Professional Documents
Culture Documents
org
San Francisco, CA, USA, June 25-30, 2017
Copyright 2017 by the International Society of Offshore and Polar Engineers (ISOPE)
ISBN 978-1-880653-97-5; ISSN 1098-6189
ABSTRACT model tests in wave, maneuverability and ice basins, wind tunnel, as
well as sea trials in ice.
The paper examines the integrated approach applied to the design of
icebreakers around the world. This method envisages the following The icebreaker of Project 21900 continues a series of sea-going
steps of the design process: development of basic design drawings, icebreakers designed by CDB Baltsudoproekt taking the benefit of
preliminary estimation of maneuverability, seakeeping, aerodynamic lessons learned from design, construction and operation of the previous
and ice performance of the vessel under design, refinement of estimated Moskva-type icebreaker type (Project 21900).
characteristics and optimization of hull lines based on model tests in the
wave, maneuverability and ice basins, as well as in wind tunnel. The Following a thorough analysis of the design, construction and operation
wind, wave and ice conditions used in the analytical and experimental of Project 21900 icebreakers, the icebreaker of Project 21900 has
evaluations are as close as possible to the specific operating been considerably modified as compared with the Moskva-type vessels
environment of the icebreaker. to accommodate higher requirements of customers.
The paper is mainly based on the studies of the Krylov State At sea the hull body and superstructures in way of helipads have
Research Centre undertaken as part of comprehensive research adverse effects on air patterns near the helipads. Strong winds, large
efforts focusing on the operational safety of icebreaker including lateral and vertical wind velocities induced by superstructures make it
difficult to take off and land, rotate or prevent rotation of main rotor
1410
blades. Vertical wall of ship superstructures produce low-pressure The air flow structure was investigated by measuring space vectors of
zones, flow re-circulation which may attract helicopters to local velocities. Flow angles over the helideck were measured at
superstructure. incident flow velocity of V0 = 30 m/s. The measurements were taken
in the wind coordinate system XYZ with its origin fixed in the helipad
center. Fig.3 shows coordinates of measurement points projected onto
the [XZ] plane.
Air flow speed, direction and turbulence over helipads are essential
constraints for helicopter operation. Anyway there is a limiting air flow
speed and direction for every type of helicopters, and our task is to
enhance the operating envelope of a given helipad in terms of the
apparent wind direction and speed based on recommendations for
smoothing air flow patterns above helipads. One of the specific
considerations for ship-based helicopters to be taken into account is
exhaust smoke from ship stacks. These smoke polluted areas have Fig. 3 Measurement points of flow angles projected on the [XZ]
local temperature elevations and fuel combustion products. It is critical plane.
to know the boundaries of these potentially hazardous areas because if
a helicopter flies into a cloud of exhaust gases its engine may falter and
risk an accident.
1411
Fig. 7 Smoke may icebreaker when = 0 (side view)
Fig. 5 Air flow angles over helipad
Studies flow patterns showed that the superstructure causes severe
For obtaining full-scale velocity vectors the non-dimensional values disturbance of the flow with the formation of a broad zone of reverse
have to be multiplied by the full-scale wind speed. Such inputs are flow across the height of the superstructure, which leads to smoke
provided to the organizations drawing up practical manuals for take- runway, as well as to smoke the air intakes of the engine room.
off/landing operations.
As a result, recommendations were formulated in Manual of the
Visualization of air flow patterns over helipad. International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), 1995, to change the
architecture of the ship above the water and studied (Fig. 8) in the wind
Air flow patterns around model can be qualitatively assessed using and hydrodynamic (Fig. 9) Institute of tubes. Changes architecture
visualizations of flow in a hydrodynamic tunnel of Krylov Centre. topside have been taken with regard to the exhaust pipe and the top of
Flow visualization and smoke nuisance tests were conducted in the the superstructure.
vertical hydrodynamic tunnel on a 1:800 scale plexiglas model of
icebreakers above-water hull (Fig.6).
The tunnel has a 150 150 mm test section of 600mm length with
transparent walls. Hydrogen bubbles, air bubbles and dye injection
techniques were used for visualization. It was also noted (Guseev, 1999;
Biryuk, 1964, Seshadri, 2006) Dye injection method shows patterns of
smoke distribution and its concentration (qualitatively), the flow lines
traced by hydrogen bubbles indicate the flow structure and flow
patterns around ship structures.
The photo in Fig.7 illustrates flow visualization by hydrogen bubbles
generated in front of the model and smoke visualization by dye
injection method. Thus it is possible to observe the outer boundaries of
flow as well as internal flow separations, large-scale axial vortex
comprising a number of vortices, which arise in front of the
superstructure and partly covers the helipad area. Continuous
superstructure under the mast, in front of the stack, at mid-ship gives
rise to a flow separation zone where a re-entrant flow is formed, which Fig. 9 Visualization of smoke when = 35 = 150
is opposite to the external flow. The smoke fills up all space in the = 0 in the ADT
flow separation area and also reaches top bridge.
1412
The finding of the research in the wind tunnel with autonomous self-propelled vessel model made in 1:56 scale.
Photo model, prepared for the test is shown in Figure 10. Model tests of
As a result of carried out experimental studies by imaging smoke the original version of the vessel held at draft T = 8 m on the scale of
icebreaker and structure of air flows over the landing pad identified nature.
path of exhaust gases from the pipe movement. Thus, our experimental
studies have shown that there are a number of airflow directions in Evaluation handling characteristics in the first stage of works carried
which significant restrictions should be introduced for the use of a out with the use of control charts: Depending on the relative curvature
helicopter. of the trajectory of the circle from the rudder angle columns f () ,
and depending on the relative diameter of the circle on the rudder angle
In a range of angles of airflow leakage from the helicopter operation is
possible, but with a significant limitation of the wind speed. When the columns D f () .
wind from the stern of the pilot action must be "jewelry" because
helicopter tail rotor will be oriented toward the superstructure. In The parameters and D are determined by the following
addition, the downward flow of the site will require restrictions relationships:
permissible wind speed. L ,
; (1)
Carrying out model tests to determine the flow of settings and R
parameters of the field of velocities above the takeoff platform 2
helicopter provides a fairly reliable materials to the extent necessary for D (2)
drawing up practical guidelines for the implementation of takeoff and
landing operations at, to determine allowable with wind speed and where R - radius of the circle.
direction, and choose according to these parameters acceptable safety
conditions helicopters maneuvering areas, and provide the necessary The results of the initial model test vessel embodiment shown in Figure
input data workout benches. 11 and 12 show that the vessel has the following control characteristics:
maneuverability; the diameter of the circle when relaying the speaker is
Methods of study of the flow structure near the surface parts of the about 30 body length; sustainability- the relative curvature of the
hulls of ships models in wind tunnels and hydrodynamic FSUE "Krylov trajectory with no arrangements of columns 0 = 0.4, (the relative
State Research Center" allows to obtain high quality air flow diameter of the circle; the critical angle of rudder columns about 4 .
characteristics of the near surface part of the ship or ship to provide
guidance to developers at all stages of design. These data show that the ship has good turning ability, but at the same
time, according to the institute, poor performance of stability of
Maneuverability tests rectilinear motion. When the degree of instability which has been
revealed in the course of testing, management of the vessel would be
The objectives of the work in the agile-nautical basin were - difficult because of the need for relocation of the speakers at a high
experimental determination of the handling characteristics of the frequency and amplitude of at least 5 to maintain a straight course.
icebreaker in the clean water; development, if necessary, Institution based on experience, to ensure satisfactory maneuverability
recommendations for improving the handling characteristics of the characteristics value 0 vessel should not exceed 0,2 0.,25
vessel and experimental verification of these recommendations; ( D0 810).
estimated certain needs will go bow thruster, based on the necessity of
the work of the icebreaker in the fire. In this regard, it was decided to carry out work to improve the
characteristics of the vessel handling. The following options were
Tests were conducted in the laboratory of dynamics of a certified DAP considered:
German Accreditation Society to carry out in the courts handling An increase in the size of ice tooth.
investigations. Extension of the deadwood, located in DP icebreaker (while
maintaining the trailing edge of the slope).
Installation of gondolas columns spurs and combinations thereof.
Studies have shown that an increase in the size of ice tooth significantly
affect the stability characteristics of the vessel. Ensuring the
sustainability of satisfactory performance by increasing the area of
deadwood rectilinear movement of the vessel can be achieved by its
renewal not less than 4.5 m (increase of deadwood area about 24 m2).
Thus 0 decreases from 0.4 to 0.25.
1413
several options for modifying the original version of the ship. it
(In order to impact resistance):
Extension of the deadwood at 4.5 m;
Setting spurs to rotary speakers;
Installation of spurs on the rotary column with simultaneous
extension of the deadwood at 2.25 m.
In all cases the vessel will have a good turning diameter of the circle in
one body length will be provided when routing columns 35 - 40 .
Model tests for ship handling when reversing to clean water have
shown that having a good turning ability, the ship has a large degree of
instability of rectilinear motion. However, for reversing it can be made
acceptable.
These data show that with increased vessel stern tube will have the
following handling characteristics:
Turning.
The diameter of the circle when relaying columns 35 is
approximately 1 body length.
Stability - relative curvature of the trajectory at neperelozhennyh
D0 8
columns 0 = 0,25, (the relative diameter of the circle ).
Fig. 11 - Dependence of the relative diameter of the circle of the
Relaying critical angle columns about 2 .
original version of the angle of the ship rudder.
These characteristics make it possible to assess the vessel turning a
Experimental determination of the characteristics of the ship
fairly good, and the degree of instability of rectilinear motion of the
controllability with increased Deadwood. The search for additional
project as the maximum allowed.
means of improving the handling characteristics.
As part of sustainability were received maximum allowable parameters,
Based on the above recommendations, it was decided to increase the
continued work to find means to reduce the degree of instability of
deadwood vessel. Compared with the original version deadwood vessel
rectilinear movement of the vessel. We examined various options for
was extended by 5.7 m (at the OP level), and the trailing edge of it is
improving the stability of the rectilinear movement of the vessel related
vertical. In this area of deadwood compared with the original version
to the installation of spurs on the PC and additional stabilizers on the
increased by 21.5 m2.
ship's hull, and trim of the boat to the stern. The bulk of the tests
carried out with draft corresponding to 8 m full-scale ship, in addition,
The area received deadwood differs significantly from most areas of
several options were tested with the draft of 8.5 m.
the considered the first stage of stern tube (extended by 4.5 m, while
maintaining the trailing edge of the original inclination). On this basis,
Evaluating the effectiveness of each option was implemented by widely
to assess the characteristics of the vessel with increased manageability
used in international practice methodology, which provides testing
Deadwood used previously obtained for the corresponding options
model maneuver zig-zag. In preparation for testing was provided by a
diagram of control (see. Fig. 12).
zigzag maneuver simulation inertial characteristics of the vessel.
Schemes of zigzag maneuvers 10-10 and 20-20 are shown in
Figures 13 and 14. The criteria for the stability of the ship in
accordance with the IMO Resolution (2002) and the Rules of the
Maritime Register (2004) the values of angles shown in the diagram
first and second yaw zigzag 10-10 angle and first yaw zigzag 20-
20. At the same time more stable vessel is of less importance yaw
angles. In assessing the options considered to improve the stability of
the vessel shall be based vessel test results with increased Deadwood
(without spurs and other stabilizers) with draft 8 m without trim.
1414
of spurs on the PC, improves the stability of the rectilinear motion.
This option is on the basis of the complex analysis and has been
accepted for implementation.
20
The diameter of the circle with increased Deadwood vessel at an
angle of 35 rudder PC is about 1 body length, the degree of
10 instability can be estimated as the maximum allowed.
6. In addition to the listed in Sec. 2, was considered a way to
0
t,
improve the stability of the rectilinear movement of the vessel
by means of giving him a trim to the stern at an angle of not less
-10 than 1 , which showed its effectiveness. Giving the ship aft trim
is particularly useful in the case of motion with draft 8.5 m, where
-20
handling characteristics and maneuverability will be worse than
the draft of 8 m.
7. When adopting the original version of the power of nasal PU
-30
positioning vessel to extinguish the fire at any angle to the wind is
possible:
-40
- When working fire monitors "under the wind" - under the
simultaneous action of the wind and waves of 7 points 6 points,
Fig. 13. - The scheme of maneuver zigzag 20/20 at the first relaying - When working fire monitors "in the wind" - under the
steering (rudder) to the left side simultaneous action of the wind and waves 4 points 3 points.
Positioning the vessel in any direction of work in the conditions of
fire monitors wind 7 points and 6 points excitement specified in
the terms of reference, is possible only by increasing the emphasis
bow thruster is not less than 2 times.
40
Seakeeping tests
30
-10
-20
1415
16 knots for about 20%. Pitching icebreaker when navigating on the counter agitation in this work made the appearance of dynamic
counter irregular waves the power of the highest 7 points while moving (impact) of the vertical acceleration at the forward end of the model.
at a speed of 12 knots (wave height hs = 5,7 m); Figures 17 and 18 show picture icebreaker model on a rampage in the
It should be noted that the amplitude of pitching with increasing travel moment of greatest baring bottoms and a corresponding time slot of the
speed slightly reduced on all examined intensities excitement. vertical acceleration of the implementation. On the implementation of
the acceleration is clearly visible the moment of impact of the wave
Heave model body.
Vertical pitching icebreaker to counter concerns about the oncoming Slamming frequency increases with increasing intensity of agitation. 10
waves of small; its large amplitude does not exceed half of the knots, given that the permissible value slamming frequency is 30 - 40
corresponding wave amplitude. times / hour, will be accompanied by discomfort to the crew. Long
icebreaker movement on the opposite excitement magnitude 6 with
Acceleration in the area of the helipad Vs speed > 10 knots, given that the permissible value slamming
frequency is 30 - 40 times / hour (ITTC, 2012), will be accompanied by
Vertical acceleration in the helipad area in a seaway force 5 points with discomfort to the crew. Caused by frequent blows waves shake and
hs = 2,7 m increase of 0,20 g at 12 knots to speed of 0,24 g at Vs = 16 vibration vessel can lead to fatigue of the crew. When changing from
knots. The amplitudes of the vertical accelerations in bow in storm the oncoming ship rate of 30 - 40 frequency and intensity of slamming
should drop significantly.
conditions when the wave height hs = 5,7 m, can reach values of 0.5 g.
Green water
In accordance with the allowable value flooding frequency data Figure 17 - Moment baring bottoms bow.
available in evaluating the overall seaworthiness different authors vary
from 40 to 60 times per hour (Boroday I.K. Nezvetaev Y.A.,1982). Terms: Up excitement magnitude 7 points, travel speed 12 knots
Therefore, we can expect that by the condition of the ice-breaker wave
sweeping speed to counter agitation force 5 and 6 points is unlimited,
on a rampage of magnitude 7 points can limit up to about 13 - 14 knots.
Time, s
1416
the icebreaker. After conducting research on clean water have been when the fire-fighting operations, perform a study of the air flow
carried out research into the conditions of the ice, which showed high pattern.
icebreaker ice possibility and confirmed the correctness of the design
solutions. It should be noted that the first project built icebreakers 21900
"Moscow" and "St. Petersburg" successfully demonstrated in field tests
At the moment, the project 21900M built icebreaker "Vladivostok", and subsequent operation of the compliance indicators ice propulsion
"Novorossiysk" and "Murmansk" (see. Figure 19), which are a and maneuverability specification requirements. In upgrade projects
continuation of the line icebreakers designed for use in non-Arctic seas 21900M icebreakers were built three icebreaker "Vladivostok",
of Russia. First icebreakers Project 21900 "Moscow" and "Novorossiysk" and "Murmansk" project, intended for use in non-
"St. Petersburg" successfully demonstrated during field tests and Arctic seas of Russia.
subsequent operation of the compliance indicators ice propulsion and
maneuverability specification requirements. As a result of in-depth analysis of experience of construction, testing
and operation of icebreakers, Project 21900, as well as taking into
According to tests while going ahead icebreaker capable of speeds of account the increased demands of the customer, the icebreaker, Project
10 - 11 knots in smooth snowless ice cover thickness of 0.8 m and a 21900M has undergone significant changes compared to the basic
flexural strength of 500 kPa, and the radius of circulation under such design of the "Moscow" type design.
conditions is not more than twice the length of the body. On astern an
icebreaker is able to successfully overcome the level ice thickness of The main differences between the icebreakers of Project 21900M are as
1.3 m on a stable travel speed in 2 knots. Good handling icebreaker is follows:
provided by two-circle rudder propellers production of the Finnish Increased icebreaking capability at the ahead and astern run due
company "Steerprop" capacity of 8 MW each. to increasing of propulsion system power by 1.4 W to
17.4 W, s well as increased hull ice strengthening category.
Special personnel group - to 22 persons.
Increased capacity of cargo deck containers, more than 70%.
Increased sizes and weight of the helicopters taken onboard.
More than twice increased cargo capacity for ship cargo gears.
Air protection intended to reduce the sulfur oxides content in the
exhaust gases.
REFERENCES
Figure 19 - Icebreaker etc. 21900M. Biryuk V.S. (1964). "Fighting smoke pollution ships", Ed.
"Shipbuilding", Leningrad.
Major changes in the modernized icebreaker of project 21900M Boroday I.K. Nezvetaev Y.A.(1982). Seakeeping of the ships,
touched an increase of a few meters length of the hull, propulsion Leningrad sudostroenie, pp 5-21, 179 -185.
system capacity by 1.4 MW, as well as a helipad transfer to the nasal Guseev A.S., Korotkin A.I. (1999). "Wrap single roughness elements in
tip. Indicators ice icebreaker propulsion will be determined during field the boundary layer." Proceedings of the III International Conference
tests, during which will be measured by the speed of movement, speed on marine intellectual technologies "Morintech-99", St. Petersburg.
of propulsion and / or propeller shafts, power power plant consumed Seshadri V., Singh S.N., Kulkarni Cdr P.R. (2006). Study of problem of
while driving, and surmounted by thick ice. Then, based on the exhaust smoke ingress into GT intakes of a naval ship. Journal of
conversion of the experimental data, a technique which own experts Ship Technology, v.2, 1, 22-35.
FSUE "Krylov State Research Center" will provide information on ice IMO Resolution 137 "Standards of maneuverability of ships" (2002), 76.
thickness, which is able to overcome the ice-breaker at full power ITTC (2012). The final and recommendations to the 27th ITTC.
consumption while maintaining a constant speed. In the study of Proceeding of 27rd International Towing Tank Conference (ITTC).
maneuverability of the icebreaker will be measured the same Manual of the International Civil Aviation Organization ICAO, (1995).
characteristics as in the study of ice propulsion to which additional Russian Maritime Register of Shipping (RS) "Guidelines for the
information will be registered in the corners rudder controls and the determination of maneuvering characteristics of ships", (2004).
trajectory of movement of the icebreaker in the performance of the The flight manual for the Mi-8 flight activity Oversight appropriate
circulation. All the data are adjusted to eliminate the discrepancy reference copy RLE, State Research Institute of Civil Aviation
between the desired and measured characteristics of the ice cover. (verification date July 11, 2005.).
CONCLUSIONS
1417