You are on page 1of 8

Australasian Emergency Nursing Journal (2015) 18, 165172

Available online at www.sciencedirect.com

ScienceDirect

journal homepage:www.elsevier.com/locate/aenj

RESEARCH PAPER

Impact of disaster on women in Iran and


implication for emergency nurses
volunteering to provide urgent
humanitarian aid relief: A qualitative study
a
Maryam Nakhaei, PhD
b,c,
Hamid Reza Khankeh, PhD
d
Gholam Reza Masoumi
b
Mohammad Ali Hosseini
e
Zohreh Parsa-Yekta
c
Lisa Kurland
c
Maaret Castren
a
Birjand Health Qualitative Research Center, Birjand University of Medical Sciences, Birjand,
b
Iran University of Social Welfare & Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, Iran
c
Department of Clinical Science and Education, Karolinska Institute, Stockholm,
d
Sweden Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
e
Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran

Received 12 June 2014; received in revised form 7 February 2015; accepted 20 February 2015

KEYWORDS Summary
Background: Men and women are equally affected by disasters, but they experience disaster
Disaster;
Special groups; in different ways.
To provide new knowledge and promote womens involvement in all phases of the disas-ter
Women
management, we decided to capture the perspectives and experiences of the women
themselves; and to explore the conditions affecting Iranian women after recent earthquake
disasters.


Corresponding author at: University of Social welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Koodakyar Alley, Daneshjoo BlV., Evin Street,
Tehran, Iran. Tel.: +98 21 22180160/Department of Clinical Science and Education, Karolinska Institute, Sdersjukhuset (KI SS),
Sjukhusbacken 10, 118 83 Stockholm, Sweden. Tel.: +46 70 408 52 05; fax: +46 8 616 2933.
E-mail addresses: Maryamnakhaee.mn@gmail.com (M. Nakhaei), hamid.khankeh@ki.se (H.R. Khankeh), masoomi-gh@health.gov.ir
(G.R. Masoumi), Mahmaimy@yahoo.com (M.A. Hosseini), ZPARSA@sina.tums.ac.ir, zparsa@tums.ac.ir (Z. Parsa-Yekta),
lisa.kurland@ki.se (L. Kurland), maaret.castren@sodersjukhuset.se (M. Castren).

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.aenj.2015.02.002
1574-6267/ 2015 College of Emergency Nursing Australasia Ltd. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
166 M. Nakhaei et al.

Methods: The study was designed as a qualitative content analysis. Twenty individuals were
selected by purposeful sampling and data collected by in-depth, semi-structured interviews
analysed qualitatively.
Results: Three main themes were evident reflecting womens status after disaster: individual
impacts of disaster, women and family, and women in the community. Participants
experienced the emotional impact of loss, disorganisation of livelihood and challenges due to
physical injuries. Women experienced changes in family function due to separation and
conflicts which created challenges and needed to be managed after the disaster. Their most
urgent request was to be settled in their own permanent home. This motivated the women to
help reconstruction efforts. Conclusions: Clarification of womens need after a disaster can
help to mainstream gender-sensitive approaches in planning response and recovery efforts.
2015 College of Emergency Nursing Australasia Ltd. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights
reserved.

women. Historically, women are responsible for domestic


What is known chores, child rearing and caring for family members. The
social norms may put women in a more exposed and vulner-
Individuals experience disasters in different ways. able position with respect to some life-threatening events and
Disasters can affect womens health directly or also following extreme physical injury, women were less
indirectly, particularly in different settings and juris- cared for and experienced worse situations with respect to
11,1417
dictions where there are different cultural context. It family and social relations. It is important, therefore,
is important to come to understand the effect that to take social gender into account as a reasonable category in
disas-ters have on women and their health at the making up these differences. Womens specific needs dur-ing
individual, community and population level for a disaster in particular, in recovering from a disaster
disaster response and recovery. have been less well researched.
Traditionally, emergency nurses have actively partici-
What this paper adds? pated in disaster relief, in both the response to and recovery
from disaster that have affected health care delivery in local,
18,19
national and international contexts, but funda-mentals
This study provides a thorough understanding of the
that support nurses roles in disasters are not well
perspectives and experiences of the women after a 18
disaster in an Iranian culture. Clarification of understood. Since having a disaster plan and being prepared
womens individual need, womens problems in in the workplace, knowing about it and having practiced, may
family and community after disasters is important for influence in the participants decision to attend work during a
disaster, they need prerequisite knowl-edge in understanding
disaster recovery.
the complexities forced on health of a community during and
1921
after a disaster.
In the context of this paper, what shapes our knowl-
edge about women and disasters is based on studies that
Introduction included gender as a variable that sometimes compared
women to men.2224 Few studies have examined the situ-
Men and women are affected by disaster in different ways. ation of women after disasters, especially in the recovery
The gender differences of perception, experience and phase in Iran.
behaviour of victims who are affected by stressful events Since the roles and responsibilities of women stem from
have been mentioned in several studies. 14 Regard-less of cultural, political and economic conditions, it needs to be
whether men or women are more vulnerable in disastrous understood the perspectives and experiences of women in
events, there are obvious differences between them in each culture. For this study, researchers decided to cap-ture
terms of socio-cultural and bio-psychological factors which womens own accounts to better understand how their
may result from differences in risk factors, man-ifest everyday lives are shaped after a disaster, and to include this
reactions and recovery from traumatic events and knowledge in all phases of the disaster cycle. The aim of this
disasters.1,2,58 paper therefore is to explore this relatively unstudied area,
Women are often portrayed as the passive victims of i.e., the status of Iranian women following disaster.
disasters, although this may not necessarily be true. 9,10
Disasters can affect womens health directly or indirectly
through socio-economic deprivation by destruction of
homes and businesses, and loss of employment
Method
opportunities, which also affects men. Some reports
indicate gender igno-rance and violation of womens rights This study was conducted to understand what happened
in the aftermath of disasters.3,1113 to women after disasters and how they experienced it.
In Iran as in other countries, there are differences in
Therefore a qualitative study design incorporating content
activities, interest and social expectations between men and
analysis, which is a suitable method when new areas are
to
Impact of disaster on women in Iran 167

be investigated in an explorative manner or if the area needs care and individual needs. Interviews were guided by main
to be explored from a new perspective,
25,26
was selected. researcher, but each of them was checked and evaluated
for interview trend and subjects which need to be probed
by research team.
Recruitment
The interviews lasted between 45 and 60 min. Time and
place of interviews were determined by mutual agreement.
In qualitative studies, research is designed on key infor-
mants based on their experience; accordingly in this study,
participants were selected among those who were able to Data management and analysis
communicate with the interviewer, had been affected by
disasters, and had experience of receiving or providing All interviews were transcribed verbatim and compared with
health services in disasters, by purposeful sampling.26 the original audio-recorded digital files for accuracy. Data
28
As a first step, women who have experienced of receiving were analysed using qualitative (latent) content analysis.
health services in disasters were selected. In continue other The analysis started by identifying units of meaning that were
participants were chosen based on the needs of the study. essential to the participants experiences and were extracted
from the statements/transcript. The codes were compared
based on differences and similarities and sorted into
Study participants
categories and subcategories that were discussed within the
research team; appropriate themes were then extracted from
Study participants were 20 individuals (16 women and 4 28
the data.
men) who had experienced disastrous events in Iran (Bam,
Zarand, Lorestan and the 2012 earthquake in Azerbaijan).
The par-ticipants ranged from 22 to 55 years of age with Data trustworthiness
three types of disaster experience (Table 1). In this study,
a rich picture of the topic and saturated emerged concepts Credibility was established through field notes and memos,
is constructed based on the contributions of a range of prolonged engagement with the participants, and revisions by
participants; for example, data were collected from male the participants using member check and peer check. The use
participants to develop concepts (sub concepts) related to of a wide range of informants (male/female and in different
family and com-munity situations. Looking through the health positions) is one way of triangulating via data sources
eyes of men can add further insight into women and 25
that can help trustworthiness. Triangula-tion of researchers
disaster thereby providing a more comprehensive in the research team helped to take into account different
understanding of this important issue. The sample size was perspectives when analysing the data. The findings and
determined by saturation,26 that the researchers interpretations of the study were reviewed by the research
concluded that collected data were repeated, new codes team as an expert revision. Maximum variation of sampling
were not developed or existing codes were not extended. 27
established the credibility of the data. As an additional
control for validity, a peer check on a sample of transcripts
Data collection method was made by two faculty members who were not part of the
research team. In addition, to confirm the fitness of the
results, they were checked by a panel of experts in the field
In-depth, semi-structured interviews were used for data
26,27
of health and rehabilitation who did not participate in the
collection. Each interview individually organised but research.
usually began with an open question, e.g. Tell me about
what happened to you after the incident? What did you feel?
What did it mean to you? or Could you explain your expe- Ethical considerations
riences with respect to the health care after the incident?
What did you need? How were the needs met? Complemen- The study received ethics approval from Birjand Health
tary probing questions were added when needed and could Qualitative Research Center (BHQRC), Birjand University
relate to prior experiences of disaster, perceptions of health of Medical Sciences (BUMS) in Iran.
The aim and process of the study were explained
verbally and in writing to the participants, after which
Table 1 Number and positions of participants. they gave written or verbal testament of informed consent
for partic-ipation in the study. Participants were informed
Code Position of participants in Number that they could decline participation at any time during
experience of incident (women/men) the study. Data collection, interview recordings and
1 Health disaster manager or 3/1 presenting were given confidentially and made anonymous
specialist by using code numbers.
2 Health care provider (nurse, 4/1
social worker) Results
3 Health service receiver 9/2
(victim, resident in disaster
A total of 20 interviews were held between 2010 and 2012.
area)
Three main themes were identified: (i) the impact of the
Total 16/4
disaster on an individual level; (ii) women and the family; and
(iii) women in the community. Each theme is introduced,
168 M. Nakhaei et al.

described and supported by findings from the content responsibilities in the family. They attempted to manage
anal-ysis of the transcribed interviews. their family even in tents or other temporary quarters.
Poor facilities and exposure made these efforts exhaust-
Individual impact of disaster ing. Inadequate facilities for everyday duties increased
their suffering. Participant #13, a mother indicated:
Women who participated in this study indicated that the
Everything was miserable whatever I say I cant
loss of family members, and especially their children, was
express our situation. . .Living in tents was too hard
the most stressful experience after a disaster. In all
no facilities, no bathroom, hot water or shower.
phases after disastrous events, especially during the
Every-thing was a problem; even doing simple
rescue phase, women worry about their children. Even if
household work was difficult. . .
women are them-selves physically injured or have other
personal problems, they prioritise finding and evacuating Moreover, reproductive health, sanitary napkins and
their own children above their own welfare. pregnant womens needs were not sufficiently provided
Individual experiences were categorised according to for. The lack of sanitation, health services and privacy in
three concepts: emotional impact of loss, livelihood prob- tem-porary facilities hindered reproductive health.
lems, and physical injuries and care needs. Reproductive health care services, including prenatal
care, delivery, and emergency obstetric care, were often
Emotional impact of loss unavailable. This made young people more vulnerable.
Immediately after the incident, women were in shock Women had no access to family planning services,
from the magnitude of the event, their injuries, and exposing them to unwanted pregnancies under
witnessing injury/death. Victims tried to find and disadvantageous or even perilous con-ditions. For example
evacuate their family members despite the lack of either a pregnant woman in disaster area (participant #16) said:
a plan or support service. They did not pay attention to
their own physical injuries but tried to save their loved After my twins, I became pregnant with my third child.
ones. Sometimes these reactions worsened their injuries. When the disaster occurred, I sometimes had to ask my
Dead bodies were accumulated in the city and this was neighbors to watch my children. . .I couldnt mobilize any
a grievous scene. People wanted to bury their loved ones energy; one time in the tent when I moved supplies, I fell
as soon as possible and they were emotionally affected by down but nothing bad happened, thank God. . .
this horrible scene. As one mother (participant #14), a
spinal cord injury victim recalled:
Physical injuries and care needs
My child was in my arms. I held him but I couldnt Physically injured women had need of health care which
save his life. . .. My back had been injured but I tried could only be provided in tents and temporary residences.
to save him but I couldnt, I couldnt move, except Some of the injured women were dependent on their chil-
with my hands to move the bricks, then suddenly I felt dren and husband to accomplish their household duties.
a sharp pain in my back. . . This made them uncomfortable especially when this
Participants believed there were widespread problems affected their personal hygiene.
among women which were not fully considered. These A spinal cord injured (Participant #10) recalled:
were the feelings of loneliness and fear of the future.
Emotional effects continued with assimilation and I had my husband, but my mother was dead, also my
memories of loved ones long after the disaster. A mother sister and her children. I lost my brother and his wife.
who residence in disaster affected (participant #17) said: Only my husband helped me. . . sometimes I couldnt
ask him to do some things. It was embarrassing, and
Personally I do not like it; I really do not want to par- some-times I was ashamed. . .
ticipate in the wedding, even though it is my brothers
ceremony. If I go, Id rather sit and watch the others. . . Because of their physical condition, they needed more
tears come to my eyes when I remember who should be health care and medical equipment which the family
there but will not be at the ceremony. some-times could not afford. In many cases, women
received improper care and there were some adverse
Livelihood problems consequences such as bed sores and even in some cases
There is a strong belief in Iranian culture that women are women became completely immobilised.
a symbol of stability; according to the participants, they The caring problems for family members obligated
always support the other members of their family. As par- them to put some of the physically injured women in
ticipant #19, a victim with amputated leg, expressed:
nursing cen-tres. Since the governmental centres were not
My mother worked too hard for me. My mother was completely equipped to admit and provide high quality
responsible for everything, especially at first I could
not even do my daily living activities. . . My mother did
health care for this group, they had to go to the nursing
everything, not only for me but also for my dad and centres and come-back to their tents. This long, exhausting
my sisters. process increased the suffering of the family and caused
Despite what happened after the incident and physi-cal the injured women to feel guilt, in part, inflicted by their
and emotional injuries, women had to continue their own family mem-bers. Moreover, the centres were often
far from the family dwelling, which could emotionally
affect them negatively, as participant #14 expressed:
Impact of disaster on women in Iran 169

After I was injured, I lost everything and I had to go Earlier I came here just for fun. After a while, I learned
to the nursing center for a year, because there was no useful and practical things. I found good friends; although
bathroom in the tents and our house was ruined. . ., four years have passed, we are still friends. . .
there was nobody with me, no mother, and no sister. I we are very happy when we see each other. They
was away one year from my home and my life. . .In helped me very much.
nursing center they tried to do their best but there is
no place better than home. On the other hand, some participants mentioned that
the community had a negative attitude towards the
victims, especially those physically injured. For example,
Women and the family
unaffected people could consider the disability of the
injured victims as a punishment. As participant #18
After disaster strikes, multiple changes happen that affect (Victim with amputated leg) expressed:
all aspects of family functioning. Culturally, because of
the important role of women as the centre of the family, I think this disability is not our main concern.
their situation can endanger family cohesiveness. Family Acquaintances, family, clan or tribe are more annoying.
separation could occur due to death, hospitalisation and . .Peoples view of disabilities is really bad. . . for
psy-chological impacts. For example a victim with spinal example, we hear families asking why their kids were
cord injury (participant #11) stated: disabled in the earthquake but our children werent
When I was injured I was very upset, I didnt like to even injured.
see my husband at all. . . When my husband came
Furthermore, improper public constructs caused limita-
home, I said, Get out! What do you want here?. . . I
tions in social and also family activities, which could result
hated him.
in extended social isolation.
Marital conflicts
Family conflicts occurred due to couples emotional break- Compensatory activation
down, addiction or remarriage. Because of the central role of Reconstruction was often delayed due to administra-tive
women in the family, physical injuries to them can create bureaucracy and the lack of organisational planning. Because
problems for the whole family. The results in this sample of difficult living conditions in tents or temporary housing,
showed that men felt ashamed of their wives disability, the womens most urgent request was to be settled in their
especially permanent disabilities such as spinal cord injury. own permanent home. This all encouraged women to help
Consequently, husbands with disabled wives, and who other family members in the reconstruction process such as
wanted to keep their children for themselves, often giving aid and offering loans, and so on.
became interested in remarriage. But among the women, Participants indicated that after the event, women
remarriage created a feeling of lack of support and con-sidered more job opportunities. Participants stated
belonging. These conflicts led to family disintegration and that their employment, resulting in earning their own
the formation of new family structures accompanied by income, helped them to gain independence and
new expectations and relationships: confidence in their future.
Participant #15, a 62 years woman had lost her children Participant# 13 said:
in disaster said:
When I came to work my mood improved . . . Paid work
Now my husband remarried to have his own children. . . made me financially independent, it helped me so
At home I have a great sorrow because of the co-wife and much. I could stand on my own two feet. . .
my husbands behavior. I just come to work and finish the
day . . . I want to have a home for myself to be indepen-
dent, I like to have a party, I want to have a peaceful life Discussion
and be happy without any conflicts.
Womens ability to recover after disasters depends to a great
Iranian women have a pivotal role in the family, so
extent on how well disaster planners and health providers
according to the participants, their physical and emotional 2932
well-being has more impact on the children than does the take womens concerns into account. Therefore there is
father of the family. a need for a thorough understanding of the post-disaster
situation of women in each culture. The goal of this study was
to capture and systematise the experiences of women, to
Women in the community understand their situation after disasters. It can help health
care providers especially nurses with a more longitu-dinal
In this theme, there are two categories: community perspective of their role beyond the clinical
18
to plan
behaviour and compensatory activation. response and recovery efforts to ensure that their needs are
adequately addressed. Having an opportunity for emer-gency
Community behaviour nurses, who will be on the frontlines of any disaster response,
Study participants indicated that women who participated are well situated to reassure women health care in disaster
in peer groups achieved positive experiences such as peer situations therefore understanding the complexities of women
learning, satisfaction and establishing social networks. For disaster relief can help to respond effectively and contribute
31,33,34
example participant #17 recalled: to the specific needs of survivors is critical.
170 M. Nakhaei et al.

The results of this study show, in spite of the harsh the separation of women from the family increased the
post-disaster conditions, women have the potential to risk for mental health problems.13
help not only themselves but also other family members. This study indicated that family separation could result in
The key elements explored in this study were the hospitalisation, death, and psychological problems. Injury or
impact of disaster on women and their efforts to separation of women from their family can endanger the
overcome them. Three main themes became evident in family union, since, as is widely suggested, it is the women
the current study; individual impacts of disaster, women 11,43,44
who hold their families together after a disaster.
and the family, and women in the community. Results showed that husbands felt ashamed of their
Individual impacts caused by disaster consisted of wives injuries and disabilities, especially permanent dis-
emotional effects, disorganised livelihood situations and abilities such as spinal cord injury. As a consequence,
challenges due to physical injuries. In the acute medical ignorance and lack of knowledge concerning the physical
response and evacuation phase, women do not escape the injury, its limitations and their wives limited capabilities
emotional impacts of health and security for children or that caused adverse effects on the relationship. This could lead
1,7,1113
of losing their property or belongings. According to to separation, divorce and remarriage. The reverse situa-
the literature, gender differences undoubtedly persist in the tion (when men were injured or disabled) was not
1,2,58 observed; wives did not leave their husbands. Marital
possible reactions to traumatic events. Although
diagnostic criteria of psychiatric disorders are beyond the conflicts led to women feeling a lack of support from their
scope of this paper, the results show that women tended to husbands and a lack of the sense of belonging.
show more emotion-based behaviours immediately after the Other studies have shown that disasters affect the mar-ital
incident and could not perform rationally. 4548
and other relationships in different ways. In the
Participants exhibited consequences of both short- and aftermath of a disaster, family consultation and commu-
long-term psychological illness that needed to be addressed. nication skills must be considered in the rehabilitation
According to the results, survivors presented a lack of help- services. The interventions that are recommended in other
seeking behaviours to resolve these conditions. Other studies studies
4851
should be considered as possible means to
have also described predictors of outcomes and dropout enhance family functions in order to better promote health.
3538
which may be affected by gender differences. It is Participants were unsatisfied with the lack of social
imperative, therefore, to provide psychological reha-bilitative acceptance (social sympathy) towards victims. Social iso-
care and local counselling, especially as part of the acute lation and limitation of mobility were expressed as part of
medical response in addition to active screening and incentive the public construct, especially for spinal cord injuries.
strategies. Since emergency nurses are usu-ally involved early Since social structure and peer group network formation
in disaster management, and are highly skilled, they could are important in social integration,5254 eliminating these
play a greater role in providing compre-hensive care that social and physical barriers must be considered.
involved psychological and well as physical support. By The results of this study showed that survivors tried to
expanding the emergency nurses role they would be better rebuild their homes and acquire economic stability, as
able to provide and support comprehensive disas-ter vital prerequisites for sustained and holistic
18
management and rehabilitation care for women. recovery.53,55,56 The role of women in aiding (to activate
The results indicate that living in camps with unsafe or accelerate) the reconstruction process helped women
con-ditions, lack of privacy, without supplies and facilities to be empowered, become familiar with social processes
for bathing and cooking and without the possibility of and establish a pres-ence in the community. As the
maintain-ing other care giving responsibilities and participants mentioned, women who are employed are
mothering tasks added to womens workload. There was independent and productive. Recovery and rehabilitation
an inadequate pro-vision of reproductive health care and
programmes should therefore include opportunities for
supplies necessary for hygiene. 11,23 These shortages are
women to participate and be empowered.43,44
also documented in other disasters 12,29,39 have been shown While the notion of a disaster health place progressing in
to affect womens mental and general health, 13,30 which terms of the programmes, the women issues although under
nurses may need prepared-ness to provide care in extreme developed, and there is a need to simultaneously strengthen
conditions when resources may be scarce.31 both the theory and practice of gender approach in disasters.
Since family members played an important role in help-ing Since womens health care is always an impor-tant element of
patient care, physical injuries imposed an excessive workload. nursing mission, exploration of womens experiences should
In line with other studies, participants mentioned problems in enhance emergency nurses awareness of the realities of
the limited accessibility and cost of medi-cal care which service delivering before, during and after disaster and the
11,13,16,40
hindered their seeking/acquiring medical care. The application them in preparedness planning.
adverse consequences were permanent or longstanding
11,17,4042
disability and an impaired recovery.
Increasing physical demands and the inability of family
members to cope with the workload and conditions forced Limitations
them to take some of the injured women to nursing centres.
Being admitted to these centres, however, had paradox-ical Because of unpredictable nature of disasters, the partici-
effects. It drew women away from the family, thus disrupting
pants in the study have experience in different time span
family unity. On the other hand, it provided the opportunity
for peer group network building and peer learn-ing. In other and different recall ability, but in this study researchers
contexts such as those observed in Pakistan, focused to capture their deep experience. Additionally,
although generalisation is not within the scope of the
qualitative
Impact of disaster on women in Iran 171

studies, findings should be interpreted cautiously because 4. Soffer Y, Goldberg A, Adini B, Cohen R, Ben-Ezra M, Palgi Y,
of different characteristics of contexts. et al. The relationship between demographic/educational
parame-ters and perceptions, knowledge and earthquake
mitigation in Israel. Disasters 2011;35(January (1)):3644.
Conclusion 5. Brewin CR, Andrews B, Valentine JD. Meta-analysis of risk fac-
tors for posttraumatic stress disorder in trauma-exposed
In short, this study explored womens needs and experi- adults. J Consult Clin Psychol 2000;68(October (5)):74866.
ences after disaster at the individual, familial and societal 6. Tolin DF, Foa EB. Sex differences in trauma and posttraumatic
levels. Clarification of womens need after a disaster can stress disorder: a quantitative review of 25 years of research.
help to mainstream gender-sensitive approaches in plan- Psychol Bull 2006;132(November (6)):95992.
7. Blain LM, Galovski TE, Robinson T. Gender differences in
ning response and recovery efforts. It can also make for
recovery from posttraumatic stress disorder: a critical review.
better resource allocation and more accurate service pro- Aggress Violent Behav 2010;15(NovemberDecember
vision to ensure that the needs of women and girls are (6)):46374.
adequately addressed. Because womens lives after disas- 8. Brown JS, Cherry KE, Marks LD, Jackson EM, Volaufova J,
ter were the main concern of this study and because this is Lefante C, et al. After Hurricanes Katrina and Rita: gen-der
a process; the researchers strongly recommend further differences in health and religiosity in middle-aged and older
investigation to explore the process by means of a adults. Health Care Women Int 2010;31(November (11)):997
grounded theory approach. 1012.
9. Giorgadze T, Maisuradze I, Giorgadze S, Utiashvili Z, Abesadze
G. Mainstreaming gender in disaster. Georgian Med News
Authors contributions 2012;208/209(July):3841 [review].
10. Eklund L, Tellier S. Gender and international crisis response:
MN & HRKh conceived the study, designed and obtained do we have the data, and does it matter? Disasters
data. GhRM assisted in the conduct of the study and data 2012;36(October (4)):589608.
11. Khankeh H, Nakhaei M, Masoumi G, Hosseini M, Parsa-Yekta Z,
collection. MAH & ZPY participated in data collection and
Kurland L, et al. Life recovery after disasters: a qualitative study
analysis. LK & MC provided advices on analysis and revised in the Iranian context. Prehosp Disaster Med 2013;28(6):5739.
the manuscript. All authors participated in data analysis 12. Nour NN. Maternal health considerations during disaster
and interpretation. MN drafted the manuscript and all relief. Rev Obstet Gynecol 2011;4(1):227.
authors contributed to its revision. All authors take 13. Anwar J, Mpofu E, Matthews LR, Shadoul AF, Brock KE. Repro-
responsibility for the paper as a whole. ductive health and access to healthcare facilities: risk factors
for depression and anxiety in women with an earthquake
expe-rience. BMC Public Health 2011;11(June):523.
Provenance and conflict of interest 14. Parvizy S, Kiani K, Ivbijaro G. Womens health bridges and
barriers: a qualitative study. Health Care Women Int
The authors declare that they have no competing interests. 2013;34(3/4):193208.
This paper was not commissioned. 15. Kumar A, Khan ME. Health status of women in India:
evidences from National Family Health Survey-3 (200506)
and future out-look. Res Pract Soc Sci 2010;6(2):121.
Funding 16. Raissi GR. Earthquakes and rehabilitation needs: experiences
from Bam, Iran. J Spinal Cord Med 2007;30(4):36972.
The authors declare that they have no funding. 17. Tauqir SF, Mirza S, Gul S, Ghaffar H, Zafar A. Complications in
patients with spinal cord injuries sustained in an earthquake
in Northern Pakistan. J Spinal Cord Med 2007;30(4):3737.
Acknowledgments 18. Ranse J, Lenson S. Beyond a clinical role: nurses were
psychoso-cial supporters, coordinators and problem solvers in
The authors wish to thank all participants for their support the Black Saturday and Victorian bushfires in 2009. Australas
Emerg Nurs J 2012;15(3):15663.
and involvement in this study. We express our deep appre-
19. Hammad KS, Arbon P, Gebbie K, Hutton A. Nursing in the emer-
ciation to the people in recently earthquake affected
gency department (ED) during a disaster: a review of the current
areas including Bam, Zarand, Lorestan and Azerbaijan for literature. Australas Emerg Nurs J 2012;15(4):23544.
their contributions to this study. 20. Arbon P, Cusack L, Ranse J, Shaban RZ, Considine J, Kako M, et
al. Exploring staff willingness to attend work during a disas-ter: a
References study of nurses employed in four Australian emergency
departments. Australas Emerg Nurs J 2013;16(3):1039.
21. Parker N. Nursing in disaster events. Australas Emerg Nurs J
1. Norris FH, Friedman MJ, Watson PJ, Byrne CM, Diaz E, Kaniasty K.
2013;16(1):12.
60,000 disaster victims speak: Part I. An empirical review of the
22. Montazeri A, Baradaran H, Omidvari S, Azin SA, Ebadi M, Gar-
empirical literature, 19812001. Psychiatry 2002;65(Fall
maroudi G, et al. Psychological distress among Bam
(3)):20739. earthquake survivors in Iran: a population-based study. BMC
2. Norris FH, Perilla JL, Ibanez GE, Murphy AD. Sex differences Public Health 2005;5(January):4.
in symptoms of posttraumatic stress: does culture play a role? 23. Motamedi HMK, Saghafinia M, Bafarani AH, Panahi F. A reassess-
J Trauma Stress 2001;14(1):728. ment and review of the Bam earthquake five years onward: what
3. World Health Organization (WHO), Department of Gen-der
was done wrong? Prehosp Disaster Med 2009;24(5):45360.
and Womens Health. Gender and health in disas-ters.
24. Raissi GR, Mokhtari A, Mansouri K. Reports from spinal cord injury
Geneva: WHO; 2002 http://www.who.int/gender/other
patients: eight months after the 2003 earthquake in Bam, Iran.
health/en/genderdisasters.pdf [accessed 25.02.11].
Am J Phys Med Rehabil 2007;86(November (11)):9127.
172 M. Nakhaei et al.

25. Strauss A, Corbin J. Basics of qualitative research. 3rd ed. 41. Rathore FA, Farooq F, Muzammil S, New PW, Ahmad N, Haig
Sage Publishing Inc.; 2008. AJ. Spinal cord injury management and rehabilitation:
26. Polit DF, Beck CT. Nursing research principles & methods. 7th highlights and shortcomings from the 2005 earthquake in
ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2007. Pakistan. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2008;89(March (3)):57985.
27. Streubert HJ, Carpenter DR. Qualitative research in nursing. 42. Gosney Jr JE. Physical medicine and rehabilitation: critical
4th ed. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2007. role in disaster response. Disaster Med Public Health Prep
28. Graneheim UH, Lundman B. Qualitative content analysis in 2010;4(June (2)):1102.
nursing research: concepts, procedures and measures to 43. Enarson E, Fohtergill A, Peek L. Gender and disaster: foun-
achieve trustworthiness. Nurse Educ Today 2004;24(February dations and directions. In: Rodrguez H, Quarantelli EL, Dynes
(2)):10512. RR, editors. Handbook of disaster research. New York:
29. Bloem CM, Miller AC. Disasters and womens health: reflec- Springer Science+Business Media, LLC; 2007. p. 13046.
tions from the 2010 earthquake in Haiti. Prehosp Disaster 44. Thurairajah N, Baldry D. Womens empowerment in post
Med 2013;28(April (2)):1504. disas-ter reconstruction: perspectives on policies and
30. Miller AC, Arquilla B. Disasters, womens health, and frameworks. Int J Strateg Prop Manag 2010;14:34761.
conserva-tive society: working in Pakistan with the Turkish 45. Irshad H, Mumtaz Z, Levay A. Long-term gendered
Red Crescent following the South Asian Earthquake. Prehosp consequences of permanent disabilities caused by the 2005
Disaster Med 2007;22(JulyAugust (4)):26973. Pakistan earth-quake. Disasters 2012;36(July (3)):45264.
31. Association of Womens Health, Obstetric & Neonatal Nursing. 46. Chan KL, Zhang Y. Female victimization and intimate partner
The role of the nurse in emergency prepared-ness. J Obstet violence after the May 12, 2008, Sichuan earthquake.
Gynecol Neonatal Nurs 2012;41(March (2)): 3224. Violence Vict 2011;26(3):36476.
47. Lowe SR, Rhodes JE, Scoglio AA. Changes in marital and partner
32. Sohrabizadeh S, Tourani S, Khankeh HR. The gender analysis relationships in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina: an analysis
tools applied in natural disasters management: a systematic with low-income women. Psychol Women Q 2012;36(September
literature review. PLoS Curr 2014;6(March). (3)):286300.
33. Usher K, Redman-MacLaren ML, Mills J, West C, Casella E, 48. Cao X, Jiang X, Li X, Hui Lo MC, Li R. Family functioning and
Hapsari ED, et al. Strengthening and preparing: enhancing its predictors among disaster bereaved individuals in China:
nursing research for disaster management. Nurse Educ Pract eighteen months after the Wenchuan Earthquake. PLOS ONE
2014;(March). pii:S1471-5953(14)00041-9. 2013;8(4):e60738.
34. Hughes F, Grigg M, Fritsch K, Calder S. Psychosocial response 49. Ekanayake S, Prince M, Sumathipala A, Siribaddana S, Morgan C.
in emergency situations the nurses role. Int Nurs Rev We lost all we had in a second: coping with grief and loss after
2007;54(March (1)):1927. a natural disaster. World Psychiatry 2013;12(February
35. Tarrier N, Sommerfield C, Pilgrim H, Faragher B. Factors (1)):6975.
associated with outcome of cognitive-behavioural treatment 50. Hackbarth M, Pavkov T, Wetchler J, Flannery M. Natural disas-
of chronic post-traumatic stress disorder. Behav Res Ther ters: an assessment of family resiliency following Hurricane
2000;38(February (2)):191202. Katrina. J Marital Fam Ther 2012;38(April (2)):34051.
36. Karatzias A, Power K, McGoldrick T, Brown K, Buchanan R, 51. Hu XL, Li XL, Jiang XL, Li R, Dou XM. Family function and
Sharp D, et al. Predicting treatment outcome on three depression in relatives of earthquake victims: a survey con-
measures for post-traumatic stress disorder. Eur Arch ducted one year after Chinas Wenchuan Earthquake. Hu Li Za
Psychiatry Clin Neu-rosci 2007;257(February (1)):406. Zhi 2012;59(October (5)):5767 [in Chinese].
37. Sijbrandij M, Olff M, Reitsma JB, Carlier IV, de Vries MH, Gersons 52. Solomon P. Peer support/peer provided services: underlying
BP. Treatment of acute posttraumatic stress disorder with brief pro-cesses, benefits and critical ingredients. Psychiatr
cognitive behavioral therapy: a randomized controlled trial. Am J Rehabil J 2004;27(Spring (4)):392401.
Psychiatry 2007;164(January (1)):8290. 53. Pratt CW, Gill KJ, Barrett NM, Roberts MM. Psychiatric
38. Felmingham KL, Bryant RA. Gender differences in the rehabil-itation. 2nd ed. Oxford, UK: Elsevier Inc.; 2007.
maintenance of response to cognitive behavior therapy for post- 54. Hu X, Zhang X, Gosney JE, Reinhardt JD, Chen S, Jin H, et al.
traumatic stress disorder. J Consult Clin Psychol 2012;80(April Analysis of functional status, quality of life and community
(2)):196200. integration in earthquake survivors with spinal cord injury at
39. Silverstein LM. Guidelines for gender-sensitive disaster hospital discharge and one-year follow-up in the community.
manage-ment by Asia Pacific Forum on Women, Law and J Rehabil Med 2012;44(March (3)):2005.
Development: a revolutionary document. Reprod Health 55. Eadie C. Holistic disaster recovery: ideas for building local
Matters 2008;16(May (31)):1538. sustainability after a natural disaster. Darby, PA, USA: Diane
40. Priebe MM. Spinal cord injuries as a result of earth-quakes: Publishing Co.; 2001.
lessons from Iran and Pakistan. J Spinal Cord Med 56. Phillips BD. Disaster recovery. NW, USA: Taylor & Francis
2007;30(4):3678. Group; 2009.

You might also like