Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FAILURE
MCL2 11
DE PARTME N T OF MECHANICA L E NG IN E E RIN G
IIT DE L HI
Failure
Failure can mean a part:
has separated into two or more pieces;
has become permanently distorted, thus ruining its
geometry;
has had its reliability downgraded; or
has had its function compromised, whatever the reason.
A designer speaking of failure can mean any or all
of these possibilities.
1
22-08-2017
Failure Examples
2
22-08-2017
3
22-08-2017
Static Strength
Ideally, in designing any machine element, the engineer
should have available the results of a great many strength
tests of the particular material chosen.
These tests should be made on specimens having the same
heat treatment, surface finish, and size as the element the
engineer proposes to design; and the tests should be made
under exactly the same loading conditions as the part will
experience in service.
4
22-08-2017
5
22-08-2017
Static Strength
To design using only published values of yield strength,
ultimate strength, percentage reduction in area, and
percentage elongation
How can one use such meager data to design against both
static and dynamic loads, two- and three-dimensional stress
states, high and low temperatures, and very large and very
small parts?
Methods are needed to safely and efficiently use published
strength values for a variety of situations
Stress Concentration
Localized increase of stress near
discontinuities
Kt is Theoretical (Geometric) Stress
Concentration Factor
6
22-08-2017
7
22-08-2017
Strength S
n
Stress
http://pubs.sciepub.com/ajcea/2/1/6/image/fig5.png
8
22-08-2017
9
22-08-2017
Failure Theories
The tension test is uniaxial (thats simple) and elongations
are largest in the axial direction, so strains can be measured
and stresses inferred up to failure.
Just what is important:
a critical stress, a critical strain, a critical energy?
10
22-08-2017
11
22-08-2017
12
22-08-2017
Sy / 2
n
max
13
22-08-2017
14
22-08-2017
Case 2: A 0 B
For this case, 1 = A and 3 = B
Eq. reduces to A B Sy
Case 3: 0 A B
For this case, 1 = 0 and 3 = B
Eq. reduces to B Sy
Case 2: A 0 B
A B Sy
Case 3: 0 A B
B Sy
15
22-08-2017
16
22-08-2017
17
22-08-2017
18
22-08-2017
Substituting for av
1+ + +
= =
3 2
19
22-08-2017
= + /
20
22-08-2017
21
22-08-2017
22
22-08-2017
DE Theory Compared to
Experimental Data
Plot von Mises stress on principal
stress axes to compare to
experimental data (and to other
failure theories)
DE curve is typical of data
Note that typical equates to a 50%
reliability from a design perspective
Commonly used for analysis
situations
MSS theory useful for design
situations where higher reliability is
desired
23
22-08-2017
24
22-08-2017
Mohr Theory
Not all materials have compressive strengths equal to their
corresponding tensile values.
For example, the yield strength of magnesium alloys in compression
may be as little as 50 percent of their yield strength in tension.
The ultimate strength of gray cast irons in compression varies from 3 to
4 times greater than the ultimate tensile strength.
Mohr Theory
Some materials have compressive strengths different
from tensile strengths
Mohr theory is based on three simple tests: tension,
compression, and shear
25
22-08-2017
Coulomb-Mohr Theory
Curved failure curve is difficult to determine analytically
Coulomb-Mohr theory simplifies to linear failure envelope using only
tension and compression tests (dashed circles)
26
22-08-2017
27
22-08-2017
28
22-08-2017
29
22-08-2017
30
22-08-2017
Brittle-Coulomb-Mohr
31
22-08-2017
Modified Mohr
32
22-08-2017
For brittle
Mohr theory is best, but difficult to use
Brittle Coulomb-Mohr is very conservative in 4th quadrant
Modified Mohr is still slightly conservative in 4th quadrant, but closer to
typical
33
22-08-2017
34