Professional Documents
Culture Documents
It has been recognized for many years that muscle function influences bone formation and morphology. It is
hypothesized here that the movement of bone into new positions within a muscle system results in
rearrangement of the stress distribution and reorganization of shape and internal structure. To test the above
hypothesis, clinical and animal experiments involving the use of posterior occlusal bite blocks, Herb9 appliances,
and temporal and masseter muscle stimulation were undertaken. Chronic or continuous alteration in mandibular
position within the neuromuscular environment with the posterior occlusal bite block and the Herb& appliance in a
sample of monkeys produced extensive condylar remodeling and change in mandibular size. Short periods of
induced hyperactivity in the masseter and temporal muscles were associated with the production of malocclusion
symptoms. Excess induced temporal muscle activity of specific frequency and intensity may interfere with the
remodeling of bone grafts placed under the temporal muscle, while a lesser level of activity was associated with
bone remodeling.
460
Primate experiments in malocclusion and bone induction 461
HERBST APPLIANCE
#978 $hvmile
..... END OF CONTROL 14 WEEKS Fig. 5. During a 45week control period the mandibular tracing
----- END OF EXPERIMENT 18 WEEKS
superimposed on metallic implants showed that the condylar
process remodeled in a posterior direction. However, after
Fig. 4. A posterior occiusal bite block, 12.00 mm. thick, was
placement of a Herbst appliance for a 18week period, a small
placed in an adult monkey. There was remodeling of the con-
amount of remodeling in the condylar area resulted in a superior
dyle in a superior and posterior direction at the end of the 18-
condylar direction.
week experimental period, as compared to 14-week control
period.
-Pre-treatment
Fig. 7. Condyle and glenoid fossa of a juvenile animal (No. 978)
- ----After 6 months Herbst appliance the1raw
after 13week Herbst appliance treatment. Extensive bone for-
mation on the postglenoid tubercle (6) and the posterior and
.--...--.After 7.5 months observation
anterior surfaces of the condyle. Prechondroblastic and chon- Fig. 9. Patient R. R. Superimposition of tracings of mandible to
droblastic layers are showing a width increase. M, Lateral show changes due to treatment and growth. The condylar
pterygoid muscle attachment. (Hematoxylin and eosin stain. growth direction is posterior and superior after 6 months treat-
Magnification, x3.0.) ment with the Herbst appliance.
direction only. Vital staining with alizarin red S posterior occlusal bite blocks were used to rotate the
showed extensive bone remodeling at the anterior areas mandible down and back, show hyperplasia of the pre-
of the ramus (Fig. 6). Ground sections with tetracycline chondroblastic and chondroblastic cartilage layers after
vital staining and decalcified sections stained with he- 4 weeks of the experiment, as compared with the nor-
matoxylin and eosin showed bone formation on the sur- mal width of the same areas in a control animal. After an
face and interior of both the condyle and the glenoid l&week experimental period, this difference did not
fossa. The glenoid fossa also showed extensive bone exist; the proliferative chondroblastic zone had been
formation in the posterior region after 13 weeks (Fig. remodeled into a trabecular bone and now showed pre-
7), with continuous forward posturing of the mandible. chondroblastic and chondroblastic layers of normal
Decalcified sections from another experiment, in which width (Fig. 8). The ground sections in the Herbst ap-
464 Woodside et al. Am. .I. Orthod.
June 1983
Table 1. Malocclusion induction by stimulated muscle activity in juvenile and adult monkeys
Muscles stimulated Malocclusion
superior and posterior direction of remodeling (Fig. 9), jet, and partial crossbite when compared with control
while the primate experiments with bite block therapy animals (Fig. 11). The tracings show that this was as-
and Herbst appliance therapy show, on the one hand, sociated with bone remodeling changes in the palate,
superior and posterior remodeling and, on the other, which normally descends (Fig. 12). These experiments
superior remodeling only. Clearly, the direction of clearly demonstrate that changing the muscle activity
condylar remodeling may be influenced by therapy, but will affect bone morphology.
at present functional appliances are employed for this
EFFECT OF MUSCLE ACTIVITY ON BONE
purpose without our knowing either the type of muscle
INDUCTION
activity or the positions in which the mandible should
be placed in order to obtain the desired change in shape Induced changes in neuromuscular activity may
and structure. take the form either of increased rate and intensity of
muscle contraction or of increased tone. While the
INDUCTION OF MALOCCLUSION previous experiments confirm that changes in neu-
Further experiments have clarified the effect of in- romuscular activity may affect bone morphology, it is
creased muscle activity on jaw morphology and tooth not known whether the activity responsible for the ob-
positioning. Our goal was to change contraction fre- served bone changes is phasic or tonic. Harvold,37
quency in selected muscles of mastication without therefore, developed another experimental model based
severing nerves and muscles or damaging tissue. Stud- on the following observations of muscle attachment and
ies of this kind call for long-term in vivo muscle reattachment:
stimulation .37 To achieve this, highly miniaturized, 1. When bone grafts are placed on the skull bone,
self-powered muscle stimulators were devised for im- new bone is formed on the exterior and in the marrow
plantation under the skin of a monkeys back (Fig. 10). spaces of the graft and the graft is progressively re-
Eleven-centimeter lengths of bipolar cardiac pacemaker sorbed.
leads, set in tunnels under each animals skin, were 2. When bone grafts are placed on the skull bone
connected to electrodes implanted in the muscles to be and the overlying muscle is removed, no new bone
stimulated. They delivered a 4.5-volt pulse lasting 1 forms external to the graft, but only in the medullary
millisecond every 3 seconds. The result was a visible spaces and between the graft and the skull base.
twitch in the muscle, with associated jaw closing, in the 3. If a muscle is detached and left in close proxim-
two adult and three juvenile animals used (Table I). No ity to the bone (3.0 mm.), the muscle will reattach.
malocclusion resulted from unilateral stimulation of the 4. In the above situation, new bone will form be-
temporal and masseter muscles for periods lasting from tween the bone surface and the end of the muscle.%
1 to 5 months, while bilateral and simultaneous stimu- 5. If the muscle endings are left beyond a certain
lation of the temporal and masseter muscles in the early distance from bone, no bone will be formed at either
transitional dentition was associated with malocclusion the bone surface or the muscle ends.3g
symptoms which increased steadily during the 12 These observations indicate that formation of new
months after stimulation. These symptoms consisted of bone depends on the presence of both old bone and
spaced and labially inclined incisors, open bite, over- muscles in reasonable proximity to each other. They
466 Woodside et al. Am. J. Orthod.
June 1983
also indicate that new bone may form under the in- 25inch inductively loaded dipole, mounted inside a
fluence of some as yet unidentified muscle activity. It vertical 4-inch (diameter) polyvinyl chloride pipe in the
appears that the environment in which bone will form is center of the cage. Transmitter and antenna were tuned
closely related to existing bone; this may indicate de- to the 13.560 mhz diathermy frequency.
pendence on the physical micro-environment close to The receiver implanted under the animals skin
the bone surface or on factors associated with bone (Fig. 10) was powered by a pair of Matshushita BR
substance itself.40 2323 3-volt lithium batteries, which fitted inside the
On the basis of these observations, an experimental tuning coil and provided many months of power. Such
model designed by Harvold37 was employed to provide radio-triggered stimulators are ideal because the stimu-
a region outside the skull where the tissue was rela- lus pulse width and repetition rate can be remote con-
tively sheltered from physical movement except for ac- trolled. A l-millisecond pulse was used, with its fre-
tivity in the temporal muscle. The activity in this mus- quency varying from once a second to once every 5
cle could be monitored and also stimulated. The goal seconds, depending on the experiment.
was to get a clearer idea of the nature of the stimuli Sites for our study of bone-muscle interaction were
originating in the musculature which affect bone for- located on the right and left frontal and parietal bones
mation and remodeling. The instrumentation used for below the linea temporalis. The side on which temporal
muscle stimulation was developed by Vreeland and as- muscle activity was modified by the muscle stimulator
sociates.41 was the experimental side, and the other was the con-
A 60-watt-output, AC-powered radio transmitter trol side.
was mounted on top of the monkey cage. It was keyed A 5.0 by 1.0 cm. graft was removed from the iliac
by a B-volt negative pulse from a conventional labora- crest and cut into pieces to provide grafts for both ex-
tory pulse generator. The transmitting antenna was a perimental and control sides. The superior part of the
Primate e,ymments in malocclmion and hone induction 67
temporal muscle was exposed, and sufficient muscle extensive condylar remodeling and change in
flaps were lifted from the skull on each side. The inci- mandibular size.
sion was made within 2.0 mm. of the muscle origin to 2. Downward and backward mandibular rotation
ensure that the graft was in contact with the muscle. To may produce large increases in mandibuhr
avoid mobility, the grafts were tightly bound with liga- length.
ture wire to holes drilled in the skull. The free end of 3. Short periods of induced hyperactivity in the
the muscle flap was reattached to the skull by suturing muscles of mastication are associated with
to the remaining tissue at the linea temporalis (Fig. 13). the production of long-lasting malocclusion
The telemetry unit was then activated to begin the symptoms.
muscle twitch at the required rate of repetition. Exper- 4. Muscle activity beyond certain limits may intl:r-
iments have ranged in length from 7 to 42 days with, to fere with bone remodeling.
date, six animals out of eleven having had two to four The original work presented in this study was made p:~s-
pairs of grafts for sequential removal after 14, 2 1, 35, sible, in part, through Grant MA7362 from the Medical Re-
and 42 days. search Council of Canada and Grant DE05397 from the PJa-
In a 42-day sham-operated control animal, exten- tional Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Md.
sive bone formation occurred on both the control and
experimental sides at the ends of the grafts nearest the REFERENCES
ends of the muscle fibers. This is in contrast with the 1. Wolff, J.: Virchows Arch. Pathol. Anat. Physiol. 155: 25(j,
results obtained when the temporal muscle on the ex- 1899.
perimental side was stimulated every 3 seconds. In an 2. Thoma, R.: Synostosis suturae sagittalis cranii ein Be&rag zur
experiment that lasted 42 days, the graft on the control Hlstomechanik des Skelets und zur Lehre von dem Interstitiellen
knochenwachstum, Virchows Arch. 188: 248, 1907..
side showed extensive bone formation, while there was 3. Baker, W. L.: The influence of the forces of occlusion on the
only limited bone formation on the experimental side. development of the bones of the skull, INT. J. ORTHOD. 8: 259,
In another animal, the temporal muscle was stimu- 1922.
lated every second for 16 days. In this animal, bone 4. Washburn, S. L.: The relation of the temporal muscle to the
form of the skull, Anat. Rec. 99: 239-248, 1947.
formation was inhibited on both sides (Fig. 14, A and
5. Bassett, C. A. L.: Clinical implications of cell function in bone
B). When the muscle was stimulated once every 3 sec- grafting, Clin. Orthop. 87: 49-59, 1972.
onds for 14 days, the control side showed beginning 6. Harvold, E. P.: Experiments on mandibular morphogenesis. In
bone formation and the experimental side showed McNamara, J. A., Jr. (editor): Determinants of mandibular fotm
none. and growth, Ann Arbor, 1975, University of Michigan Press,
pp. 155-178.
This contrasted with an experiment in which the
I. Armstrong, W. D.: Bone growth in paralyzed limbs, Proc. Sot.
muscle was stimulated once every 5 seconds for 14 Exp. Biol. Med. 61: 358-362, 1946.
days. The control side showed beginning bone forma- 8. Geiser, M., and Trueta, J.: Muscle action, bone rarefaction and
tion, and, in addition, it appeared that there was a small bone formation (an experimental study), J. Bone Joint Surg.
amount of bone formation on the experimental side 40(B): 282-311, 1958.
(Fig. 15, A and B). These experiments show that elec- 9. Saville, P. D., and Whyte, M. P.: Muscle and bone hypertrophy:
Positive effect of running exercise in the rat, Clin. Orthop. ,65:
trically induced muscle contraction at a rate higher than 81-88, 1969.
one repetition per 5 seconds may interfere with bone 10. Pratt, L. W.: Experimental masseterectomy in the laboratory rat,
formation at the end of detached muscle. This finding J. Mammal. 24: 204-211, 1943.
corresponds with observations made by Harvold and 11. Washburn, S. L.: The relation of the temporal muscle to the
his associates.42 form of the skull, Anat. Rec. 99: 239-248, 1947.
12. Rogers, W. M.: Changes in the human skull associated with
This series of continuing experiments is designed to
muscle atrophy resulting from anterior poliomyelitis and other
clarify the type of muscle activity which must be causes, Anat. Rec. 97: 364-365, 1947.
elicited by orthodontic appliances, particularly func- 13. Rogers, W. M.: Experimental changes similar to asymmetry
tional appliances, to generate desired changes in man- observed in bulbar polio in the skull and mandible of monkey
dibular position and bone remodeling. Better under- following trigeminal lesions, Anat. Rec. 121: 357-358, 1955.
14. Rogers, W. M.: The influence of asymmetry of the muscles of
standing of the role of neuromuscular activity may mastication upon the bones of the face, Anat. Rec. 131: 617-
serve as a basis for improved therapeutic methods in 629, 1958.
orthodontics. 15. Horowitz, S. L., and Shapiro, H. H.: Modification of mandibu-
lar architecture following removal of temporalis muscle in the
CONCLUSIONS rat, J. Dent. Res. 30: 276-280, 1951.
16. Horowitz, S. L., and Shapiro, H. H.: Modification of skull and
1. These experiments strongly suggest that chronic jaw architecture following removal of the masseter muscle in the
or continuous alteration in mandibular position rat, Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 13: 301-308, 1955.
within the neuromuscular environment produces 17. Avis, V.: The significance of the angle of the mandible: An
,- _-. $-t;cc.
hu1r 483
experimental and comparative study, Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. profile of masseter muscle in the long face syndrome, J. Den!.
19: 55-61, 1961. Res. 60(A): 491, 1981.
13. Moore, W. J .: Muscular function and skull growth in the labora- 33. Altuna, G.: The effect of excess occlusal force on the eruption of
tory rat, J. Zool. 152: 287-296, 1967. the buccal segments and maxillary and mandibular growth dt-
I> Gardner, D. E., Luschei, E. S., and Joondeph, D. R.: Altera- rection in the macacca monkey, M.Sc. thesis, Department of
tions in the facial skeleton of the guinea pig following lesion of Orthodontics, University of Toronto, 1979.
the trigeminal motor nucleus, AM. J. ORTHOD. 78: 66-80, 1980. 34. Harvold, E. P.: Altering craniofacial growth, force application
23. Washburn, S. L.: The effect of removal of the zygomatic arch in and neuromuscular bone induction. In McNamara. J. A.. Jr.
the rat, J. Mammal. 27: 169, 1946. (editor): Proceedings of Moyers Symposium, Ann Arbor, 1982,
21. Howell, J. A.: An experimental study of the effect of stress and University of Michigan Press.
strain on bone development, Anat. Rec. 13: 233-252, 1917. 35. Mercer, W.: Dento-facial adaptation to protrusive function in
22. Washburn, S. L.: The effect of facial paralysis on the growth of adolescent children with a modified Herbst appliance, Thesis,
the skull of rat and rabbit, Anat. Rec. 94: 163-168, 1946b. Department of Orthodontics, University of Toronto, 1981.
23. Chor, H., and Dolkart, R. E.: A study of simple disuse at- 36. Hutchison, L. G.: Herbst appliance therapy in adolescent chil-
rophy in the monkey, Am. J. Physiol. 117: 626, 1936. dren: Stability of skeletal and dental adaptation, Thesis, De-
24. Watt, D. G., and Williams, C. H.: Effect of physical consis- partment of Orthodontics, University of Toronto, 1982.
tency of food on the growth and development of mandible and 37. Harvold, E. P., Centre for the Management of Congenital Mal-
maxilla of the rat, AM. J. ORTHOD. 37: 895-928, 1951. formations, University of California, San Francisco: Personal
25. Scott, J. H.: The growth and function of the muscles of mastica- communication, 1982.
tion in relation to the development of the facial skeleton and of 38. Chierici, G., Centre for Congenital Anomalies, University of
the dentition, AM. J. ORTHOD. 40: 429449, 1954. California, San Francisco: Personal communication, 1982.
26. Nanda, K. S., Merow, W. W., and Sassouni, V.: Repositioning 39. Harvold, E. P.: The theoretical basis for the treatment of hemi-
of the masseter muscle and its effect on skeletal form and strut- facial microsomia. In monograph accepted for publication,
ture, Angle Orthod. 37: 304-308, 1967. American Cleft Palate Association Educational Foundation,
27, Meena, V. H.: A study of the effects of surgically repositioning 1982.
the medial pterygoid and masseter muscles, M.Sc.D. thesis, 40. Urist, M. R.: Biochemistry of calcification. In Bourne, G. H.
Farleigh Dickinson University School of Dentistry, 1975. (editor): The biochemistry and physiology of bone, New York,
28. Humphrey, T.: Development of oral and facial motor mecha- 1976, Academic Press, Inc., pp. l-59.
nisms in human fetuses and their relation to craniofacial growth, 41. Vreeland, R. W., Harvold, E. P., and Chierici, G.: A com-
J. Dent. Res. SO: 1428-1441, 1971. pletely implantable muscle telestimulator for monkeys, Poster
29. Spyropoulos, M. N.: The morphogenic relationship of the tem- session, A.A.M.I. 16th annual meeting, Washington, D.C.,
poral muscle to the coronoid process in human embryos and May 10-13, 1981.
fetuses, Am. J. Anat. 150: 395-410, 1977. 42. Harvold, E. P., Chierici, G., and Vargervik, K.: Personal com-
30. Bobechko, W. P., Herbert, M. A., and Friedman, H. G.: Elec- munication.
trospinal instrumentation for scoliosis: Current status, Orthop.
Clin. North Am. 10: 927-941, 1979. Reprint requests to:
31, Finn, R. A., Throckmorton, G. S., Gonyea, W. J., Barker, Dr. Donald G. Woodside
D. R., and Bell, W H. : Neuromuscular aspects of vertical max- Department of Orthodontics
illary dysplasias. In Bell, W. H., Proffit, W. R., and White, Faculty of Dentistry
R. P. (editors): Surgical correction of dentofacial deformities, University of Toronto
Philadelphia, 1980, W. B. Saunders Company, pp. 1712-1730. 124 Edward St.
32. Boyd, S., Gonyea, W., Bell, W., and Finn, R.: Histochemical Toronto, Ontario, Canada M5G lG6