Professional Documents
Culture Documents
by
A THESIS SUBMITTED
IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE
REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF
MASTER OF SCIENCE
Houston, Texas
April, 1962
ABSTRACT
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS i
LIST OF FIGURES ii
LIST OF TABLES i ii
INTRODUCTION 1
DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS 13
CONCLUSIONS 67
APPENDICES
Appendix A - Notation 69
specimens.
LIST OP FIGURES
ii
Zero Drift of Series 2 Calibrated
Compression Gages
ill
INTRODUCTION
England (3)> (4), (5), (6) and Germany (7) where It is manu
factured commercially. As a, result of this fairly extensive
-2-
THEORY OP THE GAGE
The acoustic strain gage makes use of the fact that the
ment of the necessary equipment for use with the gage is shown
the wire and the method of attaching the wire to the test
member.
40
* u/lr
-3 -
>4
o
p
o cd CQ
fH t)
*d rH to
P H cd
< O O
03
O fi
cd
p
CO
)
a
P
cd
>
u
<2
c
I
4)
tf
cd
!
P
*P
8
H
cd
o
e
EH
Pd
4
where 60 is the angular velocity of the wire
1^ is the free vibrating length of the wire
stiffness.
Elj pk
dx*
- T 4-^ -M 0)^*0
dx*- ^ <D
where E is the modulus of elasticity of the wire
A SIM H -
where A, B, C and D are four arbitrary constants
-5 -
I
y * G at x - 0 and x *
er ^
2 dt X* o and x =
dx - dx
where KdJi is a measure of the amount of elastic restraint of
dx
of the ends
and s r\
El9- at x = 0 and x = L,.,
dx
and the solution of equation (^) yields f-MlT from which
-6 -
which requires a trial and error solution.
It can he shown that the value of f in equation (^)
must lie in the range 7r<f<2 and by manipulation of equation (l)
the following expression can be obtained
oj 0.
where is the angular velocity obtained from equation
GO is the angular velocity for the condition which
leads to equation (^)
A similar manipulation of equation (2) leads to the expression
_ PTI^ET
^ L TT^ -j-'i
X -AE6
2
r -U>
t, 4-w M
LW2 OLWO+CN-O*)
<s>
and in A given by
/.CM-Of)*
but since is small compared to one then
A, AO-2AL
C n'^) _
fi?)
Now by equation
p2 NIA^ C\-2/u('N/-l)6
+2= 2
4i^lM 4L"M (XI+CN-OO - J__
again Q + (W-l)e]^ l+2(N-0&
-9-
hence equation (l|) becomes
Z _ KJAE6 f. l-2/x^N-l^ ]
" 4L* M L lJ
But by (^)
r2 k, r2. f 1-2/MfN-Qfc 1
+i*N+i L 1 + 2-CN-Oe j
Only for very large values of will the term in brackets
have any effect, hence
as
2\ 4LwtA
dLw = (ft AE U
-10-
In order for the gage to be truly effective it is desir
able that changes in strain be read directly, thus eliminat
on the instrument.
As shown in the previous discussion, a change in strain
-11-
can be shown that ' goes to MG' . Since the instrument
is so constructed that there is a linear relationship between
ship
4eTM = C(aR)
where C is a calibration factor for the measuring gage.
-12 -
DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS
for rigidly attaching the wire to the member under test; and,
measuring instrument.
-13 -
The selection of the welded stud introduces two factors
other variables affecting the gage will be the same for all
methods of gage attachment.
-14 -
used, it is essential that any variation in the initial, or
causes other than test member strain and may occur from the
-15 -
variations.
The gage selected for this study is basically the same
cation of the test member around the weld, the gage length
(center-to-center distance between end posts) was maintained
the wire and the method of attaching the wire. Due to the
wire frequency should be near the upper end of the rangej for
ial must be magnetic and the wire size such that in the
operating range, the previously derived strain-frequency
relationships remain valid. Tabulated below are the var
-l6-
DESIGNER (Ref.) DIAMETER MATERIAL
less emphasis was placed on its choice for the work under
net units and the 0.016 inch diameter wire indicated that
- 17-
The last item to be considered in the gage design is
the method of attaching the wire to the end posts. Because
at hand.
-18-
required by the Mainstone configuration. In each case the
ing operation.
succeeding section.
-19 -
DESIGN, INSTALLATION AND EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS
iations.
-20 -
-V1"'
c
o
<P
O
<D
W
IQ
IQ
O
&
%
o
CO
<L
u
g>
21
22
A one-eighth inch diameter hole drilled transversely through
the stud permits insertion of the wire between a pair of hard
post into a second slot in the top of the upper anvil. The
-23-
ween the stud and surface. A timing mechanism, also acti
vated by the trigger, holds the arc the required length of
spring loaded chuck drives the stud into the molten area of
and a third leg. The gun and template are shown in Figure 5.
-24-
CD
c3
cl
a
0
fH
T3
0
tr>
rH
I-H
LO
0
?H
3
LP
Ii
ftH
25
positioned, and the anvils and retaining pins inserted in
to the end posts. The gage was then ready for mounting
the wire.
block bearing against the upper end post, and the neces
the upper anvils, and then the lower, trimming the wire
-26-
-27-
U)
0
o
m
0
pH
0
co
!H
O
0
O
rH
>
0
Q
SUP
cti
H->
co
0
u
tr>
pH
-28 -
half inch diameter pulley on the bearing-mounted axle,
threaded through the end posts and clamped at the left
then clamped at the end posts, first at the left end, then
-29-
ranges. The initial setting of the three compression gages
fell considerably below that mentioned above? however, these
-30-
o
o
1 o
<3 o
<I
Q 0
<1 o
c
o o
o\
< Ef)
< O w
0
< O
o 8
o
E-* &H EH IH EH EH
till 1 1
r-i CVJ CO-5T liAMJ
oO HI
< o 1 | 1 j 11
<1 o o o o o o
^ <B
Q J o
< GO o
<1 0
i a\ a
0 o
<J f 4 o
<1 G O a
<
BO B o
<1 o
CO
<3 G0
8
<3
a
A
<! O o
o
^0 o OJ
B
<| 0 <
8
< 0 <4 o
o
Figrue 8e
< 0 0 * fH
< 0 o B
<1 0 O '
<1 8
<1
4
8 o
Lf\
O o
CO
c
OJ
ob
(irw)
-3f~
o
7 o
1 o
Q
^ 4 a
o &
o
o Q
<3 o <g^r
eo
o 0
&
<3 SSSEEE
1 1 1 ! ! !
0 r-i i.vj {T ^4 u \vu
1 1 1 11 l
8
G B OOOOOO ^"S
G < o s < 0
<i ai
0
xi o
8
o 0 5
. < < 0
0
0
o
o
CO
0 *3 &
0 <3 0
0 B
0 <3 0 o
o
<3 Q <4 CVJ
<1 Q
'0
<3 if o
^-1 . o
Figure 9
0 9 o
0
0 <3 # ^ o
A
0
o
0
0 o
VO
o
in.
o O o
on CVJ
-<> o
<O ooo a
I I I
a invo
i i i
ooo
o
T B 8
ooo
I I I I
rH OJ CO
I I I O CO
B ooo
0d &
0 0
Sd *>
< I
O EH
<3%J " ~ kO
<o
N B c
o
^SN\ Q 0<1 OJ
Wa o4K s
*0 sPM \
o
Figure 10.
o o
m O o
- s CO OJ
34 -
Before a correction for drift can be accomplished
-35-
noted for gages C-4-C, C-5-C, and C-6-C. In the early
sary that the reading be delayed until the wire and test
-36-
member reached the same temperature. During this same
- 37-
results of the drift observations on these gages are tabulated
-38-
Electric
Gages
E-3
JL6L12.5
Acoustic Section A--A
Gage
Compression Specimen
r
k 15--J
(rv
I5i!j
E-2 n_ ^E-3 V
E
-
X
<& ^
A
1 3^" ^ 34"
Bending Specimen
-39-
p
c
e
s
4)
U
u
<
s
'd
cd
5
C
o
CQ
(0
0)
JH
,
&
o
o
CVJ
H
0)
to
H
4o
p
c
6
0)
01
u
h
<
$
2
12C
01
ffl
on
fH
0)
bO
ri
PH
41
Since it was desirable that the results be verified by
were very erratic and it was only after a spherical seat had
-42-
constant load as possible. Reading all four electric gages
was necessitated by the possibility that friction in the
are in quite good agreement and the gage factor for this
- 43-
CVJ
c Cft rH crv rH o o o CVJ H rH
P =r CO it CO it it it it it it it
CQ o
o 0 CVJ CVi CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ
1 EH
VO
1
o rH
t-- o o CO o\ o o\ o o\
P it VO in it CO it CO it CO
CQ 0 o o o
0) CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ
EH
CO
o it VO -3* CVJ CO CO CVJ CO CVJ CVJ
p in st* it it it it it it it it it
ra o o o
d) CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVI CVJ CVJ CVJ
o CVJ
1 CVJ o B
in
i
p
CO
it
it
in
on
it
Q\
CO
it
rH
it
rH
it
B
rH
it
CVJ
it
Gage Factors for Series 1 Compression Gages
o 0 CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVI CVJ CVJ CVJ
IH
H
on VO GO it rH rH CVJ it rH rH H
P vo in =t -t it it it it it it it
CO o o
0 CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ cvj CVJ CVJ
E*
o CVJ
=t P
CO
in
in
in
CVJ
in
it
it
VO
it
it
it
o
it
rH
it
CVJ rH
it
CVJ
it it
i CO o -
o 0 CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ
EH
rH
P
p
VO
o
it
CO rH
it
CVJ c rH H o o o
it it it it it it it it
CO 0 o
0 CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ CVJ
EH
VO
MCI
O -H O
u cd rH in o in p in c in o in o in
Qtb M
ft-P =
it o\ CO
H
CO
rH
CVJ
CVJ CV1
rH
CO
VO
CO
o in o\
it it it
Table 2.
M <*N
o *o m
u <d Qi in o
H
in
H
o
CVJ
in
CVJ
o in
CO
o in o in
CO it it in in
<
- 44 -
Table 3. Gage Factors for Series 1 Bending Gages
45
-
I
VO
K
c
-46-
on opposite sides of the specimen. On examination of the
observed data (piP91- lO^Appendix B) it is seen that these
loading beams.
strain for these tests was limited to about half that for
the compression case. The total applied load then was 5500
-47 -
and a stress of approximately 7.15 ksi. The test procedure
was the same as for the compressive case with four tests,
well with those obtained for the pure compression case, the
-48 -
the deformation produced by clamping had occured entirely
in both the anvils and the wire or in the anvils only would
-49 -
that no improvement has resulted.
axis of the stud. The arbor, a one inch length of the stand
between the wire and arbor, the greater surface area of the
-50-
-5/
After the wire is wrapped and tuned, tension is maintained
by clamping the arbor against the bottom of the hole with
by eye, the end posts and magnet mounting studs were welded
had little effect and were accepted. With the exciter unit
approximately positioned, the ends of the wire were threaded
approached the desired level, one end was clamped and the
other adjusted until the required frequency was attained.
-52-
-52
compared with Series 1 gages. Since both the stiffness and
mass of the wire have been nearly doubled, this was not unex
previous case.
The results of the calibration tests are shown in
Table 4. The increase in gage factor over Series 1 gages
is the result of the decreased gage length and the increased
-53 -
t)
VO
PH
H
Zero Drift of Series 2 Preliminary Gages
-
55-
(*n*W) T*3 OJz
(*n*W) WF-IQ oaaz
o
o
8
Q
CO
<0
EH
h
-5G-
Table 4. Gage Factors for Series 2 Preliminary Gages
-57-
mass and stiffness of the wire, also it was expected that
higher than that from the compression test. The main prob
lem is in the variation in factor between the three compres
sion gages. A check of gage dimensions revealed that the
magnet gap for VJP-2-C was set at 0.02 inches while the gap
for the other two gages was 0.03 inches. A third test on
inary gages, it was noted that the wire and arbor were not
wire at the hole in the arbor had little effect. The grip
-58-
tension. The device shown in Figure 18 allows pretension
twenty-five pounds.
over the points on the legs of the gun with the stud passing
-59-
on the plate set perpindicular to the gage centerline.
Finally the magnet gap for the second set was increased
to 0.04 inches for all gages. While this caused a marked
60-
o
o o
E&$) o\ 0W &
o o
sss
8 ooo
i i i 1 1 I
H CM CO t-co o\
1 1 1
(6d JSlSlS a<3 O ! > Is
o
Time (Hrs)
m
3 o
o
o
in
O
o
GW o <3 0
ew O Q <1
o
CO
GXW <J G
o
o
CVI
<W1
0< o cQQ
8
Figure 19.
E< a
BO
00
G
o
CM rH
o o
3
W**CI oaz (*aW) oaz
6 /
62
(irw) wza oiz
o
caused the clearance between the wire and the body of the
caused the wire to touch the end post body and no consistent
dred ohm coil of the same number of turns as those used above,
ling.
-6 5-
in the wire, it is to be expected that the drift curves
will become assymptotic to the time axis after several
remain constant.
-66-
CONCLUSIONS
-67-
so that the gage is operating in the flat portion of the
uration.
-68 -
APPENDIX A
NOTATION
-69-
APPENDIX B
OBSERVED DATA
0. Miscellaneous.
-70-
JL.
-2^0 V*?A/?r &s3S^V6T)oyJ5
<7AA ?/ O' T'' fi?/5~ 67
CrAr:,^ /JuMf.3VP ! <r- /- To <5-2-7* 6-5-7"
/tJ IT/As 72*/5/&/J ! I3.ZS >5./S A3. ?sr
7BJ'Vt/ J 13.9 13,7 3.4-
OATS- TUMP Ti(S!g-\ e 77m '^P 4^ je 4\e
1 j^p-cc
/O-24 1? i Jil.S /cc.o
JO-24 1C (7(i0 j J671 iC.4 D 52.2 774 3
'6-2 S' 74 0-Oc.cA 74.0 l?.S /5> 73? 24.) 19
/giPd>
tC-'K i 2Z2. 4t> 22.2 21.2 43 Si. 9 i
is 90s
//-/4 !
75 4 1.0 I 43? 53.4 j 4C.G | 499 4/.2 4c. 7 ;
; i 71.5 4?G
//-/< ! 1
72 1 70.2 7 73 !} 523 52? | 47,2 j 573 39.5 t: 42.4 j 474
//-Ad J 43.0 !
72 : :
i M-l 43.? | 547 SO. s; 49. s : 64 7 3/9 492
JJ-A7 ! 70. 1693 43,2 | 57/ 5/.9 ; 477 ; 57/ 29.2 42.7 ; 522
.A .
n-/2 ! 43-6 | 555- 35/. 2 j 42? I 595 52. d I 439 : 546
i 7/
-7h
J.
?*r/?<Q 0/9/ fi=7~ 0/5 VsC T/CA/S
(J'JJDI5TU/2/3-0 0?A&&S ~ Cot.IT/tiUcC>
- 72 -
55/Z/55 1
XOg/FT ' O'SSS'/ev'AT/CJjJZ
C'ALiBgArzP GA<$ <^-5
-13 -
I..
.D/Cv/^r 0^75 75 t//S T/6/JJ5
II-&-6I 11 0=100 132.2 5 3.2 5*^6 2l0< 3(1.0 2l6 2)4.2 31.0 223
t
-74 -
SER/ES r
ZERO DR/PT OROPR AA T/C/PS
tl-tt-Q & 0900 1/744 42. C /340 1915.0 4-^.s <960 ^77
>2-26-41 4? CDO o j! 172.6 64.0 ISC a 170 0 sfc.S /12,9 ! 195.4- I 4i>. S
1 1145
J-2-C2 4? 2f900 j H6.7 65.3 / 67 6 193? 52,6' l29o| <96,?j 42.4 1113
1 i
f]oTi
/. EL&Cr&OMAGtiZT OR GAGE C-2- M WAO
DAM'AGEJR ACC/ORRTA/.2 y >U/P,//J<G AD/CCCA/RRCT/G R
RRCRl MEA5V &//JC, //Ursj-ROMEMT. (J AGE C~23 - W
- 75-
5E/8/81 r
^E&O O f2>S/?]/AT/0/J5
CAL./ &&A T^O GA&5
/0-244 . 1L
*
/C'25-a o=ico 301.3 15.6 \5 813: } 17.9 15
16-7441 12 CF&O 29S.* 24-. 9 39 3H.0 24.5 39 3/8.3 ' -
/&-27-CJ 70 O900 7*9?,? 2C. / 63 3/4,7 26.3 62 Zc.c.0 /?.o l9
/0-28-M .12 C9oo 29c. 0 29.9 27 5il,7 29,3 27 293.1 2 5,2 43
0-204/ 14 C9CC 229.3 30,6 HI 3/6.9 36./ ill 292.2 is.5 <^7
/6-304/76 O^OD 254,7 33,2 135 3<33 22,/ 135 -2?? 6 36 3 9/
/OSZ/\ J2 O^ico m,6 33.9 159 3o?.2 32.S' 159 247,2 3/./ 115
//-HZ 0900 279? 36 ,/ 153 306.3 34.7 123 2/?4.3 34,6 139
! 77
//~2-CZ\ 79 0900 2 21.? 35./ 267 505.3 37,7 267 2t2,0 56.3 163
//-3-6/ 12 OQCO '2793 40.6 23/ 30/.3 39.7 231 2 b"0,6; 3?. 3 T*7
//-4</ 10 Cb9 60 2713 4/-6 255 2990 42.0 255 27?.? 59.5 2//
H'5-C.t 09oo 215.6 4/,9
11 279 2990 4 2.0 219 Z77.0 4/. 3 . 235
J/-C-C/ 70 CQoo 217.2 427 36 3 29?9 42. / 303 276.5 4/.? 259
//-7-o/\ 09 0900 274.3 43.6 327 297.6 4-4.5 37-7 275.? 42. 5 223
U-H/ 71 0900 275.0 44.9 55/ 296,? 44,2 3S7 2756 43,3 307
//-9-c/ 70 <->900 274.6 4S.9 375 2.96.2 44.2 375 274.5 43, 33/
11-/04, ' 7/ 2753 44,4 399 297.2 43.? 399 27 S3 43.0 355
<0900
ll-IKI 77 0900 275-0 449 423, 2965 44*5 423 274.5 43.? 379
/I-/3-0Z 75 0900 273.3 46.6 47) 255.1 45.9 411 272.2 4C.J 427
//-/<?-! 10 0900 273.2 4-6,7 495 294.7 40.3 495 272.2 44,/ 45/
(I-/S-C/ 12 O9oo 271.2 47.7 579 292.4 4-?. 6 5/9 276.5 472 475
ZHU) 12 >9oc 276.2 4S,7 54 3 291.? 492 543 269.2 49.) 499
U-/7-0! 10 090CJ 270,2 48.7 567 292,0 49,0 sen 269-6 47,7 523
11-18-0/ 11 C3=/C 0 269.2 50.1 59/ 29 U 49.2 591 26-9.2 48,1 547
1 ' ' !
-77 -
feeo /D/ez/^r I/A T/OAJS
!2-4-C=j\1i 75 <0=00 2649 55,0 975 2?6.3 54,7 97 S 264.2 54.) 93/
\
12-6-67 l(o 0=700 26*1.7 5 S', 2 1023 2? 5.? 55,2 1C 23 262,4 54.7 979
!?*=> 2/ j 12 0900 262.? 57. / 1095 26'4,7- 50,7 1095 26/2.5 56.3 /Col
17-12-6/ 68 0=K.DO O&LL 5tf.7 H67 2/25 52,5 1167 260/2 07.) mz
n:&c,\ <28 0=700 l.(o c.\ 59. t 1335 2 ?2.0 59. C 1335 29.6 5S.7: 120)
/ 2-262/S 67 osoo 257.0 j 61.** ISO 3 239.2 6!,? 1 5C3 267.2 61.0 /459
|i
/'2-6/ii 6 / 0960 2*37.0 \620 I67| 277.3 oB.Y 167 / 255,2 6.7.5 /6 2.7
i
j
i
j|
1i
-18
I
1
,
6io/S C-4-C - ' 6T-C- C- -C,\
'fyrtt'ftAL /SA/H/OJJ . I9.S5" 19.5 5 19. S 9
rfr/HAL 7zM3/otJ ie.i i2.8 ff.C,
DATA /*iP //MB Af? 7/Mfir (8 4/? //A^E * /? 4/0 Urt
12160
//-'tr-c/ 11 47D.S
II oc. 11.00
t'fWC-6^ 72 /ooo 449.? 21,4 19 449.2 * 433.7
10 loco 44 S. 1 25.4 4-3 431.0 ISIP 73 4?r.2 /s.S 12
IH2-&/ 7/ ooo 4 4 SO 25,5 67 425.Z 24.0 413.2 19.9 46
1 47
//-20-&! 67 1 ooo 4323 37,1 I/S 417.1 32.1 95 402.5 2S.2 70
Il-21-Gt 11 looo 14 3?.) 32.6 /39 416,2 38,4 1/9 467.1 26.6 94
ri-Tl-C/ IS 1 ooo 43Q# 39,7 163 409.7. 40.0 143 406.0 21.7 112
!1-3.4-4>} 6? /QDO; 4)24.6 44,S 21/ 404.3 44.9 191 401.0 32.7 IfcCo
n-zi-Gi 72 /<ooo |! 4 24.2 46.3 2 23 401-S 47,4 263 39*3 3S.4- 23?
//-2f-/ 73 iooo'k^/D 44 5 307 401.9 47.3 287 3955 3S.2 262
It
V/-39-2/ <S7 /OOC jj4?9.l 5/4 35S 39(6.0 53, 335 392.0 41,7 310
-nr TlJCoT j
i
i
1
i
l
-79 -
CCJ2J.E5. I: SS4LSCe
^if20 2/2//=7~ 0/3S <50 EAT/C/U3
-80 - .
v)
Q *
Uj 0
* fc
<Q
vl
J
*
4]
v)
N <0
0
5
$
Q
'h
ru
-31 -
C'f^' L,AL/Q/&A7~C>
<&<,= L. /-/U.1 e,
sJo/A&e^ (/A/CX&S) (//JC/S&5) (oHASIs)
C-S-M . 2^4 O. 8G 9 2o
0-,-M .30? 0.88 320
C-4-T (0.258 0.84
C-S'-T t&.'Z'ZO 0.84-
C-Ct-T <2.267 <4.30 '
" 82 -
VS
> -S> In N <5 lo V9.Q X
NS C^ \ Ov > ^ W l '. ^
I <xi CM k O' Q} ^
Vl K Hi *
N^N S? tv> S' "> 5
^ >v' ^ *v \ X CM ^
0
k
i
cJ M Q <M nt^ ^ K ^
x) m - cvy \r
$ NS
i
0^ cH ^ X x3
CO $ & $
HT M V).
HI
MX
^ ^ O ^ Q S
f Vii CM
N ^ vj. (A
i ! ^ to ^ ^j. Ms- vi Hi VN '? o 0 $"t $
>1 ^ CM (M N N CM CM V) ^ X x N CO
S3 VI
N
x^
I X) V)
c\ X r\ Qv t*a C\j r\
^Y (X M i-M ^ o; ^ ^
v) -V. ? N ^ CO
V 3 60
^ 9- & O ^
X) csj 5^. X ro ''*
M V, CM CM VM CM CM tH CM
^ V X ^ X. Nv
I VI
V
*R
\J
X
? ?; !J ft S ^ ^ ^ < S \
% Q ^ !
vl M
. Hi
M V)
Jh rM 'o So ov 9;
S S'
^i
Vi) (K V) r> r CM ^ v3 Q 0/K(CJ
N O ^ ^
\ ^ 'V H) Vi H ro, X NS ^ Do
V? 1-5; A) CM ^
<A <M CM CM ^
X ^ v \ X \
^ > V) $ \ ^ ^
kJ
SVi <ps
X> H ^ O' ^
X) $? Ml NS X X ^ ON
SH CM X O
V) V/v O (P
x 0) ^ ^ NS ^ ^ 1
>1 OQ MS- 8
C) s5 <M r-
(M <M n n
\ ^ X ^
'C, x X\ x X X Hl^i
'vX
K
t ON Oo CM Cvl Vo Cx ? ON CO V) ^ (jN
X Vo' N 'M ^ Q v> xc vi ^ x {No ON
M- X O CM iQ X
I ^ ^ ^ ^ CM $j X
X'St
Vj X)
b M $o v\ V) (*> o
X X X CV-j <Tx V> X
M M N IM! O O
>s O5;5!35
X X CM SM X) C ^ ^ \ CM 'X vv.
V
X v
? ^ CN
O Vl ^ ^ NM vQ $ S X V ^ 8'kHR
-63-
T, r
GAGB FACTO/Z DSTSSM/A/A 770F
-S4
/<?/ J-
6;AC, r^CTO/Z / Aj AT/O/J
A\f CPA/,
U>AO /// O /C/1\TP 5r/<f/Jj ('/'ll x10 5 Sr/PA/A ACC-4 -c) <543 c 10/3
&
(Lfi) -/ -2 5-3- -4 - (m/in **5 ) (MO) (-&S *
~QS
5>/~jes> 1
. GAGS FACTO/? jO&TM/A/471sJ
T^S7" 2>
24PAD 5 T/S A /// GAKS,^ /OSAYD/A GJ<,
OO
/S/8'3
CM
0 /43SO /S8/7 )4S)2
5(300 14333 / 170 294.-9 14470 /S/39
/oooo 142? 9 /S723 376.3 \44Z4- /S097
/5ooo 142,4? /5U5' 3S6.Q 14 31? 1 S041
20000 I4IC& /ZC,2G 3 36.6 14 33) ISOOI
2SOOO /4/S4- ISS23 3 16.7 14 784 /49S6
/4/09 C
30000 1% 53 5 297. 1 4 240; /4 9| /
35000 f rf- C>? / 1 54<9o 2777 14 190
4<0 Ooo ./4o/5 ISAqq 260.2 14 146 14 S'20
4SOCDO /3970 1 S3 GO 239.3 /4 /60 14 273
So 000 /39Z3 15 3 S 2/9.9 \dcS> 2 1472?
55COO 1387 fr 1 S 30 'O 2o2.0 140 10 1468/
A(C-4-<3 f~ACU
2(7 A/7 /AO/C A TO/3 ST/OA/M ' ) /(1 6
sr&A/tJ
(24) O'l -3 0-4 (1yto ) MH
:
GAGE fAcra/? OeTEPU/A/AnoU
-87
W\>::
-k "*'
. '
,
*
:
'
-s&e/es ? . .
t
p
OA<$- ' hcro/ /LsTA5/A/AT/C>/J
:
3260 44- 42 43 47 42 n.z 1.44
: fOOoCt $2 25 86 50 S5 30.2 2.35
VfCOO ; 730 /33 732 !3C 133 55.0 2.42
n? m 779 J79 I7g 74.4 2.39
2SCOO Z7<6 223 2?5 227 333 93./ 2.40
/?<?fXXD' 20~f lib . 272 2 (7 112.2 2.40
{36000 31 e 3/4 313 3/7 314- 130.9 2.41
*40000 : 364- 36! 360 3C4 30/ 149.5 2.4/
[45000 4-1(0 406 404- 40? 405 /08.4- 2.40
56000 4Sg 453 45/ 456 452 /f7.3 7.41
556(00 SD> 502 49& 500 45=? 206.4 . 2.4 2
;
'** **
S8-
. 56F/F5 .21
G&QJ? FACTO#?
AVA&5
/.OA/O Z//D/cor^/D ST/OO/// CIV /~C /reA/3 A(c-6-c) 6005 EtX-TOitL
]c
Co) 5-1 E-2 E-3 5-4 (% *J2^) CKU.) _Cmz>5 J
-90 -
5&/P/5S T
/AC7VZ D&rdr#A'f///4770/J
SI-
$e#/es I
5AGS 7=~ACTC^ TDsrs&M//JAr/OAj
X/f
LOAD ZA/S/ CAr/F/D 5ST~5A/// o'-tt D *) 'f.v A (c-4 -M) 2AGO FACTOR
.... &&) 55 5-2 5-3 5-4 M.D5
N <* (3r, * <0-9
-91-
rfyr/^/- 33
C3A(55 5AC7-&A? }=71:rfi?M//JAr/0/U
-92 -
T
Got.* 6ACT&6 H')67'66 Af/A/Ar/OU
GAO^= C-4-M /&AJ 3G <JASUA/?Y CZt 1370
^7.3
/ "> '2/ 58.0 2.4-/
soo 22 22 175
/coo 44 42 4/ 42 si.o 2'2. S' 2,40
/SCO (0 Co (33 (4 21.4 33.4 7.44-
Toco 22 71 * F3 85 /o?,C 44.5 2.4 2,
2530 //o , 703 /03 708 134.4 5.S 2.4 2
3000 737 723 723 73/ 7(0.7 6 5.7 2.45
3500 752 743 743 752 726/6 1C .3 2,45
40CO 773 752 /G3 772 2/2 20 2.4-4
4500 795 773 723 754 239 61.9 2.44
5060 2/3 . 203 263 2i7 265 76706 2,43
5500 ; 240 223 724 ^6 6 292 77 0 2,46
-9 3-
57=/?/^s T
' PACTOte jMAr/CKi
TCAO hJD/cCi TSD .ST5,*/O Crfo 70 -*) VJ A(C.-4 -M) 6A<~C 5/^croc
lUi) 6-/ SOI 6-3 6-4 CM. U.)
-95-
F/crzjye -VIF /F M/z/s/rr/OA/
E-2 :/?_ 54
$
j
i
1
O'
/SO/O 72/39 249.2 13320 (4/03
300 7 4 2 5/ 72/(3/ 0.00 5> 1534/ 74/5/
/COO 74 8 75 72m 2.12,5 '35/3 J4l32
1000 74 957 /27.0 7 434.0 733K 74/72
2 CCO 744s 2 /2.7.30 255.3 73409 / 4 09/
. 253'C 7 44/3 72232 307. / /5430 74074
3000 74$9C 72272 317.7 /34SO 14050
3300 /4f/7 72223 37-3.2 . 13472 /4039
4o<00 74 55C 7237? 347.0 13435 140/8
4000 / 4 rJ 7 72539 357,8 735/7 74cco
SXOD /7j/o 72359 302,4 15538 13122
OOOo 74 80/ 72380 3 73,2 !j 500 72904
~9>-
(?<$ FACTO/Z jF-Jlfi?A4/iJ/\7-/<D/j
-97
<5/55 /
07 A/ , A1 \
2-ot.Q 7/25/.CYT5ZO Sr/9/5/5 (7* J ^ \*J A(C-5- /A) GAO5- AACTV/Y
-98
/
<5?AG/? /~ACT6>AS D^T^/fM/AJAr/O/S
m
>40 //Jjy/CAT/TO ST&A/A/ (^TL * /o'**) 6v\/
124) 4=-/ e-2 -3 E-4 (74.0.) * A
5A/C //JO/C A TJT/O 5354 /7J (iP/o-y /*/ ZCC-O-M) 6ACT 5AC70&
CLT) O-/ E-2 5-3 T~4. \(L*'<5L /MU. ) (9/, v ,0-7 1 -y
-too. -
<5/5/5^' /
? /Cocro,^ / 45/^5/^/A.mr/c*/
63
47'/ 75-2 C-O -7,1 /r-3
%
o 02450 /234/T 206.7 3650 /C493
500 125/2 rZ3'Z5 195,0 //029 750/8
lOOC: 12 53 C 12363 124,0 7/609 15639
/6& /2 553 /2283 173,0 //$%9 15060
2500 . /3 570 12263 167,7 7/3(23 /Z&O
2000 12 Gy . H241 /5 / >7 H54$ 15607
3c&o /2 22 12222 !4/0 //6z 2 757/3
3soo /Z<647 11262 130.3 ncoo 15/4?
4CCO /%<>?. 121 33 H92 //4f7 /5G 68
4SCG . /2/ 90 12/62 /o/. c 114-6/ /56 90
5000 >27 U 12/4/ 92.0 1/447 /57 \Z
5500 127 3'Z mn tto /1427 /si 3)
x C\Aj
/mo.. 7//o /CACOD CT/C3//J ('u 73 ) /CC-O-M) 0/-65 f/eTC/O
f '73- y A-&)
K
/LS) S-I 5-2 5-2 5-4 2 *'o3 (M.O.)
V ^ C'MJ
X 1" ' /
-/o/ -
5S/?JBS /
/6 -<
Zc^o /A?C'/C /I S/D Zor^o/A/ C/s * V 5 CC.-<L-M')S>&6& F7,CT6g
O3J -/ -2 -3 -4 ('rL * '0^)' (M.U.) d&uo-1)
-102 -
-to
il
V)
2 5,0
V)
^ Q ^ V) ^ kn .
'! ^ (> c*> \fi ^1
V]' 1 [T C: c-i1
1 i
oiCT (Nr'COCM^NXSgNN^
- tv
Mifj Cl ^ v >9 3T CN ' cji
Ovl CM <M Cv CM S ^ ^
1
t
_ t -r-_
to vSo CM v? ^
^ QvJ (0 v3 t~y
r CM v9|
1 CM xh ^ (T^ _ CN *o \^;
's*-t Vp MJ- 0-1 \p 'JI ^ ^
CD/3^^^ v'ATyoA/s
*
Q,Vi ^ O '- ro O ^ gs|
0 0
oj(0 (Si O' ( Vi
M to cn txl CM VN M- ^ in. <TV
CM CM CM CM CM CM <M CN ^1
M 00 CNJ CN X.:
VD
b
v!>- KJ 1 c- ~r (T* ^ Cr
CM M9 ^ 01
I i? ' - ^ O O' - 'St Cf & in;
V P^ Vn ^ vio v^ CT O <^r ^1
' O- cr>
1 in -^r O &<> C'M
c-I c>jj CM
0
8 1
^
i
-
?/p//=r
i ^ $ I $ $ 1 ft ft S
2
5
\ kj iii 0 S ^ M Ch C? QV g ^ I
o' 4 0 t N { 1i
Nj
p- vs oa Q\ Vn rn ^ oviO v ;
C > n l ^ SQ ^ VP bo <3 gs M i
\J
CL (K
<N 1 i ^ .
k f\ loo ^ M c>=> O'- : to 60
O cJ vJj
^ t ^ 0 5 t;
n* v ^ '^-xr'T'sr'^-^^}-^!
& 0 0^ S ? ? S sg
kj
n 9k 1 CM V) V) Cxi Vf)
1 .0 ^ ^
s
^0 V) V |Oj Cv Q
!S
<0V
'1 11 lillllllll
i
.1 II $1 ^ v 7 8: S Sf > ?
< \ -V i. < < CM V4 <NJ . M 'M
0
Sj
* kS 'O
\
'N
^ V5
U % vs V)
,<S Q
0 Uj
1 JQ
k0} Sk
Q
IV
~/o4
5PP/<S5 2
6J'C&- 0, Az 2. //K/
P0/43eg (/AjcuttJ OtJCHes) (tiJCtiers) ( /JJC s) C/K/CHeP) (OHM'S )
-105-
5iW/S 2-
<5AG /^ACTO/Z JDr7l?/g/s?///s4 ~/&//
5000. 4a 4L 41 45 46 1,4
1 2.0,4- >
-lO<o-
'; > ' . ; GAGA- /-&C7&se j-Azrr&/,/sf//S/! 710 57
:
; ;
Goo s WP-/'C c /G?/3/eo^gy JSGZ, /S3O
vW'V72=57- 9_
3 SoAD 5r/?A/AJ
0 &//?) 5-/ 52 WP-/-C 5-3 <5-4
:':^v; ' <0 /S7 70 74370 394,0 75/69 744? C
75725 74-379 3783 /S/27 1444-0
'' /o. 75450 74 223 30/.S 7508/ 74392
75 /S 4 3/ 74240 344.2 15035" 14-345
1
' , GO-.. /SS27 74 797 377,0 7-4 740 75302
25 /S639 74 749 303.7 1494-1 iizsz
) 3? 75493 74/04 29/-4 /4 ?9<9 142.70
V - 35 75449 74020 273, 7 /485I 14765
, 46> 75403 74C/3 244,0 74 80/ 74-50
45 /53S? 73905. 23 7,7 74 752 74 0 73
50 75370 73 9/7 2 79,9 74 1 jo /4 oZ9
5 7526,2 73$ 74 202.3 74 ICC *3 S?g
78 47 42 4C 4/ 1 s.7 7.61
70 % 27 *8 94 21 37. s 2.6 8
75 745 730 734 740 132. 49,8 2, (55
4o 129 173 779. m 170 67,0 7.63
.25 237 227 212 73 f 774 853 /2,63
30 . 223 z&C 27 0 276 70? 102, L 2,4 /
35 327 ' 3/0 313 32/ 3/4 120.1 2,6/
40 373 357 302 SO 6 399> 13 3,0 2, 60
45 , 419 Acs 411 4-13 4-02 150, 3 2 ,01
SO- 4-04 453 459 457 4-50 174.7 2, 62.
55 5D2 4%, so 3 49Q 49^ ill, 7 2,60
-107-
55P/P5 2- /M/AJ SJ/?r
}
<5PSP PACTOP 3 PFP /FAS//J/47~/F>A/
>
~/OQ-
57?/*S 2- P/P54/Q///JA 5 r'
PAG 50/2. /A/4r/<osj
77k GT 2-
/-GAO S>T/2/)//J <3>A6& /pTAl JO//J<5<
'fa'*) 55 5-2 14/5-2-0 5-3 5-5
o /37V 2 /8-//0 4/50 /55/7 /3409
.5' /3 73/ 7406 2 3904 /5570 /3 42 3
70 73 703 740/3 382,3 75 573 73577
y/5 735/ 73370 3470 75420 73 330
'20 13/70 13^23 337,0 754-33 /3 28/
25 73503 73375 334.0 /5 322 /3 233
30 . /33/V 7323/ 3/7,8 /S 34/ /3 /VO
35 )3 472 73783 3O/.0 15 2<?7 )3 M-2
40 73 42? 78735 324-0 IS 230 i3 09?
45 73380 /S388 758,0 75 2C3 73050
50 '13 332 73 U7 23/./ 75/57 73 003
55 13 22? 73 593 135,0 75/70 !295(3
\/CO4^ ^ &
/tJOicArzo5r-ez>/s/(/u /o ^ ST/P/^/aJ 9&c,t- SECTOR
A(I//P-2-CJ
/OAO
10 4 *
(89 -/ . ^"'2 5-3 3-4 (M.OP (TW * y
s 4f 47 47 40 48 /<>. s 2,9/
70 79 97 94 92 90 33./ 7.90
/5 13(2 Mo 737 139 139 47.9 '2.Z4
-20 7$2 187 784 /8f !2(o 05,0 7.2^
25 519 Z$S . 2729 23> 252 67 .o 73 G>
3o 213 779 17C 279 27? 98.1 7.23
35 320 327 32 O 30? 324 114.9 2.22
40 305 375 3G? 372 37/ 131.9 7.. 2 )
45 4/2. 422 4/4- 419 . 4
4/2 M-7.9 2.23
SO 4CO 409 4&0 4O0 4oS 104.2 . 2.27
S3 5c?5 S/7 507 5/3 5i 2 no,9 2.23
-/os-
5/Z?/&*$ 7 - PJO^L/MIKlA/PY
; t
<U'AD tfJ JO/CAr5C> 5r/3A/rJ Srr */0 V STgA/tJ A(wP-2-c) <5A&& S&cro/r
c
(K/P) 5;J 522 53 5:4 (4, (/^) l M.U. X (0~ ).--
1*HS ^
400 403
. 450 469 46/ 163,0
509 5/2 502 S/S' , 570 17937 7. S3
-no-
S5S/55 2- //snuA/py'
-///-
SE (?/?. 2- P/$f-L / As?//JA JP Y
:
C?A6- / ~ACr&: /D&r&R/YtKl AT/CKl
45 45 43 42 44 70.0 2,0s
90 39 82 29 89 373 7,7/
(3$ 137 73Z 739 735 49,q 2, 72
./86* 52 /7/ 185 786 (,({,7 2,?0
230 22-8 72 3 230 ZZC 84.3 :2, (2
277 275 * . 270 7.74 213 /ot.2 2,7 0
31/ 372 3/5 320 317 1/8.5 2, (2
3(7 34C 30 J 3057 30,4- 130.5 %(7
4/4 4-H 408 4-ll 4/0 153.8 2.67
440 4S2 450 400 4-5 7 1715 2. 66
5o4 504 Soo sot 502. mo 2. 66
-II2-
2^/'feELi MI MAfey
/-4C7-&/E. /5E r^/^/^/tSA T/O A/
-US'
: . 'SS/?/S' 2
Phcrc/e 2&7&&/j/M<4TyGtJ,
C:?
<34<5 M// -4-M (^o/ts/^s&^ss/oA/ 30 %y^A/o/s^y'ZS263,//coo
/*/
ZCJ/? /5 5/CA 755 ST////)/ C //V X/0~S> 6w /t(j//P-4-!/) 6 666 Pkcroe
(C5) E'! '2 .... -3 -4 /%,*-*>
V. (M.a) lrak */0~(7
-114 -
SE/?JE5 2' P/?EA//A///AJOY
; -i/7-
. 78ej?o:JO/s/y=T */&'-. v ... *
. / U*SC>/cZTU&3:<C> ?4G<\5 -,'
c' + V*
* f
. : V .
*
t .
c\i
CM cq 01 Vi CN Xh
a
os
\ cXj Vn v/> <x>
O' *n vS CS QN 1Y> XT xS VP
r-
CM Ml (N x.9 NS
c^ (P \
N Cx. in o
f <K o S 0Q
'x CN
CO (V, CM T^ 00 c^ \>3 Oo oo CN Vo VG
;< (IN (N XS vn ON fti
Q\ .Xi C\^ s> bo
(T) C>o .VM.
Os, CM
rv^ cv^ cv^ c<' W
Cr
>.. ..t) .n. \ 'a
G r
*- r-j o- Vo" Vo S S Cl 5 S' <0
O' $0 ^ ^ CM co ^ N r~ O'
v3 co 0 v9 rO V) V
Mi 0 M w M V) tO
X> <M Vo ts^ M) '**
N~ Cr> (> 06 IP s. \ \ N CN ^
$ !g
$ pt at s M ^ ? Cv-j
W'I M) v\ ^ tN-^
g Oo ^ Co ^
5 ^1 . 1Jit
3
<N <M M- >3 N ^ cy> ^
o VO - ^ vn Vi ) CNi\jv^ p)
6 vt cM O' co ^ NS e- O'
V) V N 1 C'J
w > M CM > CM
1 CM V \i
IISM!
'i fj fnrg
x
(MT~Q
$ S ^
g"
^ C'G O C\)
Mj '* N
|;^| $ < o c>
s;ss
f Oc C ^ ^ ^ f
I Cl-) ^ rr, ' i *0 ^) (Vj Cvj^ r> X) u
> tr PO
CN
~\rf~~ 0 N- CM (N. V) CM Xh 6?
JO -- Oo ^ 1 N'l CM ^ V)
i :! k*| 1 CM ^ xS <n yo C() > \9 c^ <J\
lift
VJ! 'ij
<N O CJ') CM ^ oo 'O' X)
N
4
x5 >
f- V x"c'
1 'jo
Vi^i M" vS P VO S v? 5? 2
vO C' 'Cl (M
0 A ; .M; $ 'X Vi r< \$ V f
c5,
^ Vj & O' O'* ^ si S r
!
! $ CO ^ ^ OT) ft * s Jr>_
Hi ;i
rtvi i ^ o ^ 0) CN
MO CM M* x* (Nl ^ OJ t\3
/ VNJ oi CT <A
o v
^ VO oi ^ ^
I I M" ^ O' M- \S c^ vf\
MJ 1 --T
i ^ ;CV q (x. ^ ^ CM O ^ y CK> CM
V'> v; P * V. cf Vi M -oi
<M I M ; ^ V) o- V3 X ^ X ^
Vn vTO xi 0 o (h
^ ^ ^ ^ ^
v1 M i
J 1
V .'} * vi M O' 5 Ovj m' V>
X.
vj 'V.
g?
>! Ooii :, ^*
i ^ v9 CM qj <0 <N(N\J- Oo (N M CM
o
^6 xi Mi cn <5 (Jv to
I'M ^ M- r^- M- o- ?V Vi)
i *o fO ft) CO CO ft> ^ VV) \S N) xS
JL iO
'<)
0 0 0 0 Q V' 0 0
|M>
!>, s 8 1 1
Hi $ VJ $ M v| * X ll
-120 -
5<z/?/<?$ 2 .
A [/&/> (, 6
'2GA&. /sSO/CAr-> STPAJP (,7U V/0~6J ST^A/P 4 (w-2-c) 6A<S PACTOO
(VS x/0'<*) y
(&P) P-! -2 -3 -4 7/4.0.) ( M.0, /0 J
,
5" 46 49 47 . 42 4-3 !9M 2. 45
SO 90 54 94 S4 94 30.9 1. SS
/S /39 140 139 14/ no 53.9 2. GO
20 786 ns ISC ns 125 m 7. GO
25 230 Z2S 229 233 22/ %8A 2. 52
30 2 70 275 176 22} 215 \0S.9 2 .GO
35" 3% 320 32.4 322 322 I2-3J n-.GO
46 SOS 366 3CS 37i 367 141.0 2. GO
45 4/0 469 4/S 4-20 4-12 IS7.9 2.6\
50 4S$ 456 460 466 4.5? 175,7 1.61
55, 50! 504- ' 501 5/3 SOS 197.5 2,6 2
-I2h /
... 2 ::
A V/2AG
GCAO /ASD/C^rf> S/77A/5 C/Z y /g) 3T/2A/AJ &C W-3-C) 0>A.? FACTAA?
M 55 5-2 - 3 . 5-4 (7/ *'f>9 (HU.-) (A$. 'F*) .
- 122 -
<< /?/es 2
/5j<l7'>/2. jD&TiS'/ZM/A/ArYOA/
tv..
IOAO 5r/2A/jJ /<?A)/P //J&S
.-. (itjP) 5-/ e-2 W/.-4.-C 5-3 e~<4
. *. 1 , - M
<3 //4/9 '//53o 322.0 H9/2 (2721
5 ; 1/37/ U4j 304. 7 UZC.7 (2/20
/<D //Szf 1)440 3409 1/220 (2 /35
/5~ K 254 n 393 329.3 ((723 (2020
20 1(240 n 347 3/2.3 J/7W (2044-
25 (U95 l!3of 295.7 I/O 80 K990
30 K/50 11255 272.7 J63.C 7/952
35 n /03 n 209 26/2 //590 //904-
. 40 ((652 // /C3 244.0 (1543 K259
45 Jo// n //9 22 2.2 ((499 (W3
50 /0905 // 072 2H.7 1/43/ ((144
55 /0S2O // 025 194/0 /1405 (i 7/C
Ove&A&G-
4OA> /AJO/CAfrO> ST/PAM C&tso-y zr/z*.3//y A(ujM-c) 66^0- fpcroe.
G
CKJP) 5-/ -2 e-3 -4 (MO J (OMJ. * ^ )
~!Z3~
: 5r/?/& 2 . ' '
FAcrose jD&rg'&jsi//JAT/OA/
CD
2 4 //U) /CATD ST/OO/A! ($* ~ )
/0 C
/] (w-5-c) 5/6tj FCTCJS.
Q&X JLiL 5-2 5-3 -4 ^ Ho.) 1 S
s 4 C 43 44 . 47 43 /%,3 2, 35
lo 9/ 90 90 95' 90 C
3 .7 2.45
is /4o /34 C 13 140 139 54.9 ,
2 4<o
20 m /if m nc HI 12.1 2. 51
25 229 225 22? 27,9 Z7-6. 29.1 2,54
40 112 272. 275 lie 273 /04,? 2 5 , C
35 3/9 52/ 322 320 32/ I23J 2.59
40 363 3CS 36? SCI 3C$ 141,0 2. Cl
45 409 4(4- 4/C, 4/2 4/5 (S 79 2.63
50 4$4 403 4CC . C,
45 4^4 /34.C 7,GC>
55 49 ? 51 / 502 499 5/0 !9o,2 l.(o%
- 124 -
V/uCe JOATA
-126-
APPENDIX C
BIBLIOGRAPHY
-128-