Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FVALUATION FORM
Evaluation Form
The objective of evaluating a manuscript (Original research work, Scientific review
paper, Scientific report for engineering and case studies) is to determine its
scientific merit for publication.
Manuscript No:
...................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................
Please give your evaluation (Excellent, very good, good, acceptable or weak)
along with your justifications.
I. SCIENTIFIC CHARM (QUALITY) OF THE WORK
Elements Evaluation
1 Originality of the research work
2 Scientific value and quality of the work
3 Importance of the work and it's contribution to the subject area
Please feel free to justify and comment in the view of the following:
Elements Evaluation
1 Organization and presentation
2 Language, writing style and clarity of the work
3 Compliance to INSTRUCTIONS TO AUTHORS specified by the Journal
Please feel free to justify and comment in the view of the following:
Clarity of the writing style of the presented work.
Relevance of the title and the abstract to the presented work.
Genuity of the methodology, analysis, and discussion.
Adequacy and fitness of the Figures, Tables, Pictures, Maps, etc