Professional Documents
Culture Documents
J U LY 2 0 1 7
2
INNOVATE FASTER
WITH FIELD-DEPLOYED 5G PROOF-OF-CONCEPT SYSTEMS
2017 National Instruments. All rights reserved. LabVIEW, National Instruments, NI, and ni.com are trademarks of National Instruments. Other product and company names listed are trademarks or trade names of their respective companies. 28846
FEATURE REPORT
focuses on gigabit per second mo- One reason that people are produces highly integrated silicon
bile and fixed access solutions for focusing on the fixed wireless, core IC solutions and silicon front
millimeter wave systems, explained Wolter said, is, in part, because as end for millimeter wave applica-
that fixed wireless is just natural, you mature this technology, itll tions, and also partners with Ball
analogizing that as cellular re- be easier to do that first because Aerospace on the production of
placed cordless phones, 5G is going the equipment can be larger, more phased array antennas. Gresham
to the same thing for data. What 5G power hungry and so forth, and still agreed that, compared to mobile, de-
is doing is making the last hundreds useful in that application. If you livering fixed wireless over millime-
of meters wireless. Theres not go- look at how we provide access to our ter wave frequencies is a relatively
ing to be any DSL, copper or fiber. customers, its a mix of technology, static problem. My base station is
Posed with the same question- including fiber optic cable, coaxial fixed, its at the top of a pole; I just
-why fixed wireless as the first cable, and hybrid approaches like have to send data to these 14 houses.
phase of 5G?-- Dave Wolter, AT&T fiber to the node, then copper from The first point is from a practical
Labs assistant vice president of ra- the node to the home or premises. If point of view. The second point of
dio technology and strategy, gave a you think about that area where you view is coming from a business case
similar response. go from fiber to some other technol- point of view. I think the infrastruc-
ogy...there may be a place where you ture roll out for mobile connectivity
can provide higher data speeds than is going to be a lot more complex.
are currently available in a cost ef- But, from a Verizon or AT&T per-
fective way. Its sort of the right tool spective, one of the main costs is the
for the right place. We think there is process of laying cable and feeding
probably a segment of the market, fixed infrastructure to all the hous-
driven by density of users and how es. If you can do that wirelessly and
densely you can deploy the base increase the customer base, that can
stations and kind of traffic theyre save them a lot of money.
looking for, thats an economically
viable deployment. Theres no one Understanding the business case and
size fits all. Its going to be the right solving for the last mile
tool at the right time. We think milli- Alphabet subsidiary Google Fiber,
What 5G is doing is making meter wave fixed wireless is anoth- part of one of the largest, most lu-
the last hundreds of meters er one of those tools. crative, well-funded, technological-
wireless. Theres not going to
Ian Gresham is a distinguished ly advanced companies in human
be any DSL, copper or fiber.
fellow of technology at integrated history, had grand plans for deploy-
Farooq Khan, Phazr
circuit firm Anokiwave, which ing fiber-to-the-home and offering
4
FEATURE REPORT
consumers gigabit per second broad- access, he said, this is something problem is, you bring it to each home
band as well as a television offering real. This is something our custom- then only 25% of homes sign up for
when it started in 2010. After an ers are doing. The business case for the service. With wireless you are
ambitious expansion plan gave way fixed wireless access will work. The not bringing any wire to the home,
to very slow deployment and activa- price point, of course, makes the so you are never going to invest in
tions in early markets, the company business case work. This technolo- customers who are not going to sign
scaled back and put a pause on new gy allows [smaller service providers up for your service. You will only
market entries to regroup. like WebPass] to challenge the big send the CPE [customer-premises
When this happened last year, carriers, the big service providers, equipment] to a home or a business
Scott Cleland, president of consul- with a service, that in some cases, who signs up for the 5G service.
tancy Precursor and former deputy outperforms the service that is de- Maysel summed up the economics
U.S. coordinator of communica- livered by big carriers in a fraction of delivering fixed gigabit service
tions and information policy for of the time. in millimeter wave spectrum. We
President George H.W. Bush, called Timing--another major driver of
Google Fibers FTTH approach a the business case behind 5G fixed
dead business model walking. wireless access. Khan called the
He forecasted a shift in marketing speed of deployment the most im-
away from an emphasis on the fi- portant thing. The idea is, of course,
ber aspect. To that point, Google ac- there is going to be some cost advan-
quired a relatively small, San Fran- tage, but assuming theres no cost
cisco-based service provider called advantage over fiber, the biggest
WebPass in October. advantage is youre going to light up
Boris Maysel, director of business these 5G base stations and instantly
development for Siklu, said of Web- cover the neighborhoods. Fiber, if
Pass, Id say that 80%, maybe more, you want to bring it to 100% of the
of their network is based on our population, it might take a century.
equipment. The way we position This is the greatest advantage 5G is Fixed wireless access, this
that is fixed wireless access extends going to bring over fiber.
is something real. This is
something our customers are
fiber. This hybrid fiber/wireless He continued, stressing that
doing. The business case for fixed
approach is what drives this [fixed fixed wireless access is ideal when
wireless access will work. The
wireless] application. The tech- residential density hits around
price point, of course, makes the
nology is cost effective enough to 1,000 households per square mile.
business case work.
serve single family homes, where- Wireless is a shared resource, he
Boris Maysel, Siklu
as FTTH is not. Fixed wireless said. With fiber-to-the-home, The
5
Each evolution in network technology brings new
opportunities and new user experiences. 5G is shifting
from an industry vision to a tangible, next generation
technology. CommScope connects people and technology
through every evolution. Together, well prepare and
discover the potential for 5G technology.
Visit CommScope.com/5G
commscope.com
have installations of one, two, three What are the carriers doing? customer then had the device, which
miles of coverage. This is really AT&T and AT&T Labs have a big terminated the 28 GHz 5G signal,
the last mile kind of solution. The presence in Austin, Texas, where the then we distributed that to multiple
use case for that is either MDUs or telco offers gigabit-speed home and users via Wi-Fi. We gave it a workout
businesses where the business case business fiber broadband, as well as to what an enterprise would need
is pretty obvious. The challenge is as its 5G Evolution service, which from that kind of a system and let
when you go and try to target the uses three channel carrier aggrega- the employees of the enterprise use
single family home markets. The tion, multiple-input, multiple-output it. We are, in fact, continuing that
challenge is not to be lower cost or (MIMO) and 256 QAM to double the
cheaper than fiber, the challenge speeds of its regular LTE speeds and
is to make the business case work is only available on Samsung Gal-
from the consumer perspective. axy S8 and S8+ devices. In addition
Ayvazian pointed to the 5G fixed to these mobile-related initiatives,
wireless access testing being con- AT&T is using Austin as a testbed for
ducted by AT&T--more on that later- its 5G fixed wireless access services.
-to illustrate the business advantage In partnership with Ericsson and
of using wireless, rather than fiber, Intel, AT&T last year used millime-
for the last mile. Theyre starting on ter wave spectrum in the 15 GHz
the towers where they already have and 28 GHz bands, to test enterprise
their base stations. They want to get 5G applications at one of Intels lo-
the signal as close to the households cal offices. That trial pushed more
theyre trying to serve, and as effi- than a gigabit per second in sup- We want to make sure that the
ciently as possible, without having port of enterprise apps including infrastructure we deploy can
to deploy a bunch of fiber. internet access, virtual private net- provide both mobile and fixed
The trials we are doing, Wolter of work connections, 4K video stream- services. Youre not going to
AT&T said, is going to help us pro- ing, delivery of DirecTV and VoIP. want to have separate networks
vide data for that business model The field trial extended lab testing
for those two things. As you
to see under what conditions does
move toward a software-defined
in several frequency bands and in-
network, network functions
it make sense to do this. In these volved not only Ericsson, but also
virtualization and network
areas, lets consider going out and Samsung and Nokia.
slicing, thatll help us optimize
doing that. Wolter, AT&T Labs AVP of radio
the service. Were really in
Now, lets take a closer look at technology and strategy, said the
learning mode right now.
the trial work being conducted by trial at Intels office had a range of
David Wolter, AT&T Labs
AT&T and Verizon. about 250 meters. The enterprise
7
FEATURE REPORT
work, but what weve done now is to device in the customers premise have to start getting into those
extend that to a friendly user trial behind a window pointing out to- questions and simulate the system,
that involves residential and small wards our base stations. In addition including all the scheduling behav-
business users. to generally putting the technol- ior to see what that all looks like.
That trial, also in Austin, uses Er- ogy through its paces, Wolter said That one is a little tough to answer
icssons 5G RAN (radio access net- the operator is studying millimeter as were a little early in the day.
work) and Intels 5G Mobile Trial wave propagation characteristics He explained that for this expand-
Platform. Ericsson AIR 6468 is billed in both line-of-sight and non-line- ed 5G fixed wireless access trial,
by the Swedish infrastructure giant of-sight conditions. Weve run fiber from our lab out to
as the industrys first 5G NR-capa- As to the number of devices that two telephone poles we have a little
ble radio; it has 64 transmit and 64 can be served, he continued, thats less than a mile from the building
receive antennas for massive MIMO going to depend on the ability of were using. We have the baseband
and multi-user MIMO, as well as ad- the software. What is gets down to units in our lab. Whats out at these
vanced beamforming enabled by a eventually is what does the traffic poles are the radio heads. One of
split cloud RAN architecture, and load look like, what is the demand? our apartments is behind proba-
is meant to support LTE and evolve When you talk about capacity, you bly 20 meters of foliage between
to the coming 5G standard. Intels
Mobile Trial Platform, the second
generation of which was unveiled
at Mobile World Congress earlier
this year, features a 28 GHz radio
frequency front end and 4x4 and
8x8 millimeter wave arrays. This
trial extends functionality from an
enterprise setting to include resi-
dential and small business custom-
ers, and delivers DirecTV NOW over
a fixed wireless signal.
What weve been looking at
there, Wolter said, is adding ad-
Source: AT&T
8
FEATURE REPORT
the antennas and the window this by AT&T, use cases for 5G fixed highly flexible network design to
unit is in. As you would, given the wireless access could include a cus- meet emerging 5G use cases.
beamforming capability, it has ac- tomer going to a dentists office and Like AT&T, Verizon is also scru-
tually found a bounced signal that using connectivity that allows cus- tinizing the propagation charac-
is stronger than the main signal. It tomers to do things like immerse teristics of millimeter wave trans-
is getting around some of the ... fo- in augmented or virtual reality as missions in various deployment
liage by bouncing around that. Oth- they pass the time...A hometown re- scenarios. At the 5G Innovation
ers are direct line of sight. tail shop can utilize the enhanced Summit, held in May and hosted by
Another major factor, particu- reliability to enable an all mobile test and measurement firm Rohde &
larly given modern construction checkout experience. Schwarz, Krishnamurthy Sreenath
techniques, is window attenuation, Verizon is in the process of expand- and Howard Tang of Verizons 5G
Wolter said. You cant just say, Ill ing a 5G fixed wireless access pilot network planning and strategy op-
put this 5G modem in the closet and project to 11 U.S. markets, which erations, pointed to the work that
connect my internet. Thats not go- the company said will include Verizon has done through establish-
ing to work. Right now everything several hundred cell sites that ing its 5G Technical Forum to work
is mounted in a window facing the cover several thousand customer with vendors on developing a plat-
base station. Reflective window locations, in Ann Arbor, Mich., form for fixed wireless trials using
coatings are a major hindrance; Atlanta, Ga., Bernardsville, N.J., millimeter wave spectrum. Verizon
Wolter said AT&T had to replace Brockton, Mass., Dallas and Hous- would like to see the ecosystem
infrared reflective glass with more ton, Texas, Miami, Fla., Sacramen- grow, Sreenath said, and the soft-
traditional dual pane glass. Thats to, Calif., Seattle, Wash., and Wash- ware-centric environment of 5G
going to be a concern that people ington D.C. In May, Verizon shared means that new vendors have the
have to think about if youre trying some details of its testing in Mich- opportunity for easier and faster
to do any kind of indoor deployment. igan, which involved a Samsung integration with new systems.
The equipment is not ready to do virtual RAN solution, base station Tang described a set-up of struc-
that just yet. And, while Wolter said and home router equipment, while tured and systematic outdoor-to-in-
AT&T has verified beamforming, Cisco provided a virtual packet door testing in the field that
beam tracking, beam acquisition, core. The companies focused on involves three to four clusters of
higher throughput and lower laten- interoperability between the core endpoints to create small areas of
cy-- all the things youd hope to find and radio networks and user devic- coverage and assess coverage con-
in a millimeter wave system,--but, es. Adam Koppe, vice president of ditions with targeted single fam-
at the end of the day, Everything is network planning, said, Interop- ily homes or multi-dwelling units
dependent on environment. erability, a key milestone towards across varying topographies. He
According to materials provided 5G commercialization, allows for noted that since the trials involved
9
mmW Solutions. Enabling a new world
C
27.5 - 30 GHz operation
M
>50 dBmi Tx EIRP
>-7 dB/K G/T Rx sensitivity
Y
Y
+/- 60 2D electronic beam scan
Programmable beam width and taper
Y
MY
K
Scalable for hybrid beamforming MU-MIMO
11
FEATURE REPORT
T-Mobile, in usual fashion, is in a particular direction. Now, the architecture would be for a TDD 5G
blasting its competitors 5G efforts, technology is being adapted to system and converged them at 28
while making big promises of its meet the needs of service providers. GHz. It was an educated guess and a
own; namely, the so-called Un-car- Anokiwave is at the forefront of gamble, but weve had an extreme-
rier is targeting 2020 for a nation- this evolution, Gresham explained, ly strong pull from the marketplace
wide 5G deployment using its 600 noting the company has decades for those products. Anokiwave has
MHz spectrum. Mobile 5G will cover of experience working in A&D and also recently released products for
you wherever you go. Thats real 5G, satellite communications, but, in the 39 GHz band, which along with
not fake 5G! And thats nationwide that type of application, he said a 28 GHz is of major interest to AT&T
mobile 5G, not fixed 5G, Ray wrote. single piece of equipments cost a and Verizon.
In May, following T-Mobiles an- few million dollars, which limits
nouncement of nationwide mobile the potential market. There was
5G by 2020, Sprint, along with Qual- this pent up demand, so if we can
comm and parent company Soft- drive the cost out of them and make
Bank, gave a few details, saying the them order of magnitude cheaper,
goal is to provide commercial ser- theres this new market and set of
vices and devices in late 2019. Sprint applications we can open up.
is targeting its 2.5 GHz holdings for Gresham said initial interest was
5G, with CFO Tarek Robbiati saying in the 60 GHz WiGig space. Our
in 2016 that, In our mind, 2.5 GHz is thought process was, if we can make
going to be to 5G what 800 [MHz] is phased arrays for commercial and
to the 4G world. Sprint is also work- consumer products at 60 GHz, then
ing with Nokia on testing 5G in the its applicable also for 5G. That was Phased arrays are a completely
73 GHz band, and with Ericsson in our initial starting point. What has
new technology for operators,
and the higher the frequency you
the 15 GHz band. been surprising to us is how fast the
go, the more problems you have.
market has accelerated and how
We wanted to give them a helping
Developing antennas and testing quickly demand has accelerated. hand up the ladder by putting our
millimeter wave systems We started developing products for hands on the table and saying
Phased array antennas, tradition- 5G about 18 months ago. We knew this is not intended to be your
ally used in aeronautics, defense the 5G bands were likely going to end solution or a field deployable
and satellite communications set- be somewhere in the 20 GHz to 40
thing, but itll help you figure out
what all those problems you need
tings, transmit a signal to a series of GHz space. We took some of our sat-
to figure out are.
coordinated antennas which work com products at 30 GHz and took
Ian Gresham, Anokiwave
together to increase signal strength our best guess at what the likely
12
FEATURE REPORT
Anokiwave partners with Ball Conference in San Francisco, used hardware components of a radio
Aerospace to put its IC technology OFDM with eight component car- like filters, amplifiers, modulators,
into planar phased array antennas. riers in a 2x2 downlink MU-MIMO etc...onto a software system to facil-
Gresham said the companys long configuration resulting in a 5 Gbps itate rapid reconfiguration. What
history with millimeter wave tech- throughput, scalable to 20 Gbps the SDR allows users to do, Shirai
nology, coupled with its product with eight MIMO streams, accord- said, is to prototype these wireless
portfolio, is meant to provide oper- ing to National Instruments. communications systems using
ators with a reference design that NI actually has been involved a real-world, over-the-air signals to
can be used to develop a field prod- lot with some of the industry and define waveform and modulation
uct. Our value proposition as a com- academic researchers that are ac- characteristics. We are actually tak-
pany is we dont just sell you the IC. tually leading and defining the 5G ing this whole SDR approach from
Well work with you to understand standards through 3GPP, Furea the hardware and the software
your system problems and tailor Shirai, National Instruments prod- perspectives. This flexibility in the
the IP and the system architecture. uct marketing manager, said. As prototyping business is really the
Phased arrays are a completely new companies develop and test 5G key to quickly build a prototype.
technology for operators, and the systems, National Instruments pro- National Instruments LabVIEW is
higher the frequency you go, the vides both hardware and software the systems engineering software
more problems you have. We wanted solutions that allow for real world used to test, measure and control
to give them a helping hand up the simulations. Relative to millimeter prototyping hardware.
ladder by putting our hands on the wave systems, NI offers prototyp- Nokia worked with National
table and saying this is not intend- ing tools for waveforms in the 71 Instruments to study millimeter
ed to be your end solution or a field GHz to 76 GHz range, as well as in wave systems, using the companys
deployable thing, but itll help you the 27 GHz to 29 GHz range. software solutions to facilitate a
figure out what all those problems Shirai also discussed the role of unified design flow through the de-
you need to figure out are. software-defined radios (SDRs) in velopment process, so [Nokia] could
Earlier this year National Instru- prototyping. SDRs essentially move rapidly prototype its its ideas for
ments used Anokiwaves 28 GHz millimeter wave mobile access in a
phase array antenna to demon- fraction of the time of convention-
strate a real-time, over-the-air al design approaches.
Source: Anokiwave
13
Featured Companies
FEATURE REPORT
access in place, commercial services optimize the service for fixed and
are expected to hit the market pri- mobile 5G services. Were really in
or to standardization of the full 5G learning mode right now.
spec by 3GPP. And, just as key learn- Gresham said theres still a lot
ings from fixed testing are being of problems that need to be solved
used to inform the standards-setting with a mobile solution on two levels,
process, fixed wireless and the at- one of which is having...32 or 64 an-
tendant use of millimeter wave will tenna elements on top of a pole is a
serve to inform the ultimate transi- lot more tangible than having those
tion to full-blown mobile 5G. on the back of a phone. Theres just
The physics are the same, Wolter practical problems associated with
said. All the work we do on propa- a mobile application as opposed to
Especially with the millimeter gation, the impacts to propagation a fixed position where you have a
waves, theres still a lot of and how you deploy the base sta- base station that talks to a CEP on
research that needs to be done on
tion, the core network, the trans- all the houses on a block.
different deployment situations.
port, all those things are translat- Gresham did note that some deploy-
Fixed isnt probably going to
able into the mobile environment. ment scenarios--he gave the example
answer all the 5G use cases, but
itll be applicable to some. In fact, he said current testing in- of deployments planned for the 2018
Furea Shirai, National Instruments volves putting a fixed wireless end Olympic Games in PyeongChang,
user device in a truck and driving it Korea--will serve as a bridge from
a potentially monetizable service around to test mobile connectivity. fixed wireless access to limited mo-
while further studying high fre- Were constantly testing the limits bility. You have thousands of people
quency transmission schemes seems of the equipment. moving around in a stadium environ-
to be the guiding logic. Especially As to the physical infrastructure ment, so, yes, its a mobile situation,
with the millimeter waves, theres needed to deliver fixed wireless ac- but its limited mobility and youre
still a lot of research that needs to be cess, Wolter said, We want to make moving at a slow rate. Its not going to
done on different deployment situ- sure that the infrastructure we de- be solved in one day. Itll be a step lad-
ations. Fixed isnt probably going to ploy can provide both mobile and der function. We solve the fixed case,
answer all the 5G use cases, but itll fixed services. Youre not going to we understand what a lot of those
be applicable to some. want to have separate networks for beam acquisition problems are going
those two things. As you move to- to be, then we solve for MIMO, then
From fixed to mobile 5G ward a software-defined network, limited mobility, and then vehicles
With carrier interest, and ecosys- network functions virtualization moving in an urban environment. Its
tem support, for 5G fixed wireless and network slicing, thatll help us going to be an evolution.
14
Featured Companies
National Instruments
National Instruments provides platform-based systems that enable engineers and
scientists to solve the worlds greatest engineering challenges. NIs flexible platform
is used by researchers in both industry and academia to help usher in the next
generation of 5G wireless communications, including advancements in mmWave and
Massive MIMO as candidate technologies for 5G.
CommScope
CommScope (NASDAQ: COMM) helps companies around the world design, build
and manage their wired and wireless networks. Our network infrastructure solutions
help customers increase bandwidth; maximize existing capacity; improve network
performance and availability; increase energy efficiency; and simplify technology
migration. You will find our solutions in the largest buildings, venues and outdoor
spaces; in data centers and buildings of all shapes, sizes and complexity; at wireless
cell sites and in cable headends; and in airports, trains, and tunnels. Vital networks
around the world run on CommScope solutions.
Anokiwave
Pioneering the mmW revolution, we are a fabless semiconductor company providing
highly integrated silicon IC solutions for mmW 5G, RADAR, and SATCOM markets. As
the mmW Active Array IC Solutions market leader, our customers get the fastest-time-
to-market with expert systems engineering and optimal technology solutions..
Huawei
Huawei is a leading global ICT solutions provider. We are committed to creating
maximum value for telecom operators, enterprises and consumers by providing
competitive solutions and services. Our products and solutions have been deployed
in over 170 countries, serving more than one-third of the worlds population. More
information visit: www.huawei.com/us/
15
UPCOMING 2017
E D I T O R I A L P R O G R A M S I N C L U D E :
AUGUST 2017
Incremental content
Wireless Infrastructure Series:
Reducing opex through infrastructure
269,957 monthly video minutes viewed on RCR Wireless News Youtube channel Industrial IoT Series:
68,522 monthly videos viewed on RCR Wireless News Youtube channel IIoT manufacturing and smart metering
Industry leading demand generation programs and results Telecom Software Series:
Management and orchestration in hybrid network
architectures