Professional Documents
Culture Documents
37 AUGUST 2017
THIS ISSUE Man overboard while rigging ladder 03 Delay in mounting rescue fatal 05 Midwives thrown
to deck in heavy seas 07 Every year one in four get hurt 08 09 Workers also responsible for health and
safety 10 Anchor needed to prevent grounding 12 Whiteboard notice saves fishermen 14
Delay in mounting
rescue fatal
Inside
page 5
COMBINED ISSUE
RING-FENCE BY SEPTEMBER 1ST
OR ITS A GONER.
Thousands of seafarers have already ring-fenced
their old and legacy certificates with Maritime NZ
for life.
Ring-fencing keeps all your options open,
including moving into SeaCert at a later date.
If you would still like to ring-fence let us know
by 1 September 2017. Otherwise your tickets
will expire from 2 September this year.
Check online and ring-fence your tickets now.
maritimenz.govt.nz/ringfence
Man overboard
while rigging ladder
A bosun who was rigging bosun, in his 50s, was wearing a colleague having difficulty pulling up the
an accommodation ladder full-body safety harness tethered to seaward side handrail and trying to apply
a safety wire, but had failed to don a force. The bosun then lost his balance and
on a 265 metre cargo ship, lifejacket before going over the ships fell off the ladder.
ended up lost at sea when side to free the ladder.
the steel wire securing his The 1.5 metre tether on his safety harness
He had asked the deck trainee to go and should have halted his fall. The wire
safety harness to the ship get lifejackets from the crew changing that it was attached to was sheathed
suddenly snapped. room, but did not wait for the trainee to in plastic. It extended the length of
T
he ship was approaching a South return before climbing over to try and the accommodation ladder and was
Island port two years ago, and the erect the ladders handrail. The trainee secured to the ship. But once the wire
bosun and a deck trainee were was holding out the lifejacket to the was bearing the full weight of the man it
preparing the accommodation ladder bosun, who was standing on the lower suddenly parted.
ready for when the ship berthed. The section of the ladder, when he saw his
LOOKOUT!POINTS
This fatality shows how essential Over time the plastic had cracked noted the ships position, and thrown a
it is for the owners and masters of and became discolored; and it had been lifebuoy over the side which had a light
vessels to ensure comprehensive over-painted. This meant any visual and smoke signal to better mark the
maintenance checks on wires are inspection of the wire would have been position. If the bridge team had sounded
regularly carried out. obscured by the discoloration and paint. the general alarm all crew would have
been immediately available to help with
The Transport Accident Investigation Although the accommodation ladder
the recovery.
Commission (TAIC) found that the point had recently been inspected and tested,
at which the wire failed was severely the condition of the safety wire indicated As the position where the bosun
corroded. it was unlikely to have formed part of the went overboard was not well marked
inspection. or recorded, search and rescue vessels
A safety lifeline, which is critical
had difficulty locating the correct search
equipment, should be constructed to This incident also shows a lifejacket is
area wasting valuable time.
industry best practice and regularly essential for personnel working over the
maintained. side of large ships, as well as a safety The Master broadcast person
harness. overboard on the VHF radio, and the
The wire was not entered into the
pilot boat skipper volunteered to pick
ships planned maintenance system The bosun chose not to observe
him up. But it would still have been
or wire rope register. Therefore there normal operating procedures and
prudent for the ship to have returned
was no record of it ever having been contravened Maritime NZs Code of Safe
to the scene or at least ensure the
examined, maintained or tested. Working Practice for merchant seafarers
vessels forward momentum slowed by
by not wearing a lifejacket.
It is likely water seeped through operating the main engine astern, and
cracks in the plastic sheathing and The weight of his clothing and trying to remain within sight of the man.
gradually corroded the steel wire. harness would have made it more
Three long blasts of the ships whistle
difficult for him to remain afloat without a
TAIC found that it is unsafe to use indicating person overboard would
buoyancy aid, or to swim to the lifebuoy.
plastic-coated wire for any rigging that also have helped reassure the man in the
is required to be inspected regularly. TAIC also found that the actions of water that a rescue was underway.
the bridge team were not intuitive during
In the circumstances, an immediate
the attempted rescue. They should have
Mayday call may also have assisted.
Delay in mounting
rescue fatal
The failure of a kayak hire The weather was initially warm and the the whole party decided to strike out for
operator to provide an lake calm on the late September day, the island but on the way across they
when the visiting party set out in five single spread out into three groups. After an
adequate safety briefing, and three double kayaks they had hired hour or so the wind whipped up from the
and to track the location of between them. east, and five people ended up capsized.
his clients, contributed to the In the deteriorating conditions and with
The operator who hired out the paddle
deaths of two international craft ran a resort-style kayaking
limited experience, none of them could
students on a South Island business. His sign, near the lake edge,
re-board.
alpine lake. indicated the operating area was up to The first to capsize were one man in the
A
further three students in the party five kilometres from shore. The man had middle group and a woman in the rear
of 11 also suffered from cold limited experience of kayaking himself, group of two. The womans companion
water immersion, and were near and the hirage was aimed mostly at came to her aid, but he was also flipped
death when a rescue helicopter finally tourists and back-packers many also out in the half-metre waves. That pair
hovered overhead. with little experience. decided to swim for the western shore.
At District Court sentencing, the Judge About 1.40pm that day, the student group Meanwhile all three men in the middle
told the Court the operators greatest arrived at the lake and was given a limited group tried to assist their friend in the
failure was that, once the weather briefing which did not include safety lake. Two ended up in the water
changed for the worse, he did not make warnings about changeable weather and themselves, and it was decided the third
visual contact with the kayakers, and did the dangers of prolonged immersion in man should paddle to the island to raise
not mount an effective rescue operation. cold alpine waters. The nine men and the alarm believing someone ahead had
two women were aged 2022. They wore a cellphone.
The operator pleaded guilty to charges lifejackets but not wetsuits, and did not
under the Health and Safety in The remaining three men clung to a kayak
carry any communications device. Only
Employment Act 1992 and the Maritime for a prolonged period hoping for rescue.
one was an experienced paddler, with
Transport Act 1994. He was sentenced When one of them succumbed to the
several of the others never having been
to 200 hours community service and was conditions and his body drifted away, the
in a kayak before.
ordered to pay $324,500 in reparations, other two hung on to either side of the
including $115,000 to each of the families Earlier in the day, at breakfast, some of kayak and kicked for the western shore.
of the young men who died. the group had sighted an island eight
Up ahead, the first to the island in the
kilometres off-shore. Once out kayaking,
advance group was the experienced
LOOKOUT!POINTS
This operator did not comply with and this should have been part of a Maritime NZs Safe Ship Management
his responsibilities and follow his safety comprehensive safety briefing. System in 2013 and should have
plan. subsequently transitioned into the
Inexperienced kayakers need to
Maritime Operator Safety System
He should have kept a watch on remain near land. Operators must
(MOSS).
the location of the kayakers; and assess thoroughly what level of
should have implemented an effective experience their clients have had on Business owners setting up to hire
emergency plan. This should have the water and especially their ability out kayaks and other paddle craft
included taking a suitable rescue boat to re-board a kayak and paddle back to should discuss their operating and
out when the group was no longer in safety. safety requirements with a Maritime NZ
sight and the weather turned. Maritime Officer. You can find contact
Had he checked properly the kayaking
details for our nearest Maritime NZ office
Alladventure tourism operators background of each individual, this man
on our website: www.maritimenz.govt.nz
must take appropriate steps to ensure could have specifically instructed the
the safety of customers. In this case, group not to head away from shore. People who want to assess whether
the clients should have been warned to use an adventure tourism operator
Both the operator and the group
to remain within a safe distance from should ask what safety management
should have had communications
shore. plans they have in place, and should ask
devices on hand to call for help.
to see evidence.
The judge acknowledged this man
This operator did not react quickly
was intending only to run a resort- Anyone venturing onto waterways in
enough and ended up raising the alarm
style kayaking hirage, close to shore. NewZealand needs to make sure they
far too late, with tragic consequences.
However, cold water immersion is understand the hazards of the local
a constant danger with alpine lakes As it involved a powered vessel, this environment, and take care with their
operation should have been entered into own safety.
T
he passenger services company the deck. But, before he made it outside,
To avoid the heavy seas, the Master had
was fined $35,000 and ordered the vessel hit a large wave and the
taken an alternate route in the lee of the
to pay $78,000 in reparations bow dropped with a heavy jolt, tossing
island. But as the vessel approached
after pleading guilty to a charge under passengers in the air.
the entrance to the bay to berth, it was
the Health and Safety in Employment Act
exposed to large swells. The bow was As the bow rose, the three women landed
1992. The vessels master also admitted
rising steeply and falling as it crested heavily, with one having her grip ripped
a charge of failing to take all practicable
each wave. from the railing and landing on her left hip.
steps as an employee, and was fined
She suffered three fractures around the
$15,000. A passenger inside warned the mate that
neck of her femur or thigh bone which
the group on the bow should be advised
A strong ebb tide and wind contributed required a steel rod to be screwed to it.
to return to the cabin seating area due to
to the rough conditions for the morning
the conditions. However, the mate did not One colleague suffered a fractured
journey to an island near Auckland,
move to warn them in time. kneecap and another ended up tumbling
causing some passengers to feel sea
down a stairwell and fracturing her left
sick. To get some fresh air nine of the As the vessel was nearing the point at
hand in several places.
22 passengers ventured on to the bow which a right-hand turn was necessary to
LOOKOUT!POINTS
The master and crew failed to follow This company did not ensure there north-east winds at the entrance of
the operating procedures for the vessel, was clear communication between the bay causing steep seas.
which included a requirement to close the Master and crew, and that
The safety of passengers is
the bow area when the wave height crew communicated properly with
paramount. Vessels must be operated in
exceeded 1.5 metres. passengers.
a manner suitable for the conditions to
Safety measures in a vessels MOSS The location of passengers needed to ensure those on-board return to shore
(Maritime Operating Safety System) plan be monitored given the rough weather unharmed.
need to be followed to help safeguard and heavy sea conditions. In this case,
the health and welfare of passengers the ebb tide was working against the
and crew.
THINGS TO WATCH
MACHINE
GUARDING WINCHES
Machine guards and One in four accidents on
safety stops are there a trawler involves a winch
to protect you
Keep the deck around the
Never operate the machine winch operation area clean,
with the covers or guards off tidy and free of obstructions
Never by-pass or short circuit Best practice, however,
safety cut-out switches is to install winch guards
MANUAL SAFETY
HANDLING ON DECK
Weak backs and bad Most injuries on deck
posture put you at risk are trips and falls
Keep a good posture, Fish slime, etc should be flushed
especially when lifting from the deck frequently
See a doctor as soon as you Secure loose gear up off the deck
feel discomfort in your back
HSWA SAFETY =
Under the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015, all crew must take reasonable care
to ensure that nothing they do on board harms themselves or any other person. Both
operators and skippers must make sure the vessel is safe and involve the entire crew in + HSWA
managing any risks. Now is the time for you to raise any safety concerns that you have
with your skipper or operator.
WHO IS RESPONSIBLE
Operator For tips on safe fishing go to
+ Skippers www.maritime.govt.nz/safe-crews-fish-more
+ Crew
= YOU Safe crews fish more
MARITIME NEWZEALAND LOOKOUT! AUGUST 2017 9
This seafarer had two fingers amputated to the middle knuckles when trying to clear a jam in a fish mincing machine, while it
was still operating.
Workers also
responsible for
health and safety
I
Two crew members on n two separate incidents on vessels Both injuries are a reminder that, under
fishing trawlers had fingers off the coast of the South Island, the new Health and Safety at Work Act
both men failed to comply with 2015 (HSWA), the safety of crew is not
amputated recently as safety processes on-board. One man just the responsibility of employers, or
a result of attempting to attempted to unblock a fish mincing PCBUs (People Conducting a Business
carry out dangerous tasks machine while it was operating, and the or Undertaking). The Act also requires
on machines that were still other to grease the drive chain of a rope workers to take responsibility for their
operating. spooler while it was still winching. own health and safety, and that of fellow
crew. This means they should follow
and he had worked with the machine and were fined and ordered to pay the HSWA can be viewed at:
for two years. It was the first time he reparations to the victim. maritimenz.govt.nz/hswa
had tried to use a tray rod to clear it.
A seafarers hand was pulled into the drive chain of this rope spooler, above
left, when he was attempting to grease it while the winch was still moving.
T
which could be difficult to use, but he did Maritime NZ has warned the owner
he relief skipper let the 20 metre not check with them. operator and relief skipper to make sure
trawler drift for 15 minutes in a that safety measures in the vessels
shipping channel as he tried to By the time the skipper restarted the
Maritime Transport Operating Plan are
restart the engine, while crew waited on engine and returned to the wheelhouse,
followed in future. Operators need to
deck for instruction. the vessel had drifted on to a stony beach
ensure the safe navigation of the vessel
at the outer entrance to the harbour. In the
The vessel was returning to port for a new in any situation.
outgoing tide, attempts failed to power
trawl net at about 10.40pm, when it was it off the shoreline. The vessel ended up
bumped by an object possibly a log tipped over and wedged against a large
which jammed the propeller and stalled rock. Contact was made with harbour
the main engine.
Skippers and crews of commercial anchor to ensure the vessels security including the anchor, so they can assist
vessels need to understand the Maritime and that of other marine traffic in emergency situations.
Transport Operator Plan (MTOP) for the especially in a shipping lane.
The Maritime Operator Safety System
vessel, and follow its safety procedures.
Then crews of other vessels can identify (MOSS) is designed to ensure safe
If this skipper had followed the MTOP the location of stranded or drifting boats operating practices among commercial
for the vessel, he would have dropped on their radar. operators who are responsible for
the anchor while trying to restart the developing their own safety system
The crew of the trawler should also
engine, and avoided grounding. covering the entire operation of the
have kept a lookout by all appropriate
vessel, including crew training in safety
He now acknowledges it should have means, including its radar, so they could
procedures.
been common sense to anchor the boat warn other vessels by radio if need be.
once it lost power. It is also the responsibility of the
Allcrew members should be trained
operator to ensure skippers are
If in danger, or drifting in a shipping in the operation of essential equipment,
fully aware of the MTOP and how to
route, the first action should be to
implement it.
B
efore heading out for a days fishing location at the rear of the island,
Both men were wearing lifejackets and
fishing about 9.30am the man, the skipper noticed the bow line, with a
had cellphones on them, but not in
in his 60s, listed their trip details sharks clip attached, was very tight and
waterproof bags. The vessels EPIRB
on a whiteboard at his boating club hard to hold on to. He managed to take
(rescue beacon), marine radio, and flares
in the lower North Island. He was an the shark clip off the anchor warp, but
were lost overboard or beneath the vessel.
experienced boatie, and known to be with a strong current and deteriorating
safety-conscious. weather, it resulted in the anchor warp So the pair was left with no means of
immediately pulling him to the stern raising the alarm, other than the trip report
When it was noticed, at about 4pm, that
of the boat. left on the club noticeboard.
the trip details had not been removed after
his due back time, the club realised the His friend came to help, but the weight of Meanwhile the seas were deteriorating,
pair had probably got into difficulty. Police both men meant the boat started taking but there was a strong on-shore wind
and Coastguard were called. on water over the stern quarter. With propelling the upturned boat toward the
the rear of the vessel presenting to the island.
By that stage, the men had been clinging
rough seas and wind the situation quickly
to the aluminum hull of their upturned boat Once they were a safe distance away
for some time, and were fortunate that the the pair swum toward land, injuring
themselves on rocks as they dragged of the island was shielding them from by boat, so a rescue helicopter crew was
themselves ashore. They worked their way visibility on the mainland. called in and winched them to safety. They
toward a small bay, where contents from were taken back to the beach they had
When a Coastguard boat later came into
the boat were starting to wash up. set out from, and treated by ambulance
view they set off a flare to alert rescuers
crew for minor injuries.
The flare pack came ashore but they of their location. Rough sea conditions
decided to save it, because the height meant it was not safe to recover the men
LOOKOUT!POINTS
This mans safety-conscious The skipper got distracted by the Skippers and crew must always be
approach helped save him and his friend problem of raising the anchor and did mindful to keep their vessels balanced
from a long, cold night on the island and not realise the danger that he and his and ensure they avoid presenting their
the risk of exposure. crew member were in. vessel stern-on to rough seas.
By listing their trip details on the This anchor system, using a sharks The decision by these two men to
clubs whiteboard, the alarm was raised clip on a line that attaches to the anchor stay atop the hull until it was closer
in time for a rescue before nightfall. warp, is relatively common on smaller to the island was the correct one, and
vessels with solid dodgers. However, it helped save their lives. This meant
This incident also shows the benefits
did contribute to the capsize. Skippers they were out of the rough seas and
of anybody out on the water carrying a
need to be aware of such hazards and had less danger of suffering from cold
PLB (personal locator beacon) on their
how to manage them. water immersion or fatigue.
person.
Their boat had a low transom and The system the boat club operated
Ifthe pair had had a PLB or a
gunwales which means less freeboard with members able to leave their
cellphone in a water-proof bag they
for vessel stability in poor weather, and intentions on a white board ultimately
could have contacted emergency
when all the weight is transferred to one ensured that these two men were
services.
side or the stern. rescued.