Project Name: Mudd 740 Proteomics/Biology Recr

Drawing Set/Date: 4/20/15

COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY COMMENTS
Date: 4/27/15
Reviewers: CU Ops comments

Issue
Number Drawing / Item Detail / Location Author Date Comment Response Date
On the riser diagram from page 2, the existing controller
being used is at the Cellar level. There is another Mudd_7th
1 15000A-001 ATC Submittal 3 of 10 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015 building level controller in the 700 lvl MER. Please specify
which one is the new system tying into and modify page 2 if
needed.

Note NC/FC for the return air damper and cooling coil valve
2 15000A-001 ATC Submittal 4 of 10 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015
and NO/FO for the heating coil as specified on the schedule

Since this is an RA unit, why not have the freeze protection in

3 15000A-001 ATC Submittal 4 of 10 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015 front of the cooling coil? Is the freeze protection in place for
detection for loss of heating capability?

Decision for cooling and heating coil valves on the supply or

4 15000A-001 ATC Submittal 4 of 10 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015
return side of the coil.
Decision for reheat coil valves on supply or return side of the
5 15000A-001 ATC Submittal 5 of 10 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015
unit.
DPS-1 for dirty filter pressure sensor should be DPSW2 per
P&ID. This is a transmitter per cut sheets/AI input selection
6 15000A-001 ATC Submittal 6 of 10 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015
so it for be DPS and not a SW(Switch). Change on page 4
instead.
Supply Air Humidity Sensor is labled as DH-1 on page 4 and
7 15000A-001 ATC Submittal 6 of 10 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015
RHD-1 here.
8 15000A-001 ATC Submittal 6 of 10 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015 Dip Swich for input 5, 8, 9 should be 'off'.

Output 10 and 11 for heating and cooling coil valves has

9 15000A-001 ATC Submittal 6 of 10 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015 reversed names (CV-1, CV-2) from P&ID on page 4. The
assignments here correspond to the schedule on page 10.

10 15000A-001 ATC Submittal 7 of 10 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015 DM-1 should be DM-2 since DM-1 was used on the AHU.
DM-1 through 4 to be shifted to DM-2 through 5, unless there
11 15000A-001 ATC Submittal 8 of 10 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015 are other schedules designating them as such, which are not
included in this ATC Submittal.
DM-1 and DM-2 to be shifted to DM-6 and DM-7, same
12 15000A-001 ATC Submittal 9 of 10 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015
reason as issue 11.
CV-1, CV-2 designations for heating and cooling valves.
13 15000A-001 ATC Submittal 10 of 10 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015
Same reason as issue 9.
Section 1.B. Confirm final freezestat location as mentioned in
issue 3. What preheat coil? Feeze protection pump wiring
14 ATC Sequence of Ops page 3 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015
and operation not mentioned or shown anywhere else in the
entire ATC Submittal.
Section 1.C. VFD to ramp up to required speed for flow
15 ATC Sequence of Ops page 3 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015
control instead of 'full speed'.
Project Name: Mudd 740 Proteomics/Biology Recr
Drawing Set/Date: 4/20/15
COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY COMMENTS
Date: 4/27/15
Reviewers: CU Ops comments

Issue
Number Drawing / Item Detail / Location Author Date Comment Response Date
Section 1.F. Note the induction unit operations will be
16 ATC Sequence of Ops page 3 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015
covered in section G and H?
17 ATC Sequence of Ops page 4 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015 Section 1.I. Clarify exit condition for the dehum mode.
18 ATC Sequence of Ops page 4 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015 Section 1.J. RA damper instead od OA damper listed.
Section 1.H. General comment: Would the stated sequence
have possible effect on RHC-2 controlled space? Would it be
better to change the AHU cooling coil valve to control to the
19 ATC Sequence of Ops page 4 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015
higher of the two cooling demands from the spaces. Let the
dedicted reheat coil on either side pick up the space being
over cooled.

For both RHC-1 and RHC-2, I am okay with the system not
using cascaded control based on discharge temps, though it
20 ATC Sequence of Ops page 5 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015 is preferred to control the valves via AHU discharge air temp
setpoing, RHC discharge air temp setpoings, on a reset
schedule based on the space temp control signal.

21 ATC Sequence of Ops page 5 Ryan Mao 4/27/2015 What do the temporary AC-1, AC-2 dampers do???
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
Project Name: Mudd 740 Proteomics/Biology Recr
Drawing Set/Date: 4/20/15
COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY COMMENTS
Date: 4/27/15
Reviewers: CU Ops comments

Issue
Number Drawing / Item Detail / Location Author Date Comment Response Date
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79