Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Australia
Marketing Strategy and
Implementation Plan
20 May 2012
PRBM 033 Assessment Rubrics (Assessment 3)
Total Marks: 40%
Contents
Executive Summary......................................................................................................1
1 Introduction............................................................................................................3
2 Brief Profile of Toyota Global and Toyota Australia................................................3
3 Business Analysis, Concerns and Problems.........................................................4
3.1 Strengths.............................................................................................................4
3.2 Weaknesses.......................................................................................................4
3.3 Opportunities......................................................................................................4
3.4 Threats................................................................................................................4
4 Objectives of the Marketing Strategy.....................................................................5
5 Evaluation of Different Strategies..........................................................................5
5.1 Cost Leadership Strategy.................................................................................5
5.1.1 Benefits or Advantages...............................................................................6
5.1.2 Costs or Disadvantages..................................................................................6
5.2 Product Leadership Strategy..............................................................................6
5.2.1 Benefits or Advantages...................................................................................7
5.2.2 Costs or Disadvantages..................................................................................7
5.3 Focused Strategy................................................................................................8
5.3.1 Benefits or Advantages...................................................................................8
5.3.2 Costs or Disadvantages..................................................................................8
6 Implementation Plan..............................................................................................9
6.1 Four Ps.............................................................................................................9
6.1.1 Product............................................................................................................9
6.1.2 Price..............................................................................................................10
6.1.3 Place..............................................................................................................11
6.1.4 Promotion......................................................................................................12
6.2 Control Measures.............................................................................................12
7 Conclusion...........................................................................................................13
8 References...........................................................................................................14
PRBM003 Syed Redwanur Rahman, Susan C. Valerio, Wenjing Wan, Chunxiao Zhang Page 1
Executive Summary
Private companies carefully select strategies that are supportive of their goals,
objectives and targets. It is logical that they adopt strategies that increase their
market share, maximise their returns and minimise costs to sustain their
operations. The company is guided by these because it has to offer fair
compensation package to its workers, provide the expected stockholders returns,
strengthen market share, meet creditors expectations, continue its corporate social
responsibility role, enhance its goodwill, improve profitability, among others. But
choosing strategies is a difficult decision unless these are backed up by evidence,
data or scientific studies. Each company situation is a unique case. No need for this
introduction to theory
This report selects a strategy that provides solutions to the problems identified in
Toyotas SWOT analysis. Its weaknesses are: Recalls of vehicles globally,
estimated at 15.43 million in 2009-2010, have created negative image to Toyota
(Automotive News 2010). Its operating profit declined by 29.3% annually from
March 2008 to March 2011. As such, operating profit margins went down from 5.4%
in 2006-07 to 1.3% in 2010-11 (IBISWorld 2012, p 28). The following are the threats:
High labour cost in Australia diminishes its advantages in maintaining strong export
sales. Strong Australian dollar reduces its export comparative advantage. There is
strong competition in automobile sales, from local and imported ones. Australia is a
small market. There are legal, economic and political risks in dealing with other
countries.
Given these problems, the following are the objectives of the marketing strategy: To
improve production to prevent product recalls; to produce state-of-the art vehicles
and environment-friendly ones; to produce vehicles that respond to unique business
needs; to develop and strengthen business clients confidence; to increase further
its market share and boost its operating profits.
The paper focuses on the three marketing strategies that Toyota can implement to
achieve those. These are: cost leadership, product leadership and focused
strategy. Owing to time and resource constraints, the report focuses on the
qualitative aspects of cost-benefit analyses.
Cost leadership calls for being a low cost producer in an industry for a given
quality level (Quick MBA 2010). Product leadership strategy involves creating an
innovative product/service and marketing program so it is perceived by a broad
spectrum of customers as being a leading-edge product or service. Focused
strategy concentrates on a narrow market segment by a deep understanding of its
customers and the perception of the value of the product/service offered. The
company provides superior value by segmenting its markets and then tailoring its
product or service to match exactly the needs of targeted customers.
PRBM003 Syed Redwanur Rahman, Susan C. Valerio, Wenjing Wan, Chunxiao Zhang Page 2
Based on the analyses, the most effective is the product leadership strategy. It
responds well on the marketing objectives. The implementation plan highlights
the four Ps product, price, place and promotion for Toyotas business clients.
Advertising strategies, which carry messages such as your caring partner; we
have solutions to your problems; always at your side, your partner in
sustainable development , will complement the product leadership strategy.
Every staffs understanding and appreciation of the marketing objectives and targets
are imperative. This is to ensure that all departments support each other in the
pursuit of the same direction. Control measures, such as monitoring and continuing
assessments are crucial during implementation phases of the marketing strategy and
promotion activities. These will be undertaken monthly to make adjustments when
performance is off-track or external and internal factors negatively affect the
attainment of the objectives. Contingency plan or Plan B is part of implementation
mechanism so everyone is prepared when there are deviations caused by external
and internal factors.
Good start!
PRBM003 Syed Redwanur Rahman, Susan C. Valerio, Wenjing Wan, Chunxiao Zhang Page 3
1 Introduction
Companies who want to capture the global market innovate and devise ways on how
to deal with the situation. Businesses have unending needs and problems. These
are the opportunities that innovative firms capture to provide solutions to these felt
needs.
The paper focuses on Toyotas marketing plan and the three marketing strategies
that it can implement to increase its market share, improve profitability and enhance
goodwill. These are: cost leadership strategy, product leadership strategy and
focused strategy.
The cost and benefits of each strategy is presented and a strategy is chosen. Owing
to a large number of automobile manufacturers in Australia coupled with limited
domestic market, the product leadership strategy is a tool to produce state-of-the-
art vehicles. The strategy also responds to unique business clients needs and
problems, ensure brand loyalty and increase sales globally.
An implementation plan of the chosen strategy is discussed. The plan also includes
advertising activities to improve Toyotas image and boost its goodwill. Important
consideration is given on the regular monitoring of the plan and the preparation of
contingency measures or plans to warrant the achievement of the objectives.
Discuss more about the company here
Toyota Motor Corporation was established on August 28, 1937 by Mr. Sakichi
Toyoda. The companys main business is the production and sale of motor vehicles.
Its head office is located at Toyota-Cho, Toyota City, Aichi Prefecture, Japan, with Mr
Akio Toyoda as its President. Toyotas design, research and development centres in
Japan, USA, and Europe perform the following activities: product planning, vehicle
engineering and evaluation, basic research, exterior, interior and colour design,
design, prototype development, vehicle testing and evaluation at high speed and
under cold conditions, among others (Toyota Global). The company has 50
overseas manufacturing companies in 26 countries and regions, and the vehicles are
sold in more than 170 countries and regions under the Toyota, Lexus, Daihatsu and
Hino brands (Toyota Australia).
Assembly of Toyota vehicles started in Australia in 1963, but it was only in 1987 that
Toyota Australia became fully owned by Toyota Motor Corporation (Langfield-Smith &
Greenwood 1998, p. 336). With this change in ownership, Toyota Australia has
adopted the Toyota Production System (TPS), which means lean manufacturing
system, few people, less space and inventory, zero waste to produce high-quality
and cost-competitive product (Womack et al in Langfield-Smith & Greenwood
1998, p. 337). Good.
PRBM003 Syed Redwanur Rahman, Susan C. Valerio, Wenjing Wan, Chunxiao Zhang Page 4
3 Business Analysis, Concerns and Problems
Australias motor vehicle producers have faced tough time since the onset of global
financial crisis. It had started when consumers began switching to smaller, more fuel-
efficient vehicles because of environmental concerns and rising petrol prices
(IBISWorld 2012, p 5).
Despite competition, Toyota has maintained the lead in motor vehicle sales in 2011
when it sold 17,239 units, for a market share of 20.2%; GM Holden - 10,209
vehicles, 12% share while Hyundai Motor 7,507 vehicles, 8.8% share (IBISWorld
2012, pp 27-29). The best-selling model of Toyota is Corolla with sales of 3,593,
followed by the Toyota Hilux - 3,480, Volkswagen Golf - 3,337 and Mazda 3
3,185 (IBISWorld 2012, pp 27-29).
3.1 Strengths
3.2 Weaknesses
3.3 Opportunities
PRBM003 Syed Redwanur Rahman, Susan C. Valerio, Wenjing Wan, Chunxiao Zhang Page 5
3.4 Threats
The marketing strategy will respond to the weaknesses and threats identified
while optimising the benefits of its strengths and opportunities.
PRBM003 Syed Redwanur Rahman, Susan C. Valerio, Wenjing Wan, Chunxiao Zhang Page 6
closest competitor (BLC 2010). Consumers are more and more demanding, looking
for everything at a very attractive price (Maggioni et al 2006). Cost leadership
strategy may help Toyota Australia to translate its cost advantage into price
advantage for its customers and thereby improve its market share. The prospect of
increasing the market share provides a great opportunity for the company to attain
economies of scale and improve its profitability.
PRBM003 Syed Redwanur Rahman, Susan C. Valerio, Wenjing Wan, Chunxiao Zhang Page 7
Toyota may become so concerned with maintaining low costs that they
overlook needed changes in production or marketing.
The cost-leadership strategy may be more difficult in a dynamic environment
because some of the expenses that Toyota may seek to minimise are
research and development costs or marketing research costsexpenses
Toyota may need to remain competitive.
Business consumers may think that low cost strategy means low quality
vehicles.
Product leaders are companies that dominate their markets because they
continuously offer the best and most innovative products or services in their industry.
These companies display the ability and determination to make products that
consumers consider superior and products that deliver more benefits than others
(Verweire).
PRBM003 Syed Redwanur Rahman, Susan C. Valerio, Wenjing Wan, Chunxiao Zhang Page 8
small and medium-sized businesses, durable, many and strategically-located
dealers, etc.
Toyota Australia can establish its automobiles as the industry standard,
making it difficult for followers to gain customers.
It can build a strong Toyota brand by the best and most innovative
automobile and after-sales services. As a product leader, Toyota Australia will
have rare problems with powerful buyers because it offers them the best and
unique product and services. As it is the only one who can supply that kind
of vehicle and after-purchase services, it commands brand loyalty.
Innovative vehicle and services which result to brand loyalty also create a
barrier to entry for other companies seeking to enter the automobile industry.
Toyota Australia will spend much time and high expenses in managing and
keeping people talent. The strategy will require different resources and skills.
It also implies differing organisational arrangements, control procedures and
inventive systems.
Toyota Australia will spend more expenses in advertising and market
research. It has to prepare markets and educate potential customers to
accept products that never existed before. At the same time, the company
will take high risk in launching innovation in their products and services range.
Business focuses on understanding the customers and their perception of the value
of the product or service offered. Accompanying this orientation is a focus on the
lifetime value of a relationship. It costs only about one-fifth as much to make an
additional sale to an existing customer as it does to attract and sell to a new one.
Thus the concepts of customer equity and customer share instead of market
share are central to this strategy (Slater & Olson 2001).
PRBM003 Syed Redwanur Rahman, Susan C. Valerio, Wenjing Wan, Chunxiao Zhang Page 9
Toyota will be able to offer niche market something they perceive is always
instrumental for achieving high customer loyalty and long term company
reputation.
In the choice of a marketing strategy, the greatest consideration is the one that will
address the problems of Toyota and respond to its objectives. Being part of a
volatile automobile industry, competitively-priced automobiles respond to price-
conscious customers. But the increasing labour costs even in developing countries,
the rising costs of production and the difficulties of maintaining good supplier
relationship, among others, do not guarantee that a cost leadership strategy can be
sustained in the long run.
The notion of focusing only in a small segment of the market does not respond to the
problems identified and objectives set. Costs are lower but it does not guarantee
that market share increases and profitability rises and sustained. Focused strategy
may not be appropriate then.
Toyota has to invest in research and development in order to meet the changing
needs and preferences of the market. Toyota has to export in order to widen its
market share. Thus, it needs to carefully invest in product and service innovation
to provide solutions to the divergent inclinations of its business customers in the
different countries. Despite economic turmoil, businesses still prefer automobiles
that have the state-of-the-art features of the dynamic world. Businesses want to
lower cost, so they prefer automobiles which are fuel-efficient, environment-friendly,
durable, have extensive dealer networks, among others.
Based on the cost benefit analyses of the three strategies, Toyota can better adopt
the product leadership strategy. Business needs and problems are unending.
The market is dynamic, technology changes fast. Thus, the innovation and product
and service uniqueness offered by the strategy clearly responds to the diverse
problems of every business client. Good analysis, could even use a table format
6 Implementation Plan
At the start of the financial year, the goals, objectives, targets and strategies
should be understood, appreciated, approved and supported by all decision-makers
of Toyota. These decision-makers are in the purchasing, engineering, research
and development, manufacturing/assembly, production, administration,
PRBM003 Syed Redwanur Rahman, Susan C. Valerio, Wenjing Wan, Chunxiao Zhang Page 10
marketing departments, operations, among others. The assessment of previous
years or quarters performance should also be reviewed as the starting points. Each
department then should provide a venue where each employee understands and
appreciates how his/her tasks and responsibilities are related with the
departments targets and the companys overall goals and objectives.
6.1 Four Ps
6.1.1 Product
Hence, Toyota must come up with more innovation in hybrid category and add
value features so they can capture the B2B market share more. While developing
new cars, Toyota must focus on increasing performance ability and design so the
overall quality of Toyota cars is assured.
The following concerns or criteria should be incorporated in the product plan for
Toyota Australia. The research, purchasing and production departments will be
responsible for the product plan. Product leadership is the strategy, hence, these
five criteria should make Toyota vehicles stand out with the rest. Toyota Australia
may benefit from technology leadership by applying for patents for their
technology to prevent other companies from copying it.
Efficiency Fuel efficient cars are becoming popular due to higher fuel costs,
increasing gas taxes as well as environmental issues.
Safety Develop more precise features and build higher safety system
standard to enhance the safety of Toyota automobiles and minimise
product recalls.
Longevity Taxi operators, government agencies, travel agencies, among
others are cost-conscious; hence, it is imperative to improve quality
to extend the lifetime of Toyota vehicles. Similarly, the company
needs to enhance its after-purchases services to keep the
PRBM003 Syed Redwanur Rahman, Susan C. Valerio, Wenjing Wan, Chunxiao Zhang Page 11
longevity of Toyota vehicles.
6.1.2 Price
Price plan is a significant part of the implementation plan as it may affect Toyota
Australias market shares, revenue and customer loyalty. Price is a major concern
of production, engineering and operations departments. The price plan may adopt
the following:
Value-added pricing in which buyers are willing to pay more for a superior
offer, usually based on service, brand and other benefits or features of the
vehicle itself. Toyota can easily go for value added pricing, as the business
customers are expected to be convinced by the superior innovation, value
added features and overall quality of the cars. They will be convinced to pay
that extra price for the superior benefits they will enjoy.
Toyota can set volume discounts and wholesale pricing to attract key business
customers. For example, Toyota can provide discounts and limited time free
services for taxi companies, tour operators, hotels, schools, police and other
government departments which may purchase large volume of automobiles.
These companies can also help promote Toyota automobiles with their peers
or company networks.
6.1.3 Place
The marketing and sales departments shall be involved in this category, among
their other concerns. Toyota Australia has to improve its business-to-business
distribution systems through the following:
Dealership
- Recruiting the best vehicle dealers in the local area
- Provide professional training for Toyota accredited dealers
- Focus on teamwork among different departments - including services,
parts, sales, finance and administration
- Carefully study the strategic locations of the dealers
PRBM003 Syed Redwanur Rahman, Susan C. Valerio, Wenjing Wan, Chunxiao Zhang Page 12
Toyota can continue its Toyota Environmental Dealership (TED) program
which promotes environmental leadership in the dealer network (Toyota
Australia 2012b). The program has seven dimensions which aim to integrate
sustainable business practices in daily operations and to encourage dealers
to continuously improve their environmental performance. This is done by
benchmarking their performance against other dealers and showcasing their
environmental initiatives. These benchmarks are: risk management and
commitment, energy use (carbon emissions), recycling and waste
management, water use, environmentally-preferred purchasing staff , training
and communication, social contribution and innovation (Toyota Australia
2012b).
Order processing
Build accurate and fast order processing system between marketing center
and Toyota dealers. Toyota can innovate in their distribution system in
making the selling and buying process automated. Toyota can have a
dedicated website where all their cars and their offers will be posted for the
review of their business clients. It can receive orders and payments online.
This can minimise the hassle of having too many intermediaries in the
distribution process.
6.1.4 Promotion
In its advertising strategies, the following are its objectives: to improve the company
image, to increase goodwill and to expand its business clients. Among the
messages that it can develop are: your caring partner; we have solutions to your
problems; always at your side, your partner in sustainable development.
These taglines should be translated into actions.
In carrying out its advertising messages, Toyota will utilise internet, personal selling
and sales promotion. The use of internet is promising to reach and affect
automobile market. Personal selling is likewise important because it affords more
conviction for purchase. This will be carried out by the local dealers who have been
trained to be familiar with Toyota automobile specifications through their dealership
materials and agreements.
The company shall also employ sales promotion through the use of volume discount
PRBM003 Syed Redwanur Rahman, Susan C. Valerio, Wenjing Wan, Chunxiao Zhang Page 13
to attract key customers. Toyota Australia also can offer service discount or annual
free service for key business customers.
The company should develop positive public relationships with media and the
community through its corporate social responsibility (CSR) programs. It has to
maintain good public relations to obtain favorable publicity as well as to handle
successfully negative feedbacks. Its TED program plays a major role in this image
building.
Toyota, together with their local dealers, can take part in trade shows and run
different promotional campaign from time to time. Toyota can also provide some
extra to the cars existing features without additional payment from business clients.
This can enhance business customers loyalty.
If the advertising objectives are not met, the concerned departments should
evaluate their messages and media tools for appropriate adjustments. There are
direct financial expenses on staff meetings for activity assessments and evaluation.
But the cost of closer coordination and constant dialogues among the workers is
less than the benefits of having fixed the problems promptly. Good discussion here.
If the problems are caused by external factors, the company should prioritise
strategic research and development activities to lower costs. But still, the main
strategy is product leadership. At this period, consumers are price-sensitive and
business buyers may be satisfied with a basic product and may not be willing to pay
higher price for the extra features. The purchasing, production and marketing
departments may also revise their sales targets to properly manage their inventory.
Dealers feedback should be taken timely to get the updated and constant changing
scenario of the market.
If the problems are caused by internal factors, the concerned departments should
alert others of the contingency measures. The purchasing department, for instance,
may start negotiating with other countries for raw materials delivery. The production
department may have institutionalised a pool of trained workers who can be on call
when labour problems occur. The marketing and sales department should be
properly advised on how to respond to booked sales or future orders. In this way, all
PRBM003 Syed Redwanur Rahman, Susan C. Valerio, Wenjing Wan, Chunxiao Zhang Page 14
are prepared to implement the contingency plan or plan B. You can discuss about
the urgent steps to be taken in the strategy or implementation to fix any issues rising
from the control measures
7 Conclusion
These are the opportunities that innovative firms capture to provide answers to these
felt needs. Automobiles are not anymore viewed as a luxury item but a necessity
because these facilitate business activities. As such, new product and service
features should come out from manufacturers.
Toyota should implement product leadership strategy to address the problems and
achieve the objectives identified. The negative impacts of automobile recalls can be
addressed by a high quality, state-of-the-art automobiles as a result of massive
research and development efforts. Toyota can respond to every unique business
problem through its innovations. With this reputation, businesses confidence can
increase, resulting in higher market share. Wider market share means more sales,
which can be translated into higher profitability.
8 References
Business Learning Centre, 2010, Cost leadership strategy, viewed 06 May, 2012,
http://www.seedeebee.com/business-strategy/cost-leadership-strategy-184.html
Kotler. P & Keller, L, 2008, Marketing management 2008, 13th ed, Prentice Hall,
New Jersey
PRBM003 Syed Redwanur Rahman, Susan C. Valerio, Wenjing Wan, Chunxiao Zhang Page 15
Langfield-Smith, K, Greenwood, M, 1998, Developing Co-operative Buyer-Supplier
Relationship: The Case of Toyota, Journal of Management Studies, 35:33, May
1998, and Blackwell Publishers Ltd.
Maggioni, S, Thiele, R, Rivard, S, Turner, A, 2006, Leadership in the automobile
industry, Blue Paper, Spencer Stuart, viewed 05 May 2012,
http://content.spencerstuart.com/sswebsite/pdf/lib/Automotive_Study_March_06.pdf
PRBM003 Syed Redwanur Rahman, Susan C. Valerio, Wenjing Wan, Chunxiao Zhang Page 16