Professional Documents
Culture Documents
.
...
:
! " #$ %& #' %(
) *
+ ,
*-
.
'
.*/0 123
! 4/ 5
' # *'
*06 78
+ *0) *9 . :
'
! ;' *9
+ #'
< *06 5
0 => 5
3
+? #-
@ ,' /
< 0 ;0) > #' :
' #' *0)
&,
*
+ + * #A */@
B&' , #$ . '
!? C
! " *' * B&' - ;> #'
&< # *0)
! 5
!3
+? 4' D
3
6
6? *'>
6
*!06 %(
!) *9 # #'
6
E / *
C6 C@ %96 *0
5
! I!0 5
!6? B(
!' . => *
&' #@ (*
+ G *$ G *')
#!3 */0 *" 5 # *(
&' B(
' J96
&96 #
?
! =! !+ $
!3K
&@ &)
& , # *
+ *0)
.#' &+ /0 *+ #> < *' *
+
:
*M L'
*
+ L'
*' L'
*0) *
+
1
$ % & # ! "
.
$ % & # ( ! "
' . 2
:
5?
! #!@ " #> '
'0 *090
+ *0) *9 5N-
.
O *+ *3A
#'
&0 C
5
+
&,
5
>? ' #@ &A ,' A #3 *0) 5'
$
! @A "' #> 2
+ P@
&
3"
3 & *'
'$ *
! %
-? " 32 5?
&@96 78
=N +
.*&
P@
&@, * *3 *
123 *3
< 5
3
+?
K
.*0'
+ >
0 #3 C
O
3 Q ,'
& *- 78
:
! !+ *!+
"
#$ *+
#@ *-
*!0) S *>'
&,
*+ ;0) %96 #>
R
' #@ *06 *
+
.
&< #
:
C+ *
+ #'
&< # *0) *9 " #$ . %&
#'
! #@ *
+ 123 + *+ *>' T" #
+$ ;
.*06 %(
) 52
: !"
*!>+ + *+ *>' #'
&< # *0) 4' *9> + . =0
*!0) #!> %
J6-
$
+
3 ; *
+
&2
2! D 2&
< *- T9 *>+ , > #+
6 ;- + #'
: #
=@? . D/
*
+ * *0) D
&0(
) %96 #> #'
#@ *
+ %6"
."
3K
& &) #
)
: &! ' ' : $# %
*0'
;,
#@
E / " C" 3 3
+ *3
#@ E 78 506
!&@ #
C(
0 * *+Q
+ ,9@
#0@ G ;>
*!0' S2 #> N
' + 7L- Kant 5'
0' #@ 4
,'
;@
2 5 0' #@ *,' 3 *> C 6 N
M S2 C(
@
! #!$ ;!@ )''
2 3
@ : >' #$
+ +' #Q
#! !0 #@ #'& %6Q) %(
) ;
''
32 #$ J
6
7
'
+
- +
+ ;< 7#- 7
+
;@ '
2 &@
(9
E
+
3 = -
%96
E 6A
23 #@ G
0
"6
3 " %& #$ " #@
+' 3
+
#!> Q! ?
+" ,9@ 1W
#> O D
+ *>/
+ *2
.(XZ J G XY 50 C) "C
& 5- # C0 #@
&2 #@ C
*! S$ !3 # S$ +
+
M" Santiana
'
'
2
!+ %! !'> (XZ J G XX ! *,>) "*
+ *? %
-
;!Q$ 7Q+ *@
/$ ? . 7Q+A
+'" ;'O ;@ # +'
5!0 C) "
E+ #' "
'> @ 3 " C7
$ ;@ 5'
?$ 1N
! *!9>
!> C! C"" ;'
@ Cliff Bill %
.( X[ J G XY
!' ;> .( [G] J XX * C) "
&2 #@
+A A ,,6
: - #$
#@ 5
+
.- 5
' 5
9> > *+
' #3 : *- 5
+ G
/
C@
"'> , # #3 : *Q 5
+ G
.
&> %
J(
"6 *>+ #$ *
+
D+ @ % 3
G Q!? G C! :#!3 1!' ;>
+ *- C>
+M
G *"!6- D
, G
)'
G 4
M G
' ' G
'
+
.*- 5
+ #' #3 4' *,
*+
*
:
: # ()
#!> !O !+ ;!'
'
&3 *0) #'
E - ,
+ ' ?
5
! C
!> + #> O " ? #&@ *0) &0 *- ;' C/
"!? !"
'> *' 5
, *K0 5
9 *& C7
/M 5
+
*
*0' *+ _ *'
'M 5
+
? *@
-
3 @ ^$ ... & *
+'
&'> #'K ? *
C/ T"
)' 2& L3 G *>
+ *@
.
:
: # ))
(Venturi 1987) C
#@ =
' ;
#@ Robert Venturi
'@ 5 2
;'P@ *'
D
&
6A #>
3$ *0) - *
+' '
''$"
#!> *0)
0 % 7
+ #@ "
6A #>
&'
> 3
+
'
&
!- !> .! %(
!) C
#3
&0' > C"
&'
,! `!
!-A %(
) *6 5
+
?
#+
6 &) #3
-A
.Sullivan (1949) "B' RQ 6
+
*!0
3"
' ; C"
*'
*&+ C0 #>
+ ,
#+
( J G XX] G
&-) ."
6 *&+ *"
6 *2 *
*!
+ ! !+ *+ *>' ;'
#$ *
*+
T/
'3
!'+
! *" % 23
&< # *0)
&,
#@ *06
Groat (1988) 52 . d
+ *, L &0 " 9(
*
+
L!@ 5
! 3 * 4/ *( *
J(
"6 L@ *
K
.!
!+
*
$ &@ C/
&3 D' L *( 5
+ * ,
.
' *
> ;/0
C/
3
;/0
5
5'
=! d
' . * B(
' *'
$ L@ < L *
& 5
>/ sampling
L!> ? %
! !6A =! d
' L@ *( * *'>
6$ C/
.J(
"6 123 L@ D' L> *'>
6$ *( L@ C< J(
"6
Multiple sorting L 3 6W Bishop (1983)
/ Groat (1982) 6$
,
!
! d6A 5
>+ L@ " > *6
- *&
- C *>+
23 .(
/ 1 6
6P .;0' (
3
L'
! S2 *( L@
'
& L *06
L> % L@ 0 A
.
& *
"
, L' *&+ " ( * => L> L O+ @ Sanoff (1974)
d2! Semantic differential scale L!
6P 5
&+ 3
-
: , L@ 5
+ 6
&' C
/ 5
0" *(
L>
* GGG GGG GGG GGG GGG *+
C GGG GGG GGG GGG GGG *,
L!@ *-! @ *' *
+ J(
"6 O *@ 3 ,
2$
*
L@
.*>' J(
"6 "A L@ L3 L J(
"6 12& L>/ L
*"
L"!6- 5
&+ *>/
= *9 * Krampen (1980)
.
+ 23 L@ *@
/$ Elsheshtawy (1997)
&
L *
+ 23 L@ .
&
L>
>$ C- *( L@ complexity *
C L>/ ,
.LK0 )' 5
-+ 5
)'
-
! *!, K *, *
+ 5
# . *
3 * 7
"M T"
*!
+ 3)
! *! 5! 5N 5
9
30
A *? .
*!'
6 7
"M *, . .(a] J #'0
) "
+ > 59-
!> !
.# ??
&96 #
3>
&>' . . *
'
5
!'
=!> S2! N ;> *9> + *@ *(
"M , ,
5?? ! ;!>
!,'
A 7
*'
5
+ C" #@ B(
'
.
&" * */0 < * B(
' #$ " #'
*M *
+ *' %(
) *0) *@K@ C" >
6
"! ! C *>+ " 23
6$ .C" ac > L
+P
S2 *06 *
5
3
+M 5
>+ L " Q@ .C" c 5N
5
!3
+? .! ! 4'
&@ @ "
6 '> #> *
+ C,
C
! " L@ L> .C
6 5
'
*
+ + *+ S2 *
:
3
< > *
+M
&@ , Q Q
+M
?
E Q
'
E C #> *0) *>+ */ " *' @ , GI
.?
E
+ A #$ +A
G 4
!M G C! G: #!3 *0) *06 *
+ + *+ , GII
*,
G 4' G
/
G
' *' G '
+
+'? G Q?
.
!'+ . ;(9 #(-
6? . * *'>
6
*!@
%!/ ! .!
,' > *+
6
A */ 5
+$ 7W #> "
#@ *,
&0 > *
*
+ #@ *(,
6 3
0 C
*
*
4' C
> D (
]Z)
*' 56 S2
?
.R6 2' 5' > *'
&$ #' #
L!@ *!06 *
+ + *+ L> % 5
+ *6
6
:L
+ L@ */ 5
+ 123 *06 %(
) 52 L'
* "
.
0G20 % E+ %/ + Z
21G40 % %/
41G60 % ,
61G80 %
a
81G100 % E+
]
#(
"M
J
6 (SPSS) B
' #$
?
*"
6 B(
' I0 23
*!0) 5
9 J96 #$ " *'
5
B(
' ;96 d2
.; *
+ + *+ *>' #'
3.0
2.8 2.8
2.6 2.6
2.4 2.4
2.2 2.2
FUNCTION
2.0 2.0
Mean VALUE
residential
1.8 1.8
commercial
variable
", "- "#. /0! 1 "23 ! "# $ #% &'( "& )*'+
/
*9 4'A A L3 *
+ L'
*+ L(
"M + .
+ . 4'A L3 *' L'
+
' *M L'
& L'
L'
(,[b) L'
*9 4'A 5
&+ , *(
"$ *? 2
@
*+ L@
@ .*' L'
( , Z) *M L'
(,YX) *
+
3.5
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
Mean VALUE
1.0
.5
unity variety balance proportion rhythm harmony contrast complexity
", "- "#. /0 3 78'9 56 1 "23 ! "# $ #% &'( "& )*'+ 4
variable
0
.! *A *' L'
L@
&'> *
+ #'
#@
+'? + *+ .a
(,YX) *
+ L'
L@
+'M + *+ , *(
"$ *? 2
@ +
*(
"$ *? 2
@ L> 23 .( , Z) *' ( , ) *A L'
5
+!A ! *!+' 12!3 *" O .*M *' L'
.L'
*9 4'A 4' ,@ L'
] /@O *"
6
.! *
+ *' L'
L@
&'> *M L'
L@
+ *+ Q .6
(,Xc) *!M L'
+ *+ , *(
"$ *? 2
@ +
*? 2
@ L> 23 .(,b ) *
+ (,bY) *' L'
! *!+' 12!3 *!" ! O .*
+ *' L'
*(
"$
.L'
*9 4'A 4' ,@ L'
] /@O *"
6 5
+A
#'
! ! 4
M * + *+ L@ *(
"$ *? 2
@ L> ?A .8
( ,Z[) fL- = d 4
P Q *M L'
+ . *
+ *A
L'
! ! *(
"!$ *? 2
@ L> ?M .(,Y ) *
+ L'
4!'A 4' ,@ L'
] /@O *"
6 5
+? *' *
+
4
M *+
& + *
+ L'
+ . L'
*9
.*' *M L'
3.5
3.0
2.5
2.0
Mean VALUE
1.5
1.0
unity variety balance proportion rhythm harmony contrast complexity
", variable
"- "#. /0! + 789 < :; 1 "23 ! "# $ #% &'( "& )*'+ 5
1
*!M #'
! ! !
' * + *+ L@ *(
"$ *? 2
@ + .9
L!> ( ,X)
3"
'>
' *+ D *M L'
+ @ *
+
/@O *"
6 5
+? .(,Xc) *
+ L'
5
'
' *+
& + *
+ L'
+ L'
*9 4'A 4' ,@ L'
]
.*' *M L'
' *+
4' *+ . *9 L'
4' *(
"$ *? 2
@ L> .:
4'A 4' ,@ L'
] /@O *"
6 5
+A + ;' ?$ .Q?
.*
+ L'
L> 4' *+ D *' L'
L'
*9
1.0
*!
+ ! !+ *+
!
!
!
!+ !
! *!
!'
.5
unity variety balance proportion rhythm harmony contrast complexity
4!' D
d ,
A
variable
/0 3 789 < :; 1 "23 ! "# $ #% &'( "& )*'+ =
."#. 78 . A# B "C%+ (
?'3) "#. (r= 0.43) 4
M ; (r= 0.45)
! ! .(r= 0.42)
/
3.5
Stepwise L(
"!!M !!
3.0
4
A 4' L3 *+'
2.0
L> *
+ 3 L3
/
1.5
Mean VALUE
.5
unity variety balance proportion rhythm harmony contrast complexity
*'! #'
* *'> @
variable
789 < :; 1 "23 ! "# $ #% &'( "& )*'+ <
.(R2=0.24)
."- 78 . A# B "C%+ (
?'3) "- /0 3
*!+ ! *
+ R2
' *' @ /0 *+ %/ L
+$ ,
$ + .
!@ .*' L'
&' %/ ,
M 59
?$ .*'
*
+ +
(r= 0.2)
' (r= 0.2) 4' /0 *+ L
+$ ,
$ S
'3 +
Stepwise L(
"M 6P .(r= 0.19) 4
M (r= 0.19) Q?
&
L> *
+ 3
3 QM 4' + @ Regression Analysis
*0!/ *!9 ?$ *!
+ #'
! *! *'> @ /0 *+ #> O
.(R2=0.05)
+ *+ *M R2
' *' @ /0 *+ %/ L
+$ ,
$ + .a
59
! /@ + .* ? ,
M 59
?$ .*'
*
+
!& (r= 0.24)
+!'M (r= 0.25) 4' /0 *+ L3 ,
M
3.5
(r= 0.23)
/!!
.(r= 0.22) !
'
3.0
Stepwise L(
"!M
2.0
Regression Analysis
1.5
4' + @
Mean VALUE
! !3
3
+'M
1.0
variable
/0 3 789 < :; 1 "23 ! "# $ #% &'( "& )*'+ 6 /0 *+ #> O
.", 78 . A# B "C%+ (
?'3) ",
*!! *!
!'> !
!@
.(R2=0.08) * 5 *9 ?$ *M #'
.L'
*9 4'g /0 #@ S-
3 4' d
)
: 4( ,43(
5!,6 L R
C,6 L3 " L@ L'
5
+ &@ 1
+$ L@ C,6 * 123
L' *0) &$ d S2 5
+ *
M / &0 " d6
5!' d2 &/0
' *
> 2 L> % L *@
/$ ;> L+
6 ;-
L! * 5" .
/0 2 > %6
K ;' *
5
:L @
3Q+' B(
' >
*!
+ L'
! complexity *+ *' L'
Q G
! *
+ L'
>
+'? Q C
&@ *' L'
?$ *M
.*M L'
>
&@
C!
+'M *+ . L'
4' L&@ *
+ L'
G
.
' 4
M
Q d2
>
*
+ K L@ *, + *+
& *M L'
Ga
.*
+ L'
A
' 4
M 68 >' >
%96 ;
" #' %(
) %96 O * */@ *" O *
B(
' 23
!
& &)
& , *
+ *0) *
+ = + *+ L@
.
3K
/!0 *+ #> O L> *
+ 3 L3
/ 4
A 4' G]
.*' #'
* *'> @
*'> @ /0 *+ #> O L> *
+ 3
3 QM 4' G[
.%/ O ?$ *
+ #'
*
!@ /!0 *+ #> O L> *
+ 3
3
+'M 4' Gc
.* 5 *9 ?$ *M #'
* *'>
.L'
*9 4'g /0 #@ S-
3 4' Gb
/!0 *!+ #!> <!
&2 *
+ = + */0 *" 5 B(
' 123
.L'
&+
*
=!
: ! =!
. XY
+ 5
)' 50 C
.XX 0 *
K G *,>
.XX 1 *
*
' #@ 5
+ * C
.XYb C
#@ =
' G 5
'@
.XXa 5A C
#@ * G G
.XXY
" G" > *+GQ'..S
.Xcc C
#@ *0) G
@> G #
. 5
3 ;, 4
- G 5@ #+
+
.XX]
&
- , *)' A
&
C
&-
!
!A R2
' #+
6&)" '
5
'
> #'
.XXc C3
*'3 *+ G"D
, Q #@
.XXa # .
" #'0
: (> =!
Bishop, R (1983): The perception and importance of time in architecture. Ph.
D thesis, University of Surrey.
+
Nasar, J (1988): Environmental psychology: Theory, research and
applications. Cambridge University Press.
,