Professional Documents
Culture Documents
11251134, 2001
# 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved
Printed in Great Britain
PII: S0043-1354(00)00389-4 0043-1354/01/$ - see front matter
Abstract}Red mud, an aluminium industry waste, has been converted into an inexpensive and efficient
adsorbent and used for the removal of lead and chromium from aqueous solutions. Effect of various
factors on the removal of these metal ions from water ( e.g. pH, adsorbent dose, adsorbate concentration,
temperature, particle size, etc.) has been studied and discussed. The effect of presence of other metal ions/
surfactants on the removal of Pb2+ and Cr6+ has also been studied. The material exhibits good adsorption
capacity and the data follow both Freundlich and Langmuir models. Thermodynamic parameters indicate
the feasibility of the process. Kinetic studies have been performed to understand the mechanism of
adsorption. Dynamic modelling of lead and chromium removal on red mud has been undertaken and
found to follow first-order kinetics. The rate constant and mass transfer coefficient have also been
evaluated under optimum conditions of removal in order to understand the mechanism. Column studies
have been carried out to compare these with batch capacities. The recovery of Pb2+ and Cr6+ and
chemical regenertion of the spent column have also been tried. # 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights
reserved
Equipment
Atomic absorption spectra were recorded using an atomic Kinetic studies
absorption/emission spectrophotometer (Perkin Elmer The batch technique was selected for kinetic studies
Model 3100, USA). X-ray measurements were done by because of its simplicity and reliability. A number of 50 mL
a Phillips X-ray diffractometer (Model No. PW 1140/90, stoppered glass tubes containing a definite volume (10 mL in
Holland) employing nickel filtered Cu Ka radiations. The each case) of solutions of metal ions of known concentra-
surface area of the sample was measured by a surface-area tion (3.38 103 M for Pb2+ and 5.77 103 M for Cr6+)
analyzer (Model QS-7; Quantasorb surface-area analyzer, were placed in a thermostat cum shaking assembly. At
USA). pH measurements were made using a pH meter desired temperature, a known amount of adsorbent (0.1 g)
(Model CT No. C L 46 ; Toshniwal, India). The constituents was added into each tube and the solutions were agitated
of red mud were analyzed following the standard methods intermittently. At predecided interval of time, the test
of chemical analysis (Vogel, 1989). Scanning electron solutions were centrifuged to separate the adsorbent
microscopy was performed using a Phillips SEM 501 material and the supernatant was analyzed for aqueous
electron microscope (Holland). The density of the adsorbent metal. The kinetic studies were also performed at different
was determined by specific gravity bottles. adsorbate (2.41 1034.83 103 M for Pb2+ and
Removal of lead and chromium from aqueous solutions 1127
9.60 1049.60 103 M for Cr6+) and adsorbent depict that red mud consist of fine particles, of
(5 g L120 g L1 for both Pb2+ and Cr6+) concentration. indefinite shape, at the same time, there were distinct
separate crystal having a shape of regular and
Column studies irregular quadrangle (Fig. 1(a)(d)).
Adsorption isotherms are used for some primary studies
and obtaining the operational parameters before running
more costly experiments. Hence, the practical applicability
of the product for column operations has also been studied Adsorption studies
to obtain some parameters necessary for a factual design
model. A glass column (40 0.5 cm) filled with a known Adsorption of the two metal ions was studied at
amount of red mud (mesh size 200250) was used for varying pH values to determine the optimum pH
different metal ions. Effluent flow was adjusted with a clip at range for their removal, and the results are shown in
the bottom of the column. The columns were loaded with
solutions of Pb2+ (3.38 103 M) and Cr6+ (5.77 103 M)
Fig. 2. The percentage adsorption increased with
at pH 4.0 and 2.0, respectively. increasing pH up to a certain range in both cases and
then decreased with further increase in pH. The
Regeneration maximum uptake took place at pH 4.0 and 2.0 for
Regeneration of adsorbent as well as recovery of
lead and chromium, respectively. The variation in the
adsorbate material is quite important, therefore, the same removal of lead and chromium can be explained by
have been achieved by using 1% HNO3. Simultaneous considering the surface charge of the adsorbent
regeneration of adsorbent was also tried. material, i.e., red mud. Among the various constitu-
ents of red mud the ZPC of silica is 2.3 and that of
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Fe2O3 is 8.6. The composite ZPC of the adsorbent
is found to be 3.2. Thus below 3.2 pH the surface has
Characterization of the adsorbent material high positive charge density and under these condi-
tions the uptake of metal ions would be quite low due
Chemical constituents of the activated red mud as
to electrostatic repulsion. With increasing pH, i.e.,
determined by using standard methods of chemical beyond ZPC the negative charge density on the
analysis are Fe2O3, 38.80%; TiO2, 18.80%; SiO2, surface of adsorbent increases, thereby resulting in a
9.64%; Al2O3, 17.28%; Na2O, 6.86%; Loss on
sudden enhancement in metal adsorption. As such
ignition, 7.34% by weight. Porosity and density of
lead get adsorbed at pH 4.0. However, the higher
the product, as determined by a mercury porosimeter adsorption of Cr6+ on red mud at low pH may be
and specific gravity bottles, are 0.45 fractions and due to the neutralization of surface charge by an
2.002 g/cm3, respectively. One gram sample of
excess of hydrogen ions, thereby, facilitating the
activated red mud was stirred with deionized water diffusion of dichromate ions and their adsorption on
(100 mL, pH 6.8) for 2 h and left for 24 h in an air- the prepared adsorbent. A significant reduction in the
tight stoppered conical flask. An enhancement in pH
adsorption of Cr6+ at higher pH is possibly due to
7.5 was noticed. Red mud is quite stable in water, salt the abundance of OH ions resulting in an increased
solutions, acids, bases, and organic solvents. Analysis hindrance to the diffusing species. These finding are
by X-ray diffraction showed a predominance of
also supported by considering the composition of red
poorly soluble minerals (Table 1) which shows a
mud texture. Red mud is composed of clay minerals
high chemical stability of the red mud (Index to the having negative double layer at the planar surface,
powder diffraction file, 1971; Gadsden, 1975). The
and on broken edges (Van Olphen, 1963), the
surface area of the adsorbent as calculated by BET
polarity of the double layer is reversed, i.e., the fixed
method was found to be 108 m2 g1. Surface structure part of the double layer is positive and counter ions
of activated red mud was observed by scanning are anions. The positive double layer at broken edges
electron microscope (SEM). SEM photo-micro-
changes polarity with increasing pH and results in an
graphs of activated red mud, at four different enhancement of negative adsorption sites at higher
magnifications, helped in recognizing the texture of pH. Significant adsorption of lead and chromium at
aluminium silicates, distributed with the heavy
low pH values suggested that the process of metal ion
constituents like iron. The photo-micrographs also uptake is sufficient energetic to over come the net
electrostatic repulsion.
Various fractions of particle size, i.e., 100150,
Table 1. d-spacing values obtained from X-ray diffraction of the 150200, and 200250 B.S.S. mesh have been tried
activated red mud
and it was found that as the particle size decreases,
d (A) Probable minerals d (A) Probable minerals the extent of adsorption increases this may be
because of the enhanced surface area available for
3.67 Cancrinite 2.69 Hematite the adsorption (Fig. 3(a) and (b)). However, a
4.18 Goethite 1.69 Hematite
2.45 Goethite 2.51 Hematite
uniform particle size of 150200 mesh was used
3.26 Rutile 3.52 Anataze because of convenience and due to the fact that there
2.94 Rutile 1.89 Anataze was very little difference in adsorption with particle
3.33 Quartz
size of 200250 mesh and 150200 mesh.
1128 Vinod K. Gupta et al.
Fig. 1. S.E.M. microphotographs of activated red mud at different magnifications: (a) 1 5000;
(b) 1 2500; (c) 1 160; (d) 1 80.
were obtained using expressions as described earlier Fig. 4. Effect of temperature on the adsorption of (a) Pb2+
(Gupta, 1998). The negative free energy values and (b) Cr2+ on activated red mud.
indicate the feasibility of the process and its
spontaneous nature without any induction period.
The negative values of enthalpy change (DH 0 ) for the the ratio of the adsorption capacity of the ion in a
processes confirm their exothermic nature and the single component system (q0 ) to that in a multi-
possibility of strong bonding between the metal ions component system (qm ) (Tan et al., 1985). It was
i.e. Pb2+ and Cr6+ and red mud. A negative entropy observed that the removal of Pb2+ at 4.35 103 M
of adsorption (DS0 ) reflects the affinity of the was reduced by 4.37, 7.81, 12.64, and 15.17% in the
adsorbent material towards lead and chromium. presence of 1.0 105 M Na+, Cr6+, Zn2+, and
As a result of effluent emission from commercial Cd2+, respectively, and the removal of Cr6+ at
and domestic sector, natural water bodies may be concentration 8.65 103 M is reduced by 1.50, 2.78,
contaminated by a large number of heavy metal ions 3.82, and 4.63% in the presence of 1.0 105 M
and surfactants. The competitive adsorption of Pb2+ Na+, Zn2+, Cd2+, and Pb2+, respectively. Similarly
and Cr6+ was studied in the presence of several metal a decrease in the scavenging efficiency (qm =q0 51) of
ions and surfactants. The effects of ionic interactions the red mud in the presence of anionic surfactant
on the adsorption process has been interpreted, using (manoxol 1B) and cationic surfactant (cetyltrimethyl
Table 2. Freundlich and Langmuir constants for adsorption of Pb2+ and Cr6+ on red mud
Table 3. Thermodynamic parameters for the adsorption of Pb2+ and Cr6+ on red mud
ammonium bromide) takes place for the uptake of values of the rate constant, Kad , for each system were
lead and chromium. It is found that the removal calculated from the respective Lagergerns plot and
of Pb2+ and Cr6+ goes down by 6.67 and 1.85%, are listed in Table 4.
respectively, in the presence of cationic surfactant
(1.0 105 M). Similarly in the presence of manoxol Mass transfer study. McKay and coworkers (1981)
1B (1.0 105 M) uptake was reduced by 9.88 and proposed a mass transfer model as given below
4.16% for Pb2+ and Cr6+, respectively.
Ct 1 mk 1 mk
ln ln bL 3
C0 1 mk 1 mk mk
Kinetic studies
where Ct and Co (both in mg L1) are the respective
Preliminary studies on the rate of removal of Pb2+ concentrations of the metal ion at time t and zero,
and Cr6+ by red mud (at the optimum pH and k(L g1) is a constant obtained by multiplying the
adsorbent concentration), indicate the process to be Langmuir constants Q0 and b, m (g L1) and Ss
quite rapid. Nearly 3045% of the adsorption (cm1) are, respectively, the mass and outer surface
capacity was realized within the first hour of contact. area of the adsorbent particles per unit volume of
The initial rapid adsorption gives way to a very slow particle free slurry and bL (cm s1) is the mass
rate of approach to equilibrium, and saturation is transfer coefficient. The straight line plots between
reached in 810 h. It was found that the rate of lnCt =C0 1=1 mk and t proved the validity of
removal of metal ions increases with an increase in
the amount of red mud. For both the metal ions
(Pb2+ and Cr6+) there was a significant increase in
adsorption when adsorbent amount is increased from
5 to 10 g L1. Any additional amount of red mud
does not cause any significant change. Taking into
account both the handling problems associated with
large quantities of red mud and the relatively smaller
solute removal with smaller amounts of adsorbent,
the amount of red mud taken in all subsequent
kinetic studies was 10 g L1, for both Pb2+ and Cr6+
ions.
The rate of uptake of adsorbates, in the first hour
of contact, increases with an increase in the con-
centration of adsorbate, while, the time required for
50% of the ultimate adsorption is independent of the
initial adsorbate concentration (Fig. 5(a) and (b)).
Adsorption dynamics
The adsorption dynamics of the present system
were studied as follows.
Table 4. Mass transfer cofficient (bL ) and rate constant of through the origin and the process seems to be
adsorption (Kad ) values for Pb2+ and Cr6+ particle diffusion controlled and during the later
Metal ion bL 105 (cm s1) Kad 103 (min1)
stages of reactor the film diffusion mechanism also
becomes operative which is apparent from the
Pb2+ 13.70 1.080 deviation of the plots from linearity. The Bt vs.
Cr6+ 5.770 0.615 time plots of Cr6+ were linear initially at higher
concentration and passed through the origin
indicating the process to be particle diffusion but at
the above model in the present study. The values of lower concentrations ( 5.77 103 M) it was
bL for different systems were determined from these divided into two distinct parts. Initial part of the
plots and are given in Table 4. These values indicate plot did not pass through the origin and the slope
that the velocity of mass transfer of lead and was small and thus the process was film-diffusion
chromium ions on red mud is sufficiently rapid to controlled. But in the later part of the plot the slope
recommend its use in the treatment of wastewater increases and thus particle-diffusion mechanism also
polluted by lead and chromium. operates simultaneously (plot not given).
The Di values for the lead-red mud and chro-
Rate expression and treatment of data. In order to miumred mud systems at different temperatures are
properly interpret the experimental data, it is listed in Table 5. It may be argued that the effective
necessary to identify steps controlling the overall diffusion coefficient, Di in these systems comprises
removal rate in the adsorption process. Kinetic data, two components, which are due to the simultaneous
as obtained by finite bath method has been treated by diffusion of the ingoing ions through the pores of
expression 4 and 5 given by Boyd et al. (1947). This is different widths and different electronic fields along
in accordance with the observations of Reichenberg the diffusion path. The diffusion within the pores of
(1953). wider-widths and weaker retarding forces of electro-
6 X1
1 Di tp2 n2 static interaction (particularly at the surface of the
F 1 2 exp 4 adsorbent) accounts for the faster one and the one
p n1 n2 r20
within the pores of narrower mesh widths and
stronger retarding forces, accounts for the slower
6 X 1
1
F 1 exp n2 Bt 5 component of Di . As the temperature increases, the
p2 n1 n2 contribution of the faster component of Di decreases.
where F is the fractional attainment of equilibrium at It is due to the decreasing mobility of the ingoing ion
time t and is obtained by at higher temperature which to some extent over-
comes the influence of retarding forces along the
F Qt =Q1 6 diffusion path.
The linear nature of log Di vs. 1=T plots for both
B p2 Di =r20 time constant 7 the metal ions permits the use of Arrhenius equation
where Qt is the amount of uptake at time t and Q1 is for the determination of D0 and Ea from the
the maximum equilibrium uptake, Di is the effective intercepts and the slopes of the linear plots
diffusion coefficient of adsorbate in adsorbent (Fig. 6(a) and (b)). D0 values are further used to
phases, r0 is the radius of the adsorbent particle calculate the entropy of activation for the adsorption
assumed to be spherical and n is an integer. The of lead and chromium (Table 5). It is found that the
linearity test of Bt vs. t are employed to distinguish Ea values are higher for chromiumred mud system
between the film and particlecontrolled mechanism. than for the leadred mud system. The negative DS#
The Bt vs. time plots (figure not shown) for Pb2+ at values reflect that no significant change occurs in the
lower concentrations (3.38 103 M) were linear internal structure of red mud during the adsorption
and did not pass through the origin indicating of Pb2+ and Cr6+.
the film diffusion to be the rate-determining
mechanism. However, an increase in the sorption
rate of the Pb2+ with decreasing temperature, Column studies
support the particle diffusion mechanism. But at For a feasible adsorption processes a straight
higher concentrations (4.83 103 M) initially the forward approach of Weber (1972) has been adopted
Bt vs. time plot obtained were linear and passed for the design of fixed bed adsorbers for the removal
Table 5. Effective diffusion coefficients (Di ), D0 , Ea , and DS # values for Pb2+ and Cr6+ at different temperatures
Metal ions Di (m2 s1) 1012 D0 (m2 s1) 1013 Ea (kJ mol1) DS (J K1 mol1)
Table 6. Comparison of batch and column capacity Davis L. and Ford P. E. (1972) Application of carbon
adsorption in the treatment of petrochemical waste-
Adsorbate Batch capacity Column capacity water. In Progress in Water Technology, Vol. 1, eds
(mg g1) (mg g1) W. W. Eckefelder and L. K. Cecil. Pergamon Press. Inc,
New York.
Pb2+ 64.79 88.20
Cr6+ 35.66 75.00
Dean J. G., Bosqui F. L. and Lanouette K. H. (1972)
Removing heavy metals from wastewater. Environ. Sci.
Technol. 6, 518522.
Diamadopoulos E., Loannidis S. and Sakellaropoulos G. P.
(1993) As(V) removal from aqueous solution by fly ash.
spent columns. It was observed that a treatment with Water Res. 27, 17731777.
1M HNO3 solution at a flow rate of 0.5 mL min1 Dimitrova S. V. and Mehandgiev D. R. (1998) Lead
restores the sorption capacity of columns of red mud. removal from aqueous solution by granulated blast
furnace slag. Water Res. 32, 32893292.
This treatment is to be done after each cycle. With Faust S. D. and Aly O. M. (1987) Adsorption Processes of
this treatment only 210% loss is recorded in the Water Treatment. Butterworth Publishers, Stoneham,
second cycle and no further decrease is observed in MA.
subsequent cycles. Ferraiolo G., Zilli M. and Converti A. (1990) Fly ash
disposal and utilization. J. Chem. Technol. Biotechnol. 47,
281306.
CONCLUSIONS Gadsden J. A. (1975) Infrared Spectra of Minerals and
Related Inorganic Compounds. Butterworth & Co.
Red mud obtained from the aluminium industry is (Publishers) Ltd, London.
Groffman A., Peterson S. and Brookins D. (1992) Remov-
an efficient adsorbent for the removal of lead and ing lead from wastewater using zeolites. Water Environ.
chromium. The product, activated in air, holds Technol. 5, 5459.
promising adsorption characteristics for lead and Gupta V. K. (1998) Equilibrium uptake sorption dynamics
chromium and can be used as a suitable adsorbent process development and column operations for the
for the treatment of wastewater of various industries. removal of copper and nickel from aqueous solutions
and wastewater using activated slag, a low-cost adsor-
The uptake of chromium is more than that of lead bent. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 37, 192202.
and is comparable to other commercially available Gupta V. K., Mohan D. and Sharma S. (1998a) Removal of
adsorbents. The removal of metal ions by this lead from wastewater using bagasse fly ash}a sugar
adsorbent takes place via particle diffusion and the industry waste material. Sep. Sci. Technol. 33, 13311343.
Gupta V. K., Rastogi A., Diwivedi M. K. and Mohan D.
thermodynamic parameters reflect the feasibility of (1997) Process development for the removal and recovery
the process. The results indicate that the red mud can of zinc and cadmium from wastewater using slag a blast
be successfully employed for the removal of Pb2+ furnace waste material. Sep. Sci. Technol. 32, 28832912.
and Cr6+ in a wide range of concentrations. The Gupta V. K., Sharma S., Yadav I. S. and Mohan D. (1998)
Utilization of bagasse fly ash generated in the sugar
studies on column operations show that the product
industry for the removal of phenol and p-nitrophenol
can also be used on an indsutrial scale. Metal ions from wastewater. J. Chem. Technol. Biotechnol. 71,
adsorbed on the column of this material can be 180186.
quantitatively eluted with 1% HNO3. The exhausted Ho Y. S. and McKay G. (1999) The sorption of lead(II) ions
column can be chemically regenerated by treating it on peat. Water Res. 33(2), 578584.
Huang C. P. and Wu M. H. (1977) The removal of
with 1 M HNO3 and no dismantling is required. chromium (VI) from dilute aqueous solutions by acti-
Other salts present in effluents do not cause any vated carbons. Water Res. 11, 673679.
disturbing effects. Index (Inorganic) to the powder diffraction File (1971) Joint
Committee on Powder Diffraction Standards Publication:
Acknowledgements}The authors are thankful to CSIR PD1S-21i, Pennsylvania.
(Council of Scientific and Industrial Research), New Delhi, I.S.I. (1982) Tolerance limits for industrial effluents pre-
India for supporting the work. scribed by Indian Standards Institution, IA: 2490 (Part II),
(Address: Bureau of Indian Standards; Manak Bhawan,
9 Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi 11002, India).
REFERENCES I.S.I. (1991) Drinking water specification, IS: 10500.
Lalvani S. B, Wiltowski T., Hubner A., Weston A. and
Akay G., Keskinber B., Corkici A. and Danis U. (1998) Mandich N. (1998) Removal of hexavalent chromium
Phosphate removal from water by red mud using cross and metal cations by a selective and novel carbon
flow microfiltration. Water Res. 32, 717726. adsorbent. Carbon 36, 12191226.
Aly H. M. and Daifullah A. A. M. (1998) Potential use of Li L. Y. (1998) Properties of red mud tailings produced
bagasse pith for the treatment of wastewater containing under varying process conditions. J. Environ. Eng. Div.
metals. Adsorp. Sci. Technol. 16, 3338. ASCE. 124, 254264.
Boyd G. E., Adamson A. W. and Meyers L. S. (1947) The Lopez E., Soto B., Asias M., Nunez A., Rubinos D. and
exchange adsorption of ions from aqueous solutions Barral M. T. (1998) Adsorbent properties of red mud and
by organic zeolites II kinetics. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 69, its use for wastewater treatment. Water Res. 32,
28362848. 13141322.
Chang J. S., Law R. and Chang C.-C. (1997,) Biosorption of McKay G., Allen S. J., McConvey I. F. and Otterburn M. S.
lead, copper, cadmium by biomass of pseudomonas (1981) Transport processes in the sorption of colored
aeruginosa, PU21. Water Res. 31, 16511658. ions by peat particles. J. Colloid Interface. Sci. 80,
Cheremisinoff P. N. and Ellerbush F. (1979) Carbon 323339.
Adsorption Handbook. Ann Arbor Science Publishers, Namasivayam C. and Ranganathan K. (1998) Effect of
Michigan. organic ligands on the removal of Pb(II), Ni(II), and
1134 Vinod K. Gupta et al.
Cd(II) by waste Fe(III)/Cr(III) hydroxide. Water Res. 32, Srivastava S. K., Tyagi R., Pal N. and Mohan D. (1997)
969971. Process developement for the removal of sub-
Park K. T., Gupta V. K., Mohan D. and Sharma S. (1999) stituted phenol by carbonaceous adsorbent obtained from
Removal of chromium (VI) from electroplating industry fertilizer waste. J. Environ. Eng. Div. ASCE. 123,
wastewater using bagasse fly ash}a sugar industry waste 842851.
material. The Environmentalist 19, 129136. Srivastava S. K., Tyagi R. and Pant N. (1989) Adsorption
Periasamy K. and Namasivayam C. (1994) Process of heavy metal ions on carbonaceous material developed
development for removal and recovery of cadmium from the waste slurry generated in local fertilizer plants.
from wastewater by a low cost adsorbent: Adsorption Water Res. 23, 11611165.
rates and equilibrium studies. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 33, Tan T. C., Chia C. K. and Teo C. K. (1985) Uptake of metal
317320. ions by chemically treated human hair. Water Res. 19,
Pollard S. J. T., Fowler G. D., Sollars C. J. and Perry R. 157162.
(1992) Low-cost adsorbents for waste and waste water Van Olphen H. (1963) An introduction to clay colloid
treatment: a review. Sci. Total Environ. 116, 3152. chemistry, p. 90. Interscience Pub., New York.
Reichenberg D. (1953) Properties of ion exchange resins in Vogel A. I. (1989) A test book of quantitative chemical
relation to their structure III kinetics of exchangers. analysis, 5th ed. ELBS. Publication, London.
J. Am. Chem. Soc. 75, 589597. Weber Jr. W. J. (1972) Physicochemical processes for water
Srivastava S. K. and Tyagi R. (1995) Competitive quality control. Wiley Interscience, New York.
adsorption of substituted phenols by activated carbon Weber T. W. and Chakravorti R. K. (1974) Pore and solid
developed from the fertilizer waste slurry. Water Res. 29, diffusion models for fixed bed adsorbers. J. Am. Inst.
483488. Chem. Eng. 20, 228238.