You are on page 1of 10

IEEE JOURNAL OF EMERGING AND SELECTED TOPICS IN POWER ELECTRONICS, VOL. 5, NO.

2, JUNE 2017 651

An Adjustable DC Link Voltage-Based Control of


Multifunctional Grid Interfaced Solar PV System
Chinmay Jain, Member, IEEE, and Bhim Singh, Fellow, IEEE

Abstract This paper presents a grid supported solar energy three-port converters for PV application, PV-based battery
conversion system with an adjustable dc link voltage for common charging station, and battery energy management are
point of interconnection (CP) voltage variations. A two-stage shown in [3][6]. The batteries are integral part of standalone
circuit topology is proposed, wherein the first stage is a boost
converter, which serves for maximum power point tracking, and PV-based system. However, they require frequent maintenance
the second stage is a grid tied voltage source converter (VSC), and timely replacement. Therefore, battery-less grid interfaced
which not only feeds extracted solar photovoltaic (PV) PV generation systems are more preferred where the grid is
energy into the three-phase distribution system but also available.
serves for harmonics mitigation, reactive power compensation, The initial investment to setup a PV plant is high because
and grid current balancing. An interweaved double-frequency
second-order generalized integrator-based control algorithm is of high cost of PV panels. Hence, the aim is to extract
proposed for control of this multifunctional VSC, which possesses maximum power from available capacity once a PV plant is
the feature of good steady-state performance along with fast installed. Several maximum power point techniques (MPPTs)
dynamic response even under sudden load changes at CPI. are proposed in [7][9]. The classification and basic concept
Moreover, a feed-forward term for the solar PV contribution is of MPPT algorithms used in PV applications are shown in [7].
used to enhance the dynamic response for climatic changes and
CPI voltage variation. An adjustable dc link voltage structure A power plane analysis of V I characteristics is shown in [8].
is used to accommodate CPI voltage variation, which helps in The incremental conductance (InC)-based algorithm is simple
reduction of losses in the power circuit. To implement adjustable and easy to implement. A variable step InC MPPT technique is
dc link voltage structure, the reference dc link voltage is adjusted shown in [9]. In this paper, a combination of InC and fractional
with variation in CPI voltage in real time. A proportional open circuit voltage (Voc ) MPPT algorithm is used, which is
integral controller is used to regulate dc link voltage to set
reference value. A wide range of experimental results are shown named composite InC algorithm.
to demonstrate the features of the proposed system. The total The power electronic converters-based nonlinear loads
harmonic distortion of grid current has been found well under are increasing in the distribution system. The nonsinusoidal
IEEE-519 standard even under nonlinear loads at CPI. current by these loads causes problems such as voltage distor-
Index Terms Adjustable dc link, double-frequency tion, increased distribution loss, and derating of distribution
second-order generalized integrator (DFSOGI), overvoltage, equipment. In order to solve these power quality problems,
power quality, solar photovoltaic (PV), undervoltage.
several retrofit solutions are proposed by researchers such as
I. I NTRODUCTION passive filter, active filters, and distribution static compen-
sator (DSTATCOM) [10][17].
T HE rapidly vanishing conventional energy sources
(fossil fuels) have put an alarming energy crisis
situation in front of the world. Moreover, the deteriorating
The synchronous reference frame (SRF)-based control
algorithm for active power filters has been proposed
environmental conditions have moved worlds attention toward in [12][14]. The SRF-based control algorithm provides an
nonconventional green energy sources. The solar energy has advantage that all three-phase load currents are processed
provided a new cost feasible alternative. The grid parity for simultaneously. The dc component of direct axis current
solar energy conversion systems has been shown in [1] and [2]. corresponds to uniformly distributed average power consuming
Solar photovoltaic (PV) energy generation systems can be component of load current. Therefore, only one low-pass
broadly classified into two main categories that are standalone filter is required to estimate dc component of direct axis
and grid interfaced. Several standalone systems for current. However, in the case of unbalanced operation, the
PV power generation systems considering rural electrification, second harmonic is the dominant component in the direct axis
current. In order to achieve good steady-state response under
Manuscript received February 7, 2016; revised April 25, 2016 and unbalanced operation, the cutoff frequency for low-pass filter
June 13, 2016; accepted July 7, 2016. Date of publication November 10,
2016; date of current version May 1, 2017. This work was supported by is to be set very low. However, the low cutoff frequency causes
the Department of Science and Technology, Government of India, under poor dynamic response. Therefore, there is a tradeoff between
Grant RP02583. Recommended for publication by Associate Editor steady-state and dynamic performances in SRF-based control
Xiongfei Wang.
The authors with the Department of Electrical Engineering, Indian approach.
Institute of Technology Delhi, New Delhi 110016, India (e-mail: Various advanced control approaches for DSTATCOM
chinmay31jain@gmail.com; bsingh@ee.iitd.ac.in). have been proposed to solve this tradeoff under unbalanced
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available
online at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org. operation [15][17]. A learning-based anti-Hebbian-based
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/JESTPE.2016.2627533 control approach is shown in [15]. A neural network-based
2168-6777 2016 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
652 IEEE JOURNAL OF EMERGING AND SELECTED TOPICS IN POWER ELECTRONICS, VOL. 5, NO. 2, JUNE 2017

conductance estimation-based control approach is shown not only helps in reduction of switching losses in all the power
in [16]. A back propagation-based control approach is shown devices (the VSC and the boost converter) but also in reduction
in [17]. In all these control approaches, the load current is of high-frequency ohmic losses in the interfacing converter.
processed through an advanced filtering scheme for estimation The reduction in losses is achieved not only at undervoltage
of average power consuming component of load current. but also at nominal CPI voltage.
Since all three-phase load currents are processed separately The concept of loss reduction by adjusting dc link voltage
in the VSC control approach, three such filters are required for VSC in hybrid filters is shown in [22] and [23], wherein
(one for each phase). However, in this paper, an inter- reactive power requirement of the filter is satisfied by adjusting
weaved double-frequency second-order generalized integrator the dc link voltage. A three-phase PV inverter with adjustable
(DFSOGI)-based control approach is proposed, which solves dc link voltage is shown in [24]. A single-phase solar-based
the tradeoff between steady-state and dynamic performances, system with adjustable dc link voltage is demonstrated in [25].
while processing all three load currents together. However, all these systems are different from point of view
The shunt grid tied voltage source converters (VSCs) are of circuit topology. Therefore, there is a wide difference in
used in many applications. For proper control of output work presented in [22][25] and the proposed work. The main
currents of the VSC, the dc link voltage of the VSC is contributions of this paper can be listed as follows.
kept constant (higher than peak of maximum allowable line 1) The use of interweaved DFSOGI with dq reference-
voltage) [10][17]. Most of these researchers have shown based control approach to overcome the drawbacks of
operation of the grid tied system for constant common point SRF, which enables fast dynamic response along with
of interconnection (CPI) voltage. However, in the case of better steady-state accuracy.
weak distribution system, a wide voltage variation is observed. 2) Formulation of an approximate linear model of dc link
During peak loading condition, a sustained voltage dip or voltage control structure considering the effect of
undervoltage is observed commonly, and in nighttime when feed-forward terms for load contribution and PV array
the loading of the distribution system is low, the overvoltages contribution and an assessment of dc bus control struc-
are observed. The practical range of voltage variation is ture demonstrating the need and requirements for the
about 15% of nominal voltage. In this paper, the operation feed-forward compensation.
of the complete system is shown for practical range of 3) An implementation of an adaptive dc link voltage-based
voltage variation and the control approach is appropriately control structure for multitasking solar energy conver-
modified for improved performance under this range of voltage sion system, which helps in reduction of switching losses
variation. and high-frequency ohmic losses (verified experimen-
The use of two-stage generation system for solar PV sys- tally). Moreover, it also reduces high-frequency ripple
tems has been proposed by several researchers [18][20]. content in grid currents.
Conventionally, a dcdc converter is used as the first stage, Moreover, it should be noted that the stress on the power
which serves the purpose of MPPT. The second stage is a grid circuit (power semiconductor devices, dc link capacitor, etc.)
tied VSC, which feeds the power into the distribution system. remains the same in both proposed and conventional systems,
A single-phase two-stage grid tied PV generation system considering the fact that these ratings are decided assuming
with constant dc link voltage is shown in [18]. Moreover, worst case scenario, which is the same in both the cases.
the three-phase grid tied PV generation system with constant Hence, while using the same hardware resources, an increased
dc link voltage control is also shown in [19] and [20]. The energy output is observed with the system using the proposed
dc link voltage of VSC is kept constant (higher than peak dc link voltage control approach.
of maximum allowable line voltage) using a proportional
integral (PI) controller [19], [20]. II. S YSTEM C ONFIGURATION
In this paper, a two-stage multifunctional solar energy The system configuration for the proposed two-stage circuit
conversion system is proposed, which not only feeds the solar topology is shown in Fig. 1. The proposed system consists
energy into the distribution system but also serves the purpose of a solar PV array, a boost converter, a three-phase VSC,
of harmonics mitigation, reactive power compensation, and interfacing inductors, a ripple filter, a three-phase distribution
grid current balancing at the same time. The utilization factor system, and some local loads. The three-phase distribution
of the grid tied VSC is better as it also serves for power quality system, local loads, and VSC are connected at one CPI. The
improvement in nighttime. An interweaved DFSOGI-based PV array is connected at the input of the boost converter. The
control algorithm is proposed to serve all the aforementioned output of the boost converter is connected to the dc link of
purposes. The interweaved DFSOGI algorithm is a combi- the VSC. The boost converter serves the purpose of extraction
nation of SRF [12][14] and second-order generalized filter- of maximum power from the PV array and it feeds the
based algorithm [21]. A wide variety of results are shown to extracted energy to the dc link of the VSC. The three-phase
demonstrate the performance of interweaved DFSOGI-based VSC is tied to the distribution system via interfacing inductors.
control algorithm. A small ripple filter is also connected at CPI to absorb the
Moreover, unlike previous work with constant dc link switching ripples. The VSC in the proposed system not only
voltage, an adjustable dc link voltage-based control approach feeds the extracted solar energy into the grid but also presents
is proposed here. The dc link voltage of VSC is adjusted with a point on load solution for various power quality problems
respect to CPI voltage variation. The adjustable dc link voltage introduced by local loads.
JAIN AND SINGH: ADJUSTABLE DC LINK VOLTAGE-BASED CONTROL 653

Fig. 1. System configuration.

Fig. 2. Block diagram for control approach.

III. C ONTROL A PPROACH fractional V oc MPPT, which is 0.70.9 Vocmax , where V oc


Fig. 2 shows the detailed block diagram of the proposed is the open circuit voltage and Vocmax is the maximum open
control approach. There are two main power circuits in the circuit voltage. The voltage for peak power is always searched
proposed circuit topology. The duty ratio for the boost con- in this range for fast search of Vmpp . The InC algorithm works
verter is decided on the basis of MPPT control algorithm. The in order to minimize the difference between the InC and the
input voltage of the boost converter is continuously adjusted conductance offered by the PV array. At first, the reference
such that the PV array operates at MPP. The output of the boost PV array voltage is estimated based on the InC principle, and
converter is connected to the dc link of the VSC. The dc link then that reference voltage is used to estimate the duty ratio of
voltage of the VSC is adjusted in real time considering the the boost converter. For calculation of InC, IPV and VPV
CPI voltage. Therefore, with the proposed control approach, are estimated as
both input and output voltages of the boost converter are
adjusted in real time. Moreover, the VSC is controlled such IPV = IPV (k) IPV (k 1) (1a)
that the grid deals with only real power exchanges even VPV = VPV (k) VPV (k 1) (1b)
when local load demands reactive power or harmonics. The
proposed control algorithm also presents a solution for where IPV (k) and VPV (k) are the instantaneous sampled
balancing grid currents. Hence, the currents injected by the current and voltage of the solar array.
VSC are controlled such that the grid currents are always The governing equations for InC-based MPPT algorithm are
balanced sinusoids at unity power factor. The detailed expla- IPV IPV
nation for control algorithm of the two main power circuits is = , at MPP (2a)
VPV VPV
given in the following.
IPV IPV
A. Maximum Power Point Tracking > , Left of MPP on PPV v/s VPV curve (2b)
VPV VPV
A composite InC-based MPPT algorithm is used. A range IPV IPV
of voltage for peak power is known with the knowledge from < , Right of MPP on PPV v/s VPV curve. (2c)
VPV VPV
654 IEEE JOURNAL OF EMERGING AND SELECTED TOPICS IN POWER ELECTRONICS, VOL. 5, NO. 2, JUNE 2017

The reference PV voltage and sensed dc link voltage are three-wire balanced nonlinear load, the fifth and seventh
then used to estimate the duty ratio for the boost converter. harmonics are the lowest order harmonics in the load currents.
The governing equation for estimating duty ratio is The lowest order ripple frequency is sixth as the fifth harmonic
VPVref (k) is positive sequence and the seventh harmonic is negative
Dref (k) = 1 . (3) sequence. A low-pass filter tuned to line frequency can be
Vdc (k)
used to suppress this ripple.
This reference duty ratio is used to generate switching logic In the case of unbalanced load currents, the second
for boost converter. harmonic component is the dominant part of i d . In order
to suppress the dominant second harmonic component,
B. Control Approach for Three-Phase VSC conventionally a low-pass filter with a low cutoff frequency
The three-phase VSC is controlled to achieve the objective is used. However, the dynamic response for estimation of
of reactive power compensation, harmonics mitigation, grid ILg is adversely affected by reduction of cutoff frequency.
current balancing, and regulation of dc link voltage to desired Hence, there is a compromise between the steady-state and
adjustable reference value. A total of nine quantities are sensed the dynamic performances of conventional SRFT in the case
to control the SECS, which are line voltages (vsab and vsbc ), of unbalanced loads at CPI.
dc link voltage (vdc ) and grid currents (i ga and i gb ), load The proposed interweaved DFSOGI-based control
currents (i La and i Lb ), PV array voltage (vPV ), and PV array algorithm provides a solution to tradeoff between steady-state
current (i PV ). The phase voltages are estimated from the and dynamic performances. DFSOGI-based control algorithm
sensed line voltages, and then the synchronization signals is interwoven with direct axis current control-based algorithm
are estimated from the phase voltages. To estimate the such that the double-frequency component of i d is quashed
synchronization signals at first amplitude of phase voltages separately. The estimation of double-frequency component
is estimated. The amplitude of phase voltages is estimated as with DFSOGI is given as
   I2 f d (s) 2 0 s
2 + v2 + v2
2 vsa = 2 (6)
Vz = sb sc
. (4) Id (s) s + 2 0 s + 02
3
where o is the nominal line frequency and is the conver-
This amplitude is used to determine the synchronization gence factor. The second harmonic component present in the
signals of CPI voltage that contains the phasor informa- i d is subtracted in real time. The resultant value is designated
tion of all phase voltages. The synchronization signals are as i dh , which is then passed though a low-pass filter to suppress
estimated as ripple component corresponding to harmonics in load current.
vsa vsb vsc
za = , zb = , zc = . (5) However, the cutoff frequency for low-pass filter can be
Vz Vz Vz kept comparatively higher, as the dominant second harmonic
The control objective of the VSC is to maintain the grid component is already quashed by interweaved DFSOGI
currents balanced sinusoids at unity power factor. To achieve algorithm.
the aforementioned objective, the peak of grid currents is Fig. 3 shows the comparison of the proposed interweaved
estimated, which is common for all three phases. The grid DFSOGI-based algorithm with conventional SRF algorithm.
current consists of three main parts, which are average power Fig. 3(a) shows simulated steady-state and dynamic perfor-
consuming component of load current, PV array contribu- mances. In Fig. 3(a), it can be observed that before time
tion, and losses of the SECS. The average power consuming t = 0.15 s, the loads are balanced and nonlinear, and hence
component of load current is estimated using interweaved i d contains only high-frequency ripples corresponding to load
DFSOGI-based control algorithm. At first, the direct axis current harmonics. However, at t = 0.15 s, when one of
component (i d ) of three-phase load currents is estimated. The the load lines is opened, the load currents are unbalanced.
average value of direct axis component (ILg ) represents the The i d for unbalanced load contains large second harmonic
average power consuming component of load current distrib- component along with average dc value. The DFSOGI
uted uniformly in all three phases. In order to estimate the is used to detect and quash double harmonic component
ILg conventionally, i d is passed through a low-pass filter as separately. The ILg represents the uniformly distributed aver-
shown in Fig. 2. age power consuming component of load current. It can be
The cutoff frequency of low-pass filter depends on several easily observed that the ILg estimated by DFSOGI-based
aspects related to nature of the load. In case that the load algorithm is quite smooth compared with that of the conven-
currents are balanced sinusoidal, the i d is a dc value that tional SRF algorithm. The effects of oscillations in the ILg
can be directly used without used as ILg and without using a on the corresponding component of reference grid currents
low-pass filter. However, in case that the load currents are are also demonstrated in Fig. 3. The zoomed-in version of
balanced and nonsinusoidal (representing balanced nonlinear reference grid currents shows that under unbalanced condition,
load), the i d consists of a dc with superimposed ripple com- the reference grid currents are unbalanced and distorted due
ponent corresponding to load current harmonics, and then in to the presence of oscillations in ILg in the conventional
order to estimate ILg, the i d is passed though a low-pass method. The cutoff frequency of LPFh is kept the same (o )
filter. The cutoff frequency of the low-pass filter is decided so that the steady-state performance can be compared on
by the lowest order ripple frequency in i d . In the case of the common ground. Fig. 3(b) shows experimentally captured
JAIN AND SINGH: ADJUSTABLE DC LINK VOLTAGE-BASED CONTROL 655

Fig. 4. Steady-state recorded performance for MPPT at (a) 1000 and


(b) 500 W/m2 .

is kept fixed at set reference value, the proposed algorithm


adjusts reference dc link voltage according to sensed CPI volt-
age. The performance improvement by keeping the adjustable
reference for dc link voltage has been verified experimentally
and is discussed in Section V. The reference dc link voltage
is estimated as

VDCref = 3V Z , where > 1. (8)

For proper current control, the dc link voltage must be


higher than the amplitude of CPI line voltage. Therefore,
reference dc link voltage is kept around 10% higher than the
peak of CPI line voltage, considering the drop across switches,
interfacing inductor, resistance of interfacing inductor, and
proper current control under dc link voltage dynamics. Hence,
the selected value of in the proposed work is 1.1.
The sensed dc link voltage is passed through a low-pass
filter to suppress the switching noise. The output of the
low-pass filter is designated as Vdc . A PI controller is used
to regulate the dc link voltage to the desired reference value.
The governing equation for PI controller is

Iloss (k) = Iloss (k 1) + K p {ve (k) ve (k 1)} + K i ve (k).


Fig. 3. Salient internal signals for conventional (SRF) and proposed (9)
(DFSOGI-based) algorithms in the same time frame. (a) Simulated
performance. (b) Experimental performance.
The grid currents are assumed coming out from equivalent
voltage source, and hence considering the direction of grid
internal signals. The experimental results are consistent with currents, the load power and the losses are drawn from
the simulation results. the grid, whereas the PV contribution is fed into the grid.
The PV array voltage and current sensed for MPPT purpose Therefore, the net amplitude of grid current is estimated as
are also used to estimate a feed-forward term for PV array con-
tribution in reference grid current. The PV array contribution Irg = ILg + Iloss IPVg . (10)
term is designated as PV feed-forward (PVFF) term in the
control algorithm in Fig. 2. The PVFF term is estimated as The reference grid currents are estimated using synchronizing
(2VPV IPV ) unit vectors and the estimated peak of reference grid currents.
IPVg = . (7) The mathematical expression for estimation of the reference
(3Vz )
grid currents is
The PVFF term can be considered as amplitude of grid
current for a lossless ideal system without any load at CPI. i garef = Irg z a , i gbref = Irg z b , i gcref = Irg z c . (11)
The PVFF term is so decided that it provides fast dynamic
response not only for PV power changes but also for CPI An indirect current control is used in the proposed control
voltage variations. approach, wherein the estimated reference grid currents are
For proper control of output current of the VSC, the dc link compared with sensed grid currents, and based on the polarity
voltage should be more than the peak of line voltage of CPI. of error in each sampling time, the switching logic for VSC
Unlike the conventional algorithm, where the dc link voltage is decided.
656 IEEE JOURNAL OF EMERGING AND SELECTED TOPICS IN POWER ELECTRONICS, VOL. 5, NO. 2, JUNE 2017

Fig. 5. Steady-state performance under balanced linear loads. (a)(c) vsab


with iga , iLa , and iVSCa , respectively. (d) Power drawn from grid (Pg ).
(e) Power drawn by load (PL ). (f) Power supplied by VSC PVSC .

IV. R ESULTS AND D ISCUSSION


The test results are shown in Figs. 412. A total of nine
quantities are sensed, which are vpv , i pv , vdc , vsab , vsbc , i ga ,
i gb , i La , and i Lb . The Hall effect voltage (LV-25) and current
sensors (LA-55p) are used to sense voltages and currents. The
sensed signals are conditioned and given to analog-to-digital
converter of processor (DSP-dSPACE-1103). The outputs from
processor are the switching logics for all controlled switches.
These results are captured using power analyzer (Fluke 43B)
and a four-channel digital storage oscilloscope (DSO6010A).
The test results are categorized in three sections that are
steady-state results, dynamics, and performance improve-
ment with adjustable dc link control approach. The salient
system parameters for implementation purpose are given in the
following.
Parameters of the system: three-phase grid voltage 415 V,
frequency = 50 Hz, interfacing inductor = 5 mH/phase; Fig. 6. Steady-state performance under unbalanced nonlinear loads.
(a)(c) vsab with iga , igb , and igc . (d)(f) vsab with iLa , iLb , and iLc .
three-phase loads: linear balanced 1.41 kW, 0.8 lag, nonlinear (g)(i) vsab with iVSCa , iVSCb , and iVSCc . (j)(l) Harmonics spectrum of
load balanced three-phase 1.31 kW, ripple filter R = 5 , various currents iga , iLa , and iVSCa . (m) Power drawn from grid (Pg ).
C = 5 F, K p = 0.4, and K i = 0.1; DFSOGI parameters: (n) Power drawn by load (PL ).
0 = 314, = 0.2, cutoff frequency for LPFh of DFSOGI
a pf of 0.8 lag. It can be observed that sign for power absorbed
and SRF = 50 Hz, and cutoff frequency of dc link LPF =
from the grid is negative and the displacement power factor
500 Hz; PV array maximum open circuit voltage: 500 V; PV
is 1, which shows that power is being supplied to the grid
array maximum short-circuit current: 16 A; and PV array peak
at unity power factor. Fig. 5(f) shows the power supplied by
power: approximately 6 kW.
the VSC. The power supplied by the VSC is divided between
load and grid.
A. Steady-State Performance Fig. 6 shows the performance of the SECS under unbal-
The steady-state performance for MPPT is shown in anced nonlinear load at CPI. Fig. 6(a)(c), (d)(f), and (g)(i)
Fig. 4, which is recorded from PV array simulator. The MPP shows vsab with three-phase grid, load, and VSC currents,
efficiency is around 99.7% for both the insolation levels respectively. It can be observed that load currents for phase
(1000 and 500 W/m2 ). a and b are nonsinusoidal and for that of phase c is
The steady-state performance for reactive power com- zero, which shows that the load is nonlinear and unbalanced.
pensation for balanced linear load is shown in Fig. 5. However, the grid currents [as shown in Fig. 6(a)(c)] are
Fig. 5(a)(c) shows the CPI voltage (vsab ) with grid, load, balanced (can be observed from magnitude) and sinusoidal.
and VSC currents. As under balanced loading condition, the The VSC currents are so adjusted that the grid currents are
three-phase currents for all the phases are equal, only one balanced and sinusoidal. Fig. 6(j)(l) shows the harmonics
phase quantity is shown. The reactive power compensation spectra of grid load and VSC currents. The THD of load
can be observed form Fig. 5(d)(f). Fig. 5(d) shows the power current is 21.8%; however, that of grid current is of the order
taken from the grid. Fig. 5(e) shows the load power that is at of 2%. The THD of VSC current is higher compared with grid
JAIN AND SINGH: ADJUSTABLE DC LINK VOLTAGE-BASED CONTROL 657

Fig. 7. Dynamic performance under (a) increase in insolation, (b) decrease in insolation, (c) sudden load removal, and (d) sudden load inclusion.

current as it consists of load current harmonics. The power as VSC has not to feed any harmonics current in phase c after
supplied by the grid and power absorbed by the load are load removal. The vice versa explanation of Fig. 7(c) can be
given in Fig. 6(m) and (n). The power supplied by the grid is used to explain the performance depicted in Fig. 7(d) wherein
negative, which shows that power is being supplied into the load inclusion is demonstrated.
grid. The performance of the proposed system for change in
CPI voltage can be observed in Fig. 8(a) and (b). Fig. 8(a)
B. Dynamics Performance
shows the performance for undervoltage in CPI voltage. The
The dynamic performances of the system for change in voltage of the CPI is changed from 415 to 350 V. The
insolation, load removal, and voltage variation are discussed adjustable nature of dc link voltage (decreasing with decrease
in this section. Fig. 7(a) and (b) shows the performance of the in CPI voltage) can be observed in Fig. 8(a). The PV array
system for increase and decrease in insolation level, respec- parameters are kept the same during this operation. Hence,
tively. The solar insolation is changed from 500 to 1000 W/m2 the grid currents and VSC currents are increased in order
and vice versa. Fig. 7(a) shows that with the increase in to feed the same power at lower voltage. Fig. 8(b) shows
insolation, the PV array current increases and the power the performance for overvoltage at CPI. The dc link voltage
delivered from PV array also increases. The increase in power increases with an increase in CPI voltage. The grid and VSC
fed can be observed from increase in VSC current. The vice currents are decreased to feed the same real power but at
versa inferences can be drawn from Fig. 7(b). increased voltage.
Fig. 7(c) and (d) shows performance of SECS for load
disturbances at CPI. The load disturbance is emulated by C. Comparison of the Proposed Control Approach With
opening one of the load lines (phase c), which not only Fixed vdc -Based Control Approach
causes reduction in effective load but also emulates unbalanced Conventionally, in a two-stage system, the first stage is a
load at CPI. The grid current increases after load removal as dcdc converter that serves for MPPT and the output of the
the net power fed to grid increases. Moreover, a change in first stage is cascaded to the second stage, which is a grid tied
wave shape of phase c current of VSC can be observed in VSC. The dc link voltage of VSC is kept fixed corresponding
which the VSC currents become sinusoidal after load removal to maximum value of CPI voltage. For proper control of
658 IEEE JOURNAL OF EMERGING AND SELECTED TOPICS IN POWER ELECTRONICS, VOL. 5, NO. 2, JUNE 2017

Fig. 8. Dynamic performance for CPI voltage variation. (a) Decrease in voltage from 415 to 350 V. (b) Increase in voltage from 415 to 480 V.

VSC currents under full range of CPI voltage variation, the


dc link voltage should be greater than the peak of maximum
allowed grid voltage. The dc link voltage is kept around
10% higher than the peak of maximum allowed grid voltage,
considering the drop across the inductor, switches, and proper
control under dynamics. However, while considering a weak
ac grid (far radial end), the overvoltage and undervoltage are
quite common. Considering the range of voltage variation
of 15 %, the ac mains voltage may vary between 352 and
477 V approximately for a nominal voltage of 415 V. The
fixed dc link voltage for operation under such a voltage range
is estimated as
vdc = 1.414 Vg max 1.1 = 1.414 477 1.1
Fig. 9. Switching transient for shunt grid interfaced VSC.
= 742.40 V = 740 V. (12)
In the proposed system, an adjustable dc link voltage
structure is proposed to reduce the power loss in the system.
The switching losses and the high-frequency ohmic losses in
the interfacing inductor are dependent on dc link voltage. The
ripple content in the interfacing inductor can be reduced by
adjusting the dc link voltage. The principle for power loss
reduction and its effects on the performance of the overall
system are demonstrated experimentally in the following.
Fig. 9 shows basic principle for switching power loss in
a two-level VSC considering linear transients. The switching Fig. 10. Basic principle for reduction in ripple current by keeping dc link
voltage near to amplitude of grid voltage.
logic for the two switches of the same leg is always com-
plementary. Therefore, before switching ON S2 , the switch
S1 is ON, making the voltage across S2 the same as dc link duration, pswitchon is the instantaneous power loss during
voltage. When S2 is turned ON, the voltage across S2 falls switch-OFF duration, tON is the switch-ON time, and tOFF is
to zero and current from S1 is shifted to S2 with a switching the switch-OFF duration.
transient. It can be easily observed that switching power losses It should be noted that the switching power losses in all
are dependent on dc link voltage of the VSC and the relation eight power switches (S1 S6 for VSC and SB and DB for
for total energy loss per switching in one leg is expressed as boost converter) are dependent on dc link voltage. Therefore,
 tON  tOFF the switching power losses are reduced by keeping adjustable
E = pswitchondt + pswitchoff dt dc link voltage-based control algorithm, wherein the dc link
0 0 voltage is kept just sufficient for current control.
1 The adjustable dc link voltage-based control also helps in
= Vdc IVSC (tON + tOFF ) (13)
6 reduction of high-frequency ripple current in the interfacing
where E is the total energy loss in one switching cycle, inductor, which in turn reduces the high-frequency ohmic
pswitchon is the instantaneous power loss during switch-ON losses. Fig. 10 shows the basic principle for reduction in
JAIN AND SINGH: ADJUSTABLE DC LINK VOLTAGE-BASED CONTROL 659

the worst case highest CPI voltage. It should be noted that


even under nominal voltage condition (415 V), the system with
adjustable dc link voltage feeds more power into the grid.

V. C ONCLUSION
A two-stage grid tied multifunctional solar energy conver-
sion system has been proposed. The proposed system not only
feeds the available solar energy into the grid but also helps in
Fig. 11. Grid currents for phase a with (a) proposed dc link voltage structure power quality improvement at CPI. The physical significance
and (b) conventional dc link voltage structure. of all salient internal signals of control algorithms has been
presented to make the proposed algorithm intuitive and simple
to understand. A PVFF term has improved the dynamic
response for changes in PV array power and CPI voltage
variation. An interweaved DFSOGI-based control algorithm
has been proposed, and its comparison with conventional
SRF theory has been shown to demonstrate its effectiveness.
Moreover, an adjustable dc link voltage structure for
CPI voltage variation is included in the proposed control
algorithm. A comparison of the proposed adjustable dc link
voltage structure algorithm with fixed dc link-based algorithm
has been shown, which demonstrates direct benefits in terms
of increased energy output. The proposed system not only
helps in improving the voltage power quality but also helps in
reduction of distribution losses. The proposed system yields
Fig. 12. Comparison of power fed into grid at different CPI voltages by
fixed and adjustable dc link-based system. increased energy output using the same hardware resources
just by virtue of difference in dc link voltage control structure.
The THDs of the grid currents are found less than 5% (within
ripple current by adjustable dc link voltage. The ripple in
IEEE-519 standard [26]) even under nonlinear loads at CPI.
the interfacing inductor depends on instantaneous voltage
The test results have shown the feasibility of the proposed
difference between the line voltage and the dc link voltage
system.
I (Vs Vdc ) (14)
R EFERENCES
where I is the current ripple, Vs is the instantaneous
CPI voltage, and Vdc is the dc link voltage. From (13), [1] A. M. Pavan and V. Lughi, Photovoltaics in Italy: Toward grid parity
in the residential electricity market, in Proc. 24th Int. Conf. Microelec-
it is clear that the current ripple with fixed dc link voltage tron. (ICM), Dec. 2012, pp. 14.
corresponding to worst case CPI voltage is higher under all [2] M. Delfanti, V. Olivieri, B. Erkut, and G. A. Turturro, Reaching
other voltage conditions. The increased ripple in the inductor PV grid parity: LCOE analysis for the Italian framework, in Proc. 22nd
Int. Conf. Exhibit. Electr. Distrib. (CIRED), Jun. 2013, pp. 14.
current causes increased ripple in the grid current. There- [3] D. Debnath and K. Chatterjee, Two-stage solar photovoltaic-based
fore, high-frequency ripple current is higher in conventional stand-alone scheme having battery as energy storage element for rural
system. deployment, IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 62, no. 7, pp. 41484157,
Jul. 2015.
Fig. 11 shows the experimental current waveforms for grid [4] H. Zhu, D. Zhang, H. S. Athab, B. Wu, and Y. Gu, PV isolated
current with the proposed and conventional dc link voltage three-port converter and energy-balancing control method for PV-battery
structure. The lower ripple content with the proposed dc link power supply applications, IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 62, no. 6,
pp. 35953606, Jun. 2015.
voltage control can be confirmed. The high-frequency ripple [5] N. Liu, Q. Chen, X. Lu, J. Liu, and J. Zhang, A charging strategy
current is also responsible for high-frequency ohmic losses. for PV-based battery switch stations considering service availability and
An overall experimental comparison of losses between the self-consumption of PV energy, IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 62,
no. 8, pp. 48784889, Aug. 2015.
two systems is shown in Fig. 12. [6] M. Kolhe, Techno-economic optimum sizing of a stand-alone solar
In order to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed photovoltaic system, IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., vol. 24, no. 2,
control algorithm, the experiments are conducted for both pp. 511519, Jun. 2009.
[7] M. A. G. de Brito, L. Galotto, L. P. Sampaio, G. E. de Azevedo e Melo,
conventional (fixed dc link voltage) and proposed (adjustable and C. A. Canesin, Evaluation of the main MPPT techniques for
dc link voltage) methods keeping the same power from solar photovoltaic applications, IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 60, no. 3,
array emulator. Fig. 12 shows the experimental comparisons of pp. 11561167, Mar. 2013.
[8] J. S. C. M. Raj and A. E. Jeyakumar, A novel maximum power
system with fixed and adjustable dc link voltages. The fixed dc point tracking technique for photovoltaic module based on power plane
link voltage is kept at 740 V. It can be observed that the power analysis of I-V characteristics, IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 61,
fed into the grid remains almost constant with the proposed no. 9, pp. 47344745, Sep. 2014.
[9] F. Liu, S. Duan, F. Liu, B. Liu, and Y. Kang, A variable step size
control approach; however, with conventional approach, the INC MPPT method for PV systems, IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 55,
power fed into the grid is lower at all operating voltages except no. 7, pp. 26222628, Jul. 2008.
660 IEEE JOURNAL OF EMERGING AND SELECTED TOPICS IN POWER ELECTRONICS, VOL. 5, NO. 2, JUNE 2017

[10] S. Singh and B. Singh, Optimized passive filter design using modified [25] C. Jain and B. Singh, A PEF based control for single-phase multifunc-
particle swarm optimization algorithm for a 12-pulse converter-fed tional SECS with adaptive DC link structure for PCC voltage variations,
LCIsynchronous motor drive, IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 50, no. 4, in Proc. 30th Annu. IEEE Appl. Power Electron. Conf. Expo., Mar. 2015,
pp. 26812689, Apr. 2014. pp. 17221729.
[11] H. Akagi, Active harmonic filters, Proc. IEEE, vol. 93, no. 12, [26] IEEE Recommended Practices and Requirement for Harmonic Control
pp. 21282141, Dec. 2005. on Electric Power System, IEEE Standard 519, 1992.
[12] S. A. O. da Silva and R. A. Modesto, A comparative analysis of
SRF-based controllers applied to active power line conditioners, in
Proc. 34th Annu. Conf. IEEE Ind. Electron. (IECON), Nov. 2008,
pp. 405410.
[13] M. Kesler and E. Ozdemir, Synchronous-reference-frame-based control
method for UPQC under unbalanced and distorted load conditions,
IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 58, no. 9, pp. 39673975, Sep. 2011. Chinmay Jain (M12) received the B.E. degree
[14] A. K. Verma, B. Singh, and D. T. Sahani, Grid interfaced solar in electrical engineering from the Shri G. S. Institute
photovoltaic power generating system with power quality improvement of Technology and Science, Indore, India, in 2009,
at AC mains, in Proc. IEEE ICSET, Kathmandu, Nepal, Sep. 2012, the M.E. degree in electrical engineering from
pp. 177182. the Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, India,
[15] S. R. Arya, B. Singh, A. Chandra, and K. Al-Haddad, Learning-based in 2011, and the Ph.D. degree from the Department
anti-Hebbian algorithm for control of distribution static compensator, of Electrical Engineering, Indian Institute of Tech-
IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 61, no. 11, pp. 60046012, Nov. 2014. nology, Delhi, India.
[16] S. R. Arya and B. Singh, Neural network based conductance estimation He is currently with Shakti Pumps India Ltd.
control algorithm for shunt compensation, IEEE Trans. Ind. Informat., His research interests include special motor design,
vol. 10, no. 1, pp. 569577, Feb. 2014. power electronics, drives, power quality, grid inter-
[17] B. Singh and S. R. Arya, Back-propagation control algorithm for power faced solar PV systems, and the design of custom power devices.
quality improvement using DSTATCOM, IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron.,
vol. 61, no. 3, pp. 12041212, Mar. 2009.
[18] S. Deo, C. Jain, and B. Singh, A PLL-less scheme for single-phase grid
interfaced load compensating solar PV generation system, IEEE Trans.
Ind. Informat., vol. 11, no. 3, pp. 692699, Mar. 2015.
[19] B. Singh, D. T. Shahani, and A. K. Verma, Neural network con-
trolled grid interfaced solar photovoltaic power generation, IET Power Bhim Singh (SM99F10) received the B.E. degree
Electron., vol. 7, no. 3, pp. 614626, Jul. 2013. in electrical engineering from the University of
[20] C. Jain and B. Singh, A frequency shifter-based simple control for Roorkee, Roorkee, India, in 1977, and the M.Tech.
solar PV grid-interfaced system, in Proc. 37th Nat. Syst. Conf., 2013, and Ph.D. degrees from the Indian Institute of Tech-
pp. 363374. nology (IIT) Delhi, New Delhi, India, in 1979 and
[21] A. Kulkarni and V. John, A novel design method for SOGI- 1983, respectively.
PLL for minimum settling time and low unit vector distortion, in In 1983, he was a Lecturer with the Electrical
Proc. 39th Annu. Conf. Ind. Electron. Soc. (IECON), Nov. 2013, Engineering Department, University of Roorkee,
pp. 274279. where he became a Reader in 1988. In 1990,
[22] C.-S. Lam, W.-H. Choi, M.-C. Wong, and Y.-D. Han, Adaptive he was an Assistant Professor with the Electrical
DC-link voltage-controlled hybrid active power filters for reactive Engineering Department, IIT Delhi, where he
power compensation, IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 27, no. 4, became an Associate Professor in 1994 and where he has been a Profes-
pp. 17581772, Apr. 2012. sor since 1997. His research interests include power electronics, electrical
[23] C.-S. Lam, M.-C. Wong, W.-H. Choi, X.-X. Cui, H.-M. Mei, machines and drives, renewable energy systems, active filters, flexible ac
and J.-Z. Liu, Design and performance of an adaptive low-DC-voltage- transmission systems, high-voltage direct current, and power quality.
controlled LC-hybrid active power filter with a neutral inductor in three- Prof. Singh is a fellow of the Indian National Academy of Engineering, The
phase four-wire power systems, IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 61, National Academy of Sciences, India, the Indian Academy of Sciences, The
no. 6, pp. 26352647, Jun. 2014. Institution of Engineering and Technology, U.K., The Institution of Engineers
[24] C. Jain and B. Singh, A three-phase grid tied SPV system with adaptive (India), and the Institution of Electronics and Telecommunication Engineers.
DC link voltage for CPI voltage variations, IEEE Trans. Sustain. He is also a Life Member of the Indian Society for Technical Education and
Energy, vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 337344, Jan. 2016. the System Society of India.

You might also like