Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Summary: N owadays
is evident
a
for
marketing practices with regard
tendency
changing
The present paper aims to to environmental protection. The
analyze the inception, development tendency has developed largely as
and link between the terms eco- a result of a peculiar consumers
marketing, green marketing and pressure (especially in countries with
sustainable marketing. The research developed civil societies). In principle,
encompasses scientific research corporate and especially marketing
papers treating marketings influence managers see consumer choice as
on the environment, as well as a process in which customers make
theoretic publications on the topic. a decision for a purchase on the
The research topic is the evolution basis of functional (Marketing 1.0
of marketing thinking from the point Kotler) and emotional (Marketing 2.0
of view of marketing influences Kotler) criteria. However, it should
on the ecological balance on the be taken into account that some of
earth. This paper is an attempt modern-day customers (which are
to prove the assumption that the increasing in number) are already
ecological evolution of marketing taking into account a third criterion
has gone through four stages: (1) which can be referred to as socio-
embryonic stage (pre-1974); (2) ecological (Marketing 2.0 Kotler).
ecological marketing (1975-1989); (3) Todays customers have new
"green" marketing (1990-2000); (4) perceptions, concerns and doubts
sustainable marketing (post-2000). that inevitably impact their consumer
Key words: marketing evolution, choice. In the course of time
ecological marketing, green consumers are becoming ever more
marketing , sustainable marketing concerned about questions such
as finding and keeping a job, or the
JEL Classification: M30, M31, possible increase of traffic jams.
Q01, Q50 Furthermore, they are increasingly
*
ssociated Professor, Ph.D., Marketing and Strategic Planning Department, UNWE, e-mail: hristokat@abv.bg.
71
Ecological, Green and Sustainable
Marketing: Synonyms r n Evolution
Articles f Ideas?
worried about whether air and water of the negative social and ecological
pollution will continue, whether or not effects of the present systems of
companies produce without polluting production, distribution, marketing and
the environment, whether or not foods communication. Along with "green"
contain harmful ingredients (GMOs, marketing, other similar concepts such
preservatives, etc.), and other issues as ecological marketing, environmental
at stake. marketing, sustainable marketing, are
Research in this field shows that also launched. The present study
"more and more consumers would was originally an attempt to clarify
rather buy goods and services from the nature of the aforementioned
companies that are concerned concepts and to determine the
for the environment, which is why extent to which they express different
company managers and owners have ideas or else, overlap in meaning.
to add the ecological vector to the Ultimately, after studying the evolution
administration." (Kotler., P, 2011, p. of marketing thought in this context, it
132135). Over the past few decades was established that these concepts
several marketing concepts have not only express different ideas, but
emerged and gained popularity. They also refer to different periods in the
pertain to environmental protection, development of marketing though on
production of ecologically clean the question of sustainability.
products, the preservation of the This piece of research aims to
planets natural resources, and other study the inception, development
topical questions. Since the mid-1970s, and link between the terms eco-
both scientific literature and everyday marketing, green marketing and
journalism have used such terms as sustainable marketing. The research
eco-marketing (ecological marketing), encompasses scientific papers
stable marketing, "green" marketing dedicated to issues of marketings
and others of the kind. Specialized impact on the environment, as well as
scientific literature contains fundamentally theoretical publications
(especially in the last two decades) on the issue. The research topic is
an abundance of papers dedicated the evolution of marketing thought
to the relation between marketing from the perspective of how
and mans physical environment. Yet marketing influences the planets
marketing has often been singled out ecological balance. The assumption
as the major factor for the negative is made, and an attempt to prove
impact that the production of goods it, that the ecological evolution of
and services has on the environment. marketing has gone through four
Nevertheless, a number of researchers stages: (1) embryo stage (pre-1974);
see marketing as a tool to avert real (2) ecological marketing (1975-1989);
and potential ecological disasters. (3) "green" marketing (1990-2000);
"Green" marketing is the most popular (4) sustainable marketing (post-
concept used in scientific and other 2000). The history research method
literature to define the marketing and the content analysis method (an
activities pertaining to the reduction analysis of the contents of scientific
publications on the issue) have been economics is also derived from "oik"
applied. "oikonomiks", and can be translated
2. Concerning the terms ecology as "management of the household/
and ecological marketing home". The ecological perspective
is evident when defining the so-
When it comes to the inception called "home/family economics". The
of the science of ecology, some definition of "home economics" given
basic ideas are implicitly found in the to it by the American Home Economics
works of Plato and Aristotle, more Association2 in 1902 reads:
specifically in their reflections on "Home economics, in its most
the processes of population growth common meaning is a study of the
and development, and especially on laws, conditions, principles and ideas
the effect that population growth has that involve the immediate physical
on the environments structure and environment of an individual on one
endurance. hand, and his social nature on the
Ecology as a modern-day science, other. In the end, "home economics"
however, arises in the late XIX studies the interactions between
Century. During that time, processes these two factors."
occur in economically advanced What is interesting about this is
countries from Western Europe and that the meaning of the link between
especially the United States that the business and the environment is
involve urbanization, industrialization explicitly formed over 100 years ago.
and public development. An increase It seems that state representatives
is observed in the level of education of power, business managers and
and concern for health care and well- a large portion of everyone else
being. Also during that period, Darwins have neglected, misunderstood or
theory gains popularity, natural forgotten the relationships between
sciences undergo a tremendous human activity and nature over the
development and interest in social next 60 years, only to reach sobering
sciences becomes increasingly ecological crises and a kind of
tangible. It is considered that the reminder from Mother Nature on mans
concept "ecology" itself was created dependence on all his surroundings
by the German zoologist Earnest and all living organisms on the planet.
Haeckel who holds the view that It is precisely in the 1960s that
"human individuals are the result of science thought matures when it
the interaction between two forces comes to the necessity of employing
heredity and the environment". In 1873 the systematic approach when
he suggests that this new science be studying human activity, especially the
named "oekologie", which is derived links between this activity and nature.
from the Greek word "oik", meaning Interest in the effect that marketing has
"home", "a place of inhabitance". It on its surroundings also dates back
is interesting to note that the term
2
The present name of the association is American Association of Family and Consumer Sciences(AAFCS), see: http://www.
aafcs.org. (Accessed November, 15th, 2015)
73
Ecological, Green and Sustainable
Marketing: Synonyms r n Evolution
Articles f Ideas?
to this period. Since the 1960s and marketing practices with the purpose
1970s there has been growing interest of completely overcoming the negative
and research in the field of ecological environmental effects of production
marketing. Amid this boom of and consumption and building a
scientific inquiries, books and articles sustainable policy. Peatties research
on the topic are published, though in has undeniable merits, and he has
terms of concepts and notions the evidently captured the tendency for
us of many similar terms has been thought development with regard to
observed ecological marketing, the ecological aspects of marketing.
or eco-marketing; green marketing; However, he dates the beginning
environmental marketing; sustainable of the ecological line of marketing
marketing or sustainability marketing, back to the 1970s. Our analysis,
and other terms. It is therefore however, has shown that marketing
logical that the question should arise theory affected the ecological line
as to whether there is a conflict of long before the 1970s. In this regard,
concepts or else, a typology and we offer an additional specification
systematization of these concepts on the development stages of the
could be sought? To answer this ecological line in marketing theory.
question, we have traced the historical It is necessary to strongly suggest
development of scientific thought with that we do not completely reject
regard to the marketing-environment the periodization offered by Petty;
link. The following paragraphs present we are adding new stages, and it
the result of this scientific search. develops further from the perspective
3. The Ecological Paradigm in of additional scientific theories and
Marketing Inception and assumptions, publications and trends.
Stages of Development 3.1. Embryonic stage of ecological
Ken Peattie studies the evolution marketing development
of the concept of green marketing, The debate about the ecological
which in his opinion goes through aspect of marketing activity was
three stages: (1) ecological stage launched in the late 1950s, and in the
(which is characterized by closely early 1960s by Wroe Alderson. Using
defined problems such as air pollution, the systematic approach, Alderson
oil spills, harming the environment analyzes the interaction between
with pesticides/herbicides, etc.); the marketing system, society and
(2) environmental marketing (which the environment. This is one of the
is characterized by more widely first serious attempts at defining the
defined initiatives whose aim is to concept of marketing in terms of the
reduce environmental damage as impact marketing activities have on
well as to turn these green initiatives the environment.
into competitive advantages; (3) Surveys of this type pick up pace
sustainability stage, which involves and by the end of the 1960s, and
more serious and radical changes especially in the early 1970s the
in the way of marketing thinking and issue of the ecological debate in the
75
Ecological, Green and Sustainable
Marketing: Synonyms r n Evolution
Articles f Ideas?
77
Ecological, Green and Sustainable
Marketing: Synonyms r n Evolution
Articles f Ideas?
substantial difference is observed the role that these two elements have
from the previous development (quality management on one hand and
phase of ecological marketing, environmental protection on the other)
which is a typical drive for reducing and the adoption of systematic thinking
the production and consumption with respect to the production and
of certain products (for example, marketing activities of the company.
toxic pesticides) and/or imposing Eventually, in 1996 new international
new eco-products (for example, standards (ISO 1400) were developed
recycled paper). The concept of in regard to the organizations
eco-performance brings to the environmental management system.
forefront the total impact that the Marketing thinking during the
entire company has on society and green marketing stage changes
the environment, including all its significantly. If the previous stage
products and production systems. (ecological marketing) focused on
Fifth, the concept of ecological the branches that directly influenced
quality has to be mentioned. During the environments ecological status
the green marketing period, the (petroleum industry, coal mining,
requirements towards the companies chemical industry, etc.), the green
with regard to environmental marketing stage expands the
preservation grow significantly. It is perimeter of branches and fields
no longer sufficient for one company in which decisions regarding the
to implement partial measures environment become important. The
for environmental protection for consequences of raising the issue
example, part of its production of sustainable development with
being ecological, while another not respect to marketing thinking lead to
being such; or for one unit of the widening the range of environmental
firm to introduce ecologically clean discussions. The following issues
products, while other units pollute are included within this range:
the environment. Ecological thinking the extinction of plant and animal
during this period rises to a higher species; the destruction of specific
level and more and more business ecosystems; poverty in developing
managers start viewing the enterprises countries, etc. The green wave in
under their management as physical marketing thinking widens its range
and social systems, and tracing and with respect to all household products
analyzing the interrelations between such as cleaning supplies, white
the enterprise, the environment and technology, furniture, etc., as well as
society. A typical characteristic of financial services and tourism. Along
managers thinking from the period is with widening the product range of
searching for ways to combine existing the ecological concept, its scientific
quality management systems with the development was also observed.
ecological imperatives at the time. During the green marketing period,
The term "Total Quality Environmental this development flows in the direction
Management" has even been coined, of a more serious acceptance of the
which is a sign of the realization of systematic approach in marketing,
79
Ecological, Green and Sustainable
Marketing: Synonyms r n Evolution
Articles f Ideas?
81
Ecological, Green and Sustainable
Marketing: Synonyms r n Evolution
Articles f Ideas?
London and Sydney: Croom Helm, pp. (eds.), Marketing Analysis for Societal
10-28. Problems, Urbana: University of Illinois.
Fisk, G., 1973. Criteria for a Theory of Kotler, Ph., Levy, S., 1971. Demarketing,
Responsible Consumption, Journal of Yes, Demarketing. Harvard Business
Marketing, Vol. 37, No. 2, pp. 24-31. Review. 49(6): 74-80.
Fisk, G., 1974. Marketing and Ecologi- Kotler., Ph., 2011. Reinventing
cal Crisis, New York, Harper&Row. Marketing to Manage the Environmental
Fuller, D. A., 2000. Sustainable Imperative, Journal of Marketing, Vol.
Marketing: Managerial-Ecological 75, July, pp. 132135.
Issues, Sage, Thousand Oaks, Peattie, K., 2001. Towards Sustainability:
California. The Third Age of Green Marketing, The
Henion, ., Kinnear, 1975. ., Ecological Marketing Review, 2, pp. 129-146.
Marketing, American Marketing Porter, M., van der Linde, C. 1995.
Association. Green and Competitive: Ending the
Kangun, N., 1974. Environmental Stalemate, Harvard Business Review,
Problems and Marketing: Saint or 73 (5), pp. 120-133.
Sinner," in J. N. Sheth and P. L. Wright
http://www.aafcs.org (Accessed November,
15th, 2015)