What would Heaven on EarthTM look like?

We would take many of the common conceptions from the imaginary heaven
and attempt to create them here in reality. For example:

x No one in the imaginary heaven would get sick. In the same way, in our real Heaven on EarthTM, medical
technology will cure all diseases, reverse the effects of aging, etc. WHY WON’T GOD
x No one in the imaginary heaven would be an amputee. In the same way, in our real Heaven on Earth TM, we should
find a way using stem cells, limb cloning, nanotech or prosthetics to recreate the limbs of amputees at a level
equal to or exceeding their natural limbs.
x In the imaginary heaven, everyone has eternal life. In the same way, in our real Heaven on EarthTM, people will not
die. Or they will live far, far longer than we do today, without the debilitating effects of aging. HEAL AMPUTEES?
x In the imaginary heaven, no one would be poor. Starvation, malnutrition, etc. would not exist. Everyone in the
imaginary heaven would have identical "wealth" -- the same access to everything good about heaven. In the
same way, in our real Heaven on EarthTM, we would find solutions to global poverty and the concentration of The Most Important Question We Can Ask About God
wealth. Everyone on the planet would have equal access to the world's wealth and the same standard of living.
x In the imaginary heaven, no one would have to work. Each person would have true economic freedom. In the Please read the full text online at www.whywontgodhealamputees.com for full text and links
same way, in our real Heaven on EarthTM, we should eliminate work and allow everyone to go on perpetual
vacation.
x In the imaginary heaven there would be no pollution, extinction, habitat loss, Global Warming, etc. In the same
Table of Contents
way, in our real Heaven on EarthTM, we would solve all of these problems. Introduction
x Chapter 1 The line is drawn 2
x In the imaginary heaven there would be no crime, and "bad" people would be cast into hell. In the same way, in
x Chapter 2 The mystery of God 3
our real Heaven on EarthTM, we would eliminate crime with a much swifter and stronger criminal justice system.
x Chapter 3 The Standard Model of God 5
x And so on...
x Chapter 4 Facing the paradox 7
Section 1 - prayer
Is it possible to create Heaven on Earth? Yes, it is. We are already heading in that direction to some degree. For example,
x Chapter 5 * Why Won't God Heal Amputees? 8
medical researchers are busy ending disease and lengthening life. If we made Heaven on Earth a point of focus for our
society, we could greatly accelerate the process. We would also find a way to spread the benefits of medical technology x Chapter 6 Why do you need health insurance? 18
inexpensively and universally to everyone on the planet. x Chapter 7 Why can't you move mountains? 25
x Chapter 8 Why do bad things happen to good people? 29
x Chapter 9 Who gets to go to the prom? 34
There are a number of different ways that we can create Heaven on Earth. For example, we may be able to use
x Chapter 10 Why do battlefield prayers sound so convincing? 37
capitalism to get there. It's not clear, however, that capitalism is up to the task. After all:
x Chapter 11 Reviewing the evidence about prayer 40
Section 2 - The Bible
x The United States is one of the most capitalistic countries in the world. Yet, as noted above, half the kids in the 48
x Chapter 12 Who wrote the Bible?
United States can't afford lunch. 48
x Chapter 13 Why does God love slavery?
x It is also the case that capitalism, in its modern form, has been in place for over a century. Yet, as noted above, 54
x Chapter 14 Why does God love animal sacrifice?
there are still three billion people on the planet -- half the world's population -- living in startling poverty. Capitalism 58
x Chapter 15 Why is God so sexist?
does not seem to be very quick in getting the job done either. 62
x Chapter 16 Why does God massacre millions of children?
x China is rapidly taking on capitalistic tendencies. Yet we know that many Chinese workers work in conditions that Reviewing the evidence about the Bible 64
in America could be compared to slavery. The number of hours worked and the meager amount earned gives x Chapter 17
anyone in America with a conscience a reason to pause and question what is going on. Section 3 - Jesus
x Chapter 18 Was Jesus the son of God? 71
x Chapter 19 Why didn't Jesus move a mountain? 71
If capitalism can adapt to the challenge, great. If not, let's invent something new. We are intelligent people, and, when we
x Chapter 20 Why doesn't Jesus appear to each of us? 77
put our minds to it, we are good at solving problems. Human beings are fundamentally good, and none of us like the fact
x Chapter 21 Why do we eat Jesus? 79
that three billion people live in such crushing poverty.
x Chapter 22 Why do so many children live in poverty? 81
x Chapter 23 Was Jesus' coming prophesized? 83
If we design our economy properly, the advent of robots, nanotech and other advanced technologies will give us the 87
x Chapter 24 Why does Jesus need your money?
opportunity to create Heaven on Earth in the very near future. In the process we should be able to completely eliminate 88
x Chapter 25 Reviewing the evidence about Jesus
poverty, raise the standard of living for everyone and give each person on the planet true economic freedom.
What it means
x Chapter 26 Why did I write this book? 93
But that will happen only if we make the conscious decision to do it, and then we follow through.
x Chapter 27 When we die, we die 97
x Chapter 28 Goodness, Morality and the Ten Commandments 106
It is time for the human race to grow up and embrace reality. It is time for us to discard our imaginary gods and move to
x Chapter 29 In God We Trust 110
the next level of our intellectual evolution. It is time to understand our place in the universe and take control of our destiny.
x Chapter 30 Love your neighbor as yourself 111
It is time to create Heaven on Earth for everyone. There is no God, and there are so many good things that we can
x Chapter 31 The Meaning of Life 112
accomplish as a species. Let's make the most of the opportunity that the universe has given us.
x Chapter 32 The future of the human race 115
THE END

116 1
Chapter 1 - The line is drawn
It would have to be a teacher's worst nightmare.
Imagine that you are a high school English teacher. You are standing at the front of the classroom working through the
day's lesson. Perhaps you and your students are studying verb conjugation, or analyzing one of Shakespeare's plays. It is
another normal day in the American education system, and you have a lot of material to cover.
Then the sound fills your classroom. Gunshots. And screaming. A gunman has entered the school and is shooting at
people as he makes his way down the hallway toward your classroom.
What would you do?
If you were English teacher Neva Rogers at Red Lake high school, you would take immediate action. You would shut off
the lights in the classroom. You would close and lock the classroom door. [ref] You would tell your students to crouch in a
corner of the classroom to get out of harm's way. Then you would stand in the middle of the room and begin praying to
God. According to student witnesses, Ms. Rogers prayed, "God be with us. God help us."
The gunman walks to Neva Rogers' classroom door and finds it locked. He shoots out the glass panel next to the door
and it explodes in a shower of tiny crystalline fragments. The gunman reaches in through the hole he has created, unlocks
the door and shoves it out of the way to enter the classroom. Dressed completely in black and measuring six feet tall, he
is a huge, hulking apparition.
He crosses the threshold of the classroom and looks at Ms. Rogers as she prays. He is armed with a massive 12-gauge
shotgun. He raises the gun with both hands so it is pointing straight at Rogers' head.
What should God do?
What do you think God should do in a situation like this? Step back for a moment and look at this from God's perspective.
God is sitting on his magnificent throne in heaven. God is all-knowing, so he is certainly watching Red Lake high school
as events unfold. He hears Neva Rogers' prayers, and sees the gunman pointing the shotgun at her head. Jesus has
promised that God will help, and Jesus is sitting at God's right hand.
Clearly a line has been drawn. On one side of the line is pure evil -- a sixteen-year-old who is obviously insane. On the
other side is a deeply devoted, 62-year-old woman of unbending faith in God. This is a showdown between good and evil
if there ever was one.
Think of all of the possibilities that an all-powerful God has at his disposal. Perhaps the easiest thing would be to strike the
gunman with a freak heart attack, aneurism or stroke right then and there. Hundreds of people die of heart attacks in the
United States every day, so if God struck him with a heart attack it would be completely undetectable. Non-believers
would chalk it up to coincidence, but God's followers would understand what really happened.
If God has a desire to be a bit more spectacular, there are other possibilities. For example, he could cause an earthquake.
He could send an angel to stand between the gunman and the teacher and deflect the bullets. A meteor could crash
through the ceiling, or a bolt of lightning, and strike the gunman dead. Or God could cause a police officer to burst into Ms.
Rogers' classroom just at this moment and kill the gunman on the spot. There are a million things that an all-powerful, all-
knowing, all-loving God could do to answer Neva Rogers' prayers.
The gunman looks directly at Neva Rogers with his 12-gauge shotgun pointed at her skull. He pulls the trigger. Nothing
happens. There is a click, but the gun does not fire. It seems like a miracle. Surely it is the hand of God.
Unfortunately, the gunman has a backup weapon and he does not even hesitate. He pulls out a pistol. He points the pistol
at Ms. Rogers' head as she prays and squeezes the trigger. The pistol performs according to its specifications. He shoots
Neva Rogers three times in the head and then once in the face for good measure. She dies instantly, falling into a pool of
her own blood on the floor right in front of her stunned students.
2 115
Chapter 32 - The future of the human race
In this book you have gained a key insight: There is no God. You have proven this to yourself in many different ways. See
Chapter 26 for details.
From that insight you can derive a great many others. The most important of them is this: You are a mortal being. There is
no heaven, and there is no hell. You are on earth for 80 years or so, and then you vanish forever. See Chapter 27 for
details.
A common philosophical question is, "Why do we exist?" Given these two insights, we can now answer the question
definitively: There is no "reason" for our existence. The fact is that we do exist. Through an evolutionary process, nature
has created rational creatures called human beings.
The question that we should be asking ourselves is the more profound one: "Given that we do exist, what are we going to
accomplish with our existence?" Right now, we are largely squandering our existence because we never ask ourselves
this question as a species.
What is our situation? We find that we are a race of approximately six billion people. We inhabit a chunk of iron, rock and
water that is floating though the vacuum of space. The universe we exist within has a volume of perhaps
3,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 cubic light years. To our knowledge there are no other intelligent, conscious
beings in this universe. Even if there are, they may be millions or billions of light years away, making them completely
unreachable for the time being.
Now what?
The question that we should be asking ourselves is simple: What is our goal as a species? We are, potentially, the only
intelligent species in the entire universe. What are we going to do with our existence?
Have you ever considered it? Have you ever thought about the goals of the human race?
Heaven on earth
I would like to make a suggestion. Here is one thing that I believe we should be doing with our existence: we should
create Heaven on EarthTM for every human being on the planet.
That's right: Heaven on EarthTM. Since God is imaginary, there is no "afterlife" and no "heaven" in the religious sense.
Therefore, we should begin to build Heaven on Earth.
Why is this important? Because right now, for a majority of people on this planet, what we have created is Hell on Earth.
As discussed in Chapter 22:
Even in the United States -- one of the wealthiest nations on earth -- poverty is a major problem. According to the
United States Department of Agriculture, more than 26 million children in the United States participate in the
National School Lunch Program, which provides low-cost or free lunches to children at or near the poverty level.
[ref] 26 million children represents about half of all the children in the United States.
One thing that you quickly realize, if you allow yourself to think about it, is that the number of people living in
abject poverty on this planet is staggering. A "fifth of the world’s people" is more than a billion people. You also
realize that $1 a day means that these people are living in hopeless, wretched conditions. Think about how little
food you can buy for $1. Now consider the fact that the $1 is spent on that little bit of food, so there is no money
left for housing, clean water, restroom facilities, clothing, shoes, health care, education, infrastructure, etc. etc.
Disease runs rampant. Starvation is common. This level of poverty is nearly unimaginable to most people in the
United States, yet more than a billion people live this way today.
Now consider the fact that, if you raise the bar to $3 a day -- still an extremely meager amount -- half of the
people on the planet are living at that level of poverty. More than three billion people. As discussed in Chapter 5,
10 million children die every year as a result of abject poverty.
For these billions of people, eliminating Hell on Earth and replacing it with Heaven on Earth would be a major blessing.
The thing is, we see that same kind of cooperation throughout America. Let me give you a few examples to help you see
what I am talking about.
I have food, clothing and shelter. At this moment I am warm at 72 degrees despite the outdoor temperature of 40 degrees
F. I am able to drive less than two miles to three different shopping centers and over two dozen restaurants, including
three all-you-can-eat buffets that cost less than $8 per person. I can shop in several grocery stores stocked with
thousands of food products -- the most variety ever seen by humanity.
A huge array of products are available that make life easier and better:
x I can watch 80 channels on cable with my TV
x I can surf the Internet or play a game with my computer
x I can call people on the cordless phone or my cell phone
x I can wash my clothes in the washer and dry them in the dryer
x I can play a DVD that I can rent for $3
x I can take a warm shower
x I can flip on any of the dozens of light switches when it is dark
If I get suddenly ill I can call 911 and a team of extremely competent people will be at my door in less than five minutes to
transport me to one of the three modern, fully equipped emergency rooms within 10 miles of my home. If I get hungry I
can open the refrigerator or the pantry and cook a snack or a meal on the stove or in the microwave. If I want to travel I
can fly to almost anywhere in the world from the international airport that is 10 miles away. If on a whim I decide I want to,
I can drive my car to Disney World tonight and shake Mickey's hand tomorrow morning. Since it is December, there is a
Christmas tree in the living room with a pile of presents underneath, strands of lights decorating the front porch and a
wreath on the door. The mail arrives every day. So does the newspaper. So do the packages from FedEx and UPS. So
does a nice hot pizza containing a total of 2,500 calories if I order one and pay $10. There's a scale in the bathroom that
tells me I eat too much. There's a thermostat on the wall that keeps the temperature just right. There are five smoke
detectors on the ceiling that will wake me in case of a fire and let me and my family get safely away from the building.
Then my insurance policy will pay for the damage.
My point here is simple: We take it completely for granted, but life in America is utterly amazing. Absolutely, utterly,
amazing.
Who created all of this? Did God? Certainly not. People have created all of this by agreeing to work together. We have
come together to create an orderly society that gets better and better through cooperation.
Think about the allies coming together World War II to fight evil. Or the space program in the 1960s and 1970s, where
thousands of people came together to accomplish the impossible and go to the moon. Or any big political campaign that
wins against the odds. Or a business that has a fantastic mission and vision. Or any charitable organization focused on
accomplishing something good and worthwhile. When people are involved in projects like these, their lives are richer and
fuller because they are working toward a common purpose with a group of fellow human beings. In those experiences we
can find a powerful message about the meaning of life.
The meaning of your individual life is bounded by the accomplishments of our species. Although each of our lives is
fleeting, our species as a whole is a chain stretching back thousands of years and stretching forward for an unknown
distance. You are one link in that chain. Each of us contributes to the world. Our children inherit the world that we create.
What is the meaning of life? It is about loving and being loved. It is about helping and being helped. It is about giving and
receiving, asking and accepting. It is about working with other people and allowing them to work with you. Life is about
dreaming of something better, and then making it happen. For all of us now. For our children in the future. Life's meaning
is about what we do today and tomorrow with the time we have available. It comes in thinking about that time -- that
precious moment that is your life -- and making the most of it in a way that is unique to you.
The next time you are sitting at a traffic light, look over at the person next to you. Smile. That person is a fellow human
being. You and he and six billion others mold this planet and create the future for our children. Together we create the
path of our species.
114
According to Time magazine, what the gunman does next is remarkable. He aims his gun at one of Ms. Rogers' students
in the corner and asks, "Do you believe in God?" By doing this, the gunman recreates a scene from the shootings at
Columbine. At Columbine the student answered, "Yes" to this question and was shot to death. At Red Lake the student
answers, "No." The gunman spares that student's life and starts shooting other students. [ref]
A total of ten people died on that day at Red Lake before the gunman took his own life.
The paradox
A situation like this is deeply paradoxical. For any thoughtful person, the questions
Key Point
come in a flood. Why does an all-powerful God completely ignore the prayers and
allow ten people to die? Why does God save the student who denies God's
existence? Why doesn't God strike the gunman dead at the scene, or help him In Mark 11:24 Jesus promises
earlier in life so as to completely derail the situation before it ever happens? How Neva Rogers that, "whatever you
could a loving God allow such perverse, needless and useless suffering when he ask for in prayer, believe that you
have received it, and it will be
clearly has the power and authority to prevent it? Why would Jesus make an
unambiguous promise to answer prayers in the Bible, and then renege? How can yours." In John 14:14 Jesus
promises, "if you ask anything in
God have answered millions of other prayers all around the globe on that day, while
at the same time ignoring this huge tragedy and refusing to answer any prayers my name, I will do it." Yet when
there? Neva prayed for protection from the
gunman, Jesus completely ignored
her. Jeff Weise shot Neva Rogers
It is hard for us, as human beings, to know what to think because Neva Rogers'
in the head four times, and she
death is senseless. We have no easy way to penetrate the mysteries of the Lord.
died in a pool of her own blood.
What we do know is that these deeply paradoxical situations happen all the time, and there must be a reason for that...
Chapter 2 - The Mystery of God
What happened to Neva Rogers? She prayed, but God completely ignored her. If you truly want to understand God, you
owe it to yourself to ask a simple question: Why didn't God protect Neva even though she prayed and asked for God's
help?
You may have noticed this same pattern in your own life. It is quite common for God to ignore prayers. And that seems
odd, because the Bible is clear about how prayer is supposed to work. In Mark 11:24 Jesus promises:
Therefore I tell you, whatever you ask for in prayer, believe that you have received it, and it will be yours.
In John chapter 14, verses 12 through 14, Jesus tells us just how easy prayer can be:
"Truly, truly, I say to you, he who believes in me will also do the works that I do; and greater works than these will
he do, because I go to the Father. Whatever you ask in my name, I will do it, that the Father may be glorified in
the Son; if you ask anything in my name, I will do it.
In Matthew 18:19 Jesus says it again:
Again I say to you, if two of you agree on earth about anything they ask, it will be done for them by my Father in
heaven. For where two or three are gathered in my name, there am I in the midst of them.
Given these verses, and given the fact that Neva Rogers was a faithful believer, doesn't it seem like Neva Rogers' prayers
should have worked?
We have no way to know what God is thinking, and his actions at times can be quite mysterious.
Steve's Miracle
Even when a prayer does seem to work, it is often shrouded in mystery. For example, in the May, 2004 issue of
Guideposts magazine there is a fascinating story about a huge wildfire that swept through San Diego, California. Steve
Homel lived in a subdivision engulfed by that fire. Steve prayed and God answered Steve's prayer, so Steve's story offers
a glimpse into the way that God works in our world.
3
Steve saw the fire approaching and it was terrifying -- "an eighty-foot wall of flames rolling down the ridge that overlooks
our street." He and his wife evacuated to the home of Steve's grown daughter about 15 miles away. There, as he watched
the news on TV, Steve actually saw the flames reaching his neighborhood.
What is the appropriate thing for a person to do in such a situation? As with Neva Rogers, the answer is prayer. Steve,
however, decided to take an innovative approach. According to the article: "Suddenly Steve grabbed a piece of paper.
'God bless this house and the firemen who protect it,' he scrawled." Steve then faxed that sheet of paper to the fax
machine in his home.
Days later, Steve and his neighbors were allowed to return to their subdivision. What Steve found when he arrived was
absolutely amazing. Despite the raging inferno, Steve's house stood completely unscathed. Even the trees in the yard
were protected. It was as though there had never been a fire near the neighborhood.
They found Steve's prayer in the tray of his fax machine. The fax machine had received the message, and obviously God
did too.
Since Steve prayed and his house survived, believers know what happened. Having heard Steve's prayer, God reached
down from heaven into our world and worked a miracle. When God acts on our earth so obviously like this, it is a source
of hope, a testimony to God's grace and a shining example of the power of prayer. This story about God's blessings gets
written up in magazines and sent to millions of believers: God saved Steve's house!
The Mystery in San Diego
Steve's story certainly sounds miraculous. But if we probe into this situation just below the surface, we run into another
paradox not unlike Neva Rogers'.
The problem is simple: Every other house on Steve's Street burned to the ground in the fire. According to the article, "The
only things standing were a few brick chimneys. The rest had been reduced to ash." The 39 other houses on Steve's
street were completely and utterly destroyed.
If God reached down to bless Steve by saving his house, did he not choose to curse Steve's neighbors by letting their
homes burn to the ground? Why would a loving, all-powerful God save only one house when it would have been just as
easy for him to save all 40?
This is where the "mystery of God" comes in. We have no way to understand why God would protect one house while
destroying the other 39. In order to understand why the other 39 houses burned down, we are forced to imagine scenerios
that are not particularly appealing:
x Was God specifically cursing the other 39 homeowners because of sins they committed? This is uncomfortable
because we are all sinners, and that means God may turn and curse us at any moment. He might burn our
houses to the ground or shoot us in the head tomorrow as punishment for our transgressions. It is hard to
reconcile that kind of behavior with the traditional "all-loving" God that many of us believe in.
x Did the other 39 homeowners not pray properly, or hard enough? What if God was only accepting fax prayers that
day? This is uncomfortable because it implies that there may be some sort of "magic incantation" or "secret code"
that unlocks God's blessings, and it would appear that 39 out of 40 homeowners don't know the secret.
x Could this all be part of God's plan? Perhaps the 39 other homeowners were all supposed to learn something
from seeing Steve's house survive, or perhaps all of their lives were actually improved by losing everything and
having to start over. This feels better, but it is hard to apply this theory in many situations. For example, when the
2005 tsunami killed 200,000 people, how did it make their lives any better? Also, it implies that prayer is
meaningless. If God's plan is to burn your house down, your prayers are irrelevant, so why bother?
x Or maybe it happened because Steve prayed too selfishly. Perhaps God wanted to teach Steve a lesson at the
expense of his neighbors.
This "selfish" theory is actually something to consider. Think about it: Steve's prayer was incredibly selfish. What if Steve
had changed just one word in his prayer so it had said, "God bless this subdivision and the firemen who protect it"? Would
all 40 homes have been saved?
4 113
x You have been granted one human life. With your life you have been given approximately 30,000 days on planet
earth.
x You may choose to do with your life anything that you like. You, and only you, get to choose what you want to do
with the life that has been given to you.
x You give your life its meaning by choosing what you want to do with it.
That is the meaning of life. You, and only you, give your life its meaning.
What should you do with your life? You should pick whatever it is that you believe in, or whatever it is that makes you
happy, or whatever it is that is most important to you, or whatever it is that you most enjoy doing. Then you should work to
make it happen. Choose the thing or things that you want to do with your single, unique, precious, human life, and make
them happen.
It does not matter what it is that you choose to do -- do whatever is important to you:
x If it is your kids, then figure out an equation that lets you do what you want to do with your kids and go do it.
x If it is saving the environment, then go do that.
x If it is bass fishing, then go do that.
x If it is cancer research, go do that.
x If it is making a film about something that you feel strongly, go do that.
x If it is entertaining people to brighten their lives, go do that.
x If it is making lots of money so that you can buy more and more stuff, go do that.
x And so on...
You can give your life whatever meaning you want. Pick whatever it is that is important to you. Decide what you think you
can do to help human beings, as a species, move forward, and then go do it in whatever way that you think is appropriate.
It is your life and it lasts about 30,000 days -- make the most of it.
The fact is that you, and only you, give your unique human life its own, personal meaning. You can choose to do
absolutely anything you like. Each life is unique to the human being who designs it, and the way you define your life's
meaning is up to you. This is how it always has been, and how it always will be.
Having said that, there one caveat that you should keep in mind: You can do whatever you want with your life, as long as
you stay within the boundaries of what your fellow human beings will allow. It's got to be legal. For example, if you decide
that the goal of your life is to murder as many people as possible, then the rest of us will do our best to stop you. The
reason for that is simple -- your goal terminates the existence of other human beings. As in any game, there are rules that
make it possible for the other players to play. The game of life has rules as well, established by your fellow human beings
to keep things fair. See this chapter for details.
The power of working together
You might also keep this in mind: As discussed in chapter 30, it is a fact that people often get more accomplished when
they work together. Let me give you an example to help you understand how that works.
A hospital puts human life into clear perspective. My son David has seen more than his fair share of hospitals and with
him I have met sick kids of every possible description -- retarded kids, paralyzed kids, kids with amputations, kids in wheel
chairs breathing from tubes, kids with cancer getting chemotherapy.
The kids with cancer are bald. They often vomit as the drugs are administered because the drugs are so toxic. There are
babies, toddlers, kindergartners, teens. For some, their IV lines snake up their shirts to permanent sites in the chest
because they are hooked to IVs so much.
A hospital shows us something important about human beings. A hospital is a facility designed to help other people. In a
modern hospital there is a remarkable array of technology, and medical science understands more and more every day.
All of that technology is designed to help people. We've built all that by agreeing it is important, and by working together to
attack the problems that diseases create. When we put our minds and our resources to it, we can build amazing things.
What is a church? It is a community of people who agree to get together regularly, help one another and share in each
other's company. A church also helps people to focus on the general concept of goodness once a week -- that is generally
what the sermon tries to accomplish. In addition, many churches have an outreach component. When there is a disaster,
either in the community or somewhere else in the world, the church members often will band together to help in some
way. The church might collect and send money or relief supplies. Large, advanced churches may even mount their own
disaster teams. We saw quite a bit of this type of activity in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans, both by
churches and by secular groups.
Once you remove the imaginary being -- who, remember, was never there to begin with -- along with the book written by
primitive men that advocates murder and hatred -- do churches suddenly vanish? I don't think that is necessarily the case.
In fact, it probably makes things better. Removing delusion is a good thing, not a bad thing.
A thriving church community can be an amazing thing. But it is the people who make that happen, not any imaginary
being. Once the imaginary being is gone, churches continue to exist as communities of people who enjoy each others'
company, who help one another in times of need, and who focus on goodness and good deeds for the benefit of society
as a whole. What's not to like about that? By removing the imaginary being, church attendance may actually go up,
because a strong church has a lot to offer.
Chapter 31 - The meaning of life
Billions of people throughout the ages have asked themselves the question, "What is the meaning of life?" Many people
answer that question by turning to religion.
The problem with the religious perspective is that it squanders the meaning of your time on earth. Many religious people
believe that this is the "meaning" of their lives right now:
"If I am good while on earth, then when I die I will go to heaven where the streets are paved with gold and I will
live with God in the lap of luxury and have absolutely anything I want or need for eternity! My time here on earth is
a mere nanosecond compared to eternity. I just have to tough it out here for a nanosecond to get my infinite
reward."
In this scenario, your nanosecond on earth pretty much has no meaning -- the whole goal is "heaven."
Think about where this sort of thinking can lead:
x Example #1 - This sort of thinking can be seen in the actions of Islamic suicide bombers. They believe that, by
blowing themselves (and others) up, they will be given as their reward a place in heaven with 72 virgins to satisfy
their every whim.
x Example #2 - The power of religion to completely warp the human mind can also be seen in a cult known as
"Heaven's Gate." In 1997, 39 members of this cult all committed suicide together. Why? Because their religion
taught them that by dying they would be transported to a space ship traveling near the Hale-Bopp comet. [ref] The
meaning of their lives was wrapped up in this ridiculous fairy tale, to the extent that they would voluntarily and
peacefully commit suicide.
This sort of thinking is fascinating. We all know that suicide bombers do not get entertained for eternity by 72 virgins. And
we all know that the members of Heaven's Gate were not transported to a space ship by killing themselves. These two
fantasies are obviously absurd. Yet billions of Christians believe that they are going to heaven. Christians for some reason
believe that their fantasy is true, when in fact all three of these beliefs are equally imaginary. These three beliefs also
show how cancerous religion can be. Instead of focusing on the here and now, religion focuses on an imaginary place and
time that is a total fabrication.
Life's meaning
It is a fact that God is imaginary. You have proven that to yourself beyond a shadow of any doubt. What, then, is the
meaning of life?
The meaning of life is simple and comes in three interlocking pieces:
112
What if Steve had prayed "God bless this nation and the firemen who protect it"? Would every fire in the entire country
immediately extinguish itself? If so, could we save billions of dollars per year by closing every fire station in the nation and
relying on Steve and his fax machine to take care of us?
Most of us understand that closing every fire station in America would be irresponsible. But why? It brings up an
interesting question: If you believe that God answered Steve's prayer, then why don't you believe that God would answer
a nationwide prayer from Steve as well? Keep in mind what Jesus said in Mark 11:24:
Therefore I tell you, whatever you ask for in prayer, believe that you have received it, and it will be yours.
If Jesus is God, and if God is perfect, why isn't Mark 11:24 true? Was Jesus exagerating? Was he fibbing? If Jesus is
perfect, why wouldn't he speak the truth?
Why, in other words, is God so mysterious?
The Gumball Machine
Many people respond to that question by saying, "God is under no obligation to answer prayers. God is not a gumball
machine granting every wish." Yet, if you interpret the Mark 11:24 (and other similar verses) in a normal way, it does seem
that God promises to answer prayers. So what is going on? (The article Understanding the Gumball Machine explores this
question in more detail).
When we look at Steve's situation, there is something else that is interesting to
God's Ratio
notice. What we see is this odd statistic: 39 houses not blessed vs. 1 house blessed.
Every family on Steve's street needed help, but God saved only one of the houses.
It is a terrible ratio -- a 97.5% failure rate. This ratio is so common that we could call In this case, God ignores 97.5% of
it God's Ratio. God was right there, guiding the path of the fire to save Steve's the homeowners in Steve's
house. Wasn't he? So why didn't God reach over and save the 39 other homes as subdivision. The ratio is 97.5% not
blessed vs. 2.5% blessed.
well? If Steve had changed one word in his prayer, would God have behaved
differently? Should we blame Steve for being so selfish when he prayed? Why
couldn't God see that, as a believer, Steve would want to help all his neighbors too?
What is God thinking when he allows things like this to happen to some people but not others, even if both are fervently
and faithfully praying? What was God thinking when he let Neva Rogers die? We can say, "It is all part of God's plan," but
what sort of plan is that? It can become uncomfortable if you think about it -- what if God's plan is to shoot you in the head
tomorrow, or burn your house to the ground? How do we make sense of that?
What if you could resolve the mystery of God? What if you could completely explain this mystery in San Diego, and the
mystery at Red Lake, and the many other mysteries that we witness each day?
Before we can probe into the mystery of God completely, we should take one small detour. We need to have a clear
understanding of who God is. We need to establish the Standard Model of God.
Chapter 3 - The Standard Model of God
Who is this being that billions of people believe in? Who is God? If you consult the dictionary, here is the first definition of
God that you will find:
"A being conceived as the perfect, omnipotent, omniscient originator and ruler of the universe, the principal object
of faith and worship in monotheistic religions." [ref]
Most believers would agree with this definition because they share a remarkably clear and consistent view of God. Yes,
there are thousands of minor quibbles about religion. Believers express those quibbles in dozens of denominations --
Presbyterians, Lutherans, Catholics, Baptists, Episcopalians, Methodists and such. But at the heart of it all, the belief in
God aligns on a set of core ideas that everyone accepts.
If you were to make a list of the fundamental beliefs, it would look like this:
5
 1. People believe that God is the almighty ruler of the universe. He is all-powerful, all-knowing, eternal, timeless,
omnipresent and perfect.
2. People believe that God is the creator of everything. He created the universe and the earth.
3. People believe that God is the creator of life and human beings. Many people believe that God created the first
man (Adam) and woman (Eve) in his own image, and we are all Adam and Eve's descendents. Others are not
that literal, and believe that God played a central role in the creation of the human species and our
consciousness.
4. People believe that God instills in each of us a unique and everlasting soul.
5. People believe that we have eternal life after death. When we die, people believe that our souls return to God in
Heaven for eternity if we have accepted Jesus as our savior.
6. People believe that God wrote or inspired the Bible. The Bible is God's word. There is a sentence that
summarizes the Bible for many people: The Bible is infallible, inspired and inerrant. [ref] Others are not that literal,
but do believe that God played a central role in the Bible's creation.
7. People believe that God sent Jesus to earth as God incarnate. Jesus performed many miracles while he was
alive, and after his death Jesus was resurrected, appeared to hundreds of people, and then ascended into
heaven, proving that he is God.
8. People believe that God is a benevolent and loving ruler. God is good and God is love.
9. People believe that God is a living being who knows and loves each one of us. Each of us can speak to God and
have a personal relationship with him. The way that we speak to God is through prayer.
10. People believe that God has a plan for each of us. We each have a distinct and unique purpose in God's
universe. (For details on God's plan, see Chapter 8)
We can call this the Standard Model of God. If you ask any believer about any of
By the numbers
these ten core concepts, you will get confirmation. There might be a quibble (for
example, some do not believe in a literal Adam and Eve, some are not certain that
God wrote everything in the Bible, etc.), but billions of people believe in the x Some polls estimate the number
Standard Model. These core beliefs are solid across the denominations. of Americans who believe in God
Approximately two billion human beings believe in these fundamentals. as high as 90%.
x More than 200 million U.S.
Prayer is extremely important. People believe that we can pray to God (or Jesus) citizens, and approximately 2 billion
(sometimes even Mary and certain saints) and God hears our prayers. People people worldwide, count
believe that God reaches down into our world and uses his infinite power and love to themselves as God's believers.
answer our prayers. God will intervene to cure diseases. God can save our lives in (Another one billion people around
emergency situations. God will protect us from danger. God can solve a wide range the world count themselves as
of personal problems and make our lives better through prayer. Hundreds of millions Muslims).
of people pray to God daily, and they believe that God hears their prayers. x According to Time magazine,
According to many people, God is answering millions of prayers on earth every day. more than 50% of Americans
believe in the Bible's account of
creation as described in the book of
This summary makes one thing clear. When you ask, "Who is God?", the answer is:
Genesis.
"God is an utterly amazing being." This is the conventional wisdom, and a large
x 59% of Americans believe that
majority of the people in the United States believe it.
the Bible's Book of Revelation will
come true. [ref]
There is something that is remarkably comforting about the thought of an all-loving, x In a recent survey of 1,087
all-knowing, all-powerful being watching over us, answering our prayers, protecting American doctors, 72 percent
us and welcoming us into heaven when we die. He sees us in our struggles and reported that they believe that
pain on this planet. He lends us his strength and compassion, and helps each of us miracles can occur today. [ref] The
to find our way. We would all like to believe in, and put our faith in, such an amazing dictionary defines miracle as, "an
being. event that appears inexplicable by
the laws of nature and so is held to
And yet, you have to wonder. You realize that the standard model of God sharpens be supernatural in origin or an act
the paradox. Given this definition of God, the violent murder of Neva Rogers is of God." [ref] In other words, 72
uncomfortable. The reason why it can be uncomfortable is because it does not seem percent of doctors believe that God
to fit with what we believe about God. There is something about the death of Neva is reaching down from heaven and
Rogers that is not quite right. interacting with our bodies
supernaturally to bring about cures
Let me give you another example to bring the paradox into focus... that are otherwise inexplicable.
6 111
We are now setting these standards ourselves in an open process that includes everyone. This is a far better way to do it
than to rely on "religion" and superstition.
In doing that, there will be a small minority of people who will say, "Who are you to impose your standards of morality
upon ME!" The important thing to understand is that we can ignore these people. The standards are self-evident. No one
wants to be murdered. Therefore murder is fundamentally and objectively wrong. The 99% of us who understand and
believe this self-evident truth have the right to impose our "morality" on the 1% of the population who feels the need to kill
people. "Do not murder" is a universal truth that every sane person can agree on. We need to weed out the 1% who
disagree and restrain them so they do not ruin life for the rest of us. That is why we have a legal system.
America is built on a foundation of Goodness and moral character. These concepts are important because a strong
society depends on honesty, integrity and trust as its foundation. Accepting that God does not exist does not change
those values -- they are essential to any functioning society. It simply changes the focus of those ideas. The focus moves
from an imaginary being onto us, where it belongs.
Chapter 30 - Love thy neighbor as thyself
If you have ever been fortunate enough to live in a well-connected neighborhood, then you know how beneficial the
human notion of community can be. A good neighborhood works because it brings hundreds of people into an
environment pre-disposed to helpfulness and sharing. The combination of "good people" and "helping and sharing" can
be extremely powerful. When good people get together in groups and decide to help one another to achieve common
goals, it is the most powerful force on the planet. We need to understand the power of the community and take advantage
of it as much as possible.
If you've had a baby, then you know how difficult those first few weeks can be. Let's say that couple gives birth to a new
baby in a well-connected neighborhood. Within that community, neighbors recognize the need and they help out. Perhaps
they help by preparing dinners for the family for several weeks. This is incredibly helpful to the family, and it makes
everyone in the neighborhood feel good to help.
In the same way, if someone in the neighborhood is in the hospital, people from the neighborhood visit and help the
person out. They cook meals. They help take care of the kids. They pick up the mail. They keep the lawn mowed. The
neighborhood is a strong network of people willing to help each other, and willing to receive help from the group. People
share rides, they take care of each others' kids, they work on projects together, they have pot-luck parties, they help each
other find jobs... It is an extremely powerful concept built on ideals like trust, love, understanding and giving.
Why does this happen? It has nothing to do with "God" or "religion." It happens because of human intelligence and a basic
desire to be kind and helpful. We all realize that we need help on occasion, and we all like to receive kindness. We then
extrapolate that notion to others. If I sometimes need help from others, then it is true that sometimes others will need help
from me. It does not take a rocket scientist to figure this out. Therefore, we help others. We are kind to each other. We
share. What goes around comes around -- we all know that.
There is no reason to gum up this simple notion with the belief in a non-existent being or religious ritual. You shouldn't
help your neighbors because of "God" or "going to heaven" in the "afterlife." You help your neighbors because you care
about your neighbors, and because you will appreciate it when someone helps you in the same way. It is that simple, and
that human.
It is extremely valuable to live in a community of people where the community members genuinely care about one
another. A loving community has immense value to everyone involved. What it is all about is creating a close, caring
group of people who help one another, share with one another and enjoy each other's company while we are here
together on earth.
What about Churches
This brings up an interesting point. Having recognized that God is imaginary, what happens to churches? I don't think
anything "happens" to them. They continue to exist because they perform a useful function.
We each have approximately 30,000 days that we get to spend on this earth. That's it. There is no reason why we should
tolerate the 1% of people violate the rules of our society and who make things miserable for the other 99%. Every human
being with common sense can agree on that, even though there is no god.
Chapter 29 - In God We Trust
In American society we have a number of things that we connect to God. For example, all of our money says, "In God We
Trust" on it. In the Pledge of Allegiance we say, "One nation, under God." We sing "God Bless America." And so on.
This is rather amazing when you consider the fact that God does not exist.
It is also amazing when you consider who "the God of the Bible" claims to be. Just look at the dozens of things that you
have discovered about God in the course of reading this book. If God were to exist, then why in the world would we trust
this appalling monster?
x God is an admitted torturer
x God is far more heinous and demented than Hitler, having annihilated billions of animals and people in Noah's
flood.
x God is a pervert who demands genital mutilation.
x God is a huge proponent of slavery.
x God hates women.
x God has happily killed millions of children and brags about it.
x God demands animal and human sacrifice.
x And so on... (see section 2 for details)
This is God's description of himself, in a book that God (supposedly) wrote. If God wrote this book, then God is a self-
described abomination.
Why, then, do we put, "In God We Trust" on the currency? As discussed in the previous chapter, we do it because we use
the concept of God as a proxy for Goodness. We overlook all of God's flaws -- we actually completely ignore them as part
of the delusion -- and focus on the Good.
Now that we have proven to ourselves that God does not exist, we should stop using a proxy and start being
straightforward in what we say. There is no reason to abdicate an idea as important as Goodness to an imaginary being.
When we delegate a concept as important as Goodness to a non-existent, imaginary being, Goodness loses much of its
power.
When we say, "One nation, under God," what we mean is "One nation, devoted to Goodness." That is what America is all
about. America is a nation of good people, honest people, friendly people, helpful people. We want to help others have
what we have. We should state it as clearly as that -- we, as a nation, are people who are dedicated to Goodness.
We should then make a clear statement that contains our definition of goodness. The commandments listed in the
previous chapter are a good way to do that. They act as the concise summary of our legal system. We can call them
commandments, or we can call them our "code of conduct" or our "national statement of Goodness" or whatever term we
decide to use. What we are stating is that we have a definition of Goodness, in the form of the commandments that we
have settled on as a nation. We are willing to uphold those standards in our country and help other countries to achieve
them.
Instead of "In God We Trust," our money should say, "In Goodness We Trust" or "We are Dedicated to Goodness." We
should then clearly state and uphold our self-evident standard of Goodness. Print the statement of Goodness, in the form
of our commandments, right on the bills. "Do not murder" is a good thing for people to see every day.
In taking this step -- in actually defining and controlling the commandments ourselves rather than abdicating them to an
irrelevant book or an imaginary being -- it is important to recognize something. The dictionary defines morality in this way:
The quality of being in accord with standards of right or good conduct.
110
Chapter 4 - Facing the paradox
As we saw in the previous chapter, it is hard to argue with a being who is all-powerful, all-knowing, eternal, timeless,
omnipresent and perfect. And yet, you still have to wonder...
When something big like September 11, 2001 comes along, you wonder. That is completely natural. If God can see
everything that is happening, if he is omnipotent and omniscient, and if he is reaching down and answering billions of
prayers on earth each day, then how does something huge and ugly like 9/11 happen?
Big paradoxes like this appear with some regularity. Any thoughtful person who takes a few moments to ponder our world
can see them. For example there is the Holocaust, where more than 10 million people died [ref]. There is the December
2004 tsunami, where 200,000 people died in less than a day. There is the AIDS epidemic, which has killed more than 20
million people in the last 25 years. Why doesn't God help these people? There are many smaller things as well. For
example, it is not uncommon to wake up, open the morning newspaper and find a story like this:
Family, friends mourn girl left in day-care van
Raleigh News and Observer
By Anne Saker
WAKE FOREST - They had driven together lots of times, the old man and the little girl. He picked her up every
morning and took her to the brick church where she spent her days. In the afternoon, he came to the door of her
classroom in the day-care center, and she slipped her hand into his. Then he took her home.
It all happened just that way on Monday, for Tim Day and Ranika Clifton, and so it resumed on Tuesday, until
about 7:30 a.m., when a tragic forgetfulness seized control.
Day, 63, a quiet retiree from Maryland, left Ranika, 2, belted into her car seat in a Ford Econoline van at the
Corinth United Church of Christ near Wake Forest. Seven hours passed before anyone realized she was missing.
When they found her, still in her car seat, she was dead.
Facing the paradox
Think about this innocent little girl as she suffered and died in the church van which was sitting under God's sun in a
church parking lot. She is strapped in her car seat unable to escape. The temperature in the van rises rapidly. She
screams and cries but no one hears her.
Saving Ranika would have been easy. For example, God could have helped Mr. Day to be less forgetful. God could have
caused anyone in the day care center to think about Ranika's absence. God could have brought clouds and rain to keep
the van cool. God could have sent an angel to roll down a window in the van. God could have spoken to Ranika's mother
and encouraged her to stop by the school for some reason.
God had a million options, but God did not do any of these things.
What is going on here? The whole thing with Neva Rogers getting shot in the head did not feel right. Watching Steve
Homel's 39 neighbors lose everything they own didn't feel right either. And now this -- little two-year-olds baking to death
in church parking lots. It is easy to say, "It must be God's will" or "It is all part of God's plan." But what does that mean?
What if God plans to shoot you in the head tomorrow? What if he plans to bake your child to death? What if he plans to
burn your home to the ground? What good is it to pray if that is what will be happening anyway?
As you can see, the paradox of God can be mystifying. When we look at the cases of Ranika, Steve Homel and Neva
Rogers, what is actually going on?
This book contains the answer to that question.
7

Chapter 5 - Why won't God heal amputees?
Does God answer prayers? According to believers, the answer is certainly yes.
For example, at any Christian bookstore you can find hundreds of books about the power of prayer. On the
Internet you can find thousands of testimonials to the many ways that God works in our lives today. Even large
city newspapers and national magazines run stories about answered prayers. God seems to be interacting
with our world and answering millions of prayers on planet Earth every day.
God's power often can be quite dramatic. Take, for example, this story from Marilyn Hickey Ministries:
Prayer is a communication system we have available to fellowship with our heavenly Father and which
activates His promises in our lives. No one can beat this system. It's quick. It's efficient. And it's
available to you right now! Prayer reaches our heavenly Father instantly. Years ago my mother's
doctors found a tumor in her brain. When I heard the news, I was out of town so I could not lay my
hands on her. That night as fear swept over me, the Lord quickened Psalms 107:20 to my spirit: "He
sent his word and healed them, and delivered them from their destructions." I sent God's Word long
distance to my mother's brain. When she was X-rayed again by her doctors, there was no evidence
that any tumor had ever existed! Hallelujah! Our prayers are swifter than any medical technique. Only
born again believers who have accepted Jesus Christ as Lord can have a relationship with the Father
and prayer is the communication method you must use to develop that relationship. [ref]
Stories like these can be easily found all over the Web.
How Prayer Works
For believers, it is obvious why so many prayers are answered. In the Bible, Jesus promises many times that
he will answer our prayers. For example, in Matthew 7:7 Jesus says:
Ask, and it will be given you; seek, and you will find; knock, and it will be opened to you. For every one
who asks receives, and he who seeks finds, and to him who knocks it will be opened. Or what man of
you, if his son asks him for bread, will give him a stone? Or if he asks for a fish, will give him a
serpent? If you then, who are evil, know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more will
your Father who is in heaven give good things to those who ask him!
Ask and you will receive. What could be simpler than that?
In Matthew 17:20 Jesus reiterates that same message:
For truly, I say to you, if you have faith as a grain of mustard seed, you will say to this mountain, 'Move
from here to there,' and it will move; and nothing will be impossible to you.
Since a mustard seed is a tiny inanimate object about the size of a grain of salt, it is easy to imagine that the
faith of a mustard seed is fairly small. So, paraphrasing, what Jesus is saying is that if you have the tiniest bit
of faith, you can move mountains.
Jesus says something similar in Matthew 21:21:
I tell you the truth, if you have faith and do not doubt, not only can you do what was done to the fig
tree, but also you can say to this mountain, 'Go, throw yourself into the sea,' and it will be done. If you
believe, you will receive whatever you ask for in prayer.
The message is reiterated Mark 11:24:
Therefore I tell you, whatever you ask for in prayer, believe that you have received it, and it will be
yours.
In John chapter 14, verses 12 through 14, Jesus tells all of us just how easy prayer can be:
"Truly, truly, I say to you, he who believes in me will also do the works that I do; and greater works
than these will he do, because I go to the Father. Whatever you ask in my name, I will do it, that the
Father may be glorified in the Son; if you ask anything in my name, I will do it.
In Matthew 18:19 Jesus says it again:
Again I say to you, if two of you agree on earth about anything they ask, it will be done for them by my
8 109
The Ten Commandments have performed a useful function in our society. They have acted as concise summary of our
legal system. They have done that not because they were divinely ordained, but because most of them are common
sense.
Now we are in the position to create our own commandments, designed to promote the general welfare and to secure the
blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity. We should do that as a nation. We should work to establish a set of
new commandments that we all agree to live by. What we are creating is a set of the big-picture commandments that act
as the concise summary of our legal system.
We should not abdicate something as important as the foundation of our legal system to a 2,000 year-old book written by
a bunch of primitive goat herders. We should control the commandments ourselves as intelligent human beings. We
should arrive at our commandments through a normal political process (public debate, voting, etc.). Doing this ourselves
is an extremely powerful idea because we can all take part in the process, and we will actually get a much better set of
commandments.
As intelligent human beings, what commandments might we create? Here is a starting point for the new commandments:
x Do not murder or harm other human beings.
x Do not enslave.
x Do not steal.
x Do not destroy another's property.
x Do not lie or cheat.
x Do not discriminate against groups of people on the basis of arbitrary characteristics. (We could add a list of
specific group characteristics like sex, age, race, etc., but there is no need to. It is impossible to list all the
groups.)
x Do not waste the time of another, for our limited time on earth is all that we have.
x Do not pollute the planet, for we all share it.
x Obey the laws and ordinances of the community. If you do not agree with them, work to change them rather than
disobeying them.
x And so on...
Ninety nine percent of the people in this country can agree that murder is wrong, for the obvious reason that no one wants
to be murdered. Ninety nine percent of the people in this country can agree that slavery is wrong, for the obvious reason
that no one wants to be a slave. And so on. We create our commandments based on strong agreement like that, and we
vote on the commandments to ratify them.
Why are these concepts important? Because they allow good people to live their lives in peace and happiness. When evil
people who kill, enslave, steal, destroy, lie, cheat, etc. move into a society, they ruin it for everyone else. Therefore evil
people should be eliminated so the rest of us can enjoy our precious time on this planet. The way we handle evil people
today is with jails, prison and rehabilitation.
These common sense concepts already are the foundation of our legal system. For example, the common sense
statement, "Do not murder or harm other human beings" is one foundation concept. From that foundation we derive
thousands of specific legal concepts -- first degree murder, second degree murder, vehicular homicide, armed robbery,
medical malpractice, product safety laws and so on. The broad statement "Do not murder" comes from common sense,
and so do all of the specific laws we create. We are also smart enough to make exceptions for things like self-defense and
brain-dead organ transplants.
We should establish the fundamental rules of conduct that we expect of everyone living in our society. We might have 20
broad "commandments" like those shown above. We should post our code of conduct in our courthouses, malls, schools,
etc.
This process of creating the "20 rules of conduct" is not based on "religion" or "God." It is based on common sense. "Do
not murder" is simple and obvious, and it is essential if we want to live in a functional society. We post these rules
prominently to remind ourselves of our standards and our goals as a society.
enforce this universal truth with the laws, police departments and courts that we have created to protect ourselves and
each other.
It is interesting to note that "Thou shalt not murder other human beings" is not what the Bible says. The sixth
commandment in the Bible is actually "Thou shalt not kill." If we were to take this as God's word, the commandment is
much broader. When we eat meat, we are killing. When people sacrificed animals as God prescribed in the Old
Testament, those animals were killed. Cutting down a tree for lumber kills the tree. In fact, spraying Lysol kills millions of
germs on contact. God's actual commandment is nuts, and that is why no one follows it. Nonetheless, we all understand
the universal truth that murder is evil.
As intelligent human beings, we can also understand that there are valid exceptions to the commandment. With our
brains, we can see situations involving a "higher good" and reason it out. For example:
x If someone attacks you and tries to kill you, it is OK for you to kill that person in self defense if necessary. We
understand that, on a personal level, we have the right to defend our own lives. We understand it at the societal
level as well. As a society, this is where the whole notion of the Department of Defense comes from. Note that we
do not call it the Department of Offense. Also note that we generally recognize the Department of Defense to be
our last resort.
x If a person has been in a car wreck and is brain dead but still "alive", we can keep the person alive indefinitely
with a ventilator and a feeding tube. Knowing that the person will never recover, however, we can decide that the
higher good is to turn off the ventilator and donate the person's organs to other people who need them.
Technically we have "murdered" the person and defied the Bible, but everyone understands that it is OK. Humans
are smart enough to make distinctions like these.
Murder is an obvious and straightforward concept. It is easy to create the commandment, "Thou shalt not murder other
human beings" and we can all agree that it is a universal truth. We can also agree that there are valid exceptions to the
rule.
What about stealing? It works exactly the same way. You don't need an imaginary god to know that stealing is wrong. You
simply ask yourself, "Do I want to have my stuff stolen from me?" No, obviously not. Therefore, by extrapolation, you
cannot steal from other people because they don't want to be stolen from either. So stealing is wrong. "Thou shalt not
steal."
Even when the Bible tells us something is OK, our brains can tell us objectively, and with moral authority, that it is wrong.
For example, the Bible says that slavery is great. We discussed this problem extensively in chapter 13. The Bible clearly
and unambiguously says things like this:
Your male and female slaves are to come from the nations around you; from them you may buy slaves. [Leviticus
25:44]
Do we allow slavery today? Of course not. Any human being can see that slavery is a moral abomination. We simply ask
ourselves, "Would I like to be a slave?" The answer is "No." We extrapolate that obvious conclusion to others. Therefore,
slavery is wrong. "Thou shalt not enslave others" should be a commandment. We all know that slavery is wrong, despite
the fact that God condones slavery in the Bible. In the United States and other developed nations we override the Bible --
the error-free word of the Lord -- because we know that slavery is wrong. We override the Bible without hesitation. We do
that so easily because human beings define Goodness, not an imaginary God.
We do not need an imaginary God to act as a moral authority. It is very simple for intelligent human beings to figure out
right and wrong. We do it all the time. That is where our legal system comes from.
Creating our own commandments
You should now be able to see the power of what is happening here. Having proven that God is an imaginary being and
that the Bible was written by primitive men, we are now free to discard the Bible. With it we discard the original Ten
Commandments.
108
Father in heaven. For where two or three are gathered in my name, there am I in the midst of them.
Jesus is actually in our midst and God answers our prayers.
The miracle of Jeanna Giese
There are so many examples of the power of prayer, but one in particular deserves special consideration
because it is so well documented. In December of 2004 a girl named Jeanna Giese survived a bite from a
rabid bat through prayer. Hundreds of newspapers (including the Raleigh News and Observer in my home
town) ran stories about the miracle of her recovery with headlines such as "Rabies girl in miracle recovery." In
Raleigh, the headline was "Web weaves global prayer circle - Petitions circle the world as girl beats rare case
of rabies." [Source: by Sharon Roznik, Raleigh News and Observer, December 17, 2004]
The summary of the story goes like this. Jeanna was in a church service in Wisconsin when a brown bat fell
into the aisle. She picked the bat up and carried it outside. No one gave it a second thought.
A month later it was obvious that something was wrong. Soon Jeanna had a full case of rabies. No human has
ever survived this disease without being vaccinated. Up until 2004, full-blown rabies had been 100% fatal.
According to the article, a global prayer circle helped Jeanna survive. Once she got sick, Jeanna's father called
friends and asked them to pray for Jeanna. People around the world heard about her story through the press
and by word of mouth. They prayed. They sent emails. They passed the word along. Millions of people heard
about Jeanna's plight and they said prayers for her.
And the prayer circle worked. Through the power of God, Jeanna recovered. Jeanna was the first human to
survive rabies without the vaccine.
Dr. Charles Rupprecht of the CDC in Atlanta called Jeanna's case a miracle. The family and everyone in
Jeanna's huge, global prayer circle know that God heard their prayers and answered them.
This is amazing stuff. The dictionary defines a miracle as "An event that appears inexplicable by the laws of
nature and so is held to be supernatural in origin or an act of God." [ref] So we must ask a fundamental
question: Did an all-loving, all-powerful God hear the prayers from Jeanna's worldwide prayer circle and then
reach down from heaven to help Jeanna? Did God actually interact with Jeanna's body, making the impossible
happen and curing her case of rabies through a divine miracle?
Or did something else happen?
We can actually answer this question with a simple experiment....
A simple experiment
For this experiment, we need to find a deserving person who has had both of his legs amputated. For example,
find a sincere, devout veteran of the Iraqi war, or a person who was involved in a tragic automobile accident.
Now create a prayer circle like the one created for Jeanna Giese. The job of this prayer circle is simple: pray to
God to restore the amputated legs of this deserving person. I do not mean to pray for a team of renowned
surgeons to somehow graft the legs of a cadaver onto the soldier, nor for a team of renowned scientists to craft
mechanical legs for him. Pray that God spontaneously and miraculously restores the soldier's legs overnight, in
the same way that God spontaneously and miraculously cured Jeanna Giese and Marilyn Hickey's mother.
If possible, get millions of people all over the planet to join the prayer circle and pray their most fervent prayers.
Get millions of people praying in unison for a single miracle for this one deserving amputee. Then stand back
and watch.
What is going to happen? Jesus clearly says that if you believe, you will receive whatever you ask for in
prayer. He does not say it once -- he says it many times in many ways in the Bible.
9
And yet, even with millions of people praying, nothing will happen.
No matter how many people pray. No matter how sincere those people are. No matter how much they believe.
No matter how devout and deserving the recipient. Nothing will happen. The legs will not regenerate. Prayer
does not restore the severed limbs of amputees. You can electronically search through all the medical journals
ever written -- there is no documented case of an amputated leg being restored spontaneously. And we know
that God ignores the prayers of amputees through our own observations of the world around us. If God were
answering the prayers of amputees to regenerate their lost limbs, we would be seeing amputated legs growing
back every day.
Isn't that odd? The situation becomes even more peculiar when you look at who God is. According to the
Standard Model of God:
x God is all-powerful. Therefore, God can do anything, and regenerating a leg is trivial.
x God is perfect, and he created the Bible, which is his perfect book. In the Bible, Jesus makes very
specific statements about the power of prayer. Since Jesus is God, and God and the Bible are perfect,
those statements should be true and accurate.
x God is all-knowing and all-loving. He certainly knows about the plight of the amputee, and he loves this
amputee very much.
x God is ready and willing to answer your prayers no matter how big or small. All that you have to do is
believe. He says it in multiple places in the Bible. Surely, with millions of people in the prayer circle, at
least one of them will believe and the prayer will be answered.
x God has no reason to discriminate against amputees. If he is answering millions of other prayers like
Jeanna's every day, God should be answering the prayers of amputees too.
Nonetheless, the amputated legs are not going to regenerate.
What are we seeing here? It is not that God sometimes answers the prayers of amputees, and sometimes
does not. Instead, in this situation there is a very clear line. God never answers the prayers of amputees. It
would appear, to an unbiased observer, that God is singling out amputees and purposefully ignoring them.
Understanding amputees
You can see that the amputee experiment reframes our conversation. No longer are we talking about "religion"
or "faith". What we are talking about here is more fundamental.
At the beginning of the chapter we highlighted a number of promises that Jesus makes about prayer in the
Bible. Summarizing, here is what Jesus promised:
x If you believe, you will receive whatever you ask for in prayer. [Matthew 21:21]
x If you ask anything in my name, I will do it. [John 14:14]
x Ask, and it will be given you. [Matthew 7:7]
x Nothing will be impossible to you. [Matthew 17:20]
x Believe that you have received it, and it will be yours. [Mark 11:24]
The question, therefore, is simple: Are Jesus' statements in the Bible true or false?
For example, in John 3:16 Jesus says, "For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that
whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life." People take that at face value: if you believe in
Jesus, you will have eternal life. So when Jesus says, "Believe that you have received it, and it will be yours,"
isn't it the same thing? Can't we take that statement at face value as well?
By looking at amputees, we can see that something is wrong. Jesus is not telling the truth. God never answers
prayers to spontaneously restore lost limbs, despite Jesus' statements in the Bible. Accepting this piece of
factual information, rather than denying it, is the first step in understanding something extremely important
about how prayer really works.
10
Once you eliminate the illusion of eternal life, the "spirit of September 11" is that much stronger and more important. We
all have an extremely limited amount of time on earth to experience our lives. And we are all in this together. We should
help each other to make the most of it.
This kind of thinking is where the concepts of "goodness" and "morality" start. The notion that "we are all in this together"
is the beginning of everything good about human beings.
Understanding Goodness
Many religious people who read this book will try to use the following logic:
God must exist. A man cannot decide without God what is good and what is evil.
They believe that, without God, there can be no Ten Commandments. They would state that, without God, there can be
no good or evil, and that any behavior is just as "good" as any other. That logic, of course, is silly. God quite clearly does
not exist, yet people have been deciding what is good and what is evil for thousands of years.
Here is the simple reality: God is an imaginary being, just like Zeus, Allah, Vishnu and all the rest. The concept of
Goodness, therefore, has nothing to do with God. Goodness comes from human beings. Goodness springs from the
human intellect and common sense. By understanding this fact of life, we give Goodness even more power.
God may not exist, but the concept of God currently plays one very important role in our society. Right now, God is our
proxy for Goodness. When we talk about God in many cases, we are talking about the idea of Goodness. We are
affirming that Goodness and moral behavior are important parts of our society.
The problem with using a non-existent God as a proxy for Goodness is that it places Goodness somewhere "else" -- in an
imaginary being called God -- when in fact Goodness is a human concept that emanates from human intelligence. Human
beings create and implement Goodness, and we do it for good reason.
We need to understand the power and the value of human Goodness. Then, as a society, we need to eliminate evil,
because evil has no place or value in any human civilization.
The source of Goodness
It is very easy to demonstrate to yourself where Goodness comes from, and why humans create it. We can start the
demonstration with a question that everyone understands: Is murder good or evil? Forget about God and just answer the
question using your own common sense. Murder: right or wrong?
Obviously murder is wrong. Everybody knows that. How do human beings all know that murder is wrong? We -- each one
of us -- can look inside ourselves and ask, "Do I want to be murdered?" The answer is, "No." Of course not. It is obvious.
Ask 100 people, "Do you want to be murdered?" 100 people will all say, "No." A person cannot "exist" to answer the
question unless he or she is "alive," so obviously he or she does not want to be "dead" because of a murderer. If
everyone on the planet were running around murdering each other, humanity could not exist. It's as simple as that.
Occasionally, in perhaps one out of 1,000 people, you will find someone who says, "yes, I want to be murdered." That
person is mentally ill and the other 999 of us can help him seek treatment. Life is the most precious thing that each of us
possesses, and we understand that. Without life, we do not exist.
As you can see, each one of us understands that we do not want to be murdered. The next step is extrapolation. We
extrapolate our personal understanding to everyone else. We realize that what we believe is universal. No one anywhere
wants to be murdered. That is also obvious. It does not take a genius, or a god, to figure out that no normal human being
wants to be murdered.
Through the extrapolation process, we realize something important: we are all in this together. By protecting your right to
live your life free from the threat of murder, I protect myself as well. By working together to prevent murder for everyone,
we each improve our own individual lives. So we can draw a conclusion that everyone can agree on. Murder is wrong.
"Thou shalt not murder other human beings" is the commandment that we create to project this universal truth. We
107
Chapter 28 - Goodness, Morality and the Ten Commandments
Throughout this book we have discussed the fact that God is imaginary. You have also seen that the Bible is a normal
book written by normal people living thousands of years ago, and is therefore irrelevant to us today. It is an easy
extrapolation of these two facts to realize the many implications. The most important implication is this: you have no soul,
and there will be no "everlasting life" for you in heaven or hell. The typical human being living in the developed world has
about 30,000 days to experience his or her existence, and that's it.
What do these simple truths actually mean for all of us as a society? How do we take advantage of this central reality and
do something useful with it? These are important questions.
This may sound flippant to you initially, but here is one way to think about it -- what if we compare your 30,000 days here
on earth to a trip to Disney World? It turns out that we can understand a great deal about life and our society as a whole
by examining this analogy.
A trip to Disney World
Imagine that you were to plan a big family vacation to Disney World. You are going to take a week off of work, buy the
plane tickets, reserve a hotel room and go. Most people would not travel all the way to Orlando, pay the price of
admission into the Magic Kingdom and then fall asleep on a bench. Most people want to ride as many rides as possible.
They want to see the entire park, watch the parade, eat the food, buy the souvenirs and get as much enjoyment as they
can out of the experience. That is a completely valid way to look at Disney World, and it is also a completely valid way to
look at your time here on earth. You want to get the most out of life.
Let's say that you did go to Disney World, paid your money to get in the gate, and then you discovered that there were
gangs of teenagers running around robbing people, that there were people cutting into line at every ride, that many of the
rides had been vandalized and did not work, and that there was litter everywhere. In other words, what if other people
were totally ruining the place? You would be upset. You would complain to management. You would want your money
back.
You realize several things as you think about your life in this way. For example, you can see why normal human beings do
not want criminals running around in our society. During your 30,000 days on earth, you hear all sorts of stories in the
news about:
x Gangs of teenagers robbing people and selling drugs
x Rapists attacking women and children
x Murderers killing people in cold blood
x Terrorists blowing up buildings and buses
x Drunk drivers destroying the lives of innocent people
x CEOs stealing millions of dollars from their businesses
x Etc…
These out-of-control people ruin the experience for the rest of us. If they were running around doing this inside Disney
World, management would exterminate them immediately. They simply would not be tolerated.
Your time here on earth is very precious, and you only get one chance to experience it. That is why human beings create
laws, police departments and courts to deter the people who are spoiling the experience for everyone else. The vast
majority of people are good, and they have no desire for bad people to wreck their lives.
The value of life
Once you realize that your life is limited and precious, you then extrapolate that onto others and begin to understand the
value of their lives as well. This is something that happened in a significant way just after September 11, 2001 -- people in
America were nicer to each other, more patient and more caring because each one of us realized how ephemeral and
precious life is.
106
Even if you take a liberal rather than literal stance on the Bible, this feels strange, doesn't it? You may not
literally believe that "nothing will be impossible for you" nor that "faith can move mountains," but I think we can
agree that there is something very odd about the way that God treats amputees. No matter how many people
pray. No matter how sincere those people are. No matter how much they believe. No matter how devout and
deserving the recipient. Nothing happens when we pray for amputated limbs. God never regenerates lost limbs
through prayer, even though Christians believe that God is answering millions of other prayers on earth every
day.
Does God answer prayers? If so, then how do we explain this disconnection between God and amputees?
What should we do with the piece of empirical data that amputees represent? We need to somehow explain
why God would answer millions of prayers on earth, yet completely ignore prayers for amputated limbs. Let's
examine the possible explanations one by one.
Rationalization #1
Key Point
Here is an explanation that you might have heard or used before:
No matter how many people pray,
no matter how often they pray, no
The reason God cures thousands of cancers, infections, etc. matter how sincere they are, no
each day but never intervenes with amputees is because it is matter how much they believe, no
not God's will to do that. It is not part of God's plan. matter how deserving the amputee,
This explanation seems a little odd. Amputees really do seem to be what we know is that prayers do
getting the short end of God's plan if this is the case. If God answers not inspire God to regenerate
prayers as promised in the Bible, and if God is performing all of the amputated legs. This happens
medical miracles that we read about in inspirational literature, then God despite what Jesus promises us in
should also be restoring amputated limbs. Why would God help cancer Matthew 21:21, John 14:14, Mark
victims (e.g. Marilyn Hickey's mother) and people bitten by rabid bats
11:24, etc.
(e.g. Jeanna Giese), but discriminate against amputees like this? (See
Understanding God's Plan for an in-depth look at how "God's Plan" works).
Keep in mind what Jesus promised:
x If you believe, you will receive whatever you ask for in prayer. [Matthew 21:21]
x If you ask anything in my name, I will do it. [John 14:14]
x Ask, and it will be given you. [Matthew 7:7]
x Nothing will be impossible to you. [Matthew 17:20]
x Believe that you have received it, and it will be yours. [Mark 11:24]
There is no indication from Jesus that amputees will be ignored when they pray for medical help. The fact is,
all five of these statements are completely false in the case of amputees.
The five quotes in the previous paragraph are all simple, straightforward statements. Doesn't "nothing will be
impossible for you" mean "nothing will be impossible for you"? Jesus is God, and as an all-knowing being God
knows how humans interpret sentences. If Jesus did not mean "nothing will be impossible for you," it seems
like Jesus would have said something else. He also would not repeat that sentiment so many times. And Jesus
is supposedly answering millions of prayers each day, so prayer-answering seems to be his.
Rationalization #2
In a similar vein, many believers will say, "God always answers prayers, but sometimes his answer is 'no.' If
your prayer does not fit with God's will, then God will say 'no' to you." This feels odd because God's answer to
every amputee is always "no" when it comes to regenerating lost limbs. Jesus says, "If you ask anything in my
name, I will do it." He does not say, "If you ask anything in my name, I will do it, unless you are praying about
an amputated limb, in which case I will always reject your prayer." Jesus also says, "Nothing will be impossible
to you," and regenerating a limb should therefore be possible. The fact that God refuses to answer every
prayer to regenerate a lost limb seems strange, doesn't it?
11
Rationalization #3
Here is another explanation that you might have heard: "God needs to remain hidden -- restoring an
amputated limb would be too obvious." We will discuss this idea in more detail in later chapters, but let's touch
on it here. Does God need to remain hidden?
That does not seem to be the case. In general, God seems to have no problem doing things that are obvious.
Think about the Bible. Writing the Bible and having billions of copies published all over the world is obvious. So
is parting the Red Sea. So is carving the Ten Commandments on stone tables. So is sending your son to earth
and having him perform dozens of recorded miracles. And so on. It makes no sense for a God in hiding to
incarnate himself, or to do these other obvious things. Why send your son to earth, and then write a book that
talks all about his exploits, if you are trying to hide?
In the same way, any medical miracle that God performs today is obvious. The removal of a cancerous tumor
is obvious because it is measurable. One month the tumor is visible to everyone on the X-ray, and the next
month it is not. If God eliminated the tumor, then it is openly obvious to everyone who sees the X-ray. There is
nothing "hidden" about removing a tumor. So, why not regenerate a leg in an equally open way? If God
intervenes with cancer patients to remove cancerous tumors in response to prayers, then why wouldn't God
also intervene with amputees to regenerate lost limbs?
Another example is seen in Jeanne's rabies case discussed earlier in
Key Point
the chapter. Tens of millions of people are aware of the Jeanna's rabies
miracle. Personally, I read about it in a big article in my morning
newspaper. That is pretty obvious. What is hidden about her recovery? If God intervenes with cancer
patients to remove cancerous
tumors, then God should also
Why, then, does God ignore the prayers of amputees? (see Chapter 19
intervene with amputees to
for a complete discussion of the "hidden God" theory)
regenerate lost limbs.
Rationalization #4
Some people might say, "Everyone's life serves God in different ways. Perhaps God uses amputees to teach
us something. God must have a higher purpose for amputees." That may be the case -- God may be trying to
send a message. But, again, it seems odd that he would single out this one group of people to handle the
delivery. To quote Marilyn Hickey once again:
It is because original sin tries to explain death, and many adults are incredibly afraid of death. Original sin is one of the
Bible's explanations for the fact of life called death. So Christians -- even Christians with Ph.D.s -- cling to it like little
children.
We do not die because of Adam and Eve and an apple. We die because we are big, walking chemical reactions. When
the chemical reactions cease, we cease. There is no human "soul" mixed in with the chemicals, just like there is no
mosquito "soul." When we die, we die.
Understanding death
From the story in the previous section you can see that the idea of death is disturbing to children. Many adults never
outgrow it, so death can also be disturbing to adults -- even to adults with Ph.D.s. These adults, of course, are acting like
children.
You are not a child. Imagining a place called "heaven" does not change the central fact about the chemical reactions that
drive your cells. You simply need to grow up and face death like an adult, in the same way that you face other childhood
traumas.
It is quite beneficial to see your mortality for what it is. A week or two from now, when you are thinking like an adult about
death, the truth about death will begin to change your self-image and the way that you imagine the future. Religion and its
concept of an afterlife skew your thinking by making you believe that you will live forever. You will not. You've got 70 or 80
years if you are lucky, and then you are gone forever.
At the simplest level, an understanding of your permanent mortality should help you to realize more clearly how precious
your life is. If you live to be 82 years old, what you have is approximately 30,000 days of existence. You are not going to
then commute to "heaven" to live for eternity. 30,000 days is all that you've got.
Here are some of the things in your thinking that will change once you understand and accept this simple fact:
x Your time on earth becomes much more precious to you.
x You begin to realize that everyone else's life is just as precious, and you start looking at them differently.
x You think more about what you are leaving behind when you die.
x You think more about the human species as a continuum, with yourself as a part of that continuum, and you start
thinking about the future of our species and the planet.

No matter what has happened in your past, no matter what is happening in your present, seek out your Like it or not, your total experience is here on earth. That realization should make you see a day wasted in line at the
heavenly Father in prayer as often as you can. Take my word for it -- He loves you and wants to Department of Motor Vehicles, or a week wasted preparing your taxes for the IRS, a little differently. All that you have is
answer your prayers. [ref] 30,000 days. Everyone who wastes your time -- every bureaucracy, every long line at the store -- should give you pause.
You see this logic all the time in inspirational literature and hear it every Sunday at thousands of churches:
"God loves you! God hears your prayers and will answer them for you!" See this article for an example. Yet, for
When you die, what is your legacy? What do you leave behind?
some reason, miracles never happen when it comes to regenerating lost limbs. It does not seem to make
sense that amputees would be cut off from the blessings that Jesus promises in the Bible. And it also does not
mesh with all of the prayers that Jesus seems to be answering for other people. x Whatever material objects you own, to be given to whomever you like in your will.
x Whatever contributions you have made to society as a whole. If you have done research into the cure for cancer,
Rationalization #5 you leave that. If you have written books or made movies, you leave them. If you funded a building at your
university, you leave that.
x Images of you in photographs and video, as well as any letters, writings or recordings.
Some people ascribe the problems that amputees face to free will. They will say, "Well, if you go into a war
x Your children and their memories of you.
zone and get your legs blown off, that is your own free will. God gives us free will. You made a free choice to
x The memories you leave with your friends and family.
be a soldier. It is not God's fault, and therefore he has no obligation to repair the damage." This logic is
fascinating. What about all the people who are born with missing limbs, or the people who lose limbs to
diseases through no fault or choice of their own? How are these people any different from cancer victims, who, That's it. Now that you understand that your death is final, you may look at those things in a different light.
supposedly, are constantly being healed by God?

We know that God ignores all amputees, regardless of the cause of the missing limb. Why doesn't God heal
thalidomide babies, who are by definition completely innocent? Or the innocent children who lose their limbs in
mine fields? Why would God heal millions of other diseases, but completely ignore any disease that results in
a lost or missing limb?

12 105
Irena paused for a long time and then asked the obvious next question:
Irena: Will I die?
Me: Yes. Everyone dies.
Irena: And worms will eat me? I don't want to be eaten by worms! I don't want to be buried in the ground!
We talked about it for a long time. We eventually ended up getting in the car and driving to a nearby cemetery so that she
could see what happens to people when they die. We looked at many grave markers and tombs, and talked about the
different stories that lay before us. For example, we found Hilda Sesom's grave marker. Hilda had lived for just a month
before she died in 1928. We talked about what might have happened to Hilda, and how sad her parents would have been.
What you can see here is important. The thought of dying is a remarkably troubling concept. How can it be that a person
like Grandpa, who has decades of memories, hundreds of close friends, a large, happy family and seven grandkids who
love him dearly -- how can it be that in a moment, all of that is gone? One minute Grandpa is alive. The next minute he is
gone, and everything stored in his brain is lost. We are never going to see him again.
That is troubling enough, but it is when Irena turned that logic on herself and realized her own mortality that it became
truly uncomfortable for her. What went through her little head is simple. How can it be that I will die? How can it be that my
body will turn to dust?
Even at age four she was able to put the pieces together, and she found that thought to be uncomfortable. For many
people, the thought is so uncomfortable that it is impossible to imagine.
Many adults never outgrow their childhood fear of death. Because the thought of death is so distressing to some people, it
is not surprising that they try to invent a way out. The fairy tale that Christians have invented is called heaven, and they
have also formulated the concept of eternal life. And of course, if you are going to be transported to an eternal spa/resort
in the sky, there needs to be someone to manage the place and keep the peace. That is where God comes in.
Think about it. Who wants to have eternal life if it is just like life here on earth? In no one's conception of heaven is there
murder, rape, incest, burglary, muggings, political backstabbing, office politics, gossip, rumor, PMS, arguments, anger,
discontent or disease. Heaven is free of bacterium and mosquitoes and rapists. Somehow, in heaven, everyone is
beautiful and everyone is always happy. God is there to cast the bad apples into hell (another invention), and he is also
there to keep the peace.
Christians fabricate all of this out of thin air. Their heaven and their hell and their God are completely imaginary. The
Christian fabrications are, of course, entirely different from the heaven and God of all other religions, because all of them
are imaginary. Egyptians believed something silly involving pyramids and sun gods and so on. Greeks believed in the
river Styx and Hades and so on. Muslims believe in their 72 virgins and so on [ref]. It is all gibberish, but people believe in
their fantasies quite passionately.
Even grown adults who should know better believe in these fantasies, and will go to incredible lengths to rationalize them.
In his book "The Case for Faith," Lee Strobel interviews Norman Geisler, Ph.D. During the interview Dr. Geisler states the
following:
"In sum, everything that God created was good. What changed things was the Fall [Adam and Eve eating the
apple]. When God was told, in effect, to shove off, he partially did. Romans 8 says all creation was affected -- that
includes plant life, human beings, animals, everything. There were fundamental genetic changes; we see, for
instance, how life spans rapidly decreased after the Fall. God's plan was not designed to be this way; it's only this
way because of sin."
This is the concept of "original sin." The idea is that, by eating the apple, Adam and Eve infuriated God so much that, as
punishment, God changed all living things and made them mortal. For some Christians, this is the explanation of why we
die rather than living forever.
Why would an adult with a Ph.D. believe such a silly story? Why do Christians and Jews cling to this concept of original
sin? Why don't people read the story of Adam and Eve and have a good chuckle, like we do when we read stories about
Santa as adults?
104
Rationalization #6
Some believers say, "God does help amputees - he inspires scientists and engineers to create artificial limbs
for them!" This logic is interesting, especially if we look at other examples. Take the case of smallpox. Millions
upon millions of people died of smallpox until the vaccine was invented in the twentieth century. If God is the
one who inspired the scientists, why did God wait until the twentieth century to do it? Why would God want to
be the source of the massive suffering that smallpox caused prior to the twentieth century? And why do we pay
the scientists, given that their work is simply God's inspiration? (we will discuss the question of divine
inspiration in more detail in Chapter 7)
Rationalization #7
Someone might say, "Thou shalt not test the Lord. It says so in the Bible." This is hard to swallow because
every prayer is a test. Either God answers the prayer or he does not. There is no difference between praying
for an amputee and praying for Jeanna Giese and her rabies.
Note also that many believers track their prayers with prayer journals. See, for example, prayer-journal.com.
Why not pray to God to heal an amputee, and then track the results of the prayer in a prayer journal?
Rationalization #8
Some people might say something like, "Jesus never says when he will answer your prayers. Maybe your
prayer will be answered in the afterlife." But that seems uncomfortable. Jesus is answering millions of prayers
for everyone else in the here and now. Clearly that is what he means with all his verses in the Bible. Why
single out amputees for treatment in the afterlife when Marilyn and Jeanna get their prayers answered almost
instantaneously?
Rationalization #9
Someone might say, "God will answer your prayers, but not immediately. You must be patient." They will point
to a situation like that found in Mark 6:47-51:
And when evening came, the boat was out on the sea, and he was alone on the land. And he saw that
they were making headway painfully, for the wind was against them. And about the fourth watch of the
night he came to them, walking on the sea. He meant to pass by them, but when they saw him walking
on the sea they thought it was a ghost, and cried out; for they all saw him, and were terrified. But
immediately he spoke to them and said, "Take heart, it is I; have no fear." And he got into the boat with
them and the wind ceased.
A person might say, "you see, he came in the fourth watch (generally understood to be 3AM to 6AM), not in the
first or second or third. You must be patient and wait for the Lord to answer your prayers." This is just as
uncomfortable as the previous explanation. God does not answer the prayers of any amputee to restore lost
limbs.
Rationalization #10
A believer might say, "You are taking the Bible literally." But how else are we supposed to take it? Jesus
clearly says, "If you ask anything in my name, I will do it." When Jesus says that, what does he mean?
Presumably, Jesus means that if you ask for anything, he will do it. What else could he possibly mean?
Believers often respond with, "Look, Jesus was using poetic embellishment when he said, 'nothing will be
impossible for you,' and 'faith can move mountains.'" Which leads to the following question: What prayers does
God answer? It is the response to that question that is fascinating. Because the response inevitably is, "God is
omnipotent, so God can do anything."
Which leads us right back to the question, "Why won't God heal amputees?"
13
Rationalization #11
Finally, there is this oft-used chestnut: "There is no way to understand the mysteries of our Lord. People have
believed in Jesus for 2,000 years, and there must be a very good reason for it." This feels like a sad point in
the conversation. On one side of the conversation is a person who is defending the all-powerful, all-knowing,
all-loving creator of the universe. This person's position should be unassailable. Yet, if God exists, and
answers prayers as described in the Bible, there is no explanation for what we see in the world around us. The
Bible is silent in this case. God is silent. There is not a good, comfortable explanation for the situation faced by
amputees except to say, "We cannot understand the mysteries of the Lord. We have no explanation for why
God refuses to answer prayers to regenerate lost limbs."
Explaining the case of amputees
Far more interesting, however, was Irena's response. Irena loves pets and would have hundreds if we let her. She has a
video called "Paws, claws, feathers and fins" that she has watched dozens of times. On this video, kids talk about their
pets, show what is necessary to properly care for different kinds of pets, and so on.
PCFF happens to have a segment where a small pet dies. The kids in the video put him in a little box and bury him in the
backyard. Irena had seen this segment so many times, and she wanted to bury Hamsty in a similar way.
Irena and I found a small jewelry box. We placed Hamsty gently in the box and put the lid on. She asked if she could pat
him, and I took the lid off so she could pat him one last time, which she did very gently. And she seemed fine with it. We
found a trowel, and we went out to the backyard and dug a hole. As I was about to put Hamsty in the hole she asked to
pat him again. She patted him very gently, and again she seemed fine with it. I put Hamsty in the hole and asked Irena if
she wanted to put the dirt back into the hole. She did not, so I did.

Just for a moment, I would ask you to consider the possibility of another explanation. If you believe in God, Keep in mind that Irena was four years old, and four-year-olds are famous for asking lots of questions. As I was burying
then this explanation will initially appear to be complete nonsense. However, it is interesting in light of the Hamsty, she asked me a question: "Can I pat Hamsty tomorrow?"
conversation we will be having in this book.
Me: Well, no, probably not.
One explanation for the evidence that we see before us is this:
Irena: Why not?
God exists, and God answers prayers, but for some reason God chooses to ignore the prayers of
amputees. We don't have a good explanation for why God acts this way, and it does seem to Me: Well, usually, once you bury someone you don't dig them back up. We call it respecting the dead.
contradict what Jesus teaches about prayer in the Bible, but clearly God has his divine reasons.
Irena: Why?
Now let's look at the situation with amputees from another point of view. This explanation is more
straightforward: Me: Well, for one thing, a dead body turns back to dust, so there really isn't much to dig back up. Hamsty will turn
to dust.
God is imaginary.
Let's look at what happens when we consider this explanation and see how it stacks up. Irena: Why will he turn to dust?

Assume that God is imaginary. The beauty of this explanation is that it fits the facts perfectly. In the case of Me: Everything living turns to dust when it dies. Worms will eat him, bacteria will eat him. He will decompose and
amputees, it is a valid way to explain the reality that we see in our world. The logic goes like this: turn to dust.

If God is imaginary, then he does not answer any prayers. Therefore, the prayers of amputees would Irena: Will it hurt? Won't that hurt?
go unanswered too.
Me: Well, no, Hamsty is dead, so he won't feel anything.
The thing that is so appealing about this explanation is that there is no hand waving. There are no
contradictions. It is completely fair. There is no paradox. This explanation makes complete sense in light of the
Irena looked at me for a long time, and you could see the little wheels in her head turning. The next question she asked
evidence we see in our world.
sort of surprised me though.
Irena: Is grandpa going to die?
Interestingly, this explanation also happens to cover the case of Neva
Key Point
Rogers in Chapter 1. And Steve Homel's subdivision in Chapter 2. And
Me: Yes, he is. Everyone dies eventually.
Ranika in Chapter 4. If you assume that God is imaginary, then the
paradox of God evaporates in all of these cases. Why did Ranika die? If God is imaginary, then he does
Because there was no all-powerful, prayer-answering God to save her. not answer any prayers. Therefore, Irena: Will worms eat him?
Why did Neva die? Because there was no all-powerful, prayer- the prayers of amputees would go
answering God to save her. Why did Steve's house remain standing unanswered too. The thing that is Me: Yes, Grandpa's body will turn to dust.
while 39 others burned to the ground? Because there was no all- so appealing about this explanation
powerful, prayer-answering God to save any of the houses (and Steve's is that there is no hand waving. She paused as the wheels in her head turned some more.
house was a fluke). Why did 200,000 people die in the tsunami? There are no contradictions. It is Irena: Are you going to die?
Because there was no all-powerful, prayer-answering God to save completely fair. There is no
them. And so on. It explains amputees too. The paradox of God paradox. This explanation makes
sense in light of the evidence we Me: Yes, I will die. But it won't be for a lot of years.
vanishes completely.
see in our world.
Irena: Will worms eat you?
In response to this proposal, a thoughtful person might say, "Just
because God never answers the prayers of amputees, it does not mean that he does not answer other
Me: Yes, they will.
prayers. I agree with you that it is unfair to amputees, and I agree with you that it contradicts what Jesus
teaches in the Bible, but God has his reasons. For some reason, it is not part of God's plan to help amputees
14 103
 x There is also the absurdity that comes when you compare any two people's views of heaven. Everyone's
fabrication of heaven is different. For some it involves harps and clouds and halos. For others it involves hot and
cold running virgins. For some people, the actual body is transported magically to heaven as described in the
"Left Behind" books. For others, your "soul" floats out of the body and makes it way to St. Peter. And so on.
People make up anything they like, because heaven is a completely imaginary place.
After listening to three or four explanations of heaven, the message will come through loud and clear. Heaven is a fairy
tale invented by human imagination. And each person's fairy tale is different.
We imagine that we have "souls," fabricate the concept of "eternal life" and then fantasize a place called "heaven,"
complete with streets of gold, calorie-free foods, frolicking virgins and whatever else we can come up with. Christians
imagine it so vividly and repeat the fantasy so often that they actually believe it to be reality.
How bizarre can the fantasies get? Fly to Cairo and take a look at the Great Pyramid. There is the pyramid itself -- still one
of the largest man-made objects on earth. In addition there is the whole mummification process, the disassembled boats,
the sacred artwork and so on. All of this was designed to help the pharaoh reach the afterlife. We look at it now and we all
know, with absolute certainty, that it was a complete and total waste of time. The Egyptian notion of the afterlife was a
fantasy.
The Christian notion of the afterlife is a fantasy in exactly the same way.
The fact is that, at a biochemical level, we are no different from mosquitoes. The chemical substrate that supports human
life is exactly the same as the chemical substrate that supports mosquito life. Neither humans nor mosquitoes go to
heaven.
The big difference between a human and a mosquito is the fact that humans have the brainpower to imagine a place
called heaven. The fact that we can imagine heaven, however, does not mean that it exists. If you think about whatever
your fantasy world of heaven looks like in your brain, you will realize that it is just as strange and ridiculous as the version
of heaven outlined in the dialog above. It is also as ridiculous as the Great Pyramid. None of these heavens exist.
The fact that death is an uncomfortable notion does not change its reality. If you don't like the idea of dying, you can
create whatever fairy tales that you would like. People have been creating all sorts of fairy tales for thousands of years --
This is where religion comes from. But those fairy tales do not change the central reality that surrounds death.
When you die, you die. You do not live on in the "afterlife." Pouting over this fact, or getting depressed, or imagining
places like heaven does not change the basic fact that you are big, walking chemical reaction. When the reaction stops,
you are completely dead. There is no everlasting soul mixed in with the chemicals.
The Horror of Death
You can better understand how uncomfortable death is if you look at the reaction of a child. In my household, this
discomfort first surfaced with the death of Hamsty. Let me tell you about Hamsty, because his story illustrates a central
point about death.
Hamsty, as you might have guessed, was a hamster. I have four children, and at the time of Hamsty's death they were
ages 7 (David), 4 (Irena) and 2 (John and Ian). Hamsty was their pet. He lived in a deluxe two-bedroom hamster
condominium in the kids' playroom. The kids loved Hamsty -- they would feed him, change his water, watch him, take him
out of his cage to play with him and so on.
Hamsty, being a small rodent, had a limited lifespan. One day he got sick. The next day we found him dead. He had died
peacefully in his sleep in his upper penthouse sleeping quarters.
The twins were apoplectic once they realized what had happened. This truly surprised me. They ran around the house
crying "Hamsty died!" over and over again. Every time they were reminded of it, the chorus would start anew. They fell
asleep crying about Hamsty's death, but by the next day they had stabilized.
102
by regenerating their lost limbs. There is no way to understand the mysteries of our Lord, but he does have his
reasons and they will become clear to us when we die and go to heaven." That is one possible explanation,
but words like "unfair" and "contradicts" feel, somehow, uncomfortable. They do not fit with our mental image
of an all-loving and perfect God, nor with the words of Jesus in the Bible. Why would God have such a problem
with amputees that he completely ignores their prayers to regenerate lost limbs, while at the same time he is
answering all of these other prayers millions of times a day? When it comes to amputees, why would Jesus
renege on his promises to answer prayers in the Bible?
You can see that what we have here is a paradox:
x On the one hand we have an all-knowing, all-loving God who has made very clear and specific
statements in his Bible about the power of prayer. We have billions of people who believe that their
prayers are being answered. We have thousands of examples of the power of prayer published in
inspirational literature. We have prominent doctors at the CDC declaring that God is reaching down
onto earth and performing medical miracles. We have major newspapers and magazines reporting on
the power of prayer and prayer circles.
x On the other hand, we have a piece of explicit evidence that does not make any sense if God exists.
No matter how many people pray, no matter how sincere they are and no matter how much they
believe, God does not answer the prayers of amputees to regenerate their limbs.
There are two possible explanations for this paradox:
x Many people believe that God answers millions of prayers every day, using his love and power to
bless people all over the globe. They express their belief in articles like this, published in magazines
read by millions of people. But they also believe that God ignores the prayers of amputees for a divine
reason that is unknowable to human beings. In that case, the situation with amputees is a mystery.
x Many other people believe the opposite. They believe that God is imaginary, and therefore he cannot
answer prayers. In that case, the situation with amputees makes complete sense.
Who is right?
The thing about amputees is that the evidence is rock solid. This solidity is what makes this example so
compelling.
A cascade of problems
It's not like I am revealing some hidden truth here. The funny thing about amputees is that this evidence is
obvious to everyone. We have all seen that God ignores the prayers of amputees. This evidence has been
plainly visible for centuries.
Amputees are not the only ones either. For example:
x If someone severs their spinal cord in an accident, that person is paralyzed for life. No amount of
prayer is going to help.
x If someone is born with a congenital defect like a cleft palate, God will not repair it through prayer.
Surgery is the only option.
x A genetic disease like Down Syndrome is the same way -- no amount of prayer is going to fix the
problem.
Or what about this. What if we get down on our knees and pray to God in this way:
Dear God, almighty, all-powerful, all-loving creator of the universe, we pray to you to cure every case
of cancer on this planet tonight. We pray in faith, knowing you will bless us as you describe in Matthew
7:7, Matthew 17:20, Matthew 21:21, Mark 11:24, John 14:12-14, Matthew 18:19 and James 5:15-16.
In Jesus' name we pray, Amen.
We pray sincerely, knowing that when God answers this completely heartfelt, unselfish, non-materialistic
15
prayer, it will glorify God and help millions of people in remarkable ways. Will anything happen? Of course not. Christian: God fixes them all up too!
If prayers like this worked, Christians would have prayed every disease on the planet into extinction centuries
ago. But if God were to exist, why would he ignore such a worthy prayer? [We will discuss this particular Norm: And what about all the decrepit 80-year-old bodies?
question in much more detail in chapter 6.]
Christian: God gives them new, young, beautiful bodies!
It is also easy to find corroborating evidence outside the medical arena. At the global level, we see the
evidence every day in many different ways. For example, we all see the millions of children who die every year Norm: And what about all the people whose bodies have died and decomposed?
from the tragic effects of poverty. Unicef puts it this way:
Christian: God gives them young, new, beautiful bodies too!
Every year, more than 10 million children die totally preventable deaths. Some are directly caused by
illness – pneumonia, diarrhoea, measles – and others are affected by indirect causes such as conflict
Norm: So why bother transporting the bodies of the believers to heaven? Why not just give everyone a new,
and HIV/AIDS. Malnutrition, lack of safe water and inadequate sanitation are contributing factors to
young, beautiful body and leave their old bodies on earth?
more than half of these deaths. [ref]
Jesus is supposed to love all the little children of the world: "Red and yellow, black and white, they are
precious in his sight." So we can ask this straightforward question: If children are precious to Jesus, then why Christian: The Bible says that your body is transported to heaven! It is right there in black and white in the "Left
is he killing 10 million of them every year with abject poverty? That's 27,000 dead kids every day -- more than Behind" books! That is God's will!
1,000 dead children each hour. If Jesus answers prayers as he promises in the Bible, then why haven't the
prayers of billions of people to end world hunger caused Jesus to solve the problem of global poverty? (We will Norm: OK, so heaven is full of people whose bodies or corpses or whatever have been "dematerialized" from
discuss this situation in more detail in chapter 22.) earth, and then "rematerialized" in "heaven." And then the dematerialized/rematerialized bodies are discarded,
We all know that holes like these exist. It is easy to find them. The holes and they are replaced with new, young, beautiful bodies?
Key Point
suggest that something very odd is going on.
Christian: Yes! Now you understand the power of the Lord Jesus Christ!
27,000 children die every day for
Ambiguity and coincidence
preventable reasons like
malnutrition and unsafe drinking Norm: What happens next?
The question, "Why won't God heal amputees?" probes into an water. If Jesus answers prayers as
extremely interesting aspect of prayer and exposes it for observation. he promises in the Bible, then why Christian: The believers all live in heaven in peace, harmony and joy for eternity!
This aspect of prayer has to do with ambiguity and coincidence. haven't the prayers of billions of
people to end world hunger caused Norm: What is heaven like?
Imagine that you pray for something -- It does not really matter what it Jesus to solve the problem of
is. Let's imagine that you have cancer, you pray to God to cure the global poverty? Christian: We get to reunite with all of our dead friends and family members! We get to meet our ancestors for the
cancer, and the cancer actually does go away. The interesting thing to first time!
recognize is that there is ambiguity in your cure. God might have miraculously cured the disease, as many
people believe. But God might also be imaginary, and the chemotherapy drugs and surgery are the things that
Norm: Really?
cured your cancer. Or your body might have cured the cancer itself. The human body does have a powerful
immune system, and this immune system has the ability to eliminate cancer in many cases. When your tumor
dissappeared, it might be a coincidence that you happened to pray. Drugs, an immune response or a Christian: Absolutely!
combination of the two might have been the thing the cured you.
Norm: What about people like George Washington and Benjamin Franklin?
How can we determine whether it is God or coincidence that worked the cure? One way is to eliminate the
ambiguity. In a non-ambiguous situation, there is no potential for coincidence. Because there is no ambiguity, Christian: Everyone is there! You can talk to anyone all through history! Plus you get to meet God and Jesus. I
we can actually know whether God is answering the prayer or not. can't wait to meet Jesus!

That is what we are doing when we look at amputees. Norm: That sounds like fun. What else?

When we pray to God to restore an amputated limb, there is only one way for the limb to regenerate. God must
exist and God must answer prayers. What we find is that whenever we create a non-ambiguous situation like
this and look at the results of prayer, prayer never works. God never answers prayers if there is no possibility
of coincidence. We will approach this issue from several different angles in this book, but Chapters 6 and 7 are
particularly important.
Christian: Well, the streets are paved in gold! It says so in the Bible! And everyone has a big house! And you can
eat whatever you want and not get fat! And really, you just do anything that makes you happy! Everyone is always
happy!
And so on.

The fact that prayers are never answered when the possibility of coincidence is eliminated meshes with
another fact. If we analyse God's responses to prayers using statistical tools, what we find is that there is never
any statistical evidence for prayer. In other words, when we statisically compare prayer to coincidence for
explaining any situation, they are identical. For example, this article points out:
One of the most scientifically rigorous studies yet, published earlier this month, found that the prayers
of a distant congregation did not reduce the major complications or death rate in patients hospitalized
Simply talk to Christians about heaven. Ask them to describe what heaven is like, and how they will get there. You will be
able to feel the absurdity of this notion in two different ways:
x There is the direct absurdity as in the dialog above, where the creation of entirely new and completely imaginary
"dimensions" and "materialization processes" tells you everything you need to know about how delusional things
can get.

16 101
Norm: No.
Christian: You should! They have sold over 20 million copies of the book, because it is the truth! It describes
exactly what will happen. One day the Lord Jesus calls his children home, and they are carried straight to heaven!
Airplanes crash because their pilots have vanished. Cars run into phone poles. This is exactly what is described
in the Bible.
Norm: The people completely vanish?
Christian: Yes. All that is left behind is their clothes, their jewelry and their hearing aids! The believers are
transported directly to heaven!
Norm: Their naked bodies are transported to heaven?
Christian: Yes!
Norm: There are six billion people on the planet. They each weigh about 150 pounds or so. Are you telling me
that God lifts a trillion pounds of human flesh off the planet in an instant?
Christian: Absolutely not! Only the believers are transported!
Norm: OK, half a trillion pounds?
Christian: Yes!
Norm: And where does this half a trillion pounds of flesh go?
Christian: To heaven!
Norm: To heaven... where is that?
Christian: It is in another dimension, of course! God lives in heaven!
Norm: How do all the bodies get to this "other dimension" called "heaven"? Do they float up into the sky and then
travel through the vacuum of space?
Christian: No, silly! They are dematerialized and then rematerialize in heaven!
Norm: So you are saying that half a trillion pounds of naked human flesh are somehow "dematerialized" out of our
universe, and then they "rematerialize" in "another dimension" called "heaven?" And the "dematerializing" process
somehow distinguishes between natural human flesh and unnatural things like clothing and hearing aids?
Christian: Yes!
Norm: So... what if the person has artificial heart valves, a couple of stents and two titanium hip joints? Are those
ripped out of his body and left behind with his jewelry?
Christian: Yes!
Norm: And what happens to that poor person, whose heart collapses and whose legs are now flopping around
detached from his pelvis?
Christian: The book doesn't really talk about that... I imagine God would fix them up!
Norm: And what about all the people whose bodies are wracked with cancer and AIDS and emphysema?
100
for heart treatments. [ref]
It also says:
A review of 17 past studies of ''distant healing," published in 2003 by a British researcher, found no
significant effect for prayer or other healing methods.
No scientific study has ever found any evidence that prayer works.
There are two possible conclusions to draw from these statistical studies and the situation with amputees:
1. God somehow detects every non-ambiguous situation (like amputees) and every situation where a
statistical study will be done and he "refuses" to answer prayers in those situations.
2. God is imaginary and does not answer prayers at all. In every case where it appears that God
"answers" a prayer, it truly is nothing more than a coincidence.
One problem with the first explanation is that it contradicts what Jesus teaches about prayer in the Bible. Jesus
says that he answers payers. He never says, "don't pray to me unless the situation you are praying about is
ambiguous." Another problem with the first situation is that it is possible to analyse any prayer with statistics,
meaning that God cannot answer any prayer.
In other words, we reach the same conclusion: God is imaginary.
Incredibly Interesting
Whether you are religious or not, you have to admit that what we see here is incredibly interesting. Despite the
fact that billions of people around the world believe in God, in this chapter we have seen a credible piece of
evidence that indicates that God is imaginary.
We also have many other pieces of evidence that indicate the same thing. Let's step back and look at several
of them.
First of all, we have this fact: there is no scientific evidence indicating that God exists. We all know that. For
example, God has never left behind any physical evidence that shows that he is real. None of Jesus' miracles
left behind any physical evidence either. God has never taken over all the TV and radio stations and broadcast
a message to mankind. There is the Bible, but as we will see in Section 2 the Bible has problems of its own.
And so on. So let's agree that there is no empirical evidence showing that God exists:
x If we had scientific proof of God's existence, we would talk about the "science of God" rather than
"faith in God".
x If we had scientific proof of God's existence, the study of God would be a scientific endeavor rather
than a theological one.
x If we had scientific proof of God's existence, all religious people would be aligning on the God that had
been scientifically proven to exist.
x Etc.
Second, we have the fact that there is no statistical evidence that God answers prayers. No non-fradulent
scientific study has found any evidence that prayer works. For example, if we have a prayer group pray for
certain people in a hospital but not for others, the people who were prayed for don't get better any faster or live
any longer. The prayers have zero statistical effect. We will discuss this in much more detail in Chapters 6 and
7.
Simply think about the world around you. First, if there were conclusive statistical evidence that God answers
prayers, that would provide scientific evidence that God exists. Second, we can see that there are not two laws
of probability -- one for Chistians who pray and one for everyone else. There is a single law of probability that
applies equally to everyone. Prayers have zero effect in any statistical study.
17
Third, we have quite a bit of daily evidence that also suggests that God
Key Point
is imaginary. For example, there is the paradox of Neva Rogers from
Chapter 1. In this case Neva prays openly to God and then gets shot in
the head four times. There is the paradox of Steve Homel's house, There are not two laws of
where Steve prays and his house is saved. Unfortunately, the 39 other probability -- one for people who
houses on his street are cursed and burn to the ground. That 97.5% pray and one for everyone else.
failure rate for prayer makes it feel like the survival of Steve's house is There is a single law of probability
pure coincidence rather than a miracle. We see paradoxes like that that applies equally to everyone.
constantly, and they all point to the fact that God is imaginary. Prayers have zero effect in any
statistical study.
Fourth, we have the fact that all of the gods of the past truly were
imaginary. We all know with certainty that the Egyptian gods, the Roman gods and the Aztec gods were
completely fictitious. Otherwise we would not have started to worship Jesus. We would be worshiping Ra or
Zeus rather than Jesus if Ra or Zeus were real.
Now we can start adding pieces of new evidence showing us that God does not exist. For example, we have
the case of amputees as described in this chapter. If God is real, it is apparent that there is something very odd
about amputees. God is supposedly answering millions of prayers on earth every day, but he completely
ignores amputated limbs and refuses to restore them. That makes no sense according to the Standard Model
of God and Jesus' statements in the Bible. God's treatment of amputees is inexplicable if God exists, but
makes a lot of sense if God is imaginary.
We have all of this evidence to show that God is imaginary. If we were in a court of law looking at this question,
the judge would quickly rule that God is imaginary. There is no concrete evidence that God is real and lots of
evidence that he is imaginary.
If you are a thoughtful, curious person, the case of amputees really makes you wonder: Is God real or is he
imaginary? Let's try looking at another example and see if it sheds any light on this situation...
Chapter 6 - Why do you need health insurance?
As discussed in Chapter 5, amputees are fascinating. The thing that makes the situation with amputees so
interesting is the fact that God treats amputees in such a consistent way. God never answers the prayers of
amputees to restore their lost limbs. It is not like God occasionally regenerates a leg. God never regenerates
legs spontaneously, even though he clearly has promised to do so in the Bible and has the omnipotent ability
to do so according to the Standard Model of God.
Consistency is key. When we see that God consistently ignores the prayers of amputees, it is an important
piece of data.
The meaning of amputees
In this chapter, I would like to suggest two conclusions that we can draw from the way that God treats
amputees. These two suggestions may seem completely ridiculous when you first hear them. What I would
ask, however, is that you give me one moment to explain.
Here is what God's treatment of amputees suggests:
x First, the evidence with amputees suggests that God does not answer any medical prayers at all. It is
not just that God ignores amputees. It is that God ignores every medical prayer. Amputees suggest
that all medical miracles are an illusion.
x Second, the evidence suggests that you already know this. While you do not admit it to yourself
consciously, at the subconscious level you already know that God does not answer any medical
prayers. Furthermore, you are acting on that knowledge every day.
As I said, I realize that this seems ridiculous. So let me lay out the whole argument for you with one simple
18
A bacterium is nothing but a set of chemical reactions. When those reactions stop, the cell is dead.
Now here is the question: When the bacterium dies, does it go to heaven?
I know what you are thinking: "Does it go to heaven??? Of course not!!!" It does not matter who you are -- religious or not.
There are not many people in the United States who believe that bacteria go to heaven. The Bible does not talk about
heaven being filled with all the disease, putrefaction and pestilence that bacteria cause. And what, exactly, would go to
heaven? Do all of the bacterium's molecules get transported to heaven so that they can keep reacting? If that were
happening, there would be thousands of tons of chemicals leaving earth every day. Obviously bacteria do not go to
heaven.
Next let's look at a mosquito. A mosquito is much more complex than a bacterium cell. For one thing, a mosquito is a
multi-cellular insect with some amazing (though annoying) capabilities. But if you look at each cell in a mosquito, it is very
much like a bacterium in its basic functioning. A cell in a mosquito is a fascinating series of DNA-based chemical reactions
-- nothing more. When those chemical reactions cease, the mosquito dies.
Mosquitoes obviously do not go to heaven. Think of how many mosquitoes have lived and died over the course of millions
of years. No one imagines heaven being full of septillions of everlasting mosquitoes.
What about a mouse? Ditto. Mouse cells are little chemical factories churning away. They are fascinating, but they are
soulless and inert. Mice do not go to heaven -- if they did, then heaven would be overrun with quadrillions of mice.
What about dogs? Lots of vets and pet owners would argue with you here, but dogs do not go to heaven either. When
they die, they die.
What about chimps -- the closest living relatives to humans? Ditto.
So what about humans?
The human body is nothing but a set of chemical reactions. The chemical reactions powering a human life are no different
from the reactions powering the life of a bacterium, a mosquito, a mouse, a dog or a chimp. When a human being dies,
the chemical reactions stop. There is no "soul" mixed in with the chemicals, just like there is no soul in a bacterium, a
mosquito, a mouse, a dog or a chimp. There is no afterlife, no heaven or hell, for the chemicals that make up a human
body.
This concept -- this idea that a human being simply ceases to exist upon death -- drives many people absolutely nuts.
They cannot imagine it. "Me? Die? I am going to totally cease to exist? All my thoughts, all my experiences, all my
relationships, all of my ideas and memories… It all simply vanishes and I am gone? Impossible!!!" Nonetheless, that is the
reality of the situation.
You are a collection of chemical reactions. When these chemical reactions cease, you die. When you die, "you" cease to
exist. Imagining eternal life and creating a fantasy called "heaven" does not change anything. When you die, you are
dead.
Talking to Christians
If you talk to a Christian about the reality of death, you can clearly understand that the notion of heaven and everlasting
life is imaginary. Each conversation will be different, but a typical conversation might go something like this:
Christian: What you are saying is completely devoid of hope! Jesus transcends death and promises eternal life to
all who believe in him! Lift up your heart to the Lord Jesus Christ and he will give you eternal life!
Norm: OK, how will he do that?
Christian: Have you ever read the book called "Left Behind?"
99
For some reason, many people find death terrifying and mystifying. Throughout the ages this terror has been a constant. question. The question is this:
You can go all the way back to the Neanderthals and find that they buried their dead. They even placed flowers and other If God answers medical prayers, then why do you need health insurance?
artifacts in the grave. This was happening tens of thousands of years ago. Obviously death has been a very big deal for a Simply think it through. If what Jesus says about prayer in the Bible is true, and if all the stories about medical
very long time. miracles in inspirational literature are true, and if the cure of Jeanna Giese is true, and if your belief in God and
the power of prayer is true, and if God has a plan for you, then why do you ever need to visit a doctor or go to
The central feature of the Christian faith, therefore, is "eternal life." In John 3:16 we find the signature verse of Christianity the hospital? Why don't you simply pray for a cure whenever you get sick? In fact, why not pray preemptively
on this topic: every day -- "Dear God, I have faith that you will protect me from all illnesses today, Amen" -- and go through
your life completely healthy?
"For God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten son, that whosoever believes in him shall not perish
but have eternal life." The reason I ask this is because the statement that Jesus makes in Mark 11:24 is so simple:
By believing in Jesus, you can have life everlasting. This is the promise of Christianity.
Therefore I tell you, whatever you ask for in prayer, believe that you have received it, and it will be
If you are terrified by the idea of death, you can imagine that the promise of "eternal life" is quite compelling. This is one of yours.
the fundamental reasons why so many people turn to religion. So is what he says in John 14:14:
If you ask anything in my name, I will do it.
There is only one problem: "eternal life" is a fabrication. The Bible is a fictional book written by primitive men (see section There is this statement in Psalms chapter 41:
1
2), so its promise of eternal life is make-believe. Blessed is he who has regard for the weak;
the Lord delivers him in times of trouble.
2
The Lord will protect him and preserve his life;
The reality of the human condition is quite simple, and it is this: the time that we have on earth is all the time that we have.
he will bless him in the land
For many people this idea is terrifying, but it is a fact of life:
and not surrender him to the desire of his foes.
3
The Lord will sustain him on his sickbed
x There is neither heaven nor hell. These two places are fairy tale worlds that spring from the human imagination. and restore him from his bed of illness.
x You do not have an "everlasting soul." The concept of a soul is completely imaginary. In Mark 16, Jesus talks about the laying on of hands:
16
x People do not have "eternal life" after their deaths. The whole notion of eternal life is a fantasy. He who believes and is baptized will be saved; but he who does not believe will be condemned. 17
x People do not meet back up with dead friends and family members in the afterlife, nor is there any reincarnation. And these signs will accompany those who believe: in my name they will cast out demons; they will
x There are not 72 virgins waiting for you in heaven if you martyr yourself in a suicide bombing. speak in new tongues; 18 they will pick up serpents, and if they drink any deadly thing, it will not hurt
x And so on... them; they will lay their hands on the sick, and they will recover.
But even more remarkable is James 5:15, where the Bible says:
All of it is imaginary. The truth is this simple: When you die, you die. And the prayer offered in faith will make the sick person well; the Lord will raise him up.
These are powerful verses. Keep in mind, according to the Standard Model of God, that these are the words of
an all-powerful, all-knowing, perfect God. And James 5:15 is completely unambiguous. If these words are true
Some people have a tremendous amount of trouble getting their arms around this fact of life. Chances are that you have
and perfect, it seems like a faithful person should have no need for health insurance.
heard about "eternal life" and your "everlasting soul" since you were a toddler. Heaven is as deeply ingrained in you as is
your native language. Nonetheless, "everlasting life" is imaginary. Let's look at the evidence so that you can better
understand this. A conversation about God

Understanding the chemistry of life
It should be obvious to all of us that "eternal life" is imaginary. Simply by understanding the chemistry of life you can see
why life after death is impossible.
To understand how death works, we can start with a bacterium cell. A bacterium is a tiny bag (a cell membrane) filled with
a variety of molecules. These molecules react together in different ways to create what we call life. Some of the molecules
react to build and repair the cell wall. Some of the molecules react in ways that allow the cell to move. Some of the
molecules react to provide energy to the cell. And so on. A bacterium cell is a little chemical machine.
What reason would a perfect God have for making false statements in the Bible? Yet, by owning health
insurance, you demonstrate to yourself that something in these verses is amiss. You may find yourself in
conversations like this:
Norm: Does God answer your prayers?
Chris: Yes, of course. I have a strong personal relationship with God. I pray to him many times each
day. Jesus hears my prayers and, through his grace and the grace of the Holy Spirit, my prayers are
answered. I am blessed every day by God.

One of the molecules inside a bacterium cell is a long DNA strand. There are molecules floating around the DNA strand
that are able to copy parts of the DNA to manufacture new molecules that the cell needs.
Although all of these molecules are reacting in fascinating, interlocking ways, they are still nothing more than chemicals
reacting. The "miracle of life" is no miracle -- it is a big chemical reaction.
Let's say that a foreign molecule gets into the bacterium cell and it gums up a part of the DNA chemistry. Or let's say that
something damages the DNA strand in the bacterium so the cell can no longer manufacture an important molecule that it
needs. Eventually the chemical reactions inside the bacterium will stop. The cell "dies." Its cell wall breaks down and
bursts. All of the chemicals inside the cell float away and the bacterium ceases to exist.
Norm: So if you prayed to Jesus for something, would he answer your prayer?
Chris: Yes. Of course. Jesus promises in the Bible that he answers prayers. We see prayers being
answered constantly.
Norm: Why pay for health insurance if you can pray and God will cure you? Why do people need
doctors, prescriptions and hospitals?
Chris: Sometimes it is not God's will to answer prayers.
Norm: But in John 14:14, Jesus says, "If you ask anything in my name, I will do it." James 5:15 says,

98 19
 "The prayer offered in faith will make the sick person well." Why would God ignore your prayers?
Chris: God is not some Santa in the sky. He does not answer prayers like that.
Norm: Didn't you just say that God answers prayers? In the Bible, doesn't Jesus promise to answer
prayers?
Chris: God does answer prayers. I can show you millions of examples of God answering prayers. I
have 20 books on my shelf at home filled with answered prayers.
Norm: Then why do you need health insurance?
Chris: Because, sometimes, it is not God's will to answer a prayer.
Norm: Why do you say that? "The prayer offered in faith will make the sick person well" is completely
unambiguous. But when you pray for a cure, in a lot of cases nothing happens. Doesn't that mean that
Jesus is lying?
Chris: No. Jesus is perfect so Jesus cannot lie. When God does not answer a prayer, it is not part of
his plan.
Norm: So you go to the doctor anyway?
Chris: Yes. Of course I do.
Norm: Aren't you defying God's will? Aren't you ruining God's plan?
Chris: No. God does not intend for me to be sick.
Norm: Then why doesn't God answer your prayers and cure you himself?
Chris: There is no way that we can understand the mysteries of our Lord.
I imagine that you can see the problem in this conversation. The problem is that we cannot trust God with
something important like health care. God is completely random when he is "answering" prayers. That is why
people need health insurance.
Praying for a cure
When people are sick, they often pray to God for a cure. This is especially true in the case of profound, life-
threatening illnesses and chronic diseases. We've all heard the stories of amazing cures and medical miracles
that have come through prayer. For example, here is a story from a housewife in Santa Monica:
"I went to the doctor, and he told me that I had cancer of the uterus. One solution, according to my
doctor, was a radical hysterectomy. But he wanted to try chemotherapy first, just in case. For me, my
only goal in life was to have children, and I could not let the doctor make me sterile with a
hysterectomy. That very day I got down on my knees and I prayed to God for a miracle. I read every
passage of the Bible that had anything to do with healing, and I wrote them all down on index cards
that I carried with me everywhere. I recited the verses, and I prayed whenever I had a spare minute --
Whether I was waiting at a stop light or for my husband to come home for dinner, I was praying and
reciting those verses. And you know what? The good Lord cured me. I started on chemotherapy. At
the very next visit, my doctor noticed a change. At my next visit he said, 'Let's postpone the surgery
and see what happens.' A year later he could no longer detect the tumor, and he declared me cured. I
knew in my heart -- it was the power of those scripture verses. God answered my prayers and cured
me."
If you subscribe to Guideposts magazine you can read a new story like this just about every month. Even big
20
Many christians are so polarized and so sensitive right now that they will crush anyone with an opinion contrary to their
own. Once branded as an atheist, the candidate is attacked in the public forum.
Then look at the rest of the world. In many Islamic countries, women cannot freely choose how they dress, much less
what they do, where they work or how they behave. They often cannot even drive a car. The repression of women's
freedom in Islamic countries is well known, and ridiculous.
There really is only one solution. It is time for Americans, both religious and non, to openly discuss the evidence showing
that God is imaginary. Let's stop hiding the discussion, or attacking it. Let's talk openly. Let us have an honest, open,
rational, civil conversation about all of the evidence that we have seen in this book.
If we have that debate in an open forum, the majority of us will reach agreement that God is imaginary. The reason why
we will come to that conclusion is because the evidence, as presented in this book, overwhelmingly favors it.
We must also recognize as a society that there is no such thing as an atheist. We must end the branding and the name-
calling. Click here for details.
Reason #3: Understanding why people create religions
What I am proposing to you in this book is both quite profound and quite baffling. It is this: Everything that we associate
with religion is imaginary. God, the Bible, Jesus, the resurrection, prayer, the Ten Commandments, the creation story,
your soul, everlasting life, heaven... every bit of it is the product of human imagination. The same goes for Allah, the
Koran and so on. As a species we have believed all of this religious dogma for centuries, and most of us believe it today
to some degree. And yet... it is all fiction. It is just as fictional as were the gods of the Egyptians, the Romans and the
Aztecs. We have seen 25 chapters of clear, unambiguous evidence and all of it supports this conclusion.
If it is so obvious that God is imaginary, then why might half of the American population profess belief in God? We have
asked this question throughout the book because the whole situation is profoundly strange. Why would we, as a species,
create all of this mythology and nonsense over and over again through the millennia? We must do it for a reason.
If we can understand the reasons and deal with them rationally rather than through the silliness and mythology that is
religion, we actually can do ourselves a great deal of good.
There are two important reasons why humans fabricate all of our religions:
1. People invent God as a way to cope with death. Many humans are terrified by death for some reason. They invent
religion as a way to deal with their terror.
2. People invent God as a proxy for goodness. People want a way to promote "goodness" and eliminate "evil" in
their societies. In the past, inventing an imaginary God has been perceived to be one way to facilitate that
process.
Death and goodness are important to people. They touch on fundamental human emotions. If we can separate death and
goodness from the mythology of God so that we can understand them and work with them in a positive way, we can
actually do something very helpful. We can create a rational world for ourselves that is focused on benefiting mankind.
In chapter 27 and chapter 28, we will talk about death and goodness. We need to understand the reasons why we
fabricate our gods and then act on these reasons rationally.
Once we understand why we create religion, we can begin creating the social structures that will replace religion. The
remainder of the book discusses this process.
Chapter 27 - When you die, you die
Death is a central feature of every human life. As we live, we know that we will die.
97
Let's ignore the danger that can be found in the ashes of 9/11/2001, and the subsequent events in Afghanistan, Iraq,
Madrid and London. There are many zealous and misguided Muslims who believe that, through Jihad, they must kill non-
Muslims -- Christians and Jews in particular. Let's ignore that.
Let's ignore the ill effects of religion around the world over the last several decades. We have Muslims killing Christians
(and vice versa), Jews killing Muslims (and vice versa), Protestants killing Catholics (and vice versa), Shiites killing Sunnis
(and vice versa), etc., etc. All of it is completely pointless, because all human gods are imaginary. But let's ignore all of
that killing and destruction.
Let's also ignore all of the insanity that religion has brought us through the ages -- the crusades, the witch hunts and all
the rest. Let's ignore it because it's all water under the bridge.
Even in the United States -- a modern, advanced nation -- religion creates problems. The delusion created by Christianity
is so extreme and so pervasive at the moment that we have Supreme Court justices and politicians who publicly claim that
God handed down the Ten Commandments to us in the Bible (see chapter 13). These justices and politicians are
speaking about a book that openly advocates slavery and misogyny along with many other notions that are beyond
absurd. Yet no one can question their claims in public because it is far too dangerous (see next section for details).
To have otherwise intelligent Americans babbling on about an imaginary God like this is dangerous, if for no other reason
than this one: If so many people are this delusional in the area of religion, it makes you wonder where else they harbor
equally significant delusions in their thinking. In addition, religion in America is now actively restraining scientific research
and social progress. The problem that American scientists are having with stem cells is just one of the many
manifestations of the problem today.
There is also growing evidence that the delusion of religion may cause significant social dysfunction. Statistical research
is revealing the problems that go with religious delusion. For example, a recent article in the Journal of Religion and
Society points out that religion is correlated to the significant social difficulties that we can see in America:
In general, higher rates of belief in and worship of a creator correlate with higher rates of homicide, juvenile and
early adult mortality, STD infection rates, teen pregnancy, and abortion in the prosperous democracies (Figures 1-
9). The most theistic prosperous democracy, the U.S., is exceptional, but not in the manner Franklin predicted.
The United States is almost always the most dysfunctional of the developed democracies, sometimes
spectacularly so, and almost always scores poorly. The view of the U.S. as a “shining city on the hill” to the rest of
the world is falsified when it comes to basic measures of societal health. [ref]
The prevailing view is that religion is harmless even if it is delusional. That turns out not to be the case. America is the
most religious country of those studied in the developed world. America also has the biggest problems in terms of things
like homicide, juvenile and early adult mortality, STD infection rates, teen pregnancy, and abortion.
Religion is delusion. A planet full of delusional people is not healthy.
Reason #2: We must freely discuss the delusion of religion
It is time for Americans, both
religious and non, to openly
Religion creates significant free-speech and free-thinking issues both here in the United discuss the evidence showing that
States and around the world. Let me help you to understand what I mean when I say God is imaginary. Let's stop
that, and offer a solution to the problem. hiding the discussion, or
attacking it. Let's talk openly. Let
Let's imagine that any normal, intelligent American were to stand up in public today and us have an honest, open, rational,
say something like this: "I do not believe that an all-powerful, all-loving, all-knowing God civil conversation about all of the
wrote the Bible or the Ten Commandments. The reason why I don't believe it is because evidence that we have seen in this
the Bible openly advocates slavery and misogyny in both the Old and New Testaments. book. If we have that debate in an
God could not love slavery or hate women." See section 2 for details on his statement. open forum, the majority of us
will reach agreement that God is
Within seconds of making this honest, completely rational statement, that American will imaginary.
be branded as an atheist.
In today's America, being branded as an atheist is poisonous. It is as poisonous as being branded during the McCarthy
era in the 1950s. Imagine someone who has been branded as an atheist trying to run for public office in America today.
96
city newspapers and national magazines report on these stories now. The story of Jeanna Giese in the
previous chapter is a perfect example of the process.
There are two questions that we should ask based on this story:
1. Why did our housewife from Santa Monica need chemotherapy if God was going to cure her anyway?
God is all-powerful, so his cure should be instant and free of side-effects.
2. On the flip side, if "God's plan" were for her to have a hysterectomy, what point is there in her praying?
God's plan comes from an all-powerful being and it is going to run its course no matter what we do.
What good is it to pray in such a situation? (we will discuss God's plan in much more detail in Chapter
8)
If you think about these two questions and how they interact with each other, you will realize something
important. If God exists, and if God answers prayers, and if God has a plan for each of us, then there is no
point in ever visiting a doctor. Owning health insurance is a complete waste of money. The reason is easy to
see: Either God will or will not answer any prayer for healing. If he does answer the prayer, there is no need for
a doctor. If he does not, then God's plan is for you to be sick. Since God is omnipotent, no amount of doctoring
will change the outcome of God's plan. Seeing a doctor is a waste of time.
Understanding Jesus
If you are a believer and if you have your Bible nearby, we can look at your health care policy from another
angle. Turn to Matthew 6:25-34. Jesus says:
Therefore I tell you, do not worry about your life, what you will eat or drink; or about your body, what
you will wear. Is not life more important than food, and the body more important than clothes? Look at
the birds of the air; they do not sow or reap or store away in barns, and yet your heavenly Father feeds
them. Are you not much more valuable than they? Who of you by worrying can add a single hour to his
life? "And why do you worry about clothes? See how the lilies of the field grow. They do not labor or
spin. Yet I tell you that not even Solomon in all his splendor was dressed like one of these. If that is
how God clothes the grass of the field, which is here today and tomorrow is thrown into the fire, will he
not much more clothe you, O you of little faith? So do not worry, saying, 'What shall we eat?' or 'What
shall we drink?' or 'What shall we wear?' For the pagans run after all these things, and your heavenly
Father knows that you need them. But seek first his kingdom and his righteousness, and all these
things will be given to you as well. Therefore do not worry about tomorrow, for tomorrow will worry
about itself.
[If you would like to read a theological analysis of Jesus' statement, turn to this page.]
Jesus' statement is utterly clear: "Therefore do not worry about tomorrow, for tomorrow will worry about itself."
Yet health insurance is a physical manifestation of worry. You buy health insurance because you are worried
about your health tomorrow.
The question to ask yourself, therefore, is simple: If you are a believer, why you need health insurance? Or, for
that matter, car insurance, life insurance or home owner's insurance? Why are you worrying about your health
in the future when: A) Jesus has told you specifically not to worry (Matthew 6:34), and B) Jesus has promised
to cure any illness that arises (James 5:15)? In addition, why are you worrying about money, which is what
health insurance is all about, when in Matthew 6:19 Jesus specifically says:
Do not lay up for yourselves treasures on earth, where moth and rust destroy and where thieves break
in and steal; but lay up for yourselves treasures in heaven, where neither moth nor rust destroys and
where thieves do not break in and steal. For where your treasure is, there your heart will be also.
In Matthew 19:21 Jesus goes even further, telling you to sell everything and give the money to the poor.
Obviously he intended for you to give up your health insurance policy and give its monthly payment to the poor
as well.
21

And then there is Poverbs 3:5-8:
Trust in the Lord with all your heart and lean not on your own understanding; in all your ways
acknowledge him, and he will make your paths straight. Do not be wise in your own eyes; fear the Lord
and shun evil. This will bring health to your body and nourishment to your bones.
Why do you own a health insurance policy when you are supposed to be putting your trust in the Lord, who will
bring health to your body?
Everything the Bible says is very clear. Why are you ignoring everything that it tells you to do?
Here is a possibility for you to consider. Is it possible that you are completely ignoring the Bible because, in
your heart, you know that God is imaginary? What other reason is there for you, as a believer, to ignore him so
profoundly by owning health insurance?
A hidden God
What may be running through your mind right now is the following: "You do not understand God at all. God
must remain hidden. If he answered our medical prayers, it would destroy faith. That is why we need doctors."
As discussed in the last chapter, this argument has several problems:
x First, as discussed in the previous chapter, there is no evidence that God wants to remain hidden. God
parted the Red Sea. God carved his commandments into stone tablets with his own finger. God
incarnated himself in the form of Jesus, who then performed millions of miracles on earth to prove that
he is God (see Chapter 19 for a complete discussion).
x Second, if God answers any prayer, it would destroy faith. In the case of our Santa Monica housewife,
she has had her faith destroyed. Therefore, under the "hidden God" theory, God can not answer any
prayers without blowing his cover.
x Third, any medical miracle that God performs today is obvious because we have so much advanced
technology. The removal of a cancerous tumor, for example, is obvious because it is measurable. One
month the tumor is visible to everyone on the X-ray, and the next month it is not. If God eliminated the
tumor, then it is openly obvious to everyone who sees the X-ray. There is nothing "hidden" about
removing a tumor.
x Another example is seen in Jeanne's rabies case. Tens of millions of people are aware of the Jeanna's
rabies miracle. Personally, I read about it in a big article in my morning newspaper. That is pretty
obvious. What is hidden about her recovery? God has unmasked himself to tens of millions of people.
Another common explanation that you might hear is, "God is not a gumball machine. He is under no obligation
to answer prayers. God helps those who help themselves. Therefore, when you get sick you go to a doctor.
That is what God demands that we do." See Understanding the gumball machine for details on this line of
reasoning.
What if, instead of assuming that God is trying to hide or that God is refusing to be a gumball machine, we
assume that God is imaginary?
Understanding reality
Let's simply look at an example. Imagine that the rate of remission for some particularly nasty type of cancer is
5%. That means that if 20 people get this type of cancer, it is almost always fatal. Only one in 20 of the people
who get the disease will survive. Knowing this, you can see the reality:
x 20 people contract the disease
x All of them have read James 5:15, so all of them pray.
x 19 of them die
x The one who lives proclaims, "I prayed to the Lord and the Lord answered my prayers! My disease is
cured! It is a miracle! I KNEW God would answer my prayers!"
22
It is also interesting to note that, by proving any one of these things, we have automatically proven the other two. For
example, once we know that the Bible was written by primitive men rather than God, then it is automatic that God does
not answer prayers and that Jesus was a completely normal human being. The Bible is the book that tells us about prayer
and Jesus, so if the Bible is meaningless then prayer and Jesus are meaningless as well. The fact is that we have proven
all three things separately. Jesus is not God, the Bible is not the word of God, and God never answers prayers. These
three things are true, therefore, both directly and by association.
Understanding your delusion
In this book there is a tremendous amount of evidence showing us that God is imaginary. You have just seen 25 chapters
of good, solid, easily-digested evidence. It would be easy to present a hundred more chapters just like them. The
evidence is all around us.
On the other hand, there is no evidence showing that God is real. A Christian can point to prayer, but it is easy to disprove
the efficacy of prayer with statistical analysis (see Section 1). A Christian can point to the Bible, but it is easy to show the
myriad problems with the Bible (see Section 2). There is no verifiable evidence for Christians to present.
Is God real, or is he imaginary? At this point, we have our answer. We can look at all of this evidence and we can see that
God is imaginary. Christianity is a delusion. Religion in general is a delusion.
I understand that the word "delusion" is uncomfortable. However, it is the correct word in the English language to use. The
dictionary defines "delusion" in the following way:
A false belief strongly held in spite of invalidating evidence. [ref]
The invalidating evidence is all around us. Chances are that you have known it for many years, but you have been unable
to face the reality of the situation. (In Chapter 27 we will discuss why it is so terrifying to face reality.)
When I say that religion is a delusion, I am not intending that in an insulting way or a derogatory way. Instead, I am
speaking to you as a friend would. My goal here is not to criticize you for your religious beliefs, but instead to help you to
recover from your delusion.
I know what you are thinking. If you are a Christian, you are thinking, "I am not delusional. Christ is the way, the truth and
the life." What if I could show you your delusion? What if I could hold up a mirror that would allow you to see your own
delusion in the reflection? If you would like to clearly see how the delusion of Christianity works, please read
Understanding Delusion.
All religion is delusion. With any luck you can see that now, and you can start down the road to recovery -- you can begin
the process of healing that will free you from your own personal delusions.
What does it mean?
There are three reasons why it is important for us to speak honestly and openly about the delusion of religion:
1. Religion truly is a delusion. By allowing this delusional behavior to persist unchallenged, we do ourselves
damage.
2. We currently have significant free-speech and free-thinking issues around religion.
3. It is time for us, as an intelligent species, to understand the reasons why human beings invent religions, and to
begin addressing those reasons rationally rather than delusionally.
Each of these points is important. Let's look at them one by one so that we can understand what they mean.
Reason #1: Religion truly is delusional
Let's start by asking a question: Does it matter? In this book we have proven, conclusively, that God does not answer
prayers, that God did not write the Bible and that Jesus is not God. In other words, the God of popular religion is
imaginary. But does it really matter? What difference does it make if half of the people in the United States want to believe
in an imaginary being? What does it hurt?
95
Here is the thing that I would like to help you understand. If we assume that God exists, then each of these questions
presents us with its own individual mystery. Each question creates a paradox that requires excuses, rationalizations and
convoluted explanations. These paradoxes and rationalizations are extremely uncomfortable because they make no
sense. If we assume that God exists, then God is ridiculous.
On the other hand, if we assume that God is imaginary, then all of these questions are very easy to answer. Our world
makes complete sense.
What you realize, if you take the time to probe into your religion and think about it deeply, is that all of this evidence is
telling you something important. It is telling you, clearly and concisely, that God is imaginary.
If you are a Christian, I realize that your immediate reaction may be to completely ignore what you have read here and
turn away from it. Rather than turning away, however, I would ask you to examine all of the evidence that you have seen
in this book. Think about the questions at the top of this page. Give your mind permission to understand what the
evidence actually means. Allow your brain to analyze your religion rationally. What you will find is that all of this evidence
points in the same direction: God is imaginary.
Reviewing the evidence
In this book we have looked at God from many different angles. What we have found is that there is no evidence for God's
existence. God does not answer prayers. God did not write the Bible. God has not incarnated himself. In other words, God
is imaginary.
How do we know, for sure, that God does not answer prayers? As described in section 1, we simply pray and watch what
happens. What we find is that nothing happens. No matter how many people pray, no matter how often they pray, no
matter how sincerely they pray, no matter how worthy the prayer, nothing ever happens. If we pray for anything that is
impossible -- for example, regenerating an amputated limb or moving Mt. Everest to Newark, NJ -- it never happens. We
all know that. If we pray for anything that is possible, the results of the prayer will unfold in exact accord with the normal
laws of probability. It is easy to demonstrate this fact. For example, if we ask 1,000 devout Christians to pray that a coin
toss come up heads, and we then have all one thousand of the Christians flip a coin one time, about 500 of them will see
their coins land tails. If we repeat the experiment, the same thing will happen. In every situation where we statistically
analyze the effects of prayers, looking at both the success AND the failure of prayer, we find that prayer has zero effect.
That happens, always, because God is imaginary. Every time a Christian says, "The Lord answered my prayer," what we
are seeing instead is a simple coincidence. Christians never talk about failed prayers, but if we look at all the prayers that
fail as well as the prayers that work, a statistical analysis proves that God does not answer prayers. See section 1 for
details.
How do we know, for sure, that God did not write the Bible? As discussed in section 2, we simply read the Bible and note
how uncomfortable it is in so many places. We note that God is a huge proponent of slavery in the Bible, despite our
absolute certainty as normal human beings that slavery is a moral abomination. We note that God is a huge misogynist in
the Bible, despite our certainty that misogyny is a moral abomination as well. We note that God kills huge numbers of
babies and small children in the Bible, and we know that this is both an atrocity and horrifically disgusting. We note that
God, who is supposed to be all-knowing, knows no more than the primitive men who actually wrote the Bible. And so on.
Anyone who takes the time to actually read the Bible rapidly reaches the conclusion that the Bible was written by primitive
men, not by an all-knowing God. See section 2 for details.
How do we know, for sure, that Jesus was a normal human being? As described in section 3, we can ask this simple
question: If a man were to proclaim himself to be the son of God today, what would we do? We would want to see
incontrovertible proof. Jesus does not get a pass because he lived 2,000 years ago. We note the fact that none of Jesus'
miracles left any lasting evidence. For example, even though Jesus proclaimed that anyone can move a mountain, we
note that no one -- not even Jesus -- has moved a mountain. All of Jesus' miracles are either faith healings or magic
tricks, and we all know that faith healers and magicians are frauds. We also note that there is no evidence that Jesus is
resurrected. Jesus could easily appear to each of us in the flesh to prove that he is resurrected, just as he did with Paul.
Yet Jesus never does that. If he did, there would be thousands of videos floating around on the Web showing Jesus'
appearances. We note that Jesus says dozens of things in the Bible that are plainly wrong. We note that even though
Jesus is the all-powerful creator of the universe and promises to answer prayers, all of his churches depend on the money
of mere mortals to support themselves. And so on. It is obvious that Jesus was a man like any other. See section 3 for
details.
94
x You never hear about the 19 who died. No one ever writes about that in a magazine. "Person prays,
then dies" is not a great headline. And since they are dead, you will never hear from any of the people
who had a deadly experience with prayer.
x Therefore, if you don't look at all the facts around the "answered prayer," and you only hear about the
one out of twenty prayers that succeed, it appears that prayer is successful.
The fact is, people who pray die from this disease at exactly the same rate as people who do not.
We can see the reality of this situation simply by opening our eyes. But we do have to open our eyes -- We
have to look at both the successes AND the failures of prayer to see the reality of our world. When we take a
scientific approach and we do look at both sides, we see what is really happening.
When a prayer is answered, what is happening? It is nothing but a coincidence. We know this without a doubt
in two different ways:
x If we look at disease remission rates for praying people vs. non-praying people, and we control for all
variables like income, known risk factors, etc., disease remission rates for the two groups are identical.
People who pray for a cure gain no advantage from prayer.
x We can take 200 sick people. With 100 of them we create a prayer circle and we pray for them. With
the other 100 we do not. Then we look at what happens to those two groups of people. We find that
both groups have the same outcome. The prayed-for group does not recuperate faster or live longer.
You can pick any disease. If you analyze both the successes AND the failures of prayer, you will find the same
thing. It does not matter how many people pray, how often they pray, how sincere they are or how devout and
worthy the patient is. It simply is a fact that, statistically, God ignores all medical prayers. Plenty of scientific
studies confirm it, as shown in this article:
In the largest study of its kind, researchers found that having people pray for heart bypass surgery
patients had no effect on their recovery. In fact, patients who knew they were being prayed for had a
slightly higher rate of complications.
See also this page.
Yes, there are people who do pray and live, and their stories sound convincing. But the only reason that they
sound convincing is because the millions of people who pray and die never get to tell their stories.
Revisiting Jeanna
What about the miracle of Jeanna Giese discussed in Chapter 5? Didn't God interact with her body and
miraculously cure her rabies because of her gigantic prayer circle? How did that work? It worked because, if
Jeanna had died, the story of her prayer circle never would have appeared in the paper. People do assemble
gigantic prayer circles that fail. It happens all the time. But you never hear about them, so it appears that
prayer circles always work.
How can we know, for sure, that Jeanna's prayer circle was a coincidence? Let's assume that it was Jeanna's
prayer circle that did cure her. Millions of people prayed, God heard the prayer and God actually did cure
Jeanna. In that case, the prayer circle missed an incredible opportunity. What the prayer circle prayed was
this:
Dear God, Please cure Jeanna, Amen.
What they could have prayed is this:
Dear God, Please eliminate the disease of rabies worldwide, Amen.
This second prayer would have cured Jeanna, and it would have also helped countless other people and
animals around the world. It would have ensured that no one, ever again, would be afflicted with rabies.
Even if you believe in God, I think we can agree that the second prayer would not work. We know that with
certainty. It is obvious from the evidence that we see all around us. If the second prayer ever worked, then
23
people would have prayed every disease into extinction centuries ago.
Why doesn't the second prayer work? If God actually did answer Jeanna's prayer, why would he not answer
the broader prayer as well? I believe that we all know the answer to that question, even if many of us are not
willing to admit it consciously. The second prayer does not work because the first one did not work either. The
simple fact is that God does not answer medical prayers and Jeanna's cure was a coincidence. The statistics
prove it every time.
The evidence all around us
But this same Bible also tells us that slavery is great, that women should be hated, that animal and human sacrifice is
necessary, and that massacring babies and small children is one of God's favorite pastimes (see Section 2 for details).
We don't believe the Bible when it talks about slavery, misogyny, etc. Why would we believe the Bible when it talks about
Jesus?
Understanding the evidence
There are two options with Jesus. Either Jesus is God, or Jesus was a regular human being. When you look at all of the
evidence, which of these two options seems more likely to you?

If prayer worked as promised by Mark 11:24 and James 5:15, people would not need doctors. We could get
down on our knees and pray to God in this way:
Dear God, almighty, all-powerful, all-loving creator of the universe, we pray to you to cure every
case of cancer on this planet tonight. We pray in faith, knowing you will bless us as you
describe in Matthew 7:7, Matthew 17:20, Matthew 21:21, Mark 11:24, John 14:12-14, Matthew
18:19 and James 5:15-16. In Jesus' name we pray, Amen.
Instead, what we see in our world is this:
If you are a Christian, and if you have believed all your life that Jesus is resurrected and Jesus is God, all that I would ask
you to do is take a few moments to look at all of this evidence. See also chapter 27 to understand where your beliefs
about Jesus may be coming from.
Chapter 26 - What does it all mean?
Let us pause for a moment and review the evidence that we have seen in the prior 25 chapters. If God exists, how do we
explain all of the different things that we have seen?

x As a nation, the people of America are spending approximately two trillion dollars on health care every 1. How do we explain the death of Neva Rogers? (see Chapter 1)
year. None of that money would need to be spent if God truly answered prayers as he promises in 2. How do we explain the 39 houses that were destroyed on Pinecastle Street? (see Chapter 2)
James 5:15. 3. How do we explain the death of Ranika? (see Chapter 4)
x Pharmaceutical companies are making hundreds of billions of dollars selling thousands of drugs and 4. How do we explain the way that God ignores amputees? (see Chapter 5)
medications to handle medical problems. If God truly answered prayers, we would not need any of 5. How do we explain the fact that Christians need health insurance? (see Chapter 6)
those drugs. 6. How do we explain the fact that you cannot move a mountain? (see Chapter 7)
x In every city there are huge hospitals filled with patients. If God truly answered prayers, we would not 7. How do we explain the fact that bad things consistently happen to good people? (see Chapter 8)
need any of these hospitals. 8. How do we explain God's plan? (see Chapter 8)
x If you look at both the successes AND the failures of prayer, statistical studies show no benefit from 9. How do we explain the fact that Christians who pray have exactly the same odds of winning in Las Vegas as
prayer. people who don't pray? (see Chapter 9)
x And everyone you know has health insurance, including you. 10. How do we explain the fact that so many people die on battlefields when all of them are praying? (see Chapter
10)
In other words, what your common sense tells you, and what statistical analysis of disease and prayer tells 11. How do we explain the fact that God is a huge proponent of slavery? (see Chapter 13)
you, and what the overwhelming evidence in the world all around us tells you, and what your own personal 12. How do we explain God's statement in Exodus 21:20 where he says, "If a man beats his male or female slave
health insurance policy tells you, is that God does not answer medical prayers. with a rod... he is not to be punished if the slave gets up after a day or two, since the slave is his property." How
can God encourage humans to beat other humans? (see Chapter 13)
If prayer did work, then both your hospital and your insurance company would have a Department of Prayer, 13. How do we explain the fact that Exodus 21, where God is telling us it is OK to beat our slaves as long as we do
and they would have employees praying feverishly day and night. Hospitals and insurance companies want to not kill them, is the chapter that immediately follows Exodus 20, where God enumerates the Ten
save lives and save money just as badly as you do. If prayer worked, corporations would be using it every day Commandments? Why would we hold up the Ten Commandments as the immutable and sacred word of God,
without hesitation. while at the same time knowing that Exodus 21 is ridiculous? (see Chapter 13)
14. How do we explain the fact that God demands animal and human sacrifice? (see Chapter 14)
15. How do we explain God's hatred of women? (see Chapter 15)
The response to all of this evidence often is, "You are wrong! God can't answer my prayers. If he did, it would
16. How do we explain the fact that God massacres so many children in the Bible? (see Chapter 16)
take away my free will to believe in him! God must remain hidden." This is the same thing as saying, "God
17. How do we explain the fact that the Bible is so full of irrelevant, incorrect and useless material? (see Chapter 17)
does not answer prayers." If God cannot answer your prayers because it would take away your free will, then
18. How do we explain the fact that the Bible tells us to kill all homosexuals? (see Chapter 17)
God cannot answer any prayers.
19. How do we explain the fact that the Bible is supposedly inspired by an all-knowing being, yet the author of the
Bible knows no more than the primitive men who wrote it? (see Chapter 17)
You can elicit this response quite easily, as seen in the following conversation: 20. How do we explain the fact that Jesus never proved that he is God? (see Chapter 19)
21. How do we explain the fact that Jesus has never appeared to anyone after his death? (see Chapter 20)
Chris: Pray to God and he will answer your prayers! 22. How do we explain the fact that we have to eat Jesus' body and drink his blood? (see Chapter 21)
23. How do we explain the fact that 10 million children die every year of simple things like starvation? (see Chapter
Norm: OK, let's pray together for God to do something concrete right now. 22)
24. How do we explain the fact that Jesus -- the all-powerful, prayer-answering creator of the universe -- needs your
Chris: Oh, now, we can't do that! That would take away our faith in God. God cannot prove that he money? (see Chapter 24)
exists. 25. How do we explain the fact that there are a billion Muslims who think that all the Christians are delusional, and
there are two billion Christians who think all the Muslims are delusional? (see Chapter 25)
Norm: That means God can answer none of your prayers. Any prayer he answers will prove his
How do we answer all of these questions?

24 93
 x I do not have enough faith
x I cannot test the Lord
x Jesus only appeared to the apostles
x Jesus is sitting at the right hand of God, and is no longer appearing on earth
x Jesus is actually all around me, but I cannot see him
x It is not part of Jesus' plan for me
x Jesus will not appear in the flesh, but instead will appear by rearranging the dust motes in the air. But it is not
dusty enough here.
x Jesus will appear in my dreams
x Jesus is here -- I can feel him in my heart
x And on and on and on...
You are an expert at creating rationalizations like these. You have to be, because Jesus constantly lets you down. The
reason why you are an expert is because you have been creating rationalizations like this for Jesus your entire life. Jesus
has disappointed you so many times that you expect to be disappointed. That is why creating this list of rationalizations is
so easy and so natural for you.
But here is the more interesting thing. Let's say that there is some legitimate reason that Jesus did not appear to you. For
example, it turns out that you happened to be wearing blue jeans as you prayed, and Jesus does not like the color blue.
The fact is that the resurrected Jesus has not ever appeared to anyone. Zero people are worthy, or we would see the
video clips for sale at Christian book stores.
It is easy to imagine how a Christian would respond to this experiment:
Chris: Of course Jesus would not appear to you -- that would take away your free will. And if you video taped it, it
would take away the free wills of everyone else.
Norm: So Jesus can appear to no one, is that correct?
Chris: Yes, that is correct. That is why the resurrected Jesus does not appear today.
Norm: Then how did Jesus prove that he was resurrected?
Chris: By appearing to people, of course. How else would we know that Jesus was resurrected?
It is a circle of absurdity. The only way for Jesus to prove that he was resurrected was to appear to people, and that was
OK, but for Jesus to appear to you is impossible.
The reason why Jesus does not appear to you has nothing to do with your free will. It has to do with the fact that Jesus
appeared to no one.
The evidence of Jesus
Another way to prove to yourself that Jesus does not exist is to ask yourself this simple question:
Is there any evidence that Jesus exists today?
As you think about this simple question, you will realize that there is not. Everything else that you believe in has left
behind some sort of evidence that proves its existence. But with Jesus there is nothing. There is no physical evidence of
his existence. There is no miraculous evidence -- it is very strange, but not a single one of Jesus' miracles left behind any
physical evidence for us to see today. There is no prayer evidence. No matter how much we pray to Jesus, nothing ever
happens (see section 1). There is, quite simply, zero evidence to prove that Jesus exists today.
A devout Christian would point out that there is the Bible -- God's perfect word. Yes, there is the Bible. The Bible talks all
about Jesus. It predicts Jesus' coming (see chapter 23) and then tells us about Jesus' time on earth.
92
existence.
Chris: That is not true. God answers millions of prayers every day!
Norm: Then let's pray for him to answer a prayer right now.
Chris: No, No, we cannot do that.
How can it be that God is answering millions of prayers, yet it is impossible for God to answer a prayer? It is
because all of those "answered prayers" are simply coincidences. Let's look at another example and you will
see what I mean...
Chapter 7 - Why can't you move mountains?
Many people believe that God reaches down onto earth on a regular basis to answer prayers. People talk about their
answered prayers all the time. Inspirational books and magazines document thousands of answered prayers.
In chapter 5, however, we learned that there is a specific group of people whom God never helps through prayer. No
matter how much they pray, no matter how many people gather into a prayer group to pray for them, no matter how much
they believe, no matter how deserving and holy they are, what we found is that God never reaches down onto earth to
regenerate the legs of amputees. And amputees aren't the only group that God completely ignores. For example, God
never reaches down onto earth to cure those who suffer from Down syndrome either. There are hundreds of diseases that
are impossible to cure with prayer.
In chapter 6, things got even more interesting. What we discovered is that God actually does not answer medical prayers
in general. We found that it is easy to create the illusion that prayer works. The way you do it is by reporting only on the
successes of prayer. As soon as you start tracking both the successes AND the failures of prayer, and apply some
statistical analysis to the data, it is easy to see that prayer has no effect on the outcome of disease.
The amputation experiment in chapter 5 falls into a class of prayers that could be called "impossible prayers." It is
impossible, in the natural course of events, for a human leg to regenerate. It is easy to think of hundreds of other
impossible prayers, and it turns out that impossible prayers can teach us something about how prayer works. Here are
several examples:
x "Dear God, I pray that, tomorrow morning at 8AM, you pick up and move the Empire State Building to Paris.
Amen."
x "Dear God, I pray that you levitate this car 5 feet off the ground right now, and leave it hanging in the air for 15
minutes. Amen."
x "Dear God, I pray that you let me fly over the earth today, just like Superman does in the comic books. Amen."
x "Dear God, I pray that you let me run the World's first one-minute mile tomorrow, shattering the Olympic record in
that event. Amen."
x "Dear God, I pray that you make a living, breathing Tyrannosaurs Rex appear on the Mall in downtown
Washington DC tomorrow. Amen."
x "Dear God, I pray that you move Mt. Everest to Newark, NJ tomorrow. Amen."
x "Dear God, I pray that you put $100 million in small unmarked bills in my basement tonight. Amen."
x "Dear God, I pray that you completely eliminate all of the diseases in the world tomorrow. Amen."
If you were to pray any of these prayers, none of them will ever be answered. Ever. We all know that. No matter how
sincere you are. No matter how much you believe in God and his ability to answer prayers. No matter how many people
gather together in a prayer circle. Your impossible prayers will go unanswered.
What if your impossible prayer is incredibly worthy? For example:
x What if you are praying to levitate a car because a drunk driver has run over a college freshman and she is
currently pinned under one of the wheels?
25
 x What if you are praying to fly like superman so that you can rise up to a tenth story window and save two children
from their burning apartment?
x What if you plan to donate the $100 million that God gives you to a worthy and deserving charity?
None of it matters. God never answers impossible prayers.
Why is that?
It really is strange. We can take Mount Everest as the simplest example. It should be easy to move Mount Everest to
Newark. In Matthew 17:20 Jesus talks about mountains directly and says quite clearly:
For truly, I say to you, if you have faith as a grain of mustard seed, you will say to this mountain, 'Move from here
to there,' and it will move; and nothing will be impossible to you.
What could be simpler? There are no reservations in Jesus' statement. There are no conditions. There is no waffling. A
devoted person with a little bit of faith should be able to move Mt. Everest to Newark at a moment's notice. Jesus is God,
so he cannot be wrong and he has no reason to lie to us in the Bible. If you believe Jesus, impossible prayers should be
getting answered all the time. What could be clearer than, "Nothing will be impossible to you"?
And yet... We have never seen a mountain move. Not even Jesus moved a mountain, even though he claimed it was
easy.
God is omnipotent, so nothing is impossible for God. However, if you pray for anything that is clearly impossible in the
natural course of events, it is not going to happen. You certainly are not going to see the Empire State building fly off to
Paris one morning and settle gently next to the Eiffel Tower. Nor are you ever going to see a human being on the evening
news stretch out his arms and zoom up to a tenth story window like Superman.
Although God should be able to do the impossible according to the Standard Model of God and Jesus' promises in the
Bible, it never actually happens. It is essential that you ask yourself, "Why might that be?" It is a very important question.
Explaining the contradiction
How do we explain the fact that God never answers impossible prayers?
There is the "God must remain hidden" argument. But, as mentioned in chapters 5 and 6, a hidden God would never
incarnate himself, or publish a Bible, or part the Red Sea, or put rainbows in the clouds, so obviously God has no need or
desire to hide.
There is the "you are misinterpreting Jesus and taking his statements out of context" argument. But, since Jesus is God,
and God is omniscient, Jesus would account for that. Jesus would know that when he says, "nothing will be impossible to
you," normal human human beings would interpret it to mean, "nothing will be impossible to you." This is not rocket
science. If Jesus did not mean that, he would not have said it.
Imagine the following conversation:
Norm: Does God answer prayers?
Chris: Yes, certainly. He has answered hundreds of my prayers.
Norm: Pray for him to put $10,000 in my pocket right now.
Chris: It does not work that way. I said God answers prayers, not that he is a cosmic genie.
Norm: So, in Mark 11:24, when Jesus says, "Whatever you ask for in prayer, believe that you have received it,
and it will be yours," what did he mean? That sounds like you can have whatever you pray for.
Chris: He means that you pray for something, and if it is his will then you can have it.
26
Jesus, if he actually were God, could have done so much. He could have prevented massive amounts of human suffering
with his words and deeds. Instead, he did none of this. To any rational person, these problems make it painfully obvious
that Jesus was a normal human being.
Jesus, the eternal torturer
Simply take a moment to think about the following statement:
"Hello, my name is Jesus. I love you deeply. I have loved you since you were conceived in the womb and I will
love you for all eternity. I died for you on the cross because I love you so much. I long to have a loving personal
relationship with you. I will answer all of your prayers through my love. But if you do not get down on your knees
and worship me, and if you do not EAT MY BODY and DRINK MY BLOOD, then I WILL INCINERATE YOU WITH
UNIMAGINABLY TORTUOUS PAIN IN THE FIRES OF HELL FOR ALL ETERNITY BWAH HA HA HA HA HA!"
Yes, this is the central message of Christianity.
Think about this message. We have a being who, according to the Standard Model of God, embodies love. Yet, if you do
not get down on your knees and worship him, you will be physically tortured for all eternity. What sort of love is that?
Imagine a human being who acted this way. Imagine that a human being for some reason "falls in love with you." This
person sets up hidden cameras and begins tracking you everywhere you go every minute of every day. This person
leaves a book on your doorstep that professes how much he loves you. But this person gives you a deadline and says, "If
you do not begin to love me by my deadline, I will capture you and physically torture you in the most hideous ways." How
would you describe such a person? We would call such a person a lunatic, and we would put such a person in prison for
life.
Asking Jesus to appear
Here is another way to prove it to yourself. Simply get down on your knees and pray to Jesus. Ask him to appear to you,
in the flesh, just like he did to Paul (see chapter 20). Ask Jesus to demonstrate to you, personally, that he is resurrected.
When he appears, take your family camcorder and record the event for posterity.
Of course, Jesus will not appear.
What Jesus says in John 14:12 is so clear:
"Truly, truly, I say to you, he who believes in me will also do the works that I do; and greater works than these will
he do, because I go to the Father. Whatever you ask in my name, I will do it, that the Father may be glorified in
the Son; if you ask anything in my name, I will do it.
You have asked for something in his name. You have even asked him to do something that he is clearly able to do. The
Bible says that Jesus appeared to hundreds of people, so it should be no problem for him to appear to you.
Yet, predictably, Jesus will not appear.
Now I would ask you to examine it at a deeper level. Look at what is happening inside your mind right now. You have read
the Bible and seen Jesus' clear statement: "If you ask anything in my name, I will do it." He does not say, "I might do it."
You have prayed for Jesus to appear and Jesus has ignored you.
Even though Jesus did not appear, and even though Jesus says to you quite clearly in the Bible that he will, look at how
you deal with this setback. Do you draw the obvious conclusion from the evidence? If you are a Christian, then probably
not. Instead, in your mind, you are coming up with a thousand rationalizations to explain why Jesus did not appear:
x It is not his will
x He doesn't have time
x He may appear, but it will be in the afterlife
x I didn't pray the right way
x I am not worthy
91
despite all the problems, contradictions and lack of evidence, a Christian will cling to Jesus. You will begin to understand Norm: If it is his will, aren't I going to get it anyway? Why pray?
why Christians do that in Chapter 27, but for now let's simply review the evidence that we have seen.
Chris: Ask, and you shall receive. You have to ask...
In this section of the book we have looked at Jesus from a number of different angles. What we have found is that Jesus
was a human being just like you and me. We simply ask the questions that any normal person would ask of someone who Norm: ...and then you should receive. Jesus does not say, "Ask, and you might receive if it is my will." His
claims to be God. For example: statement has no conditions.

x If Jesus is God, why did he never prove it in a meaningful way? Why are none of his miracles visible today? We Chris: Well, he meant that. It is implied.
examined this question in chapter 19. Of the questions asked in this section of the book, this one is the most
important. It is important for this simple reason: If a man were to walk up to you today and state that he is God, Norm: OK, why does he never answer impossible prayers?
you would want to see proof. The proof would have to be obvious to everyone and scientifically irrefutable. Jesus
is no different.
Chris: It is not his will.
x If Jesus is God, and Jesus is resurrected, then why hasn't he appeared to you in the flesh to prove that he is
resurrected? We examined this question in chapter 20. In order for the Apostles to believe in the resurrection,
Jesus appeared to them. In order for Paul to believe in the resurrection, Jesus appeared to him. Why would Norm: Ever?
Jesus, who is all-loving and timeless, think of you as any less important than Paul? The reason is because Jesus
did not appear to anyone. Chris: It is never his will.
x Why do we need to eat Jesus? We examined this question in chapter 21. We have Jesus -- the all-loving creator
of the universe -- demanding that we ceremonially cannibalize his body and satanically drink his blood if we want Norm: So in Matthew 17:20, when Jesus says, "nothing will be impossible to you," why isn't flying-like-superman
to have "eternal life." The source of this bizarre ritual is not Jesus. The ritual comes from primitive pagan religions or $10,000-in-my-pocket-right-now part of that?
that were common at the time.
x Why do so many children live in poverty, and why does Jesus misspeak so many times in the New Testament? In Chris: What he meant is that nothing that is possible will be impossible for you.
chapter 22 we examined a number of statements where Jesus is wrong. Why would a perfect God write things in
the Bible that are incorrect?
Norm: So when Jesus uses the example of moving a mountain, which is clearly impossible, what did he mean?
x Why does Jesus need money from you every Sunday morning? In chapter 24 we examined this interesting
paradox.
Chris: He was speaking metaphorically.
There are broader pieces of evidence as well. As pointed out in Section 1, Jesus does not answer prayers. As pointed out
in Section 2, the Bible is provably the work of primitive men. And so on. Norm: So when Jesus said "anyone with faith can move a mountain," what he actually meant was, "No one with
faith can move a mountain."
We can look at Jesus from several other angles and reach the same conclusion.
Chris: No.
The biggest problem with Jesus
Norm: Then, who can move a mountain?
The biggest problem with Jesus is his incredible myopia. We can see that now looking back at him 2,000 years later. Why
didn't Jesus use his omnipotence to actually do something magnificent and beautiful on earth rather than squandering his Chris: God can move a mountain.
"power" as he does in the Bible?
Norm: But he never does.
At the very least, Jesus could have transcribed passages into the Bible that would have ended sexism, racism and slavery
forever. As the simplest example, think of all of the suffering that slavery has caused. As described in chapter 13, millions Chris: It is not his will.
upon millions of people have suffered through the bondage and the remarkable brutality of slavery because Jesus and his
Bible fully endorse slavery. If Jesus had simply made a clear statement -- "Slavery is forbidden, free all the slaves" -- he Norm: Let me make sure I have this straight. Here is what Jesus said in Matthew 17:20:
could have prevented much of that suffering. Yet he did nothing of the sort. In the same way, Jesus could have chosen
women to be six of his apostles and made several speeches on the topic of women's equality and he would have put a You will say to this mountain, 'Move from here to there,' and it will move; and nothing will be impossible to
huge dent in sexism (see chapter 15). Still today we see the effects of Jesus' shortsightedness in this area. you.

At a larger level, if Jesus were God, he could have performed so many real miracles. He could have, for example, But here is what you think he meant:
eliminated smallpox and a host of other diseases that science is busy eliminating today. Jesus could have given the
people of Israel the knowledge that they would need to start a technological society and raise themselves above the
You will say to this mountain, 'Move from here to there,' and it will move; and nothing will be impossible to
primitive living conditions of the day. As mentioned in Chapter 17, Jesus could have taught the Israelites about metallurgy,
you, as long as it is possible and as long as it is my will.
chemistry, biology, physics, manufacturing, mathematics, medicine, engineering, etc., etc., etc. He could have also taught
them how to responsibly use these technologies to solve the problems of pollution and habitat destruction that so often
accompany them today. He could have made clear statements to deter nuclear proliferation. He could have taught Is that right?
mankind to share wealth so that the immense problem of global poverty that we see today would have been solved long
ago. He could have laid down a template for governance that would have ended monarchies, dictatorial regimes and Chris: You are really splitting hairs here.
warlords forever. He could have made his message so clear, and the proof of his godliness so obvious, that all six billion
people on the planet would have aligned with him rather than fragmenting into dozens of bizarre and often warring Norm: Answer the question. Is that what he meant?
factions.
90 27
 Chris: This is irrelevant to the conversation.
Norm: Here's what I don't understand. What Jesus said in the Bible is quite clearly wrong. If God is inerrant, there
is no reason why God would put something that is completely wrong in the Bible. Why do we need human beings
like you to interpret and massage and explain what God might have meant in the Bible? Why wouldn't an
omnipotent, all-knowing God have written it the way he meant it, in an understandable, clear, unambiguous,
truthful, correct way? There isn't anything vague about, "Nothing will be impossible for you" or, "Ask, and you shall
receive." Yet, it is completely wrong. Explain that to me.
Chris: You are completely missing the point.
And so on...
Most people can see the problem that is apparent in this conversation. There is no reason why an all-knowing, perfect
God would write down, "you can move mountains" or, "nothing will be impossible for you" or, "Ask, and you shall receive"
unless he meant that.
Norm: OK, then let's pray to Jesus about anything. Let's ask Jesus to do anything for us right now. What we saw
in Section 1 is that Jesus does not answer any prayers. Why don't we ask him to move a mountain for us?
Chris: You are so wrong.
Norm: Why can't we pray to him right now? In Mark 11:24 Jesus' message is crystal clear: "Therefore I tell you,
whatever you ask for in prayer, believe that you have received it, and it will be yours." He says, "Ask, and you
shall receive." In Luke 1:37: "For with God nothing will be impossible." Nothing is impossible through prayer. Why
won't he respond to us if we pray to him right now?
Chris: You are completely wrong. That is not how prayer works!
Norm: Here's another way to look at it. Why don't we take a vote? We take all six billion people on the planet and
we ask them to vote on whether Jesus is God or not. Only two billion people on the planet are Christian, so the
other four billion are going to vote against Jesus. For every Christian, there are two non-Christians who think you
are delusional.

Unfortunately, the reality is that no one can move mountains, and thousands of things will be impossible for you. Not even Chris: They are all wrong! If only they knew the Lord Jesus like I do!
Jesus could move a mountain.
Norm: You are telling me that all one billion Muslims are wrong? They believe that Jesus was a man, not God. It
Divine inspiration says so right in the Koran [Koran 5:75].

A thoughtful person might say, "You are completely missing the point. Coal Chris: The Muslims are delusional!
Key Point
companies move mountains. Scientists create artificial limbs for amputees. A crane
can make a car levitate. These human accomplishments are divinely inspired. God Norm: Those are fightin' words.
acts on this world through men." In Matthew 17:20 Jesus promises
that you can move mountains and
that "nothing will be impossible for Chris: They are delusional! Everyone knows it! Jesus is Lord!
There are three problems with this argument. In Matthew 21:21 Jesus says:
you." Unfortunately, the reality is
that no one can move mountains, Norm: So there are a billion Muslims who think that all the Christians are delusional. And there are two billion
I tell you the truth, if you have faith and do not doubt, not only can you do and thousands of things will be Christians who think all the Muslims are delusional. Would you consider, at least for a moment, the possibility that
what was done to the fig tree, but also you can say to this mountain, 'Go, impossible for you. Not even Jesus all three billion of you are delusional?
throw yourself into the sea,' and it will be done. If you believe, you will could move a mountain.
receive whatever you ask for in prayer." Chris: I am not delusional! Jesus Christ is our resurrected Lord! I talk to him every single day and he talks to me!
Jesus does not say, "You will have to hire thousands of people, spend a billion dollars on heavy equipment and then work And he answers my prayers!
24 hours a day for 20 years to move this mountain into the sea, and it will be done." He says, "You can say, 'Go, throw
yourself into the sea,' and it will be done." The mountain actually moves itself in Jesus' statement.
Norm: OK, then give me anything -- give me any evidence at all that shows me that Jesus exists.
The second problem is that the vast majority of people do not have a billion dollars. Therefore, Jesus statement is false
even if he had earth-moving machinery in mind. Chris: The Bible talks all about Jesus!

The third problem is that, if these human accomplishments are "divinely inspired," then there is no reason why God did Norm: So you think we should reinstate the slave trade? You think that Christians should hate women?
not "divinely inspire" them 4,000 years ago. For example, why didn't God "divinely inspire" a smallpox vaccine in 2000
BCE, rather than waiting until 1950? Why would an all-loving God want tens of millions of people to suffer and die from Chris: NO!
smallpox over the last 4,000 years, and then suddenly decide to "divinely inspire" a cure in the twentieth century? If that
explanation is true, then God is clearly a sadist. Only a sadist would cause the suffering of smallpox for thousands of Norm: Give me anything.
years when he had a "divinely inspired" cure waiting in the wings. Why would we want to worship a sadist?
Chris: I cannot. Jesus must remain hidden! If he were not hidden, we would all know that he exists. It would
The reason why we call them human accomplishments is because they are human accomplishments. God has nothing to destroy faith.
do with them. If God is divinely inspiring them, then the headline in the paper should never be, "Scientist discovers
transparent aluminum." It should always be, "God divinely inspires scientist to discover transparent aluminum." In that Norm: If Jesus must remain hidden, then how do you know that he exists?
case, you have to wonder why God is so unfair in his distribution of inspirations. You also have to wonder why we pay the
scientist, since quite clearly he didn't do anything. And why did the scientist need to go to college?
The conversation can go on and on like this.
Explaining prayer
To anyone who stands outside the Christian faith and looks at Jesus rationally, it is obvious that Jesus either was a
complete myth who never existed at all, or was a normal human being who was turned into a myth after-the-fact. Yet,
The fascinating thing about impossible prayers is that they allow us to see what is actually happening when a person
says, "God answered my prayer."
28 89
Chapter 25 - Reviewing the evidence about Jesus
If we were to talk to a Christian about Jesus, the conversation might go something like this:
Chris: You are completely wrong about Jesus. Jesus is Lord! Jesus is resurrected and Jesus sits on the right
hand of God the father almighty!
Let's imagine that a person prays for something that is impossible, no matter what it is. For example, a person prays that
Mt. Everest fly to New Jersey. Obviously this is not going to happen, despite all of Jesus' promises. So the religious
person prays and nothing happens.
How does the religious person rationalize the prayer's failure? The person will rationalize the unanswered prayer by
saying, "it is not part of God's plan." Is this rationalization true? No - of course not. The fact is that this event is impossible,
Jesus lied and God is imaginary. That is why no impossible prayer will ever be answered.

Norm: Why do you believe that? Now let's look a different situation. A person prays for something that is possible. For example, a person prays to win a
church raffle, and he actually does win. What is happening here is nothing more than a coincidence. Here are the steps
Chris: I know it in my heart. I talk to Jesus every day. I have a loving, living relationship with our Lord Jesus that led to the coincidence:
Christ!
x The event in question must be possible. It has to have some non-zero probability of happening.
Norm: How do you know that Jesus is resurrected? x Then it does in fact happen.
x A person, coincidentally, happens to pray.
Chris: It says so right in the Bible. Matthew, Mark, Luke and John were real people. So was Paul. They have no
reason to lie. They saw the resurrected Jesus. That coincidence is an "answered prayer." How can we prove that this "answered prayer" is a coincidence? We simply
look at all the losers. If there were a million people entered in the raffle, then 999,999 people lost. Since it was a church
Norm: I understand what you are saying. The thing I would like to help you understand is that the Bible is full of raffle, they all are believers and they all prayed. That's 999,999 unanswered prayers vs. 1 answered prayer. It is a terrible
problems. There is no reason why we should believe the Bible when it talks about the resurrection. ratio. As soon as we look at the successes AND the failures of prayer, it is obvious what is actually going on. "answered
prayers" are coincidences every time.
Chris: The Bible is not full of problems!
What we are seeing here is important. There are two easy ways to unmask the illusion of prayer:
Norm: That is what we saw in Section 2. The Bible thinks that slavery is great, that women are to be hated, that
people should be sacrificing animals and that God loved killing children. We can open the Bible to nearly any 1. Ask a believer to pray for something concrete that is impossible. According to the Bible and the Standard Model of
page and find nonsense. We know that the story of Noah is nothing but a story. And so on. There are problems God, God should be answering impossible prayers all the time. However, what we will find is that every
with the Bible everywhere we look. Given all of these problems, there is no reason to trust anything the Bible impossible prayer goes unanswered:
says. o This explains why God ignores the prayers of amputees.
o This explains why no one can move a mountain.
Chris: Jesus is resurrected! Jesus is Lord! o This explains why, if Jeanna's prayer circle had prayed that God completely eliminate rabies worldwide,
nothing would happen.
Norm: Let's pray to Jesus and ask that he appear to us right now to settle this. o And so on...
2. Ask a believer to pray for something that is possible, and then simply count both the successes AND the failures
of the prayer. As soon as we count both sides, we can statistically analyze the situation and see that "answered
Chris: He can't do that! Jesus can't appear to us!
prayers" are nothing but coincidences. The statistics prove it every time:
o This explains why non-believers win lotteries just as often as believers do.
Norm: Why not? o This explains why believers die of cancer as often as non-believers do.
o This explains why believers need health insurance just like non-believers do.
Chris: He cannot! o And so on...

Norm: But why? Even if you are a devout believer, you should be starting to see a pattern here. God does not answer the prayers of
amputees. If he did, we would see amputees regenerating their severed limbs on a daily basis. God does not answer
Chris: He's so busy doing everything God needs him to do! Plus, if he just appeared right here out of thin air, it medical prayers. If he did, you would not need health insurance. God does not answer impossible prayers. If he did,
would take away our free will. We would both KNOW that he exists. He can't do that! people could actually move mountains like Jesus promises.

Norm: Then how was Jesus able to appear to Paul? How was Jesus able to appear to the 500 brethren? Why If you are a believer, here is the question that you must seriously consider: Is it possible that God is imaginary? Is this the
was it OK for them to KNOW that Jesus exists? reason why God is not answering all of these different kinds of prayers? The advantage of this explanation is that it
perfectly fits the data that we see in our world. No rationalizations, hand waving, explanations or excuses are required.
Chris: That was different. Let's look at another example that will further reinforce this line of reasoning....

Norm: Why? Chapter 8 - Why do bad things happen to good people?

Chris: Jesus had only been dead a couple of days. "Why Do Bad Things Happen to Good People?" It is an incredibly common question.

Norm: Why does that matter to a timeless, omnipotent being? This question is so common, in fact, that there is a well known book by that title written by Melvin Tinker. There is another,
even better known book entitled, When Bad Things Happen to Good People by Harold Kushner. Even more popular is the
Chris: You are so wrong about this! book When God Doesn't Make Sense by James Dobson.
88 29
For James Dobson to weigh in on this, it must be an important question. And that makes sense -- it is a total paradox for
any believer, and rightly so.
In his book, James Dobson opens with the story of Chuck Frye, a gifted student who graduated from college and was
accepted to medical school. Frye had decided to work as a medical missionary and Dobson says, "If permitted to live,
Chuck could have treated thousands of poor and needy people who would otherwise suffer and die in utter hopelessness.
Not only could he have ministered to their physical needs, but his ultimate desire was to share the gospel with those who
had never heard this greatest of stories." Unfortunately, despite fervent prayers from his parents, family and friends, Frye
contracted and then died of leukemia shortly after starting medical school. As Dobson puts it, "how can we make sense of
this incomprehensible act of God?"
We see this kind of thing all the time. For example, we read about a woman who is a devout believer. She is so devout
that she goes to church three times a week. She gives her time and money to charity. She is constantly helping others.
She wears a crucifix and a WWJD bracelet. She walks with Jesus. Then one day a car jacker forces his way into her car.
There is a Bible sitting right there on the front seat next to her, but it does not matter. The car jacker shoots her in the
head and dumps her body in a ditch. Her family is left to pick up the pieces in bewilderment.
When we ask, "Why do bad things happen to good people?" the essence of the question is simple. If God is looking down
upon us from heaven and answering our prayers, how could he allow these horrible things to happen to true believers?
How could he ignore their prayers? If someone lives a good and faithful life, and if a person is doing God's work, then why
would God allow bad things happen to that person? Why doesn't God -- the all-powerful, all-loving, all-knowing creator of
the universe -- protect a person who is going to church every Sunday, putting plenty of money in the offering plate,
following the commandments, praying faithfully and so on? The case of Neva Rogers in Chapter 1 is a perfect example of
the problem.
The reason why this question is so puzzling is because the question makes two assumptions:
1. God exists
2. God keeps score
In other words, the question assumes that God is sitting in heaven looking down on us, answering our prayers and
keeping track of who is good and bad on a minute-by-minute basis. We assume that God keeps a record of "goodness"
and "badness" for each of us. Under the Standard Model of God, the reason why God is keeping score is so that he can
decide whose prayers he should answer and who should go to heaven once they die.
But what if we were to approach the question from the opposite angle? What if we hypothesize that God is imaginary?
As in chapters 5, 6 and 7, once we hypothesize that God is imaginary, the paradox and the mystery evaporate completely.
If there actually is no one in heaven answering prayers and keeping score, then one would expect bad things to happen to
good people all the time.
When you look at it this way, everything makes sense. Whether you are good or bad is irrelevant. In the real world that we
live in, things like cancer, hurricanes and serial killers would have no way to know whether you are good or bad, nor would
they care. Therefore, bad things would happen to good people just as often as they happen to everyone else.
Bad things happen to everyone
To get a clearer picture of what is going on here, let's take a simple example. In the real world, what are your chances of
getting cancer if you are good? We find that they are the same as your chances of getting cancer if you are bad. That is
easy to prove statistically -- believers get cancer just as often as non-believers who have the same risk factors.
Why might that be? It is because any given cell in every human body has some probability of turning cancerous, and that
probability is the same regardless of religious background. There are many different paths to cancer, but let's focus on
one of them and use it as an example: cosmic rays.
30
wrote the Bible and if Jesus were sent by God! The chances of one man fulfilling all of these prophecies together are
infinitesimally small -- Jesus MUST be God!" You've heard it so many times you've simply taken it on faith.
But have you ever actually taken the time to read the Bible and check out these "prophesies"? Have you ever looked at
the context around them as we have here? Have you ever noticed that the "prophecies" are scattered far and wide
throughout the Old Testament without a single thing tying them together and absolutely nothing indicating that they point
to Jesus? Have you ever noticed that there are thousands of other prophesies -- like the rod and the cheek, the bees and
the curd, the seven shepherds, the eight princes, the Nimrods, the doves of Assyria, the razors from across the river, etc.,
etc., etc. -- that never came to pass?
If you read all of the examples in this chapter, and especially if you read the material in the Bible surrounding the
"prophecies", I believe that you will understand two things. First, the "prophecies" that "prove" that Jesus is God are
irrelevant and meaningless. Any unbiased observer can see that. Jesus' coming was never "prophesized" in the Bible.
These prophesies are as random and arbitrary as your horoscope in the newspaper -- so vague and diffused among so
much irrelevant material that they are completely meaningless.
The second thing you will see is a reiteration of chapter 17 -- much of the Bible is irrelevant to us today. Since God is all-
knowing and timeless, it is difficult to understand why that would be unless we assume that God had nothing to do with
the Bible.
Chapter 24 - Why does Jesus need your money?
Imagine hearing this advertisement on the radio one day:
"Hello. My name is Jesus, and I am God. I am the all-powerful creator of the universe. I created everything that
you see before you -- the galaxies and stars in the heavens; the oceans, the mountains and the plains of earth;
the sun and the moon and the skies; along with every living thing on the planet. I created you personally, and I
gave you your unique soul. I created everything!
Everything of value on earth I created. I buried thousands of tons of gold in mines around the planet. I placed
billions of gallons of oil under the sands in the Middle East. I created the millions of carets of diamonds being
mined in South Africa.
And I will answer your prayers. Pray to me for anything and I will hear and answer your prayers. I say it in dozens
of places in the Bible, but I like the way I say it in Mark 11:24 the best: "Therefore I tell you, whatever you ask in
prayer, believe that you have received it, and it will be yours." Anything you need -- money, love, happiness, you
name it -- I am here to provide it for you.
Now, there is just one thing I need in return. I need your money. I need lots of your money. The Bible specifies
that you send me ten percent of your gross income, but think of that as a starting point. Feel free to give more!
When they pass the offering plate at church, be sure to give generously!
Because even though I created the universe and everything in it, and even though I will give you everything you
ask for in prayer, I can't give a cent to any church, ever.
So, please give generously at your place of worship today! I thank you for your support!"
This is what every church tells you every Sunday morning when they pass the plate. Jesus is the all-powerful creator of
the universe and everything in it, he will answer all of your prayers, but he has no money.
Why don't the ministers and deacons of the church gather together every Sunday morning and pray for Jesus to deposit
$1,000,000 in gold bars in the offering plate? Why doesn't Jesus answer their prayers? Why do they have to beg for
money from mere mortals when there is an immortal, all-powerful God who should provide anything they ask for?
The reason why Jesus needs lots of your money every Sunday morning should be obvious to you at this point.
87
 keeping watch. 9 Rejoice greatly, O Daughter of Zion! Shout, Daughter of Jerusalem! See, your king comes to
you, righteous and having salvation, gentle and riding on a donkey, on a colt, the foal of a donkey. 10 I will take
away the chariots from Ephraim and the war-horses from Jerusalem, and the battle bow will be broken. He will
proclaim peace to the nations. His rule will extend from sea to sea and from the River to the ends of the earth. 11
As for you, because of the blood of my covenant with you, I will free your prisoners from the waterless pit. 12
Return to your fortress, O prisoners of hope; even now I announce that I will restore twice as much to you. 13 I will
bend Judah as I bend my bow and fill it with Ephraim. I will rouse your sons, O Zion, against your sons, O Greece,
and make you like a warrior's sword.
Once again you notice that this material from the Bible is totally irrelevant and nonsensical (see chapter 17). The
prophesy is verse 9. Do you see anything in there that says we are talking about Jesus? Verse 8 is also interesting in light
of Hitler.
Example 4
In Micah Chapter 5 verse 2 there is a "prophesy" that Jesus will be born in Bethlehem:
1
Now you are walled about with a wall; siege is laid against us; with a rod they strike upon the cheek the ruler of
Israel. 2 But you, O Bethlehem Eph'rathah, who are little to be among the clans of Judah, from you shall come
forth for me one who is to be ruler in Israel, whose origin is from of old, from ancient days. 3 Therefore he shall
give them up until the time when she who is in travail has brought forth; then the rest of his brethren shall return to
the people of Israel. 4 And he shall stand and feed his flock in the strength of the LORD, in the majesty of the
name of the LORD his God. And they shall dwell secure, for now he shall be great to the ends of the earth. 5 And
this shall be peace, when the Assyrian comes into our land and treads upon our soil, that we will raise against him
seven shepherds and eight princes of men; 6 they shall rule the land of Assyria with the sword, and the land of
Nimrod with the drawn sword; and they shall deliver us from the Assyrian when he comes into our land and treads
within our border.
Look at all the other stuff around this "prophecy." There is the wall, the siege, the rod, the cheek, the flock, the Assyrians,
the seven shepherds, the eight princes, the Nimrods, the sword, and so on. Once again all of this material is irrelevant
and nonsensical (see Chapter 17).
There is something else that you may notice in this passage. Look at this phrase: "with a rod they strike upon the cheek
the ruler of Israel." Let's say that, at some point in the Gospels, Pontius Pilate had struck Jesus with a rod on the cheek. If
that had happened, then Micah 5:1 would be a prophecy about Jesus' coming. Since Jesus is never struck on the cheek
with a rod in the New Testament, this "prophecy" is never mentioned. Once you understand that, you completely
understand the "300 prophecies of Jesus."
This "rod and cheek" phenomenon is where the "prophecies" of Jesus are coming from. The Old Testament contains
thousands and thousands of words, most of them total nonsense. Out of those thousands of words, you are going to get
some that happen to match up with the New Testament accounts of Jesus in some obscure way. However, you are going
to get thousands more, like the rod and the cheek, the curds and the honey, the razor from across the river, the Nimrods
and all the rest, that do not. If you look for the ones that do happen to randomly match up and completely ignore the
thousands and thousands that do not, you can claim that the Old Testament "prophesizes" the coming of Jesus. Any
normal person, on the other hand, sees it all as gibberish. Any correspondence is complete coincidence.
In chapter 17 of this book we discussed the amount of nonsense in the Bible. In all of the quotes that you have seen
around these prophecies, do you find that you are left in amazement at the word of the Lord? Or have you found it all to
be completely meaningless to you? Why, if the Bible and these "prophecies" are the word of the Lord, is book filled to the
brim with such meaningless, useless, ridiculous nonsense?
Here is one last thing to consider. No one would care about these "prophecies" in the Old Testament if Jesus had actually
proven that he is God. Since Jesus did not prove that he is God (see chapter 19), Christians have to fall back on the
"prophecies" because this is all they've got. Since any normal person can see that the prophecies are completely
meaningless, this is a very sad place for a Christian to be.
Reaching a conclusion
If you are a Christian, you have heard the following statement over and over again: "Jesus' coming was prophesized
hundreds of times in the Old Testament, centuries before Jesus' birth! The ONLY way that could have happened is if God
86
Every hour of every day, your body is bombarded by about half a million cosmic rays. These cosmic rays have some
probability of altering the DNA in a cell in your body. If a cell is altered in a certain way, the cell can turn cancerous and a
tumor begins to form.
The cosmic rays in nature have no way of knowing whether you are good or bad, nor do they care. Everyone gets hit by
the same number of cosmic rays whether they are good or bad. Therefore, everyone has the same probability of getting
cancer from cosmic rays. Your goodness or badness has no influence on cosmic rays. Since God is imaginary, he will not
protect you from cosmic rays if you are good. Therefore, cancer happens to good people in exactly the same way that it
happens to bad people.
You actually can change the probabilities in certain cases. You do have some control over cancer. A person who smokes
increases his probability of getting lung cancer. A person who likes to lie on a tanning bed increases her probability of
getting skin cancer. A pilot or an astronaut gets hit by more cosmic rays and increases the probability of cancer. So by not
smoking, staying on the ground and remaining pale, you reduce your cancer risk. But no one can eliminate the threat of
cancer. You cannot stop the half million cosmic rays that will hit your body in the next hour.
If God is imaginary, these cosmic rays do not care whether a person is good or bad. In the same way:
x A hurricane does not care if the people in its path are good or bad
x A deer does not care whether the driver is good or bad when she leaps out onto a highway at midnight and
crashes through a windshield.
x Fat molecules do not care whether you are good or bad as they attach themselves to your heart's arteries and
create the conditions necessary for a heart attack.
x A volcano does not care whether good or bad people will be buried in its lava when it erupts.
x And so on.
What we find in the real world is that a hurricane causes just as much damage for believers as non-believers. We also find
that God does not divert hurricanes away from devout nations -- hurricanes hit the United States every year, often with
devastating results, despite the fact that the large majority of Americans believe in God.
The thing for you to notice is this: If we assume that God exists and that the Standard Model of God is true, then the
question "Why do bad things happen to good people?" is a complete mystery. Our world makes no sense. However, if we
assume that God is imaginary, there is no mystery at all. Our world makes complete sense.
That lack of mystery is one way we can know, for sure, that God is imaginary. All evidence points toward the fact that God
is imaginary. God is not reaching down from heaven and arbitrarily modifying the laws of probability on behalf of believers.
We know that, with certainty, by analyzing the statistics. Nor is God sitting in heaven answering the prayers of believers.
Statistics show us that as well. Therefore, bad things happen to good people all the time. Hurricanes, volcanoes, forest
fires, tornadoes, tsunamis, car crashes, diseases... they do not care whether you have been bad or good. They are equal
opportunity disasters. We can prove this both with common sense and statistical rigor.
God's plan
One of the things running through your head right now may be "God's plan." This is the way that believers traditionally
explain things like cancer, hurricanes and car accidents.
For example, when God ignored the prayers of Neva Rogers and allowed the Red Lake gunman to shoot her in the head
four times (see chapter 1), she died as part of God's plan. Her death had a purpose. God called her home for a reason.
When two-year-old Ranika baked to death in a church van, her death was part of God's plan too (see chapter 4). You
know how this works -- even if something bad happens, it is actually good because it is part of God's plan.
You can see how pervasive "God's plan" is by looking in inspirational books and magazines. For example, if we look in the
book A Purpose Driven Life by Rick Warren, we find this remarkable paragraph in Chapter 2:
Because God made you for a reason, he also decided when you would be born and how long you would live. He
planned the days of your life in advance, choosing the exact time of your birth and death. The Bible says, "You
31
 saw me before I was born and scheduled each day of my life before I began to breathe. Every day was recorded
in your book!" [Psalm 139:16]
There is also this:
Regardless of the circumstances of your birth or who your parents are, God had a plan in creating you.
Under this view of the universe, God plans everything.
Take a moment and think about what Rick Warren said. Rick said, "He planned the days of your life in advance, choosing
the exact time of your birth and death." Let's examine one incredibly simple implication of this statement. What this means
is that God pre-planned every abortion that has taken place on our planet.
If you think about this simple implication for a few moments, you will begin to realize how impossible "God's plan" is. If the
concept of "God's plan" is true, you can first of all see that God wants us to be aborting children. Every single abortion is
planned by God, so God must be doing it for a reason. Second, you can see that both the mother who requests the
abortion and the doctor who performs it are blameless. Since it is God who planned the abortion of the child (God chose
the "exact time" of the death, according to Rick Warren), the mother and doctor are simply puppets who are fulfilling God's
plan. You can also see that all the believers who are fighting against abortion are missing the point. They are actually
fighting against God's plan, and their fight is completely futile. God is the all-powerful ruler of the universe, and his plan is
for more than a million children a year to die in the United States through abortion. [ref] Each one of those abortions was
meticulously planned by God, so fighting against abortion is a totally wasted effort.
You may be thinking, "God does not intend for us to perform abortions!" But if you believe what Rick is saying, then you
are obviously incorrect. If God exists and God has a plan for you, then God is actually the direct cause of every abortion
on earth. If you find that notion to be uncomfortable, I would agree with you. Unfortunately, that is the logical outcome of
God's plan.
In order to better understand God's plan, let's look at one of the biggest global events that humans have ever witnessed:
World War II. According to Encarta:
The human cost [of WWII], not including between 5.6 million and 5.9 million Jews killed in the Holocaust who
were indirect victims of the war, is estimated to have been 55 million dead—25 million of those military and 30
million civilian.
In addition, according to Encarta:
x 61 countries participated in WWII
x 1.7 billion people participated in WWII
x 75% of all human beings alive at the time participated in WWII
World War II was obviously a major disaster -- perhaps the most horrific event the world has ever seen. It is safe to say
that nearly every human being on planet Earth prayed to God that this war would end.
There is also Adolph Hitler. He was evil incarnate, and Hitler is well known for the atrocious things he did. It is interesting
to look at Adolph Hitler in the context of prayer, and understand how people try to reconcile an all-loving, prayer-
answering God with such a hateful man.
Consider this statement: "Hitler is part of God's Plan." Think about what Rick said:
He planned the days of your life in advance, choosing the exact time of your birth and death. The Bible says, "You
saw me before I was born and scheduled each day of my life before I began to breathe. Every day was recorded
in your book!" [Psalm 139:16]
Rick also says:
God never does anything accidentally, and he never makes mistakes. He has a reason for everything he creates.
Every plant and every animal was planned by God, and every person was designed with a purpose in mind.
If God has a divine plan for each of us, then he had a divine plan for Hitler too. It is when you stop to think about it deeply
that the contradictions hit you.
For example, simply think about what "God's plan" would actually mean. Since God is an all-powerful being, God's plan
would, of necessity, need to be all-inclusive. Hitler and WWII would fit as one tiny piece in a supreme plan of massive
32
That's a lot of stuff. So you look at it… You read it closely… You read it again… It is pretty dense, I realize, and much of it
is completely nonsensical (see chapter 17 on irrelevant material in the Bible). I will make you a wager that you cannot get
halfway through it without your eyes glazing over, but try to muscle through it and read the entire thing. In there is an
important prophecy of Jesus' life. Can you see it? It is in verse 14. The sentence is:
14
Therefore the Lord himself will give you a sign: The virgin will be with child and will give birth to a son, and will
call him Immanuel.
According to Christians, this sentence prophesizes that Jesus will be born of a virgin mother. That is one of the 300
prophecies in the Old Testament that prove that Jesus is the son of God.
You have the context of the entire chapter -- do you see anything here that indicates we are talking about Jesus? Then
there are all the other "prophesies" in this same chapter -- the flies and the bees, the curds and honey, the razor from
across the river, the cow and the goats, the briers and thorns, etc. What is the relationship between curds and honey and
Jesus?
Example 2
Here is another example. In the book of Hosea, chapter 11, there is an important prophecy about Jesus. This is the entire
chapter so you have plenty of context:
1
When Israel was a child, I loved him, and out of Egypt I called my son. 2 The more I called them, the more they
went from me; they kept sacrificing to the Ba'als, and burning incense to idols. 3 Yet it was I who taught E'phraim
to walk, I took them up in my arms; but they did not know that I healed them. 4 I led them with cords of
compassion, with the bands of love, and I became to them as one, who eases the yoke on their jaws, and I bent
down to them and fed them. 5 They shall return to the land of Egypt, and Assyria shall be their king, because they
have refused to return to me. 6 The sword shall rage against their cities, consume the bars of their gates, and
devour them in their fortresses. 7 My people are bent on turning away from me; so they are appointed to the yoke,
and none shall remove it. 8 How can I give you up, O E'phraim! How can I hand you over, O Israel! How can I
make you like Admah! How can I treat you like Zeboi'im! My heart recoils within me, my compassion grows warm
and tender. 9 I will not execute my fierce anger, I will not again destroy E'phraim; for I am God and not man, the
Holy One in your midst, and I will not come to destroy. 10 They shall go after the LORD, he will roar like a lion;
yea, he will roar, and his sons shall come trembling from the west; 11 they shall come trembling like birds from
Egypt, and like doves from the land of Assyria; and I will return them to their homes, says the LORD. 12 E'phraim
has encompassed me with lies, and the house of Israel with deceit; but Judah is still known by God, and is faithful
to the Holy One.
So you look at it… You read it… You read it again… Once again you notice that the material is completely nonsensical
(see chapter 17). In there is an important prophecy of Jesus' life. It is in verse 1. This is supposedly the prophecy that
Jesus will be called out of Egypt after God sends him there to avoid the murder of thousands of babies (see chapter 16).
You have the context of the entire chapter -- do you see anything that indicates we are talking about Jesus besides the
random pair of words "my son"? Even verse 2 is nonsensical. There are all the other "prophesies" in this same chapter --
the Ba'als, the incense, E'phraim, the bands of love, the return to the land of Egypt, the kingdom of Assyria, the sword, the
yoke, Admah, Zeboi'Im, the lion, the birds, the doves of Assyria and so on. What is the relationship between all of this
random material and Jesus?
Example 3
In Zechariah Chapter 9, there is a prophesy that Jesus will ride into Jerusalem on a donkey. Here is the context and the
verse:
1
The word of the Lord is against the land of Hadrach and will rest upon Damascus- for the eyes of men and all
the tribes of Israel are on the Lord - 2 and upon Hamath too, which borders on it, and upon Tyre and Sidon,
though they are very skillful. 3 Tyre has built herself a stronghold; she has heaped up silver like dust, and gold like
the dirt of the streets. 4 But the Lord will take away her possessions and destroy her power on the sea, and she
will be consumed by fire. 5 Ashkelon will see it and fear; Gaza will writhe in agony, and Ekron too, for her hope will
wither. Gaza will lose her king and Ashkelon will be deserted. 6 Foreigners will occupy Ashdod, and I will cut off
the pride of the Philistines. 7 I will take the blood from their mouths, the forbidden food from between their teeth.
Those who are left will belong to our God and become leaders in Judah, and Ekron will be like the Jebusites. 8 But
I will defend my house against marauding forces. Never again will an oppressor overrun my people, for now I am
85
However, the "prophesies" that Jesus fulfilled are odd. They are a collection of rather strange, oblique references proportions. Under an all-encompassing plan like this, the 60 million people who died in WWII all died for specific reasons
scattered throughout the Old Testament. People have grabbed onto them as somehow indicative of something having to -- each death had meaning -- and each death would have rippled through the world causing countless side-effects, also all
do with Jesus, although it is not clear why they do that. Let me show you several of them so that you can see what I part of God's plan. God's master plan would include everyone and everything, including Hitler and WWII.
mean.
Now let's imagine that you say a prayer in this sort of universe. What difference does it make? God has his plan, and that
Example 1 plan is running down its track like a freight train. If God has a plan, then everyone who died in the Holocaust died for a
reason. They had to die, and each death had meaning. Therefore, Holocaust victims could pray all day, and they would
Here is a complete chapter from the book of Isaiah so that you have plenty of context: still die. The idea of a "plan" makes the idea of a "prayer-answering relationship with God" ridiculous. Yet people attach
themselves to both ideas, despite the irresolvable contradiction.
Isaiah chapter 7:
Think about what God's plan means for you personally. If the plan happens to say that you will get hit by a bus tomorrow,
1 or that terrorists will blow you up, or that you will be shot in the head four times, then that's what will happen. It would be
When Ahaz son of Jotham, the son of Uzziah, was king of Judah, King Rezin of Aram and Pekah son of
the same with any disease. If you contract cancer this afternoon and die three months later, that is God's plan for you.
Remaliah king of Israel marched up to fight against Jerusalem, but they could not overpower it.
Praying to cure the cancer is a waste. God plans for you to die, so you will die. He has pre-programmed the exact time of
2 your death. There is nothing you can do to change the plan -- no amount of prayer will help -- because your death will
Now the house of David was told, "Aram has allied itself with Ephraim"; so the hearts of Ahaz and his people have meaning and your death will cause side-effects that are also part of the plan.
were shaken, as the trees of the forest are shaken by the wind.

3 Who will you marry? You actually have no choice in the matter. God has pre-planned your wedding in minute detail. Rick
Then the Lord said to Isaiah, "Go out, you and your son Shear-Jashub, to meet Ahaz at the end of the aqueduct Warren says, "God knew that those two individuals [your parents] possessed exactly the right genetic makeup to create
of the Upper Pool, on the road to the Washerman's Field. 4 Say to him, 'Be careful, keep calm and don't be afraid. the custom 'you' that he had in mind. They had the DNA God wanted to make you." Therefore, your spouse was pre-
Do not lose heart because of these two smoldering stubs of firewood-because of the fierce anger of Rezin and chosen by God for you so that you would create the children who are a part of his plan. You also have no choice in the
Aram and of the son of Remaliah. 5 Aram, Ephraim and Remaliah's son have plotted your ruin, saying, 6 "Let us number of children you will have -- God has pre-planned their births.
invade Judah; let us tear it apart and divide it among ourselves, and make the son of Tabeel king over it." 7 Yet
this is what the Sovereign Lord says:
In addition, this sort of universe means that Hitler is blameless. Hitler was not "evil," because Hitler had no free will at all.
Hitler was simply an actor forced to play his role in God's plan. God planned for millions of people to die in the Holocaust -
" 'It will not take place, - he planned their deaths in exact detail according to Rick Warren. Hitler had to kill those people. Hitler was God's puppet
it will not happen, in making that those millions of deaths happen right on schedule.
8
for the head of Aram is Damascus,
and the head of Damascus is only Rezin.
Within sixty-five years In the same way then, every murderer is blameless. Since God has planned each of our deaths in exact detail, murderers
are actually essential to God's plan. Why do we punish them? We should be rewarding them for doing their God-planned
Ephraim will be too shattered to be a people.
9 duty. What if you get raped tomorrow and get pregnant? God did that because he planned the exact time of that child's
The head of Ephraim is Samaria,
and the head of Samaria is only Remaliah's son. birth and death. God actually pre-planned your rape, and the rapist was God's puppet. Rather than hating the rapist, we
should celebrate God's plan.
If you do not stand firm in your faith,
you will not stand at all.' "
Do you believe that murderers and rapists should be rewarded? Do you believe that Hitler was sent by God to kill millions
10 of people in the Holocaust? Do you believe that God is the direct cause of every abortion on this planet? Do you believe
Again the Lord spoke to Ahaz, 11 "Ask the Lord your God for a sign, whether in the deepest depths or in the
highest heights." that you have no choice in your spouse or the number of children you have? Probably not. But that is what believers are
saying when they say, "it is all part of "God's plan."
12
But Ahaz said, "I will not ask; I will not put the Lord to the test."
You should be able to see reality now. The statement "It is part of God's plan" is meaningless. when you sit down and
13 think it through using your common sense, it makes no sense.
Then Isaiah said, "Hear now, you house of David! Is it not enough to try the patience of men? Will you try the
patience of my God also? 14 Therefore the Lord himself will give you a sign: The virgin will be with child and will
give birth to a son, and will call him Immanuel. 15 He will eat curds and honey when he knows enough to reject the Understanding the illusion of religion
wrong and choose the right. 16 But before the boy knows enough to reject the wrong and choose the right, the
land of the two kings you dread will be laid waste. 17 The Lord will bring on you and on your people and on the You may have believed in God's plan your whole life. There's a very good chance that you own a copy of Rick's book -- it
house of your father a time unlike any since Ephraim broke away from Judah-he will bring the king of Assyria." has sold over 20 million copies.

18 The problem is, what Rick proposes is impossible. If God has "planned the days of your life in advance, choosing the
In that day the Lord will whistle for flies from the distant streams of Egypt and for bees from the land of Assyria.
19 exact time of your birth and death", what that means is that you have absolutely no free will. Humans have no control over
They will all come and settle in the steep ravines and in the crevices in the rocks, on all the thornbushes and at
all the water holes. 20 In that day the Lord will use a razor hired from beyond the River-the king of Assyria-to anything. We are simply puppets executing the plan. It also means that prayer is absolutely pointless.
shave your head and the hair of your legs, and to take off your beards also. 21 In that day, a man will keep alive a
young cow and two goats. 22 And because of the abundance of the milk they give, he will have curds to eat. All You can understand the illusion simply by using your common sense. Work through the implications of what Rick Warren
who remain in the land will eat curds and honey. 23 In that day, in every place where there were a thousand vines says. As soon as you think about it, you will begin to see what is actually going on. As you think about it more and more, it
worth a thousand silver shekels, there will be only briers and thorns. 24 Men will go there with bow and arrow, for becomes obvious that God is imaginary.
the land will be covered with briers and thorns. 25 As for all the hills once cultivated by the hoe, you will no longer
go there for fear of the briers and thorns; they will become places where cattle are turned loose and where sheep
run.

84 33
Chapter 9 - Who gets to go to the prom?
Jesus makes an extremely clear statement about prayer in Mark 11:24:
Therefore I tell you, whatever you ask for in prayer, believe that you have received it, and it will be yours.
Nothing could be simpler than that. All that you have to do is say a prayer, then "believe that you have received it," and
your prayer will be answered. That is what Jesus promises, and Jesus is God so he is perfect.
But is Jesus' statement true? We can test it with this thought experiment.
Let's imagine the following situation. Two girls are attending a Catholic high school. Their names are Alicia and Kristin.
Both of the girls are good students and devout believers. They obey God's commandments. They attend church twice a
week. They pray to God daily. And they are both beautiful, so clearly God has shown them favor.
The prom is coming up, and the most eligible boy at the school is named Mark. Mark is perfect: A great student, a star
athlete, good looking, yet humble and friendly. Everyone loves Mark. He too is a devout believer and he knows both Alicia
and Kristin well.
With the prom approaching, both Alicia and Kristin pray a simple prayer. They both ask God to be Mark's date for the
prom. They do this separately, and neither knows that the other is praying.
Alicia believes with all her heart that God will answer her prayer. Kristin believes with all her heart that God will answer her
prayer. As expressions of their belief, both Alicia and Kristin go shopping for their prom dresses, knowing that Mark will
invite them.
Jesus now has a problem. He has made a promise that he cannot keep. God is perfect and unerring, so the Bible can
contain no mistakes. But clearly Jesus has made a mistake here. Both of these girls believe that their prayers will be
answered, but one of them is going to lose. Jesus is going to end up lying to either Alicia or Kristin. Or he might end up
lying to both of them -- maybe Mark is in love with Buffy, so he invites Buffy instead.
The fact is that Jesus' promise is a false one. Whenever two or more people pray for the same thing and only one person
can have it, someone is going to lose. Common sense tells you that. It does not matter if they both believe, and it does not
matter how fervently and sincerely they pray. The simple fact is that they cannot both get the same thing in that kind of
situation. Therefore, Mark 11:24 is wrong.
In addition, there is nowhere in the belief structure that says that people are God's puppets. God cannot force someone to
fall in or out of love because of someone else's prayer. Common sense tells you that. If we were God's puppets, we would
all be walking around like zombies, doing whatever God wants.
Opposites
What if two people pray for two things that are opposites? If they both believe, who is going to win? For example:
x Imagine that a farmer prays for a good, soaking, daylong rain on Saturday, while a bride who is having her
wedding nearby prays for crystal clear sunshine on the same day. One of them is going to lose.
x Imagine that the fans of two opposing football teams both pray for their teams to win the Super Bowl. One group
is going to lose.
x Imagine that one member of a devout couple prays to become pregnant, and the other prays that they do not.
One of them is going to lose.
Someone must lose, and Jesus' promise in Mark 11:24 turns into a lie. It does not matter how much you believe or how
fervently you pray. If someone else is praying for the opposite of what you are praying for, one of you must lose. It is easy
to think of thousands of situations where Jesus' promise in the Bible cannot possibly be fulfilled.
So... this is uncomfortable. Jesus unmistakably says in the Bible:
34
I tell you the truth, if you have faith and do not doubt, not only can you do what was done to the fig tree, but also
you can say to this mountain, 'Go, throw yourself into the sea,' and it will be done. If you believe, you will receive
whatever you ask for in prayer."
That is obviously false. Section 1 demonstrated dozens of examples that prove this statement to be incorrect. See in
particular Chapter 7.
This statement is also false in John chapter 14:12:
Truly, truly, I say to you, he who believes in me will also do the works that I do; and greater works than these will
he do, because I go to the Father. Whatever you ask in my name, I will do it, that the Father may be glorified in
the Son; if you ask anything in my name, I will do it.
If this were true, we would have completely eradicated all diseases and eliminated all poverty centuries ago.
This statement in Mark 16:15 is provably false:
And [Jesus] said to them, "Go into all the world and preach the gospel to the whole creation. He who believes and
is baptized will be saved; but he who does not believe will be condemned. And these signs will accompany those
who believe: in my name they will cast out demons; they will speak in new tongues; they will pick up serpents,
and if they drink any deadly thing, it will not hurt them; they will lay their hands on the sick, and they will recover."
If this were true, we would not need doctors, hospitals or pharmaceutical companies. You would not need health
insurance. The two billion Christian believers on planet earth today could take care of all of our medical needs for free by
simply laying their hands on us.
This passage from Matthew 15:21-28 is quite bizarre:
Leaving that place, Jesus withdrew to the region of Tyre and Sidon.A Canaanite woman from that vicinity came to
him, crying out, "Lord, Son of David, have mercy on me! My daughter is suffering terribly from demon-
possession." Jesus did not answer a word. So his disciples came to him and urged him, "Send her away, for she
keeps crying out after us." He answered, "I was sent only to the lost sheep of Israel." The woman came and knelt
before him. "Lord, help me!" she said. He replied, "It is not right to take the children's bread and toss it to their
dogs." "Yes, Lord," she said, "but even the dogs eat the crumbs that fall from their masters' table." Then Jesus
answered, "Woman, you have great faith! Your request is granted." And her daughter was healed from that very
hour.
The thing you notice is the incredible racism. Jesus equates the woman to a dog because she is not an Israelite. Would
God do that? Imagine a world leader today equating someone to a dog because she is not of the correct nationality or
religion. The negative reaction would be overwhelming.
What you realize is that, if you go through the Bible and actually read what Jesus says, he is completely wrong in quite a
number of cases. The question you must ask yourself is this: If Jesus is God, why is he not perfect?
Here is the thing that I would like to help you understand: The reason why Jesus was incorrect in so many places is easy
to understand. Jesus was not God. Jesus was a normal human being who was way, way out on a limb.
Chapter 23 - Was Jesus' coming Prophesized?
In the eyes of Christians, one of the things that irrefutably proves that Jesus is God is the fact that Jesus fulfilled many
prophesies from the Old Testament. For example, if you look at the Web site for the Campus Crusade for Christ, you find
this paragraph:
More than 300 prophecies like this were made in the Old Testament and then fulfilled through Jesus' life, death
and resurrection. The chances of one person fulfilling a mere 8 of these prophecies are 1 in
100,000,000,000,000,000. For one person to fulfill 48 of these prophecies, the number becomes staggering--1
chance in 10 to the 157th power (1 with 157 zeros after it). Add to that the 250 other prophecies and it becomes
impossible for any other person except Jesus to ever fit that particular sequence of time and events. [ref]
300 certainly is a huge number of prophesies, and Christians put a lot of stock in them.
83
 Poverty has been described as a situation of “pronounced deprivation in well being” and being poor as “to be
hungry, to lack shelter and clothing, to be sick and not cared for, to be illiterate and not schooled…Poor people
are particularly vulnerable to adverse events outside their control. They are often treated badly by institutions of
the state and society and excluded from voice and power in those institutions.” Using income as a measure of
poverty, the World Development Report refers to the “deep poverty amid plenty” in the world and states that a fifth
of the world’s people live on less than $1 a day, and 44% of them are in South Asia. [ref]
Even in the United States -- one of the wealthiest nations on earth -- poverty is a major problem. According to the United
States Department of Agriculture, more than 26 million children in the United States participate in the National School
Lunch Program, which provides low-cost or free lunches to children at or near the poverty level. [ref] 26 million children
represents about half of all the children in the United States.
One thing that you quickly realize, if you allow yourself to think about it, is that the number of people living in abject
poverty on this planet is staggering. A "fifth of the world’s people" is more than a billion people. You also realize that $1 a
day means that these people are living in hopeless, wretched conditions. Think about how little food you can buy for $1.
Now consider the fact that the $1 is spent on that little bit of food, so there is no money left for housing, clean water,
restroom facilities, clothing, shoes, health care, education, infrastructure, etc. etc. Disease runs rampant. Starvation is
common. This level of poverty is nearly unimaginable to most people in the United States, yet more than a billion people
live this way today.
"Therefore I tell you, whatever you ask for in prayer, believe that you have received it, and it will be yours."
That is so clear and simple, it is impossible to misinterpret it. And Jesus is God, so there is no reason for him to lie about
it. Unfortunately, if the prayers or two people are opposites, one of them is guaranteed to lose no matter how much they
both believe. Jesus' statement is completely wrong.
An experiment
Do your own experiment. Take a devout believer to a casino. Have her pray sincerely to win. Have her recite Mark 11:24
one thousand times. Then have her place a $10 bet on number 17 on the roulette wheel.
Since Mark 11:24 is the word of God, Mark 11:24 must be true. Therefore, she will win and receive $350. Right? What
other possibility is there? Jesus is perfect, and Jesus clearly says, "Whatever you ask in prayer, believe that you have
received it, and it will be yours" and, "if you ask anything in my name, I will do it" and, "Ask, and you shall receive." So she
will win.
Have her then bet the $350 on number 17 and pray again. She will win and receive $12,250. According to Mark 11:24, the
odds of winning are 100%. This bet is a sure thing.

Now consider the fact that, if you raise the bar to $3 a day -- still an extremely meager amount -- half of the people on the You will probably have to move to a new table at this point, because you will be over the table's limit. Move to a new table.
planet are living at that level of poverty. More than three billion people. As discussed in Chapter 5, 10 million children die
every year as a result of abject poverty. Have her bet $12,250 on number 17 again. She will win. That is what God promises. At this point a crowd will have
gathered. Perhaps a news crew will be on hand. She will be holding chips worth nearly half a million dollars in her hands.
Where in the world is Jesus?
Have her bet it all again on lucky number 17.
Here is what Jesus has to say about poverty in the Bible. If you look in Matthew chapter 6:25, you will find this amazing
quote: Why should she stop? There is nothing that is impossible for God. Jesus clearly says that nothing is impossible through
prayer. In Matthew 17:20 Jesus says:
"Therefore I tell you, do not be anxious about your life, what you shall eat or what you shall drink, nor about your
body, what you shall put on. Is not life more than food, and the body more than clothing? Look at the birds of the For truly, I say to you, if you have faith as a grain of mustard seed, you will say to this mountain, 'Move from here
air: they neither sow nor reap nor gather into barns, and yet your heavenly Father feeds them. Are you not of to there,' and it will move; and nothing will be impossible to you.
more value than they? And which of you by being anxious can add one cubit to his span of life? And why are you Nothing will be impossible for you. That statement is crystal clear, and this is the word of God.
anxious about clothing? Consider the lilies of the field, how they grow; they neither toil nor spin; yet I tell you, even
Solomon in all his glory was not arrayed like one of these. But if God so clothes the grass of the field, which today Because of Jesus' promise, your friend will soon be worth millions of dollars. Won't she? What will happen next?
is alive and tomorrow is thrown into the oven, will he not much more clothe you, O men of little faith? Therefore do
not be anxious, saying, 'What shall we eat?' or 'What shall we drink?' or 'What shall we wear?' For the Gentiles 1. Millions of believers will descend on Vegas when they hear the news.
seek all these things; and your heavenly Father knows that you need them all." 2. Every casino in Vegas will be bankrupt one day later.
If "your heavenly Father knows that you need them all," then what in the world has gone wrong? When Jesus says, "Do
not be anxious," what could he possibly mean? If you are living on $1 a day, you are going to be anxious about everything
If prayer worked the way the Bible says it does, then Las Vegas could not exist. People would have prayed all the money
including food, clean drinking water, clothing, basic medical care, sanitation facilities and education. More than a billion
out of Las Vegas years and years ago. Yet, anyone who has visited Vegas recently can see that Vegas is alive and well. It
people are living like that today.
not only exists, but it is growing and thriving. Casinos are making billions of dollars from the unchanging laws of
probability, despite Jesus' promises in the Bible.
How many people is a billion? Take all 300 or so million people in the United States. That is a lot of people. Quadruple
that number. That is how many people are living in abject, wretched, unimaginable poverty around the world. If Jesus
Here is another way to prove that prayer does not work. Take 38 devout believers to the roulette table. Have them all
loves all the little children of the world, he has a truly bizarre way to show his love.
pray. Let all of them call their prayer circles on their cell phones. Make sure all of them recite Mark 11:24. Then have the
38 believers all bet a different single-number bet. There are 38 pockets on the roulette wheel, and there is one devout
What any normal person realizes, when looking at the facts that are plainly visible in our world, is that what Jesus said in believers betting on each of the pockets.
the Bible is completely wrong. Jesus' statements about poverty in Matthew 6:25-32 are clearly false. God is not looking
out for these people. God is not feeding them, nor is he clothing them like lilies. Jesus hates quite a few of the little
Now spin the wheel.
children of the world, and he demonstrates his hatred by imprisoning them in abject poverty.
How many of these 38 prayerful people will win? One. That is how the world works. It does not matter what Jesus
Jesus is completely wrong
promises in the Bible. It does not matter how much the 38 people believe. It does not matter how big or powerful their
prayer circles are. No matter how much they all pray, only one of them can win if the wheel spins one time.
This is not the first example that we have seen in the Bible where Jesus is completely wrong. In section 1 of this book, we
saw that Jesus is clearly wrong when he talks about the power of prayer. Jesus says in Matthew 21:21:

82 35
Explaining the reality that we see in our world
A believer might say, "Out of the 38 people, God will pick the one who is most deserving and let him win." An easy way to
prove that statement false is to put one devout believer and 37 godless, convicted murders around wheel. If God were to
pick the most deserving person, then the devout believer would win every time you spin the wheel. But that is not what
happens. The laws of probability will make sure that each of the convicted murderers wins just as often as the believer
does. It does not matter how much anyone prays or how much anyone believes.
A believer might say, "God only intervenes in lotteries and casinos occasionally, only when it is his divine will, and only for
the most deserving people." That is not what Jesus promises in the Bible. And it is interesting that God only "intervenes"
in a way that exactly follows the natural laws of probability.
If we simply look at what is happening in our world in an objective way, the actual truth of this situation is apparent. The
fact that the outcome exactly follows the natural laws of probability conclusively and provably tells you that God is not
answering prayers. When something exactly follows the laws of probability, what we are seeing is coincidence and
nothing more. If God were actually answering prayers, we would be able to see a statistical effect of God's work. The laws
of probability would work differently for praying people than they would for other people. We would actually have two "laws
of probability" -- one for believers and one for non-believers.
Another person might explain it by saying, "Well of course Jesus does not answer prayers in a casino. Jesus never
answers prayers for money. Prayers for money represent greed." That may be true, but in that case Jesus should have
said, "nothing will be impossible to you, except if you pray for money." There are also lots of believers who would disagree
with the statement, because they believe that God has answered their monetary prayers. The "Prayer of Jabez" is all
about money.
Another believer might say, "God can not bend the laws of probability, in the same way that he cannot bend the laws of
nature. If God was constantly bending the laws of probability, they would not be laws anymore." That makes sense, but
that is not what Jesus said.
Here is what Jesus said in Mark 11:24:
"Therefore I tell you, whatever you ask for in prayer, believe that you have received it, and it will be yours."
That is clear and simple. But it is completely wrong. Why, then, did Jesus say it? Why would Jesus lie to us?
The more important question to ask is: What kind of prayers does Jesus answer? If he never answers the prayers of
amputees, and if he never answers medical prayers, and if he never answers impossible prayers, and if he never answers
prayers that break the laws of nature, and if he never answers prayers that violate the laws of probability, and if he never
answers a prayer that turns another person into a puppet... What's left? When does Jesus answer prayers?
What does your common sense tell you? Based on the experiments we've discussed in the last several chapters, we have
discovered all kinds of prayers that God never answers. How do you reconcile what Jesus has to say about prayer in the
Bible and the Standard Model of God with the reality that we see in our world?
Now what?
When you add all of this to the concepts from the previous chapters, you realize that Jesus misspoke rather broadly when
he talked about prayer. Instead of saying:
"Therefore I tell you, whatever you ask for in prayer, believe that you have received it, and it will be yours."
What Jesus might have meant was this:
Therefore I tell you, whatever you ask for in prayer, believe that you have received it, and it might be yours, as
long as it is possible, and as long as it is my will, and as long as what you pray for does not violate a law of
nature, and as long as what you are praying for does not violate a law of probability, and as long as what you pray
for does not turn another person into a puppet, and as long as no one else who is praying for the same thing
believes more than you do."
36
The usually ritualistic eating of human flesh by a human being
What Jesus is demanding is cannibalism.
You may be beginning to see a pattern here. We have already discussed in chapter 14 that God, in the Old Testament, is
quite captivated by animal sacrifice. God tells people how they are to sacrifice animals in minute detail. In the New
Testament things move to a completely new level and God requires human sacrifice. God is not the only one who gets
excited by human sacrifice -- a flood of Christians saw the movie "The Passion of the Christ."
Now we learn that the human sacrifice is not enough, and we need to ritualistically cannibalize Jesus' body, and
satanically drink his blood, to have "eternal life."
What does your common sense tell you about all of this? Look at it through the eyes of a child. What we are talking about
here is cannibalism, and what Christians are doing looks exactly like a pagan/satanic ritual. If you are a Christian, the two
questions you may be asking yourself right now are:
1. Why in the world am I, as a sane individual, participating in ritualistic cannibalism? How in the world did I stoop to
this point?
2. Why would an all-powerful, all-loving God demand that I do this? What sort of God am I worshipping?
As we saw in section 2, God condones slavery, demands animal and human sacrifice, hates women and revels in the
annihilation of children. Cannibalism is just one more thing to add to this pile of insanity.
The source of the ritual
If you are curious, here is why Christianity contains this bizarre ritual. It is not the case that an all-powerful God in heaven
demands this behavior. All of the rituals in Christianity are completely man-made. Christianity is a snow ball that rolled
over a dozen pagan religions. As the snowball grew, it freely attached pagan rituals in order to be more palatable to
converts. The process is described succinctly and accurately in the book "The Da Vinci Code" by Dan Brown. The book
offers these two accounts of the acretion process:
x "The vestiges of pagan religion in Christian symbology are undeniable. Egyptian sun disks became the halos of
Catholic saints. Pictograms of Isis nursing her miraculously conceived son Horus became the blueprint for our
modern images of the Virgin Mary nursing Baby Jesus. And virtually all the elements of the Catholic ritual - the
miter, the altar, the doxology, and communion, the act of "God-eating" - were taken directly from earlier pagan
mystery religions."
x "Nothing in Christianity is original. The pre-Christian God Mithras - called the Son of God and the Light of the
World - was born on December 25, died, was buried in a rock tomb, and then resurrected in three days. By the
way, December 25 is also the birthday or Osiris, Adonis, and Dionysus. The newborn Krishna was presented with
gold, frankincense, and myrrh. Even Christianity's weekly holy day was stolen from the pagans."
To any normal person, the practice of communion is one of the most bizarre things that Christians do. Jesus' cannibalistic
tendencies offer explicit evidence that Jesus is not God.
When you research it historically, you realize that Jesus was a human being like any other. The mythology of his birth, life
and death are pagan stories that are all man-made.
Chapter 22 - Why do so many children live in poverty?
If, on any Sunday morning in America, you were to visit a Sunday school class full of small children, there are two things
that are nearly guaranteed. On the wall there will be a picture or poster of Jesus with a group of children around him. And
the class will end up singing the song "Jesus loves the little children." Christians are quite fond of both the imagery and
the music.
The question that we should ask is a simple one. If Jesus is all-powerful, all-knowing and all-loving, and if Jesus loves the
little children, then why do so many children live in abject poverty? A paper entitled "Chronic poverty in India" describes
the poverty faced by the world's children in this way:
81
 Child: What's communion?
Daddy: Well, it's where... Well, it's... you know, what we do is we eat Jesus' body to... Well, it's complicated. Let
me see...
Child: We eat Jesus' BODY???
Daddy: Yes. Well, no, but...
Child: Why do we need to eat Jesus??? I don't want to eat Jesus!!!
Daddy: No, no, no. It's OK honey. It's OK. Be quiet now, don't cry in church. Shhhh. Shush. Now it's OK.
Child: But Daddy, I don't want to eat Jesus!
Daddy: Mom, help me out here.
Mom: Honey, it is a holy sacrament. You see, we eat Jesus' body and we drink his blood because...
Child: I have to drink his blood too??? Mommy, I don't want to drink blood!!!
Mom: Honey, calm down! You don't actually drink his blood.
Child: But that man up there is holding up a cup and he is saying that it is Jesus' blood! Mommy! I want to leave! I
am leaving!
Mom, Dad: No honey! Wait! We can't leave now!
And so on...
Because Christians have been participating in the communion rite for many years, they tend to forget just how bizarre this
ritual is. But any child sees it with fresh eyes. And many children are, naturally, horrified at the thought of eating Jesus'
body and then drinking his blood. It is grotesque in the extreme and a child implicitly understands that.
Have you ever wondered where this ritual came from, or why billions of people would participate in a ritual that is this
bizarre? First, let's look at the part of the Bible that prescribes the ritual. You find it in Mark, Chapter 14:
And as they were eating, he took bread, and blessed, and broke it, and gave it to them, and said, "Take; this is my
body." And he took a cup, and when he had given thanks he gave it to them, and they all drank of it. And he said
to them, "This is my blood of the covenant, which is poured out for many.
There are a few lines in Luke chapter 22 that are nearly identical.
Jesus gets far more graphic, however, in John chapter 6:53-55:
So Jesus said to them, "Truly, truly, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink his blood,
you have no life in you; he who eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up at the
last day. For my flesh is food indeed, and my blood is drink indeed.
To any normal person, this sounds very much like the script of a gruesome horror film. It sounds like some sort of
revolting satanic ritual. It definitely does not sound like the words of the all-loving creator of the universe.
Imagine that you are a normal person, and you have never been exposed to Christianity before. Now imagine that a
Christian comes up to you and quotes John 6:53. Any normal adult would rightfully assume the Christian to be insane.
Thus, you never see a bumper sticker that says "John 6:53."
However, the assumption is accurate. The dictionary describes cannibalism in the following way:
80
If this is what Jesus meant, then it begins to explain why so many prayers go unanswered. Unfortunately, it also means
that what Jesus had to say about prayer in the Bible is wrong. And it is hard to explain why God would publish something
that is wrong in the Bible when God is perfect.
Is there a better explanation? Yes, there is. If we assume that God never answers any prayers, then all of these conflicts
and problems disappear completely. The huge advantage of this explanation is that it perfectly fits the data that we see in
our world. And what it means is that prayer -- a cornerstone of the religious faith -- is meaningless. Whenever "God
answers a prayer," what we are actually seeing is a simple coincidence, nothing more.
Chapter 10 - Why do battlefield prayers sound so convincing?
If you have taken the time to read the preceding chapters, you may be starting to notice a pattern. If we assume that God
is imaginary, then the world makes far more sense than it does if God is real. For example:
x Why won't God heal amputees? If God is real, it is a mystery. If God is imaginary, it makes complete sense.
x Why is there no statistical advantage to praying if you are sick? If God is real, it is a mystery. If God is imaginary,
it makes complete sense.
x Why can't you move a mountain? Why does God never answer impossible prayers? If God is real, it is a mystery.
If God is imaginary, it makes complete sense.
x Why do the laws of probability in Las Vegas apply to believers in exactly the same way that they do for everyone
else? Why haven't believers prayed all the money out of Vegas? If God is real, it is a mystery. If God is imaginary,
it makes complete sense.
x Why do bad things happen to good people? If God is real, it is a mystery. If God is imaginary, it makes complete
sense.
Let's look at one more example that confirms this trend: The Battlefield Effect.
The "battlefield effect" is one reason why so many people believe in the power of prayer. By understanding how it works,
you can understand a great deal about how prayer works.
Let's say that a general sends 10,000 soldiers into a fierce battle. Although the general does not know it at the time, the
10,000 men end up marching into an ambush. The enemy has 30,000 troops, artillery support plus close air support and
is able to decimate the 10,000 soldiers in short order. Once the enemy is finished, they leave 100 survivors out of the
original 10,000 to limp and crawl back to base.
You may have heard that there are no atheists in foxholes. Before they died, we can assume that every single one of the
10,000 soldiers who marched into the ambush prayed fervently and deeply for God to spare his life. Despite those
prayers, the enemy proceeded to attack with deadly force. 9,900 of those who prayed wasted their breath -- they died.
The 100 who return from the battle, however, feel as though their prayers were answered. They have been through a
horrific firefight, and they are deeply grateful to have escaped with their lives. At the time they prayed, they were
absolutely and totally terrified and desperate. To have survived seems like a miracle.
The 100 survivors fan out with their personal stories of answered prayers. They tell their soldier buddies how they prayed
for their lives and their prayers were answered. When they arrive home they tell their families and friends about their
harrowing experiences on the battlefield and how nothing but their prayers saved them. They give testimonials at church,
give speeches in the community, write articles for magazines, etc. Millions of people are exposed to the positive, powerful,
personal testimonials of the 100 survivors.
This is great advertising for prayer. And it works. People hear the stories of the survivors and they believe. The real power
of this approach, however, comes from the fact that the 9,900 dead soldiers never get to tell their side of the story. Ninety
nine percent of the soldiers died, and only one percent survived. Far more men prayed and died, but they never get to tell
anyone about their disappointment.
So the 100 personal testimonials FOR prayer are strong, loud, frequent and compelling. Meanwhile the 9,900 personal
testimonials AGAINST prayer are silent, because the dead soldiers never get a chance to speak. Therefore, to a casual
37
observer, it appears that prayer works. Every story that you hear is positive. The reality is that 99% of the praying people
died. It is another perfect example of God's Ratio (see Chapter 2).
Dropping like flies
Let's say that you listen to a person tell this story: "There I was in a horrific firefight on the battlefield. All of my friends
around me were dropping like flies. But I prayed to God and he saved me." The question that any normal person would
ask is, "Why did God let all the others drop like flies? And why aren't you running away from a God who killed 99% of your
friends instead of answering their equally fervent prayers?"
The fact that 9,900 praying people died while only 100 survived should be plenty of evidence to indicate that prayer does
not work. A 99% failure rate is significant. But for some reason, believers do not seem to think about the 9,900 who died.
They instead celebrate the "answered prayers" of the 100. The 9,900 who died are swept under the carpet.
It should be becoming obvious to you what actually happens on any battlefield. The survivors benefit from random luck
and nothing more. Their "answered prayers" are simply coincidences.
Here are several other examples of the same coincidental phenomenon. Imagine that you hear the following stories from
four survivors:
x "I was a prisoner in a concentration camp, and in the morning we were marched to the death chambers. I knew
that I could not die -- I had to live so that I could see my baby again. I began praying the most intense prayers I
have ever prayed as soon as we started marching. When we got to the gas chambers, an amazing miracle
occurred -- I somehow had moved to the end of the line, and there was no room for me in the chamber! I was told
to join a nearby work group, and I survived. God heard my prayers,
and I was saved!"
God's Ratio
x "It was the most amazing flood in the history of Honduras. An
immense wall of mud cascaded down the mountain and through our
Mary kills 20,000 people in the mud
city, killing 20,000 people. I was caught in the tide of sludge and
slide but answers the prayers of
sucked deep into the bowels of the torrent. In just a few seconds I
one. That's a 99.995% failure rate
would drown and die in a sea of mud. But I prayed to the Virgin
for prayers. It should prove to you
Mary, and not one second later my head popped to the surface, I
conclusively that neither Mary nor
was able to grab a nearby branch and pull myself out. The virgin
Mary answered my prayers!" God answer prayers.
x "There is no way to explain the miracle that happened next. I said a
quick prayer before my car slammed into and then underneath the truck in front of me. As if by magic, the entire
car crumpled like a wad of paper -- the entire car, except for the passenger area where we were sitting! God
heard and answered my prayers by using his power to protect the interior of the car and save our lives!"
x "I was on a business trip. I got drunk and had a one night stand with a stranger. It is totally unlike me, but it
happened. In the morning I realized what I had done and I was wracked with guilt. I got down on my knees and
said a very sincere prayer: "Dear God, please don't let me have AIDS. I cannot die of AIDS. The embarrassment
and pain would be too much for my spouse, my children and my parents. It only happened one time, and I
promise that it will never happen again. If you will grant me this prayer, I will do ANYTHING that you ask. Amen." I
waited three months and I was a nervous wreck. I went to my doctor to get tested and I was clean. The relief that I
felt was incredible, like a huge burden being lifted from my soul. God personally answered this prayer for me!"
Believers seem to love these stories. We hear miraculous personal testimonies like these all the time. They are supposed
to show the "power of prayer" and the "love of God" in our world today.
However, what I would ask you to consider is both sides of the story. Look at both the successes AND the failures of
prayer, and what we see is extremely uncomfortable. All of them display God's ratio as described in Chapter 2. If God let
millions of people die in the Holocaust, but then "heard the prayers" of one person and saved him, what sort of God is
that? To say that God killed millions and saved one is a terrible ratio. God would have to be a monster. Killing millions of
people is an unimaginable atrocity.
38
Whatever you ask in my name, I will do it, that the Father may be glorified in the Son; if you ask anything in my
name, I will do it.
In Matthew 18:19:
Again I say to you, if two of you agree on earth about anything they ask, it will be done for them by my Father in
heaven. For where two or three are gathered in my name, there am I in the midst of them.
Jesus is actually in our midst. So he is right here already, supposedly. Yet when we pray to him to physically materialize,
as he did to hundreds of others, nothing happens.
Isn't it odd that Nothing happens, given the fact that Jesus promises us that something will happen? Isn't it odd that
nothing happens when, supposedly, Jesus is right here with us already, and materialization would be trivial for him?
What you will find, if you think about it, is that the situation we see here is exactly like the situation in Chapter 5. We have
created a situation where coincidence cannot "answer" the prayer. The only way for this prayer to be answered is for
Jesus to actually, unambiguously, materialize. In this situation, we also know that it is trivial for Jesus to materialize, that
there would be many benefits if Jesus did materialize, that Jesus has supposedly materialized to other human beings, and
that Jesus has promised to answer our prayer that he materialize.
How do we explain the fact that this prayer goes unanswered, no matter who prays, despite Jesus' promise that he will
answer our prayers?
As you think about this, you will realize that Paul's story in the Bible must be false. Simply look at Paul's story like any
judge in a courtroom would. What Paul's story in 1 Cor 15 is suggesting is entirely unprecedented - a man dead three
days with mortal wounds came back to life. Yet there is no evidence that it is true, and there are many alternative
explanations for what Paul is saying. Paul could be fabricating the story, Paul could have hallucinated or dreamed the
meeting, Paul could have seen an imposter, etc. In addition, no one is seeing Jesus today, even though it would be trivial
and obvious for Jesus to appear to people today just like he did with Paul.
Given this evidence, if this were any normal situation instead of a religious one, people would conclude that what Paul is
saying is untrue. There is zero evidence to support Paul's story, zero reason to believe it, a motive to lie and plenty of
alternative explanations. There is also the fact that much of the rest of the Bible contains provably false stories. Plus the
fact that it would be trivial for Jesus to provide the evidence that Paul needs to confirm his story by reappearing on earth.
Add to that the fact that Jesus has promised to answer our prayers but refuses to materialize when we pray to him. The
only thing to do is to reject Paul's story. Every bit of evidence points to the fact that the resurrection story is a myth,
nothing more.
What about Jesus' famous statement in the Bible, "Happy are those who have not seen yet still believe"? What you realize
is that this statement creates the perfect cover for a scam. Let's say you are Jesus, you are a normal human being, you
realize that you are going to die and you want to cover for this fact. Here is what you would say: "Happy are those who
have not seen yet still believe." What you are saying is, "I exist, and the way I am going to show you that I exist is by not
showing that I exist." For every other object in the universe, the way that we know it exists is because the object provides
evidence of its existence. If there is no evidence for an object's existence, we call it imaginary (e.g. Leprechauns). But with
Jesus, the lack of evidence is turned into evidence. Quite clever, but obviously a scam.
If the resurrection were true, then Jesus would be answering prayers as he promises in the Bible. He would also appear
when people pray to see him. The fact is, as we saw in Section 1, there is no evidence whatsoever that Jesus answers
prayers.
Chapter 21 - Why do we eat Jesus?
If you are looking for an easy way to prove to yourself that Jesus is not God, try this simple experiment. Take a small
child, perhaps age 4 or 5, to church on Sunday and let the child watch communion. You may experience something like
this:
Child: Daddy, what are they doing?
Daddy: Well dear, this part of the service is called communion.
79
 x Matthew chapter 28
x Mark chapter 16
x Luke chapter 24
x John Chapter 20 and 21
1 Corinthians 15:3-6 provides a nice summary of those passages, as written by Paul:
For I delivered to you as of first importance what I also received, that Christ died for our sins in accordance with
the scriptures, that he was buried, that he was raised on the third day in accordance with the scriptures, and that
he appeared to Cephas, then to the twelve. Then he appeared to more than five hundred brethren at one time,
most of whom are still alive, though some have fallen asleep. Then he appeared to James, then to all the
apostles. Last of all, as to one untimely born, he appeared also to me.
As you can see in this passage, Jesus appeared to hundreds of people a number of different times.
Being like Paul
When we look at these Bible passages, there is a question that comes to mind -- why did Jesus stop making these
appearances? Why isn't Jesus appearing today?
It really is odd. Obviously Paul benefitted from a personal meeting with the resurrected Christ. Because of the personal
visit, Paul could see for himself the truth of the resurrection, and he could ask Jesus questions.
So... Why doesn't Jesus appear to everyone and prove that he is resurrected, just like he appeared to Paul? There is
nothing to stop Jesus from materializing in your kitchen tonight to have a personal chat with you. And if you think about it,
Jesus really does need to appear to each of us. If Paul needed a personal visit from Jesus to know that Jesus was
resurrected, then why wouldn't you?
It is an important question for the following reasons:
Key Point
x We are told by the Bible that Jesus appeared to hundreds of people. If Paul needed a personal visit from
x We know that it is OK for Jesus to appear to people -- it does not take away Jesus to know that Jesus was
their free will, for example -- because it was OK for Jesus to appear to resurrected, then why wouldn't
hundreds of other people. you?
x We know that it would be easy for Jesus to appear to everyone all through
history, since Jesus is all-powerful and timeless.
x We know that, if Jesus did reappear to everyone, it would be incredibly helpful. We could all know, personally,
that Jesus is resurrected and that Jesus is God. If Paul (and all the other people in the Bible) needed a personal
visit to know that Jesus was resurrected, then why not you and me?
x Yet, we all know that Jesus has not appeared to anyone in 2,000 years.
In other words, there is nothing stopping Jesus from appearing to you, and several
Key Point
good reasons for him to appear.
The reason why Jesus has
Praying to Jesus
appeared to no one for 2,000 years
is because Jesus never appeared
What if we pray to Jesus like this: "Dear Jesus, please appear to us, as you did to to anyone.
Paul and the 500 brethren, so that we can see the evidence of your resurrection. In
your name we pray, amen." Here is what Jesus has promised us in the Bible:
Matthew 7:7 Jesus says:
Ask, and it will be given you; seek, and you will find; knock, and it will be opened to you. For every one who asks
receives, and he who seeks finds, and to him who knocks it will be opened. Or what man of you, if his son asks
him for bread, will give him a stone? Or if he asks for a fish, will give him a serpent? If you then, who are evil,
know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more will your Father who is in heaven give good things
to those who ask him!
In John chapter 14:14:
78
Believers seem to be completely comfortable with the sort of schizophrenia shown here. They are happy about the one
person saved from the Holocaust by a prayer -- they actually celebrate his story and tell it with glee. They do not seem to
care that, if it was God saving the one, then it must also have been God who killed the millions of others by completely
ignoring their prayers.
With your common sense you can examine all of these situations and see what actually happened by looking at both
sides of the story:
x In the case of the Holocaust survivor, it was not a "miracle" that God's Ratio
saved him. To believe that is to believe that God killed millions of
others by specifically withholding his blessings from them. What
actually happened was dumb luck and coincidence. God kills millions in the Holocaust
x In the case of the mudslide, do you believe that Mary heard the but answers the prayers of one.
prayers of one person while purposefully ignoring the prayers of That's a 99.99998% failure rate for
20,000 others and killing all of them? Of course not -- that is prayers. It should prove to you
ridiculous. This man's survival involves luck and coincidence as conclusively that God does not
answer prayers.
well. If the man's story were actually true, it would make Mary a
capricious demon guilty of mass murder.
x In the case of the car, it is not a miracle that the passenger compartment remained intact -- that is how the car is
designed. It is called a passenger safety cage. God had absolutely nothing to do with it. In the United States,
40,000 people die every year in car accidents. If God actually saved this driver, then it is an atrocity that God let
the other 40,000 people die by ignoring their prayers.
x In the case of the AIDS survivor, God did not answer the prayer. Tens of millions of people have died of AIDS. To
believe that God answered the prayer is to also to believe that God killed tens of millions of other praying people.
What actually happened is random luck. Despite all the media attention AIDS gets, in the United States less than
one percent of the sexually active adult population has the HIV virus. [ref] And it is not guaranteed that HIV will be
transmitted during every sexual encounter. So the odds are excellent that, after one sexual encounter, the person
will not get AIDS. It does not matter whether the person prayed or not -- it was simply luck through the normal
laws of probability.
The unconscionable arrogance of the blessed
Let's assume that a tremendous hurricane like Hurricane Katrina hits Louisiana. It does an incredible amount of damage,
destroying hundreds of thousands of homes, killing thousands of people and wiping entire towns off the map.
Your sister, a devout believer, happens to live in Louisiana, and a week later when cell phone service is restored she
gives you a call. The first words out of her mouth are:
"Oh, God has blessed us so much this week! We prayed all through the storm, and he answered our prayers. The
next town over was completely decimated, but our house is still standing. We are so blessed! God answered our
prayers!"
What I would like you to do is step back for a moment, look at this statement, and think about the remarkable arrogance
that it represents. What your sister is saying is this, "I am so special and God loves ME so much that God heard MY
prayers and personally helped ME. All those millions of other people who God cursed -- obviously God hates THEM. I am
cool in the eyes of God, and all those other wretched people out there are, obviously, uncool in the eyes of God.
Otherwise he would have helped them just like he helped ME."
For a beliver to talk about his or her blessings in a huge natural disaster like Katrina is to implicitly ignore the damage and
suffering that are plainly visible for all to see. If God "blessed" one, while completely ignoring millions of other believers
caught in exactly the same predicament, it says nothing about blessings. It says that God is an insane demon. For anyone
to believe that God personally helped her while at the same time wreaking havoc on millions of others is a supreme
arrogance. Yet believers seem to be completely comfortable with this arrogance.
The truth of the matter is easy to see if you will take the time to look at both sides of the equation. The hurricane hit, and
God neither blessed nor cursed anyone. The hurricane did its damage according to the laws of nature. The fact that one
house is undamaged while thousands of others are swept into the sea is not a blessing. It is random luck, nothing more.
39
When you hear people discussing their personal experiences with the power of prayer, simply listen to the stories they tell
and ask to hear both sides. Look for God's Ratio. In every case, the prayer's power can be explained by coincidence, luck,
normal probabilities, the laws of physics, human design or some other normal, non-miraculous process. And God's Ratio
will be terrible, just as it was on Steve Homel's street.
Chapter 11 - Reviewing the evidence about prayer
At the beginning of this section, we looked to the Bible and found that Jesus makes a number of specific and remarkable
promises having to do with prayer. For example, in Matthew 7:7 Jesus says:
Ask, and it will be given you; seek, and you will find; knock, and it will be opened to you. For every one who asks
receives, and he who seeks finds, and to him who knocks it will be opened. Or what man of you, if his son asks
him for bread, will give him a stone? Or if he asks for a fish, will give him a serpent? If you then, who are evil,
know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more will your Father who is in heaven give good things
to those who ask him!
In Matthew 17:20 Jesus reiterates that same message:
For truly, I say to you, if you have faith as a grain of mustard seed, you will say to this mountain, 'Move from here
to there,' and it will move; and nothing will be impossible to you."
Jesus says something similar in Matthew 21:21:
I tell you the truth, if you have faith and do not doubt, not only can you do what was done to the fig tree, but also
you can say to this mountain, 'Go, throw yourself into the sea,' and it will be done. If you believe, you will receive
whatever you ask for in prayer."
Jesus says something even more straightforward in Mark 11:24:
Therefore I tell you, whatever you ask for in prayer, believe that you have received it, and it will be yours.
In John chapter 14 Jesus describes just how easy prayer can be:
12 "Truly, truly, I say to you, he who believes in me will also do the works that I do; and greater works than these
will he do, because I go to the Father. 13 Whatever you ask in my name, I will do it, that the Father may be
glorified in the Son; 14 if you ask anything in my name, I will do it.
In the case of medical problems, James 5:15-16 says:
And the prayer offered in faith will make the sick person well; the Lord will raise him up. If he has sinned, he will
be forgiven. Therefore confess your sins to each other and pray for each other so that you may be healed. The
prayer of a righteous man is powerful and effective.
Jesus' message in the Bible is so clear and simple. God answers prayers. Ask and you will receive. The message is
reiterated over and over again. In Mark 9:23: "All things are possible to him who believes." In Luke 1:37: "For with God
nothing will be impossible." Nothing is impossible through prayer.
However, when you look at the world around you, you find that things are not like that at all. You find yourself surrounded
by contradictions:
x God never answers the prayers of amputees. If he did, we would see amputated limbs spontaneously
regenerating every day.
x God never moves mountains -- if he did, we would see mountains moving around all the time.
x God never answers impossible prayers -- if he did, people would be flying through the air like superman on a
regular basis.
x God never answers prayers that turn people into puppets -- if he did, then you are a puppet.
x God never answers prayers that break the laws of nature -- if he did, then scientific equations and computer
models would have to take God's random antics into account.
x God never answers prayers that break the laws of probability -- if he did, then every believer would be rich and
Las Vegas could not exist.
x When two people pray opposite one another, obviously someone's prayer will go unanswered. If a million people
pray for the same thing but only one can have it (e.g. - winning the lottery), then by definition 999,999 people will
have their prayers unanswered.
x God doesn't answer medical prayers -- otherwise the U.S. would not need to spend $2 trillion a year on health
care.
x God doesn't answer prayers to avert natural disasters -- if he did, hurricanes would not hit the U.S.
40
In 1 Corinthians 15:6, Paul says,
Then he [Jesus, after the resurrection] appeared to more than five hundred brethren at one time.
Those 500 people must have lost their free will. And John says:
Jesus did many other things as well. If every one of them were written down, I suppose that even the whole world
would not have room for the books that would be written. (John 21:25)
That's an awful lot of miracles -- so many that the world would not have room for all the books describing them.
Presumably at least one person witnessed each miracle. Think of how many names fill just one phone book. Now imagine
a whole world full of phone books. That's a lot of people. Weren't all of their free wills affected? How is God hiding if
millions of people saw Jesus and the miracles he performed?
Jesus claims to be God, and Jesus is a physical being running around Israel for all to see. He apparently performed
millions of miracles in front of millions of people. The God of the Bible is not hiding -- God is so hungry for publicity and
exposure that he actually incarnates himself and then starts performing miracles for everyone on the planet. Then he
creates a God-breathed book to describe everything and publishes billions of copies all over the world.
Yet, for some reason, God wants none of us today to see any of those miracles because he "needs to remain hidden" so
that he will not "taint our free wills." Does that seem likely? Or is it more likely that Jesus never performed a real miracle?
When you combine this evidence with the fact that Jesus answers no prayers (see section 1), it is clear to us what is
actually happening.
Drawing a conclusion
Here is an important question for you to ask yourself: If Jesus needed miracles to
Key Point
prove to people that he is God, and if it did not hurt their "free wills" to see these
miracles, and if all these miracles were written down and attested to by Matthew,
Mark, Luke and John so that we could all experience them vicariously today, then If Jesus needed miracles to prove
why didn't Jesus perform a single real miracle? Why didn't any of Jesus' miracles to people that he is God, and if it
have a physical permanence that would transcend time and prove his story? did not hurt their "free wills" to see
these miracles, and if all these
miracles were written down and
To better understand the question, try this: Imagine that you are watching a
attested to by Matthew, Mark, Luke
magician like David Copperfield on television. He "heals" a few people -- makes a
and John so that we could all
blind person see, makes a lame person walk, etc. He demonstrates that he can "turn
experience them vicariously today,
water into wine." Then he goes one step further and says, "I am God! I have just
then why is it wrong for us to see a
proven it to you by my miracles!"
real miracle and have actual proof
today? Why didn't any of Jesus'
Would any of us believe him? Of course not. To believe that someone is God, we miracles have a physical
would need incontrovertible proof. We would not accept magic tricks. We know that permanence that would transcend
they are meaningless. time and prove his story to
everyone? Because Jesus was a
God is not trying to remain "hidden" -- all we have to do is open the Bible to see it. normal human being just like you
And it is obvious that, if a person were to claim to be God today, we would demand and me.
real proof. Therefore, the fact that Jesus did not perform a single miracle that is
visible and testable today proves to all of us that Jesus was a normal human being, just like you and me.
Chapter 20 - Why doesn't Jesus appear to each of us?
In the last chapter, we discussed Jesus' miracles. There is one miracle, however, that deserves special discussion. Jesus'
resurrection after his death is the ultimate and defining proof of Jesus' divinity.
Just about everyone knows the story of Jesus' death and resurrection. The story is summarized in the Apostles' Creed.
Jesus was crucified, died, and was buried. He descended into hell. On the third day he arose again from the dead. He
ascended into heaven and sits at the right hand of God the Father Almighty.
There is only one way for Jesus to prove that he rose from the dead. He had to appear to people. Therefore, several
different places in the Bible describe Jesus' appearances after his death:
77
 Then Moses stretched out his hand over the sea; and the LORD drove the sea back by a strong east wind all
night, and made the sea dry land, and the waters were divided. And the people of Israel went into the midst of the
sea on dry ground, the waters being a wall to them on their right hand and on their left.
That is impressive, and it is utterly obvious. Thousands of Israelites witnessed this event. There are many other events
that are equally obvious: manna from heaven, the Ten Commandments carved onto stone tablets, the Passover
massacre and so on. All of it is described in the Bible, which God wrote so that billions of people can read about these
events and experience them vicariously today.
It is pretty hard to hide something that you do in front of thousands of people and then describe and publish in billions of
books. Clearly God is not a hidden God.
But there is an even more impressive sign that we often forget. If God exists and God wrote the Bible, then rainbows are
actually proof that God exists. God is not hiding at all. If you read Genesis 9:12-13 you will find this:
And God said, "This is the sign of the covenant which I make between me and you and every living creature that
is with you, for all future generations: I set my bow in the cloud, and it shall be a sign of the covenant between me
and the earth..."
What could be more obvious than that? God left a sign for all future generations, according to the Bible. Clearly God does
not want to hide.
There are also plenty of cases in the New Testament. For example, Matthew, Chapter 17:
After six days Jesus took with him Peter, James and John the brother of James, and led them up a high mountain
by themselves. There he was transfigured before them. His face shone like the sun, and his clothes became as
white as the light. Just then there appeared before them Moses and Elijah, talking with Jesus.
Peter said to Jesus, "Lord, it is good for us to be here. If you wish, I will put up three shelters--one for you, one for
Moses and one for Elijah."
While he was still speaking, a bright cloud enveloped them, and a voice from the cloud said, "This is my Son,
whom I love; with him I am well pleased. Listen to him!"
These are not exactly the actions of a God in hiding. Apparently the free wills of Peter, James and John were not that
important to God. And again it is published in the Bible so that billions of other people can read about it.
Or take this passage from the book of Matthew, Chapter 3:
As soon as Jesus was baptized, he went up out of the water. At that moment heaven was opened, and he saw
the Spirit of God descending like a dove and lighting on him. And a voice from heaven said, "This is my Son,
whom I love; with him I am well pleased."
Again, not exactly a hidden God.
Or this passage from the book of Luke, Chapter 2:
And there were shepherds living out in the fields nearby, keeping watch over their flocks at night. An angel of the
Lord appeared to them, and the glory of the Lord shone around them, and they were terrified. But the angel said
to them, "Do not be afraid. I bring you good news of great joy that will be for all the people. Today in the town of
David a Savior has been born to you; he is Christ the Lord. This will be a sign to you: You will find a baby
wrapped in cloths and lying in a manger."
Suddenly a great company of the heavenly host appeared with the angel, praising God and saying, "Glory to God
in the highest, and on earth peace to men on whom his favor rests."
When the angels had left them and gone into heaven, the shepherds said to one another, "Let's go to Bethlehem
and see this thing that has happened, which the Lord has told us about."
The free will of the shepherds was certainly tarnished a bit here.
76
It is easy to see that God does not answer all of these different kinds of prayers. It is obvious through casual observation,
but it is also easily proven with statistics. Statistical studies do not show any effects from praying. [ref] When people talk
about "the power of prayer", what we are actually witnessing is "the power of coincidence."
So let's agree on this point -- God does not answer prayers. Something this apparent should not be hard to accept, and
this conclusion perfectly fits the evidence that we see in the world around us. There is no evidence whatsoever that any
human god answers prayers. There are mountains of empirical and statistical evidence showing that prayers are never
answered.
If it is this obvious, then why do believers so adamantly insist that God answers prayers? Why is there an entire industry
built around inspirational literature? Why do believers demand prayer in public schools? Why do believers hang onto the
idea of prayer so strongly when it is quite obvious that God does not answer prayers? To answer these questions, please
see Understanding Christian Motivations.
The problem with prayer
The problem with prayer is simple: prayer is an illusion, and the people who believe in prayer must ignore reality in order
to believe in it. If you look at the data rationally, you can see exactly what is happening here:
x When we pray to God about any unambigous situation, God never answers the prayer. For example, if we pray to
God to restore an amputated limb, absolutely nothing happens. See this page for an in-depth discussion.
x When we analyse any ambiguous prayer using statistical tools, we find zero effect from prayer. For example, if we
have Christians pray for 1,000 cancer patients, those patients do not recover any faster or live any longer.
In other words, the data shows us that every "answered prayer" truly is a coincidence, nothing more. God doesn't
"answer prayers" at all. The whole idea that "God answers prayers" is an illusion created by human imagination.
Christians, unfortunately, must ignore reality in order to believe in prayer.
Whether you are a Christian or not, I think we would agree that people who "ignore reality" and "turn off their ability to
process factual information" have some sort of problem. And the problem is serious. For example, we would probably
agree people who ignore reality are not the sort of people who we want in positions of responsibility in our society. And
yet, Christians cling to their beliefs.
Thus, Christians find themselves in extremely awkward and, quite frankly, embarrassing positions. They must "believe"
that God answers their prayers even though it is quite obvious that he does not. They find themselves in uncomfortable
conversations like this one:
Chris: God DOES exist! God IS all-loving and all-powerful! God DOES answer prayers! God is real and I have a
living relationship with him every day! Lift up your heart and accept the Lord Jesus into your life today!
Norm: Can you give me an example?
Chris: Absolutely. Just yesterday I locked my keys in my car, and I prayed to God. Not five minutes later my
husband came home unexpectedly for lunch and let me into the house. God answered my prayer yesterday!
Norm: Can you not see that this was a coincidence?
Chris: Absolutely not. God made my husband come home at that moment. God did it.
Norm: Wouldn't that make your husband God's puppet?
Chris: Absolutely not.
Norm: So… God answered your specific prayer in five minutes by sending your husband home. God actually
reached down onto planet earth and guided your husband. But on the same day, God allowed thousands of
41
 praying people around the globe to die of starvation, and he allowed thousands of praying patients to die of
cancer and other diseases, and he allowed thousands more praying people to lose their jobs, die in accidents,
contract diseases, etc.?
Chris: Yes, God answers MY prayers.
Norm: Does that make sense to you? Why would God have a relationship with you so intimate that he personally
solves your most trivial problems, while at the same time he has given thousands of people new cancers today?
Chris: God loves me.
Norm: And what about the times when you pray for something and he doesn't answer your prayer? Or all the
millions of people whose very sincere prayers go unanswered each day?
Chris: When God does not answer my prayers, it's because it is not part of his plan.
Norm: God has a plan for each of us?
Chris: Yes, of course he does. God has counted every hair on my head. God has a plan for me.
Norm: So… God's plan was for millions of people to die horrible deaths in the Holocaust? He planned that?
Chris: Yes.
Norm: Isn't a being who commits the pre-meditated murder of millions of people an abomination -- a horrific
monster?
Chris: Of course not. God is all-loving.
Norm: Then what if God's plan for you is for you to die after being raped, tortured and then stabbed to death by a
serial killer? When you pray for escape, God totally ignores you and you die because that is his plan for you.
Would you say that God answered your prayers in that case?
Chris: God would never let that happen to me. God loves me. God answers my prayers.
Norm: Then how, exactly, did God totally ignore millions of praying people who died in the Holocaust?
Chris: They were not believers. God punished them.
Norm: OK... Then why did God kill the tens of millions of praying believers -- both soldiers and civilians -- who
died during WWII? Why would God send your husband home for lunch, but completely ignore these millions of
other people.
Chris: It was all part of God's plan.
This discussion can go on and on and on like this, cycling endlessly. The believer appears to be unhinged on multiple
levels. It seems to be the only way for the believer to maintain the internal illusion that God exists and that God wrote the
Bible.
An Insane God
Simply look at the world we live in. All around us we have murderers, rapists, robbers, child molesters, terrorists, etc...
How do they do their deeds? If God is all-knowing and God answers prayers, then we have to believe that:
42
For religious people, however, it is a different story. If you ask a religious person
Key Point
about Jesus' divinity, you may find yourself in a conversation like this:
Jesus did not provide any concrete
Norm: If Jesus is God, why didn't Jesus ever prove that he is God?
proof of his divinity. For any normal
person, that makes things simple --
Chris: He did! He performed many miracles, and he was resurrected. That Jesus is not God. To believe that
proves that he is God! anyone today is God, we would
need concrete proof. Jesus does
Norm: Why did he not prove that he is God in a way that is definitive and not get a pass because he lived
scientifically provable -- for example, by moving a mountain? 2,000 years ago.
Chris: He could not do that! That would take away man's free will to believe in him. People must come to God
through faith.
Norm: Why, then, did Jesus perform the miracles described in the Gospels?
Chris: To prove that he is God. If he had not done the miracles, culminating in his final most miraculous
resurrection, we would not know that he is God.
Norm: I thought that if Jesus performed miracles to prove that he was God, then it took away our free will.
Chris: No.
Norm: Isn't that what you just said?
Chris: No. What I just said is that Jesus' miracles prove that he was God.
Norm: So why didn't Jesus perform real, concrete miracles like moving a mountain?
Chris: Because that would take away our free will.
Try having this conversation yourself with a Christian and you will find it to be a very odd discussion. The circular logic will
make you dizzy:
x Jesus had to perform miracles to prove his divinity, and that doesn't take away free will...
x ...But if Jesus performed miracles that we could see and scientifically verify, it would take away free will.
Any normal person can see reality. The reason why Jesus did not perform concrete, verifiable miracles is because Jesus
was a man like any other. The "miracles" discussed in the Bible were not miracles at all.
A hidden God?
Here is a line of reasoning that Christians will frequently use to try to rationalize Jesus' behavior. In the book "The Case
for Faith," the author Lee Stroble interviews Peter Kreeft, Ph.D. Dr. Kreeft says the following:
"Scripture describes God as a hidden God. You have to make the effort of faith to find him. There are clues you
can follow. And if that weren't so, if there was something more or less than clues, it's difficult for me to understand
how we could really be free to make a choice about him."
Clues? Hidden? According to the Bible God incarnated himself. He created an entire human body named Jesus. That is
not a "clue" -- that is a huge, obvious piece of evidence. It is very hard to "hide" a 170-pound human being who is running
around performing miracles on every street corner. Then you collect the stories of those miracles and publish them in a
book. Where is the hiding in that?
There are examples of God's desire for publicity throughout the Bible. The best known is God's parting of the Red Sea in
the book of Exodus, chapter 14:
75
 1. Everyone has seen all sorts of "faith healers" who can "heal" the sick. And we all know that this sort of "healing" is
quackery. If it were true, then we would not need doctors, hospitals or prescription medicines. (see also Chapter
6)
2. Turning water into wine... Doesn't that sound like something that a B-grade David-Copperfield-wannabe magician
would do in a nightclub act? There are a dozen ways that you could stage things to make it look like water is
turning into wine. There is no reason why a normal person would accept a magic trick as proof that someone is
God.
It is as simple as that. If someone claimed to be God today, you would never believe it if the evidence consisted of faith
healing and magic tricks. Never. Yet billions of people claim that Jesus' faith healing and magic tricks prove that he is
God.
Real proof
Let's imagine that Jesus truly is God. What might he have done to prove it? He could have started by taking one of his
most famous quotes from the Bible and acting on it. In Matthew 17:20 Jesus says quite clearly:
For truly, I say to you, if you have faith as a grain of mustard seed, you will say to this mountain, 'Move from here
to there,' and it will move; and nothing will be impossible to you.
To prove that he is God, Jesus would have moved a mountain. Especially since it is so easy. And Jesus would have
written something down to explain himself. Here's what the first page of Jesus' book might have looked like:
My name is Jesus, and I am God. I know there are a lot of people out there who will doubt that I am God, so let
me start off by proving it to you. Take a look at Mount Sinai. Everyone knows that, until today, Mount Sinai stood
near here. It is the mountain where God, my father, gave Moses the Ten Commandments.
Mount Sinai vanished this morning, and what was left in its place was a perfectly smooth, polished stone base
measuring four miles square. Hundreds of years from now, people will find that Mount Sinai landed near a place
that will be called Newark, New Jersey. When scientists dig into the mountain, they will find that the bottom of the
mountain is also completely smooth and polished, and that the bottom of the mountain in New Jersey perfectly
matches the polished plain nearby. Scientists will be able to align the mountain and the plain, looking at it rock
crystal by rock crystal at a microscopic level. I have said many times that, if you have faith, you can move
mountains. I moved Mount Sinai to show how easy it is, and to prove that I am God.
I know that that may not be enough, so let me offer a second proof. If you draw a circle, you know that there is
distance across the circle. Let us call it the diameter of the circle. There is also a distance around the outside of
the circle. Let us call it the circumference. If you divide the circumference by the diameter, you get another
number. Let us call it Pi, and its first 6 digits are 3.14159. Pi is an irrational number. It is a number that is made up
of an infinite number of non-repeating digits.
There will come a day when machines called computers will calculate billions of digits of Pi. If you calculate Pi out
to the millionth trillionth digit, here is what you will find:
9823456451237823492278583495083498745....
Now, having proven that I am God to any rational being, through my documentable movement of a mountain and
through my foreknowledge of Pi at the millionth trillionth position, here is what I want to say to the human race as
your creator, and as the creator of the universe...
Wouldn't that be awesome and amazing? If we had such a book, and if Mount Sinai had actually moved, then there would
be no questions about Jesus. We would all believe that he is God. How could we not? Imagine what such a book would
say on the following pages. A book like that, I am sure, would leave all of us in awe. (see also chapter 17)
Unfortunately, Jesus did not provide concrete proof of his divinity. For any normal person, that makes things simple --
Jesus is not God. We would not believe that anyone today is God without concrete proof. Jesus doesn't get a pass
because he lived 2,000 years ago.
74
1. God watches them as they murder, rape, molest and terrorize other people millions of times a day, but he does
nothing to stop them.
2. God watches the victims as they are being murdered, raped, molested and terrorized, but he does nothing to help
them.
3. God completely ignores the prayers of the planet to eliminate murder, rape, child molestation and terrorism and
allows these atrocities to continue unabated.
According to the Standard Model of God, God is an omniscient, all-powerful, all-loving being who answers prayers.
Imagine God sitting on his magnificent throne in heaven looking down upon Earth, seeing every detail. God speaks:
"Look at all of those praying people getting tortured in that death camp. Excellent! I won't do anything to stop that.
And look at that little girl down there being raped and murdered. Perfect! She is praying like mad, and so is her
mother, but I won't do anything to stop that. And there are three terrorists preparing to blow up a church and kill
1,500 people who are saying the Lord's Prayer to me right now. Outstanding! I won't do anything to stop that. How
wonderful it is that 1,000 prayerful people will die of starvation today in Ethiopia. I love it! I won't do anything to
stop that. Oh… and there's little Suzy Jankins praying that I remove that pimple from her nose for her big date
with Chad tomorrow. Let me go help Suzy right now…"
Do you believe in a God who acts like this? Of course not. If you believe that God is
Key Point
specifically reaching down from heaven to answer your trivial prayer to remove a zit
or to help you find your lost keys, while at the same time God is allowing 27,000
children to die of starvation each day by specifically ignoring their prayers, then your If you believe that God is
God is insane. specifically reaching down from
heaven to answer your trivial
prayer to remove a zit or to help
Yet, if you believe in a God that answers your trivial prayers each day, this is exactly
you find your lost keys, while at the
the type of insane God that you are worshiping. And you look insane for believing it.
same time God is allowing 27,000
children to die of starvation each
The Power of Coincidence day by specifically ignoring their
prayers, then your God is insane.
What, then, is actually happening when God "answers" a prayer? Let's take a simple
example of a trivial prayer:
"I had finally gotten to the end of my rope with women, so I simply gave it up to God. I prayed, 'Lord, I need you to
send me a sign. When you have found the woman you want me to marry, I want you to show me by letting her
birthday be on the same day as my mother's. Amen.' And you know what? About a year later I met a woman, and
she was the most beautiful woman I had ever seen, and eventually I got up enough nerve to ask her out. On our
first date we had such a great time I asked her when her birthday was. It was the same day as my mother! I told
her about my prayer, and we got married six months later. We have been happily married for 15 years."
That seems like an amazing event. It is so amazing that it must be the hand of God, right? It seems like a one in a million
chance -- impossible without divine intervention. How could this man actually find a woman with the exact same birthday
as his mother???
It is nothing but a coincidence. And it is not a "one in a million" shot. The chance is 1 in 365 that any woman will have the
same birthday as his mother.
What really happened? If the woman had had the wrong birthday, the man would not have married her, and eventually he
would have found someone who was a match. Or, he would have simply forgotten about the prayer and married her
anyway. In that case, we would not have heard the story.
Coincidences -- even remarkable ones -- happen all the time. The "power of prayer" should actually be called the "power
of coincidence." The dictionary defines the word "coincidence" in this way:
A sequence of events that although accidental seems to have been planned or arranged. [ref]
"Answered prayers" are always coincidences, nothing more. The easy way to see that is to count unanswered prayers
along with answered prayers and analyze the statistics. As soon as you do the statistical analysis you unmask the illusion
of prayer.
43
You could pray for 20 trivial things today: Jesus2: Which part of Central Park?

1. Pray for your car to start in the morning. You: It really doesn't matter to me.
2. Pray for traffic to be light so you get to work on time.
3. Pray that you don't get fired for the mistake you made yesterday. Jesus2: Well, there is a slight problem.
4. Pray that the coffee stain on your purse comes out.
5. Pray that it doesn't rain. You: Really? What is the problem?
6. Pray that the price of a stock has gone up.
7. Pray that your computer doesn't crash.
8. Pray that your son got a decent grade on his math test. Jesus2: It is not my will to move the skyscraper.
9. Pray that there's enough money in your checking account.
10. Pray that the guy you went out with on Saturday calls you. You: Really? I thought you were God. Aren't you all-powerful?
11. Pray that your mother in law cancels her trip for the weekend.
12. Pray for there to be an available washing machine at the Laundromat when you get there. Jesus2: I am God, yes. I am the bread of life. I am the blessed and only potentate. However, it is not my will to
13. Pray that your car passes inspection. move that skyscraper.
14. Pray that they have your size in the shoes you are thinking about buying at the mall.
15. Pray that the envelope you are opening contains a check rather than a bill. You: Why not?
16. Pray that your cat didn't pee on the new sofa.
17. Pray for your baby not to wake you up tonight screaming so you can get some sleep.
Jesus2: It simply is not. I like Central Park the way it is.
18. Pray that you have the winning bid for that camera on EBay.
19. Pray that they have the video you want at the video store tonight.
20. Pray that your team wins the game on Sunday. You: OK. Move it somewhere else. Move it to a vacant lot in Jersey.

Some of your prayers would get "answered," some would not. The next day you could simply watch 20 trivial things Jesus2: It is not my will to do that.
happen without praying. Some would work out, some would not. There would be no difference. The act of praying about
them does not change the outcome. You: I see. Well, have a nice day!

Coincidences happen to all of us every day. If you are a believer, you handle those coincidences in the following way: And you would walk away.

x If something nice happens, you attribute that to God -- he answered your prayer and is "looking out" for you.
x If you pray for something and it does not happen, or if something bad happens, you rationalize that it is part of
"God's plan" (see chapter 8). It is "his will" that this bad event happens.
An unbiased observer looks at the same good and bad events and sees them for what they are -- random events. God
has nothing to do with them.
It is the same with any superstition. Walking under a ladder is not "bad luck". Neither is breaking a mirror. Neither is
seeing a black cat. Statistics prove that a broken mirror has zero effect on your life. In the same way, statistics prove that
God never answers prayers.
If you are a believer, try this experiment. Go for a week without praying. You will find that things work and don't work in
exactly the same way that they do if you pray. Coincidences and problems still happen whether you pray or not, and in the
same numbers. Prayer has no effect on the outcome. Good coincidences will not stop happening if you stop praying. Bad
coincidences do not stop happening no matter how much you pray.
The dictionary defines the word "superstition" in this way:
An irrational belief that an object, action, or circumstance not logically related to a course of events influences its
outcome. [ref]
The belief in prayer is a superstition. When a prayer appears to be answered, it is a coincidence. You have seen dozens
of examples in chapters five through ten that demonstrate the coincidental nature of "answered prayers."
Prove it
Think about it. If someone were to come to you and say, "I am God!", wouldn't you want proof? Yes, you would. Of course
you would. And you would not want goofy proof. You would not accept something that looks like a faith healer's show at a
tent revival, and you would not accept something that looks like a magic trick. You want real, solid proof. You want any
person who claims to be God to do something that is clearly impossible, like picking up a skyscraper, levitating it through
the air and settling it into the middle of Central Park.
Something like that, quite obviously, would have to be the work of an all-powerful God. Levitating a skyscraper and
moving it from here to there is clearly something that no human being can do, so it would be convincing. There is no way
to fake it. And millions of other people would be able to verify that, yes, the skyscraper did move from its original location
to a new location. If the building were hooked into water, sewer, power and phone at its new resting place, that would be
perfect.
No normal person, and I mean no one, would accept anything less than rock solid proof from a person who claims to be
God.
Why should it be any different with Jesus? Jesus was a man who claims to be God. If he is God, then he ought to be able
to prove it in a real, inimitable way. If he cannot prove it then, quite clearly, he is not God.
A Christian would say, "But Jesus HAS proven it! Just look at all of the miracles he did in the Bible! He healed the sick! He
changed water into wine! That PROVES that Jesus is the Lord!"

Proving it to yourself Does that make sense to you? Imagine that someone, today, were to come up to you and say, "I am God, and I will prove
that I am God by healing the sick and turning water into wine!" What would you say? Be honest. You would not believe
What I would ask you to do at this point is simple. I would like you to think this whole thing through. You have seen lots of this person because:
evidence. What do you believe? Either:

44 73
You try to look at the ground and walk past him, but he actually steps right into your path and you stop short. He focuses
his eyes on you and says, " I am the light of the world: he who follows me shall not walk in darkness, but shall have the
light of life. I am the way, and the truth, and the life; no one comes to the Father, but by me. I am the prince of peace. I am
God. Believe in me and you shall have Eternal life...."
You are thinking that this person is a total nut case. You are fingering the cell phone in your pocket, making sure that you
will be able to dial 911 if you need to. Fortunately there are a number of other people walking by, so you feel fairly safe.
And there is something about the intensity of his gaze... Instead of running away, you say, "Wait a minute. Wait a minute.
Let me make sure I heard you right. You are God?"
Man: "Yes. I am God. I am the son of the highest. I am the lord of our righteousness. I am the horn of salvation.
I..."
You: "Whoa. Slow down. You are God?"
Man: "Yes. I am God."
You: "Can you show me an ID?"
Man: "No. I am God. I don't need an ID."
You: "Of course. OK. Can you tell me your name?
Man: "My name is Jesus2."
You: "Can you prove to me that you are God? That's a pretty stupendous claim."
Man: "Yes, certainly. Walk with me."
Jesus2 walks about half a block, and you come upon a homeless person in a wheel chair begging for change with a sign
and a rattling cup. Jesus2 approaches him and says, "Good sir. May we interrupt you for a moment?"
Homeless man: Yes.
Jesus2: Have we ever met before?
Homeless man: No, I've never seen you before in my life.
Jesus2: Now good sir, how long have you been confined to this wheel chair.
Homeless man: Going on 20 years I'd say. Seems like my whole life.
Jesus2: Arise and walk. You are healed!
At this point the homeless person leaps to his feet screaming, "It's a miracle! I am cured! I am able to walk!" and runs off
down the street joyously.
Now, what do you think about this? You need to make a decision here. Either this man is God and has just healed a
person who has not walked for 20 years. That's option #1. Or... this man is not God, and there is some other explanation
for what you just saw. For example, it might, possibly, be the case that Jesus2 is a homeless man too, and that these two
homeless men might -- just might -- be working together on some sort of scam. That is option #2.
Chances are that you suspect that option #2 is the more likely of the two scenarios at work here. So you might say to
Jesus2, "Wow. That was impressive. You just healed a guy who had been in a wheelchair for 20 years. But look -- I need
something a little more convincing. See that skyscraper across the street? Can you pick it up and move it to the middle of
Central Park?"
72
Assertion #1: You believe what Jesus says in the Bible about prayer. When Jesus says in the Bible that anyone
with faith can move a mountain, you believe him, even though no one has ever moved a mountain. When Jesus
says that nothing will be impossible for you, you believe him, even though God has never healed an amputee.
When Jesus says that he will do anything that you ask in his name, you believe him even though you can ask for
something right now and he will completely ignore you. You believe in prayers despite the evidence to the
contrary.
Or:
Assertion #2: You do not believe what Jesus says about prayer in the Bible. You simply look at the world around
you and you can see that it is not true. God does not answer prayers.
The first assertion is incompatible both with common sense and with everything that you experience every day. There are
thousands of examples. You see the world each day, and it is quite obvious that God does not answer prayers. It has
been said before, but let's repeat it here:
x God never answers the prayers of amputees. If he did, we would see amputated limbs spontaneously
regenerating every day.
x God never moves mountains -- if he did, we would see mountains moving around all the time.
x God never answers impossible prayers -- if he did, people would be flying through the air like superman on a
regular basis.
x God never answers prayers that turn people into puppets -- if he did, then you are a puppet.
x God never answers prayers that break the laws of nature -- if he did, scientific equations and computer models
would have to take God's random antics into account.
x God never answers prayers that break the laws of probability -- if he did, then every prayerful believer would be
rich and Las Vegas could not exist.
x When two people pray opposite one another, obviously someone's prayer will go unanswered. If a million people
pray for the same thing (e.g. - winning the lottery) but only one can have it, then by definition 999,999 people will
be left in the cold.
x God doesn't answer medical prayers -- otherwise the U.S. would not need to spend $2 trillion a year on health
care.
x God doesn't answer prayers to avert natural disasters -- if he did, hurricanes would never hit the U.S.
If God does not answer all of these different types of prayers, it is clear that he does not answer prayers at all. When
someone says, "God answered my prayers," what he or she means is that a coincidence happened.
You can prove it to yourself right now. Simply pray for something. Pray for anything. What Jesus promises in the Bible is
crystal clear and completely unambiguous:
x If you believe, you will receive whatever you ask for in prayer. [Matthew 21:21]
x If you ask anything in my name, I will do it. [John 14:14]
x Nothing will be impossible to you. [Matthew 17:20]
x All things are possible to him who believes. [Mark 9:23]
x For with God nothing will be impossible. [Luke 1:37]
Nothing could be simpler or clearer than this. Jesus is God, so there is no reason for him to lie to you. In fact, it is
impossible for him to lie to you because he is perfect. So go ahead and pray. Pray that God cures every case of cancer on
the planet tomorrow. Pray sincerely, knowing that when God answers this prayer it will help millions of people in
remarkable ways.
Will it happen? Of course not.
Watch in your mind
Now watch, in your own mind, what happens. You have prayed, but your prayer has not been answered. In your mind,
you will start coming up with a thousand excuses -- reasons why Jesus has refused to answer your prayer. It is not his
will. It is not part of his plan. This prayer is "too big". This prayer is "too obvious". The Lord works in mysterious ways. It
will be answered three years from now, not today. You are not sincere enough. God will eventually inspire scientists to
cure all forms of cancer, blah, blah, blah....
45
You are an expert at creating excuses like these. You have to be. The reason why you are an expert is because you have
been creating excuses like this for Jesus your entire life. Jesus has disappointed you so many times that you expect to be
disappointed. That is why creating this list of excuses is automatic for you.
There is a reason why God has never answered a prayer to restore an amputated limb. It is because God does not
answer prayers. Every "answered prayer" is a coincidence. It is easy to prove it using statistics.
Proving it on TV
It would also be possible to prove that God does not answer prayers with a reality TV show. Imagine this -- we conduct a
nationwide survey, and we find the 1,000 most devout believers in the land. We assemble them in a studio and ask them
to form the nation's most powerful prayer circle. We then ask them to pray on live TV. Here are some of the challenges we
would give them:
1. In Matthew 17:20 Jesus says, "For truly, I say to you, if you have faith as a grain of mustard seed, you will say to
this mountain, 'Move from here to there,' and it will move; and nothing will be impossible to you." We ask our
1,000 devout believers to pray that Mt. Everest move to Newark, NJ tomorrow. We watch and see what happens.
2. We bring in a double amputee and have him sit in his wheelchair on the stage. We ask our 1,000 devout believers
to pray for his legs to be restored as he is sitting there. We watch and see what happens.
3. We find someone suffering from terminal cancer. We bring her on stage on a gurney. She is weak, gaunt and
bald. She has just a week or two to live as her metastasized tumor consumes her body. We ask our 1,000 devout
believers to pray for a miracle that cures her. We watch and see what happens. Let's say that a miracle does
happen. She jumps off the gurney ten minutes later, completely cured. We bring in another patient. Ten minutes
later that patient is cured. We bring in another patient, and the cure works again. So we ask our 1,000 devout
believers to pray for the complete elimination of cancer worldwide tomorrow. We watch and see what happens.
4. It is hurricane season and a Category 5 hurricane named Johansen is barreling straight toward the United States.
We ask our team of 1,000 devout believers to pray that the hurricane be completely eliminated so it does no
damage. Let's say that the prayer works. Do you know what this means? It means that the United States will
never be threatened by a hurricane again. Every time a hurricane approaches, we can assemble our 1,000
devout believers and they will be able to eliminate the storm. This will save the United States billions of dollars,
and thousands of deaths, every year.
5. Etc.
You can see what would actually happen. Our team of 1,000 devout believers will not be able to move a mountain. They
will not be able to restore the limbs of an amputee. They will not be able to cure cancer worldwide, or even one cancer
patient on stage. They will not be able to divert all the hurricanes that hit the United States. They will not be able to
accomplish anything reliably through prayer on TV. We all know it.
Why is that? Why is it that all of Jesus' promises about the power of prayer are false? It is because God does not answer
prayers.
What does it all mean?
Please scroll back several pages and look at Assertion #2. The assertion is that God does not answer prayers. It should at
this point be very easy for you to accept Assertion #2. We have demonstrated it from a dozen different angles. It is
compatible with common sense and the things that you experience every day. It meshes perfectly with all of the evidence
that we see in our world. The "power of prayer" is really "the power of coincidence." That should be plainly apparent to
you.
In that case, you have discovered a profound truth. Here are several of the implications:
x It means that the world makes sense. If you have been looking at the world wondering why God "answers" some
payers while ignoring billions of others, you now have a sensible explanation for your observations.
x When someone says that God "answered my prayers" or that "God sent a miracle," what you are actually
witnessing is the power of coincidence.
x It means that there is no supreme being sitting in heaven doling out favors to some people but withholding them
from others based on his whims.
46
on earth today. What do we do with them? We ignore them. We do not take them seriously. We exclude them from
reasonable public discourse and debate.
If a presidential candidate were to stand up and say, "the alignment of the planets indicates that in foreign policy, we
should follow a path that…," or if he/she were to end a speech with "Jupiter bless America," we would not vote for this
candidate.
People who believe in the Bible are in the same boat. Why would we listen to anyone who believes in slavery, hates
women and supports a God who is a flagrant baby-killer? Do we want people like that holding public office, sitting on our
courts, running our corporations or teaching our children?
The Bible is clearly the work of primitive men, many of whom were insane. Anyone with common sense can see that.
Exodus 21:20-21 alone is enough to prove it. When people insist that the Bible is the word of God, we should ignore them
and exclude them from public discourse. It's a free country, and people have a right to their superstitions in the privacy of
their own homes. But no one is required to take them seriously in a public forum.
Simply look back through Chapters 13, 14, 15 and 16. The Bible is so wrong in so many places. What are we thinking
when we quote from this book? Why do intelligent people allow this book to be referenced in public discourse? It is
amazing when you consider how much evil this book harbors. See Chapter 28 for additional details.
Chapter 18 - Was Jesus the son of God?
The centerpiece of the Christian faith is Jesus. The life, death and resurrection of Jesus are celebrated by Christians all
around the world. Jesus' miracles prove to Christians that Jesus is the son of God. As discussed in chapter 14, Jesus'
death is the human sacrifice that finally appeased God.
Jesus claims in many places in the Bible, and in many different ways, that he is God. For example, in John chapter 4,
verse 25 we find this:
The woman said to him, "I know that Messiah is coming (he who is called Christ); when he comes, he will show us
all things." Jesus said to her, "I who speak to you am he."
In John Chapter 10, verse 24 we find this:
So the Jews gathered round him and said to him, "How long will you keep us in suspense? If you are the Christ,
tell us plainly." Jesus answered them, "I told you, and you do not believe. The works that I do in my Father's
name, they bear witness to me."
In John chapter 14, verse 8 we find this:
Philip said to him, "Lord, show us the Father, and we shall be satisfied." Jesus said to him, "Have I been with you
so long, and yet you do not know me, Philip? He who has seen me has seen the Father."
And so on. It is clear that Jesus claimed to be God.
According to Jesus, his miracles prove that he is God. For example, in Matthew chapter 11 we find this:
Now when John heard in prison about the deeds of the Christ, he sent word by his disciples and said to him, "Are
you he who is to come, or shall we look for another?" And Jesus answered them, "Go and tell John what you hear
and see: the blind receive their sight and the lame walk, lepers are cleansed and the deaf hear, and the dead are
raised up, and the poor have good news preached to them."
What we have here is a man who says that he is God, and who claims that his miracles prove that he is God. The
question that any normal person would ask is simple: Is this true? Is Jesus God, or was Jesus a normal human being?
Chapter 19 - Why didn't Jesus move a mountain?
Let's say you are walking down a New York City street one day, and you notice a man walking toward you from the other
direction. There are two reasons why you notice him. First, he is wearing a long white robe and leather sandals. Second,
he is obviously planning to talk to you. He has made direct eye contact and is motioning for you to stop so that he can say
something to you.
71
This is how we know, without a doubt, that God did not write the Bible. If an all-powerful, all-loving, all-knowing creator of
the universe actually wrote this book, it would not be filled with so much idiocy. Slavery, misogyny and child-massacre are
abominations and we all know it. The reason why the Bible contains this material is because primitive men wrote the
Bible, not God.
What it all means
If the Bible really were the error-free word of an all-powerful God, it would be profound, meaningful, timeless, fascinating,
and enlightening both at the spiritual level and at the technological level. It would tell us things that we did not already
know. It would stun us with the brilliance of the author. We would look at the words in the Bible in awe.
Instead it is clear that God had nothing to do with the Bible. Simply open the book up and read it. The Bible is the work of
primitive men who lived 2,000 or 3,000 years ago, without a hint of guidance from the "all-knowing creator of the
universe." The previous chapters clearly demonstrate that beyond the shadow of any doubt.
If you are a Christian, this leaves you with two choices:
x You can continue to proclaim that the Bible is the Word of God. You do that knowing that it is a lie. Quite clearly
an all-knowing, all-loving God cannot also advocate slavery. Nor can he be sexist.
x You can make a rational decision based on clear evidence: you can reject the Bible. You can accept that the Bible
is the work of primitive men and is therefore completely irrelevant to us today. You can reject the Bible's authority,
and you can reject all the people who claim that the Bible is a message from God.
Once you accept that the Bible is a book written by primitive men rather than God, it is a very powerful realization. It has
many implications:
x The Bible claims that Jesus is the Son of God. Now that you know that the Bible is the work of men rather than
God, you can see reality -- Jesus was a man like anyone else.
x Both Christianity and Judaism are invalid as religions, having lost the Bible as a theological foundation.
x The Bible can no longer be used under "God's authority" as a tool of oppression. For example, take the Bible's
position on women. In 1 Corinthians the Bible says: "As in all the congregations of the saints, women should
remain silent in the churches. They are not allowed to speak, but must be in submission, as the Law says. If they
want to inquire about something, they should ask their own husbands at home; for it is disgraceful for a woman to
speak in the church." That's about as oppressive as you can get. Or look at the way the Bible discusses
homosexuals. Leviticus 20:13 states: "If a man lies with a male as a woman, both of them have committed an
abomination; they shall be put to death, their blood is upon them." Conservative Christians are quite fond of these
passages, and use them whenever they wish to justify their prejudice against women and homosexuals. They do
so, in their minds, with God's blessing. Since it is quite obvious that the Bible is not the word of God, we can see
that people who quote these verses are simple bigots rather than God's messengers. The next time you hear
people try to marginalize or degrade anyone using the Bible, you are able to completely ignore them.
x The Bible's story of creation is irrelevant, so we can completely ignore "creationists" and the proponents of
"intelligent design". God did not create human beings as described in the Bible -- the entire creation story is a
mythological legend written by primitive men. The concept of "original sin" and the concept of mankind's divine
creation are invalid.
x You have no soul and there is no eternal life after death. See Chapter 27 for details.
x An amazing 59% of the American population believes that the Bible's book of Revelation will actually come true.
Now it is easy to see that the Book of Revelation is a work of pure fiction.
x And so on…
The Bible clearly is not the word of God. The slavery passages in Chapter 13 provide more than enough evidence to
prove that. When you think about it and truly let that fact sink in, the full implications are enormous. Once you eliminate
the Bible, it is amazing what you eliminate with it.
As intelligent people, what do we do with the Christians -- millions of them -- who insist that the Bible is the word of God?
Let me answer that question with another question: What do we do with people who believe in astrology? You know the
people I am talking about -- they believe in horoscopes, and they believe that the alignment of the planets affects our lives
70
x It means that when a person says a prayer, he is talking to himself. There is nothing wrong with that -- meditation
can be a powerful and beneficial activity. However, there is no God listening to and answering prayers.
x It means that praying for God's intercession in any catastrophe, like a hurricane or a terrorist attack, is pointless.
x It means that public prayers, for example at conventions and sporting events, are a waste of time. There is no one
at the other end of the line to hear the prayer.
x It means that humans need to solve the problems of the world. Instead of praying to God to solve, for example,
world hunger, you should use that time to work toward a solution to world hunger yourself. God is not going to do
a thing about world hunger.
x It means that people who believe in "the power of prayer" should not be taken seriously. When someone says to
you that God answered his or her prayers, it means that the person is superstitious. The person is just like
someone who believes in the power of horoscopes and astrology.
x It means that everything that Jesus says about prayer in the Bible is wrong. Therefore, the Bible is not the
"unerring word of the Lord." The Bible is a collection of stories written by primitive men thousands of years ago.
We will discuss this topic further in the next section.
As an intelligent species, it is time for us to recognize that there is not a "God" in "heaven" who is looking down onto earth
and answering prayers. We can see it, undeniably, using both common sense and statistics. In the same way that the
pyramids of the Egyptians were pointless, and the Roman temples were pointless, and the human sacrifices of the Aztecs
were pointless, praying to God is pointless.
If you don't believe me, you can prove it to yourself right now. Simply pray for something concrete. Then watch as your
prayer is ignored.
On a personal level
The fact that God answers no prayers has meaning to you on a very personal level. Let me give you an example of what it
means.
Let's say that you have a friend who is 35 years old, and she finds out that she has breast cancer. Obviously she is
devastated. The cancer is fairly advanced, and the prognosis does not look immediately promising.
If you are a believer, what is the first thing to do? The first order of business is prayer. Then the advanced believer would
create a prayer circle to channel the "Lord's healing power" to your friend.
As you now know, both the prayers and the prayer circle are pointless. God never answers prayers. If prayer circles
worked, then we would be able to regenerate the legs of amputees, and we know that we can't. If prayer circles worked,
we would not need doctors or hospitals. If prayer circles worked, we would pray that God completely eliminate breast
cancer, and no one on the planet would ever get this disease. The effort spent praying is a waste of time.
So what should you do instead of praying? Think about this question: What might actually help your friend? Do not waste
the time praying -- spend your time wisely doing something that will actually help your friend. For example:
x Make her family a nice dinner and deliver it to her home.
x Offer to take care of her kids for several days while she recovers from her last round of chemo.
x Make get-well cards to cheer her up.
x Organize a bake sale or telethon to raise money for breast cancer research.
x Go sit by her bedside in the hospital each day and read to her.
x Bring happy movies for her to watch in the hospital.
x Etc.
God does not answer prayers -- the evidence is all around you. Now that you know that for certain, make the most of this
knowledge.
47
Chapter 12 - Who wrote the Bible?
The Bible is the sacred text of the Christian faith. It is also one of the best known books on the planet today. All around the
globe there are billions of copies of the Bible in every human language. Chances are very good that you have at least one
copy of the Bible in your home right now. Nearly everybody does.
To Christians, the Bible is the error-free word of God. The Bible is not the work of men -- it is God's word to his creation.
To reinforce this fact, there are over 4,000 places in the Bible where it says things like, "Thus says the Lord." [ref] The
Bible itself refers to its author in a number of places. For example, in 2 Timothy 3:16 the Bible says:
All scripture is God-breathed and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in
righteousness.
In 1 Thessalonians 2:13 the Bible says:
And we also thank God constantly for this, that when you received the word of God which you heard from us, you
accepted it not as the word of men but as what it really is, the word of God.
In 2 Peter 1:20-21 the Bible says:
Above all, you must understand that no prophecy of Scripture came about by the prophet's own interpretation. For
prophecy never had its origin in the will of man, but men spoke from God as they were carried along by the Holy
Spirit.
In Psalm 19:7 the Bible says:
The law of the Lord is perfect, reviving the soul.
The Bible is the law of the Lord, and it is perfect. So says the Lord.
This quote from the Christian Courier sums up the position of many Christians on the origin of the Bible:
God, although using human writers in the composition of the Bible, is nevertheless its ultimate Author. And since
the perfect God cannot be the source of confusion (1 Corinthians 14:33) or contradiction (Hebrews 6:18), it must
be acknowledged that the Bible is perfectly harmonious. [ref]
The fact that the Bible is written by God gives the Bible ultimate authority -- God's
Key Point
authority. Because it is the perfect, error-free word of God, the Bible is essential to
Christianity. The Bible acts as the single God-given source of information for
Christians. The Bible states that it is not the
word of men but the word of God,
and that the Bible is perfect.
If God exists and the Bible is the word of the Lord, then everything that Christians
believe is true. Jesus is God, God does answer prayers, God did create Adam and
humans have both souls and eternal life.
But what if the Bible was not written by God? What if the Bible is simply a book of legends and stories written by fallible
human authors? What if God had nothing to do with this book? In that case, then Christianity collapses.
In other words, there is a lot riding on the Bible.
Is it possible to know who wrote the Bible? Answering this question is the purpose of this section.
Chapter 13 - Why does God love slavery?
Frederick Douglass started life as a slave. He was born to a slave mother in 1818, at a time when slavery was practiced
almost universally throughout the United States. At the age of 20 he was able to escape from slavery, educate himself
and transcend his humble origins. This transformation gave Frederick Douglass a unique perspective on slavery.
Frederick Douglass wrote an autobiography in which he described many of his experiences as a slave in graphic detail.
He was a person who experienced the atrocities firsthand.
For example, he describes the violence of his master in this way:
48
"There are 47 different types of abnormal discharges that I have inflicted on the human body when I created it.
They are, in order of frequency of occurrence: 1) Discharge from an infected skin lesion, normally caused by
some sort of cut or puncture wound. What is happening here is a bacterial infection. First off, whenever you get a
cut or puncture wound, you should wash it carefully with an antiseptic solution to kill the bacteria, and then cover
the wound with a sterile dressing to keep bacteria out. Also, make sure that your tetanus vaccination is up to date.
These steps will prevent 98.7% of all infections. But if the wound does become infected, what you should do is
incise and drain the wound. This will be painful, but it is important because if you allow the pus to build up..."
God should know all of this stuff -- according to Christians he is all-knowing. When reading Leviticus 15, any normal
human being asks questions like these:
x Why didn't God transcribe a useful medical guide into the Bible for these primitive people, rather than transcribing
rituals that accomplish nothing?
x Why doesn't God explain how to manufacture antiseptic solutions, sterile dressings, tetanus vaccines and
antibiotic creams?
x Even better, why not explain how to build a Star Trek Tricorder to instantly heal the wound?
x Even better, why didn't God design the human immune system to prevent all infections in the first place and
eliminate the discharges completely? Why would God intentionally inflict human beings with all of these different
types of abnormal discharges?
Extending on these ideas, why doesn't God use the Bible to explain metallurgy, chemistry, biology, physics,
manufacturing, mathematics, medicine, engineering, etc. to these primitive people so they can dramatically accelerate
their development?
Why, in other words, is the Bible so useless? Why does the author of the Bible, who is supposed to be God, who is
supposed to be all-knowing, know so little? Why is the knowledge of the author limited to the knowledge of the primitive
men who wrote the book? If you think about what you are reading in the Bible in the context of an all-knowing God who
supposedly wrote it, none of it makes any sense. But if you think about the Bible as being a book written by primitive men
like you would find in the remote regions of Afghanistan today, it makes complete
sense.
Key Point
After reading the Bible passages in this section, what is your common sense telling
you about the Bible? Do these passages from the Bible match up with your view of
what an all-knowing, all-loving, all-powerful being would write down in his book? If you think about what you are
Does it make sense to you that a book created by an all-knowing God would contain reading in the Bible in the context
so much nonsense? Are you left agape as you read the Bible, or are you of an all-knowing God who
dumbfounded by its utter stupidity? supposedly wrote it, none of it
makes any sense. But if you think
about the Bible as being a book
Weigh the evidence. Does it seem more likely that the Bible was written by God, or
written by primitive men like you
by a bunch of primitive men?
would find in the remote regions of
Afghanistan today, it makes
Proving it to yourself complete sense. This tells you
everything you need to know. The
It is easy to prove to yourself that God did not write the Bible. We can do it in the Bible was written by primitive men,
following way. not by God.
I challenge you to go on national TV with me. We are going to go on a major, nationally broadcast show with a major host
like Oprah, Larry King, Bill O'Reilly, etc.
Here's all that you have to do. You are going to read for 30 minutes from the New International Version or the New
American Standard Version (your choice) of the Bible. This should be a dream come true for you -- here you will have the
chance to spread the power of God's word directly to the nation.
There is only one thing that I ask. I want you to let me choose the verses that you will read.
Would you take the challenge? Of course not. If I pick the passages, I can make you look like a total idiot on national
television. I can have you read verses about slavery, misogyny, animal sacrifice, child massacre, sliced up concubines,
tent pegs and all the rest. No one in their right mind would take this challenge.
69
1 Kings 8:
Then Solomon assembled the elders of Israel and all the heads of the tribes, the leaders of the fathers' houses of
the people of Israel, before King Solomon in Jerusalem, to bring up the ark of the covenant of the LORD out of the
city of David, which is Zion. And all the men of Israel assembled to King Solomon at the feast in the month
Eth'anim, which is the seventh month. And all the elders of Israel came, and the priests took up the ark. And they
brought up the ark of the LORD, the tent of meeting, and all the holy vessels that were in the tent; the priests and
the Levites brought them up. And King Solomon and all the congregation of Israel, who had assembled before
him, were with him before the ark, sacrificing so many sheep and oxen that they could not be counted or
numbered.
Yes, so? How is this at all relevant? Why would God write this?
Psalms 89:
A Maskil of Ethan the Ezrahite. I will sing of thy steadfast love, O LORD, for ever; with my mouth I will proclaim
thy faithfulness to all generations. For thy steadfast love was established for ever, thy faithfulness is firm as the
heavens. Thou hast said, "I have made a covenant with my chosen one, I have sworn to David my servant: 'I will
establish your descendants for ever, and build your throne for all generations.'" [Selah] Let the heavens praise thy
wonders, O LORD, thy faithfulness in the assembly of the holy ones! For who in the skies can be compared to the
LORD? Who among the heavenly beings is like the LORD, a God feared in the council of the holy ones, great and
terrible above all that are round about him? O LORD God of hosts, who is mighty as thou art, O LORD, with thy
faithfulness round about thee? Thou dost rule the raging of the sea; when its waves rise, thou stillest them. Thou
didst crush Rahab like a carcass, thou didst scatter thy enemies with thy mighty arm.
Again, how is this relevant?
Acts 10:
The next day, as they were on their journey and coming near the city, Peter went up on the housetop to pray,
about the sixth hour. And he became hungry and desired something to eat; but while they were preparing it, he
fell into a trance and saw the heaven opened, and something descending, like a great sheet, let down by four
corners upon the earth. In it were all kinds of animals and reptiles and birds of the air. And there came a voice to
him, "Rise, Peter; kill and eat." But Peter said, "No, Lord; for I have never eaten anything that is common or
unclean." And the voice came to him again a second time, "What God has cleansed, you must not call common."
This happened three times, and the thing was taken up at once to heaven. Now while Peter was inwardly
perplexed as to what the vision which he had seen might mean, behold, the men that were sent by Cornelius,
having made inquiry for Simon's house, stood before the gate and called out to ask whether Simon who was
called Peter was lodging there.
Revelations 12:
And a great portent appeared in heaven, a woman clothed with the sun, with the moon under her feet, and on her
head a crown of twelve stars; she was with child and she cried out in her pangs of birth, in anguish for delivery.
And another portent appeared in heaven; behold, a great red dragon, with seven heads and ten horns, and seven
diadems upon his heads. His tail swept down a third of the stars of heaven, and cast them to the earth. And the
dragon stood before the woman who was about to bear a child, that he might devour her child when she brought it
forth; she brought forth a male child, one who is to rule all the nations with a rod of iron, but her child was caught
up to God and to his throne, and the woman fled into the wilderness, where she has a place prepared by God, in
which to be nourished for one thousand two hundred and sixty days.
Are you amazed by these passages? Are you inspired by their brilliance and insight? Do they leave you with a sense of
wonderment? Do they have any bearing at all on you, or your life? After reading them, do you find the Bible to be a book
that you would want to continue reading? Most importantly: Do these passages leave you with the impression that they
were written by an all-powerful, all-knowing God? Or was this book written by primitive men? Try the experiment yourself
and see what you find. Think about what you are reading in the context of an all-knowing God.
Be honest with yourself. Does the Bible strike you as a book filled with brilliance, or with nonsense?
Think about what you are reading
What do I mean when I say, "think about what you are reading?" Let's use Leviticus 15, from the previous section, as an
example. The passage is discussing "discharge." Why doesn't God in Leviticus 15 say:
68
He was a cruel man, hardened by a long life of slaveholding. He would at times seem to take great pleasure in
whipping a slave. I have often been awakened at the dawn of day by the most heart-rending shrieks of an own
aunt of mine, whom he used to tie up to a joist, and whip upon her naked back till she was literally covered with
blood. No words, no tears, no prayers, from his gory victim, seemed to move his iron heart from its bloody
purpose. The louder she screamed, the harder he whipped; and where the blood ran fastest, there he whipped
longest. He would whip her to make her scream, and whip her to make her hush; and not until overcome by
fatigue, would he cease to swing the blood-clotted cowskin. I remember the first time I ever witnessed this horrible
exhibition. I was quite a child, but I well remember it. I never shall forget it whilst I remember any thing. It was the
first of a long series of such outrages, of which I was doomed to be a witness and a participant. It struck me with
awful force. It was the blood-stained gate, the entrance to the hell of slavery, through which I was about to pass.
He spoke of the slave trade in this way:
We were all ranked together at the valuation. Men and women, old and young, married and single, were ranked
with horses, sheep, and swine. There were horses and men, cattle and women, pigs and children, all holding the
same rank in the scale of being, and were all subjected to the same narrow examination. Silvery-headed age and
sprightly youth, maids and matrons, had to undergo the same indelicate inspection. At this moment, I saw more
clearly than ever the brutalizing effects of slavery upon both slave and slaveholder.
[Source: "Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglas" by Frederick Douglas.]
Imagine these injustices magnified across the lives of thousands upon thousands of slaves in the United States and you
can begin to understand the horrific magnitude of slavery in America. Slavery is a scourge. It is an atrocity.
All of us know that slavery is abhorrent. Slavery involves the loss of free will and the subjugation of one person to another.
Slavery is a form of imprisonment. Slavery turns human beings into a type of livestock that can be bought and sold as the
property of another person. As described by Frederick Douglass above, slavery is often accompanied by remarkable
brutality. No human being would want to be enslaved. This is what makes the concept of slavery so repugnant.
Now that you have a clear image of slavery in your head, here is an important question: How would you imagine that God
feels about slavery?
As the all-loving creator of the universe and of each human soul, you would expect God to be violently opposed to the
enslavement of human beings. Our all-knowing God would certainly despise slavery in the same way that any normal
person does. What other position could a perfect God take?
It is surprising, therefore, to discover that the Bible tells a different story. If we read the Bible, we find instead a God who
embraces slavery wholeheartedly. The Bible is so supportive of slavery, in fact, that it was frequently used as a
justification for American slavery prior to the Civil War.
What the Bible says about slavery
Here are ten passages from the Bible that clearly demonstrate God's position on slavery:
Genesis chapter 17, verse 12:
And he that is eight days old shall be circumcised among you, every man child in your generations, he that is born
in the house, or bought with money of any stranger, which is not of thy seed. He that is born in thy house, and he
that is bought with thy money, must needs be circumcised.
In this passage God understands that people buy other people and, quite obviously, is comfortable with the concept. God
wants slaves circumcised in the same way as non-slaves.
Exodus chapter 12 verse 43:
The Lord said to Moses and Aaron, "These are the regulations for the Passover: No foreigner is to eat of it. Any
slave you have bought may eat of it after you have circumcised him, but a temporary resident and a hired worker
may not eat of it.
God again shows that he is completely comfortable with the concept of slavery and singles out slaves for special
treatment.
49
Exodus Chapter 21, verse 1:
Now these are the ordinances which you shall set before them. When you buy a Hebrew slave, he shall serve six
years, and in the seventh he shall go out free, for nothing. If he comes in single, he shall go out single; if he
comes in married, then his wife shall go out with him. If his master gives him a wife and she bears him sons or
daughters, the wife and her children shall be her master's and he shall go out alone. But if the slave plainly says,
'I love my master, my wife, and my children; I will not go out free,' then his master shall bring him to God, and he
shall bring him to the door or the doorpost; and his master shall bore his ear through with an awl; and he shall
serve him for life.
Here God describes how to become a slave for life, and shows that it is completely acceptable to separate slaves from
their families. God also shows that he completely endorses the branding of slaves through mutilation.
Exodus Chapter 21, verse 20:
If a man beats his male or female slave with a rod and the slave dies as a direct result, he must be punished, but
he is not to be punished if the slave gets up after a day or two, since the slave is his property.
Not only does God condone slavery, but he is also completely comfortable with the concept of beating your slaves, as
long as you don't kill them.
Exodus Chapter 21, verse 32:
If the bull gores a male or female slave, the owner must pay thirty shekels of silver to the master of the slave, and
the bull must be stoned.
Not only does God condone slavery, but here God places a value on slaves -- 30 shekels of silver. Note that God is not
sophisticated enough to understand the concept of inflation. It is now 3,000 years later, and a gored slave is still worth 30
shekels of silver according to God's word.
Leviticus Chapter 22, verse 10:
No one outside a priest's family may eat the sacred offering, nor may the guest of a priest or his hired worker eat
it. But if a priest buys a slave with money, or if a slave is born in his household, that slave may eat his food.
Here God shows that the children of slaves are slaves themselves, and that he is completely happy with that concept.
Leviticus Chapter 25, verse 44:
Your male and female slaves are to come from the nations around you; from them you may buy slaves. You may
also buy some of the temporary residents living among you and members of their clans born in your country, and
they will become your property. You can will them to your children as inherited property and can make them
slaves for life, but you must not rule over your fellow Israelites ruthlessly.
Here God states where you may purchase your slaves, and clearly specifies that slaves are property to be bought, sold
and handed down.
Luke, Chapter 7, verse 2:
Now a centurion had a slave who was dear to him, who was sick and at the point of death. When he heard of
Jesus, he sent to him elders of the Jews, asking him to come and heal his slave. And when they came to Jesus,
they besought him earnestly, saying, "He is worthy to have you do this for him, for he loves our nation, and he
built us our synagogue." And Jesus went with them. When he was not far from the house, the centurion sent
friends to him, saying to him, "Lord, do not trouble yourself, for I am not worthy to have you come under my roof;
therefore I did not presume to come to you. But say the word, and let my servant be healed. For I am a man set
under authority, with soldiers under me: and I say to one, 'Go,' and he goes; and to another, 'Come,' and he
comes; and to my slave, 'Do this,' and he does it." When Jesus heard this he marveled at him, and turned and
said to the multitude that followed him, "I tell you, not even in Israel have I found such faith." And when those who
had been sent returned to the house, they found the slave well.
Here Jesus shows that he is completely comfortable with the concept of slavery. Jesus heals the slave without any
thought of freeing the slave or admonishing the slave's owner.
50
of Aaron the priest who has a blemish shall come near to offer the LORD's offerings by fire; since he has a
blemish, he shall not come near to offer the bread of his God. He may eat the bread of his God, both of the most
holy and of the holy things, but he shall not come near the veil or approach the altar, because he has a blemish,
that he may not profane my sanctuaries; for I am the LORD who sanctify them.
Doesn't it seem odd for an all-loving God to discriminate against people with handicaps and genetic problems?
Here is another example. In the book of Deuteronomy, Chapter 21:18, the Bible says:
If a man has a stubborn and rebellious son who does not obey his father and mother and will not listen to them
when they discipline him, his father and mother shall take hold of him and bring him to the elders at the gate of his
town. They shall say to the elders, "This son of ours is stubborn and rebellious. He will not obey us. He is a
profligate and a drunkard." Then all the men of his town shall stone him to death. You must purge the evil from
among you. All Israel will hear of it and be afraid.
Doesn't that seem to contradict the sixth commandment, "Thou shalt not kill"? And doesn't it seem just a tad harsh? If we
applied this sort of philosophy today (as Christians should, since they proclaim the Bible and the Ten Commandments to
be God's infallible word), millions of our teenagers would need to be stoned to death.
Here is another example. On the day Moses comes down from Mount Sinai with the stone tablets containing the Ten
Commandments, he discovers that the Israelites have created a golden calf. To punish the people, Moses gathers a
group of men and takes the following action in the book of Exodus, Chapter 32:
"Then he [Moses] said to them, "This is what the Lord, the God of Israel, says: 'Each man strap a sword to his
side. Go back and forth through the camp from one end to the other, each killing his brother and friend and
neighbor.' " The Levites did as Moses commanded, and that day about three thousand of the people died.
So... one minute we have God carving into stone, "Thou shalt not kill." Then the next minute we have God telling each
man to strap a sword to his side and lay waste to thousands. Wouldn't you expect the almighty ruler of the universe to be
slightly more consistent than this? 3,000 dead people is a lot of commandment breaking.
Some Christians try to find an out for all of this irrelevance and contradiction by saying, "Well, I don't believe the Old
Testament. God sent Jesus to cancel it out." But that really is not the case. If God wrote the Bible, then God fully intended
for the Bible -- the entire Bible -- to be a timeless book. In Isaiah 40:8 God says, "The grass withers, the flower fades; but
the word of our God will stand for ever." In Matthew 5:18 Jesus says, "For truly, I say to you, till heaven and earth pass
away, not an iota, not a dot, will pass from the law until all is accomplished." When Jesus says "the law" what he is talking
about is all of the laws that God lays down in the Old Testament. Those laws include everything that God says about
slavery, misogyny, animal sacrifice, stoning teenagers, cutting off hands and all the rest.
An experiment
Here is an experiment for you to try. Pick up any handy Bible. Open the book to a random page. Read it. You tell me -- is
this a book that amazes you? I am trying this experiment this morning as I write this book. Here are the five random
quotes that I came upon:
Leviticus 15:
The LORD said to Moses and Aaron, "Say to the people of Israel, When any man has a discharge from his body,
his discharge is unclean. And this is the law of his uncleanness for a discharge: whether his body runs with his
discharge, or his body is stopped from discharge, it is uncleanness in him. Every bed on which he who has the
discharge lies shall be unclean; and everything on which he sits shall be unclean. And any one who touches his
bed shall wash his clothes, and bathe himself in water, and be unclean until the evening. And whoever sits on
anything on which he who has the discharge has sat shall wash his clothes, and bathe himself in water, and be
unclean until the evening. And whoever touches the body of him who has the discharge shall wash his clothes,
and bathe himself in water, and be unclean until the evening. And if he who has the discharge spits on one who is
clean, then he shall wash his clothes, and bathe himself in water, and be unclean until the evening. And any
saddle on which he who has the discharge rides shall be unclean. And whoever touches anything that was under
him shall be unclean until the evening; and he who carries such a thing shall wash his clothes, and bathe himself
in water, and be unclean until the evening.
Can you imagine every doctor and nurse following God's law?
67
 Then Judah said to Onan, "Lie with your brother's wife and fulfill your duty to her as a brother-in-law to produce
offspring for your brother." But Onan knew that the offspring would not be his; so whenever he lay with his
brother's wife, he spilled his semen on the ground to keep from producing offspring for his brother. What he did
was wicked in the Lord 's sight; so he put him to death also.
Judges Chapter 3
Ehud then approached him [the fat king] while he was sitting alone in the upper room of his summer palace and
said, "I have a message from God for you." As the king rose from his seat, Ehud reached with his left hand, drew
the sword from his right thigh and plunged it into the king's belly. Even the handle sank in after the blade, which
came out his back. Ehud did not pull the sword out, and the fat closed in over it. Then Ehud went out to the porch;
he shut the doors of the upper room behind him and locked them.
Judges Chapter 19
But the men would not listen to him. So the man took his concubine and sent her outside to them, and they raped
her and abused her throughout the night, and at dawn they let her go. At daybreak the woman went back to the
house where her master was staying, fell down at the door and lay there until daylight.
When her master got up in the morning and opened the door of the house and stepped out to continue on his
way, there lay his concubine, fallen in the doorway of the house, with her hands on the threshold. He said to her,
"Get up; let's go." But there was no answer. Then the man put her on his donkey and set out for home.
When he reached home, he took a knife and cut up his concubine, limb by limb, into twelve parts and sent them
into all the areas of Israel. Everyone who saw it said, "Such a thing has never been seen or done, not since the
day the Israelites came up out of Egypt. Think about it! Consider it! Tell us what to do!"
Joshua Chapter 10
When they had brought these kings to Joshua, he summoned all the men of Israel and said to the army
commanders who had come with him, "Come here and put your feet on the necks of these kings." So they came
forward and placed their feet on their necks.
Joshua said to them, "Do not be afraid; do not be discouraged. Be strong and courageous. This is what the Lord
will do to all the enemies you are going to fight." Then Joshua struck and killed the kings and hung them on five
trees, and they were left hanging on the trees until evening.
1 Samuel Chapter 31
Saul said to his armor-bearer, "Draw your sword and run me through, or these uncircumcised fellows will come
and run me through and abuse me." But his armor-bearer was terrified and would not do it; so Saul took his own
sword and fell on it. When the armor-bearer saw that Saul was dead, he too fell on his sword and died with him.
Numbers Chapter 31
Moses was angry with the officers of the army-the commanders of thousands and commanders of hundreds-who
returned from the battle. "Have you allowed all the women to live?" he asked them. "They were the ones who
followed Balaam's advice and were the means of turning the Israelites away from the Lord in what happened at
Peor, so that a plague struck the Lord 's people. Now kill all the boys. And kill every woman who has slept with a
man, but save for yourselves every girl who has never slept with a man."
Deuteronomy Chapter 25
If two men are fighting and the wife of one of them comes to rescue her husband from his assailant, and she
reaches out and seizes him by his private parts, you shall cut off her hand. Show her no pity.
There are two things to notice in these quotes. First, they are all disgusting. Second, they all tell stories about men and
women doing things that are utterly and completely irrelevant. Why do you care about a woman killing a man with a tent
peg, or a man cutting up his concubine and mailing her body parts around? Do you care about Moses telling his soldiers,
"kill everyone, but save the virgins for yourselves"? If God is going to take the time to write a book that will last for
millennia, why fill it with such useless material?
Another problem with the Bible is that it frequently contradicts the Standard Model of God. Here is an example from
Leviticus 21:17:
Say to Aaron, None of your descendants throughout their generations who has a blemish may approach to offer
the bread of his God. For no one who has a blemish shall draw near, a man blind or lame, or one who has a
mutilated face or a limb too long, or a man who has an injured foot or an injured hand, or a hunchback, or a dwarf,
or a man with a defect in his sight or an itching disease or scabs or crushed testicles; no man of the descendants
66
Colossians, chapter 3, verse 22:
Slaves, obey in everything those who are your earthly masters, not with eyeservice, as men-pleasers, but in
singleness of heart, fearing the Lord. Whatever your task, work heartily...
Here God shows that he is in complete acceptance of a slave's position, and
Did God mean it?
encourages slaves to work hard. This sentiment is repeated in Titus, chapter 2 verse
9:
Many Christians will try to argue
that God does not intend for us to
Bid slaves to be submissive to their masters and to give satisfaction in every
keep slaves today. That simply is
respect; they are not to be refractory, nor to pilfer, but to show entire and
not true. As you can see, both
true fidelity.
Jesus and the New Testament are
Once again God shows that he is quite enamored of slavery.
strong advocates of slavery. In
Isaiah 40:8 God says, "The grass
God loves slavery withers, the flower fades; but the
word of our God will stand for
If the Bible is written by God, and these are the words of the Lord, then you can ever." In the twenty first century,
come to only one possible conclusion: God is an impressive advocate of slavery and God and the Bible fully intend for
is fully supportive of the concept. us to have slaves.
If you are a Christian, I realize that what I am about to suggest is uncomfortable. However, it is crucial to the conversation
that we are having in this book. What I wish to suggest to you is that these pro-slavery passages in the Bible provide all
the evidence that we need to prove that God did not write the Bible. Simply put: there is no way that an all-loving God
would also be a staunch supporter of slavery.
What does your common sense tell you about God? Doesn't it seem that an all-loving, just God would think of slavery as
an abomination just like any normal human being does? If any sort of all-knowing, all-loving God had written the Bible,
shouldn't the Bible say, "Slavery is wrong -- you may have no slaves"? Shouldn't one of the Commandments say, "thou
shalt not enslave"?
As you can see, these slavery passages present us with a paradox:
x On the one hand, we all know that slavery is an outrage and a moral abomination. As a result, slavery is now
completely illegal throughout the developed world.
x On the other hand, the creator of the universe states in writing that slavery is perfectly acceptable. Beating your
slaves is fine. Enslaving children is fine. Separating slave families is fine. According to the Bible, we should all be
practicing slavery today.
The intensity of this paradox is remarkable.
The importance of the Bible
Most people in the United States are Christians, and therefore in the United States we take the Bible completely for
granted. It is like gravity or the morning sunrise -- the Bible is there all the time, so you don't even think about it.
Because we take it for granted, we tend to forget just how important the Bible is to our lives. Let me give you three
examples of just how significant this book is.
First of all, think about Jesus. Everyone in the United States has heard of Jesus. We all know that Jesus was born on
Christmas. We know that Jesus died on the Cross and was resurrected three days later. We know that God loved the
world so much that he gave his only begotten son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life (John
3:16). And so on. How do we know all of that? Because of the Bible. If the Bible did not exist, no one would have ever
heard of Jesus. Without the Bible there would be no Christianity.
Second, there are the Ten Commandments. According to Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, "Ninety-nine percent of
Americans believe in the ten commandments." [ref] Scalia has also pointed out that the Ten Commandments are "a
symbol of the fact that government derives its authority from God." [ref] Where do the Ten Commandments come from?
The Bible. And because they come from the Bible, we assume they come from God. The Bible is God's word.
51
Third, think about your soul. Chances are that you believe that you have a soul. In What should the non-Christians make of this?
Key Point
addition you probably believe that, when you die, your soul lives on forever. You
also believe that your soul goes either to heaven or hell. Where did those ideas If you are a Christian, and if you insist that God wrote or "inspired" the Bible, then there is a second question that you may
come from? They come from the Bible. The Bible is the place in our culture that tells According to Supreme Court
want to consider:
us about heaven and hell. Without the Bible, these concepts would not exist. The Justice Antonin Scalia, "Ninety-nine
whole notion of "everlasting life" is based on the Bible. percent of Americans believe in the
ten commandments." [ref] Scalia Why do you worship this God? And why do you publicly and openly admit it?
has also pointed out that the Ten Think about the non-Christians who live next door to you. They can read the Bible. Wouldn't it seem logical for people
It really is quite amazing when you think about it. We take Jesus, the Ten outside Christianity -- for example, the Muslims, the Hindus, the Buddhists and so on -- to look at you as a monster for
Commandments are "a symbol of
Commandments, heaven and hell completely for granted. Nearly every person in worshipping such a being? By worshipping this God, giving him your money, etc., you show that you yourself must believe
the fact that government derives its
America has heard of them, and few would question their existence. The place in slavery, misogyny, animal/human sacrifice and baby-killing. Do you not? All of these passages are right there in the
authority from God." [ref]
where these core concepts originate is the Bible. Without the Bible, these concepts Bible. Anyone can read them. By stating that you believe the Bible, are you not endorsing these passages? By
would not exist. The Bible has a gigantic impact on the lives of people around the worshipping this God, do you not show that you endorse his actions in the Bible? Why in the world would non-Christians
world. The only reason it has this impact is because Christians believe that God is the author. want you openly spreading your messages from a slavery-condoning, woman-hating, sacrifice-loving, child-killing God?

Let's say that the Bible were not the word of God. Imagine that it was written by a group of random men 2,000 or 3,000
years ago and God had nothing to do with it. Would you believe in heaven and hell? Would you believe in the Ten
Commandments? Would you believe in Jesus? No. Of course not. If primitive men wrote the Bible rather than God, no
one would care about the Bible. Homer was a primitive man, and 3,000 or so years ago he wrote a book called "The
Odyssey." In this book Homer talks about a Cyclops, a goddess named Athena and a place called Hades, along with
many other things. Do we believe any of it? Of course not -- it was a fanciful story written by a man. We ignore the
Odyssey in our daily lives because the author was human.
The Bible and Slavery
So now we have opened the Bible and looked at it, and inside the Bible -- God's word -- we have found ten extremely
clear and outrageous passages about slavery. What these passages indicate, without any question, is that the Bible
supports slavery. The Bible thinks that slavery is great. According to the Bible you are free to buy slaves and you are free
to beat your slaves. There is no denying that, in the Bible, slavery is perfectly acceptable.
A Christian would respond to this question with something like the following: "God is NOT a murderer! God does NOT kill
babies! God does NOT hate women! God would NEVER do any of the things that you are talking about. God is LOVE. It
says so in the Bible!" Such a person is ignoring the obvious. The slavery-condoning, woman-hating, sacrifice-loving, baby-
killing verses are all there in the Bible plain as day. They would not be there unless God wanted them there. God is
omnipotent. If God took the time to write the Bible, he would also take the time to protect its contents from corruption. If
God wrote the Bible, then every word in it was placed there -- intentionally and purposefully -- by God himself.
It is not as though God has one slip of the tongue that might be misinterpreted as condoning slavery -- there are at least
ten places in the Bible where God openly, unashamedly and absolutely endorses slavery. God does not "sort of hint" that
he might dislike women -- God displays open animosity toward women in his words and deeds. God not only likes animal
sacrifice -- he demands it, and gives explicit instructions for how it is to be done. God does not kill one or two children --
God openly massacres millions of children and admits it in writing.
This is the God of the Bible. This is the God that Christians worship.

If you are a Christian, you automatically and unquestioningly believe in Jesus, the Ten Commandments, heaven and hell.
Why? Because you believe that the Bible came from God.
The problem is that if you support the Ten Commandments and believe in Jesus, you must also support slavery. The
same God and the same Bible that tells us about the Ten Commandments and Jesus is also telling us about slavery.
Take a moment right now to ask yourself this simple question: Do you believe in slavery? Having read how God feels
about slavery in the Bible, do you now believe that in America and around the world we should repeal all anti-slavery laws
and re-open the slave trade? If you are Christian, what choice do you have? God fully advocates slavery in the Bible, and
you believe the word of God.
Why is the Bible so irrelevant?
For many people, the last four chapters prove that God did not write the Bible. They prove it beyond the shadow of any
doubt. It is painfully obvious: Primitive men wrote the Bible, not God.
But what if you need still more proof? If so, then here is a question: Why, when you read the Bible, are you not left in
awe? Why doesn't a book written by God leave you with a sense of wonder and amazement? If you are reading a book
written by the all-powerful, all-knowing, all-loving creator of the universe, wouldn't you expect to be stunned by the
brilliance, the clarity and the wisdom of the author? Would you not expect each new page to intoxicate you with its
incredible prose and its spectacular insight?

If you are going to believe that the Ten Commandments came from God because they are in God's Bible, then you must
also believe that all of these slavery passages came from God. You, Justice Scalia and everyone else who believes that
God wrote the Bible should be perfectly comfortable with the slave trade.
An all-or-nothing book
Instead, opening the Bible inevitably creates a feeling of dumbfoundment. Have you ever noticed that? Instead of
brilliance, much of the Bible contains nonsense. The topics of the previous several chapters, where we discussed the
Bible's advocacy of slavery and animal sacrifice, the Bible's misogyny and so on, are excellent examples. But they are just
the tip of the iceberg. You can open the Bible to almost any page and find nonsense instead of wisdom. Here are several
examples:

If you do not believe that God wrote the slavery passages in
the Bible, then the obvious question to ask yourself is this:
How can you possibly know which parts came from God and
which parts were inserted by primitive men? How can you pick
and choose like that? You have absolutely no way to know
whether the slavery passages came from God or primitive
men.
It is when you start thinking about the Bible in this way that
you understand something very important about the Bible.
Either the entire Bible really is God's Word, or the entire Bible
Key Point
If you are going to believe that the Ten Commandments
came from God because they are in God's Bible, then
you must also believe that all of these slavery passages
came from God as well. Therefore you, Justice Scalia
and everyone else who believes that God wrote the Bible
should be perfectly comfortable with the slave trade.
Christians must believe that all the laws that forbid
slavery in the United States defy God's word, and we
should be actively working to repeal them.
Judges Chapter 4
But Jael, Heber's wife, picked up a tent peg and a hammer and went quietly to him while he lay fast asleep,
exhausted. She drove the peg through his temple into the ground, and he died.
Genesis Chapter 19
Lot and his two daughters left Zoar and settled in the mountains, for he was afraid to stay in Zoar. He and his two
daughters lived in a cave. One day the older daughter said to the younger, "Our father is old, and there is no man
around here to lie with us, as is the custom all over the earth. Let's get our father to drink wine and then lie with
him and preserve our family line through our father."
Genesis Chapter 38

52 65
What does God have against children? Why would an all-loving, all-knowing being act in this way? In the case of Herod's
massacre, a religious person might say, "God had to do it to fulfill a prophecy in the Bible." But that makes no sense,
because God could have left the prophecy out.
A normal person, after reading passages like these, is left first with a deep sense of disgust. Any normal human being
knows that these acts are monstrous. What we are seeing here is not a loving God, but instead a demonic executioner
working at a massive scale. Why would anyone worship this appalling monster?
A normal person then asks the obvious question: Did God actually write these verses in the Bible? Would God actually
condone these acts?
I think we can all agree that a loving God would not condone these acts. Therefore, these parts of the Bible could not
have been written by God. It should be obvious to all of us that God did not write the Bible.
It is appropriate at this point to speak to Christians, especially the "casual Christians" who go to church occasionally
because it seems like the "right thing to do." Most Christians have never read the Bible. They have no idea that the God of
the Bible is a huge proponent of slavery, or that God hates women, or that God finds the annihilation of small children so
enthralling. Should we, as human beings living in the modern world, be worshipping a God like this?
Chapter 17 - Reviewing the evidence about the Bible
In the last four chapters we have looked at dozens of Bible passages. We have found that God is a huge proponent of
slavery, that God hates women, that God revels in the destruction of small children, and that God spells out detailed
instructions for animal and human sacrifice. If you are a Christian, here is the important question that you should be
asking yourself:
Do you believe that an all-loving, all-knowing, all-powerful, prayer-answering God wrote these passages in the
Bible?
This question is incredibly important because of this fact:
There is no reason for you to believe that you have a soul, or that you will have eternal life after death, or that
there is a heaven and hell, or that God answers prayers, or that God wrote the Ten Commandments, or that
Jesus is resurrected, and so on, unless you believe that God wrote the Bible.
If you insist that God wrote the Bible so that you can believe in the Ten Commandments or eternal life, shouldn't you also
be a proponent of slavery and a misogynist? It is the same book in both cases.
The point is simple. Can you imagine God sitting on his magnificent throne in heaven saying this?
"As the all-powerful, all-knowing creator of the universe, I shall write a book for my creation, and I shall call it The
Bible. Let's see, what shall I put in it??? Well, I want to be SURE to write about my absolute endorsement of
slavery in both the Old and the New Testaments -- slavery is very important to me and I want people buying and
selling slaves for thousands of years. And I want to be CERTAIN that the book shows how much I hate women in
both the Old and the New Testaments. And I can NOT forget the parts about animal and human sacrifice,
because sacrifices are an essential element of every proper religion. I want people slaughtering animals,
splattering their blood and then burning the carcasses on a stone altar because the aroma is pleasing to me. And
I want to make human sacrifice the centerpiece of my worship. And I CERTAINLY need to include the juicy parts
about child massacre in both the Old and the New Testaments. Baby killing is something that I will emphasize
throughout this book because it is very important to me."
Do you believe this? Of course not. Yet, clearly, if God does exist and God wrote the Bible, this is in fact what God said to
himself. You have seen with your own eyes the numerous passages in the Bible where God displays these tendencies.
Confirm them yourself by looking them up in God's word.
An all-knowing, all-loving God could not have written such appalling verses into the Bible. It should be obvious to you that
primitive men wrote this book, not God.
64
was written by primitive men with absolutely no input from God. Here is the reason for this very strong dividing line:
If part of the Bible came from God and part came from primitive men, how can you possibly know which is which?
How do you know if Jesus really is resurrected, or if that's just a make-believe story inserted by primitive men?
How do you know if God wrote the Ten Commandments or not? If any part of the Bible has been polluted by
primitive men, you have to reject the whole thing. There is no way to know who wrote what, so the entire book is
invalid.
There really is no middle ground. The Bible has to be an all-or-nothing book. Either the entire Bible came from God, or
none of it did.
The Tylenol Scare
Why can there be no middle ground? To understand the problem, simply look at slavery passages in the Bible. Many
Christians believe that God did not write these passages, and therefore reject them. These Christians believe that these
passages were inserted by primitive men without God's approval. However, these Christians have no way to prove their
belief. And by calling the authorship of these passages into question, they call into question every sentence in the Bible.
Pick any sentence in the Bible and ask yourself, "Did God write this sentence, or did primitive men write it without any
input from God?" There is no way to know. Since there is no way to prove it one way or another, and since it is possible
that primitive men wrote any sentence in the Bible rather than God (i.e. every sentence in the Bible could be a forgery),
we must assume that every sentence is the product of primitive men.
An analogy can put a finer point on the problem. Imagine that I tell you that several madmen around the country have
inserted capsules containing cyanide into random bottles of Tylenol sitting on store shelves. The poison capsules look
identical to normal capsules, and the tainted bottles of pills are indistinguishable from normal bottles. If I now hand you a
bottle of Tylenol capsules off of a store shelf, will you take one of the pills? Of course not. Every pill could, potentially,
contain poison. There is no way to know which pills do and do not contain poison. Therefore, you must assume that every
pill does contain poison. If you do not know who created the pills, you must suspect that every pill came from a madman.
This Tylenol situation actually happened in the United States in 1982, and it is the reason why all bottles of over-the-
counter medicine now have tamper-proof seals on them. The lesson from 1982 is simple. Since every capsule of Tylenol
could contain poison, we had to suspect that every capsule did contain poison. We threw out millions of capsules because
of that uncertainty. In addition, all manufacturers began putting tamper-proof seals on all bottles of over-the-counter
medicine to eliminate the uncertainty.
The Bible suffers from exactly the same problem. And the Bible contains no tamper-proof seal. If we suspect that any one
sentence in the Bible might have been randomly inserted by primitive men without God's approval, then every single
sentence in the Bible now comes under suspicion. It does not matter whether any of the Bible might have been written by
God. Because we are uncertain and have no way to prove it one way or another, we must assume that primitive men
wrote every sentence of the Bible. Because of the uncertainty, we must throw out all of the sentences, just like we threw
out all of the Tylenol capsules. If primitive men could have written any sentence, we must assume that they wrote the
entire Bible. We have no other choice. The Bible is an all-or-nothing proposition.
Drawing a conclusion
With this all-or-nothing reality about the Bible now understood, you can see that there are only two possible explanations
for the slavery passages in the Bible:
x The Bible is right, and God loves slavery. The entire Bible is God's word, so these slavery passages must be
God's word too. The laws in the United States and other modern nations that make slavery illegal defy God's
word. Justice Scalia should be promoting slavery in exactly the same way that he promotes the Ten
Commandments.
x The Bible condones slavery because the Bible was written by slave-owning men, not by God.
Chances are that you have a problem with the first explanation. God would not champion the abomination that is slavery.
We all know that.
53
Therefore, what you are left with is the second explanation. And suddenly, the Bible becomes a poisoned book.
Here is the thing that I would like to help you understand: You, as a rational human being, know that slavery is wrong. You
know it. That is why every single developed nation in the world has made slavery completely illegal. Human beings make
slavery illegal, in direct defiance of God's word, because we all know with complete certainty that slavery is wrong (see
also Chapter 28). If God actually had anything to do with the Bible, then the eleventh commandment would be, "Thou
shalt not enslave."
What does your common sense now tell you about a Bible that supports slavery in both the Old and the New Testaments?
Given the fact that the Bible clearly condones slavery, and given the fact that the Bible is an all-or-nothing book, does it
make more sense for you to believe that God wrote the Bible, or that primitive men wrote the Bible without any input from
God? Be honest with yourself. Make a choice, and then let's look at another example that is just as outrageous...
Chapter 14 - Why does God love animal sacrifice?
So the people of Israel did just as the LORD had commanded through Moses and Aaron. And at midnight the
LORD killed all the firstborn sons in the land of Egypt, from the firstborn son of Pharaoh, who sat on the throne, to
the firstborn son of the captive in the dungeon. Even the firstborn of their livestock were killed. Pharaoh and his
officials and all the people of Egypt woke up during the night, and loud wailing was heard throughout the land of
Egypt. There was not a single house where someone had not died.
Here the death of the children is directly at the hand of God.
In Isaiah chapter 13, God paints this word picture:
Anyone who is captured will be run through with a sword. Their little children will be dashed to death right before
their eyes. Their homes will be sacked and their wives raped by the attacking hordes. For I will stir up the Medes
against Babylon, and no amount of silver or gold will buy them off. The attacking armies will shoot down the
young people with arrows. They will have no mercy on helpless babies and will show no compassion for the
children.
What a lovely image.

For most people, the last chapter offers sufficient evidence to prove to themselves that God did not write the Bible. In Jeremiah chapter 49, verse 20, God paints a similar picture:
Clearly, an all-loving God cannot be a huge proponent of slavery. Therefore, since the Bible specifies that slavery is
perfectly acceptable in the eyes of the Lord, it is easy to conclude that primitive men wrote the Bible rather than God.
Therefore hear the plan which the LORD has made against Edom and the purposes which he has formed against
the inhabitants of Teman: Even the little ones of the flock shall be dragged away; surely their fold shall be
However, if you need additional evidence, then we can approach the Bible from another angle and reach the same appalled at their fate. At the sound of their fall the earth shall tremble; the sound of their cry shall be heard at the
conclusion. Red Sea.
In Hosea chapter 13, God paints a similar picture:
To any normal human being, the idea of animal and human sacrifice is both abhorrent and nauseating. The dictionary Samaria shall bear her guilt, because she has rebelled against her God; they shall fall by the sword, their little
defines "sacrifice" in this way: ones shall be dashed in pieces, and their pregnant women ripped open.
In Numbers chapter 31, God paints a similar picture:
The act of offering something to a deity in propitiation or homage, especially the ritual slaughter of an animal or a Moses said to them, "Have you let all the women live? Behold, these caused the people of Israel, by the counsel
person. [ref] of Balaam, to act treacherously against the LORD in the matter of Pe'or, and so the plague came among the
This, quite clearly, is something that primitive savages would do. There is no need to beat around the bush: We all know, congregation of the LORD. Now therefore, kill every male among the little ones, and kill every woman who has
without question, that animal and human sacrifice is an absurdity. Sacrificing and burning an animal on an altar does not known man by lying with him. But all the young girls who have not known man by lying with him, keep alive for
have any beneficial effect for anyone. yourselves.
Here Moses, acting as an agent of God, specifies that thousands of male babies and children be killed, as well as
The Aztecs in Mexico would take a virgin to the top of a pyramid, slice her still-beating heart out of her chest and eat it -- thousands of women. The Bible states in verse 35 that the captured women numbered "thirty-two thousand persons in all,
or whatever -- and we all know that their practices were insane and barbaric beyond belief. [ref] The death of the virgin did women who had not known man by lying with him." This was not a small attack. Tens of thousands men, women and
absolutely nothing to improve crop yield or rainfall, nor did it "appease" the Aztec gods (since those gods were completely children were massacred.
imaginary). It is impossible to understand why the Aztecs would do something so bizarre and disgusting. Was it mass In Deuteronomy Chapter 3 we find this:
delusion? Rampant superstition taken to the Nth degree? Total desperation? A horrific combination? There is no way to
know, but we do know that the behavior of the Aztecs was insane. Next we turned and went up along the road toward Bashan, and Og Key Point
king of Bashan with his whole army marched out to meet us in battle
Any normal person is disgusted by religious sacrifice, and you would imagine that God is too. Ritual slaughter like this has at Edrei. The LORD said to me, "Do not be afraid of him, for I have It is appropriate at this point to speak to
nothing to do with an all-powerful, all-knowing, all-loving, prayer-answering creator of the universe. The idea of killing an handed him over to you with his whole army and his land. Do to him Christians, especially the "casual
animal, splattering its blood about and then burning its flesh is, quite obviously, absurd and ridiculous. God would have what you did to Sihon king of the Amorites, who reigned in Christians" who go to church occasionally
nothing to do with animal sacrifice. Heshbon." So the LORD our God also gave into our hands Og king because it seems like the "right thing to
of Bashan and all his army. We struck them down, leaving no do." Most Christians have never read the
survivors. At that time we took all his cities. There was not one of the Bible. They have no idea that the God of
But then we examine the Bible -- the holy word of God and the single authoritative source of all information about Jesus --
sixty cities that we did not take from them—the whole region of the Bible is a huge proponent of slavery, or
and find passages like these:
Argob, Og's kingdom in Bashan. All these cities were fortified with that God hates women, or that God finds
high walls and with gates and bars, and there were also a great the annihilation of small children so
Leviticus Chapter 1 many unwalled villages. We completely destroyed them, as we had enthralling. Should we, as human beings
done with Sihon king of Heshbon, destroying every city—men, living in the modern world, be worshipping
The Lord called to Moses and spoke to him from the Tent of Meeting. He said, "Speak to the Israelites and say to women and children. But all the livestock and the plunder from their a God like this?
them: 'When any of you brings an offering to the Lord , bring as your offering an animal from either the herd or the cities we carried off for ourselves.
flock. They massacred all the men, women and children in 60 cities at God's request.

"If the offering is a burnt offering from the herd, he is to offer a male without defect. He must present it at the
entrance to the Tent of Meeting so that it will be acceptable to the Lord . He is to lay his hand on the head of the
burnt offering, and it will be accepted on his behalf to make atonement for him. He is to slaughter the young bull
before the Lord , and then Aaron's sons the priests shall bring the blood and sprinkle it against the altar on all
sides at the entrance to the Tent of Meeting. He is to skin the burnt offering and cut it into pieces. The sons of
54
Then there is Noah's flood, in which God massacred every single child on the face of the earth.
Doesn't it feel odd to find all of this material in the Bible? Especially the quote from Moses in Numbers 31. You may recall
that the sixth commandment is, "Thou shalt not kill."
63
Chapter 16 - Why does God massacre millions of children?
For most people, the last three chapters offer all the evidence that they need to prove to themselves that God did not write
the Bible. Clearly, an all-loving God cannot be a huge proponent of slavery. Nor can an all-loving God be an advocate of
both animal and human sacrifice. Nor can an all-loving God be a flagrant misogynist. Therefore, since the Bible specifies
that God loves slavery and animal/human sacrifice and that God hates women, it is easy for most people to conclude that
primitive men wrote the Bible rather than God.
However, if you need additional evidence, then we can approach the Bible from another angle and reach the same
conclusion.
In the book of Matthew, chapter 2, mixed into the Christmas story, the Bible describes an amazing massacre of thousands
of babies:
And when they were come into the house, they saw the young child with Mary his mother, and fell down, and
worshipped him: and when they had opened their treasures, they presented unto him gifts; gold, and frankincense
and myrrh. And being warned of God in a dream that they should not return to Herod, they departed into their own
country another way. And when they were departed, behold, the angel of the Lord appeareth to Joseph in a
dream, saying, Arise, and take the young child and his mother, and flee into Egypt, and be thou there until I bring
thee word: for Herod will seek the young child to destroy him. When he arose, he took the young child and his
mother by night, and departed into Egypt: And was there until the death of Herod: that it might be fulfilled which
was spoken of the Lord by the prophet, saying, Out of Egypt have I called my son. Then Herod, when he saw that
he was mocked of the wise men, was exceeding wroth, and sent forth, and slew all the children that were in
Bethlehem, and in all the coasts thereof, from two years old and under, according to the time which he had
diligently enquired of the wise men. Then was fulfilled that which was spoken by Jeremy the prophet, saying, In
Rama was there a voice heard, lamentation, and weeping, and great mourning, Rachel weeping for her children,
and would not be comforted, because they are not.
Think about the thousands of families who were affected by this massacre. The Bible describes
their suffering: they wept and could not be comforted. Of course they could not be comforted. If
you are a parent, you know exactly how distraught you would feel if an agent of the government
Watch the video
came to your door one morning and slaughtered your children.
Why did God do this? Being all-knowing, God knew that this would happen. In fact, according to the Bible, God acted on
his knowledge. But why would God take the time to reach down to earth and save his own child, and then allow all of
these thousands of other innocent children to die? If God is love, where is the love in that? How could a loving God
willfully allow such massive suffering without taking action?
Think about how easy it would have been for God to prevent all of this suffering:
x God could have appeared to Herod in a dream and told him not to kill these children.
x God could have killed Herod.
x God could have guided the wise men so that Herod would not have felt mocked by them.
x God could have protected the babies.
x God could have spoken to the murdering soldiers and turned them away from the task.
x God could have sent all of these families to Egypt when he sent Jesus and his family there.
x God could have made it so that no male children besides Jesus were born during that time.
x God could have changed history so that Herod was not king.
It is easy to come up with thousands of solutions, yet God did nothing.
God, by sending his son to earth, was the direct cause of this massacre. And God, as an all-powerful and all-knowing
being, knew that it would happen and had the power to prevent it. In fact, God did take direct action to save Jesus.
Instead of saving the thousands of other children, however, God stood by and watched as they were slaughtered.
It is interesting to note that this is not the only place in the Bible where God causes thousands of children to die. In the
book of Exodus chapter 12 verse 28, God writes about one of his early massacres:
62
Aaron the priest are to put fire on the altar and arrange wood on the fire. Then Aaron's sons the priests shall
arrange the pieces, including the head and the fat, on the burning wood that is on the altar. He is to wash the
inner parts and the legs with water, and the priest is to burn all of it on the altar. It is a burnt offering, an offering
made by fire, an aroma pleasing to the Lord .
"If the offering is a burnt offering from the flock, from either the sheep or the goats, he is to offer a male without
defect. He is to slaughter it at the north side of the altar before the Lord , and Aaron's sons the priests shall
sprinkle its blood against the altar on all sides. He is to cut it into pieces, and the priest shall arrange them,
including the head and the fat, on the burning wood that is on the altar. He is to wash the inner parts and the legs
with water, and the priest is to bring all of it and burn it on the altar. It is a burnt offering, an offering made by fire,
an aroma pleasing to the Lord .
"If the offering to the Lord is a burnt offering of birds, he is to offer a dove or a young pigeon. The priest shall bring
it to the altar, wring off the head and burn it on the altar; its blood shall be drained out on the side of the altar. He
is to remove the crop with its contents and throw it to the east side of the altar, where the ashes are. He shall tear
it open by the wings, not severing it completely, and then the priest shall burn it on the wood that is on the fire on
the altar. It is a burnt offering, an offering made by fire, an aroma pleasing to the Lord .
Burning flesh is an aroma pleasing to the Lord? Does this make any sense to you as a rational human being?
Here is another example:
Leviticus Chapter 5
'If a person sins because he does not speak up when he hears a public charge to testify regarding something he
has seen or learned about, he will be held responsible.
'Or if a person touches anything ceremonially unclean-whether the carcasses of unclean wild animals or of
unclean livestock or of unclean creatures that move along the ground-even though he is unaware of it, he has
become unclean and is guilty.
'Or if he touches human uncleanness-anything that would make him unclean-even though he is unaware of it,
when he learns of it he will be guilty.
'Or if a person thoughtlessly takes an oath to do anything, whether good or evil-in any matter one might carelessly
swear about-even though he is unaware of it, in any case when he learns of it he will be guilty.
'When anyone is guilty in any of these ways, he must confess in what way he has sinned and, as a penalty for the
sin he has committed, he must bring to the Lord a female lamb or goat from the flock as a sin offering; and the
priest shall make atonement for him for his sin.
'If he cannot afford a lamb, he is to bring two doves or two young pigeons to the Lord as a penalty for his sin-one
for a sin offering and the other for a burnt offering. He is to bring them to the priest, who shall first offer the one for
the sin offering. He is to wring its head from its neck, not severing it completely, and is to sprinkle some of the
blood of the sin offering against the side of the altar; the rest of the blood must be drained out at the base of the
altar. It is a sin offering. The priest shall then offer the other as a burnt offering in the prescribed way and make
atonement for him for the sin he has committed, and he will be forgiven.
You are an intelligent human being, so think this through. Here is the logic expressed in Leviticus chapter 5:
"Today I accidentally touched something that was 'ceremonially unclean,' and I didn't know about it at the time,
but fortunately a priest brought it to my attention, and I am guilty. Now, I can't afford a lamb. But I can get two
young pigeons for a shekel over at Saul's bird emporium, and then I can take them both to the priest. He will wring
the head from the neck of one of them, but not sever it completely. And he will sprinkle the blood, and drain the
rest. And then the priest will burn the other pigeon. Then I am forgiven. Thank God!"
What does your common sense tell you about this? It probably tells you that it is impossible to imagine an all-loving, all-
knowing God demanding this, and you are correct.
55
Here is another example:
Leviticus Chapter 7, The priest's share
The Lord said to Moses, "Say to the Israelites: 'Anyone who brings a fellowship offering to the Lord is to bring part
of it as his sacrifice to the Lord . With his own hands he is to bring the offering made to the Lord by fire; he is to
bring the fat, together with the breast, and wave the breast before the Lord as a wave offering. The priest shall
burn the fat on the altar, but the breast belongs to Aaron and his sons. You are to give the right thigh of your
fellowship offerings to the priest as a contribution. The son of Aaron who offers the blood and the fat of the
fellowship offering shall have the right thigh as his share. From the fellowship offerings of the Israelites, I have
taken the breast that is waved and the thigh that is presented and have given them to Aaron the priest and his
sons as their regular share from the Israelites.' "
Does it seem more likely that God commanded this, or that primitive men looking for the "priest's share" wrote this?
Here is another example:
Leviticus Chapter 9
[Moses] then presented the other ram, the ram for the ordination, and Aaron and his sons laid their hands on its
head. Moses slaughtered the ram and took some of its blood and put it on the lobe of Aaron's right ear, on the
thumb of his right hand and on the big toe of his right foot. Moses also brought Aaron's sons forward and put
some of the blood on the lobes of their right ears, on the thumbs of their right hands and on the big toes of their
right feet. Then he sprinkled blood against the altar on all sides. He took the fat, the fat tail, all the fat around the
inner parts, the covering of the liver, both kidneys and their fat and the right thigh.
Then from the basket of bread made without yeast, which was before the Lord, he took a cake of bread, and one
made with oil, and a wafer; he put these on the fat portions and on the right thigh. He put all these in the hands of
Aaron and his sons and waved them before the Lord as a wave offering. Then Moses took them from their hands
and burned them on the altar on top of the burnt offering as an ordination offering, a pleasing aroma, an offering
made to the Lord by fire. He also took the breast-Moses' share of the ordination ram-and waved it before the Lord
as a wave offering, as the Lord commanded Moses.
We have Moses putting the blood of a freshly slaughtered animal on the ears, thumbs and toes of other people.
What does your common sense tell you about these passages?
When looking at passages like these in the Bible, everyone can see the problem. Animal sacrifice is abhorrent, and it has
nothing to do with an all-knowing and all-loving God.
For most people, no further evidence is needed. It is obvious that primitive men wrote the Bible, not God. God would have
nothing to do with the Bible if these passages are in it, and the Bible is an all-or-nothing book (see Chapter 13 for details).
No all-powerful, all-loving God wants people to kill animals, splatter their blood, cut them up into pieces, arrange the
pieces on an altar and burn them so that he can "smell the
pleasing aroma." There is no difference between the Bible's book Key Point
of Leviticus and the insanity of the Aztecs.
All of this material about animal sacrifice is found in
Therefore, in the same way that the slavery passages in the the Old Testament of the Bible. This is the same
previous chapter prove that God did not write the Bible, these place where we find the Ten Commandments. Only
animal sacrifice passages prove that God did not write the Bible. about 20 pages separate Exodus chapter 20 -- the
The whole notion of an all-knowing, all-powerful God purposefully source of the Ten Commandments -- from Leviticus
writing this material is patently absurd to any rational human Chapter 1.
being.
Keep in mind that all of this material about animal sacrifice is found in the Old Testament of the Bible. This is the same
place where we find the Ten Commandments. Only about 20 pages separate Exodus chapter 20 -- the source of the Ten
Commandments -- from Leviticus Chapter 1.
56
Rationalizing misogyny
If you are an unbiased observer, you probably find this situation to be mystifying. There is not any room for
misinterpretation when God says, "Women should remain silent in the churches. They are not allowed to speak, but must
be in submission." Nor when God says, "I permit no woman to teach or to have authority over men; she is to keep silent."
Why would God say that if he did not mean it? And why would Christians allow women to speak in church and teach in
our schools given that God specifically forbids it?
A religious person might say, "God had to 'fit in' with the customs of the time." We discussed this argument in Chapter 13
when discussing slavery. What does your common sense tell you? If God -- the all-powerful creator of the universe and
father of mankind -- wanted women treated equally, all that he had to do was set things in motion when he created Adam.
Or God could have written a twelfth commandment that said, "Thou shalt treat men and women equally." God could
portray men and women as equals throughout the Bible. Half of Jesus' apostles could have been women -- that would
have made things utterly clear. If God wanted men and women to be equal, he would have made it happen.
You can think about it, and think some more. No matter how you slice it, the sexism is there, plain as day in the Bible.
There is no ambiguity. We are forced to conclude God is an all-powerful misogynist, are we not?
In chapter 17 we will discuss the following comment in detail, but it is important to introduce it here: if God is going to take
the time to write and publish "the Word of God," why does the book contain so many problems?
x Why isn't each page of the Bible astonishing us with its brilliance and insight, and filling us with wonder?
x Why, instead, does the Bible contain so much nonsense or, in this case, bigotry?
x Why are Christians constantly having to justify, rationalize, excuse and explain the Bible? In this case, we find
modern Christians trying to defend a God who obviously dislikes women on many different levels.
x Why didn't God understand how he would look to intelligent human beings in the twenty first century, and get it
right when he wrote the Bible? The fact is that we are forced to completely ignore God when he says, "I permit no
woman to teach or to have authority over men; she is to keep silent." No one believes that, most especially the
50% of the population who are female.
If you are a Christian, I would ask you to consider the two possible ways to explain
Key Point
the sexism that we are seeing in the Bible:
To any unbiased observer, the
x You can assume that God actually did write the Bible and truly is sexist and reason for rampant sexism in the
misogynistic. In that case we are directly defying God's word today by Bible is very easy to understand:
allowing women to be equal to men. The Bible was not written by God. It
x Or you can assume that God had nothing to do with the Bible. In that case, was written by primitive men who
the Bible is meaningless and we can discard it, as discussed in Chapter 13. were flagrant sexists. Just look at
how men in primitive countries like
Drawing a simple conclusion Afghanistan treat women today.
Those are the kind of men who
To any unbiased observer, the reason for sexism in the Bible is very easy to wrote the Bible. God had nothing to
understand: The Bible was not written by God. It was written by primitive men who do with this book.
were flagrant sexists. Just look at how men in primitive countries like Afghanistan
treat women today. Those are the kind of men who wrote the Bible.
And we all know it -- Christians and non-Christians alike. The reason why modern societies (including most Christians
living in those societies) completely reject sexism is because we all know that the Bible's sexism is wrong. It is exactly the
same situation we see when Christians face slavery and animal sacrifice in the Bible. Christians and non-Christians alike
reject the Bible's teachings in these areas because the Bible is obviously wrong. The part that is profoundly strange is
that, while completely rejecting these parts of the Bible, Chistians will claim that other parts of the Bible are God's word.
They seem to be blind to the obvious contradiction.
At some point, Christians have to accept the evidence that we all can see: Either God wrote the Bible, or he did not. If he
did, then he is wrong, and we should reject the Bible and him. If he did not, then we should reject the Bible.
This fact should now be apparent to every woman, and to any rational man.
61
 x In 1 Peter 3:7 we find: "Husbands, in the same way be considerate as you live with your wives, and treat them
with respect as the weaker partner and as heirs with you of the gracious gift of life, so that nothing will hinder your
prayers."
x In 1 John 2:13, John says, "I write to you, fathers, because you have known him who is from the beginning. I write
to you, young men, because you have overcome the evil one. I write to you, dear children, because you have
known the Father." No mention is made of women.
x In Numbers 31:14-18 we find: "Moses was angry with the officers of the army—the commanders of thousands
and commanders of hundreds—who returned from the battle. "Have you allowed all the women to live?" he asked
them. "They were the ones who followed Balaam's advice and were the means of turning the Israelites away from
the LORD in what happened at Peor, so that a plague struck the LORD's people. Now kill all the boys. And kill
every woman who has slept with a man, but save for yourselves every girl who has never slept with a man."
Making sex slaves of women apparently is God's will.
x And so on. There are many, many examples like these throughout the old and new testaments.
There are other, broader examples of misogyny that are readily apparent in the Bible:
x Are any of Jesus' disciples women? No.
x Are any of the elders in the book of Revelation women? No.
x Are any of the books of the Bible written by women? No.
x Etc...
God, it would seem, wants nothing to do with women.
The modern rejection of God's misogyny
How do you, as a woman, feel about all of this sexism?
Keep in mind that God's misogyny as portrayed in the Bible has affected society for centuries. The United States
constitution, for example, was originally drafted to specifically deny rights to women. Women could not even vote in the
United States until 1920, and only then after decades of battle in the women's suffrage movement.
If you think about it, you will realize that something else is odd. In spite of the Bible and its far-reaching effects, and in
spite of the fact that the Bible is supposed to be God's eternal Word, modern human beings have advanced well beyond
the Bible's teachings. In fact, we totally reject God's sexism. Modern human beings completely ignore God:
x We make women the CEOs of major corporations.
x We elect women to high government offices.
x We appoint women as presidents of universities.
x We fill our schools with female teachers.
x We allow women to speak freely in church.
We do all of this in direct defiance of God's Law in the Bible because we know God and his eternal word is wrong.
Why do we completely defy the Bible like this? Why do you, as a woman, reject God's Word when it comes to sexism? I
would offer this possibility: We do it because the Bible's attitude toward women is completely irrational. There is no
rational reason for women and men to be treated in any way other than equally, and modern, intelligent human beings
know that with complete certainty. Therefore, we have to reject what God says in the Bible.
Can you see the contradiction there? We are mere mortals, and we have told our all-powerful God that he is completely
wrong.
The funny thing is, billions of Christians still worship God and claim that the Bible is the word of God. Women will happily
stand up in church and proclaim how much they love God, in complete defiance of God's word. Supreme Court Justice
Antonin Scalia will trumpet his support for the Ten Commandments, which come from the same book that tells women to
shut up and be subservient (see Chapter 13 for details on Justice Scalia). What is going on here?
60
Human Sacrifice
If you are a Christian, how do you handle these passages in the Bible? A Christian has a problem, because it is hard to
put faith in a book that harbors numerous passages where God demands animal sacrifice. As with the slavery problem
discussed in the previous chapter, there are two possible approaches for a Christian:
1. Pretend that the passages are not there and change the subject when they are mentioned.
2. Try to develop some sort of highly convoluted rationalization on God's behalf to explain the passages.
Christians tend to take the latter approach, and then they do something quite unexpected. You would imagine that
Christians would try to distance themselves as far as possible from animal sacrifice. But they do not.
Suprisingly, many Christians embrace these parts of the Bible. Only in the context of this abhorent practice does the
horrific death of Jesus on the cross (as portrayed in the movie The Passion of the Christ) make even a modicum of sense.
For Christians, the human race had to actually move into the realm of human sacrifice to finally appease their God.
Senselessly killing animals was not sufficient. According to the Christian faith, Jesus is the human sacrifice that satisfied
God.
For example, here is something that a Christian minister might say:
If you read all those dry regulations for sin sacrifices in Leviticus and if you read about the requirements for the
Passover lamb, you will realize that Jesus is the perfect sacrifice for sin. He is the first-born son, not of a sheep or
a goat, but of God. He is innocent of all sin, He volunteers of His own free will—that is, He was convicted only by
His own confession. He freely submitted to His Father’s will. He is, by the Levitical code, a perfect sacrifice, and
therefore He perfectly removes all sin. He meets all the requirements for a fellowship offering, and thus places us
in fellowship with God. Since even on the cross, none of His bones were broken, He also meets all the
requirements for a Passover lamb, whose blood protects us from the angel of death, thus He prepares us for the
Resurrection.[ref]
As uncomfortable as this sounds, this is the core belief of the Christian church. Christ had to die as a human sacrifice for
our sins to appease the "God" of Leviticus. The most prominent religion on this planet, practiced by two billion people, has
human sacrifice as its central tenet.
When we read about animal sacrifice in the Old Testament, what we discover is a God who must be insane. No rational
human being can accept that an all-loving, all-knowing, all-powerful God could possibly support animal sacrifice.
But then we turn to the New Testament and find that God has moved beyond insanity. God becomes a monstrous
absurdity who demands human sacrifice. In other words, Christians are dwelling in the same realm as the virgin-killing
Aztecs.
Contemplating the crucifixion
Have you ever thought about how bizarre the crucifixion story is? Imagine the all-powerful, all-knowing creator of the
universe sitting on his magnificent throne in heaven. He looks down onto earth and says to himself:
Those evil humans down on earth. I hate what they are doing. All this sin...
Since I am all-knowing I know exactly what the humans are doing and I understand exactly why they commit each
sin. Since I created the humans in my own image and personally programmed human nature into their brains, I
am the direct author of all of this sin. The instant I created them I knew exactly what would happen with every
single human being right down to the nanosecond level for all eternity. If I didn't like how it was going to turn out, I
could have simply changed them when I created them. And since I am perfect, I know exactly what I am doing.
But ignore all that. I hate all these people doing exactly what I perfectly designed them to do and knew they would
do from the moment I created them...
So here's what I am going to do. I will artificially inseminate a virgin. She will give birth to an incarnated version of
me. The humans will eventually crucify and kill the incarnated me. That will, finally, make me happy. Yes, sending
myself down and having the humans crucify me -- that will satisfy me. I feel much better now.
57
It makes no sense, does it? Why would an all-knowing being need to have humans kill himself (Jesus is God, after all) to
make himself happy? Especially since it is a perfect God who set the whole thing in motion exactly the way he wanted it?
The whole story of the crucifixion is absurd from top to bottom if you actually stop to think about it.
Chapter 21 explains where this bizarre story actually comes from. It has nothing to do with "God".
Thinking about our sacrificial God
Have you ever stopped to think about it? If you are a Christian, have you ever thought about how uncomfortable this is?
You are worshipping a God who demanded animal sacrifice, and then was finally "appeased" by human sacrifice. Many
Christians seem to actually revel in human sacrifice. How else can we explain the tens of millions of Christians who
flocked to the movie The Passion of the Christ?
Have you ever consciously thought about how truly uncomfortable this situation is?
Key Point
Please simply take a moment and think about what you have read in this chapter.
Many Christians actually seem to
Here are two points of view for you to consider:
revel in human sacrifice. Tens of
millions of Christians flocked to the
1. God wrote the Bible and the Bible is the word of the Lord. God demanded movie "The Passion of the Christ".
animal sacrifice and he specified how he wanted the sacrifices done in
minute detail in the Bible because God enjoys animal sacrifice. These ritualized animal killings allowed humans to
atone for our many sins against God, and the aroma of the burning flesh was pleasing to the Lord. By moving to
the level of human sacrifice, Christians were finally able to appease their God.
2. Animal sacrifice is absurd, abhorrent, ridiculous and revolting. Human sacrifice even more so. The Bible was
written by primitive men, not by God. Those primitive men were as insane as the Aztecs.
Use both your head and your heart to analyze the situation. Which point of view makes more sense to you?
Now, let's look at another example that is just as outrageous...
Chapter 15 - Why is God so sexist?
If you are a Christian woman, then in this chapter I would like to talk with you directly and openly about God. And let me
get right to the point. When we look at the Bible -- God's Word -- God seems to have a major problem with women.
The dictionary defines a misogynist as "One who hates women." [ref] It defines the word "sexist" as:
1. Discrimination based on gender, especially discrimination against women.
2. Attitudes, conditions, or behaviors that promote stereotyping of social roles based on gender
Do you, as a woman, think of God as sexist, or as a misogynist? Probably not -- why would a Christian woman worship
God if he were obviously a sexist? When we think of God, we generally do not think of him as hating anyone. Under the
Standard Model of God, we think of God as an all-knowing and all-loving father. We think of him as being fair. We think of
God as loving each person equally, regardless of any distinction like skin color or gender.
Yet, strangely, we find that God treats women quite differently than he treats men. For example, we find this in 1
Corinthians chapter 14:
As in all the congregations of the saints, women should remain silent in the churches. They are not allowed to
speak, but must be in submission, as the Law says. If they want to inquire about something, they should ask their
own husbands at home; for it is disgraceful for a woman to speak in the church.
This seems like a straightforward passage. And God is the one who inspired the Bible. In Isaiah 40:8 God says that the
word of the Lord will last forever, and he says the same thing again in 1 Peter 1:24-25. So here we have God, in his
eternal and everlasting Word, saying that it is disgraceful for a woman to speak in the church.
58
Why would God personally create man and woman in his own image, and then
Key Point
silence the women? What possible reason does an all-loving, all-knowing God have
to be sexist?
In the New Testament of the Bible -
- God's holy word to his creation --
Even more interesting is this question: why would you, as a woman, worship a God
it says that it is disgraceful for a
who acts like this?
woman to speak in the church. In 1
Timothy chapter 2 it says, "I permit
The breadth of God's sexism no woman to teach or to have
authority over men; she is to keep
There are many places in the Bible where God talks about women. This quote from silent."
1 Corinthians 11, for example, is odd:
But I want you to understand that the head of every man is Christ, the head of a woman is her husband, and the
head of Christ is God. Any man who prays or prophesies with his head covered dishonors his head, but any
woman who prays or prophesies with her head unveiled dishonors her head--it is the same as if her head were
shaven. For if a woman will not veil herself, then she should cut off her hair; but if it is disgraceful for a woman to
be shorn or shaven, let her wear a veil. For a man ought not to cover his head, since he is the image and glory of
God; but woman is the glory of man. (For man was not made from woman, but woman from man. Neither was
man created for woman, but woman for man.) That is why a woman ought to have a veil on her head, because of
the angels.
What, exactly, is God saying there? You may find it hard to believe that something that confusing is in the Bible, yet if you
look it up you will find it is there.
Then there is this section from 1 Timothy chapter 2:
Also that women should adorn themselves modestly and sensibly in seemly apparel, not with braided hair or gold
or pearls or costly attire but by good deeds, as befits women who profess religion. Let a woman learn in silence
with all submissiveness. I permit no woman to teach or to have authority over men; she is to keep silent.
It is hard to miss God's meaning when he says something as direct as, "I permit no woman to teach or to have authority
over men; she is to keep silent." (see chapter 12)
If you think about it, you will realize that God started this type of sexism at the very beginning of the Bible. In Genesis
chapter 17 God says:
This is my covenant, which you shall keep, between me and you and your descendants after you: Every male
among you shall be circumcised. You shall be circumcised in the flesh of your foreskins, and it shall be a sign of
the covenant between me and you.
God makes no mention of forming any sort of covenant with women.
There are many other examples that we can find in the Bible:
x In Matthew 25:1 Jesus says: "At that time the kingdom of heaven will be like ten virgins who took their lamps and
went out to meet the bridegroom."
x In John 20:17 Jesus says to Mary: "Touch me not; for I am not yet ascended to my Father," as though the touch
of a woman is somehow improper, but a few verses later, is happy to have Thomas touch him.
x In Genesis chapter 3, God punishes Eve, and all women for thousands of years, with greatly increased pain
during childbirth. No such pain is inflicted on Adam.
x In Deuteronomy 22:28-29 we find this: "If a man meets a virgin who is not engaged, and seizes her and lies with
her, and they are caught in the act, the man who lay with her shall give fifty shekels of silver to the young
woman’s father, and she shall become his wife. Because he violated her he shall not be permitted to divorce her
as long as he lives." So, what God is saying is if you are a man, and you rape a girl, she gets to be your wife. Very
nice.
x In Ephesians 5:22-24 we find this: "Wives, submit to your husbands as to the Lord. For the husband is the head of
the wife as Christ is the head of the church, his body, of which he is the Savior. Now as the church submits to
Christ, so also wives should submit to their husbands in everything."
59