'US007414816B2
2 United States Patent (io) Patent No: US 7,414,416 B2
Watkins, Jr. et al (45) Date of Patent: Aug. 19, 2008
(St) ELECTRICAL CONDITION MONITORING (52)_-US.CL 32493; 73866, 32871.
METHOD FOR POLYMERS jase
(58) Field of Casiction Search... 7265.9 866,
(75) toventors: Kenneth S. Watklns J, Dahlonega, TAS. 6, 786, 802; 324/513-5486, 691
GA (US); Shelby J. Morris, Hampton, 324541, $55.71.
VA.US): Daniel D, Masakowsk Sec aplication file for complete search history
Worsester, MA (US); Ching Ping Wong. ae
Duluth, G 8 Luo, Boise, eo Ref Cited
IDWS) US. PATENT DOCUMENTS
(73) Amine: Polymer Aging Concepts Ie, aoonia A | ater, a
Dahlonega, GA (US) 4.988875 A * V/1991 Ortiz ot ab 280/330
(*) Notice: Subject oany disclaimer the erm of his ««SV7282 A> S194 Krshuc pam
Patent is extended or adjned under 35 SAHRAOS AT 71995 Songer SAT
Ue eres aoe 6008817 A * 121999 Chamberlain etal. 43656
ee acne Gavrtsd A + "12000 Yorkie on 7A NSOX
(22) PCT Fil: Mar 5, 2008 (Continved)
(85) PCTNos — RETIUSosaRes FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
nea 3oI0us9 A B86
(@),(4) Date: May 9, 2005
(87) PCT Pub. No WO03/076983 (Continwed)
Primary Examiner—ThenoasP Noland
PCT Pub, Date: Sep. 18,2003 (8) dtorne, gen, oF Firm Keath S. Watkins
5) Prior Publication Data 6 ABSTRACT
US 20050268734 AL__Dee. 8, 2008
An electrical condition monitoring method utilizes measure
Related US. Application Data nent of elecrial resistivity of an age sensor mode of a
on No, 60/362,157, ladon Mar. conductive matrix or composite disposed in polymeric
No. 607362,157, filed on Mar. retusa as an electrical cable. The cnchctive matix
(6) Provisional appli
6, 2002 ‘comprises a base polymer and conductive filler. The method
61) mmc Jnclides communicating the resistivity toa measuring instr
GOIN 1700 (200601) ‘ment and correlating resistivity ofthe conductive matrix of
GOIN 3344 (2006.01) resistivity of an accelerated-
GOIN 74 (00601) ‘aged conductive composi
GOIN2720——_200601)
GOR 32 (2006.01), 45 Claims, 8 Drawing SheetsUS 7,414,416 B2
Page 2
US. PATENT DOCUMENTS, 2007016681 A1* 72007 Watkins ta
670,787 82% 42008 Kimura et
66802446 B2* 102008 Chaar eta
GSIO7I8 B2* 11/2008 Walon ta
63194120 B2*
20080284232 AL 122005 Rice
A609
FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
WO WO 2006001681 A2* 8/2006
* cited by examinerU.S. Patent Aug. 19, 2008 Sheet 1 of 8 US 7,414,416 B2
Percentage of Volume
Elongation at break (%)
Elongation at break versus aging time for sample
with 25% carbon black
3
8
Aging time (day)
FIG. 1A
Volume Change versus Aging time
Aging timo (day)
° 10 20 30 40 50 60
ee eee aee :
oe °
a i
. .US. Patent Aug. 19, 2008 Sheet 2 of 8 US 7,414,416 B2
Density of sample with 25% carbon black verus
aging time at 125C
Restivitivity versus aging time for sample with
25% carbon black loading(aging temperaure:
125C, measured one day after the sample was
taken out)
100000000
1000000
10000
100
resistivity (ohm-cm)
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Aging time (day)US. Patent Aug. 19, 2008 Sheet 3 of 8 US 7,414,416 B2
FIG. 2AU.S. Patent Aug. 19, 2008 Sheet 4 of 8 US 7,414,416 B2
7US. Patent Aug. 19, 2008 Sheet 5 of 8 US 7,414,416 B2US. Patent Aug. 19, 2008 Sheet 6 of 8 US 7,414,416 B2
FlésUS. Patent Aug. 19, 2008 Sheet 7 of 8 US 7,414,416 B2
Fle 6US. Patent
Aug. 19, 2008
Sheet 8 of 8
US 7,414,416 B2
Flg.7US 7,414,416 B2
1
ELECTRICAL CONDITION MONITORING
METHOD FOR POLYMERS.
‘This application claims priority for U.S. Provisional Appli-
‘ation No, 60/362, 157 filed Ma. 6, 2002.
This application resulted, in part, from research funded by
the US. Department of Energy. Certain rights for any intl-
Jectual property resulting from this application may apply to
the Government ofthe United States.
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
“The present invention relates to methods and apparatos for
determining deterioration and remaining lie of polymeric
material utilizing measured electrical quantities, and, more
Particularly, for determining mechanical properties and
remaining life of a polymeric material by measurement of
‘lecrical resistivity ofa conductive composite of the poly
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
‘The polymeric materials use in wire and cable insulation
‘and jacketing (and other polymers) degrade with age, espe
‘ally in severe environmental conditions. The saleoperation
‘of existing and future plants such as nuclear power plants
requires monitoring of the insulation materials in onder to
‘anticipate degradation before performance of the wire and
cable is adversely affected,
‘Age related wire and cable failure is primarily a mechani-
‘cal mechanism. A te insulation ages, it becomes embritled
‘and eventually fails mechanically by cracking and exposing
bare conductors. The industry has spent considerable time
and effort to develop condition monitoring methods which
‘monitor installed wire and cable and ensure that the materials
Ihave not degraded excessively. These methods are also used
1 predict safe operating lifetime of wire and cable insulation
materials for anticipated environmental conditions. Pres-
‘ently, cable condition monitoring (CCM) methods are catego
Firal ws mechsnical methods, chemical methods and eleti-
cal methods.
Elongatio-at-break (EAB) has traditionally boen one of
‘the most common tnd well-documented CCM methods, This,
mechanical method measures the elongation ofa sample of
insolation material just prior to break and is normally
‘expressed asa rato ofthe break length divided by the original
length ofthe sample. Since elongation measured i the testis
analogous to elongation occurring when bending wire and
‘cable, the results can be easily cordate to actual wire and
‘able insulation condition. Arhenius methods described by
‘others are aormally wed to predict material lifetime at target,
‘ambien! temperature from acceleration aged data.
‘A serious disadvantage ofthe EAB method is tha area.
tively ange sample portion is required to perform the tes.
‘This makes the test essentially destructive since the cable is
‘rendered inoperative when the sample is removed. Even if
‘able is sacrificed in order to run a test, some portions ofthe
‘cable may be difficult or nearly impossible to access for
‘ample removal, 8 would be the case ifthe area of interest
‘within a cable bundle, wire tay, or intemal toa penetration.
‘The equipment newded for measurement is relatively expen
sive and requires specialized skills.
Tndenter modulis tet isa relatively new mechanical test
that utilizes @ machine to press a small anvil at constant
velocity against the outer surface of the cable or insulated
‘conductor while measuring the force exerted on the anvil. The
indenter modulus is defined asthe slope ofthe force-position
4“
2
uve. A major advantage ofthe indenter modus tests that
theteativelis mon-dstrctve However, the testis Timed
‘se on conductor insulation sinee access oa sufiint length
of individual conductors i often restricted. Also, the test
fot practical on cable withincabl bundles oriays,orinother
confined spaces
Oxidation Iniveton Time (OTT is chemical conton
monitoring method that uilizes small (8-10 mg) samples
removed from able insulation materials. The methodutizes
4 dilfereatial scanning calorimeter (DSC) to provide an ind
Cation of the rapid oxidation ofthe sample when anti-oxi
dns, normally preset in the insulation materia, are
txhavsted. Short induction times indicate exatation ofthe
ati-oxidant ad anticipate api degradation ofthe materia
Sanple collection gure acess othe cable which mits
testable portions of the cable Messtrement requires expen
sive laboratory equipment and specialized taining
Electrical condition monitoring methods inchide insu
tion resistance, high potential es, an-la ts, and io
Jigod gas medium et Thess ests are essentially "g0-00-20"
tess not predict the remaining lifeo the sample) since no
‘welhestablished methods reliably predict insolation lifetime
based on the results. Several ofthese tests require high ele
tcl potentials o he connected to cables, requiring removal
‘of corncted equipment an loads in ond foe the test 10 Be
performed.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
‘Therefore an object ofthe resent inventions to prove
condition monitoring msthod for polymers which proves
the ability to measure an electrical property of a conductive
cenmposhtof he polymer ins aon-fesructve rane.
“Ater objec ofthe invention is to provide a conton
roaring method which allows corelation ofan else
propery of a conductive composite ofthe polymer witha
Imechaical proper
"Atoer abet ofthe invention is to provide a coiton
socioriag etied which lows croatia of on eect
propery of a conductive composite of the polymer wih
Fenians lit of he pole
Sill nae’ objet of the vention i to provide a condi-
tin monitoring mod which ublizes contocive poser
{racer to monitor te aging conditions in any environment
The methodology ofthe proposed condtlon monitoring
method utlizes th lectical easy of a conductive come
poste Rrned fom w cant polyrcrmtral es ighly
Fensitve measurement of a mechanical property (volume
Strinkage). Volume shrinkage intra, willbe orate sa
tmechaneal indicator of ison mitral aging. The
‘method eliminate disadvantages of urentmethods nd po
‘es condition monitoring meta which niprves sty
tt pooes contiion mentocag cos
“the incorperation of inert conducive panicles into the
priya to ea» condone couyoete peories ental
Sign advantages for condition mentoring:
(1) Asal change in volume ofthe conductive compite
‘eli a lange change in electri resist. A few
percent change in vous faction ofthe inultcn
Inner provides poten ofS orders of magnitude
Sore change inthe esis othe composite. TH
ihmensreet serait vies nonpoint