in severity of facial paresis. One might
the time of availability of the first patient speculate that our conclusions are only valid
records 8 years of experience working with for the local situation because a data set ob-
patients with facial nerve paresis; this allows tained from another Dutch center for facial
for a stable cognitive frame of reference when rehabilitation in Amsterdam2 reports for the
assessing patients at intake and discharge. In period 1974 to 1983 a sex ratio of 1.0 in their
a recent project,20 interrater agreements group of patients, whereas in this study it was
were assessed concerning facial functioning. 3:2 favoring women. This Amsterdam group
Twenty-five patients (mean age 45 years, only consisted of patients with Bells palsy,
range 13-74) with a mean severity of III on the which is expected to affect both sexes alike,
HB-FGS were videotaped. Three raters inde- whereas our group included patients with fa-
pendently scored the patients using the Sun- cial nerve paresis of other etiologies. For our
nybrook FGS.15 The Sunnybrook FGS covers Bells palsy patients, the sex ratio is 5:3. The
the same areas of facial functioning as mea- Nijmegen hospital apparently sees relatively
sured in this study and uses a comparable more women than men for facial rehabilita-
item pool. The intrarater reliabilities of the tion. One could speculate about the reasons;
composite scale for the observers were deter- we will not do this. Because there is no cor-
mined to be intraclass correlation coefficient relation between sex and the changes ob-
between 0.89 and 0.98. The interrater reli- served (except for nasal passage), we do not
abilities varied between intraclass correlation believe that overrepresentation of women bi-
coefficient 0.90 and 0.95. One of the 3 raters ases the results concerning the changes during
was the physiotherapist from the present the physiotherapy episode.
400 BEURSKENS AND HEYMANS

CONCLUSIONS CONCERNING CHANGES 3. Devriese PP: Treatment of sequelae after facial pa-
ralysis: A global approach. J Laryngol Otol 112:429-431,
IN FACIAL FUNCTIONING 1998
4. Adour KK, Byl FM, Hilsinger RL, et al: The true
After a period of 3 to 5 months of Mime nature of Bells palsy: Analysis of 1000 consecutive pa-
tients. Laryngoscope 88:787-801, 1978
therapy, a significant degree of improvement 5. Beurskens CHG, Elvers JWH, Oosterhof J, et al: The
was observed in all areas investigated including role of physical therapy in patients with facial paralysis:
facial impairments, disabilities, and quality of State of the art, in Stennert ER (ed): The Facial Nerve.
Proceedings of the VIIth International Symposium on the
life. Asymmetry in the face at rest decreased Facial Nerve. New York, NY, Springer-Verlag, 1994, pp
for each of the 4 facial areas investigated, all 8 125-126
aspects of measured voluntary facial move- 6. Mosforth J, Taverner D: Physiotherapy for Bells
palsy. BMJ 13:675-677, 1958
ment improved, and synkineses associated 7. Ross B, Nedzelski JM, McLean JA: Efficacy of feed-
with each of these 8 facial movements de- back training in longstanding facial nerve paresis. Laryn-
creased significantly. Patients reported less goscope 101:744-750, 1991
8. Segal B, Hunter T, Danys I: Minimizing synkinesis
serious complaints concerning pain, stiffness, during rehabilitation of the paralyzed face: preliminary
involuntary movements, sensation, eating, assessment of a new small-movement therapy. J Otolar-
drinking, speaking, and quality of life. Ac- yngol 24:149-153, 1995
9. Devriese PP, Bronk J: Non-surgical rehabilitation of
cording to the HB-FGS, almost all patients facial expression, in Fisch U (ed): Facial Nerve Surgery.
improved at least 1 stage in 8 to 10 sessions. Amstelveen, The Netherlands, Kugler Medical Publ,
Age, sex, and affected side were not predictive 1977, pp 290-294
10. Beurskens C: The functional rehabilitation of facial
of the observed changes in HB-scores or of muscles and facial expression, in Castro D (ed): Facial
most changes in complaints. A high degree of Nerve, Proceedings of the Sixth International Symposium
stability of interindividual differences in on the Facial Nerve. Amsterdam, Kugler & Ghedini Publ,
1988, pp 509-511
nearly all facial aspects was observed except 11. Beurskens CHG, Burgers-Bots IAL, van Rossum-
for asymmetry of the mouth at rest. A reason Herraets MEJ: Fysiotherapie bij een perifere facialisver-
for this could be that the increase of the lamming, in Vaes P, Aufdenkampe G, den Dekker JB, et al
(eds): Jaarboek Fysiotherapie/Kinesitherapie, Houten/
amount of synkineses was greatest for the Diegem, Bohn Stafleu van Loghum, 1997, pp 98-116
mouth region, perhaps indicating that the ten- 12. Devriese PP, Beurskens C, van Heiningen I: Reha-
sion in the mimetic muscles could have in- bilitation of facial expression by mime. Amsterdam, Huis-
drukkerij A.Z.U., 1998
creased, thus giving a changed asymmetry 13. House JW, Brackmann DE: Facial nerve grading
score. system. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 93:146-147, 1985
The improvements observed in patients af- 14. Evans RA, Harries MA, Baguley DM, et al: Reliabil-
ity of the House and Brackmann grading system for facial
ter being treated with Mime therapy are con- palsy. J Laryngol Otol 103:1045-1046, 1989
sistent with the recently RCT-proven effec- 15. Ross BG, Fradet G, Nedzelski JM: Development of a
tiveness of Mime therapy even though the sensitive clinical facial grading system. Otolaryngol Head
Neck Surg 114:380-386, 1996
patient sample in this 10-year study was more 16. VanSwearingen JM, Brach JS: The Facial Disability
varied in age, number of treatment sessions, Index: Reliability and validity of a disability assessment
cause of facial paralysis, and duration of the instrument for disorders of the facial neuromuscular sys-
tem. Phys Ther 76:1288-1300, 1996
paresis. 17. Cummins RA: Normative life satisfaction: measure-
ments issues and a homeostatic model. Social Indicators
Res 64:225-256, 2003
REFERENCES 18. Taillefer MC, Dupuis G, Roberge MA, et al: Health-
related quality of life models: Systematic review of the
1. Beurskens CHG, Heymans PG: Positive effects of literature. Social Indicators Res 64:293-323, 2003
Mime therapy on sequelae of facial paralysis: Stiffness, 19. Cronbach LJ, Furby L: How we should measure
lip mobility, and social and physical aspects of facial change, or should we? Psychol Bull 74:68-80, 1980
disability. Otol Neurol 24:677-681, 2003 20. Beurskens CHG. Mime therapy: rehabilitation of
2. Devriese PP, Schumacher T, Scheide A, et al: Inci- facial expression [thesis]. Nijmegen, KUN, 2003
dence, prognosis and recovery of Bells palsy: A survey of 21. Coulson SE, Croxon GR: Assessing physiotherapy
about 1000 patients (1974-1983). Clin Otolaryngol 15:15- rehabilitation outcomes following facial nerve paralysis.
27, 1990 Aust J Otolaryng 2:20-24, 1995

You might also like