You are on page 1of 49

2

Lean
Manufacturing

1 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 1 of 49
2

Contents
Lean tools Box
3 Ms in waste
Defining waste
organizations Value steam
Seven waste
Lean and seven wastes

2 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 2 of 49
2

LEAN TOOL BOX

3 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 3 of 49
2

Lean Tools
PDSA
Wastes Elimination
OEE
Takt time
5S visual Workshop
Visual Management
Kaizen
Problem solving
Poka yoke
JIT 4 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 4 of 49
2

3 Ms in waste

MUDA (Waste)
MURI (Strain / Over burden)
MURA (Unevenness)
5 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 5 of 49
2

Eliminating MURA
Happens sometimes?
Happens some places
Happens to some people

MURA is
Inconsistent or
Irregular or
Uneven use of person or M/c.

6 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 6 of 49
2

MURA
Unfair demands on our processes
and people and cause the creation
of inventory and other wastes.

Mura is the variation in the operation of a process not


caused by the end customer.
It is the unevenness, unbalanced work on machines.
Mura results when employees are told to work like crazy
early in the morning only to stand around and do nothing
late in the day.

Result: Excess capacity allocation and increased cost.

7 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 7 of 49
2

MURI- Over Burden


Muri is the overburden on equipment, facilities
& people caused by mura and muda.

Muri is pushing a machine or person


beyond natural limits.

Overburdening people results in safety and


quality problems.

Overburdening equipment causes


breakdowns and defects

8 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 8 of 49
2

MURI- Over Burden


Muri is to cause overburden,
mean to give unnecessary
stress to our employees and
our processes. MURI is
caused by Mura Which
causes the other failures. i.e.
Lack of training,
unclear or no defined ways of
working,
the wrong tools, and ill
thought out measures of
performance.

9 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 9 of 49
2

Identifying MURI
MURI = Physical Strain, Overbourden
Bend to work?
Push hard?
Lift weight?
Repeat tiring action?
Wasteful walk?
Placing of excessive demands on
People
M/Cs, Production equipment.

Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 10 of 49
2

What is MUDA or Waste

Waste is anything that


happens to a product that
does not add value from
the customers perspective
Products being stored,
inspected or delayed,
products waiting in
queues, and defective
products do not add value

11 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 11 of 49
2

Why waste is not identified?

Waste is often built into job


12 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 12 of 49
2

The Solution

But first we have to know about the real problem


13 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 13 of 49
2

The Parts Cleaning Process


Dirty parts Clean parts

Clean Clean
Water Water
Cleaning Cleaning
Tank 1 Tank 2

Discard water
The parts get clean, so no one questions this. What is wrong
with this picture?
14 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 14 of 49
2

The Lean Parts Cleaning Process


Why Not Make the Water Work Twice?
Dirty parts Clean parts

Clean
Water
Cleaning Cleaning
Tank 1 Tank 2

Discard water
The almost clean water from the second tank is good enough
for use in the first tank. Water usage can be cut 50 percent.
15 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 15 of 49
2

Exercise-2

Click to see a movie Clip-2

Questions:
1. Identify the waste in the process?
2. How the waste was eliminated?

Please Use the paper provided to write the


answer.
16 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 16 of 49
2

Lessons so far
Waste often hides in plain view.
People become used to "living with it"
or "working around it."
Definition for employees at all levels:
If it's frustrating, a chronic
annoyance, or a chronic
inefficiency, it's friction.
(Levinson and Tumbelty, 1997, SPC Essentials and
Productivity Improvement, ASQ Quality Press)

17 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 17 of 49
2

Organizations value stream

It is a network of different Business Processes.

Input
Process-1 V Process-2 V Process-3 V Process-4 V Product

W W W W

V: Value added product/services


W: Wasteful product / practices/services that does not add value

18 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 18 of 49
2

Non Value added activity is waste


Value Added time:
What the customer is willing to pay for
Non Value added work
Unnecessary motion
Material handling
Waiting time
37%
89%
Rework/ scrape 50%
Unnecessary part
processing 13%
Excess inventory 13%
Over Production`

Tea Breaks, Lunches,


Training
Education,
19 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 19 of 49
2
Customer value
Customer

Customer Customer
Selling Price
Requirements Schedule

Quality Cost Delivery

Process
Production Cost Process Speed
Capability

Supplier

20 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 20 of 49
2
Customer value
Customer

Customer Customer
Selling Price
Requirements Schedule

Quality Cost Delivery


Defects Resource Waste Delays
Process
Production Cost Process Speed
Capability

Supplier

21 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 21 of 49
2
Increasing profit by increasing price

22 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 22 of 49
2
Increasing profit by reducing cost

23 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 23 of 49
2
Changing the performance level

Ideal State
Performance level

Future State

Current State

Time frame

24 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 24 of 49
2
7- WASTES

1. Defects
2. Overproduction
3. Waiting
4. Transportation
5. Inventory
6. Motion
7. Extra processing

25 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 25 of 49
2
Waste-1 Defects
The effort involved in
inspecting for and fixing
defects (errors and
mistakes).

26 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 26 of 49
2
Waste-1 Defects

PAINT SHOP T/M MAKING REPAIR IN


SPOT REPAIR BOOTH.

27 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 27 of 49
2
Waste-1 Defects
Why Repair/Replacement in Warranty period
be a MUDA?

Prevention: Correction: Failure

= 1:10:100
1

Prevention is always 10
cheaper.
100
28 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 28 of 49
2
Waste-2 Over Production
Generating more information than the
customer needs right now:

More information than the customer


needs
Creating reports no one reads
Making extra copies
More information than the next process
needs
29 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 29 of 49
2
Waste-2 Over Production

OPERATOR SHOULD BE IN THIS


STATION (ST 16) BUT IS
WORKING AHEAD IN ST 15

30 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 30 of 49
2
Waste-3 Waiting
When people, parts, systems, or
facilities wait for a prior step in
the process to be completed.
Goal is smooth and continuous
flow between each process step
Waiting for:
Faxes
The system to come back
Copier machine
Customer response
A handed off file to come back
31 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 31 of 49
2
Waste- 4 Transportation
Transportation of
products, equipment,
materials or people
without adding value.

Carrying documents to and fro


Taking files to another person
Going to get signatures

32 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 32 of 49
2
Waste-5 Inventory
Unnecessary storage
of materials.
Files waiting to be worked on
Open projects
Office supplies
E-mails waiting to be read
Unused records in the
database

33 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 33 of 49
2
Waste-5 Inventory

34 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 34 of 49
2
Waste-5 Inventory

STANDARD SET AT 4 HIGH X 3 DEEP PART BIN


STACKED 6 HIGH

35 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 35 of 49
2
Waste-6 MUDA OF Motion

Movement of people that


does not add value to a
product or service and
may create health and
safety issues.

Searching for files


Extra clicks or key strokes
Unnecessary movement for gathering information
36 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 36 of 49
2
Waste-6 MUDA OF Motion

TEAM MEMBER IN PAINT SHOP ATTEMPTING TO


UNTANGLE HOSES TO THE BACK-UP GUNS IN THE
TOP COAT BOOTH.

37 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 37 of 49
2
Waste-7 Over Processing

Producing a higher
quality product or
service than what is
required by the
customer, and using
elaborate or expensive
equipment when more
simple options exist.

38 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 38 of 49
2
Waste-7 Over Processing

BODY SHOP T/M SANDING


DOOR THAT HAD NO DEFECTS

39 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 39 of 49
2
Another Waste: Non Utilized Talent

Staff hired to do X and


spending time on Y
Dont let your employees
skills go to waste!
Remove process barriers
so that staff can do the
work they were hired for
and want to do!
40 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 40 of 49
2
Lean and seven waste
1. Clarify the problem
5. Formalise new process
What is the problem for the
Confirm new process,
customer time, cost,
measure and monitor,
quality?
and create new process
map, SOPs etc

2. Map the Process


Steps 5. Reduce Value Enabling
Study the
process where Once waste is
the problem eliminated, look to
occurs reduce the value
enabling content where
possible

4. Eliminate waste

Plan and execute actions


3. Analyse the process steps to eliminate the waste
steps
Decide what is value
adding, value enabling
and waste in the process

41 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 41 of 49
2

Lean and Seven Waste The Philosophy


Central theme of Lean:
The identification and elimination of
waste for the value stream.

Successful implementation requires:


Trained work force to identify and
eliminate waste from their work.

Effective efforts:
Collective integration of man, method,
material, and machine.

42 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 42 of 49
2

Click to see a movie Clip:


Seven types of waste Introduction
Seven types of wastes

43 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 43 of 49
2

44 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 44 of 49
2

The entire work looks normal and no waste


can be found.

45 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 45 of 49
2
Conduct a Motion Study
Break down the work and show it by components of
motions. Then find a waste of motion.

46 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 46 of 49
2

Lessons so far

Waste often hides in plain view.


People become used to "living with it" or "working
around it."
Definition for employees at all levels: If it's
frustrating, a chronic annoyance, or a chronic
inefficiency, it's friction. (Levinson and Tumbelty,
1997, SPC Essentials and Productivity Improvement,
ASQ Quality Press)

47 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 47 of 49
2

Group Exercise-3
Form a team. (submit the names)
Review your process and process flow
Identify the maximum types of waste (Muda)
in your work area.
Investigate the cause (s) of the Muda your
identified.
Propose the corrective action (s) to eliminate
the Muda.

48 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 48 of 49
2

Thank you

49 of 42
Lean Training Course DC (A 2008), Issue Jan-2014 - Copy Right Reserved @ Training Division -Deans Consulting Inc, Houston, Texas USA . 49 of 49

You might also like