SAINT LOUIS UNIVERSITY

DEPARTMENT OF ARCHITECTURE
SCHOOL OF ENGINEERING AND ARCHITECTURE
A. Bonifacio Street, 2600 Baguio City, Philippines
Tel. Nos.: (074) 442-3043; 442-2793; 442-2193; 4448246 to 48
FAX (074) 442-2842
1

Annex 9

Thesis Title: ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Name: ________________________________________________

RUBRIC FOR ADVISERS EVALUATION FOR MOCK DEFENSE - INDIVIDUAL

Aspect Poor presentation: Fair presentation: Good presentation: Score

Introduction 1-3 4-7 8-10
of overall Provides no overview statement or statement Contains a complete but somewhat contains a complete and well organized
Concept is so short as to be useless disorganized overview statement. overview statement.

Organization 1-3 4-7 8-10

is disorganized and deals completely with is somewhat disorganized and provides is well organized, moving from general
details without providing a broad explanation too much detail without giving a good topics to specific details; provides a
of the work explanation of the work. good explanation of the work.

Findings 1-8 9-15 16-20

student has made no significant findings and student has made few significant student has made significant finding that
has not met objectives. findings or finding are inconclusive are evidence base, accurate, and
clearly expressed.

Technology 1-3 4-7 8-10

makes no use of technology to find answer(s) makes improper use of technology to makes effective use of technology to
to leading question(s) find answer(s) to leading question(s). find answer(s) to leading question(s).

Speaking 1-3 4-7 8-10

Skills essentially reads the material from a relies heavily on presentation to make uses presentation resources as a guide,
presentation to make the report; clearly report; somewhat comfortable with the gives detailed explanations, is easily
uncomfortable with the topic. topic. understandable, and keeps eye contact
with the audience.
2

Visual Aids 1-3 4-7 8-10

contains no visual aids or visual aids are so contains few or inadequate visual aids contains visual aids that help audience
poorly constructed as to be worthless. or visual aids have a neat and understand work; visuals have a neat
professional appearance, but poorly and professional look, easily understood;
used in making points used well to make points.
Questions 1-10 11-20 21-30
and Answers answers none of the answer questions well. answers only some of the questions well. answers questions clearly and
accurately.

TOTAL POINTS:

A score of ZERO may be given for criteria that are not at all satisfied

_________________________________ Date: _____________________________

Name and signature of evaluator