Professional Documents
Culture Documents
o mez 2
Fernando G
Carmen Campos Panisse 3, E-11500 Puerto de Santa Mara, Spain
629
630 EZ
F E R N A N D O G OM
Hayakawa et al. (2015) and Gavelis et al. (2015) car- were unfavorable for unarmored dinoflagellates. The observa-
ried out the immune-cytological and genomic stud- tions were also scarce from samples collected in the surface
ies, and new TEM studies in warnowiid waters of the port of Valencia, due to pollution and the dis-
tance between the sampling area and the laboratory that
dinoflagellates. These results concluded that the delayed the observations more than 1.5 h after collection.
ocelloid is a chimeric structure, incorporating orga- The observations of Erythropsidinium were more numerous in
nelles with different endosymbiotic histories. The the tropical coasts of Brazil, and the mild weather conditions
rhodopsin sequence of the retina-like structure of favored the sampling almost the entire year. In this case, the
Erythropsidinium branched with haptophytes, and results were limited due to the deficiencies in the microscope
that supported the chloroplast-derived origin sug- and camera facilities. Sampling was carried out using a phyto-
plankton net (20 lm mesh size) between March and Decem-
gested by Greuet (1977). From the observation of ber 2013 in the surface waters of S~ao Sebasti~ao Channel
live cells, Hayakawa et al. (2015) concluded that the (23500 4.05 S; 45240 28.82 W, 40 m depth). The live
lenses can extend the range of light sensitivity by plankton concentrate (35 L) was collected in the early
concentrating dim light. morning. During the day, aliquots of 50 mL were serially set-
Evolutionists such as Gehring (2005, 2014) tled and examined (Appendix S1). Cells of Erythropsidinium
hypothesized that the ocelloid of Erythropsidinium were found in the first hours of observations, and very rarely
at the end of the day. This suggests that the cells lysed as a
may be the origin of the eyes in metazoans. He pro-
consequence of the unfavorable conditions in the plankton
posed that the dinoflagellates may have transferred concentrate. The samples were examined in Uterm ohl cham-
their photoreceptor genes to cnidarians (Gehring bers at 9100 and 9200 magnifications with an inverted
2005, 2014). For many, the elaborate ocelloid of Ery- microscope Diaphot-300 (Nikon Inc., Tokyo, Japan). Cells
thropsidinium is considered a model of the smallest were photographed with a digital camera (Cyber-shot DSC-
eye on Earth (Schwab 2004, Colley and Nilsson W300; Sony, Tokyo, Japan) mounted on the microscopes
2016). The delicacy and the difficulties in culture of eyepiece. The camera also captured movies with time resolu-
tion of 30 frames per second (fps). The frames were
these heterotrophic species make it necessary to extracted using Free Video to JPG converter v. 5.0.28
work with recently collected wild cells. Erythropsi- (DVDVideoSoft Ltd, London, U.K.). An inverted microscope
dinium is widespread in the euphotic zone of the Eclipse TS-100 (Nikon Inc.) with higher magnification objec-
warm oceans (G omez 2008), while the specialized tives was available from November 2013. Cells were pho-
laboratories are mostly located in high latitudes. tographed with the same digital camera mounted on the
The role of the ocelloid in the ecology of Erythropsi- microscopes eyepiece. This procedure was not optimal for
recording swimming organisms because while the camera was
dinium, tentatively used in prey selection and preda- mounted, the target cell moved out the observation field and
tor avoidance, remain unresolved. The piston is a the camera needed to be removed in order to search again
unique organelle whose mechanism of propulsion to locate the cell. From the December 2013 to December
and function has not been investigated. 2015 samplings were carried out off Ubatuba (23320 20.15
This study reports observations of live cells of Ery- S; 4550 58.94 W, 15 m depth), and using the same inverted
thropsidinium with the aim to shed light on the func- microscope Eclipse TS-100 and the Sony Cyber-shot camera.
From May 2015 an inverted microscope Olympus IX73
tions of the ocelloid and piston, and the influence of (Olympus Inc., Tokyo, Japan) was available. A digital camera
these unique organelles in the morphology and behav- with a standard C-mount adapter (EUREKAM 3.0; BEL Pho-
ior of the entire cell. This study provides data on the tonics, Monza, Italy) was connected to the lateral camera
behavior, cell and ocelloid division, with new insights port, and operated with BEL View software. The video option
in to the taxonomy and synonymy of Erythropsidinium. was not useful for swimming cells because the time resolution
This study provides the first data on the type of prey of video recordings was limited to 6 fps. A high-speed camera
and feeding as a first step for culturing under labora- (Photron FASTCAM SA2 model 86K-C3; Photron, San Diego,
CA, USA) connected to the Olympus IX73 inverted micro-
tory conditions, and the first data on the mechanism scope was available for several days in late August 2015.
of cell propulsion and piston velocity and function. Despite winter being the most unfavorable season, several
active cells were recorded at 1,500 fps and 60 fps, and oper-
ated with Photron FASTCAM viewer. It should be noted that
MATERIALS AND METHODS at 1,500 fps, a recording file of a few seconds requires tens of
Live cells were collected from four coastal sites in the minutes for saving. During that period the target cell became
Mediterranean Sea in France and Spain (Marseilles, Banyuls- inactive or lysed. It was difficult to record a cell that was
sur-Mer, Villefranche-sur-Mer and Valencia) and two sites in already swimming because when using high magnification it
the South Atlantic Ocean in Brazil (S~ao Sebasti~ao Channel easily moved out of observation field or out of focus. When
and Ubatuba). Methods of collection and observation were using low magnification, the thin hyaline piston was hardly
described in G omez et al. (2016) and in Appendix S1 in the visible. At the beginning of each observation, the cell was on
Supporting Information. The aim of the observations at Mar- focus because it is still close to the bottom of the settling
seilles and Banyuls-sur-Mer was to obtain the first molecular chamber, and consequently there is wall effect until the
data of Erythropsidinium in order to resolve its phylogenetic cell is suspended. Consequently, the speed values are proba-
affiliation (G
omez et al. 2009). The cells were immediately bly underestimated.
isolated for PCR analysis to prevent cell lysis, and conse-
quently the behavioral observations were scarce. Samples in
RESULTS
the Bay of Villefranche-sur-Mer were collected from hauls
from 80 m depth to the surface with a 53 lm mesh size Morphology of the ocelloid. The warnowiid dinoflag-
plankton net. This method damages the delicate cells and ellates are characterized by the presence of an
the poor living conditions in a dense plankton concentrate
O C E L L O I D A N D P I S T O N I N ER YT H R O P S I D I N I U M 631
ocelloid (see Video S1 in the Supporting Informa- of a posterior cavity or invagination (Fig. 2o). This
tion). The melanosome, dark retinoid-like body, hemispherical posterior cavity showed a slit (Fig. 2p,
shows the red autofluorescence of chlorophyll a Fig. S2). A part of the piston can lyse, while the
when examined with epifluorescence microscopy other part may continue beating (Video S1). A fully
(Fig. 1, a and b). The cell body of Erythropsidinium lysed piston was able to regenerate in half an hour.
is slightly laterally compressed, with the ocelloid in If the cell lysed when the piston was beating, the
the left anterior side of the ventral view (Fig. S1 in isolated piston may continue beating for 1 min, and
the Supporting Information). The dorsal contour is finally retract into the bulb before lysing. The swel-
convex, while the anterior ventral side is concave ling at the end of piston acted as a suction cup
with the sulcus and intercingular region in a that adhered to the bottom glass of the settling
depressed area along the anterior longitudinal axis chamber (Fig. 2q, Fig. S3 in the Supporting Infor-
(Fig. S2 in the Supporting Information). The ocel- mation; Video S1). As the cell was unable to pull
loid was sometimes laterally directed (Fig. 1c), and the bottom glass, during the phases of contraction
more commonly anteriorly directed (Fig. 1, dm). and extension, the cell moved towards and then
The entire ocelloid rotated up to 45 from its ante- and moved away from it. The piston contraction was
rior position towards the left lateral side, and about three or four times faster than its extension
quickly returned to the anterior position (Fig. 1, d (Fig. 2q, Fig. S3; Video S1).
and e). The ocelloid rotation often preceded cell Cell and piston motility. The piston activity and cell
swimming (Video S1). The lenses of the hyalosome swimming were examined with a high-speed camera
concentrate the light on the melanosome (Fig. 1, (1,500 and 60 fps), and more frequently with a stan-
fj). The melanosome is chevron-like or kidney- dard camera with the time resolution of ordinary
shaped in lateral view (Fig. 1i), and circular in api- video recordings (30 fps). The activity of the piston
cal view (Fig. 1k). The hyalosome is hemispherical, showed a phase of extension, contraction and then
located on the concave side of the melanosome, remained in the posterior cavity before the next
and composed of lenses forming concentric layers, extension. The time interval between these phases,
with a cornea-like external envelope. The inner especially between the extension and the contrac-
lenses overlap laterally in the wedge-shaped pattern tion suggests two modes: a static mode, without
(Fig. 1m). When the cell lysed, the ocelloid significant cell swimming, and a locomotion
remained as an independent organelle (Fig. 1, or). mode, where the cell swam usually backwards (in
The melanosome remained intact for some time, the direction of the cell antapex) and more rarely
while the lenses immediately became disorganized, forwards (towards the cell apex). Here the back-
but they maintained the capacity to concentrate wards speed is considered as negative.
light (Fig. 1r). During the static mode, the phase of extension
Morphology of the piston and body exten- showed a variable duration and once extended, the
sions. Warnowiid dinoflagellates are characterized piston may remain extended for a variable period.
by a convex end of the hyposome or a pointed anta- The duration of the contraction was more regular
pex (Fig. 2, a and b). Proterythropsis showed a poste- and faster than the extension. The piston retracted
rior body extension (Fig. 2, c and d), and into the posterior cavity in 16 ms. This implied that
sometimes Nematodinium showed a hand-like lateral the piston attained a peak speed of 36 mm s1
body extension with distal finger-like projections (Figs. 3a, S4 and S5 in the Supporting Informa-
that were moveable (Fig. 2e; Video S1). Some cells tion). The piston remained in the posterior cavity
whose morphology corresponded to Erythropsidinium for a variable period before the next extension. Dur-
scarlatinum (Kofoid et Swezy) P. C. Silva showed an ing piston extension, the cell body moved forwards
elongated and thin lateral body extension with dis- at ~0.1 mm s1, while during the piston contrac-
persed pigmented granules (Fig. 2, fh, m and n). tion moved backwards at ~0.4 mm s1 (Figs. 3a,
Other cells whose morphology corresponded to S4 and S5). The balance between the extension and
E. extrudens (Kofoid et Swezy) P. C. Silva (Fig. 2, contraction did not necessarily yield a significant
ik) showed a shorter body extension, with a more cell displacement. The cell remained motionless at
or less pointed end, and the same coloration of the the bottom of the settling chamber, with some rota-
cell. The pigmented posterior or postero-lateral tion of the cell body (Fig. S6 in the Supporting
body extensions of E. scarlatinum and E. extrudens Information). It should be noted that the cell body
were likely mistaken for the piston in their original was in contact with the bottom glass of the settling
descriptions. The piston was always hyaline and cov- chamber, and consequently there is a friction and/
ered by papillae (Fig. 2, jm). The piston may pos- or wall-effect that may reduce the movement.
sess one nodule or several nodules in different Observations of the locomotion mode were car-
positions along its length. It showed a distal swelling ried out when a settled cell that was in focus began
of lanceolate (Fig. 2, k and l) or rounded shapes to swim. Recordings were difficult when the cell was
(Fig. 2m). The piston extended and contracted in a already suspended and swimming because it easily
straight line, and it was sometimes bent (Fig. 2n). went out of focus or the observation field. When
The piston retracted into a bulb located at the base compared to the static mode, in the locomotion
632 EZ
F E R N A N D O G OM
FIG. 1. Light micrographs of warnowiid dinoflagellates and their ocelloids. (a and b) Warnowia sp. (b) Note the autofluorescence of
the melanosome. (c) Erythropsidinium sp. with laterally directed ocelloid. (dr) Erythropsidinium agile. (d and e) Lateral rotation of the ocel-
loid. (fj) Right lateral view in differences focuses. (j and r) Note the light concentration by the lenses. (k) Apical view. (l and m) Detail
of the ocelloid. (m) Note the overlapping of the lenses in the hyalosome (or) Ocelloid before and after cell lysis. ci, cingulum; lf, longitu-
dinal flagellum; hy, hyalosome (lenses); me, melanosome (pigment cup); nu, nucleus; oc, ocelloid; pi, piston; su, sulcus; tf, transversal flagel-
lum; scale bars, 20 lm. [Color figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]
mode: (i) the piston immediately retracted after piston during the static and locomotion modes
the extension, and (ii) the piston attained a greater attained 500 and 700 lm long, respectively. A phase
length during the extension. For the same cell, the of extension and contraction lasted for ~120 ms.
O C E L L O I D A N D P I S T O N I N ER YT H R O P S I D I N I U M 633
FIG. 2. Light micrographs of warnowiid dinoflagellates and their body extensions. (a and b) Warnowia sp. with pointed antapex. (c and
d) Proterythropsis. (e) Nematodinium. Note the moveable lateral extension with finger-like projections. (fh, m and n, q) Erythropsidinium scar-
latinum. (il) E. extrudens. (o and p) E. agile. (km) Note the different outline of the distal end of the piston. (l and m) Note the papillae
in the piston surface. (n) Note the bended piston. (o) Note the posterior cavity. (p) The arrow points a slit. (q) Time-lapse sequence of
the piston end attached onto the bottom glass of the settling chamber. be, body extension; ci, cingulum; lf, longitudinal flagellum; nu,
nucleus; oc, ocelloid; pi, piston; st, surface striae; su, sulcus; scale bars, 20 lm. [Color figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]
During that time, the piston was extended for more time in the opposite direction. The balance
~70 ms, the contraction lasted for 16 ms, and it during a phase of contraction and extension was
remained retracted in the posterior cavity for ~1 mm s1. The cell swam usually backwards, but
~30 ms. A piston with a length of 700 lm that also after a stop the same cell was able to reverse
retracted in 16 ms implied an average speed of the direction and swam forwards (Fig. S8 in the
~50 mm s1, and a higher peak speed in the mid- Supporting Information).
dle of the contraction. During the extension phase Feeding behavior and morphology. Erythropsidinium is
of ~70 ms, the cell swam forwards at ~0.5 the unicellular organism with the most elaborate
0.6 mm s1, and during the contraction the cell eye-like organelle, and a piston that is unknown in
jumped backwards at ~3 to 4 mm s1 (Fig. S7 in any other organism. The type of prey and the feed-
the Supporting Information). This was a peculiar ing mechanism may help to understand the adap-
swimming pattern in a straight line. In order to tive advantages of these unique organelles. The
swim in a given direction, the cell was moving for morphology of Erythropsidinium is different from
634 EZ
F E R N A N D O G OM
FIG. 3. Time-lapse sequence of the piston activity of Erythropsidinium. (a) Phases of extension and retraction during the static mode
recorded at 1,500 fps. Only one each five consecutive frames is illustrated. The interval between two micrographs is 3.33 ms (See Fig. S4
for the complete sequence). (b) Several phases of extension and retraction during the locomotion mode recorded at 60 fps. The inter-
val between two micrographs is 16.66 ms (See Fig. S5 for the complete sequence). The lateral size scale corresponds to the stage microme-
ter with divisions each 10 lm. [Color figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]
O C E L L O I D A N D P I S T O N I N ER YT H R O P S I D I N I U M 635
other warnowiid dinoflagellates. Erythropsidinium cf). The hyalosome and melanosome divide inde-
shows a very anterior cingulum in a reduced epi- pendently as two dissociated elements. The concen-
some, and a short longitudinal flagellum (Fig. 2, j tric lenses of the hyalosome decompose and formed
and m). The flagella appear insufficient to propel 810 globular hyaline masses (Fig. 5, e and f). At
the cell, and Erythropsidinium remained motionless this step, cells with an elongated shape and several
in the static mode, moving the piston without sig- hyaline globules in an apical position corresponded
nificant cell swimming (Fig. 3a). In contrast, the to the morphology described as the genus Greueto-
cingulum of other warnowiid dinoflagellates turns dinium A. R. Loeblich (Fig. 5g). The melanosome
several times around the cell and that implied loses the chevron-like shape and develops an elon-
higher propulsion by the transversal flagellum gated ellipsoidal shape (Fig. 5, c and d). The hya-
(Fig. 4, ae). When the other warnowiid dinoflagel- line globules formed a lobulated sac formed of two
lates were not enclosed in a hyaline membrane lots of about six overlapping globules (Fig. 5, h and
(Figs. 1a and 4, a and d), they were actively swim- i). The nucleus migrates to the middle of the cell
ming (Fig. 4, b and c; Video S1). The ocelloid and and develops an elongated shape (Fig. 5, j and k).
nucleus are located in an anterior position in Ery- The cell loses the red coloration in some parts
thropsidinium (Figs. 1, dg; 2, fk; and 4, fq). The and the pigments concentrated into granules
antapex shows a large posterior cavity with a slit (Fig. 5, hk). Five hours later, the cell changes to a
(Figs. 2, o and p; S2). In contrast, other warnowiid globular shape. The cingulum encircles the cell in a
dinoflagellates show a convex antapex, more or less single turn and in a more posterior position than
pointed, and lacked the posterior cavity. The ocel- the non-dividing cell (Fig. 5, l and m). At this stage,
loid is median or posterior and that may interfere only the piston and the red coloration show that
with harboring a large vacuole (Fig. 4, ae). In con- the cell corresponds to Erythropsidinium (Fig. 5m).
trast, the cylindrical shape of Erythropsidinium per- The melanosome divided into two dark masses, and
mits harboring a large vacuole that will not the hyalosome is hardly visible. One hour later,
interfere with the anterior organelles such as the cytokinesis begins with a transversal constriction at
ocelloid that protrude from the cell and the nucleus the middle of the cell body (Fig. 5n). Each daugh-
protected by a perinuclear envelope (Fig. 4, fk). ter cell received a melanosome mass. The hyalo-
Nematodinium and Warnowia show spherical or some is located between the two daughter cells that
ellipsoidal food vacuoles (Fig. 4, ae). The vacuoles still remained joined (Fig. 5, oq). The sulcus is
of Nematodinium show brown pigmentation, evidence already visible in both daughter cells (Fig. 5r). After
of the capture of motile prey such as chain-forming cytokinesis, the daughter cells split (Fig. 5s), while
photosynthetic dinoflagellates (Fig. 4a). The species in other cases they remained joined for a longer
of Warnowia with a median ocelloid also fed on pho- period with the apex of the posterior daughter cell,
tosynthetic dinoflagellates (Fig. 4, b and c). Species attached to the basis of the posterior cavity of the
of Warnowia with a more anterior ocelloid show vac- anterior daughter cell (Fig. 5t). The melanosome
uoles with a hyaline content that may correspond to and hyalosome began to migrate towards the apex,
those of heterotrophic dinoflagellates (Fig. 4, d and and they will assemble to form a new ocelloid in
e). Erythropsidinium shows a large vacuole that occu- each daughter cell (Fig. 5, tv).
pies the hyposome with a lateral hump and it is able The posterior daughter cell keeps the piston from
to engulf large prey items with a diameter greater the parent cell (Fig. 5, o and p), while the anterior
than its cell depth (Fig. 4, fk). The prey was spheri- daughter cell must form a new bulb and piston.
cal (~60 lm in diameter) with thick covering and a The bulb is small, hyaline and internal, and it was
brownish pigmentation. The prey contents were pro- difficult to track its formation in the anterior daugh-
gressively consumed (Fig. 4, j and l), and residual ter cell based on light microscopy. The new piston
matter released through the posterior cavity in a in the anterior daughter cell appeared before the
process that lasted for ten seconds (Fig. 4, mq; cell split and the assembly of the new ocelloids
Video S1). The product of the exocytosis was an (Fig. 5s).
empty copepod egg with the envelope collapsed or
pierced in some areas (Fig. 4r).
DISCUSSION
Cell and ocelloid division. The division of the ocel-
loid began before the cytokinesis, and the ocelloid Speciation and synonymy in Erythropsidinium. The
remained incomplete even after the cytokinesis and unarmored dinoflagellates tend to show a high mor-
separation of the two daughter cells. The mecha- phological plasticity, and the cells often deformed
nism of division is similar among warnowiid genera during observations. This is important to recognize
(Fig. 5). A difference is that Nematodinium and War- because the species richness of the warnowiid
nowia divide inside a hyaline capsule (Fig. 5, a and dinoflagellates is likely overestimated; most species
b) that is absent in Erythropsidinium (Fig. 5, cv). Ery- have been described from a single or a few individu-
thropsidinium develops a more elongated shape and als, often moribund cells (Kofoid and Swezy 1921).
the ocelloid that usually protruded from the cell The genus Erythropsidinium (=Erythropsis) was
surface, begins to migrate to the inner cell (Fig. 5, restricted to the type species E. agile, until Kofoid
636 EZ
F E R N A N D O G OM
FIG. 4. Light micrographs of warnowiid dinoflagellates with food vacuoles. (a) Nematodinium. (b and c) Warnowia with antero-median
ocelloid. Note the brown vacuole. (d and e) Warnowia with posterior-median ocelloid and a vacuole near the melanosome. (fi) Erythropsi-
dinium scarlatinum with an ingested egg. (f) Note the longitudinal striae and deformation. (jq) Another individual during the absorption
and exocytosis of a crustacean egg. (lq) Sequential images of the exocytosis. (r) Empty egg after exocytosis. ci, cingulum; lf, longitudinal
flagellum; nu, nucleus; oc, ocelloid; st, surface striae; su, sulcus; va, vacuole; scale bars, 20 lm. [Color figure can be viewed at wileyonlineli-
brary.com]
and Swezy (1921) transferred into Erythropsis two E. extrudens and E. minus (Kofoid et Swezy) P. C.
species originally described without the piston, Pou- Silva], and the subgenus Polyopsidella for species with
chetia cochlea F. Schutt and P. cornuta F. Schutt, and hyalosome divided in several globules [E. scarlat-
E. agilis sensu Pavillard as E. pavillardii. Kofoid and inum, E. hispidum (Kofoid et Swezy) P. C. Silva,
Swezy also described six new species and since then, E. labrum (Kofoid et Swezy) P. C. Silva and
the number of species of Erythropsidinium has E. richardii (Kofoid et Swezy) P. C. Silva]. The obser-
remained unchanged. Kofoid and Swezy (1921) vations reported here suggest that Kofoid and Swezy
divided the genus into the subgenus Erythropsis for (1921) likely erected a subgenus and new species
species with complete ocelloid [E. agile, E. cochlea for life stages during cell division of erythropsisid
(F. Sch utt) P.C. Silva, E. cornutum (F. Sch utt) P.C. species. The species descriptions of the polyopsidel-
Silva, E. pavillardii (Kofoid et Swezy) P. C. Silva, lid species were based on instable diagnostic
O C E L L O I D A N D P I S T O N I N ER YT H R O P S I D I N I U M 637
FIG. 5. Light micrographs of warnowiid dinoflagellates during the cell division. (a and b) Warnowia with dissociated melanosome and
hyalosome. (b) Two daughter cells of Warnowia sp. (cv). Cells of Erythropsidinium spp. during the division. (c and d) Elongated cells at
the beginning of the cell division. Note the separation of the hyalosome into globules. (g) Greuetodinium with apical globular hyalosome
masses. (hr) Sequential images of a dividing cell. (h and i) Note the separation of the hyalosome and melanosome. (j and k) Note the
perinuclear envelope. (l and m) After five h, the cell acquired a globular shape. (n) After six h, the cell beginning of the cytokinesis. (o
q) Cell after seven h. (r) The two daughter cells after split. (sv) Other recently divided cells. ci, cingulum; hy, hyalosome; me, melano-
some; nu, nucleus; pi, piston; su, sulcus; scale bars, 20 lm. [Color figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]
characters such as the ocelloid morphology of divid- motility with that anomalous lateral propulsion.
ing cells, the cell coloration and the presence or Kofoid and Swezy (1921) also described E. scarlat-
absence of an apical horn, or a distal stylet in the inum with a short, slightly laterally oriented piston
piston. Greuet (1973) considered that all the warno- that possesses pigmented granules. However, the
wiid genera were probably monotypic. Elbrachter piston of Erythropsidinium is a hyaline structure and
(1979) proposed E. pavillardii, E. cornutum, and spe- always directed posteriorly, except in cells with
cies of Polyopsidella (E. hispidum, E. labrum, E. scarlat- duplicated pistons (figs. 1315 in G omez 2008).
inum, E. richardii) as synonyms of E. agile. Kofoid Kofoid and Swezy (1921) possibly mistook the left
and Swezy (1921) illustrated E. extrudens with a later- posterior body extension with the piston. Cells with
ally oriented piston with the same pigmentation of a posterior body extension have been reported from
the cell, and they even speculated on the cell the Pacific Ocean (fig. 16 in G omez 2008), and in
638 EZ
F E R N A N D O G OM
the coasts of Brazil (Fig. 2, fk). These cells with a Hausmann and H ulsmann (2010) reported micro-
body extension constitute a distinct species, graphs of the piston activity with a high-speed cam-
described as E. extrudens or E. scarlatinum. The co- era. They commented that the contraction is about
occurrence of these cells in the same sample, and three times faster than the extension, with no addi-
the intergradation in the position and shape of the tional information. Taylor (1987, p. 136) reported:
body extension suggested that they are morphotypes Erythropsidinium travels extremely quickly and jerkly
of a single species. The original description of in a straight line (5 cm s1). Based on our obser-
E. scarlatinum fits better with the most common vations this speed of 50 mm s1 should be
morphotype. reduced for, at least, one order of magnitude. The
Greuet (1968b) described Greuetodinium (as Leu- piston attained up to 50 mm s1 during the con-
copsis Greuet) for large cells with an elongated cylin- traction phase. However, only a small fraction of the
drical body with an ocelloid dissociated into several piston movement is transmitted for the cell locomo-
hyaline globules in an anterior position. Greueto- tion. Our observations showed that during the con-
dinium was not subsequently reported, with the traction the cell jumped with a peak speed of
exception of Meave del Castillo et al. (2012). Later, 4 mm s1 (Figs. 3b, S7 and S8). However, in the
Greuet (1977) described the life stages during the balance between a phase of extension and retrac-
cell division of Erythropsidinium. He did not realize tion the cell swims at ~1 mm s1. This is due to
that Greuetodinium is probably a life stage during the the peculiar propulsion mechanism, with several for-
division of Erythropsidinium (Fig. 5g). In conclusion, wards steps during the piston extension, and a
Erythropsidinium (=Greuetodinium) is composed of, at quick backwards jump during the contraction
least, three species, E. minus and E. scarlatinum (Figs. 3b, S7 and S8).
(=E. extrudens) and the type species, E. agile with Table 1 summarizes the swimming speed of some
many synonyms. Unfortunately, the speciation dinoflagellates and ciliates. The most typical dinoflag-
cannot be tested by molecular phylogeny because ellates swim in helicoidal trajectories propelled by the
the sequences of Erythropsidinium are restricted to a flagella. Dinoflagellates such as Akashiwo Gert Hansen
single isolate (Gomez et al. 2009). et Moestrup, Prorocentrum Ehrenberg, Scrippsiella
Motility and function of the piston. Erythropsidinium Balech or Lingulodinium D. Wall do not attained
differs from other warnowiid dinoflagellates in the speeds higher than 0.4 mm s1 (Jeong et al. 1999).
piston, and position and the degree of complexity Other red-tide colony-forming species do not
of the ocelloid. The cingulum and the transversal attained speeds higher than 0.85 mm s1 (Table 1).
flagellum are reduced, located in a very anterior During the locomotion mode, Erythropsidinium is
position (Fig. 1, dj) and the longitudinal flagellum faster than most of the dinoflagellates. It is should be
is short (Fig. 2, j and m). In contrast, the cingulum noted that Erythropsidinium swims occasionally, while
of other warnowiid dinoflagellates trace several the red-tide dinoflagellates are active swimmers for
turns around the cell (Fig. 4, ae). This is com- longer periods.
monly associated with higher flagellar propulsion in The cilia-driven propulsion of the ciliates is faster
dinoflagellates (Jeong et al. 1999). The develop- than the bi-flagellated dinoflagellates (Table 1).
ment of the piston may induce the atrophy of flagel- There is a group of ciliates (Tontonia Faure-Fremiet,
lar propulsion. While other warnowiid Pseudotontonia Agatha) that possesses an appendix
dinoflagellates are active swimmers, Erythropsidinium or tail, capable of fast contraction reminiscent of
usually remains motionless, with the piston inactive the piston. Greuet (1967) and Greuet et al. (1986)
or in the static mode (Fig. 3a), and only occasion- investigated ultrastructure of the piston and the
ally swims in the locomotion mode (Fig. 3b). contractile appendix of Tontonia, respectively.
TABLE 1. Swimming peak speed (mm s1) of some dinoflagellates and ciliates.
Erythropsidinium scarlatinum 4* This study Gymnodinium catenatum (4-cell chain) 0.35 Lee et al. (2015)
Erythropsidinium 50 Taylor (1987, p. 136) Polykrikos hartmannii (2 zooids) 0.63 Lee et al. (2015)
Akashiwo sanguinea 0.28 Jeong et al. (1999) Protoperidinium bipes 8.2 Jeong et al. (2004)
Scrippsiella trochoidea 0.34 Jeong et al. (1999) Myrionecta rubra 8 Crawford and
Lindholm (1997)
Cochlodinium polykrikoides 1.45 Jeong et al. (1999) Mesodinium pulex 2.1 Jakobsen (2001)
Cochlodinium polykrikoides 0.39 Sohn et al. (2011) Strobilidium sp. 5.2 Jakobsen (2001)
(single cell)
Cochlodinium polykrikoides 0.85 Sohn et al. (2011) Strobilidium sp. 27 Gemmell et al. (2015)
(8-cell chain)
Alexandrium affine 0.41 Fraga et al. (1989) Tontonia sp. 88 Gemmell et al. (2015)
Gymnodinium catenatum 0.24 Fraga et al. (1989) Pseudotontonia sp. 55 Gemmell et al. (2015)
*Jump during the contraction.
O C E L L O I D A N D P I S T O N I N ER YT H R O P S I D I N I U M 639
Greuet et al. (1986) concluded that organization extracellular digestion in Erythropsidinium. Greuet
structure of both organelles was similar. It is uncer- was perhaps influenced by the contemporaneous lit-
tain whether the dinoflagellate piston and ciliate tail erature and co-workers that showed dinoflagellates
have a common evolutionary origin, or there is only with peduncles to suck the prey contents (Cachon
a morphological convergence. The piston may also and Cachon 1968). In this mechanism of extracellu-
derive from the posterior or lateral appendices lar nutrition known as myzocytosis, the prey is
observed in other warnowiid dinoflagellates (Fig. 2, pierced by means of an extensible, tube-like pedun-
ae). The ciliate Tontonia sp. possesses a tail of cle and the contents are sucked out, including
310 lm that contracts up to 225 mm s1 and the both dissolved and particulate organic substances
cell jumps up to 88 mm s1 (Gemmell et al. (Schnepf and Deichgraber 1984). A thick envelope
2015). It should be noted that the quick jump of protects the crustacean egg, and after engulfing the
the ciliates is restricted to a few ms, enough time to harpoon-like stomopod may be an internal orga-
escape from the aspiration current of the predator. nelle used to perforate the prey cell covering and to
In contrast, the occasional swimming during the lo- inject the lysing substances.
comotion mode of Erythropsidinium may last for This study reveals that the post-digestion residuals
tens of seconds. of prey items are released from the antapex (Fig. 4l;
Predation and the piston. Greuet (1967) considered Video S1). The exocytosis does not take place from
that the piston is exclusively used for locomotion. the intercingular region or the sulcus. It is difficult
However, the piston shows a distal swelling or suc- to assume that Erythropsidinium would develop inde-
tion cup that resembles the tentacular clubs of the pendent structures for ingestion and egestion. Con-
squid, and sometimes including a distal stylet sequently, it can be assumed that the prey was
(Kofoid and Swezy 1921, G omez 2008, figs. 12, 17). ingested though the posterior cavity where the pis-
The suction cup is able to change its shape and ton retracts (Fig. 2o). The observation revealed that
attach to objects or tentatively a prey (Figs. 2q, S3; the piston is able to attach to objects using the dis-
Video S1). The morphological adaptation of the pis- tal suction cup (Fig. 2q). During the retraction, a
ton does not seem to be directly related to the loco- prey attached or pierced by the distal end of the pis-
motion. During most of the time the piston moves ton will be placed into the posterior cavity for
in the static mode, without a net cell swimming engulfing. In the animal world, the suction cup of
(Fig. 3a). These features suggest that locomotion is the piston may act as the chameleon tongue used to
not the exclusive function of the piston. capture insects. Despite the lack of direct observa-
This study documents an intracellular digestion tions, this appears as the most probable mechanism
by Erythropsidinium. It is able to engulf a large prey, for prey capture (Video S1).
of a diameter larger than feeding cell (Fig. 4, fk). The piston activity showed two modes: The loco-
Important organelles as the nucleus and the ocel- motion mode is occasional, while the piston moved
loid are placed in an anterior position, leaving space usually in the static mode without cell swimming,
for the large vacuole. The cylindrical cell shape and except for some cell rotation (Fig. 3a). Conse-
the posterior cavity also facilitates phagocytosis of quently, during most of the time the function of pis-
large prey. The members of the Gymnodinium clade, ton is not locomotion. When a piston is extended
which Erythropsidinium belongs (G omez et al. 2009), 500700 lm in a straight line, it contacts with
are mostly constituted of species with a smooth cell objects located in a sphere of a diameter of 1,000
surface. In contrast, Erythropsidinium possesses a cell 1,400 lm around the cell. This is equivalent to a
surface with longitudinal striae (Fig. 4f) and a per- radar-like beam that scans the surrounding waters.
inuclear envelope (Fig. 2, f and g) that also Consequently, the piston may act as a tactile orga-
occurred in unarmored dinoflagellates that experi- nelle or mechano-receptor for prey search. In fact, I
ence considerable deformation after engulfing large hypothesize that the static mode is a prey search
prey [i.e., Gyrodinium spirale (Bergh) Kofoid et mode.
Swezy]. The longitudinal striae of Erythropsidinium Function of the ocelloid. If the earlier protozoolo-
may help to control cell deformation (Fig. 4f). All gists disbelief of the existence of Erythropsidinium,
these features are adaptations to engulf a large prey further authors have speculated on the function of
in an internal vacuole. Consequently, it is highly the ocelloid (Colley and Nilsson 2016). Omodeo
improbable that Erythropsidinium will have a dupli- (1980, p. 150) reported Nematodinium fires its bat-
cated feeding mechanism and developed additional teries only when the target is at the right direction
structures for an extracellular digestion. and distance. . .. It is interesting to note that Ery-
Based on TEM observations, Greuet (1969) thropsidinium does not catch the prey with the
described a harpoon-like organelle, the stomopod, nematocysts as Nematodinium does but by means of
that he supposed to protrude from the cell and a wounding appendix, the stomopod, which
injected lysing substances in the prey for an extra- injects lysing substances into the prey. Polykrikos
cellular digestion. Greuet never observed the use of shoots nematocysts to narcotize and immobilize the
the stomopod, vacuoles or the engulfing or exocyto- fast-swimming prey before engulfing it in an intra-
sis mechanisms, and then he assumed an cellular digestion (Matsuoka et al. 2000, Lee et al.
640 EZ
F E R N A N D O G OM