Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Introduction
This assignment introduces eight multicultural books listed on the Notable Books for
Global Society lists. In this essay we will summarize, analyze, and identify main points in each
one of these books that relate to the NBGS criteria. We will also identify the reason for
multicultural literature and how we could incorporate it into our future classroom. We take a
look at eight completely different books, but find similarities in each. Each one of these books
addresses the issues of cultural awareness and promotes the understanding of diverse
backgrounds.
Purpose
literature. Reviewing and analyzing the books enables us to look at a wide variety of
multicultural books and dissect each one. We are able to look at the similarities and differences
of the books and identify important features. The Notable Books for Global Society votes on the
books that they feel meets the criteria. This assignment makes us look at the book in different
lenses and critique it like they would. It also enhances our understanding and appreciation of
multicultural literature. We will be able to introduce these books into our classroom one day and
explain why they are so amazing. It is important to be educated and understand different
cultures, race, sexual orientation, values, and ethnic. If we are educated about these topics we
will have a better relationship with our students and be able to introduce these topics in the class.
Steps taken
outcome. We first planned our roles and expectations. We then looked at the Notable Books for a
3
Global Society list together and talked about what books sparked our interested. We began
researching the books and going to the local libraries. We then discussed what books we wanted
to read and why they we wanted to use the specific books we chose. We finally decided to
narrow the list down and only use books in the 2015 Notable Books for Global Society. We
made that decision because we wanted to compare the books and see how they were related. We
both had a few of the 2015 books that were on the lost and we got the other books from the
library. After this decision I noticed that Where the Mountain Meets the Moon was one of the
books that made the list for a different year. Out of all of the books I have read this semester that
book was my favorite, so I really wanted to do this book. We talked about it and decided it was a
great decision. After reading each one of the books, we discussed the organization of the paper
and the criteria. We then wrote out our paper and compared our work. We did our best to make
our format similar so we were constantly in contact. I thought we worked very well together and
our communication skills were wonderful. This project was a lot easier than I anticipated solely
Definition
awareness of cultures all around the world. Multicultural literature is all about introducing
diversity and accepting one another. I came up with this definition after our discussion in class. I
thought about what multicultural literature meant and what went into it. Before this class I did
not think about the purpose of multicultural literature. I just thought it was about different
cultures, I thought it was boring and uninteresting. I now know there is a lot more to this genre,
and the books are very interesting. These books touch on so many issues and real topics that
leave readers speechless. Issues about race, tradition, sexual orientation and so many other
4
controversial topics are discussed in these books. It touches on religious groups and individuals
with physical problems. It is an educational and pleasurable genre that any age group would
love.
BOOKS
Pinkney, A. D., & Evans, S. (2014). The Red Pencil. Little, Brown Books for Young Readers.
Summary -
The Red Pencil is a verse novel that is told in poems and pictures by Andrea Davis
Pinkney. This book is about a twelve year old girl named Amira. Amira lives and works on a
farm in Africa with her parents and her little sister Leila. Her parents are very traditional and do
not believe that women should go to school. Amira dreams about going to school, but her
parents dream of her marrying and having children. The Janjaweed attacks their village and they
lose everything, but the biggest, her father. They are forced to leave and they find refuge in
Kalma. In Kalma someone gives her a red pencil and yellow paper, she is ecstatic. This lifts
Amira and she finds her passion once again. Old Anwar is a family friend who teaches Amira
how to write. She gets so involved that she wants to leave and get an education.
Critique NBGS
This novel deserved being on the Notable Books for a Global Society list. This book did
not only meet the criteria, but it exceeded the expectations. The topic of this book was about a
young girl who lived in Darfur, Africa. This book touches on so many issues and real problems
that are happening all over the world. The committee is looking for an outstanding book that
5
promotes the understanding of cultures, race, sexual orientation, values, and ethnicity. The
committee made an excellent decision with this one. The Red Pencil is a culturally diverse book
that touches on every aspect of the NBSGs criteria. To begin, this book introduces a culture that
many individuals may not know too much about. Andrea Davis Pinkney introduces the Sudanese
culture and race in a beautiful way. The setting of this book is in a Sudanese village, it speaks on
the daily lives of the residents and their everyday struggles. It touches on their work, their families,
and their fight against enemies. When girls turn twelve years old, they are essentially an adult, this
means for Amira (the main character) she was an adult. This meant that Amira had to work harder,
she had to do more on the farm and help out around the house. Amira also received a Toob when
she turns twelve, which is a traditional cloth that wraps around the body. This is a cultural aspect
that is portrayed in the book. Sexual orientation is also depicted in the text, Amira is expected to
marry and have children and obey her husband. She is constantly her testing her mothers patience
because she is certain that she does not her mothers life. She wishes to get an education and teach.
She believes that women should be able to read, write, and go to school but because she is a
women, she is not allowed to. For the first part of the NBSGs criteria The Red Pencil covered
almost half of the requirements when the book only needed to meet one part. The book portrayed
cultural accuracy and authentic in terms of intellectual abilities and problem solving capabilities,
leadership and cooperative dimensions, and social and economic status. As I mentioned earlier,
Amira was expected to work on the farm until she found a husband, she was expected to listen to
her parents and obey them. They lived in a small Sudanese village that was not very well educated
or wealthy. This touches on the aspect of intellectual abilities as well as social and economic status.
For part two of the criteria, Pinkney invited reflection, and critical analysis in her novel. When
Amiras village gets attacked, it raises many questions. It is a great section to reflect about where
6
she is and the struggles that her and her village are facing. Pinkney also used a unique style of
writing and an appealing format. She used a verse novel, which creative way to introduce a grim
topic in a light hearted and engaging way. The text states Well-written books that express
multicultural themes or are international in their origins may have a profound effect on readers,
promoting a global outlook as well as an understanding that members of the human family have
more similarities than differences (Tunnel, et., al. 2016, p. 201). Pinkney did research while she
was writing this book, she traveled to Africa and hoped to make this book as accurate as possible.
She did an excellent job introducing a small part of the Sundaneses culture and providing her
Literary elements -
The illustrations are simple, yet hold so much meaning. The illustrations include sketches
of powerful images that represent different aspects of the book. The book would not have been
the same if the illustrations were non-existent. Personally I was able to connect with the book
and it gave me a better understanding of the culture. It was much easier to read and understand a
book when the book is accompanied by illustrations. If the book did not include illustrations, I
think it would have been much more difficult to read. Especially considering the age level of this
book. This book is targeted towards young adult readers and younger, I think the illustrations
pull kids in. This book is dealing with a real topic and it could be a dry subject, but Pinkney
created a well-written and well-illustrated book that could engage readers of all ages. I thought
Pinkney did a nice job with the plot, theme, and characters. The plot of this book is about a
young girls journey through sorrow and possibility in Africa. She wishes to get an education but
she is not able to because it is unheard of for women to get an education. The theme of this book
is about hope and achieving your dreams. Amira almost gave up on her dream when her village
7
got attacked and she lost her father. Amira was depressed and did not see the light at the end of
the tunnel. Until someone gave her a pencil and paper and her dreams were alive again. This
book is about coming back from devastating circumstances and still believing in something
special. A few of the characters in this book were Amira who played a stubborn girl, but for a
good reason. Her mother, who was very traditional, but in Amiras eyes, hardheaded. Her father
who wanted the best for Amira, but could not give it to her. Old Anwar who was a wise man who
supported Amiras dreams. Her friend who moved to get an education, who she was jealous of.
Finally her little sister Leila, she was very young and still had a lot to learn, but she loved and
obeyed Amira. The voice of the book was very peaceful, Pinkney introduces painful situations in
a particular that makes it a little easier to read. I found myself frustrated and sad when I was
reading this book because of what Amira had to go through, but I felt like I was listening to
Amira when I was reading it. The verse style, provided the book with rhythm and a soft tone.
One example form the text is "Slowly, I repeat. // With my pencil, / I swirl sweet's delicious
beauty / onto my tablet's paper. / Sweet. / Sweet. / Sweet. // I have already tasted this new word's
meaning. //" (Pinkney, Et., al. 2014, p. 239). When I read that sentence I feel calm and a sense of
hope.
Critical reaction -
To begin this novel is written in verse which could be a strength and weakness. Every
reader is different, some may enjoy the style, but others may hate it. The verse style introduces
the difficult topic in a more settling way. It allows readers to comprehend the material in a
different way and it may be easier for some children to read. The verse style could also be a
weakness because many readers cannot follow poems or understand them. A few strengths that
the book portrayed were the illustrations. I found that the illustrations were a great addition and
8
made the book much more interesting. Another strength that I think the book portrayed was the
presentation of the information. The genocide that occurred in Darfur was devastating, but
Pinkney spoke about it perfectly. It was appropriate for the age level and still provided enough
information. This book also provides a small glimpse into Amiras life, which gives readers a
better understanding of the world she lives in. A weaknesses that this book had was the ending, it
was abrupt and dry. I felt like it should have expanded on Amiras life and what she was doing,
but instead the book just ended. We didnt find out how things worked out or what ended up
happening. She took a lot of time setting up Amira, her family, and her feelings, but readers are
left confused. I would introduce this book into my classroom in a curriculum or even just read it
for fun. This book can be educational, but I also think that this book is for enjoyment as well.
Students can learn and take a lot from this book ranging from different cultures and
accomplishing your dreams. This would be a great way for students to learn about poetry and
different types of poetry. It could also be used for introducing different cultures and why it is
important to learn about different cultures. This meets my criteria for good multicultural
literature because I would be introducing different cultures, values, and styles of writing.
Depending on the grade level, I could have the students write a paper about what they learned
from the book and why they think reading multicultural literature is beneficial. I would use this
specifically because of the style, theme, and plot of the book. This book covered all of the basis
Russell-Brown, K., & Morrison, F. (2014). Little Melba and her Trombone. Lee & Low Books
Summary -
9
Little Melba and Her Big Trombone is a true story about Melba Doretta Liston. This book
tells the story of a young girls passion for playing music and the struggles she faces because of
her skin color. She was surrounded by music her whole life, so she decided to get her own
instrument. She was dedicated and her family was there to support her, although she hard times.
She was a master musician and she traveled around the world to play. She sadly experienced
discrimination because of her skin color and this book discusses her fight towards her dream.
Melba was so discouraged that she thought about walking away from her trombone, but her fans
didnt let her quit. This is a great multicultural book that many people would enjoy reading.
Critique NBGS
Little Melba and Her Big Trombone is a multicultural book that is on the NBGS list. As I
have mentioned before, the criteria is specific to diversity and enhancing childrens
understanding of different cultures. Miss Melba Doretta Liston is an American musician that
experienced discrimination because she was an African American. Liston out beat the odds of a
women musician becoming successful during 1940s through the 60s. During this time it was
odd to see a women successful and strong. Not just that, but an African American women, which
made many people angry. This book deals with sexual discrimination, like when the boys at her
high school are making fun of her. This book meets part 1 of the criteria because the book is
discussing an in-depth treatment of cultural issues. Melba experiences cultural issues first hand
and the book captures those emotions. The in-depth treatment of people not attending her shows
and not being allowed to go into building and play are example of part 1. In part 2 of the criteria
this book meets every part, the style of the book is unique and is appealing. This book expresses
a powerful message in a childrens book. The book is about a real story but introduces in an
Literary Elements -
The illustrations in this book were very well executed. The warm colors provided a sense
of hope and calmness. The lines are precise and about a fourth of the page is dedicated to the
text. Each page has an extreme amount of detailed, for example in the music class the chalk
board has writing on it and each individual hair is done perfectly. The angles are precise and
creative, which makes the book come alive. The plot of the story is about a young girl who loves
playing music, but as she is growing up she is noticing the acts of segregation and racism. Melba
was being pushed away from something she loved because of her skin color. The theme of this
book is, doing what you love regardless of discrimination. Melba was tempted to quit music, but
she didnt and she kept playing. I think that could be a lesson to many children and young adults
reading this book. The voice in this book is cheerful in the beginning, sad in the middle, and
hopeful at the end. The first sentence from the book represents the cheerful mood, Spread the
word little Melba Doretta Liston was something special. The year she was born was 1926, the
place was Kansas City where you could reach out and feel the music (Russell-Brown, et., al.
2014, p. 1). This book mentioned several characters such as her grandfather, her band, and
famous players, but the whole book revolved around her. They introduced her and her story in a
personal way and I think the book represented Melba very well. The illustrations depicted both
sides of the story the best way possible, which was an emotional and happy journey.
Critical Reaction
This book has many strengths, but it also has a few weaknesses. The presentation of this
book is done very well. The illustrations are a strength that gives the book character. I do not
think this book would have been selected without the illustrations. They add so much to the book
and provide the book with real emotions. I also think the book introduced Liston very well. A
11
weakness is the information in the book. I wish the book dug a little deeper and spoke more
about the issues that Liston faced. I understand that this is a childrens picture book, but it could
also be an educational book. The book touched lightly on the topic, when I wish it couldve gone
more in detail. I enjoyed reading the book, but I am not sure if I like the story line. This book
was nominated because of the multicultural aspects portrayed. It touches on more cultural issues
than other books that I have read. It does meet my criteria for a good multicultural book, and I do
think this book deserved being on the list, because it does include sexual discrimination and race.
This book does provide readers with a better understanding of issues happening around the
world.
Summary -
Jackie is the main character in this novel, she shares her experiences of segregation,
racism, and the civil rights movement. Growing up in the 1960s and 1970s and being African
American came with many obstacles. Throughout the book Jackie is trying to find her voice and
wrap her head around everything going on around her. Her parents have different views about
the South which causes many arguments. Her parents eventually split and her and her siblings
move into her grandparents house with her mother. This is where she learns about nonviolently
fighting for what you believe in. Jackie experiences so many obstacles and during that time she
is trying to find herself. She is dealing with the civil rights movement and the separation of her
parents. She is creating relationships with her family members and finding her calling to be a
writer. This book allows readers to get an insight of Jackies life and her feelings. The story does
12
indeed have a slow start, but Alexander has an interesting approach to the information. This book
is written in a verse, so the whole book is comprised of different poems. This book is written in a
very personal way which allows the readers to connect with the book. The topics discussed in
this book are real problems and issues that people deal with today. I had a difficult time reading
this book because of the style of the novel, but I thought the theme and story line of the book was
well done
Critique NBGS-
This book meets the NBGSs criteria with ease. This book is a multicultural verse novel
that discusses and promotes the understanding of Jackies culture. This book meets part one of
the criteria which is rich in cultural detail. Woodson is able to create an authentic novel that is
rich in detail because she experienced every account personally. Woodson reminds her audience
that she grew up in the 60s when segregation and racism was alive. She refers to white only
signs and not being able to sit too close to the bus driver because of their skin color. Woodson
touches on many cultural components which is why the book was chosen to be on this list. The
book touches on Jackies religion, her grandmother converted them to Jehovah Witness, although
she switches later. Jehovah Witnesses are not supposed to celebrate any holidays including
birthdays. This small detail provides us with Jackies culture as well as her values. The book also
meets part two of the criteria. Woodson invites reflection, critical analysis as well as a response.
One of my favorite quotes in the book that fits this component perfectly is, Even the silence /
has a story to tell you/ just listen. Listen (Woodson, 2014, p. 238). This allows the reader to take
a step back and actually think about what Jackie is talking about. This book also uses a unique
language and style. The language used in this novel is so simplistic but transcends a powerful
13
meaning. Woodson speaks upon her real and personal feelings towards culture, race, and values
Literary Elements
The plot of this book is interesting because it deals with a young African American girl
who shares her experiences segregation, racism, and the civil rights movement. She speaks on
her frustrations, wishes, and obstacles that she has to overcome. Jackie is trying to figure out
what life is all about and in the process she is dealing with many struggles in her life. The theme
of this book is Jackies Journey through life. She is trying to find her voice and understand the
world around her. She is dealing with the civil rights movement and the separation of her
parents. She is creating relationships with her family members and finding her calling to be a
writer. The voice of this book is powerful, Jacqueline Woodson reminds us the time that she
grew up and what was happening in her life. For example, Then I let the stories live / inside my
head, again and again / until the real world fades back / into cricket lullabies / and my own
dreams (Woodson, 2014, p. 81). Jackie Woodson is the main character of the book. Her parents
Jack and Mary Ann Woodson, who split up because they have different views. Her grandparents
Georgiana and Gunnar Irby and her siblings Dell, Hope, and Roman. Woodson develops Jackies
relationship with her grandfather, she idolizes her grandfather and begins to call him daddy.
She describes spending time with her grandfather and how she would fall asleep on his
shoulders. He passes away and her family is torn apart. This is an example of how the characters
were presented in the book and each individual impacted her life. This style of this novel is a
memoir written in free verse. Woodson tells the story of her life beginning to end and explores
Critical Reaction
14
I enjoyed reading this book, but I found it relatively difficult to stay interested. I think
this book has strengths, but I also think that this book could have been introduced in a different
way. It was difficult to read because the verse style, it did not compliment the book. I believe
that the verse style was a weakness, I think that Woodson could have introduced this book in a
different manner and it would have been much stronger. I appreciated overlying message and
theme of the plot, although it was difficult to get there. This book displayed an immense amount
of detail and allowed for reflection, which are strengths that this book conveyed. The powerful
verses also held a lot of meaning, but I wonder how well young adult readers would comprehend
them. An example of a powerful message in the book is, I want to catch words one day. I want
to hold them / then blow gently, / watch them float / right out of my hands (Woodson, 2014, p.
141). Woodson talks about powerful stories all throughout the book and she did a great job
introducing them. Another strength that this portrays is Woodsons selflessness. She shares many
personal feelings and raw emotions with the readers that strengthen the meaning of the book.
Lin, Grace. (2009). Where the mountain meets the moon. New York: Little, Brown and Co.,
Summary
Where is the Mountain Meets the Moon is written by Grace Lin and is about a young
girls journey to change her families fortune. This book is an adventurous and engaging book for
young adult readers, although I think many people would enjoy this book. Minlis live with her
very hard working parents. Her father is constantly retelling folk talks that she is mesmerized by.
Her mother is constantly angry and does not like to listen to her father foolish stories. Her mother
is constantly complaining about their fortune and because they live off of very little food and
15
work very hard. Minli wants to do something about it, so she takes off without her parents
knowing and goes on an unforgettable journey to find the old man of the moon to change her
fortune.
Criteria NBGS
This book met the criteria of the NBGS and promotes cultural awareness. One of the
biggest aspects that this book meets is the authenticity of the book. The traditional folktales
enable the reader to appreciate the culture. It provides a little insight of the traditions and the
beliefs. It also provides an understanding of why they do certain things. This multicultural book
focuses on the Chinese culture which is distinguished by the characters. This meets part 1 and
part 2 of the criteria, it honors and celebrates diversity as well as demonstrates a unique language
and style. This book differs from other books because it is a fantasy book, although it holds
traditional values. It honors diversity and they cherish every folktale that is told in the book. The
style of the book is an interesting way to approach cultural awareness, but it was an engaging
way. Many children would enjoy this book because of the fantasy aspect, but they will learn
about the Chinses Culture as well. Gracie Lin grew up as the only Asian in her school and she
soon began to neglect her heritage. She later felt shameful for what she did and she began
traveling China and other countries. This story is a mix between non-fiction and fiction. Lin
created this story but incorporated real facts into it. I know from experience that many children
disregard their heritage and this book could change childrens outlook. I am half Mexican and
half Caucasian and I grew up in a predominately Mexican school. I have very light skin, so I was
an automatic target. Although it was difficult for me because I was like all of the other kids, I ate
the same food as them, I went to the same church, I had the same traditions, but because my skin
color was white I was bullied. I began hating the other half of myself and wished that I didnt
16
have white skin because I was constantly I target. As I became older, I realized that I was foolish
and that the kids were outright mean. I can understand and relate to children just like Lin
experienced. This book would be a great book to introduce into a classroom and explain Lins
story.
Literary Elements
The plot of this book is about a young girl who goes on an adventure to change her
parents fortune. As she is on this adventure is meets people along the way and comes across
certain challenges. She meets people who change her life and changes her perspective on things.
When she eventually finds the old man of the moon, who is going to change her fortune she
realizes that her friends fortune is more important than hers. The theme of this book is
friendship, without the friendships she made throughout her journey, she would not have made
the right decision. Her closest friend that she made was the dragon, she also became friends with
twins, buffalo boy and many more. The voice in the book is curious and hopeful. Minli travels
through areas that she knows nothing about and danger could ne awaiting her. The voice is
through Minli as she is narrating the story. There are parts throughout the book that include the
folktale that is told by different people. Although through the help of other people Minli travels
safely. Minli is the main character in the book, but she meets individuals through her journey.
Her closest friend the dragon goes on the entire journey with her, although he cannot fly. Her
parents are back home, hoping that Minli is safe. The writing style is a fantasy book for children.
Critical Reaction
17
The strengths that this book embodies is a creative story and the Chinese folktales. The
format and presentation of this book is also a strength. This creative story interweaves true
Chinese folktales into an adventurous book. The storyline and presentation of this book was
executed very well. The story had a beginning, middle, and end and each section had a purpose.
The book also introduced the Chinese culture which provided a small glimpse into their
traditions. At the end of the book Grace Lin explains why she wrote the book and the process.
Many of her illustrations were real photos that she took in China but transformed them and used
them in her book. A weakness that this book conveyed would be not as much cultural
background. I wish that this book included more information about her culture, rather than just
the folktales and a couple other things. This book could have used stronger cultural ties such as
religion, traditions, and other aspects in that nature. Some may argue that the style of book is a
weakness. I know this book was difficult for some people to read because of the fantasy style,
Tonatiuh, D. (2014). Separate is never equal: Sylvia Mendez & her family's fight for
Summary -
Separate Is Never Equal: Sylvia Mendez & her familys fight for desegregation was a
picture book written and illustrated by Duncan Tonatiuh. This book is a true story about a young
Mexican girl and her familys fight to gain equality. The book is written in first person from the
little girls perspective, Sylvia. This story takes place before, during, and immediately following
This story begins with Sylvia Mendez coming home all upset after her first day at school.
Sylvia was bullied and called names all day about being in her new school, and isnt very excited
about going back the next day. Her mother hears this and tells her daughter that they worked
really hard to get where they are and she needs to think about how good of a thing it was for
everyone like her, which is followed by a jump back to when Sylvias family first tried to get her
into the school she was in. The Mendez family moved to California so Sylvias father could run
his own farm. This caused her and her two brothers to change schools, but when they attempted
to enroll they were told by the principle that they couldnt because the school was only a white
person school and they needed to go to the Mexican school. This made the Mendez family very
angry because the children were US citizens, they were closer to the white students school, and
The Mendez family was told that they should sue and take it to court, and Mr. Mendez
agreed. The fight in the court went further and further up the court system and the Mendez
family was gaining lots of support from other non-Caucasian families. Sylvia watched at the
sidelines and dreamed about being called to the stands. After many months that courts finally
made a decision and declared that schools could not turn down students because of their race,
color, or background. Sylvia was taken back to the school and started her first day only to be
called names and bullied by the other students. She came home crying and not wanting to come
back, but her mother calmed her down and talked to her about it. Her mother told her that it
didnt matter and she needed to ignore the other kids. They worked very hard to get where they
were and she couldnt give up now otherwise nothing would ever change.
Critique NBGS -
19
Separate Is Never Equal: Sylvia Mendez & her familys fight for desegregation, found on
the Notable Books for a Global Society list does a great job of following the (NBGS) criteria.
This book honors and celebrates diversity as well as common bonds in humanity, in multiple
different ways. It is greatly shown in the fight for equality these individuals went through and
how more and more people stuck together, from different backgrounds, just to support the same
cause. This book also includes members of a minority group in the United States, which is shown
through the Mexican population. This book, Separate Is Never Equal: Sylvia Mendez & her
familys fight for desegregation, also demonstrates an interesting style of writing, as shown in the
court case section of the story. The format in this book is very appealing because the story would
have been a lot drier without the pictures on every page. Overall this story met all of the NBGS
book criteria, and was a very good story for students and adults to read.
Literary elements -
The illustrations in this book were very interesting, they looked like they were inspired
by old Mexican art work. The colors in this books illustrations were very dull, and mellow toned.
The writing style of this story was in the form of a childrens picture book, and was meant for
younger audiences. The plot of this story was all about the Mendez Court Case, but was shown
in the view of the child not the adult. This story started with Sylvia not being allowed to go to a
good school because of her race, then it showed the following years though the court case until
Sylvia finally was allowed into that one school that originally sent her away. The theme of the
story could be just because you look or act differently doesnt mean you should be treated
differently, or no child should have a lesser education because of what they look like or where
they come from. The voice of the story is very frustrated at some points, and very excited or
expectant at others. The characters in this book grew some as the story unfolded. Sylvia for
20
instance started out very sad about her situation at school, and ended happy and proud when she
Critical reaction -
Separate Is Never Equal: Sylvia Mendez & her familys fight for desegregation, has many
strengths and some weaknesses throughout the story. The books strengths would include the way
the author made a historical event exciting and connectable for children, and another would be
how the story was written from a childs perspective. The way the author made this court case
exciting and connectible for children was very good. It had a lot of historical information but was
written in a way that students would not know that they were actually learning throughout the
entire book. The choice to have this picture book written from a childs point of view was also a
very wonderful idea. This made the story very connectable for children, and helped them
understand from Sylvias point of view. This book also had some weaknesses such as it did not
show much of what it was like for Sylvia at her Mexican school. This book did show a little of
what her education was like, but it would have been more educational if it had a little more of
Kuklin, S. (2014). Beyond magenta: Transgender teens speak out. Candlewick Press.
Summary -
Beyond Magenta: Transgender Teens Speak Out was written by Susan Kuklin and
Candlewick. This book is a collection of transgender teens stories and all their experiences with
finding themselves. This book starts out with the story of Jessy, a man in a womans body, when
he gets his first period. This chapter talks about how Jessy had a good child and was never really
21
bullied because he had a positive and bubbly attitude. Jessys real name was Kamolchanok and
he was from Bangkok before he moved to the US. Even Jessys parents now call him their only
son. At age thirteen Jessy went into the boys bathroom, and was very confused when he was
pulled out of school by his parents who said it was unacceptable. The story jumps back to when
Jessy was younger and some of the thoughts he had. Such as his first crush on a girl, wearing a
suit to picture day, and taking karate and boxing. He talked about having to do dance and crying
to his mother begging her not to make him go, because he didnt like it. Puberty came and Jessy
started to get breasts and other changes that he didnt want. They had to go back to Thailand and
Jessy was highly question who he was, and was experimenting a lot. He tried to be a girl, and fit
in, but when it wasnt working and they found out he might be gay they became mean. High
school was just as complicated as elementary if not more because Jessy came out and tried to
find himself as a man. During college Jessys mom finally accepted him as a man. The story then
This book also went on to tell the story of Christina who was born as Matthew. Christina
has had bad experiences with people bullying her, and treating her badly about her life choices
and feelings. Christina was born a boy and grew up with judgmental family and friends because
of her choices to become a woman. Christina always considered himself girly even when he was
a little boy. Christiania never liked sports, and loved shopping and dressing pretty. His dad knew
from the beginning that Christina always wanted to be a girl and was very okay with it, but her
mother was not as accepting. During her senior year Christina went full transgender and had
many people not understand or not except her decision. People bullied her, physically and
mentally assaulted her, and full out separated her from the rest of the school. Throughout school
Christina only had one teacher nice to her, and a few friends that somewhat accepted her. By the
22
end of senior year she was taking estrogen and becoming a women like she wanted. Christina
Mariah also had a story in the book, Mariah is a transgender woman who has had a harder
time transitioning because she feels that she will never be fully human. She started wearing
female cloths at the age of four, and had many problems with adults and teachers treating her
badly and like she was wrong. Unlike the other stories Mariah showed her girly side at a very
young age. The book continued with more and more examples of young individuals that were in
the wrong body and became transgender. Cameron, Nat, and Luke all had different but similar
stories.
Critique NBGS -
This multicultural cultural book, Beyond Magenta: Transgender Teens Speak Out, found
on the Notable Books for a Global Society list does a great job of following the (NBGS) criteria.
This book honors and celebrates diversity as well as common bonds in humanity, as shown in
each of the mini stories throughout the book. Each of the main characters learn at one point or
another that they should be proud and celebrate who they are, as well as their family and friends
that support them. This book also includes members of a minority group in the United States,
which is shown through the transgender populations. Beyond Magenta: Transgender Teens
Speak Out also demonstrates an interesting style of writing, as shown by the main independent
sections of the book being split between a handful of teens. This form of writing is also part of
the appealing format in the book, I think that this was a great choice in how to add multiple
different views. Overall this story met and went beyond the criteria of an NBGS books, and was
a very good and well written book all the way around
23
Literary elements -
There were not as many illustrations in this book because it was a chapter book, but there
were a few pictures. The pictures found in this book were to show the transitions and changes
that these teens went through on the way to finding themselves. Each of these pictures showed
only headshots or body shots of the storyteller. There are multiple themes in this story and they
all stayed relatively consistent. The first theme could be shown as; be who you are even if others
tell you not to, and dont feel lesser if you are not what others want of you, be who you want.
The style of this story was also very good. The story was in the form of a chapter book, which
was very fitting and appealing to the story. The voice of the story is mostly frustrated, excited, or
confused and it switched back and forth depending on the person and the age they were talking
about. The organization was also well done, each teen had their own start that started from when
they first felt different to when they finally found themselves. The plot was repetitive with each
teens story, but it consisted of their stories throughout their time of finding who they were and
changing to become who they wanted to be. Finally the characters had good description and
growth throughout each individual story. We watch Jessy, Christina, Mariah, Cameron, Nat, and
Luke all grow and change into the people that they are supposed to be and not what their families
Critical reaction -
The story, Beyond Magenta: Transgender Teens Speak Out, has many strengths and some
weaknesses. The books strengths would include the many viewpoints, and the multiple stories
told by transgender teens. The multiple viewpoints in this story showed how horrible and mean
some people in society can be and how everyone needs to be more excepting of transgender and
gay individuals because being mean does not change or solve anything. The stories also showed
24
how many transgender individuals go through multiple different situations all with a common
problem of acceptance. These two points made very strong and good aspects to the book that
really needed to be shown and stated. This book also had some weaknesses such as it dragged
sometimes in the background aspect to the book. Although most of the background stories made
the book what it is, others caused the storyline to drag a little slower than it could have been.
Some of the stories shared needed to be shortened or removed because of irrelevance to the plot
and storyline.
Uegaki, C., & Leng, Q. (2014). Hana Hashimoto, sixth violin. Toronto, ON: Kids Can Press
Summary -
Hana Hashimoto, Sixth Violin written by Chieri Uegaki and illustrated by Qin Leng. This
book is a childrens picture book about a little girl and her violin. The story begins with a little
girl named Hana Hashimoto that goes to her brothers and tells them her exciting news of joining
the school talent show. Her brothers laugh at her because Hana has just started learning how to
play her violin and is not yet very good. She goes inside to practice and starts thinking about the
previous summer when she picked up her first violin. Hana then thinks back to last summer went
and visited her grandfather Ojiichan in Japan. The story talks about how her grandfather used to
be a violinist in symphony orchestra in Kyoto. It also talks about how her grandfather was so
good he even played in front of the imperial family. Ojiichan played his violin every morning to
wake Hana up, and throughout the day he would play Morzart, Mendelssohn, or Bach on the
veranda. The story showed that her grandfather liked to play notes that sounded like different
25
things such as crickets, water droplets, fireflies, and more. Finally Hana thought back to every
When Hana left Tokyo and her grandfather to go back to the states and her parents she
decided that she wanted to play the violin. Hana practiced every day in front of her family, which
usually had her brothers running, her dog, and a picture of her grandfather. Finally the day of the
talent show came and Hana walked out onto the big stage all alone to play her violin. Hana felt
very scared until she saw her family, and best friends, then she remembered her grandfather
telling her to do her best. Hana took in a deep breath and started to play. First she played the
mother crow calling to her chicks, then she played a neighboring cat calling, the sound of rain on
paper umbrellas, buzzing bees, cows, mice, croaking frogs. Then she ended with a great big bow.
That night her family asked for an encore, and she made the funny animal noises on her violin as
they laughed. She was very surprised but happy that they enjoyed it so much. Hana sat playing
that night and hoped that next year she would be good enough to play Ojiichans favorite piece at
Critique NBGS -
This multicultural cultural book, Hana Hashimoto, Sixth Violin, found on the Notable
Books for a Global Society list follows the (NBGS) criteria impeccably. This book honors and
celebrates diversity as well as common bonds in humanity, as shown between Hana and her
grandfather Ojiichan. This book also includes members of a minority group in the United States,
which is the Japanese cultural group. As well as these this book also demonstrates an interesting
style of writing, as shown when Hana is listening to her grandfather play the violin, or is playing
herself during the talent show. This book has an appealing format, and it meets generally
26
accepted criteria of a good quality book. Overall this story met and went beyond the criteria of an
NBGS book.
Literary elements -
The illustrations in this book were very well done. The colors and hues were colorful but
not overpowering and blinding. There was good texture to the book, which was shown in what
looked like paint and brushstrokes. The illustrations were fun but not super exaggerated to where
they took up all of the attention away from the story. As well as the illustrations there were also a
few other literary elements that were beautifully done. There are multiple themes in this story
and they all stayed relatively consistent. The first theme could be shown as; dont give up on
something you want to do even if others are not supporting because you can achieve anything,
and listen to what your grandparents stories you never know when one can change your life.
The style of this story was also very good. The story was in a childrens picture book, which was
very fitting and appealing to the story and the eye. The voice of the story is mostly encouraging
and determined. The organization was also well done, it started with the purpose of the story,
then went back to the very beginning of the story just to work all the way to the conclusion. The
plot developed nicely in this story as well. First the story shows Hana and her violin, which is
followed by how she decided to pick up her first violin and her first real concert in front of an
audience. Finally the characters had good description and growth throughout the story. We watch
Hana learn to play her instrument and slowly get better and better. We also see Hana gain more
Critical reaction -
Hana Hashimoto, Sixth Violin has many strengths and some weaknesses. The books
27
strengths would include the illustrations, and the cute connection between grandfather and
granddaughter. The illustrator did a great job of showing beautiful pictures of what was
happening in Hanas life without overpowering the story or text. The pictures mingled and
flowed with the text in an overall tasteful manner. This book also had a wonderful connection
between grandfather and granddaughter that many students might be able to connect with. This
book also had some weaknesses such as it did not go into as much detail into what all her
grandfather did and how he learned to play. This book would have been more interesting for
older readers if it added just a little bit of background to the characters lives.
El Deafo
Bell, C., & Lasky, D. (2014). El Deafo. New York, NY: Amulet Books.
Summary -
The book El Deafo is a book written by Cece Bell and illustrated by Harry Abrams. This
story is in the form of a large graphic novel, and is written in first person from the perspective of
Cece. This is a true story written by the author and about the author.
This book is about a four year old girl named Cece. One day Cece gets sick with
meningitis and has to go spend many weeks in the hospital. As an outcome to Ceces meningitis
she ends up losing her hearing and becomes almost completely deaf. Cece has to go to some
hearing specialists and finally receives a hearing aid that allows her to somewhat hear people, the
only problem is she has to work a lot harder at understanding people. Almost everything that
Cece hears is jumbled and mixed up, so she learns the skill of reading lips. The book follows
Cece as she goes through first grade all the way through third grade. Like any other child we
watch Cece go through school trying to make friends and find her place. She finds it is hard to
28
find good friends and know when a relationship is not what it should be.
Throughout the summer she ends up losing her best friend Martha. She loses Martha
because Cece ends up hurting her eye while playing a game with Martha, and she gets worried
about hurting Cece. Cece also finds her first crush named Mike Miller over the summer. The
following school year she tries to fix her broken relationship with Martha and start a new one
with Mike. Cece ends up gaining somewhat of a relationship with her crush Mike which leads
Critique NBGS -
The multicultural cultural book, El Deafo, which is on the Notable Books for a Global
Society list follows the (NBGS) criteria perfectly. This book includes members of a minority
group, the deaf community, as the main focus. This book also focuses on celebrating diversity as
well as common bonds in humanity. Throughout the entire book Cece is learning that being
different actually makes her what she calls a superhero this book also brings in bonds between
friends and family even when times are tough. This book is in the form of a graphic novel so it
could be considered to be written in a unique style or language. Being in the form of a graphic
novel also caused this book to have an appealing format. Over all this book focuses heavily on
culture and different ways of living and thinking other than the social majority. This book fulfills
Literary elements -
The illustrations in this book were very well chosen and completed. The entire book was
illustrated in graphic novel form. Because the book was illustrated in a graphic novel the pictures
accompanied the text all throughout the story. The illustrator chose to have the characters in a
29
human bunny mix. Because of this decision to make the characters in the book half bunny it
added an emphasis to the hearing senses and the characters ears. The colors chosen in this book
were on the brighter side to show Ceces positive world around her. Cece is always surrounded
by bright colors and such as greens, oranges, and yellows. The illustrations were made of mostly
strait lines. The illustrations looked to be done with computer paint shop and did not have much
texture to them. The illustrations in the book mostly focused on the main characters rather than
the background, to show the main focus of the story. The illustrations were not only pictures in
this books. The text in this story also could be considered illustrations on their own. The words
in this graphic novel got bigger when being yelled, smaller when whispered, translucent when
she was losing her hearing, and blank when the main character, Cece, could not hear anything at
all. There are multiple themes in this story and they all stayed relatively consistent. The first
theme could be considered hearing, and another could be learning to make friends and finding
your place in the world. The style of this story was also very good, the story was in a graphic
novel format and was very entertaining and the way the author/illustrator chose to have the story
line. The voice of the story is mostly positive and cheerful but in some points, like when Cece
loses her hearing, it is sad and frustrated. The organization was also well done, it went from year
to year as Cece got older and did not skip any important details. The plot developed nicely in this
story as well. First the story shows a happy little girl, then she gets sick and loses her hearing this
is followed by a lot of learning appreciating herself and her hearing aid. Good description and
growth of the characters is also found in this story, almost all of the characters change and have
their place in the book as the story unfolds. The description and changes in the setting, also occur
every time Cece goes to a new place or a new grade in school, and each place it talks about has a
Critical reaction -
The story El Deafo has many strengths and even some weaknesses in it. The books
strengths would include the illustrations, the variation of audiences, and the insight to what it is
like to be deaf. The author/illustrator did a great job of adding fun and entertaining illustrations
the story. These illustrations only intensified the good story, and added depth to what the words
were saying. Another strength the book had was the how the book focused toward a younger
audience but still was entertaining for older readers. There was good language and humor that a
wide range of ages could enjoy. Finally the book did a great job of showing insight to what it is
like for someone to be deaf and what it is like for the family and friends of the deaf individual.
This book also had some weaknesses such as it did not show much to the medical side of Ceces
hearing loss. I know that she was very young and it was from her perspective so it didnt focus
much on the medical side, but it would have been nice to see a bit more than it showed.
Honors:
We picked two books as honors in this assignment, the first honor book chosen was El
Deafo. We thought this book should be one of our honor books because it appeals to students, it
has many uses in the classroom, and shows excellent in following the NBGS criteria. All of the
books read for this assignment could have classroom applications connected with it, be appealing
to students and show excellence in following the NBGS criteria, but this book was one of three
that stood out above the others, and needed to be recognized as such.
El Deafo is a good honor book because it could be very appealing to students. This book
is a graphic novel, so it could potentially be appealing to nonreaders and readers while teaching
both a bit about deafness. This book could also be appealing to students because it shows real life
31
situations where a young kids deal with friendship problems and insecurities. El Deafo can be
used in the classroom to support many different lessons. This book would be a good trade book
for school use because it is an informational book that is fun and entertaining for students, but
still tells them about the world around them (Saul & Dieckman, 2005). One lesson could be
about different types of literature, another could be about meningitis or deafness, and a third
lesson could be about knowing the difference between a good and bad relationship. Each of these
lessons could be covered using El Deafo. Finally this book is one of our honor books because it
shows excellence in following the NBGS criteria. This book is written in a unique style or
language because it is in the form of a graphic novel. Being in the form of a graphic novel also
caused this book to have an appealing format for young students, or students that are not yet a
big fan of reading. Over all this book focuses heavily on culture and different ways of living and
thinking other than the social majority. This book fulfills all of the NBGS criteria. This book
includes members of a minority group, the deaf community, in the United States. This book
focuses on celebrating diversity as well as common bonds in humanity. Throughout the entire
book Cece is learning that being different is not a bad thing and that it can actually make her
special and great. This book also brings in bonds between friends and family especially when
times are tough. Such as shown between Cece and her family when she first loses her hearing
and later on in life with her best friends when Cece gets hurt. This book is overall very well
written and inspiring book that deserved the title of an honor book if not a winner.
The second book we chose for honors was Hana Hashimoto, sixth violin. This book
should be one of our honor books because like the other; it can appeal to students in multiple
different ways. This book could also be used in the classroom for multiple different lessons and
teaching purposes. Finally this book shows excellent in following the NBGS criteria beyond
32
what some of the others showed. Overall this book was another great story that needed to be
This book, Hana Hashimoto, sixth violin, could be appealing to students because it is a
beautiful picture book that is appealing to the eye, and because it is a very uplifting story that
shows that you can do whatever you set your mind to. This book is also has many applications in
the classrooms, over all this book could be in a lesson about Japanese culture, or about music, or
even about setting your mind to something and not giving up even if people tell you that you
cant. Finally this book shows excellence when looking at the NBGS criteria. This book showed
cultural authenticity in its pictures about Hanas grandfathers home. The story honors and
celebrates diversity as well as common bonds in humanity, as shown between Hana and her
grandfather Ojiichan. Throughout the story you mostly see members of the Japanese cultural,
which could be seen as a minority group in the United States. This book also shows unique
language and style throughout the performance and musical portion of the story. Overall this
book is a wonderful story that was very well written and illustrated.
Winner:
We chose The Red Pencil as our winner because it exceeded the expectation and criteria
of the NBGS. The committee is on the search for a book that promotes the understanding of
culture and vanishing the stereotypes that many people proceed cultures to have. This book
touched on every component as well as created a creative and engaging book for a wide variety
of readers. In our textbook Tunnel states, Literature can be one of the most powerful tools for
combating the ignorance that breeds xenophobic and judgmental behaviors (Tunnel, et., al.
2016, p. 202). This quote is the perfect example of what this book exemplifies. Introducing this
book into a classroom would be beneficial to students. This book does not only display a great
33
story, it offers educational features that could be taught in a classroom. To begin with, this book
could be used to teach different types of literature. This book is a verse novel, which many kids
might not be familiar with. This book could be used to identify the form of writing and the
positives and negatives about this style. After reading this book I found myself very interested
in the Sudanese culture and I wanted to expand my learning. This book is very informational and
will introduce a new culture into the classroom, if not already. This book would appeal to
students because it is a relatable novel that discusses real life issues. This book discusses real
issues that are happening right now around the world. This allows for critical thinking and
analyzing the world. This book also enables a reader to connect with the book because it is very
personal. I also think that students would appeal to this book because it is dealing with Amiras
strive towards educated. This may change the minds of many students that dread going to school.
Children all over the world do not get the opportunity to go to school, and many want to. This
may broaden their thinking and they may realize that they are lucky they are able to get an
education.
As you may already tell, I am passionate about this book because this book offers endless
amount of knowledge while reading this book, such as the Sudanese culture and the obstacles
that they are overcoming. As Amira turned twelve years old, she was seen as an adult, which
meant she was treated as an adult. Amira also received a Toob, which is a traditional cloth that
covers the body. These are a couple of example from the text that offer a small glimpse into the
Sudanese culture. Amira was also not allowed to get an education because she was expected to
marry and have children. This is a great topic to introduce into a classroom. Many may think that
sexism doesnt exist, although it exists all throughout the world. Amira has to fight for her
34
education and learn how to write behind her mother back. She is so determined and dreams of
becoming a teacher. This book could teach children about never giving up on their dreams and to
work hard. She wants to go to school and get an education, but she is not allowed to. It is so
frustrating listening to Amiras story because the reader experiences her struggles with her. The
story is so raw and real that I felt like I was with Amira. Her village is attacked and everyone has
to flee with village and they are left with nothing. Her father passes away and Amira and her
family are torn. This book promotes the understanding of culture, race, sexism, and values. The
book also enhances the learning of a different culture and allows for appreciation of that culture.
I would love to share this book with my classroom because it allows for so much reflection and
understanding of another culture. The book also portrays cultural accuracy and authenticity.
Andrea Davis was not from Africa or associated with the Sudanese culture, she did a
phenomenal job with this book. She did her research and created authentic book in my opinion.
The book also shows problem solving such as when Amira is arguing with her mother, learning
the alphabet, and also running away. In each one of these moments Amira experiences stopping
blocks where she has to overcome and problem solve. She became a leader in her own life and
decided she was going to leave and get an education on her own. The book is rich in cultural
detail and honors diversity. This book has an appealing format and meets the criteria perfectly.
This is now one of my favorite book and I think everyone should have a copy.
Conclusion:
This assignment allows us to use the information we have learned and incorporate it into
our classroom and our daily lives. First of all this assignment could be connected to multiracial,
or multicultural learning. It could be linked to what we have been learning about promoting
understanding and appreciation of different people, cultures, and sexualities across the world.
35
This assignment could also be connected to class because the underlining goal of both is to gain
recognition of different cultures and types of people around the world. All of these link to what
we are doing in class and are important because many people are not open to new ideas and ways
of life outside their own. As stated in Childrens Literature Briefly Xenophobia, the mistrust or
fear of people who are strangers or foreigners is in part responsible for our worldwide inability to
live together in peace, affording one another equal opportunities (Tunnel, et., at. 2012, p. 201).
Lastly this assignment could connect to what we are learning in class about different books to
share with our students. This project has shown us multiple nonfiction trade books that we can
use in class to construct knowledge in a fun, engaging, and nontraditional way (Saul &
Dieckman, 2005). This project showed us many books about different cultures and lifestyles. All
of these books could potentially connect with some students and expand other students way of
There were a lot of information we learned from this assignment overall. A great amount
of what was learned came from inside the books themselves, such as about transgender teens,
and writing styles of the Japanese Culture. As well as what was learned inside the book there was
also a great deal learned when looking at all the books as a whole. People could look at all eight
of these different books; Brown Girl Dreaming, The red pencil, Little Melba and her Trombone,
This Day in June, Separate is never equal: Sylvia Mendez & her family's fight for desegregation,
El Deafo. Hana Hashimoto, sixth violin, and Beyond magenta: Transgender teens speak out, and
see they are all about different cultures, thoughts, and ways of life. Teachers, parents, and
students could all use these books to gain; understanding, acceptance, and recognition about
people different from themselves. These books also taught about different views that we as
teachers need to consider and keep in mind when working with our students. These books
36
showed first-hand how not everyone is the same or going through the same challenges, so
teachers must be understanding and ready for anything a child might be going through.
There are a lot of things that still need to be learned when it comes to the books from the
Notable Books for a Global Society, and how to pick good books for our classrooms. All of these
books are very different, and there is a lot to learn from each of them. There is also a lot for us to
figure out when it comes to which books to bring into our classrooms and which ones are good
for the age range we are teaching. There are a lot of awards like the Notable Books for a Global
Society, and so we need to figure out how to decide which award books to have in our
classrooms and to what extent. The list of what we, as students, still have yet to learn is extensive
but over all these are the things we have yet to learn compared to this assignment.
If we could do the assignment over we would have changed a few things. First of all we
would have added more meeting times to work together on the paper. During this paper there
was only a few times that schedules aligned allowing us to meet, and it would have been nice if
we would have found more times we were free. Secondly we would have tried to ask more
questions about the writing rubric because there was some things that took a lot of discussion on
to figure out what was required and what all we needed to add in order to get full points on the
assignment.
37
Bibliography
Bell, C., & Lasky, D. (2014). El Deafo. New York, NY: Amulet Books.
Kuklin, S. (2014). Beyond magenta: Transgender teens speak out. Candlewick Press.
Lin, Grace. (2009). Where the mountain meets the moon. New York: Little, Brown and Co.,
Pinkney, A. D., & Evans, S. (2014). The Red Pencil. Little, Brown Books for Young Readers.
Russell-Brown, K., & Morrison, F. (2014). Little Melba and her Trombone. Lee & Low Books.
Saul, E. W., & Donna Dieckman. (2005). Theory and Research into Practice: Choosing and
Retrieved from
http://searchit.libraries.wsu.edu/WSU:WSU_everything:TN_gale_ofa149950954
Tonatiuh, D. (2014). Separate is never equal: Sylvia Mendez & her family's fight for
Tunnell, M. O., Jacobs, J. S., Young, T. A., & Bryan, G. (2012). Childrens literature, briefly.
Uegaki, C., & Leng, Q. (2014). Hana Hashimoto, sixth violin. Toronto, ON: Kids Can Press.