Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Conyer, Leahy & Lofgren Letter To Kushner About EB-5 VISAS & Conflicts of Interest

    Uploaded by

    Beverly Tran
    208 views9 pages
    The Judiciary Committees of the Senate and the House of Representatives have oversight and authorizing jurisdiction over the EB-5 Regional Center program. Since 2015, bipartisan members of these committees have worked together to develop broad reforms to the program. Members have also engaged with the Department of Homeland Security, under both the Obama and Trump administrations, through a regulatory effort to administratively improve the program. Despite wide recognition that the EB-5 program is in need of reform, however, these efforts have been opposed by select entities.

    Original Title

    Conyer, Leahy & Lofgren Letter To Kushner About EB-5 VISAS & Conflicts of Interest

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    The Judiciary Committees of the Senate and the House of Representatives have oversight and authorizing jurisdiction over the EB-5 Regional Center program. Since 2015, bipartisan members of these committees have worked together to develop broad reforms to the program. Members have also engaged with the Department of Homeland Security, under both the Obama and Trump administrations, through a regulatory effort to administratively improve the program. Despite wide recognition that the EB-5 program is in need of reform, however, these efforts have been opposed by select entities.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    208 views9 pages

    Conyer, Leahy & Lofgren Letter To Kushner About EB-5 VISAS & Conflicts of Interest

    Uploaded by

    Beverly Tran
    The Judiciary Committees of the Senate and the House of Representatives have oversight and authorizing jurisdiction over the EB-5 Regional Center program. Since 2015, bipartisan members of these committees have worked together to develop broad reforms to the program. Members have also engaged with the Department of Homeland Security, under both the Obama and Trump administrations, through a regulatory effort to administratively improve the program. Despite wide recognition that the EB-5 program is in need of reform, however, these efforts have been opposed by select entities.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 9
    Congress of the Anited States Washington, BE 20510 June 1, 2017 Laurent Morali President, Kushner Companies 666 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 10103 Dear Mr. Morali: ‘The Judiciary Committees of the Senate and the House of Representatives have oversight and authorizing jurisdiction over the EB-5 Regional Center program. Since 2015, bipartisan members of these committees have worked together to develop broad reforms to the program. ‘Members have also engaged with the Department of Homeland Security, under both the Obama and Trump administrations, through a regulatory effort to administratively improve the program, Despite wide recognition that the EB-5 program is in need of reform, however, these efforts have been opposed by select entities. We are concerned about recent reports detailing Kushner Companies’ use of the EB-5 Regional Center program, especially in light of Jared Kushner’s role in the Trump administration and the potential for conflicts of interest. ‘These reports indicate that Kushner Companies and its latest EB-5 project, “One Journal Square,” may be seeking to benefit from the Kushner family’s connections to the White House. These reports also suggest that luxury developers have aggressively lobbied Congress to prevent reforms to the EB-S program. Such lobbying appears intended to benefit luxury development projects like those built by Kushner Companies, and thus presents the appearance of a conflict of interest given Mr. Kushner’s new position in the administration. As Congress considers what reforms are necessary to the EB-5 program, we request that you provide additional details regarding your participation in this federal immigration program. Jared Kushner’s Financial Ties to EB-5 1, Jared Kushner has retained numerous holdings in Kushner Companies. The Washington Post recently reported that Mr. Kushner has retained 220 assets, including 124 real estate properties, worth a minimum of $167 million.’ The White House confirmed that Mr. "Daria Cameron, Amy Brittain and Jonathen O'Connell, ‘What Jared Kushner stil owns,” The Washington Past (May 21, 2017), available at https:/www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/poites/kushner- conficts/2utm_term=fe6304592137. Laurent Morali Sune 1, 2017 Page 2 of 9 Kushner still owns a stake in another Kushner Companies" project financed in part by EB-S, “Trump Bay Street.”? a, Please provide complete details of any holdings of Kushner Companies in which Mr. Kushner, directly or indirectly, is a partial or full owner. b. Please deseribe which of those holdings have been financed or expect to be financed, in whole or in part, using any proceeds derived from capital investments by immigrants seeking a visa under the EB-5 program (“EB-S Investors") 2. Even though Jared Kushner has stepped away from a leadership position within Kushner Companies for the time being, we understand that he may step back into a leadership or more prominent ownership role once he leaves his White House position. ‘This raises the question of what steps Mr. Kushner would have to take to regain any ownership interests from which he has divested. a, Ihe chooses to do so, could Mr. Kushner merely resume identical ownership interests? Would his family be permitted to gift him equity interests in the company or projects, or would he have to purchase or otherwise acquire any interest at fair market value (or at a discount or premium)? Marketing Familial Relationships with the White House 3. Earlier this month, at a promotional event in Beijing for One Journal Square, Jared Kushner’s sister, Nicole Kushner Meyer, included in her pitch to potential investors that her brother served as Kushner Companies’ chief executive until he left to serve in the ‘Trump administration.’ She also noted that “this project means a lot to me and my entire family.”* Ms. Meyer was scheduled to attend additional conferences to pitch the family business but those were cancelled after the press reported on the Beijing event.5 Kushner ‘Companies has since stated that it “apologizes if that mention of [Meyer's] brother was in any way interpreted as an attempt to lure investors." a, According to a report in Reuters, Kushner Companies is using the Chinese migration agency Qiaowai to market the One Journal Square project to potential 2 Anna Wemer and Laura Strickler, “Kushners use controversial EB-S visa program to finance their developments,” CBS News (May 8, 2017), available at http:/www.cbsnews,com/news/kushners-use-controversial-cb-S-visa- program-to-finance-their-developments. 5 Javier Hemandez, Cao Li, and Jesse Drucker, “Jared Kushner’s Sister Highlights Family Ties in Pitch to Chinese Investors,” The New York Times (May 6, 2017), available at hiips:/www.nytimes.eon/2017/0S/06/workd/asia/jarede ushne e-meyer-ching-investorsun!? 1-0 "id. 5 Kushner family company to skip Chinese Investor conference,” The Associated Press (May 12, 2017), available at fup/ww hss. conv/nevs/jared-kushner-sister-nicole-kushner-meyer- hina © Merrit Kennedy, “Kushner Companies’ Pitch to Chinese Investors Raises Conflict of Interest Questions,” NPR (May 7, 2017), available at hup:/www: npr ore/seetions/thetwo-way/20 [7/0507/527282482/kushnet-connpanies: onflict-ointerest-questo. Laurent Morali June 1, 2017 Page 3 of 9 Chinese investors.’ Qiaowai claims to have raised money for the Trump Bay Street project as well. Qiaowai’s promotional materials noted Ms. Meyer's, familial relationship to President Trump and called her the event's “heavyweight honored guest."? According to The New York Times, one potential investor stated that Qiaowai “said [that President Trump] would make sure [the visas] came through” and that Kushner Companies’ ties to President Trump ensured that “there was no chance [the project] could fail."! Have you requested that Qiaowai cease exploiting Ms. Meyer's and Kushner Companies’ connections to the White House in its efforts to recruit investors on your behalf? b. What steps, if any, have you taken to ensure that no one affiliated with Kushner Companies or Qiaowai references or otherwise exploits Kushner Companies’ connections to the White House? 4, Qiaowai has reportedly described the marketing event with Ms. Meyer as a success, stating that it resulted in a “buying rush.”"" a, How many investors have either committed or signaled they intend to commit to investing in One Journal Square following the marketing event with Ms. Meyer at which Mr. Kushner and President Trump were mentioned? Lobbying in Opposition to EB-S Reform 5, Since 2015, members of the Judiciary Committees of the Senate and House have worked together to develop broad bipartisan reforms to the EB-5 Regional Center program. Members also requested in March 2016 that then-Secretary of Homeland Security Jeh Johnson do what he could administratively to improve the program.'? The Obama administration then issued new proposed rules in January 2017.!° ‘These efforts have been actively opposed by select large developers and business interests. In a report titled, “Changes to visa program could set back Kushner family’s real estate company,” The ? Alexandra Hamey, “Behind Kushner Companies, a Chinese agency skirts visa-for-investment rules,” Reuters (May 12, 2017), available at htip:/vww.reuters.comvarticlefus-china-kushner-qiaowai-insight-idUSKBN 1882EL “1d td "Javier C. Hernandez and Jesse Drucker, “How to Woo Chinese Investors: With Visa Offers and the Trump Name,” The New York Times (May 19, 2017), available at hiips://www.nytimes,comn/2017/05/19/businessikushner- trump-china-green-cards htm ‘Kushner Companies has yet to secure EB-S funds for Jersey City project after Chinese road show,” The Real Deal (May 15, 2017), available at hps:/herealdeal.con/2017/05/1S/kushner-companies-ha S. funds-for-jersey-city-project-after-chinese-road-show/- " Letter from Bob Goodlatte, Charles Grassley, John Conyers, Jr, and Patrick Leahy to Jeh Johnson, Secretary, Department of Homeland Security, at 1 (Mar. 2, 2016). 82 Fed, Reg, 4738 et seq. (Jan. 13, 2017). Laurent Morali June 1, 2017 Page 4 of 9 Washington Post reports that “[b]ig-name developers have hired armies of lobbyists to fight changes in the EB-5 rules,”!* In order to secure EB-5 funding for its projects, Kushner Companies partners with a regional center known as U.S. Immigration Fund.'® A New York Times report described the U.S. Immigration Fund as “at the forefront of efforts to stop an overhaul of the EB-5 program in 2015 and 2016,”'® According to public disclosure records, between 2013 and the first quarter of 2017, U.S. Immigration Fund spent $980,000 on lobbying related to the EB-S program.'7 The Chairman and CEO of U.S. Immigration Fund, Nicholas Mastroianni IT, was featured in a Fortune Magazine report titled “The tangled past of the hottest money-raiser in America’s visa-for-sale program.”'* According to the Washington Post, U. Immigration Fund’s president, Nicholas Mastroianni III, contributed $100,000 to the Trump inauguration.” ‘The younger Mastroianni was then “invited to an exclusive dinner with Trump’s future Cabinet members on Jan. 18, days after the [EB-5 rule] changes were proposed.” The Palm Beach Daily News reported that Mr. Mastroianni TIT sat at the same table as Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kelly.”° a, Aside from partnering with U.S. Immigration Fund to secure EB-S funds for its projects, has Kushner Companies coordinated, pursued, or discussed any lobbying or advocacy efforts with U.S. Immigration Fund? b. Prior to Jared Kushner resigning as CEO of Kushner Companies in January 2017, did anyone associated with U.S. Immigration Fund have any communication with Mr. Kushner regarding EB-5 regulations? ' Shawn Boburg, “Changes to visa program could set back Kushner family’s realestate company,” The Washington Post (May 11, 2017), available at hiips:/4www.washingtonpost con/national/kushner-family-drops-out-of-china- ppresentation/2017/05/1 1/a8368ea0-Mef-| le7-bee- 3460506637 1_tern=. 21450086517, Mm "See, eg. the list of U.S. Immigration Fund projects on its website, which includes “88 Kushner-KABR,” available at http://visaeb-5.com/usi-fund-projects/new-york-regional-center! * Javier C. Hemandez and Jesse Drucker, “How to Woo Chinese Investors: With Visa Offers and the Trump Name,” The New York Times (May 19, 2017), available at httgs/Avww nstimes.com/2017/05/19/business/kushnk trump-china-green-cards hum! "The United States Senate, “Query the Lobbying Disclosure Act Database,” available at hitps://soprweb senate gov/index.cfm?event=processSelectFields (click “Client Name," submit, and then query ‘simmigeation fund LLC"), "Peter Elkind and Marty Jones, “The tangled past ofthe hottest money-raiser in America’s visa-forsale program,” Fortune Magazine (Oct. 14, 2014), available at hitp://fortune.com/2014/10/14/eb-Stangled-pasV ' Shawn Boburg, “Changes to Visa Program could set back Kushner family’s real estate company,” The Washington Post (May 11, 2017), available at htips://wwsv..vashingtonpost.conv/nationg mnily-drops-oute cof-china-presentation 2017/0511 1ia8368a -bv4ee-434b6d506037_ story. himI?in_term=2145a4b8eS [7 George Bennett and Bill DiPaolo, “Many County residents gave big to Trump inaugural committee,” Palm Beach Daily News (April 24, 2017), available at huip:/sw,palmbeachdailynew vave-big-trump-inausural-commitie/ZhzSjheWSWXVY fotV200YNi. com/news/local/many-county-residnts, Laurent Morali June 1, 2017 Page 5 of 9 ¢. To your knowledge, has anyone associated with U.S. Immigration Fund made any representations to any EB-5 stakeholders regarding policy positions or actions that Mr. Kushner or the White House intends to take with respect to regulations ot reforms to the EB-5 program? 6. Jared Kushner, as CEO of Kushner Companies, was a member of the Real Estate Roundtable in both 2015"! and 2016.” The Real Estate Roundtable has been active lobbying Congress on issues related to EB-5, and it includes the program among only six “Policy Issues” listed on its website.?* The Real Estate Roundtable also describes itself as a “Founding Member” of another EB-5 lobbying group, the “EB-S Investment Coalition.” On January 4, 2017, representatives from the Real Estate Roundtable, the EB-5 Investment Coalition, and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce met in person with government officials regarding the DHS proposed rule. These organizations then wrote to the President on the day of his inauguration, and to Secretary Kelly on February 24, 2017, requesting that the regulations be withdrawn.26 Now that Mr. Kushner has stepped down as CEO, is anyone affiliated with Kushner Companies still a member of the Real Estate Roundtable? b. What other lobbying or advocacy activities has Kushner Companies engaged in, directly or indirectly, related to reform or reauthorization of the EB-5 program? c. Has anyone affiliated with Kushner Companies discussed the DHS proposed regulations, or EB-5 issues generally, with Jared Kushner since President Trump took office? 4. Has anyone affiliated with the Real Estate Roundtable, the EB-5 Investment Coalition, or the U.S. Chamber of Commerce discussed the proposed regulations, or EB-S issues generally, with Jared Kushner since President Trump took office? 212015 Annual Report,” The Real Estate Roundtable, available at hitps/wwwy.cerorg/?015-Annusl-Repor’ (accessed May 30, 2017), 222016 Annual Report,” The Real Estate Roundtable, available at http/www.rer.orz/2016-Annual-Report (accessed May 30, 2017). 2 See The Real Estate Roundtable, “The Urgent Need to Reform and Reauthorize the EB-5 Investment Program,” Policy Issues, available at http://www. rer org/EBS » 1d, (“The Real Estate Roundtable suppors legislative efforts to extend EB-S regional centers and isa ‘Founding Member’ ofa broad-based EB-S coalition”) » Office of Information and Regulatory A\fuirs, “View EO 12866 Meeting 1615-ACO7 (Title: BB-S Immigrant Investor Program Modernization)” available at huis:f/www reginfo,gov/public/do/viewEO12R66Mecting2viewRule-tmegrin=16 ACOT&meetinghd=2280dacronym=1615-DUSUSCIS, % See “Exhibit I,” Comments to Proposed EB-5 Regulations, EB-S Investment Coalition, available at htips//www rexulations,gov/document?D=USCIS-2016-0006-0257. Laurent Morali June 1, 2017 Page 6 of 7. The New York Times has reported that Qiaowai and U.S. Immigration Fund brought Rudolph W. Giuliani to Beijing last year to speak to potential investors.”” Mr. Giuliani is employed by Greenberg Traurig,” the same law firm that is “fighting changes to the rules of the EB-5 program” on behalf of the EB-5 Investment Coalition a, Has Mr, Giuliani recruited investors on behalf of One Journal Square or Trump Bay Street? b. Has Mr. Giuliani had any communication with Jared Kushner, while he was serving as CEO of Kushner Companies or afterwards, regarding the pending EB-5 regulations? 8. Reuters reported that Ding Ying, the founder and president of Qiaowai, the Chinese migration agency used by Kushner Companies and U.S. Immigration Fund, attended the inauguration of President Trump and met with the President, his family, and members of his cabinet. Reuters did not find evidence that Ms. Ying or Qiaowai donated any money to the Trump inaugural committee. The company’s website stated that “[t]he fact that Ms, Ding has once again been invited to attend a presidential inauguration shows that the U.S. Congress values and approves of the Qiaowai group.”° a, To your knowledge, did Ms. Ying, or anyone affiliated with Qiaowai, provide any or all of the $100,000 that Nicholas Mastroianni IIT donated to the Trump inaugural committee, either in the form of a direct payment, fee discount, or any other form of transfer? If'so, how much? Use of EB-5 Development Incentives for Distressed Areas 9. The current default investment amount of $1 million is lowered to $500,000 in a targeted employment area (TEA), which is a rural area or an area with an unemployment rate of at least 150 percent of the national rate.*! However, this provision has been interpreted to allow “developers who propose projects in wealthy urban areas, such as Manhattan and even Beverly Hills, to qualify for {the] incentives that are supposed to be reserved for 2 Javier C. Hernandez and Jesse Drucker, “How to Woo Chinese Investors: With Visa Offers and the Tramp Name,” The New York Times (May 19, 2017), available at htps://vw.nytimes.com/2017/05/19/business/kushner- trump’china-green-cards html Greenberg Traurig, “Biography: Rudolph W. Giuliani,” available at hitp./www.gtlaw.com/People/Rudolph: Giuliani, Javier C, Hernandez and Jesse Drucker, “How to Woo Chinese Investors: With Visa Offers and the Trump Name,” The New York Times (May 19, 2017), availabe at hips: /\ww.nytimes.com/201 7/05! 9/businessushnet= srump-china-green-cards him. °° Alexandra Haney, “Behind Kushner Companies, @ Chinese agency (May 12,2017), available at hitp:/vww.teuters.com/article/as-china-hushner-qiaWA NUS. § 115300X5). rts visa-for-investment rules,” Reuters insight-idUSKBN L882E1 Laurent Morali June 1, 2017 Page 7 of 9 [the] poorer areas.”* In a statement before the Senate Judiciary Committee last year, the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights described the misuse of TEAS as a civil rights issue, and observed that “the EB-5 Program has become a ‘bait and switch’ for the thousands of blighted communities it was meant to serve.” This economic gerrymandering—with census tracts stitched together to connect a project’s actual location with distressed areas to meet the requisite unemployment rate to qualify as a TEA—is now the norm. The Government Accountability Office reviewed a sample of EB-5 petitions filed in 2015* and found that 97 percent of petitioners were investing in projects that claimed to be in a high unemployment area. Of those, 90 percent needed to stitch together multiple census tracts (or census block groups) to reach the statutorily required unemployment rate. a, There is concern about the manner in which Kushner Companies’ EB-5 projects appear to qualify as high unemployment areas. The Washington Post reported yesterday that the TEA map for Trump Bay Street “stretched nearly four miles and included some of the city’s poorest and most crime-ridden neighborhoods [while it] excluded some wealthy neighborhoods only blocks away.”°* The report included a similar map for One Journal Plaza. Are the TEA maps for the two Kushner Companies’ projects as reported in the Washington Post accurate? b. Ithas been reported that Kushner Companies may also seek EB-5 investment for 666 Fifth Avenue,™ a building that, according to a Bloomberg report, has you “casting about for a savior” due to escalating fees and rising debt costs.” Yet this building is located in Midtown Manhattan, one of the most affluent neighborhoods in the country, Please provide any anticipated TEA map, with reference to the census tracts used to meet the requisite unemployment rate. awn Boburg, “Changes to Visa Program could set back Kushner family’s real estate company,” The Washington Post (May 1, 2017), available at htips:/ww..ashingtonpost.conv/national/kushner-Fanily-

    You might also like