Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A CASE REPORT
Craig C Akoh, MD1, Cameron Schick, MD1, Jesse Otero, MD1, Matthew Karam, MD1
ABSTRACT INTRODUCTION
Fat embolism syndrome (FES) is a multi-organ Fat embolism syndrome (FES), first described by
disorder with potentially serious sequelae that is Zenker in 1861, is associated with long bone fractures
commonly seen in the orthopaedic patient popu- and often presents as a constellation of neurological, pul-
lation after femur fractures. The major clinical monary, dermatological, and hematological symptoms.
features of FES include hypoxia, pulmonar y dys- Zenker described the first autopsy case of fat embolism
function, mental status changes, petechiae, tachy- with the presence of pulmonary capillary fat deposition
cardia, fever, thrombocytopenia, and anemia. Due in a patient who suffered from a crush injury1. In 1873,
to technological advances in supportive care and Bergmann described the first clinical case of FES in a
intramedullar y reaming techniques, the incidence patient who suffered a distal femur fracture2. In 1875,
of FES has been reported as low as 0.5 percent. Czerny explored cerebral symptoms associated with
Here, we present a rare case of FES with cerebral FES3. The incidence of FES has been reported to occur
manifestations. A previously healthy 24-year old in 0.5 to11 percent of patients with long bone fractures4.
nonsmoking male was admitted to our hospital Although rare, it is more common at level I trauma cen-
after an unrestrained head-on motor vehicle col- ters where polytrauma patients are often transferred for
lision. The patients injuries included a left olec- specialized care. Mortality from FES has been reported
ranon fracture and closed bilateral comminuted to be as high as 20 percent5. Early diagnosis, high-
midshaft femur fractures. The patient went on to pressure PEEP, and supportive treatment have been the
develop cerebral fat embolism syndrome (CFES) mainstays of treatment6,7.
twelve hours after immediate bilateral intramedul- Multiple theories have been proposed to explain the
lar y nail fixation. His symptoms included unre- pathophysiology of FES. In 1924, Gauss established the
sponsiveness, disconjugate gaze, seizures, respi- mechanical theory, which states that three conditions are
rator y distress, fever, anemia, thrombocytopenia, necessary for the development of fat embolism: injury to
and visual changes. Head computed tomography adipose tissue, rupture of veins within the zone of injury,
and brain magnetic resonance imaging showed and a mechanism that causes the passage of free fat
pathognomonic white-matter punctate lesions and into the open ends of blood vessels8. The biochemical
watershed involvement. With early recognition and theory proposed by Lehman in 1927 stated that plasma
supportive therapy and seizure therapy, the patient mediators mobilize fat from body stores and cause the
went on to have complete resolution of symptoms coalescence of larger droplets. The presence of fat within
without cognitive sequelae. various tissues such as the lungs and the brain initiates
an inflammatory cascade causing injury9.
Major and minor diagnostic criteria for FES were
proposed by Gurd and Wilson [Table 1]. Using their
system, a diagnosis of FES could be made if one major
feature, four minor features, and fat macroglobulinemia
were present10,11. Schonfeld proposed the fat embolism
index (FEI) to aid in diagnosing FES [Table 2]12. A
1
University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics
cumulative score of five or more over the first three
Department of Orthopaedics and Rehabilitation days of hospitalization corresponds with a diagnosis of
Corresponding Author: FES12. Lindeque stated that FES could be diagnosed
Craig C Akoh, MD with respiratory changes alone13. However, given the
Department of Orthopaedics and Rehabilitation
University of Iowa
complex nature of polytrauma patients, it is often dif-
200 Hawkins Drive ficult to accurately diagnose FES as these patients have
Iowa City, IA 52242 multiple injuries and are often intubated upon arrival.
Telephone: 319-356-2595
Craig-Akoh@uiowa.edu
Volume 34 55
C. C. Akoh, C. Schick, J. Otero, M. Karam
Table 1: Gurd and Wilsons major and minor criteria for fat embolism. The presence of one major feature, four minor features, and fat mac-
roglobulinemia is diagnostic for FES11.
Figure 1: Preoperative and post-operative films of the left femur (A) and right femur (B). Both femurs were definitively fixed with Synthes
9mm diameter titanium anterograde intramedullar y nails and locking screws.
Volume 34 57
C. C. Akoh, C. Schick, J. Otero, M. Karam
A B
A B C
Figure 3: Supine AP chest radiograph upon admission showing normal lung fields (A) and inter val diffuse bilateral pulmonar y infiltrates one
hour post-operatively (B).
the patient was weaned off pressure support ventilation Although poorly understood, the pathophysiology of
and was stable on room air. At this time the patient FES can be explained by two theories that originated in
was disoriented but was able to converse. Throughout the 1920s. The mechanical theory proposed by Gauss
the remainder of admission, the patients mental status in 1924 is often associated with traumatic injury and the
continued to improve to a GCS of 15. The patient was release of fat droplets into the circulation from the site of
discharged on HD20 awake and oriented without neu- trauma20. These fat droplets subsequently pass through
rologic deficits to a rehabilitation facility. At the time of the right side of the heart into the lung capillary bed,
discharge the immediate family felt that the patient had causing ventilation-perfusion mismatching and subse-
returned to his baseline cognitive and neurologic status. quent acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS)16.
At his two month follow up, the patient was noted to Recent studies describe the intramedullary pressure in
have a mild decrease in visual acuity without cognitive long bones as being the most decisive pathogenic factor
deficits or seizure activity, and was allowed to return to for developing FES21-23. Further supporting evidence of
work without restrictions. the mechanical theory comes from autopsy studies of
multiply injured patients, post mortem lung intravascular
DISCUSSION fat was shown to be similar in composition to bone mar-
We have presented a case of a young male patient with row fat24,25. The biochemical theory proposed by Lehman
closed bilateral femur fractures that went on to develop in 1927 is thought to be supported by non-traumatic
fat emboli syndrome with cerebral sequelae. FES most FES9. The mobilization and lysis of excess triglycerides
commonly occurs in the second to third decade of life, leads to the incomplete binding to albumin and eventual
12 to 72 hours following traumatic long bone fractures triglyceride entry into the circulatory system. Once
6, 11, 14,15
. Less common non-traumatic causes of FES present within various tissues such as the lungs and
include TKA and THA, soft tissue injury, liposuction, brain, an inflammatory cascade is initiated, causing end
hepatic failure, propofol infusion, burns, acute sickle organ injury26. Additionally, circulating free fatty acids
cell crisis, acute pancreatitis, and altitude sickness16. It is are associated with an increase in acute phase proteins
important to make the distinction between fat embolism and catecholamine release, leading to further increases
and fat embolism syndrome. While fat embolism is a sub- in lipolysis. Various mediators such as catecholamines,
clinical phenomenon that occurs in over 90 percent in free fatty acids, protein degradation products, and C-
patients with traumatic injury, 3 to 4 percent of patients reactive proteins increase the agglutination of chylomi-
with long bone fractures present with clinically relevant crons (normally 1 M) to form fat globules 10 to 40 m
symptoms of FES6. As modern techniques in fracture in diameter26,27.
fixation have improved, the early operative fixation of FES is an entirely clinical diagnosis11. Our patient was
long bone fractures has reduced the incidence of FES diagnosed with FES after fulfilling Gurd and Wilsons
to as low as 0.5 percent4, 15, 17. one major and five minor criteria. These clinical signs
included diffuse tachypnea with lung infiltrates, tachy- by distracting injuries. An animal study suggests that
cardia, pyrexia, sudden anemia, and thrombocytopenia. nitrous oxide-mediated disruption of the blood-brain-
The patient also had a Schonfeld FEI score of 11, well barrier by arterial fat globules leads to transient brain
above the score of five needed for diagnosing FES12. The edema, neutrophil infiltration, and activation of metallo-
most common presentation of FES is hypoxia (96 per- proteases35. Hypoxemia has also been described as being
cent), which often occurs before pulmonary symptoms the cause of developing cerebral embolism syndrome
develop15,31. Pulmonary dysfunction occurs in 75 percent due to pulmonary failure from systemic emboli14. How-
of FES patients, often manifesting as tachypnea, dys- ever, Allardyce et al. found that low oxygen tension levels
pnea, cyanosis, and hypoxemia11. Although hypoxemia did not correlate with the development of cerebral FES4.
has been previously associated with subclinical FES11, This patients management for FES included con-
Talucci indicated that the incidence of critical hypoxemia tinuous vital signs in the SICU, neuro-monitoring, daily
is similar between trauma patient with and without FES32. CBCs, chest radiographs, echocardiogram, CT scan, and
Additionally, Wong found that continuous pulse oximetry serial MRI scans. Initial emergency management of FES
monitoring was able to detect subclinical desaturations includes ruling out other pulmonary and cerebral patholo-
in 100 percent of long bone fractures post-operatively in gies such as pulmonary embolism, pneumonia, vascular
comparison to zero percent with daily arterial blood gas injury of the neck, and meningococcal septicemia36,37. With
monitoring31. Therefore, the authors recommended that any disorder, standard arterial blood gas analysis, com-
subclinical hypoxia, although common after long bone plete blood cell count, coagulation profile, and a search
fracture, should be monitored closely with continuous for petechiae should be obtained33. Chest radiographs
pulse oximetry monitoring for earlier detection. Initial are often non-specific but often show diffusely increased
pulmonar y dysfunction may progress to respirator y pulmonary markings (snow-storm appearance) and right
failure in 10 percent of patients11. Other presenting heart dilatation38,39. Electrocardiogram may show signs
symptoms include mental status changes (59 percent), of right-sided heart strain28. A high-resolution chest CT
petechiae, fever, tachycardia, thrombocytopenia, and scan will show bilateral or centrilobular ground-glass
anemia15. opacities40. Neutral lipid concentration obtained from
Although macroglobulinemia was included in Gurd bronchoalveolar lavage may assist with the diagnosis of
and Wilsons criteria of 1974 included macroglobulinemia FES41. Obtaining a transthoracic echocardiogram may
as a laboratory criterion our patient did not receive this show evidence of an intracardiac shunt, which is present
lab. There has been much debate on its significance in in 20 to 34 percent of the population and may predispose
detecting FES. In Gurd and Wilsons 1970 study, it was a patient to develop CFES28,42. However, a case report by
determined that fat particles from bone marrow larger Eriksson suggested that systemic manifestations of FES
than 8 um in diameter can embolize10. Allardyce et al can occur in the absence of an intracardiac shunt39. A
suggested that larger and more numerous fat globules proposed theory is that an increase in pulmonary arterio-
from peripheral venous and arterial blood samples on venous anastomosis occurs during periods of exercise and
the day of presentation significantly correlated with the hypoxia43, potentially creating a conduit for fat emboli to
development of FES in patients placed in skeletal trac- be systemically released. Head CT is usually negative for
tion. However, these elevated levels are rarely seen after any abnormalities the first one to two days post-injury37,44.
day four4. Nolte disputed the specificity of the presence However in symptomatic patients, multiple hypointense
of large fat globules in diagnosing fat emboli syndrome white matter lesions can arise that typically resolve with
given that large fat globules are often present in asymp- residual subdural effusion and cerebral atrophy44. Brain
tomatic patients with long bone fractures48. Therefore, MRI imaging is the most sensitive imaging technique for
post-mortem fat emboli found in the lungs and brain diagnosing cerebral fat embolism, and will show multiple
must coincide with clinical symptoms of FES29,49. hyperintense nodular or punctate foci on T2 sequences
This patient was diagnosed with CFES after post- as early as four hours after the onset of cerebral fat
operative unresponsiveness and disconjugate gaze. The embolism37,45. These punctate lesions are often confluent
incidence of CFES is 0.9 to 2.2 percent14. Encephalopathy with extension within the white and gray matter of the
is the hallmark for diagnosing cerebral embolism syn- subcortical and watershed regions with extensive cyto-
drome in the setting of pulmonary symptoms33. Diffuse toxic and vasogenic edema46. The pathognomonic starfield
cerebral findings such as headache, irritability, stupor, pattern seen on diffusion-weighted MRI sequences is
convulsions, and coma can also occur. Focal neurologic thought to be caused by cytotoxic edema from multiple
findings are less common and include apraxia, hemiple- microemboli37. Pfeffer showed that a large quantity lesion
gia, scotoma, anisocoria, and conjugate eye deviation33,34. burden on DWI correlated with irreversible brain injury
However, neurologic deficits are rare and are masked and poor long-term clinical outcomes47.
Volume 34 59
C. C. Akoh, C. Schick, J. Otero, M. Karam
Our patient underwent volume resuscitation with with a short reamer, a hollow reamer, and different di-
crystalloid fluids prior to bilateral definitive fixation ameter flexible driver sizes. The study concluded that
within 24 hours of injury. Recommended prevention most of the pressure build-up was dependent on the
and treatment of fat emboli syndrome includes defini- diameter of the flexible driver, with significant pressure
tive fracture management, supportive care, and treat- decreases going from a 9mm to a 7mm diameter driver.
ment of shock6,11. Albumin is recommended for volume Additionally, it was reported that using a 9.5mm hollow
resuscitation to retain blood volume and to bind fatty reamer with a 7mm driver and decreased in vitro pres-
acids to decrease the extent of lung injury7. Although sures by 61 to 66 percent65. In another comparison study,
5% ethyl alcohol, heparin, and hypertonic glucose are Volgas monitored intracardiac fatty emboli with intra-
historically described as treatment options for FES28, operative transesophageal echocardiogram during the
only methylprednisone has limited evidence in the treat- standard sequential reaming technique and compared
ment of FES11,13. A meta-analysis of seven double-blind it with the reamer irrigator-aspirator (RIA) system66.
randomized studies and 389 patients with isolated tibia Results showed that the RIA group had a strong trend
and femur fractures showed that corticosteroids reduced for decreased fatty deposit released during the second
the risk of FES by 78 percent and hypoxia by 61 percent. pass and nail insertion steps. A significantly lower level
However, a closer look at the studies showed that cor- of fatty emboli was also detected in the nail insertion
ticosteroid treatment failed to significantly reduce the step in the RIA group66. Although the data suggest that
incidence of FES51 or hypoxemia12. Additionally, these irrigator-aspiration reaming effectively reduces intramed-
studies are not generalizable to the modern trauma pa- ullary pressures, the significant expense and bulkiness
tient given delayed fracture stabilization51,52, differences of the RIA system precludes its widespread use in the
in fracture severity between treatment groups53, and orthopaedic trauma population. Overall, the techno-
varying diagnostic criteria12,13,51-55. Even more trouble- logical advances in the commonly used reamer systems
some is that none of these randomized controlled trials have allowed for more aggressive fracture fixation with
looked at long-term outcomes after steroid treatment50. reduced risk of systemic extravasation of medullary fat
In regards to fracture stabilization, our patient under- and subsequent development of FES.
went close hemodynamic monitoring during sequential
intramedullary nail placement, over-reaming with a flex- CONCLUSION
ible AO driver, and subsequent placement of bilateral FES is a rare clinical entity that most commonly
9.0mm intramedullary nails. Kuntscher was the first occurs after high-risk orthopaedic injury. The patients
to describe the systemic effects of intramedullary nail- collective risk factors for FES included closed bilateral
ing due to increased intramedullary pressures and fat femur fractures, mild hypoxia, tachypnea, critical hypox-
emboli56. It has been shown that inadequately stabilized emia, and mild tachycardia. Intraoperative risk factors
fractures and delayed operative fixation led to a higher include bilateral intraoperative reaming, intramedullary
incidence of FES32,57. Additionally, a retrospective study nail insertion, and tenuous ventilation associated with
by Pinney found that there was a higher incidence of respiratory acidosis. Preventative measures taken in-
fat embolism syndrome in patients that received de- cluded early fixation, flexible reamers, and narrow size 9
layed definitive intramedullary fixation after ten hours, nails. Prophylactic corticosteroids were not administered
especially in patients with isolated femur fractures58. due to limited clinical evidence in the setting of isolated
Pell found that intraoperative transesophageal echocar- femur fractures and unknown long-term effects. The
diogram showed fat extravasation into the lung vascu- patients eventual development of CFES was marked
lature during reaming59. In Papes 10-year retrospective by unresponsiveness and a disconjugate gaze. Imaging
study, it was reported that early fracture fixation in the showed pathognomonic diffuse hypointense punctate
setting of a chest injury led to a higher incidence of foci and watershed involvement of primarily white mat-
ARDS. Therefore, it was suggested that patients with ter. Given that the foci were not confluent, the patient
chest injuries should undergo unreamed intramedullary is likely to continue to have a good cognitive outcome,
nailing60. Technologic advances such as slow insertion despite having coma and in-hospital delirium prior to re-
of hollow nails, distal venting, narrower reamers, and covery from CFES. In conclusion, our patient developed
reamer irrigator aspirator devices have been developed the rare episode of FES with cerebral manifestations
in an attempt to reduce intramedullary pressures61-63. In after definitive bilateral femur fracture stabilization. The
a 2011 prospective study, Richards found that reamed patient fortunately went on to full cognitive and respi-
intramedullary nails were a moderate risk factor for ratory recovery due to early diagnosis and aggressive
developing cognitive impairment one year post-injury64. supportive therapy.
Mller compared the conventional AO reamer system
Volume 34 61
C. C. Akoh, C. Schick, J. Otero, M. Karam
40. Malagari K. High resolution CT findings in mild 53. Shier MR. Fat embolism prophylaxis: a study of four
pulmonary fat embolism. Chest 2003; 123(4): 1196- treatment modalities. J Trauma 1977; 17(8):621-629.
1201Chan P, Fishman R. Brain edema: induction in 54. Kallenbach J. Low dose corticosteroid prophylaxis
cortical slices by polyunsaturated fatty acids. Science. against fat embolism. J Trauma1987; 27(10):1173-
1978;201:358-360. 1176.
41. Karagiorga G. Biochemical parameters of bronchoal- 55. Alho A. Corticosteorids in patients with a high risk of
veolar lavage fluid in fat embolism. Intensive Care fat embolism syndrome. Surg Gyn Ob 1978; 147:358-
Med. 2006; 32:116-23. 362.
42. Nastanski F. Posttraumatic paradoxical fat embolism 56. Kuntscher G. Medullary nailing in fractures. Arch
to the brain: a case report. J Trauma 2005; 58(2):372-4. F Klin Chir 1940; 200:443-455.
43. Lovering AT. Intrapulmonary shunting and pulmo- 57. Svennisngsen S. Prevention of fat embolism syn-
nary gas exchange during normoxic and hypoxic drome in patients with femoral fractures-immediate
exercise in healthy humans. J Appl Physiol 2008; or delayed operation fixation. Annales chirugiae et
104(5):1418-25. gynaecologiae 1987; 76(3):163-166.
44. Sakamoto T. Computed tomography for diagnosis 58. Pinney SJ. Fat embolism syndrome in isolated
and assessment of cerebral fat embolism. Neurora- femoral fractures: does timing of nailing influence
diology 1983; 24:283-285. incidence? Injury 1998; 29(2):131-3.
45. Takahashi, M. Magnetic Resonance Imaging Find- 59. Pell AC. The detection of fat embolism by trans-
ings in Cerebral Fat Embolism: Correlation with Clini- esophageal echocardiography during reamed intra-
cal Manifestations. J Trauma. 1999; 46(2):324-327. medullary nailing. A study of 24 patients with femoral
46. Bondanapally UK. MR imaging and differentia- and tibial fractures. JBJS Br 1993; 75(6):921-5.
tion of cerebral fat embolism syndrome from diffuse 60. Pape HC. Primary intramedullary femur fixation
axonal injury: application of diffusion tensor imaging. in multiple trauma patients with associated lung
Neuroradiology 2013; 55:771-778. contusion--a cause of posttraumatic ARDS? J Trauma
47. Pfef fer G. Restricted diffusion and poor clinical 1993; 34(4):540-7.
outcome in cerebral fat embolism syndrome. Can J 61. Pape HC. Timing of Fixation of Major Fractures in
Neurol Sci 2010; 37(1):128-30. Blunt Polytrauma: Role of conventional indicators
48. Nolte WJ. Evaluation of the Gurd Test for Fat Em- in clinical decision making. J Orthop Trauma 2005;
bolism. J Bone Joint Surg-Br 1974; B56(3): 417-420. 19(8):551-562.
49. Miller, M. Autopsy Diagnosis of Fat Embolism Syn- 62. Cox, G. Cerebral fat emboli: A trigger of post-opera-
drome. Am J Forensic Med Pathol 2011; 32(3):291- tive delirium. Injury 2011 42:56-510.
299. 63. Mller C. Effect of flexible drive diameter and reamer
50. Bederman SS. Do corticosteroids reduce the risk design on the increase of pressure in the medullary
of fat embolism syndrome in patients with long-bone cavity during reaming. Injury 1993; 24 Suppl 3:40-47.
fractures? A meta-analysis? Can J Surg 2009; 52:386- 64. Richards JE. The association of reamed intramedul-
93. lary nailing and long-term cognitive impairment. JOT
51. Babalis, GA. Prevention of posttraumatic hypoxae- 2011; 25(12):707-713.
mia in isolated lower limb long bone fractures with a 65. Mller C. Effect of flexible drive diameter and reamer
minimal prophylactic dose of corticosteroids. Injury design on the increase of pressure in the medullary
2004; 35:309-317. cavity during reaming. Injury 1993; 24(Suppl 3):S40-
52. Stoltenberg J. The use of methylprednisolone and S47.
hypertonic glucose in the prophylaxis of fat embolism 66. Volgas DA. Fat embolus in femur fractures: a
syndrome. CORR 1979; 173:211-221. comparison of two reaming systems. Injury 2010;
41(Suppl 2):S90-3.