Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ScienceDirect
Original Article
Ming Liu a, Ken Gu a,*, Thomas K.S. Wong b, Min Z. Luo a, Men Y. Chan a
a
School of Health Sciences, Macao Polytechnic Institute, Rua De Luis Gonzaga Gomes, Macao
b
Knowledge Transfer and Consultancy Company Limited, Hong Kong
Article history: Objective: This study aimed at investigation of the stress perceived by Macao nursing stu-
Received 29 December 2014 dents in the clinical learning environment.
Received in revised form Methods: A cross-sectional research was designed and 203 nursing students in a public
21 April 2015 higher education institute were recruited. The Stressors in Nursing Students Scale-Chinese
Accepted 24 April 2015 Version (SINS-CN) was used to measure nursing students' stress. Data analysis includes
Available online 14 May 2015 descriptive analysis and analysis of variance.
Results: The overall SINS-CN mean score was 3.33 (SD 0.49), while the scores for different
dimensions were: clinical, 3.44 (SD 0.54), education, 3.35 (SD 0.62), finance and time,
3.31 (SD 0.72), confidence, 3.21 (SD 0.60), and personal problems, 3.03 (SD 0.68).
Among 10 most common stressors, four belong to the clinical dimension, four to the ed-
ucation dimension, one to the confidence dimension, and one to the finance & time
dimension. Analysis for factors associated with stress indicated that no statistical signifi-
cance was found in most demographic variables, except year two students' stress scores
were significantly lower than those of students in other years (p values were between 0.000
and 0.026).
Conclusions: Macao nursing students, to some extent, experienced stress in clinical learning
environment and the stress level was higher than that of Hong Kong nursing students. The
most common stressors were related to clinical and educational dimensions. The study
suggests that teaching and learning modalities and the workload of nursing students
should be reviewed.
Copyright 2015, Chinese Nursing Association. Production and hosting by Elsevier
(Singapore) Pte Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://
creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
*
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: kengu@ipm.edu.mo (K. Gu).
Peer review under responsibility of Chinese Nursing Association.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijnss.2015.04.013
2352-0132/Copyright 2015, Chinese Nursing Association. Production and hosting by Elsevier (Singapore) Pte Ltd. This is an open access
article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f n u r s i n g s c i e n c e s 2 ( 2 0 1 5 ) 1 2 8 e1 3 3 129
a previous study and the internal consistency with Cronbach's Year of students
a is >0.7 [20]. The original SINS-CN is a 43-item, self- Year 1 54 26.6
administered questionnaire covering clinical, confidence, ed- Year 2 53 26.1
Year 3 53 26.1
ucation and financial sources of stress [20]. The questionnaire
Year 4 43 21.2
uses a five-point Likert scale from 1 being not at all stressful to
5 being extremely stressful [20]. The validated version among Religions
No religion 173 85.3
Macao nursing students consists of 43-item with five di-
Christians 14 6.9
mensions with Cronbach's a 0.96 for overall scale and
Catholics 8 3.9
0.67e0.94 for sub-dimensions [21]. A test-retest reliability with Buddhists 8 3.9
2-week interval was 0.82 for the overall instrument and
Parents' marriage status
0.70e0.88 for the sub-dimensions [21].
Married 173 85.2
Single 11 5.4
2.5. Data collection/procedure Divorced 19 9.4
have attributed to the level of stress reported in the results. expectations of the students' performance, particularly on the
The multicultural and complex clinical environment certainly part of clinical preceptors [25,26]. A special training program is
had an impact on the students' stress. As mentioned in the needed to equip clinical preceptors' knowledge and skills in
introduction, students could have felt challenged and stressed precepting students in clinical environment.
by the multi-language clinical environment. Leong stated that The other most common stressors were related to the
even the students majoring in languages in Macao, e.g. heavy workload. The findings supported those from the
Translation and Interpretation majors, have to cope with studies in Hong Kong and Taiwan [27,28]. This might be a
three formidable languages and several dialects [23]. It sug- result of the heavy curriculum with too many clinical place-
gests that school should help students build up their language ment hours compared to those in western countries. Ac-
ability by employing more strategies, e.g. adding Portuguese cording to the California Board of Registered Nursing, nursing
leaning in the curriculum, facilitating mandarin leaning and students in the United States are only required to complete
practicing opportunities. about 1000 hours of clinical practice before graduation [29];
Among the top ten common stressors ranked by Macao the University of Notre Dame in Australia requires 1240 hours
nursing students, most of them were clinical and education of clinical placement [30]. The 4-year Bachelor of Nursing
related stressors. Particularly, the first and second most program in Macao was designed with 160 learning credits,
common stressors encountered by students were due to stress among which 46 credits (1840 hours) are clinical placement
from the clinical dimension, such as Fear of making a mistake [31]. In each clinical unit, students are required to submit at
in clinical placement (M 4.00, SD 0.93) and Having too least three assignments including a clinical learning plan,
much clinical responsibility (M 3.86, SD 0.71). These clinical reflections and case study reports. In addition, both
findings are consistent with the previous findings by Wilson clinical supervision nurses and academic teachers are
and by Mahat [24,25]. The high stress scores could be a result required to assess the performance of each student, which
of inadequate preparation and lack of confidence. Students might have caused additional stress to students. Considering
often worry that any mistake they make will affect their grade the present study findings, the researchers suggest that the
and even their status. According to the currently implemented teaching and learning modalities and the workload of nursing
clinical placement regulations in the studied school, a student students should be reviewed.
who makes any mistake in invasive procedures, adminis-
tering oral medications, or procedures causing any injury to 4.2. Factors associated with stress
clients, would be suspended from his/her clinical placement.
The student is then asked back to the school laboratory to Among all demographic variables, only year of study was
practice the skills until judged satisfactory by the School found to have a significant effect on students' stress. Post-hoc
Pedagogical Committee, whereupon the student is allowed to analysis demonstrated that the second year students claimed
resume his/her clinical practice. Besides, the students' fear to experience less stress than their peers in the other three
could have been exaggerated by the preceptors' high class groups both for the overall stress scale and sub-
Table 3 e Comparison between year groups with overall SINS-CN and sub-dimensions.
Scale and sub-dimensions Year 1 (n 54) Year 2 (n 53) Year 3 (n 53) Year 4 (n 43) F p
Mean score (SD)
Overall scale 3.57 (0.54) 2.98a (0.51) 3.46 (0.37) 3.37 (0.44) 5.63 0.021
Clinical 3.58 (0.62) 2.99a (0.54) 3.57 (0.42) 3.48 (0.43) 9.33 0.000
Confidence 3.39 (0.63) 2.98a (0.62) 3.24 (.46) 3.21 (0.60) 7.74 0.000
Finance and time 3.31 (0.74) 2.97a (0.72) 3.36 (0.62) 3.59 (0.75) 3.27 0.022
Education 3.34 (0.52) 3.02a (0.71) 3.34 (0.52) 3.40 (0.60) 4.80 0.003
Personal problem 3.25 (0.78) 2.78a (0.65) 3.03 (0.56) 3.04 (0.67) 3.14 0.026
a
p < 0.05.
132 i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f n u r s i n g s c i e n c e s 2 ( 2 0 1 5 ) 1 2 8 e1 3 3
dimensions (p < 0.05, Table 3). This result is inconsistent with future to conduct a longitudinal study on a cohort of students,
the findings of the previous studies reported from other and if possible, complementary work with a qualitative
countries. A study conducted by Rajesh Kumar in Iran found procedure.
that the first year students had the highest level of stress
compared with other senior year students [32]. She explained
that the higher stress level experienced by first year students
could be a result of being placed in an unfamiliar environ-
Acknowledgment
ment, separation from the families and the demand of form-
The authors gratefully acknowledge the valuable contribu-
ing new social groups apart from academic pressures and
tions of Dr. Joanna Radwanska-Williams in the preparation of
clinical training. Interestingly, a study conducted in Malaysia
this manuscript. The project was sponsored by the Macao
found that second year students in fact claimed to be more
Polytechnic Institute Research Fund (Code: RP/ESS-03/2012).
stressed than other year groups [33]. It is therefore appropriate
to postulate year of study as an independent factor that may
affect the nursing students' experience and perception of Conflict of interest
stress, though the effect is very much dependent on curricular
context. Reviewing the curriculum design and organization of The authors declare no conflict of interest regarding this
clinical placement in the studied school, the researchers research and paper.
noted that no special feature was found in year two study
except more extra-curricular activities than in other years of
references
the program. These activities might have helped students
enhance their adaptation to and management of the stress
induced in the clinical environment. In view of this uncertain
[1] Kohler JM, Munz DC, Grawitch MJ. Test of a dynamic stress
association, we recommend a longitudinal cohort study be
model for organizational change: do males and females
conducted to assess the possible changes of stress perception require different models? Appl Psychol Int Rev
of Macao nursing students and the associated factors. To 2006;55(2):168e91.
further understand the student's experience and perception, a [2] Pulido-Martos M, Augusto-Landa JM, Lopez-Zafra E. Sources
qualitative study including, but not limited to the use of in- of stress in nursing students: a systematic review of
depth interview and story-telling should be carried out quantitative studies. Int Nurs Rev 2011;59(1):15e25.
either together with the longitudinal study or on its own. [3] Lim J, Bogossian F, Ahern K. Stress and coping in Australian
nurses: a systematic review. Int Nurs Rev 2010;57:22e31.
[4] Pryjmachuk S, Richards DA. Mental health nursing students
differ from other nursing students: some observations from
5. Limitations a study on stress and coping. Int J Ment Health Nurs
2007;16(6):390e402.
This study used cross-sectional design, so the data were [5] Chang EM, Hancock KM, Johnston A, Daly J, Jackson D. Role
collected at a single time point. The pattern, consistency and stress in nurses: review of related factors and strategies for
moving forward. Nurs Health Sci 2005;7(1):57e65.
intensity of stress over time were not assessed. Future study
[6] Al-Kandari F, Vidal V. Correlation of the health-promoting
should incorporate a longitudinal cohort design to improve
lifestyle, enrollment level, and academic performance of
the present research methodology. In addition, as previously College of Nursing students in Kuwait. Nurs Health Sci
mentioned, Macao SAR has two higher nursing education in- 2007;9(2):112e9.
stitutions, one charity-funded and another government- [7] Deary I, Watson R, Hogston R. A longitudinal cohort study of
funded. This study setting was confined only to the burnout and attrition in nursing students. J Adv Nurs
government-funded institution. Therefore, generalization of 2003;43(1):71e81.
[8] Jones MC, Johnson DW. Distress, stress and coping in first-
the results should be cautioned. Dimensions of SINS-CN
year student nurses. J Adv Nurs 1997;26(3):475e82.
questionnaire does not address local issues such as multi-
[9] Beck DL, Hackett MB, Srivastava R, McKim E, Rockwell B.
culturalism and language issue, a modification and validation Perceived level and sources of stress in university
of scale study may be needed. professional schools. J Nurs Educ 1997;36(4):180e6.
[10] Lindop E. A comparative study of stress between pre- and
post-Project 2000 students. J Adv Nurs 1999;29(4):967e73.
6. Conclusions [11] Burnard P, Edwards D, Kim B, Thaibah H, Tothova V,
Baldacchino D, et al. A comparative, longitudinal study of
stress in student nurses in five countries: Albania, Brunei,
Macao nursing students, to some extent, experienced stress in the Czech Republic, Malta and Wales. Nurse Educ Today
clinical learning environment and the stress level was higher 2008;28(2):134e45.
than that of Hong Kong nursing students. The most common [12] Timmins F, Kaliszer M. Aspects of nurse education
stressors were related to clinical and educational dimensions. programmes that frequently cause stress to nursing students
Except for the variable year of study, all other demographic e fact finding sample survey. Nurse Educ Today
2002;22:203e11.
variables did not show any statistically significant effect on
[13] Brown H, Edelmann R. Project 2000: a study of expected and
students' stress. Comparative results analysis indicated that
experienced stressors and support reported by students and
year two students experienced less stress than other peer qualified nurses. J Adv Nurs 2000;31(4):857e64.
groups. To further understand the student's experience of [14] Vong LY, Iu CM, Chan CY, Un LB. Nursing students' clinical
stress in learning, the researchers consider it necessary in the practice stress. Macau J Nurs 2003;2(1):27e9.
i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f n u r s i n g s c i e n c e s 2 ( 2 0 1 5 ) 1 2 8 e1 3 3 133
[15] Li RL. A survey study of the stress of nursing students in [24] Wilson M. Nursing students' perspective of learning in a
practice period and their coping strategies in a nursing clinical setting. J Nurs Educ 1994;33(2):81e6.
college in Macau. Unpublished Master's thesis. Library of [25] Mahat G. Stress and coping: Junior baccalaureate nursing
Macau University of Science and Technology; 2013. students in clinical settings. Nurs Forum 1998;33(1):11e9.
[16] Liu M, Yin L, Zhu MX, Yuan HB. Lived experiences of clinical [26] Liu M, Zhu MX, Da HX, Yuan HB. Clinical nursing preceptors'
preceptors: a phenomenology study. J Nurs Educ Today perceptions of effective characteristics of clinical teaching: a
2010;30(8):804e8. qualitative study. J Macao Polytech Inst 2009;3:18e27.
[17] Yung E. Student engagement survey 2014. Macao Polytechnic [27] Chan C, So W, Fong D. Hong Kong baccalaureate nursing
Institute (unpublished report) 2014: 4e10. students' stress and their coping strategies in clinical
[18] Statistics and Census Service (DSEC in Portuguese). practice. J Prof Nurs 2009;25(5):307e13.
Demographic statistics. Government of Macao special [28] Sheu S, Lin HS, Hwang SL. Perceived stress and physio-
administrative region. Available from: http://www.dsec.gov. psycho-social status of nursing students during their initial
mo/Statistic/Demographic/ period of clinical practice: the effect of coping behaviors. Int J
PreliminaryResultsofthe2011PopulationCensus/ Nurs Stud 2002;39(2):165e75.
PreliminaryResultsofthe2011PopulationCensus.aspx; 2013 [29] The California Board of Registered Nursing. Professional and
[retrieved 20.01.14]. vocational regulations: division 1426. Required curriculum;
[19] Liu M, Lam B, Fong P, Yuan HB. Nursing shortage: the facts prior approval. California: The California Board of Registered
and strategies in Macao society. Online J Issues Nurs Nursing. Available from: http://www.rn.can.gov [retrieved
2012;18(1):1e9. 28.03.14].
[20] Watson R, Chen Y, Ip M, Smith G, Wong T, Deary I. The [30] NC Board of Nursing. Clinical practicum. Available from:
structure of stress: Confirmatory factor analysis of a Chinese http://www.nd.edu.au/broome/schools/nursing/clinical-
version of the stressors in Nursing Students Scale (SINS). practicum [retrieved 06.04.14].
Nurse Educ Today 2013;33(2):160e5. [31] Government Bulletin of Macao SAR. Boetim official da regiao
[21] Liu M, Gu Q, Wong KS, Watson R. Validation of stressors in administrativa especial, de Macau-1 Serie 2013: 610e4 [in
nursing students scale-Chinese version (SINS-CN) in a Chinese and Portuguese].
population of Macao nursing students. Chin Nurs Res [32] Rajesh Kumar N. Stress and coping strategies among nursing
2015;1(1):25e30. students. Nurs Midwifery Res J 2011;7(4):141e51.
[22] Watson R, Deary I, Thompson D, Li G. A study of stress and [33] Gurbinder Kaur JS, Hamidah H, Blackman I, Wotton K,
burnout in nursing students in Hong Kong: a questionnaire Belan I. Perceived stress related to nursing education and its
survey. Int J Nurs Stud 2008;45(10):1534e42. influence on nursing students' academic and clinical
[23] Leong SL. English language teaching in Macau: sharing, performance. Med Health 2011;6(2):86e97.
reflecting and innovating. Macau Res 2003;16:212e28.