nporPAMM HblE

BbICTynnEHV1A
MACTEPOB
3An A,[lHO
E B PO nE ~C KO ~
nV1TEPATYPbl
xx BEKA

Cl>PAH~lJISi
lJITAilMSI
lJICnAH H~
rEPMAHlJISf
ABCTPmI
WBEMl.4APlJISi
WBE~lJIjI,
AAHlJISi
HOPBErMSI
BEnlJlK06PlJITAHlJISf

o.
'0

o
~a
ro
)to
Ke

IEl"! V13,QATEnbC TBO . n pOrPECC b

MOCKBA e
1986

3
 BaeTeCh "An CTaJTbROH KapKac .R 3bI Ka: 0pY:>KHHbl MllTpat.\a OCTaJTHCb Q T06b1 OblTh c .o paneAJIHBblM, ayJKHa 60JIblIDUl 1nI~ . Ee MbI
qCJIbI. Bbl :>Ke B3J1eTeJllf fla B03.t\YX. B 'feCTHOCTH BawHx CTpeMJIe ImH .D,OCTH.I '3eM M}'JK.eCTBOM c-:rpofQCTIl. n a, Nhl .D,OJDKBhl pelJlBTbC.Sl Ha 3TO
COMHeB.m fleT . Ho jj HaxmKY npHCKopORbIM. 'ITO BaM nOCTOJIH.HO B HAAeJKAe , qrO O.D,UY 33 .lUJyroB MbI fpOM03j\HM 6ecCMe pTUbl e neJIH,
rrplIXo.t\HTCR 8H,AeTb upe.t\ COOOlO npeU.RTCTBJ'UI, 'ITO Bbl OOCTOHHHO :p.D,O Bepji B T O, "ITO MbI JIHJ.IJb HrpyUJKa TBOpetfWl , a TO, 'ITO BaM
.t\OJl)f(HbJ HaraJTKnnaTbCji aa HHX, 'ITO BaM He ,AaH3 JlerKOCTb <J:RCTOro, Ka3aJlOCb ne.nHICHM, TO Bblcmee -Bcero .TUro.Ib M3.JJeRhx:aB 3KcnepH
UeTeOpeTlf3.FJpYJOlI\ero no::na. 03J1eTalOmero H~ npen.RTCTBWlMH. 8,,1 MeRT. C apxa3MY nOABepr n OCh 6b1 Bee TO, "ITO MhI mo6HJIH, OaIDa
HanpaCHO TpaTHTe CBOft nap yOc)f(.t\eHRH Ha Hac. 3aHHMalOmHXCR crpacTL npe3Hpanacb ObI. Y'lHTLmaJI 31'0, Mhl P;OJDKHbJ nepeiITH B
CO,{HRHTeJIbCTBOM. IlJtacnr'lHOCTH. KOaneHTpaQ"Hlf H HBTeHCHnHOCTI1 08cryruteHHe. He06xo,AlIMo MY)l(eCTBO 6oJlhmee, ~eM TO, lCOTOpoe
MO:>KRO ,AOCTK'"lb MROrHMH nyTHMH; Bam "Y1'h RaoepHRKa He ny'lIlIH"R H yraeplK,qaeT. 6ynro OqepWieT H aa.nyBaeT ce6ji, BCKPblBaa 'Iepen
OPM JlR xopounu1 He nO'ITlITe 3a TPYA , OOY'IliTeCh } Hac! BalUH cp;enrumo B. oeII\H H3 mo60UbITCTBa. 'lT06b.1 Y3.HaTb, eCTb 1IH BHyrpH
KHflT'lf nOKa3aJTH. ~ITO Bhl-XVnO:iKRlfR:. 0031", Ii 3Hepnfji Baunn; He~o BenpexOnRIIlee. TOJIbKO yMeBlte He p;OBepjiTb caMOMY ce6e He
HHCTRlIKTOB. cBoGona If eITHOcn. Bamcro RarypaJIHlMa. Bawa ):I8eT yraCH)ITb TOCKe, rrpH,AaeT D03HTRBROMY 3axOJl'{eHHbJe qepTbJ.
arn1i3poTH!<3 BCTpenlT Y Hac If Y MeIDl UOJlHyIO CHMnantJO. Ho TOJIbKO TaK. Hc.tIbrryJOIQKH B3rJUl,D, crrocoOeR coxpa:aan. AHCTaB:qHlO.
H11Korna Ha 3aobIBaiiTe, 'ITO neT HCKYCCTBIl, CCTb TOJlbKO TOT lITO TOllbKO Tax H~e3UeT roproRonOAOOlJaR rOJlOBa H8IIp3BJJeHIUI,
neJlaeT HCKYCCTnO, 'ITO Ka)K.llbJJi paCTCT rrO-CBoeMY H .llomKCIi HCKJllO ., aurpb.lBalOIIlaR co speMcBeM, H BOT MhI BTOprneMCji B ero cep~l\e.
'''",CJJbHO 6epe)l{HO 00parq3ThCSI C ceoe nO,AooUL1M B JlHTepuType He OJnIHM e1fRHhlM nophlBOM. Uepe60H 3TOro cCPMa CBSl3aHbI C npom
cymeCTByeT MaCCOBoro yunnepCaJTl>Horo npOHJBOJlCTB3 To, 'TO He llhrM H C 6Yro'lI(HM. T01fbKO C nOMOlJU>1O crpOJKa.H:mmt xy,D,O:lKeCTBeo
3aBoeBaHO C06CTBeHHh[M)l CBJlaM.t , He } Aep>KKWh. He CTPCMIlTeCb h HLlX yCTaHOBOfC MhI np~eM fcO BnCBpeMeHBOH TO'lKe 3peHIUI. Ho,
CT3.llHOCTIt. OT Hee JlHII1b MHO! 0 mYMa H MaJIO wepCTH . BbIBe,AUT~ CBOkl OJKeT 6bITb. 'f}'T HaM .D,6JDI(H0 TOJIbKO )JC,I{3Tb. nepHTb H Ra,tlemDCji
8ll} H3 30HW onaCHOCTFI. IT03a6oThTeCb 0 CBOeM q,YTYPH3Me. jf o oe BeAaTb. OJtBHM 'wIbT BJla,JleeM BaBel)RJlKa; Gonee OllLrTHhrM
nO'3aOOl.JYCb 0 CRoeM ne6JJ1tHH3Me . B3rJUl,D,OM B3f.JUl]t Ooparqeu K HCTOpHlf. OHa )f(e Bcero ; mUTh Jlortl'lRa,
r llyxa K re....HblM B33.KMOCB~3.SIM BHYTPR H,AeR. .u;yx He. pa3BBBaeTC$I
1913 ! lOI'H"IBO, C:le!\y~ ooJlee rny60KH.M CYJlaM. oH , 8ocnapReT. neWlCb HllH
OelMOJIBCTBY:JJ. Mbl JJHIIIb OJ:llYU1,aeM ero. B3aHMOCIDl3H BC OPSIMOllH
KA3L-1MIi1P 3,QWMIi1,Q OeHm.I, OUB r.ny6:>Ke, '1eM BRABMaJI CTopoHa speMeHH. K TOM)' )fCC
3KcnPECCMOHM311 B n033MM
Ha.t\O }"llITbJBaTh, 'ITO 'lHCTO j)opMa.rn.Roe palBHTKe y Hac .JIHIlleBO
KOf,Aa CBji3aH C KaKHM-RH6rnb ):IBI1 qeTfCOCTH. TaJOI(c TPY.D.RO AOCT}'UHbI H "tJRCTO OpHeBTHpOBO'lDble
:>KeHUeM .IIH'l.RO H Oll.\YLQaeIl1h OOTpeOHOCTb BbICKa3aTbC~ 0 ReM, CBC,AeOJUI 0 BHeIDHeM XO,Ae pa38HTBJr 11 repMaHBH .
TpeoyeTcR npe:>K.Ae Bcero RenpCKJlORHOCTh H CaMOOTnatta. rJlYOOKO Y Hac eIlle HCT TPa.o.JlWIH, exne lIeT TBepnoH POAROH nO'IBbI, Ha
aeplI B R.D,elO, TpeBQ)lomU,Cji 00 ee ,AOJITOBe'IHOcm. B3rmlJ~, Ham KOTopoa B nponecce opraHB.q}Joro pOCTa pa:mHB8eTCji H.D,eH. Bo
CJlHlDl<OM norpY)f(eHHhrH B 3eMHYlO )f(H3HL, cnoc06eR n erKO OOMaHyTb ~P3.fIllHH, aanpHMep. ~IH pesOIDOJ:(BOllep CTOHT oa WIeqax CBoero
CJl B cBoeH OpHBep:>KeHROCTFI. Ho 6eCKoHTpOJIbR.aji CTpaCTh HeYKpOTH opeAmeCTBeHBHKa. B repMaHHB BOCeMBaJtll3.TWI.e TlJlrli ~8eT .llBa
Ma. TOJlbKO Bepa, Tep3aeMaR TOCKOH, B KOHne KOsnOB CTaHOBHTCH M8TBJIeTRerO ~1WTOM. Bo ~ M01I.op;oii B K3XOH-TO crencBH
,AeHCTBeHROJi. OCMbICJleHHe 803HRKaeT BCJle):l 3a HeaepUblM mafOM. ysa:lKaCT B CTapmeM cooero POAIf'l'eJUl. Y oac OB era HroopHPYCT.
nOHOWemte COOCTBeUHoro caMOOTpeqeHUJI AeJlaeT era no ~aJIIlY3 qepnaCT H3 cpeAOTO<mR HapOABoro BeeMHpBoro 'l}'BCTBa.
H3CTOJiIQeM}- Cn3JIoCTHhIM. Ha &1Horoe RY)f(RO PCWHThCJl 3.t\eCh, qrOOhl HeMe~ KIDK,t(hrB pa3 Ha'IBHa.eT C JC.aKoro-HH6YP;b HOBoro MeCT3 B
H30e)f(aTlJ HeBRSITHOCTH. pel.UlfTbCji ua Bce. 'fTOObJ OonjiTh, B '1eM OPOBR~. Y HaC eIlle MHOroe - KOIlBYJlhCHJI q,opMBp}'JOII{erocR
upas,na. OAHa .1IHllIh 3Hq,OPIt.Sl- CTpaCTb orpaRH'IeHRbIX. CMenOCn1. HapO,AlIoro MeHTaJIHTeTa. EIlte MHoroe npeACTaBJUIeT coOOH lJH3Bepra
KOTOPOi1 3BaKOMbl COMHeHHH, AOCTyTmhl OJlarOpOARble ~eJllf. Y IOIIlKiicR xaoc, He npeepaTHllOCb eIlle B PaBmmy , CDoc06JJy1O BbJAep
nOCWlIIteHHOro co~aCTBYIOLQerO - :>KeJTaHlie UPOA.1UI"Ib .D,O oeCKOOe'lllO )KJ{B3Tb 6oJIblll1le uacpY3KH. n03TOMY Y Ha c 6o.JIee BeHCTOBble, Gonee
cnl ceoe nepe)((J{BaHlIe, KOTOpOMy 00 Ii rrpunaCT oecnpeneJJhHyIO oecnpeA e1fbRhl e, HO 60Jree Tep3ae MbIe npOTHBOpeq]UIMH xY,AOXCecTBeH
q,OPMY np" 3TOM npHCTpaCTffOCTb OTHHMaeT y Hero cnOCOOHOCTb KhJe npoH3Be.D,eBJDI. Y .llPYnoc: oapo.D,O"B cpop Ma M e Bee nO,ABep )l(eua
BepROH oqCRKR. n03TOMY TYT MO)f(eT ObITh TOJIhKO O.D,RO TpeOOBaHHC: B3MeUeH.HJDt.
CYPOBOCTh. TaJ<: }')l(e .D,OOKe opH n OHClGlX Cyn(BOCTH B0 3 lIBICleT "fPY.D,U OCTb, KaK
OO"eKTBBRaR p eanhHOCTb jiBAAeTCJf n e peA HaMR co Bceit O'feB(!):I nep eAaTb j)OPMaJILHoe pa3BHTHe . H CTOPlDl" TaIOKe B 3p;e Ch DJUlCTCSI
OOCTbIO TO.rn.J.(O B TnKOM OOHa:>KeRHOM BU.D,e. Ho B 3TO Mhl rO)Ke JIHlUb JIHlllLBHelIIRBM P }'KOBO.D,CTBOM. Co speMe.HH POMallTllKH qapBJJa
npe.D.'IYBCTByeM. OKOB'laTeJIbHOCTb C}')KJteRHR BbDIBHT TOJlhKO Bpe C'I"3.fIIa.l\BJI. Ho BOT u aqaJIC.Sl Be.lIBIOIH B3J[CT oypX<}'alHOr O qyBCTBa,
MR - He BpeMeaHOCTb BamHX ABeiL n OK.a3bmaIOIIlerO TenepJ. n epBblC opB:ma.K:B c ooero K.O~ Do 06ec
300
301
 JCp08JleHHOMY 3 nHrOHCTBY Y.IlapWIa lJaTYPaJIHCTH~e CKa})BonHa. 113 }lOCTll'lh n03THqeCKMX 4c.!JeO mWlh nOCpC,QCTBOM
f0)10 rO Q>aKTa
no~ I"pHMa, H HfOBor o JIHCTU fieCCTbJ.llHO }1BUJlC}1 cfIru<T.
acaAa )KM3BM' OTOrpa<tmpOBaJili51 ,QeHCTBHTellbHOCTH
H B1I1IbiX 'lynCTB.
HH'Iero CYIllHOCTHoro . HHKaKOU nO.llmrHHOCTH 3a npe~MeTOM qYB CTpOrnH 3aKOH r eopre BbIIIJell 3a npeAeJlhJ Taiinoro COI03a, YTBep
CTBeRROrO MHpa. Tom.Ko HKCallH}), OJlRH lllUiMeUOBaUIDI. Ho r080 nHJ1C1I B n033ID1 n 3CCe, B ,IlpaMC H pOMaHe H cnOC06CTBOBaJI
PHTC$J Bee C rpaRllR03ROH, MOII{ROIl rpOMomaCHOCTblO, He HMelOw,elf BOClIHTaHHIO.
3Ra"feHR$J ~JISJ xygo)l(CCTBeUHoro npOInBe.neHIDI B ero OKOH4aTeJlbHOH Tax K YMeHHIO BHgeTL aKTbr rrpHflaBMOCh 'IYSCTBO q,opMhr.
q,opMe HO JlalOU(eii 11MDym.Cbl, n06Y:>K,QalOll.(Hc K 60pb6e. HaTypa HMITpeCCHOl:lH3M aOllO)KRJI Ha"faJIO nOnbITKe CllHTe3a.
JIH3M 6'bIJI 6RTBou . KOTOPaJf caMa DO ce6e HMeJIa MaJIO CMhlC.na, HO Oli B OnpeAeJleHHOH 06naCTR 08 6hJJl. ~3)Ke }lOCTHrH}'T. Hanpa8Jl5l
nopOnHJI ROBbm 06pa3 MbICJIeH . IOlI\He }lBH:>KeHHJf 3nOXH CJlBBannCb BMeCTe, 110 paJrOp8.Jlf(Cb OB.H B
HeQ)KH~aBHO BHOBh B03HHKJ11t ~OMa. 60JIeJHb, JlIO,QH, 6e,QBOCTL. KaKOH -TO OnpC,IlcneRHhrH MOMeBT. 31'0 6bUlO HCKYCCTBO MOMeHTa.
cpa6pUlrn. Y BHX ew;e He 61>1)10 CB1I3J.1 C Be'lliblM, OBB He 6b1J1H TOT. KTO C03J:{aBaJI ero, 6hlJI 06PaJOsaH H DonOH 3aMhlCJl.OB . C
OfiJlO,llOTBopeRbJ HAeeH . Ho 0ID1 6blllH BaJBaJD,J, nOKaJaRbl. OOHIDKH Hmy-poR 06pamannch C BepBH"IeCKOii He:lKBOCThlO . IIpmf3Bc,QeKHJI
JI}ICb 3y6bJ 3nOXlJ n CB~eTeJTbCTBOBa.Jm rOJlo,Qe. Ou no~uM nOpO~a.nH.Ch BCllbJWKaMH TBop"lecTBa. DblJla nOIThITKa pemJITh Bce
4eJTOBe4eCKHe BonpoCbl B 3TBM npH6ml3UJl HaC K liCTIUIHOMY .Ou np06J1.eMhl UP" nOMOII{H U3htCKaHBOH Texumm, 80 3TO 4.aCTO DpRBO,QH
TeCRO oepenneTaJIc.Jl C COtV'laJIhHbIM, OU BhlKPHKRBaJl: ronOJl, npoCTB no K OIDlC3TeJlb1l0CTIi. IIO,QllBHlfbrH, nOCJle,QHHH CMhJCJI H306pa:>KaeMO
TYTKH, 3lll1,!leMHH, pa60~U1e. ro Be 6hlJl elQe AO KOR~a yTpaqeH. Be~h CSeTOBOH JJY"f TBop...a
Ho, HC ItMe$J npe,QCTaBJleHIHI 0 CBOBX S03MO:>KROCTHX, 08 60poncJf OCBeTBJI ax JlHlllh Ra MrROBeHbe. EblJlB OCJ1enwreJlbf{hJe :>KeCTbI,
He TOJJbKO C $IB.1TeIDUlMH npexo~sunllMB, Y Hero 6hJJIH TIUOKe TBOp4e 60iKeCTBeRRhJe MOMeHThl. 1ieccMepTRoe lJCDJIhmaJIO, OllleJJOMJUUlO H
CKHC a.M6H1..tJm. OR ,nYMaJI. 'ITO MO)KeT 060RTlfCh 6e3 ,nyxa, H 3aTeM HC'ie3aJIO. 31'0 6wlIo .KaK B3blBaBBe K 60ry, tIMf ,npO)f(alQBe 04epTa
60pb6y 6YKa.JJ1.Kl.t C 60rOM. 31'0 H CTaJlO erOKOHI...\OM. OB npocyw;e BID! nap.JlT B B0 3Ayxe. OJl(YlI{aIDTC5I, 110 EfJfKOr,lla ae BblJIHBaIOTCS B
CTBOBaJJ He ,n01lhille B3,1l0xa. peaJIhHY IO OPMY. EWJIH MOMeflTaJlhBhle CHHMKH, CBH.Jl:eTeJlhCTSY
Ero 6eCCHCTeMHOH Opraall3auIDI npOTHBOCTOj[JJO }lB.H)l(elUle, nOJl JOl.l.{He 0 rcpaCOTe, 6blJlll )KeCThl, rOBopsunlle 0 f ny6HHe, MO:>KeT 6btTh,
Hoe apItCTOKpaTl13Ma. B npOTHBOBec ruYMy - ,nBOPJfHCTBO, He'ITO BMCJlO MeCTO ~a)Ke KaKoe- TO ,Q eBCTBHe, KaK011-TO n OCTy nOK. an
aCOJJ.HaJIhROe , BCKYCCTBO a tout prix I. CJIlllJJKOM BhJCOK3$J o ...eUKa MrROlJeHbe BhtpBaBlllruJCSI. Ba CBeT 6eCCMepTRaJl K p a COTa.
MeXalrUCTHQeCKOrO npKBClIa K TOMY, 'ITO eraJIR 3aMC'IaTh ,nymy. Ho H 3Ta 3noxa Haxo,nMaCb B TOM orpoMBoR cepe, KOTOPaJI,
H TYT CHOBa JlBWlaCh U0331HI. BeJlHK3$J wrypa C TeQ>aaa reoprc 6y~y"fB ,QOCTYUHOH 6yp:>Kya3HblM npe,QCTaBJleHHSIM, 6 YAY"IlI nOABJla
BCTaeT nepe~ HaMJI. Ho eMY, ew;e apHBep)KeBHOMY K 6JIH3J1e:>KaII{HM CTHOH KaIDITaJTRCTH'ieCKHM 06CTowre.J IbCTBaM, OCTaBaJIaCb RHAH1UI~y
4JiCTbJM q,aKTaM, He ~aao C03~aTh BC.JIID(HX Bce06beMJIlOIQHX TBope aJlhHOH. 3a60Tbr H RYJK,lI,hl B1QJ,ll1lR,nyYMa :>KMH B Hew. Eyp)f(YaJHoe
H1lH, 'ITO BblpaJH)"rn 61.1 TeMll, AYX B OPMY csoeR 31l0XH. ,/:lJuI 31'0ro 06w;ecTBo onpe,lleJUUlO TeMhI, np0611eMhI, CO,QepiKaHHe. DPaK, ceMh$J.
SpeMJf e~e He HaCTaJIO. C~eCTBeHReHwa~ 3aCJIyra 3TOro aanpaolle- 6YP)f(YaJ8.0e 6hlTHe CT8J11t TeMaMH, lWTOphI~ xY}lO:>KeCTBeBHO R
1lH}1 6hUIa B TOM 3Ha'leHIDl, KOTopoe ORO npli,!{aoaJIO MO('deHTy OpMbl. TeXHJfl{eCKli JlOBKO pa3pa6aThlBaJmCh. K OT,na :>Ke 06pantaJlHCh K
BHOBh Ha4aJIB OC03HaBan., 'ITO KBJUleTC5I ODHcaTeJTbROCThlO, a 'ITO KOCMH4eCKOMY . TO Re AOCTRraJIIJ ero, pe'lh OCTaBaJlaCb He'UleHopa3
uanpOTDB, RCTBHHOit n033fleH . C TaJI.H ~CRhJMH pa3.JIHtJlur Me:>K,IlY ,neJlhBoii.
6eJlJ1eTpHCTOM H 1l03TOM. H Bce )Ke: OlJR 6 bJJ111 ClIHlllK.OM 4eTKO KOr,l~a 06pamarmCh K npRpO,Qe - nonyqaJIc$J cpparMeRT, 06palQa
COPMYJJ]{POBaJfhl. Ha TOM 3TO ,IlBIDKel:ll{e Ii 3aCThlJlO . O[f}f nYT8.JIf( lIHCh K )J<H3RR - 3aneqaTJleBaJIH MrHOBeBhe, 06paJI(annCh K CMepTH
TBOpqeCTBO C }lOCTOHHCTBOM. BepwlB, 'ITO CYW;Hoe - 3TO aBrYCTeH H306pa:>KaJUl JlHlllh 3aTYXalUle, a He QYI'OBHlI(lloe, HHKor,Qa lIe
rucc, 'ITO ~OCTOHHCTBO ny'lIIJe, qeM MY:>KeCTBO 611arOHaMepelfHOro npeKpaD..\alOU(eeC5I TparJ.!'leCKOe C06hITBe.
BMCmaTCJlhCT Ba. IlOJl,llcp:>KHBaJlCJf KynbT TaRHOH Be4eplf. 3 CTeTH3M MMnpeCCHOHH3M, BHKor,na He 6hlBWHii CTom TOTaJIbHhlM B AaBruHH
FIliXOAIM Bec 60llhruec pacupOCTpaUeBJIe " rrpHinellc$J Ha :,IfiOXY, JIRIIIl> OTphIS01fHbJe C03}laRH$J , TOJlbKO APaMaTH"IeCKBe. J1HpH'leCKHe
KOTOP3$J, o60ranmlDHCh 3a rO,llbl rpIOH~epCTBa. ncpeHaChITHBtDBCh BJIH ceHTHMeRTaJIhlIble. npe,l{BalBa'lelJR'hIii ,IlJljf O~Horo :>KeCTa, 6 hm
UPlITOKOM }leHer, BCpHJ1a B TO, "ITO MO)KeT llrpaTh pOJIh npeJCpaCHoro lUHit. mlDIb qyBCTBOM, HO 'laCTonpa,naoasonrH 3THM MalIeHhKHM
~ CKa,Q aHCa Ha ew;e a6COJllOTIfO ae COPMIJpOBaBWeitC5I KYJlbTypHOii OTpblBK3M 60Jlhworo MHpa npeKpacaytO OPMY , no OTI10meHHlO K
n04Be CBoeTO SpeMCB.H. KOCMOCY CTaJI H JJ.on:>KeH 6hlJl CTaTh M03aBKOB, sa KOTOPOH Jle)f(aJI
TeM He MCRee 06IQ:Hii YPOBeRb S1.rpOC. nOCJ1e reop rc Y:>Ke He Jlh3$J OTCBeT 60:>KeCTBeHHOrO TBOpeBHJf.
6bl1l0 3a6bITh. "ITO xy~O)KCCTBeJfBoe TBOpeHBe HeMhlCJlHMO soc Ha 6eC41lClIeHHhle MaJleHbKBe qaCTH pa3n O:>K.HJI OR MHP, ,na6bl
Bhl COKOH OPMhI. OTHLIHe 6hlll0 60Jl.hWe HCB03MO:>K.HO DhrTaTbCjJ BJJ.OXHyrL B Hero 6 0llee rny60Koe JJ.bIXaane. Oll 6hlJl KO~OM ,noJU'oro
pa3BBTWI. 8e.rnmoe npOCTpaHCTBeHHOe 'l}'BCTBO PeBeccaHca 3aBepWlf
I Jl1060ii lIeHOR, 8 0 'ITO 6bl H11 CTaJIO (g;pa lil~.). 110 l,Qech CB Oit n Y Th. OR Bce paJJJaraJI, paCTBOpJf)J, pa36H8aJl ua K YCKH

302 303
H 83 pa3pywellHOrO C0 3,J:(aoaJl M3JlbIe O~eHlUl. BOCC0 3,J:(aBaJI 6ypXCyalBOrO H KaIlRT3.IIBCTHqecKOro MLmmellIDl.
CBJi.3B, yrpaqJffi<Ut apR 3TOM 6hJnylO MacmT36ROCn.. 3 a DJlM Morna OUR He r JUI,IJ; e.IIH.
6h1Tb y->Ke TO.ru.KO auapX1Ul. OOH B3HpaJlH.
4JyryPS3M-3aK1OO'IHTe.ru.8hrH :nan ero pacruma. 3xCnpecCH OBH BC 6blJIR cpOTorpaq,aMH.
OHB.3.M Be HMeeT C HHM HKKaKHJl npB3HaKOB PO,J:(CIBa. 3To OHH, OllB KMe.mt CBOe JIHIJ.O.
q,yrypHCThl, em:e pa3 B30Psan:B npOCTpaHCTBO, pa3fiHToe aa 'l3CTH. HMeCTO 8CJlhllUKH ODD C03nami npoA.o.JDKKreJJhBDe UOJIReHHe.
MHByrt,J, q,opMaTbl, H306pIDKaJi KaPTrmy MJq)a KaK OAROBpeMenROC BMeCTO MOMeHT3-,J:(eBCTBHe B.o BpeMeHB.. OHH Be nOKalblBa./UI
COCCACTBO q}'BCTBeHlfblX Bne'laTnemrn. OHH .IJBUlb CJlelUl.1W 'f3CIl1 fiJlecT.Hl1.\erO llBPKouoro npeACTaBJleEIIDI. OHB. XOTe.llH ,Il.JlJDllerocJl
HMllpeCCROHH3Ma BMCCTe, OTIll.lJBc1JOBalIB nonyqeBBoe, npHAamt eM} C06blTlUI.
yrnoBal)'to tPOP}fy H 60nee upH3pa'lIJhlC OQePT3HlUI. H36eJ1Ul npH cf1aIrrhl UNlClOT :maqeUHe J1Hl1lL BaCTO.IlhKO, 'lT06h1 .o.aTb X}'AO:lK
3TOM KOKeTllHllOCTB, R JlpeBpaTHJDi JlOCJle,J:(OBaTeJlhHhlH XO,J:( RMJlpeCCH KKK} B03MO)K}lOCTL CKB03b I:lHX AOCTH'D. TOrO, 'lTO COKpblTO 3a
OHHCTCKoro MHpOBOro rrpOl\ecca B ropOIlJlHBOC 3.3rHaHImc COCYlIlC HHMH.
CTIJOBaJrne. OU BH.nHT qenoseqeCKDe B npocnrryrKaX.. 6o}KecTBeHBDe B cpa6pH
3KCnpCCCRORH3M . 3ar.llaBHOe C.IlOBO COMIUITeJIbUOU <p<>pMymtpoa Kax. Ou..eJlbHLIM XY,J:(O>KeCTBeIiUhIM ait.."TOM 00 .oK33hlB3eT B.1lHJlHHe ua
KB, HH"IerO 06l1.\ero He HMee-r C KMnpeccHOHH3MOM. OR ShIwen ue In TO .orpoMOoe, "ITO COCTdBJUleT MHp. Ou naeT 60nee rnYOoKHii 06pa3
Hero. Y Hero C HHM HeT HHKaKOH BHYTPeHHeii CBlI3H, ReT All'Ke CBst3" npe.o.MeT8, naRnw.aqrr er.o I1CK}'cCJ:Ba-3TO TOr orpoMHhui paiiCKHH,
C 'reM HOBhIM, 'ITO npH3BaHO npHROIJ'tHTh crapoe. ECJIR "ITO fI H3na\lanbHO COTBOpeHHhlH oorOM Jlaa,t{llIaqrr, 'UD npeKpaCHell, Kpa
06"heAllWleT 3TH ABa nanpaB.IleulUl. TaK 3T0 TO, 'ITO OAUD IloAroTOBWlO CO'lHeit u 6ecKOUe'lHeH TOro, KOTOPhlii HawK rJla3a MOryT BOCDPHmt
APyroe. cne.D.}'R TeMllOMY HMMaseHTBOM}' H aeJlora'lSOM) 3aKOH}' Man. TO.llhKO B 3MIUtpB'leCKOH cnenoTe H OnDeaTb KOTOPblB Tenepb
HHCTKIIKT3., :JaKOBY yCHJreRBSI ~eH n Hap8CTaHH.S1 CJlJIbJ. GblJ10 6hl HeB03MO)KHO.
Y 3RCnpeCCHOHB3Ma 6I.lJlO MHoro npe)J.weCTBeJIllRKOB 80 seeM BeJlBRoe TpaBCCPOPMHpYlOlI\ee BCeJleOcKoe qyBCTBO 6bJJto ltanpaB
Mltpe BO Bce BpCMeoa COO'fBeTCTBeHllO TOMY Be.JJHKOMY 11 BCe061>eMJUO neBO npe)K,Qe BCero npOTHB MOJleK}'JUlpHoro JJ;P06Jlell.oro MJfpa 1iM
II{eMY. 'ITO lIeJKBT B ero OCHOBe To, 'ITO moAB" flHJlSIT cero,J:(RJl. npeccHoRHCIOB. 3eMIDL, 6bITHe npeACT3.IlB t.::aK Be.llH'lecTBeHHoe sH;I\e
3RaKOMRCb C BHM,- 3TO no'TI'B "ITO O~O ro.ru.KO JlHl-'O. TO, ~TTO RHe, BKJIJO'l3BIIIee 8 ce6J1 nIOneii C In "IynCTBaMH. OUB ,J:(O.1DKllb1 6hDIH
6YJ.{opIDKHT, 'ITO 3nanrpYeT. HM He .BR;rJ.BO HYTPa. fiporpaMMhl. 6hITh OC03naHbl B eBoeH nepB03,J:(aHHoii cyra. BeJ1RK<UI MY3h1K8
KOTOpbJe nerICo JlOCTYlIHpouaTh~ HO lCOTDpbJe HeB03MOJK]J0 ocyme n03Tll - 3TO efO repoH. OHH BeJlH'JecTBeIlBbJ Y aero TOJJhKO Tocna,
CTBRTL. POJK.AaJOT B M03fY xaoc, BO KOr.l\a KaKoe HCKYCCTBO 6hlJlO Kor,J:(8 Be.IlH'leCTBeHBO HX 0KPyxeDBe. ORH He cepolfIICCKoro tPOPM8
ABIDKlIMO qeM-TO RUbJM, K3JC Be nOTpe6HOCThIO 3aqaTWI. MO,J:(a, Ta - 3TO npHBeJ10 6hl :mmn. K neKopanmuOCTH,- BeT, ORB BeJlB'le
npeAnpHHHMaTeJlbCl:BO.. crpaCTh, ycnex OKpYJlGllOT ero. OCMemmoe CTBeRHhI B TOM CMbIC.Ile, 'ITO HX 6bITHe, ax nepe)l{lfB3lJlUl - QaCTL
Buaqane. BeJJl:lKOrO 6hlTlUl He68 B 3eMJIH, 'ITO HX cepnu.e, po,J:(CTBeHlloe BceMY
BOT OBR nepe,J:( BaMH, B rnyxOM nop.hIBe TBOpqCCKOro HBCTRlJKT3 npDucxo.o..JJIIJ;eMY, 6beTCJI" B eJ\HHOM pBTMe C MHJ>OM. ,lI.ruI 3TOfO
COTBOPHBIIJHe Hoooe. Kor].{a 11 TpH ro)J.a Ba33,[t RaIlHCM CBOto nepBYto He06x.o)J.HMhl GbUlR no-HaCTO~eMY HOBbIe XY.I\O:lKecTBeHHble 4><>PMLI.
KHIIlj', }I, MaDO 3a60TllBUIHiic.1I Toc,J:(a 0 xY,J:(OJKeCTOeHHblX rrpo6neMax. )J.0IDKBa GbUla 6brth C03nana BOOall CltCTeMa MHp3, KOTOPlUl 6b1
npOqe.rr C Y,J:(KBJJemJeM : BOT nepBhIe 3lCcnpeCCJWBHCTCKHe HOBeJlJIhl. 60llbwe He HMena UH'lero 06meco C llJIT3lOfI\e.HCR JTHIIIh OIlhlTOM
HeAl. C.IlOBO Ii CMblCll 6bJ.1lR TOC,J:(a )J.Jl.H MeIDl nOIlJITKJlMlf HOBhIMH. }I CHCTeM.oH HaTYP3JmCTOB, KOTOpa.8 He lIMeJJ3 6b! lIWlero 06lqero C 'reM
6bJJl rJlYx to:: HlIM. To.m.KO Te lITO 6ecIlJIO].{eH, onepe)K8lOT TeOpaeH .l\p06JJelJ.hlM OPOCTpaDCTBOM, C03A8IOfI\HM MJtMoneTB.oe Boe<JaTJlellHe
npaKTHKY! D,OmKHa 6bUla 6hITh C03AaHa CBCTeMa MHpa, ItOTOpaSl 61.1 BhlpWK3Jla
BbICTYnan, B 3aJ:QlfTY qerO-TO -,J:(illI 3TOro H}')KIJa CMe.nocn... ,D.1I1I Re'lTO 80 MH.oro pal 6o.ru.mee, 6b1Jla 6h1 nOAIDfHBee, a lIOTOM)'
3Toro uY)tQJO 061IaAaTh AOCTOI{HCTBOM, o6"hl1B1U1T1. JKe ce6Jl CTOPOHHH npeKpacBee.
KOM '1ero-TO OJUIOfO - npR3RaK oI'paHll'{e.HHhJX M03fOB. TfI\ecJIaBBeM 3eMJIJl - - 3TO HCnOJIBRCKHH neH3aJK, co3,J:(rumwii AIDl Hac OOroM.
HanO.lmeIJa Bell 3Ta nOBepXHOCTWUl 6opJ.Ga 3a ~, 3a .l\ywy EIa Hero HaAO CMOTpe'Th 1"3K, 'lT06b1 DH HHqero OT HaC ue 3aCJIoUJlJJ.
rp<bKAa.HHDa. nOClleJ(llee CJlOBO HMeer, c o 6CTBeHHO, JIHIIII. cnpaBe,J:(lIJf ElBKTo He COMUeBaeTC.1I, "ITO He M.o:>KeT 6hITb RCTHHUbIM TO, "ITO
BruI , BepBO IDUJpaBJIeHHIUI CIDIa. rrpe,J:(CT3.eT K3K OHeIlIHllJl pea.m.H.oCTh. PeaJlhHOCTb AOJOKHa 6bITh
nOJIBHJIHCb XY,J:(OJKHHKH ROBOro ABlVKeHHSl. OHH He 6hlJIH yJKe C03,J:(ruta ll3.MK. MhI D,D.lDKHJ>1 nOKonan.cJl )J.O CMWCJJa IIpe,J:(MeTa.
B036Y.1\HTeJlSIMH JlerKoro BOJlUeJ:UUJ. OllB He 6hLnH YJl(e 1I0CHTeJU1MJ4 Henb311 ,J:(OBOJILCTBOBan.cJl OUHcaDBhIM tPaJCTOM, IIpHlUlTLlM. Ha uepy
roJlOfO q,aKT3. . MrBoDelIll.e, ccKYfI].{a HMIrpeCeBO.HB.CTCKOrO TBOpeRRlI H1IH .HBJlJI1OlQ,lIM.CJJ. WJO.l\OM uoo6 paxeHlUl, KapTHHa MHpa ].{o JlJKlJa
6bIffil WUl IIlIX mum. OYCTblM 3epBOM D MeJlbB.J'{Qe BpeMeBJJ. ORB He OMen. 'l1ICTOe, He 8CJ(3JKeBHoe OTpaJKerute. H o T3.KOo oe eCTb JlHl1D, B
6hUlH 6o.ru.me pa6 aMH lQl:eii. 6e.l\ H .J1H'lHhIX Tpare,ItHii B .l\yxe sac caMHX.

304 3D5
 TaK BCe rrpOCTpaHCTBO X~0)KHHKa-3KCnpCCCROHHCTa CTaHOB HTC~ e'f 8l0p XYAO)KHHKa. OKa3bIBaeTCSI, OHIi 6bfJIH q,acaAaMlI . 3a KYJlHCa
BH.QeRHeM. Y Hero He B3f~A - Y Hero B30p . OH He onHCbmaeT _ O 1>1 '" II I10)l, jlPMOM OCTaBJIeRHOrO B Hacne,ACTBO OIqyt:neHHJI He CKpblBa
Ji
COpepe>K1lBaeT. O'fl He OTPax<aeT-OH H306pa)l(aeT. OB He 6epeT ~ OIl e1'C SI " H'le TO , KPOMe 1.J.enOBeKa.
HIQeT. JiI BOT BeT 60Jlhme u:eml $aKTOB: !j>aGpHK, AOMOD, 6oJle38eli He 6enoJo.-ypaJ'l 6eCTHSI, He nOA.1lbrli npHMHTHBAhIR '4enOBeK . a
UPOCTBTYTOK, KpHKa H rOJIOAa. ECTb TOnhKO BHAeHHe 3Toro' LJeJIOBeK npocToli , Ge3hlcKYCHbLH. 'The cepAI~e AbIWHT. 'lbR nerKHe
llaH;!\wa!j>T HCK)'CCTBa, rrpOWlKBOBeRHe B fnyGHH}', nepS03,AaHHOCTb I~ nonH.b1 CTPaCTH.; 08 OT,uaCTCSI rrpHpOAe, 00 'taCTI> ee, ee DJJaBRbie
AYXOBRYIO KpaCOl}' KOTOPOro nOJIHO HOBhIMH OTKPbJTHHMJI. R P~OCT5I ABHJKeHlUI OTpruKalOTCJI B HeM . Of! YCTpaHBaeT )lCH31:1b, PYKOBOACTBY
MB . Reb He Me/lO~OH JIOfUKOH, He CJlenCTB.HeM , He nOC1' bJ,I(IJOH MopanblO H
Bce CTaHOBHTCH CBX3aJmbIM C ae'IROCTbJO. BOJIbltOU - He TOJJhI\O npH<tHRHOCTblO, a .fI1ll1lh neCJlhlXaliHhTM KpHTepHeM CBoero 'IYBCTBa. C
CTp3.QalOlWfH Ka./IeKa . OH CTaHOBHTC'" caMoif GOJIe3Hbro, CTp3Aruute rex nop KaK ero uyrpo Bbtp.aa.nOCb HapYiKY . OR CB~3aR co sceM. OR
BcerO ero cymeCTBa H3JIYlfaeT ero TeJIO, BbT3blBaH CTp3AaJUle c03AaTe . nOHHMaeT Map, OH cpoCC" C 3eMJIeH . OM TBepAO eTOHT sa HCit, I!ro
JIJI . .11;OM - 3TO He TOJTbKO rrpeAMeT, 'fle TOJIbKO KaMeHb, Be TonbKO )f(enaIme oxaaTbt.Bael' BB,QllfdOe H YBHAeHHoe . GeJl0BeKOM HaKOHe~
06..eKT 3pe1UUI, He TOJIbKO lleTblpexyrOJIhHHK C aTpHGyraMR rrpeKpa c o MITb OBnaneJlH 60JlbUrne senOCpeACTDeHHbJe qyncTBa. BOT OH CTOH,.
Horo EfJIH )KaJIKoro C~eCTBOBaHHg. OB fTOAHJJMaeTCJI Bblille ace r o nepeA RaMB, a6COJllOTBO nepB03A aHHbtH , BCCb npOfTHTaHHblR BOJIHaMR
3Toro. HY)KBO TaK .QOJIro HCKaTb s ero CaMOH cyrqROCTHoii cyrJ1, DORa c BoeH KPOIUl , H nopblBbl ero cep~lI,a CTOJIb O'leBH.l1.Hbl, 'ITO Ka)f(eTCJI
He npOJlBHTCJI ero COKpbTTa'" a rny6HHe !j>opMa, DOKa .QOM lJe BCTaHeT ero cep.l1.l.\e HapliCOBaHO Y Hero Ha rpYAH. OH GOJIhlUC De 6Y,AeT
BO BeCb POCT, OCBo60)KAeHHLtii 0" 3aTXJTOH 3aBlfCHMOCTB OT ,AeHCTBII cPHrypOH. OR A~HCTB1HenbHO qeJIOBCK. OR 'taCTI> KOCMoca, sepRee
Te.JJbaOCTH, H B HeM Bce AO nOCJIe.IlRero yrOJTKa ODpeAenHTC}I, KOCMII"IeCKorO " YBCTBa. OR B )J<J13.m Re MYJlpCTByeT JlYKaBo. DB }lACT
DpOCeHTCJI AO TorO Bbrpa)KelUUJ , 'fT0. ,[lax<::e PHCKYJ'I CBoeo npK.BbJ'UfOH llPjlMOH Aoporoit. OH Be pa3MblWllJleT 0 ce6e, OR nepe"'lfBaeT ce6R ,
BHenmOCTbJO, OB 6YAeT OKOa'laTeJIbBO roTOB BbUlBHTb CDOH xaprucrep , OH He KPy"'UT BOKPyr .Be[Qei1, OB npOHH1<aeT B nx cepJlu.esHBY DB He
DOKYAa BC BOCrraplIT runf PYXReT, nOKY.Qa Re ITpHAeT B ,[lBIDKeHHe Ji.lIH npllHa,tl.lleiKHT K ClJepXlle.nOBeKaM, OB TonbKO 'IenOSeK, TPYCJlHBblH H
Be 3aCTblHeT. AO Tex nop, nOKa He HCIlOJT8HTCJI Bce, Bce, 'lTO B HeM CHllbHblK, .l1.06pbrH, nO.l1.JlhfR Ii npeKPaCFlliTK, TaKOD, KaKlIM ero Gor,
cmIT. ITpocnrrYTKa Gonee He TO.JlhKO CYlQeCTBO, 06BeWaRHOe H C03.JJ.aB. OTnYCTflll B Mlip. il09TOMY Bce BC[QU, RaCTO~1O CY[QHOCTh
Har<pameRHoe aKceccyapaMH peMecna. Oua UOjjJ3HTCJI 6e3 AYXOB, Ge3 KOTOPblX OB rrpHBbrK paCn03HaBaTb, eMY 6mnKH. Ha Hero He
PYMmJ, Ge3 CYMKH, Gy~eT paCKallHBaTb 6e~paMH . Jill Hee AOJUKRa OKa)KelUb AaBJleIDUl, OH JII06HT 11 60peTCg no c06CTBeHllOMY rro6Y)KAe
HCXO,AHTb ee nO,[lJIHHRaji CYlUHOCTb, H llpOCTOTa !j>OPMbI ~On)KHa GblTb HHIO. E,I{HHCTBeHHoe, 'ITO R.M pYKOBOArrr,- 3TO ero GOJlhillOe qYBCTBO ,
BlOPBaHa Jl3HYTPH nopO[(OM, JI10608hlO, BYJIhrapBOCTbIO R Tpare.l{Heii, a He 9CKYCCTBeRlwe MhIlll11eSHe . TaKlfM oGPaJOM, OB MOJKeT, Bce
BceM TeM. 'fTO COCTaBmleT ee peMeC.ITO. Be.t\b lPHMaJ'I ,AeHCTTHfTen.b Gonee BAOXH08AA))Cb, ,AOCTHr8T b COCTOHH.WJ BblCO'lamuero BooAyweB
HOCTh ee CYlQeCTBOBaHHR 3Ha'leOIUI He HMeeT. Ee IITllJrnKa, ee neIDUl, Be.JJ.Hl(lI'U 9KCTa3 Mox<eT B03.HOCHTb ero ,Aymy. OR nO.l{JIHMaeTCR
noxo,qKa, ee ry6hJ-31'0 cypporaTbI. Ee cyrqeCTBO Be HClJepmlBaeTCSI ~O npeAenOB 60ra Bc1Ilfl<OR Bepuml:fOH 'IYBCTBa, .JJ.OCTH...:b KOTOpOH
lfMll. MO)l(lJO JIHWb B BeCJTblXanHOM 3KCTa3c .t\yxa.
MHP nepe,q JUlMli. BblllO 6b.1 6eCCMbfCneHHO nOBTOpKTh ero. H Bce )f( 3TH JIlOAH Be 6e3paCCYAHbi. TOllbKO HJ( MblCJJBTeJlbHblH
3acTaTb ero B COCTOHHBH BblcweH HCTOMbJ, B ero RaImo~1lHRHefuneH npou.ecc HMecT APyrylO npHpO,AY. Ou ecrecTBeH. OHH CBoGoAUbI OT
CYTH. 3aCTaTb Ii BOCC03,AaTb - BOT aenH<t.aHmaJ'l 3a,!{aqa BCKYCCTBa. pe!j>neKCmf. Mx nepeJKHBaRWJ He COBepWaIOT KpyroB H nOBopOTOB, .HX
K3)KAhrH lJe.llOBeK Teuepb He TonbKO mmTfBH)],YYM, CBSl3amn.Iii HC BOllBYeT 3XO. Hx 'lYBCTBa ABIDKYTCJI no npjlMOH .
.t\onrOM, MOpam.lO, 061l(eCTBOM, CeMheH . OR B 3 TOM HCKYCCTBe B TOM COCTOHT 8bIC01.J.aH.waJI TaHHa 3Toro HCKYCCTBa. 3TH XYAO)KRH
CTaROBIITCSI He qeM RHbIM, KaK CaMbTM B03BbimeHRbiM H CaMhfM KH ./lHWeHbI npHBhNHOrO A~ Hac llCHXOJlOrH3Ma. TeM He MeRee H.X
)f(aIlKHM - Oli CTaHOmrrCR '-IenOBeKOM. "yacTBa rnyGx<e. I1x qYBC'l'Sa Bbl6HpalOT npoCTeiinme rryTH, H.e TC
3~eCb 3aKJDOlJenO H080e Ii HecJlhIXaHBOe no cpaBfleHHlO C npeAhl R3BHJJHCTble. C03JlaHHhIC 'leJIOBeKOM, He Te on030peHHbiC '1eJIOaeKOM
AYmHMH 3110XaMH. 3,AeCh GYP)KyalHaJ'I MHpQBaH MhICJIb GYKCYeT. cnoc06bJ MbIlIlJIeHRJI , KOTopoe, 6YAY'4R HanpaB.lUleMO R3BeCTHOH
3~eCh 60JJbme HeT 06CTORTeJlhCTB, 3aTYMalJliBaIOlQHX oGPa3 <{enose npIf'fHBHOCTbIO, HHKOTAa He MOX<eT 6blTh KOCMH'feCKBM. 113 nCHXono
qeCKoro. HKK3KID( ceMei1l:1blX RCTOpIDi, HHKaKRX Tpare.l{HH, 803HHKa ~leCKoii cq,epbl []pUMeHReTC~ TOJIbKO aHaJW3. OR npHMeHSleTC"',
IOmHX H3 CTonKHOBeHHJI YCJIOBHOCTeH B nOTpe6ROCTH CBo6o.t\hf 'ITOGbl paCKpbrBaTh, KOIITpOnHposaTh. ,J.1erraTh BhrBOJlhl, o6"~CHJITb, a
6bITOBbfX mee, CTpOTHX me!j>OB, JKH30epa,!{OCTHbIX o!j>n:qepOB, KYKOn He 1l0Ka3aTh CBoe BCe3RaRCTBO, BblKa3aTh CBOM JIHQeMeplJhIH yM,
BHC~ Ra HHTJlX nCHXOnOrHl-leCKHX MHPOB033peHHH ~1 HrpalOmHX KOTOPbllt BAeT Bce )Ke TOJIhKO no CneAaM pe3YJIhTaTOB , 3TH iKe
llbecy 06 3TOM C03~aHROM H CKORCTpYHPOBaRHOM 'leJIOneKOM oGlQe pe3Y1T.bTaTbl RarnHM CJIerrbJM K Be.llH1<OMY lfYAY rna3aM R 6e3 Toro
CTBeRHOM cYlQeCTBOBamrn, C ero 3aKOHaMJoI, n03BQHRMH. 3a6ny)KAeRH OqeB~Hbl. 1160 He GYACM 3a6brBaTh: Bce 3aKOHhI, n CHXOnOnNeCKHe
jlMH R nOpOKaMll. CKB03b Bce 3TH cypporaTbl 6el)KaJlOCTBO rrpoHD.Ka CBSl3R Me)K.rI Y )J{H30ellHbrMU IJ)IKJIaMH npHAYMaHbl HaMH caMllMH, HaMH

306 307
 BOCIIPBIDITbl H DpHBJtrLI Ha BePY AM
aeo&wiCHHMorO .lVUI MHpa .IVUr ttO CTbIO H nornomaer ee. IiKqero ,npyroro He OCTaeTCSI. nopoH B
601'3 B IICHXOJlOrHqeclCOii cclJepe ReT 06"bJlcHe llBJl .JIHIm. UO~e cHJll> HOM nopblBe "yaCTBa Y8JIe'leHBocTb npoR3Be,neHHeM CUJlaBJUleT B
(IJle"'IaMB, JIHIIlL OTp~e. HeM Bce OaCTOJThKO BoeAHHO , 'ITO 3TO ~fO:>KeT B,btrJlSl,IJ.eTb HCKa)KeRKeM.
HOBOe RCrcyCCTBO rr03TOMY n03HTHBHO. nOTOMY 'ITO ORO lfHTy flo CTpYKTYpa npOH3Be;qeUHJl ,IJ.OBe,neua 1.10 nOCJJe,nBeH CTeneHH
HTHBHO. fIOTOMy 'ITO OBO, HMe~ IIpOCTeHunte qyacma, C fOTOBRo HaDP 1DKeBlUI )KaP qyaCToa TaK OaKaJIIDl ,IJ.yrny TBopffill,ero, 'ITO OHa B
CThfO, HO TeM He Menee roPAO OTA~Cb BeJlHKoMY "YAY 6hlTHJi. CBoeM crpeMJIemnf K 6 C3MepHOMY Ka'UfHaeT HCTOPfaTb ueCJIbJXaJlHoe.
06na.o;aeT CBeJKRMH CKJIaMH ~ aKTHlJROH ;qeRTe.nI.HOCTH R CTpaAaHIUI. 9TO CTPCMJJeRHe OT'leTlllfBee Dcero rrpOSlBJUleTCJJ 8 :lKH"BOIDICH.
:na XY;qO)t(8HJ(lf Dc RAYT OKOm.RbIMH U}'TBMIJ cnRpHTyam.uoii KYm.Ty ~C8ee BcerO - B clC}m.nTYpe. B mtTeparype C:>KaTUe R BHAOH3MeHeKHe
phi. 0"" OTJ.C.a3blD31OTClI OT ce611 80 1DUl 6oJICeCTBeHUOfO. ORif q,OPMUl, XOTb If npe,IJ.npHRlfMaIOTCJJ He BnepBble. RHKOf,na ,nORbIHe He
np1lM0JIHRemn.r. Omt OPRMRTHBRhI. ORB DpOCTbI . nOTOM)' "'ITO [(PO llOCHlfaJDf TaKoi1 npORRKROOeHROCTJI H TaI<OH pa,IJ.UKaJThHOCTIf R
CTeiimee - caNoe 'fPy;qHoe R caNoe CJTOJICHoe, 00 UpRBO,l{HT K 8eJIll n03TOMY npIfBO.I1"T B 3aMewaTeJTbCTBO. B CKYnhnTYPax PO,IJ.eHa
'laiin.mM OTlCpblTHJlM. H MLJ De 336.J1Y'1QlaeMC"; TOJThKO B KOlII(e Bcero nOBepXHOCTJi eme pa30pBaRhI. KaJK;qaJI JIllRIUI , KaJK.nbIR iKeCT eute
HaxOAHTC~ opocroe, TOJlI.KO B KOHl.(e UPO)KRThJX ABeH JKB3Kt. BXO):{HT 8 opHeRTUpOBaH H3 3<PcPetcr, ua MntooeRbe, H.a OAHOKP3THoe ,neHCTBHe,
coOlcoARoe BenpepbTBRoe PYCJlO. Kopoq.e: OHH Bbrpa:>KeHhl toITHOBeH.heM U UpH tJceA BblPa3HTeJJhHOCl1i
H TIl]( c.nyqaeTC~, ' ITO 3TOflCKyCCTBO, T3.IC T<aK OHO HCKyccrno no.o;'IRHeRbl nCJr<OJlOfHQeCKOH lQlee . O;nIfTI ,llY101aeT. .l(Boe APYrKX
KOCMIPIeCKoe, AOCTBraeT OOJThIIlHX BepUIHH H rny6HR, "eM KaKoe-JIH60 l.\enYIOTC". Bce OCTaeTC~ npOlicmeCTBHeM. Y COBpeMeHHblX iKe
;lPyroe - HMTTpeCCBOHHCTCKoe H R3TypanKC'l1RCCKoe HCK}'CCTBO, "PH 11306paiKenKH nOBcpXHOCTH ,llaRbl MfROBCHHblM KOffTYPOM. ClUIa.r:\Kfl'
YCJTOBKR. 'lT0 eTO npeACTaBHTeJIH 06n3;qafOT CMOS. C OTITa;qeRJIe ", pa3fnaiKeRbI. BhlJlennCHO TOJlbKO cymecTBellUoe Ho H306pmt<eKHe
nCHXOnOrH'leCKOrO acneXTa BC'Ie3aCT BCSI qeK3,l{eHTCKaSI B03ID1. 3a-rpa CTaHOBllTC1I THllfNllbL.\1, He OOA'lllHeHHhll\1 60nee KaJWH-TO oilBOH
rHBafQTC" CaM'ble BacyJItRbJe BOnpOCbl. Rel\eTClI llaCTyTIneOHC Ra MblCJDt . 3To Tenepb Be TOJ11>KO -rpeOCT CCKyHilbI. fl306paiKeHlie
OOnbrfme )l{H3HeHHLle np06J1eMbI. COBepmeUHO nO-ROOMY OTlCp1>TDaeT npli06peTaeT 3Ha'IHMOCTb BO BpCMeHH. OTCYTCTBYCT Bce BTopocreneR
ClI 'flfP HaBCTpeqy pa3ropalOn\eMYC" OJ} RCTBy. Ofl)OMBbTH paHCKttH Hoe. Cyn, AaCT H):IelO: OTHbrue npe,nMeTOM H306p3)Kemnl 6y;qeT He
C3;q 60ra OTlCpbJBaeTC~ 33 MHpOM aemeH. eCJTH c.'lf0TpeTI. fl3 HHlt MbICJIjfiIQ.m, HeT.-Mhl1lllleIDfe. He )lOoe CJlHTblX B 06bJITlrH. HCT,
HaJlJHM 6eccMepTIILTM 83fJIJIAOM. OncpLl831OTCH TITBpolCHe roPH30BThI . caMO 06"bJITHe.
HnoH cnoc06 BH;IlellHJl 'JaMYTWleT ~ 'lHTaTeJJJl B 3pHTen~ 91'0 - rnaseHCTByronvrli lUICTHRKTHBHbm 3aKOB, 3TO He 3aKOB
R306p3JK3.eMoe. A
TalC K.aJC OR fJIJIART R He BRAHT, HOBble oqepJ'aHH" p33pymeHR$I , a 3aKOB, no KOTOPOMY BbI6Hpa,IOTC~ TO~, MaI'HeTHqe
AJllI Hero 06MaH'1HBhI. qeJJOBexy oenOAl'OTOBJIeBHOMY 31'0 BH;IleHHe CKH THroTefOlqne APyr K ilPyry. H OR AHcl.\;HT1JlBHlIpyeT CTPYKTYPY
npeACTaBIDJeTClI 'leM-TO AanelOlM, neYJ(JJfO)KHii npeAMeT - BaDpOTHB . I1peAJlO)J(ellHJl YlOJaAblBalOTC" B pHTM Re TaR, KaK 3TO l\eJJ.a.eTCSI
"CllhIM H 6J1H3KHM. YAaneBBe nCHXOJIOfB"ecICOfO acueKTa ;qKKTYeT 06bl'lHO. OIDt nOA'UffieHbI O;nHHaKOBOMY HaMepeHHfO, O;qROM)' H TOMY
CTpOe8H1O xy;qO)ICeCTBeHHoro npoH3Be;qe1lIDl JUlynte 3aKOBhl, -rpe6YeT :>Ke OOTOKY ;qyxa, pO~3lOmeMY TOJThKO IfCTUHHoe. OHH BO BJIaCTH
60nee 6JIafOpoABOii CTpYJCTYPbl. HC'Ie3aeT BTOpocreneHHoe. BRyTpeH MeJlOilHKH K CJlOtJOTBOp'leCTBa. Ho B 3TOM HeT CaMoneJlH. IlpeilJJO)Ke
Bee YCTpOHCIBO, cpe;qa OCTafOTC~ JIHIDb CJTerKa 0603Ha'leBHhIMB , HlI". 06beAlIHCHHble B ,nJlllHHOH e;nBBOH lIeon, CJly:>t<aT AYXY, KOTOPblH
OHH - l(aJC KOpoTKllil na6pocoIC Ba pacKaJleHRoA MaCCe ;qYIUH. HCKYC HX <popMHpyeT .
CTBO, KOTOpoe XO'lCT TOJlhKO no;qJIHHHOro, HCK.lIJO'laCT sropocreneH HM lt3tJeCTeR TOJlbKO TOT nYTb, KaJ(ltM B]l eT ;nyx. ero QelIh, ero
Boe. ReT 6om.me Entremets I, BCT Hors-d'ocuvre 2, O'I'lrbIHe BKKaKOrO CMblCJl . OHM cOOJJTeHHlOTCJJ APyr C ,IJ.pyroM, 3BeHO K 3Beey, DpOIIHKaIOT
M}']{PCTBOBaHIUI, KOoapUO BBO;qJllllero B 336.1Iy.lK.AeBHe, RlJ'{ero 3Cceu APyr B .trpyra, 60JlCC He CBSl3aHHble 6yq,epOM JlOrl-r'-leCKOro ncpexOA3
cnrqecKoro , 060 seeM fOBOPJllllero B 06nun 'IepT3X, OTBLlHe HH'lero 3naCTH'IHOii , yrrpyroH, TlOKa3f1011 mnaKJIeBKOH nCilXOnOrBH. Hx 3na
AeKOpaTHBHoro, HMeTOmero qeJILJO BHenmee YKP3IIJATeJthCTBO. HeT. CTR1JROCTh HaXO,IJ.HTCSI B HHX caMllX. TaIOKe If CJTOBO nOJlY'laeT .trpyrylO
cYtItJToc a CYmeCTBeBRoe CJIe;q}'JOT APyr 3a ApyroM- :Qenoe rrpa06pc CHJIy. OnaCaTCJTh1l0e, 06CaChI"BafOmee ope;qMeT CO BceX crOpOB
TaeT '1eKaHHhle O'lepTaRlUf, SCm.re JIlIBIIH, CTpOryTO C)((3TYfO <jJopMY . HCQe3aeT. J.I.n" Hero ReT 60JThme MeCT3. CnOBO CT3JlO CTpeJlOH. ORO
ReT 60JJee APJl6noro )IIClIB()1'8, 06BBCJT1>1X rpy;qeH. Tope XYAOJICeCTBeH nopa)KaeT 1l}'TP0 npe;nMcra H OAYXOTBOpSl.eTCR HM. BblKPHCTallJlH30
BOro DpoH3BeAeB1Ul, BbtpacT3JI oa CTpOiiHblX T)THX 6eAPax B CTaHo BblB3e TCSI no,nJJmll1hri{ 06paJ Be~. OTUa;qafOT CJIOBa-BCTaBKH. rJlAfOJl
BSlCb uce 60JJee 6.naroPOAHhlM, DpeBp3II\aeTCSI B H3TpeBHpO.BaHBOC y,IJ.JTHRjIeT CH, 3aOCTJ)JleTCSI, aanp1DKellHO CTIlPaSlCb Ba.Wm 'leTKoe
copa3Mepaoe TYJlOBJIII\e. IInaMJI 'lyucTBa, CJIHBaJOlIleroc" Henocpe;q KCTHHHoe Bhlpa)KeHHe. IlplfJJaraTeJlbBoe cJJK83eTCJI B e,U;HHblH CTUIaB C
CTBeRBO C cep;qqeltHHoi BCeJJeHBOH, OB.1lAAeoaeT 3TOB aeuocpe)lcrneH- HOCRT eneM CJJOBeCHOH MbICJlH . O HO T 01Ke He ;qOJDKHO 0[]JfCbIB3TL. O RO
.I10JDKHO caMhIM C)KaThIM 06paJOM BbtpIDl<an. CYIIIBOCTb, R TOJIbKO
J JIcrme 6moAO. DO~ OcpeA AecepTOM (lj~.).
CYlIlB OCTb. Ii 60Jlhme RHqero.
2 JaKyc:u (ljJHllUl..).
H Bce )ICe 06 3TH BTopOCTeneRRbIe BeII\H. a He 0 u;eJIR pa36 1fBaeTc"

308 309
 Ofihl<ntO }lHCKYCCH)I. TeXHlf'feCKHH BOnpOC 3anYThIBaeT, OH CT<UlOBI1TC$I ObJpaJKeHHSI He BeMel\KHH, He P~Y3CK.d:f. OR Ha.lVlaqHOHanbHblB.
npC]:IMeTOM AaCr-remCK. E ro CqliTaIOT 6JIeOM. HHKorna cll\e b Ou He TOJILKO 3~a4.a RCKYCCTBa. OH rpefiOBaHHe AYxa. OB - He
UCKYCCTBe TeXHHKll KCIJOJlHeRBJI ee fibTn3 B TaKOH CTeneHH np0ltYlITOM OporpaMMa CTHJ151. OH-Bonpoc .L\ymll. 3'ro - - llpofineMa 'leJJOBeQe
,[(yxa, KaK 3,[(CCb. He uenpHBhl<JUru! opMa C03ltaeT ypOBem. XYltO)f(e . CTDa. 3KcnpeccltoBlf3M cyU.\eCTBOBan BO Bce BpeMeRa. He fibUlO BH
CToeAAoro npOH3Be~emul. He B 3TOM ee UCJTh U ee H.D,ell. HaTHcK .D,yxa OltHO H ofinacTH. KOTOpa1l fi He 3Hana ero, HM onHOH pe.J1HI'HH, KOTOPaJI
H fiypHaB aOJIHa qYBCTBa, CJUfB3$lCh, HeCKOJIbKO ynpOlQalOT ,f.\pyr 6b1 ero CTpBCTHO He C03ltaaana. He fi.b1JlO HK 0,[(80ro nJleMeIDI.
ltPyra, H TOJIbKO Y)f(e H3 :noH oTCeSUIHOH., o'IHU(eHlfoii OPMbl KOTopoe fibl He BOCOeBaJIO H He BOWlOll\anO c ero nOMOU.\blO CBoe
ohlpacraeT BHJ\eRlfC. Ho qenOBe'leCTOO 3HaTb He XOqeT, 4TO Bcerna cM)'TRoe pe.rlHrH03Hoe 'JYBCTBO. Pa3BBBlllmiC5I B BelIHKHe BpCMeHa
nO)l BUelllReH OPMOB CKphlBaeTCJJ HenpeX0ltSIU..\ee. )l,yx, B03BOCRU(Hii cHJIbIJeIDmtx nOTP)1CeHHH, mnaeMbrn rnyfioKHMlt ruIaCTaMH rapM01Ul'J
BelQH K fionee BblCOKOMY CYl.QeCTBOBaHIDO B 'lHOo opMe, qeM Ta, B flO pa3BliB3lOIl\eHCll )J(H3HH H KOpUJfM8 y)Ke CJIO)f(HBIlleHC)I B rapMO
KllKOH OliH BOCrrpHHHMaIOTCSl qYOCTBemo,IM OlQyU(eHHeM B 3TOM HH'lHhLX YClIomt5lX rp~B.QK", C031J,anCSI CTHJIb, ofiI.QJffi AJlJf MHOl"ltX:
orpaRJ{qeBHOM MHpe, Qen08eQeCTBY He 3UaKOM. OT nOBHM3lUUI 3TOro aCCRpHHu,bl. nepCbl, rOTHKa, erHDTHHe, np"MBTl1BHCTbJ, CTapble He
Hac OT,[(e.JUIeT ltO CMeWBoro ManOe paCCTOJlHlfe . Ho ~!eJlOBeqeCTBO eu.\e MeQIOle MaCTepa BJ]~eJlIl HM. Y COBceM ltpeOHlU. HapOAOB, no.o.Bep
He 3uae T, 'lTO RCKYCCTBO TOJIbKO 3TaIJ B.a nyn, K fiory . )f(eHHblX HeooroAe, uaCblJlaeMOH Ha IUlX fiO)l(ecTBOM 8.3 fie3rpaIDl'lHblX
Ho QeJJH BaXOltJITCSJ TaM, r,[(e fior. JIyqJJ qe.JIOBeqeCKOro cepJ\~a npOCTpaH'-'TB npHPOAbl, OH cyan BHOHHMHbJM BblpaJKeHHeM CTpaxa H
yxltSJT K "eMy, OTph.1 DasCL OT nOBepXHOCTH. JllrqHoe nepepaCTaeT BO 6J1arOrOBeIDUl.
BceofilQee . npe)f(Ree npeYBeJIH'leHHOe 3HaqeIDIe e,[(HHH~oro no,[{Bc p Y OT)leJlbRblX Be.JIHI<HX MaCTCPOB, qMf ltywa fibUla nepenOJIHeHa
raeTCSI fiOlIee CRllbHOMY B03)leHCTBlflO HJ\eH. DoraTCTBO CHHMaeT C npOAyKTHBHOCTblO, ou CTaJI eCTeCTBCHHeKwHM Bblp<UJ<eWleM HX npo
cefill BHeUUHee OfilIaqeRHe H CTaROBRTCll fioraTblM B cooeH npOCTOTe . H3Be,[(eHHH. OR 6bU1 B BH,[(e ltPaM3TIfl1eCKOrO 3Kcnua y rplOOCBaJIh,[(a,
Bce Bell\H B030paIT.\aIOTCJI K cooeo cym: K npOCTOTe, BceofilJ.(BOCTH , 6blJl IDlPH'lH}'IM B neclUJ)' 0 XpKCTe MOHaXHHH. rJJyfioKo B3BOllHOBaB
Cy:Jl{BOCTH. Cep~a, HanpaBJllleMbJe TaKHM aenOCpeltCTBeJlHl>lM ofipa HblM Y llleKcTlHpa. HellpeKJlOHRblM B CBoeH Re>KHOCTH y ~eB, B
30M, fiblOTCSl CBofiOltBO If nmpOKO. )l,eHCTBHC HallOHl-leHO finarorooen H CBoeH )f(eCTOKOCTU Y CTpHJmfiepra. 11 BOT OR Y)f(e 3aXBanmaeT QeJloe
eM TaK)lCe R B pg;qOBh[x cHTyaJW1lX. 31IeMeHTbl )f(HBYT DO Be nOKoneHHe.
3aKOHaM. TaR: Qcnoc CTaHOrutTCSl TaJOKe 3TJ1qeCKlfM. Ho BOT BHe3anRO ll,eJloe nOKOlIeHHe EBPODbl. BeJIHKaJI HOJIRa AYXOBHoro ABIDKellH.Sl
B038B.I<aIOT POltCTBeBHbJe <{epTb]' fix HCT01<Jl - Be B npeltbJ~eM B3JleTaeT nOBCfOltY BbICOKO. IIOClIeltHerO rpefiyeT 3Doxa. Bce MO
noKOlICHHB, OT KOTOPOfO 3TO HCXYCCTBO OTMe)lCeBblBaeTC5I no BceM . JlOAoe OOl(OneHHe JKeJlaeT yltOBlleTBOpJlTb 3TOMY Tpe60BaHHIO. To,
OllH He B qeM-TO OTlteJILHOM-He B rOTmCe, Be B HaqHOHaJ)hHOM, He y '{eMY CYJK,I:.IeHO nOJlBHTbCH, fiylteT 6 0PhfioH CUJlbl c BeJleHMeM 300XR.
nrre , rplOHeBa.JIb,[(a 8JIH MeXTIDIhlthl Mar,[(efiyprcKoH. He B pOMaH IIOTor-!y 'ITO TO, 'ITO xYAO)l(eCTBeBHble nporuBe,[(eHIDl nOJlBJUUlBCb Ha
CKO" KpBDTe, He y HOTKepOB, He Y OTTo TpeTherO, He y 3KKexapna , caeT, RHKorlta He fibTnO CJlenCTBHeM llAeH. OHa .JIHDJb )I(~a [10
He y KpeTheHa ,[(e Tpya, He B 3aKIIBHaIDlSlX. HCTOp.HI nynrn He elQe fiOJ1ee cOBepmeHROMY, 3aXJleCTblBaJOll\3j1 qeJJOaeKa. )l,JI5I op
,[(Bl'OJ<eTC5I no KOHBeHepy fiblJloro CTOJIb npOCTO e nOCJIenOBaTeJlhHO. MHpoBafUUl RY)J(1Ta CHJIa. Y OOKOJleJ6UI OHa HllH ecn, HJIH ee BeT.
POnCTBO He orpaBH'leHO. TpaltHl.(BJI - BODPOC He Rat(BOHaJIbB&rn H He Ho 3TO Bce Boepe1J,H, B HaID M03r He B cunax T)'T 'lT0-JUt60
CBJI3aIIJJbfft C UCTopHeH KaKOra-TO nepHOna. npeltyra,o,aTb. TpefioBarme HCTBHROrO AOJl)l(Il0 fil>ITb nOCTaBJleRO co
ReT, pO.I(CTBeHHoe, noxo)f(ee, CKJIOHROCTh K qeMY -To B03HHKaeT Bcen crporoCTblO. T eM oCTpeo,"ITO r JlaBHa)1 onacooCTb. rp03SUI\ru!
nOBClOny TaM, rne qyltOSHIllBas cKJla 1l0fi~Hna ltyUlY fihITb MorYlQe ,UBK)I(eBlilO, HMeeT nOKa Oe$lCRhl e OqepTaBlUI, H n03TOMY TaK CTporo
CTBeHHOH, RCKllTb 6ecKOBe'lHOrO, BbTpaJKaSl TO fiecnpe,nelIbHoe, 'ITO .D,OJl)KHO fiblTb nOCTaalIeBO rpe6 0BaHHe BCTIfRHoro. TOlIbKO BuyrpeR
CS1l3bmaeT 1I1OlteH c KOCMOCOM. HJlJl cnpaaeltJlHBOCTb DpR CTOlIb BblCOKOH QeJIll MO)l(eT fiblTh CTOJlh
B CIO,[(Y, f,[(e B03I'OpenOCb nJIaMJl CBofiOltbJ, npesparr(aJI Bce MOJlJlIO pa,u;IlKaJIbROii. H BOT Y)I(e TO, qyo fibUlO B3PbIBOM, cyaROBBTCSl MOltoB.
cKoofipa3Boe B ofiyrneHllble 'rpYlIbl, no npH 3TOM npHJ\aaas 6eCKOReQ BUYTPb Y)f(e np0 6HpaeTCSJ TJleTBOpm.l" .I(YX. B CJCpblBaTb 3TTHrOHCT
HOMY . TaKYJO OPMY, ClIOBHO OHO nOIDKHO B03npaTHTbCll Ha3alt K BO, OfiH3)I(3Tb HeltOCTaTKR, nOAqepKHBaTb Hcy ltoBJleTBOpHTen:bBoe, B
ltJTaIDI TBOPQa, Bce MpaqltbIe BeJlHKHe peBOlIlOQRH .I(yxa nopOJK,L\aJIJf TOH CTe De trn , UaCKOJlhKO TaKoe BblJlBJIeRHe H npOI1RKHOBeIme B rIiyfih
nlffi H TOT )l(e Ofipa3 TBOpeHHJI. Ha3brsaTh JlBJleHHe, )lJUI KOToporo npeAMeTa BO3MO)l(JlO, OCTae TCll 38J).aqeif qeCTlIblx. r nyfioqaitwaJI
ceiNac ynOTpefiJUJIOT RCTepToe cnOBO 3KcnpeccHoHH3M, HOBbIM o.eHHOCTh, flIyfioqaHunrli CMblcn COKpblTbl OT BCCX Hac .
JlO)Kh. HaJhmaTb MO,[(OH - OCl<opfineHHe. HaJbmaTb TOJIbKO xY.o. o)f(e HeT , He TBOpqeCKaSI HHTeHCHBBOCTb, npIUlHMaJOlQaJI crpaRHbJe
CTSeHBbIM 5IBJIe nUeM - KJIeBeTa. BHeWHlle OPMhI, npH]\aeT RanpaBllemuo CTepTble qepTbI qer a-TO
Bcerlta, Koma TOT IUIB RHOH npe,[(CTaaUTe.Jlb qeJJOBeqeCTBa ,[(ep)I(aJ) RPPa[\HOBaJIbHOro. ClIe n o CJIe.I(YlOll\ero Mo,[(e . 3To B 60JIbWeH CTeoeRB
B PYKax KOPBlf Bell\eH u y nero fiblJIa H KpeIIKaJI XBaTKa, H C03BaTeJlbIJO OCYII\eCTBJleSRaJI nporpaMMa . )1;YXOBHo e A BIDKeHHe He
filIarorOBeHHe nepe,n Bell\blO, ynaaanocb TO )l(e CaMoe. 3TOT c Docofi BblltaeT peQerrroB . OHO CJleAyeT JlHlDb OpralH3YIOII\eMY 'J}'BCTBY T aK

310 311
 KaK )J,BH:lKeflHe Y:>Ke ocy~eCTBB.J'[OCh, ero 'reOP Wl Sa'llIHaeT ,neH CTB O~
BaTh 3aAHHM qHCnOM. D HO CTaHOBHTCjJ WKOJloii, aKa,neMHeH . CPaKeJl b~
mmcH rrpeBp~alOTCJI B UOJllIIleiiCKKX, B r JIaID:rraeB 0,nHo06pa3Hoij
AorMaTHKH, OrpamtqCHHhIX, CBJl3aHB1.lX BepHOCThIO 6YKBe. C TH./lh B
BbJCmeM em CMhlCJlC ocy~ecTBJljleT ce6J1 KaK CHJly, KaK 6YIDIhiH
POCT, perymfpyeMbJll ThrCjlqaMB rrpBTOK08 II TetleHHH, BMelO~liX
CBOHM HaqanOM onyx TBOpqeCKOH CH.Ilb1. llHKorna - K3.K CPOPMY. KaJ<
pa3 OpOCTbJe .IlBHHB. 60JIbWHe IUIOCKOCTH, yceqeHBM CTpYKTYpa
CTaHOBJlTCJI ,no Y:lKaca MOBOTOBHhIMJf, CMepTeJIhHO CKyqRbfMH, KOr)~a
ORR TonhKO YMeJlO c,nenaHl.J, a He npOqyBCTBOBaHhl. A6CTpaKTRoe
CTpe"'lJIelUfe, O,nHaKO, 60JTbme He BHJlHT rpamrQ. He MO)ICeT OC03HaTh,
KaKJie C6anaHCKpOBaRw,le B03MO)IC80CTH cYlUeCTBYIOT Me)K.Qy rrpe,nMe
TOM'" TBoPJUlleii <p0PMOH. fipOphmaJICb 'repel rp~r QYSCTBeIrnO.
ro, OHO TBOpHT crrnOlllHYIO TeopBlO. HeT 60m.IlJe BetqH, KOropylO Obi
CO 3AaBaJIK , ope06pa30BhlBanH, HCKaHB, TOJIhKO rOJIM a6CTPaK~jJ ,
nOKlf,qalOtQaJI Done 6HTBbl. 3,neCh, KaK 3TO "Iacro 6hlBaeT, 3a6bmaeT
ell, <iTO Y KaJK,nOH rrpaB,nhl eCTl. Ta KPaHHSJI TO'lKa, rJl,e oHa,
o CYl.UeCTBJIeHllaJI C 6e3paccy,nHoii nOC.lle,n08aTeJIhROCfblO, CTIlHOBIITC"
! JO;;KblO. He TeRliIaJteR TOT, KTO HaMepeHIIO KOClIO)J3hl"leH, He nepnOJ
aHeH TOT. KTO no,npa'KaeT Herp~t.- HMJtTltpYfl. HeJTb31f C03,naT!.
10Boro. 3,neCb 60JIl,me, 'leM r,ne-JIlf60. Bce pemaeT 'leCTHOCTl.. Mbl Ht::
O:lKeM HHqero no,neJJan fill C ~QijQij, IDt C Ua1J.1H.M BpeMt::HCM.
C03HaTe.llbHrul flaRB HOCTh Y)Kacna. ,IJ;enal:uu,li:f -lKCrrpeCCHOHK3M
:>KaJrKoe BapeBO, : nOAH, C03,naHHhle YCWUleM BOJIB, CTaHOBKrCjJ MawJi
HaMH. 3TO TaJOKe CBO,nHTCSI
BOnpOCY 0 npHHy)t(AeFllill. )J;BIDKYlI{HM H
06lQHM S1BJIj1CTCR TOJlbKO Bepa, CIDla H CTPaCTh.
Ho TaM, rAe Bce 3TO 06'beA,HWUloch B MHCTB1:fecKHii cBa,ne6HhrH
npalA,HJ.1K , 3KCnpeccHOHH3M 6hlJI B Ka)K,QOM HCRycCTBe, B KIDI<,QOM
nocTYnKc.
BR8"1'ane - TBOpeHlile, aenIf1(He xpynl MHq,OB, cKa3amur, 3,Q,na . Y rrpoTHBope1:fHHMH, rue8J:10 pbJ,naJOW;BH Hll,lJ, 6eCCMhlCneHBOCThlO peaJIh
faMcyHa, y EaaJta illeMa, y TeJIb,nepJIHHa, Y HOBaJIlIca, y ,r:J;aJITe , Y
IOTO-3.QTeKoB, a caHcKpHTe, Y Kocrepa, y foroM, Y <l>n06epa, B
MBCTHKe cpe,nlleneKOBhjJ, a IDfCbM3X foreaa, y AxJlMa <pOB ApHJlM a .
Y q,JIaMaHAQa ,IJ;eMOJIh,Qepa, fere, DOPOIO y Xewu.\e, Y Pa6ne, Y fcopra
olOXHepa. y EOKKaq"lO. 3TH ~lMeHa, B3J1Tbre Rayra,n, He RTOr, OUR He
upeTeu,nYIOT Ha 1l0nHOTY, om .JIB.Illh BaMeKH, HX, HaBepBoe, A3)Ke
Re,nOCTaTO'lHO. OBJI - JUlUlh '"laCTHOCTH.
Ho OBJI nepeROCstT OADY 3110Xy B ApyrylO. Ha 3TOM CTOKf
ceroAHml.IBJIe . Uenoe OOfCOJleHBe.
Ha 3TOM CTORI cpaaaTH1:feCKruI. q,Hrypa PeBe IIIm<ene, KOTOPbrH ,
B03BhlCBBIIIHCh BaA 6YP)f(Ya3HOCTblO, B,nOXHOWleBBl>l.H KpOBhIO ABYX
aa, llTYPMOBaJI HCKYCC'TBO, KaK 6appKKa,ny, B KaJl<AOH CBoeH
p afioTe, 6blna JIB ORa a e}'Aa'leo, 6hlJla JlH ycuexoM, BcerAa YCTpeM
JleHHhm , C PYK<lMH, rrpocTepTblMH K ae6y, Bcer,na CMen o Aep:>Kan.utii
llepe A C060 D 3HaMjJ Ayxa .
Ha 3TOM CTOHT felfpRx MaBlJ, caMbrH CTIlPIOHH, 1l0.1lHbJit JlJ0 6BJI K
BeJIBKOR MbJCJUf "I'eJIOBelJeCTBa , " B npeYBeJIH"leHHRX H B HeHUBH CTH
I(o rop oro n p ucyrCTByeT TOCKa 0 0 cOBepm eRHOMY 'ienOBeKY , n HeM
312
eme MHoro HaHOCHoro. ou e~e He OTCTOjJJICSl, flO OR scerna [103T, 83
crapOB 300X 8 BXOA ~ B HOBYEO. El.Ue 1l0 ,nBJ1aCTB3jJ BpeMeHH,
copHeHTHpOBaHHOMY 8a 06hlBaTen2 8 KaJUlTan, BeJtJ{I(aJI TBop'leCKaJI
CHna ero HCKYCCTBa n03BOJ1HJla eMY BCTynRTh B 60ph6y. Y Hero
MO)KBO BMCTb ruraBTCKoe HaIIPj{)f(eHHe B q,OPMKpOBaRJUI " OAYXOTBO
PCHKliI MaTepHH . 11 ace )ICe '{lflaTeJIH e~e npOCTO-RanpOCTO He Be,QaJOT
06 ::ITOM. Hx o-myru,eHIDJ e~e onocpeACTBOBaHbl, H cep,nQe ax ollyraao
peq,ncKCWIMIl. Ho BeJIBKJrli npophlD TOTOBIlTCJI lAeCh c BeJIHK.B.M
pa3MaXoM.
Ha 9TOM CTOHT llaym, A,unep, KOTOPbrH CHOBa H CROBa COBcpUlaeT
1l0llhlTKY nOJIllOCTbIO npopBaTb o60nottKy 3eMBoro. To, "ITO 00
muneT, HCXO.D.JiT OT a6coJIlOTHo TBOp'1eCKOro ,Qyxa. ~ RCTBB
IIbdi 06pa3 MliIpa 9 .n;yDllJ B CaMbJX TyMaHHeiiurnx rpe3ax, ero
6apxarnO-MjJfKHll R CJJOBBO HO'lflaJI "epno1'a no6necIOlB3.lO~ ronoc
OTpa:lKaeT npOCTpaRCTBO H TOCKY a 6ecnOKOHOO-MY3b1KaJIbBOA <popMe.
H B dTOM 00 .!\OXo,nHT ;\0 DOCneAHJfX rrpe,ne.nOB.
Ha aTOM CTOHT ,IJ;e6mm. DB KBaApaTeH. OR CTpOHT cDOH pOMaIJ R3
cliMMeTpR'leCKliX Ky60B, B neM aeT ft CJJc,na nCHXOJlOI1fQeClCOH
KOHCTPYKJ..\ID1. Ee3 Harun.IBa CTPacm, nO,D.oGBo ropaM, opr3JDl'lH0
BhlpaCTaeT MORYMeHTaJIhHoe BbJpll)l(emlC. ORO wmew;aeT Q TOM, <iTO
MHp iOJIhKQ ~YXOBeR Hero lIeB03!'d0:;.KHO 1I0CTIl'lh nocpCACTSOM
nOCT)'llKa, rrocpe.n;CTBOM ,neHCTBlUI cra MO'KHO TonbKO OIlTepKfb. Coer
.;(flPteCKoro, n pHrJIymeliHblH oa a3HaTCK.H:H Mauep. KHTaH y aero
KaK HcnonHRCKoe BH,neHHe. HH'lero Be HapHCOBaHO, Bee YBH,UeHO,
HlNero oe H306pa:>KCJ:lO. Bee rrpO<JYSCTBOBaRO. HKttero 3anHCaHHOrO,
Bce BOfLllow;eRO a 06pa3 BHAeHIDl .H8RJlaCb MO~ yt)e'KACHHOC'DI
JIeoHxapAa <lJPaJ:JKa. 4laHaTH'lH3j) sepa yrureKaeT ero, DpeA'bHBJIAA
K ,no6py Bee 60JIhwe H 60JIhUle Tpc60BalUlii.
3peBUITaHn, 1C0CMH...ecKHB aeYAa<JBHK, Tep3aeMhJi~ BsyrpeHHHMIl
Roro MliIpa, SB.lUleT repoHqeCICH ,nenpeccHBRoe MHpOB033peBlle, OCBO
6o)K.QaJI AYmy B 06JUtQeHlUlX li rp03BhlX MO.llBTBax.
HaruteTcR BaJlh3ep , BOCnpHHltMaJonuriilKH3Bh C pe6J11IeCKOH YJJhJ6
KOU, 3 BCJIe,n 3a HHM e1Qe r.rry6:lKe KonaJOlIQ{H Kaq,Ka, Hec~ Ha
3eMJUO "I"Y,n0 R nepeA,alOQHH DHctmme Be~ npoCTbIMH CJI0BaMll, C
He:>KBOH H TORKOB eCTeCTBeOHOCThEO, KaK 'lTO-TO Oe3eMHOe. illTepR
XaHM AeMOBCTpHpyeT RCKYCCTBO DP03bl, HCXOA,mn.ee OT OCTpciiruero
M03ra,- M03fa, CTasmcro aaCTOJlhKO MorymeCTBeRlibIM, "ITO OR B
COCTORHHH Bhlpa3HThC2 npO,nYKTHBBO, craTh n 0 3TINeCKBM. PeQeDT,
80 peQem reB1laJIhHbIA. KplOQOK , Ra KOTOP OM BemaJOTC1f 3DKrOHhI.
llo,n06Ho e HCKYCCTBO, MeRLIlJe Be em cpe,llll Beex ,npyrax pO)fC,l{eHHOe
B3pbm OM qyBCTBa, .Ile r ...e Bcero DOA.n;aCTCSI RMH'I'3QHH. 3 ,neCh eCTb
onaCHOCTb 3mmeMHH- 3Ta M3 0 e pa B cBoeii CyxOCTH H CAep:>KaBBOCTH
AOXOAHT AO KpaibIo cm, 'ITO MO:>KeT CAenaTh CTIDIh HCBb LHOCBMh!M. A
BOT JlB.IUIeTCS elIte 51 oy6ep, KOTOPblA c aeYMOJUfMOH CTpOro CTbIO,
TBep.n;o R MHJIOCepAHO CJJe.o. YCT 3a De.J:lHK1lMH 3KCTaTH'lecKBMH JlH'<IHO
CTJlMH CBoero eBpeiicKo r o Hap OAa H CBOIt C06CTBeBHhIe rHMHhI,
RcnonHCHlIbJe npOCTOT b J H BeJlH'!HjJ, 3aMennmaeT Ha oe.l1HKHX PeJlHI"H
313
03HblX B3nenx paBBIDIOB.
onyx SOJILq,eBWTaKHa, TBepAblH: Ii RenpeKJlOAHbIH; Enacc, 3acnyra
KOToporo 0 TOM, \fT0 OR peoomoWiOHR3HPOBaJI CTRX; PyfiHHep B
OHR Bee 1U1~YT KOHQa R a6comoTa. OAIUt 3aKOB cyn(ecrnyeT An"
CBOeM nOJlCKe aKT}{OHOrO finara, c.na,nKaSI TOMHaJI. MY3hTKa llepKe.
RHX - 3aKOH sayrpeElSeH CJlJlbl. HH OAWlM C06blTlleM Be 06ycnOBJlH
BaeTC}I TO, 'ITO OHll COBepJIIalOT. HH O){HH neib:DK He OrpaRH'lHBaeT MY3hlKa 60ra TIaRa.
IlX. HpaBCTBeHHoe AeHCTBeHHO, KorAa npOHHJ<;aeT B qyBCTBa. OR" MY)KCKa5I, CMe.113j[ M 6naropO]lBaJI <PHTYpa 3pIJCTa illT3)J;Jlepa,

AHKT}'1OT BHelllHeM)' MHJ>y Gonee AOllrOBe'IHblH pHTM H3 B3BOnHOBaH KOTOPbm CO cTPacTLIO BOltTb1BaeT B cefiJi. oaelIIHHii MlIP R upeKpac
BorO Ayxa. ORK peffilrH03Rbl. KOr,D;a crpeMJITcj[ 'K KOHC'lHOH uemt I-\hlM pUTOpH'leCKHM j13blKOM BonnOlI{aeT ero B MYlhlKY, B IJ,BeT R S
3T1t':leCKR , a Be .nOrMaTltqeCKH, [(OrA a B blpa>KaJOT TeMltLlU TOCKY
HeOC03HaHBblH DopbrB 3IIoca, 6e3 KOToporo Rli onna n0331tj[ ue Be,neI<JUm nop,XOART K APaMe KaK K op03e, OB rJlhlGoH BpaCTaeT 0

np01Uf'KaJ1a B rny6HHbI TeMHOTbI. Heme: TaK KaK ORH mo6HT nTOAeif. l:Iee - MOCT, ycrpCMJJeHHhllf B 6y,nYII\ee.
CaMhlH CBJlhllbrli lil Bcex, reopr Kllihep, C ero xpycraJlbHo
Olm nO.llHT1f'lHbl, RO OHJl :lKeJlaJOT mo60n, a lie BJlacnr. OHH HLqyJ
Gora, ~blii no CBOIiM CJlJlaM R B03MO)J(ROCT1IM . 'lRCTbIM AyxOM, Aooe,qe){TlblM AO )l.paMaTIl'leCKOH 8anpIDKCRHOCTIJ,
llOTOM 1IBJlj[eTCSI 0033RSI: <l>paHq Bep<PeJlh, CaMblH Bt.ma:JO:mIDfC1I. ObJ3bffiaIOlI{KH Y qRTaTeJUI ReHCToBbm, TpeneTRbllf,B03ROC1IIIl;HH BBblCb

Ero MY3bl'Ka rpOMOJlOAoGBa: nJ060Bb . )l(eCTbl ero CTRXa HeoocpeA KCTal. MJlrqe erO KOPH<peJJb,n, npmnep,mu.H C BOCTOKa, nOC.IJ3HelJ,

crneHBbl H BeJJWl ccrneHHbI, 'ITO TPY,D;HO 6bIllO apeAnOJJO)l(BTb B PycCKoro AYxa, C BerpOMKBM na<pocoM H306paLKarolI{Jfi1 COOliX repoeB
eBpeOCKoif n033RR, HenocpeACTBeHHbl, no'ITH KaK y JIacKep-illronep, o HX MRJIocepAlm, cnyJKeHlfH H npeo,noneHHH fiblTIDl, BaCTOJlbKO

rAe }')Ke IIOCTaBlleHO paneHCTBO MeJK,!{Y cnrXOM H KpOBblO . OHa CDOKOiiHo-JrnpK'lHbm, 'ITO 'K.3)KeTCSl Kaibepy cmmn<OM xono:l(RbIM.

oAna U3 BeJlHqaHmUX no:necc , nOTOMY 'ITO OHa aaeopeMeHHce Bcex, IOHomeCKaJI oKpbllleHHoCTb Xa3eHK1feBepa CTPCMHTCSI K mtpHqeCJG1M

OHa BruJOTRYlO npH61lIDt<aeTC}I K neCHe n~CHcH. K3)l(eTC5I. BC1I A3H}I yrroeHHHM ClJOfiO,D;bJ, K npcKPacublM CK)'DblM c~eHaM, ii, XOTJI OR He

M
CTMa n0331tefi a CTpaHBOM napa.o;e ee CTKXOO. Bcp<pcJIb, HanpOTHB, MhlCJTUM 6e3 Bep<penJl, OR OTUlTb :>Ke caMo6h!TeB 0 CBOCM ToponmmO
apopoK C BOCTOKa. Recyr:qHiJ B ce6e eBponeHcKHH 3noc. Bcp<penb npOBHKROBCHRO.M nonCKe rny6HHbI. BecnOKoHCTBO, eIl\C BC COBceM
MOll:(Hee , a HeM <paHaTflqRblH OroHh. JIacKep-.I.llionep-C3.M3 000)10 nOTep1lBmee CBJl3b c KrreHCTOM, Beyp,ep)K}{MO CTpCMRTCJJ npH nOMOl1l,}l
lQeHBaSl D0331U1. ORa HeDocpeACTBeHReH. Bep<penb-n03T, CO}l3aH CHJ1bBO y,nJ1.HHRBIDRXCjl ClJ,eB npoBHKRYTb B caM}'1O cyn. BeqHblX
HbIB CO opeMeoeM. HaCKep - aHe Bcero. MO)KeT 6b1Tb, n03,D;IlCe OHa BorrpOCOB qenOoeqCCTBa. 3a60Ta, nO-KaTOJDf'{CCKJf CIp3CTBO
OK3JKeTCj[ KpYDRee ero. BOCTopJKeHH3j[, 03apJleT ero .mm.o fiO)KecrneBBhlM CBeTOM. 3p,eCh HeT
A BOT reopr reHM, KOTOpbJH BBaqane MOHYMeHTanbRbrM JKecroM npanBpOBKli, nCIDwnorHlM3, 06~CCTBeRBOH 06YCllOBlleHROCTIl, MBPO
RH30epran Ha Il3C r JTbJ6bl CTHXOB H KOBan H3 06pa300 H CTpO<p CBOH B033peRIDl HJUI KapTHROK fiblTa. OqeOHJ(BO , 'ITO yHH'IT0)KBTb Bee
BHAeHHjl. A BOT 3AOPOBaSI CHJla Uexa, KOTOPL!H CJOJKeTbl 30n}l 3TO R jlBJUleTCJI l(e1lblO mTepl:lXaHMa, KOTOPblH B ClJoeij nOCTOj[RROH
3a.KJ1lO'IHll B WlH3.MWIeCJOIe COHeTLI. 60Pbfic C 6YP"'Ya3ROCTbIO JlBJUleTCjl IIHOHepOM, KOTopbm npOAeMORCT
BOT CJla.o;KaJI HTpa KpacoK, HI.qylQ3j[ B pa3nO)KeHRH fi0.11e3JfeIJHYI0 pHpOOaJl B canrpe BOBbm JKCCT CBoero CTHJUl, HO TBOP'Jccrno KOToporO B
KpacOTY fio)l(ecTBeBJwro, Y TRpOJTbIJ,3 reopra TPaKJl3, KOTOPb!" caoCH KpaHHen CYTH ecTb TOJlhKO DepexoA K BC./lHIGiM 3a.o;aqaJVI npOCToro

HanonRSlJl np"poAY 3J1ern'lecKHMH npH3PaKaMlf RHKorA3 He BH,naHHOH qenOBCqeCKOrO ofipa3a. 3ACCb Ba cueRe mo.t\B, MHP, CYAbfia. 3T0,
KpaCOTbl. Y liOraHBeCa P. Bexepa CTRXlt aOXO:>KH oa oeJIHqecTBeBRbJi' MO)l(eT 6blTb, npHBeAeT K C03,na:H.HJO OCJTUKOH ApaMbJ. ECJIH Ha 3'1'0
B3pbIB . B311eTaJI. CTUX pa3pblBaeTCSI Ha ..acrn. CTOJlb Reofibf'l3iiHo AOCTaHeT CRn. Be,t\b l(emt Jl.CHbl, RX MO)t(RO oi<HHyTb B30pOM. Ho
qYBcrnO, BOCCTaBmee B HeM. OTAellbRble 3ByKH y,D;aJOTC5I eM)' HHorAa o603peTb CHJJY AapOBaHHH e~e ReB03MO)KRO. TIOIDlTO oCY:lKAaTb ox,
KaK UHKOMY APyrOMY-QeROH CJJR.lII.KOM fiOJTbIDOro p33pyweIDI~.
6Jm30PyKO BOCxsa..Jlj[Tb RX. Ho HHKTO Be MOJKeT peWRTbC}f AaTb fionce
pe)f(e Y]laeTCSI eMY Qenoe CTRXOTBopeHHe. rny60l<:Yro 01(cm<y. 3ACCb TaK)KC YMeCTHO cKalaTb na, KaK H BeT. Bce
CaMoe Kpa-noee 1IBneHHe - lllTpaMM, Tal( paCnnaBIIlJllHH lillOTh 3TO-CYAWa.
CTHX.a, ~O OCTaJTRCb JIRllIb orORbKR. OT,neJTbRble cnooa, JIHUlb Sepa, 'ITO UClIH 3T0ro I:fCK)'CCTBa BbUDe, qeM qeJ1H BCKYCCTBa
CAaBJJeHRLlH eTOH TOCKH. 3,neCb TaKJKe npeAen. 3TH CTUXlJ, XOT1I eme HC,D;aBRerO n pom.11 oro , He ,nOJIJKHa AaTb BaM 3afi'blTh, 'ITO BeJJRKoe
Ii BeAoMble OCTpcii:IDHM AYXOM, JKeJ1alOIIUle 60llhUJe KPRKOM, '1eM xyn )KecTBe8ll0e npOB3BC,t\eRRC C03Jl,3eT Bce )l(C TOJlbKO BCJl..H10m
O
HCKYCCTBOM, B03PO,nftTb 06pa3 TBOpeHIUl , a3XOAHTCj[ no TY CTOPOOY TBope~. H B 3TOM rJlaBHaJi. ~eJlb. Tpare,nHJI BpeMellB Morna 6bl
00338J1 H, 06peTJI B300llROBaHHbm rOllOC Ael<JlaMaTOpa, CTaHOBSlTCJI., nO:>KenaTb pacnpe,neJTRTb AapOBaRIDI no cooeMY YCMOTPeHRlO H no
CKopee, MY3bJJ<OH, peanhHOCTbJO, 1l03HHKaJOII{eH H3 xaoca. CBOHM ,nJIJI Hac HenpOHHlJ,aeMblM nOWlTWlM. OHa MO)l(eT lIMeTb B BBAY
BOT ,IJ,oH6JJep Hero B cepe6pHCTbIX H3JUU1HIDIX KOCMH'IeCKH 'ITO-TO H COBceM APyroc. OHa MO)KeT ooceJTRTb BeJTHKHe TaJJaJITbl BO
pa3paCTaJOII{aJlCSI WIOTb CTHXa, BOT CeTOBaHHJI 3peHUITaHJfa 0 neco spCMeHa HCKYCCTBa He CTOJlh SbJCOKOrO, a fioJJee MaJIhle OCTaBJITb Ana
BepmeHcrne Ml:Ipa, CK33a.BHble C fiOJJbIlIHM 113<P0COM, OfilleqeOHbJ e senBKBX 60es I:f r.JtY60KHX IJ,CncH. 11. 3TO TO)l(C B~O yqwn.maTb .
nopoH B qepecqyp l<JIacCH'leCKYJO 33KpyrJ1eHHYJO <POPMY. HIllY1I{.m Haum rJJ33a eIl\e MOJKRO yBJIC'lb. Y Rac e~e ReT npoCTpaRCTB3 AM
3J4
31 5
 3peHIDl. E~HHCTaeHH.bm pacnOpj{,lJ,HTCJlb C03.D;amn.IX npOH3Be,[lelfRH _ ,L(ana - peBoruoQIDI Jot OTCyrcTBRC Haqa.rra. 11 Bbl, A PY3bJJ, " Bbl,
BpeM1l. B KOHe'ffiOM HTore pewaer, MI.! 3R.aeM 3TO CerO,[lIDI, KaJ< 3Ha1J1f r Ope-n o3Tbl, APaJKaHlDHe eBaHreJlHCTbf,- 8bl TOJKe A3A3. AMa
Bcer~a , MOlJ.(b TBopelUUl. Ho CaMoe fi01lbWoe 3afiJly~eRHe B TOM, 'ITO Tuapa, Aana - XfOJIb3eR6eK, 'u3Aa Pd', nana MXM' J1llA3, A3Aa-Xro,
mo,[lH, nOBep)KeHRble ,I.1YXOM BpeMeHHOCTH CMelllHBalOT aMfiffQH}f .llaAa-T~3.
npOlf3BC.D;eHHoH pa60Tbl C rrpOH3.BcAeHHeM XOTSI BOJljj ,[Iyxa If KaK J.\OCTHraJOT BeqROrO fiJlaJKeRCTB3? ITPOR3ROCH: AllAa. KaK
pa3paCTaeTCJJ Bee 3Hepm'!HeH If Bblme , HO nOCJle.D;Hee CJlOBO Opmt3,!l c T3BOBHTCH 3RaMeBHTblM? ITpoff39OCJl: A3Aa. C fiJIarOpO~H}'IM ')KeCTOM
JleJKHT JlH'IHOCTII. HK'ITO He 1Iy'UIIe. OTToro 'ITO BOBO. HRKaKOc It B3mI{llb1MJI MaRepar.m. ,[(0 YMooOMpaqeBrul, AO 6ecC03HaTeJlbllOCTB.
HCKyCCTBO He OJlOXO. OTToro 'ITO He CXO)Ke C .D;PyrHMH. TaJ< AYMan KaK C6pOCHTb C cefiSl Bee 3MeffRoe, CK1IH3KOe, Bce pynmnoe,
6blJl0 fibl fie3rpa1nftrROH caMOYBepeR1:l0CThIO. KorAa rrpRXO.D;HT 8peMSI 6 0p30rmccKoe? Bce uapj{,lJ,uoe H npHr.1UQ\Roe, Bce npHMepnoe B
cnOKOHRoii , crrpaBe.D;JIHBoii OI~eRKH. BbHICRReTCJI, 'ITO T01lbKO Aofipoc MaRepRoe, 6JJaroBepRoe, HlYBepRoe? IIpoo3ROCJJ: ,tJ.a,qa. nana - 3TO
nOCTO.RIDIO, TOJILKO KCTHHHOe cnpaseWIHBo. qHCTbm liMIIpeCClfOIHIC1. tlyma MRpa. ,[(llAa-3TO ra03Ab ce30na .!J;a,qa - 3TO rryqmee l\BeTO'lRoe
eCJlH 011 BeJlltlGtH XYAO)fOt}J". AJlJJ Be'fIlOCTH OcraBHT GolTbme , qeM MblJlO B MHpe. A3Aa-rocnOAHR PyfiRBep, A3J1a-rocnoABR KOPpoJlR.
cpeAHHH 3KcrrpeCCJlORHCT, KaK fibl 01:1 RH crpeMHJ]CJJ K 6eCCMepTHlO . ,na,qa - AR3CTa3HYC JIU1IJfenurraHR.
MOJKeT 6 LITb. oepeA nOC1IeAHKM CYAOM fieCCTLmHaJJ. mTaBTCKaR. ITo-ReMellJ<}f )TO 3H3'1lofT: fiOllbwe BcerO ~eHRTb rOCTenpHlfMCTBO
3a8K81O~aJJCJJ, HaraJJ MOIItb 30M rrpeJ.\CTaJleT KaK oetlTO GoJlce UlBeRwlPRH; B CMlolCJ1e 3CTeTK'leCKOM Bce 3aJU1CffT OT Toro, CfTO
qeTmoe. '!eM HaWH 6opeunS! 80 KMSI fiara. H 3TO TO)f(e CYAb6a . npHIDlTO 33 3Tal10n. H tflfTalO CTHXH, KOTopble CTaBJJT nepeA co6oii
MOJKer CJlY'I\ITbC.sr. ~TO 3KcnpeCCH0KH3M npHBe,l.1eT K Be.1IB'KHM Aocni UeJTb fO mt MHoro HH MaJlO, KaK OTKa3 OT SOhIKa.
)f(eHIDlM. MI.1 6b! rrpBlUUJH ax O:l CBOH nne'!R. MO)f(eT CJTylfllThC.R. Mbl Aa,qa Horalm 4>YKcr:mr I re-re. .!J;a,qa C TeH.D;aJlb. AMa BYMa.
nOHMeM, 'ITO npe,l.1Ha3HaqeHbJ J.\JUl nClI He CTom. Be.1lHl<RX , 'ITO Mbl He arras !laMa. ll~a Ftt' 1311a, J{3Aa M' AllAa Aa.D;3 M X .... n~a
AOCTHTmt cBoeA ~eJm . Ho AaJKe B 3TOM cJIY'lae B Hac GbTlI CMl>lCJ1. Mbi
KaK 6hJ nOArOT08RllR nyn. qeMY-TO ,[IpyrOMY, 60llee BeJlHKOM}', TOM) Bce .nellO 8 C1Un)lX. 8 TOM. 'lT06 RX 811a'laJIe C1Ien<3 napytIlllTlo. 51
'ITO TOJlhKO n03,[1Hee BOPBeTCJJ B Barny )KH 3Hb . MI.J KaK fibl He XO'IY ClI0B, KOTopble H'JofiPeTenbJ APYrH MB . Bce Clloaa R306pe-reHbI
nOArOT081IJTR HCTJflUJhm CTHJ1l. 3noXH. ELlJIO fihl ryM3HBO B3Hrb Ha ~I PYMlMH. 51 XO'lY COOepW3Th CDOH COfiCTBelfHI.le 6e3Y\1HbJe nOC'I)'IIKR,
ce6S1' n 3TY 3a,q3QY 3To Y)f(e 38 rrpeAellaMH H3mero 3peHHSI. 06 'n OM x oqy "MeTh .D;1IJJ :i) TOrO COOTBeTCTBYlOlIlHe rJlaCHble R corJlacHble.
BeA3eT OAHH fior , nOfiY)f(AaBIIIHH Hac I< TBOpqeCTBY. Mbl He BbTHOCHM EC1IB 3aM3X !'dOli mRpOK. MHe aYJKRbl AJI.R 3Toro nOAaT1IHBhle C1Ioaa C
npRrOBOp3, Y HaC eCTL .rmnn. Bepa. Mw BepRbJ RanJRM DpRH:qHnaM H B mHpOKHM 33MaxOM. ClI0Ba JlCe rocnOJ{HH3 lliYJIbQe He 6oJIbll1e ABYX C
MaJIOM. H STO TO)fCe fieccMepTHo.
nOJlOBHHOH C3HTHMeTpoB.
MO)fCno craTh CBH.D;eTeJleM B03H11KJfOBeRIDI 'U1eHOpa3],\eJlbBOH pe'IB.
1917 j{ npOCTO npOH3BOJKY 3BYJGf. BCTlJIbmatOT ClI0Ba, OJle'IH ClIOB, Born,
pyKH, JlaAOHH ClI0B. CTUx-3TO DOBOA 00 B03MO)IQJOCTH 06oiITHcl.
6e3 ClIOB R )l3blxa. 3Toro DpOK.IDlToro Jl3bIKa, JlHIIKoro OT rpSl3HbLX
xyro 6AllIlb MAHMCI>ECT K nEPBOMY BE'-IEPY PrJ< MaKJlepOB, OT npRKOCHOBemm KOTopbrx CTHp3JOTClI MOBeThl . j{
AAeqAMCTOB B L(IOPMXE xoqy BJl3,[(eTh ClI0BOM B TOT MOMeHT, KOrAa OHO HC'le33eT B KOrn3 OHO
aaQBHaerCH.
,[(3.D;3 - HODoe Hanp3Bl1eOHe B HCK)'C Y KaJl(AorO Ae.rra CBoe ClIOBO; 3AeCh CJlOBO caMO CTaJlO AeJlOM.
CTBe. 06 aTOM rOBopfIT Y)f(C TO , 'ITO AO cm nop RI'fl-""1'OlJlfqero 0 l:IeM IIoqeM)' ].\epeBO nOC1le ].\O)IC].\SI' He MorllO fihT Ha3hlJlaThC)l wuoruoome
He 31:1.811, a 3aBTpa 0 ReM 3arOBopHT BeCb l(fOpHX. ClIOBO " A3A8 B3JJTO HJlH OJlIOnmo6ameM? H noqeM-y OHO Boofime .D;OJDKBO K3K-TO Ha3h1
H3 ClI0B3pJJ. Bce Y)K3CRO DpOCTO. ilo- <ppaau.y3CIQi OHO 030a'laeT: BaTbC.R? H Boo6lI{e , BO Bee JIH Ham JJ3bJK AO.IDKen COBaTh CBOH HOC?
KOReK . mofiHMoe 3aHJJTIfe. no-HeMe~JOt; a,qbe, npomaii, 6Y.D;b Aofip. DOBO, ClI0BO, BC}! 60JJh COCpe].\OTO'TB1l3Cb B ReM, CJlOBO, r ocnO.D;a,
CJl33h C Moeif meR , AO CBH,tJ.atmJI , AO cKoporo! llo-PYMbIRCIGf: Aa , OfimeCTBeRHaJJ npofiJleMa nepBOCTeneRBOH B3)((HOCTH.
BepKo, Blol npaBbl , 3TO Tax, K01te'lHO , J(eHCTBHTellbHO , TaK H nopelIIHM .
H TalC AaJlee. 1916
IiHTeplfaqJ{OHam.aoe ClIOBO. TOJIbKO CJlOBO . C lIOBO KaK ABIDKeHHe .
Bce npOCTO AO YJKaC3.. C03AaTL ff3 3Toro aanp3B1leRHe B HCK)'CCTBe
3Ha'lltT npeABOCXHTIITh MHOl'fle 3arpYAReHIDL ,[(a,qa - OCRXOJlOrWl,
A3A3-JlBTepaTyp3, A3Aa - fiYP)Kya3HJJ, H Bhl, yaa)Kaer.o.le n03TbJ,
TaOpHBlUlIe 0 PH n OMOII{H ClIOB, HO HHKOrna He TBOpllBmffe CClMO . 1 Hrpa CJ10 B: lIPaBlUlhBOC IDoUI li're - Ho1'1UlH Bo.nbcjJraur; nO-lIeMe~ 1IClJIIocjJ
ClI0BO,- BbJ TO)Ke A3Aa. ,[(3.D;3 - MHPOBWI BOiWa H 6ecKOReQHOCTh. 00.111<, cjJYXC-JlHca. I'3HI"- OOllO,[lKa.

316
317