Professional Documents
Culture Documents
79]||ClickheretodownloadfreeAndroidapplicationforthisjournal
Review Article
Key words: Blood transfusion, damage control resuscitation, massive transfusion protocol,
packed red blood cells, plasma, platelets, trauma resuscitation
How to cite this article: Ramakrishnan VT, Cattamanchi S. Transfusion practices in trauma. Indian J Anaesth 2014;58:609-15.
to concerns for safety and also due to the scarce and ischemia, known to be allied with trauma, which
resources.[10] Unfortunately, this change occurred promotes the release of activated protein C, leading
without any major retrospective studies or randomized to depletion of plasminogen activator inhibitor and
controlled trials on MT. Component therapy does inhibition of the systemic anticoagulation, clotting
convey benefits in financial, logistical and inventory cascade and hyperfibrinolysis.[17]
management. It is uncertain if component therapy is
better or even comparable to whole blood transfusion Shaz etal. in a recent casecontrol study of ETIC
in a MT patient.[2] patients found no difference in thrombin or fibrin
generation between the cases and the control had no
People did not adapt well to the component therapy, difference in the amount of fibrinolysis.[18] Patients
and there was confusion as to how to use it in MT. with ETIC were administered more crystalloids in
In 1970s and 1980s, this resulted in unintentional the prehospital phase and concluded that ETIC is
haemodilution as part of MT, which led to a secondary to traumainduced coagulopathy that occurs
vicious cycle of problems such as coagulopathy, early before patient reaches hospital. Coagulopathy of
acidosis and hypothermia, known as lethal triad trauma(both ETIC and traumainduced coagulopathy)
of trauma.[11] During the same period, it became a are concomitant with a significant risk of bleeding
common practice to administer significant amounts and high mortality. Care ought to be taken to decrease
of crystalloid before admission, leading to abdominal this risk that can be achieved by significantly
compartment syndrome, acute respiratory distress reducing the quantity of crystalloids that are initially
syndrome, and multiorgan failure.[12] Clinicians in administered.[18]
the late 1990s, realised the lethal effects of excess
crystalloid administration and began restricting its Ley et al. found out that receiving intravenous
use.[13] crystalloid >1.5 litres in the emergency department
(ED) is an independent risk factor for mortality.[19]
Retrospective data from recent war experiences Other major factors like Glasgow coma scale<8, injury
recommend that whole blood is clinically superior to severity scores>16, age>80years and hypotension,
component therapy in severely traumatised patient were also found to be the causes of increased mortality
requiring MT.[10] Since whole blood is not easily in trauma patients. Elderly patients receiving a higher
available in major hospitals; clinicians are widely volume of crystalloids(>3 L) are associated with
using damage control resuscitation(DCR) practices higher mortality rates.[19]
with the increased ratios of plasma: Platelets: PRBCs
during transfusion.[7] This review will focus on latest James etal. in a recent study regarding the use of either
transfusion practices in trauma along with DCR. crystalloid or colloids in early trauma patients in South
Africa, observed that initial resuscitation with colloids
TRAUMAINDUCED COAGULOPATHY instead of crystalloids, after a penetrating injury, had
less renal injury and decreased lactate levels.[20]
Traumainduced coagulopathy is a condition in
which various elements like acidosis, hypothermia, FIBRINOGENS
haemodilution and consumption of clotting factors
from transfusion of crystalloids and PRBCs play a Thousand milligrams(mg) of fibrinogen are present
crucial role.[14] It is a significant predictor of blood in a unit of whole blood, so the loss of one unit of
utilisation and traumarelated mortality and is whole blood, dissipates 1000 mg of fibrinogen. This
iatrogenic.[15] loss is usually, restored with transfusion of one unit
of both PRBC and fresh frozen plasma(FFP), where
This iatrogenic coagulopathy is preceded by early 1 unit of FFP contains only 500 mg of fibrinogen
traumainduced coagulopathy(ETIC) which presents in it. So in later stages, it is necessary to add more
with prolonged PT on admission. One theory suggests fibrinogen to restore the deficit. Cryoprecipitate
that ETIC is caused due to the release of tissue factor derived from coldthawed human plasma is transfused
from the actual injury, which subsequently causes to restore the fibrinogen deficit. At the end of an MT,
thrombin and fibrin production and utilisation causing ten units of cryoprecipitates are transfused to restore
disseminated intravascular coagulation.[16] Alternate the fibrinogen deficit as ten units of cryoprecipitates
theory suggests that ETIC may be due to hyperperfusion contains 2.5 g of fibrinogens.[2]
Stinger etal. has shown that a high fibrinogen: PRBC are available and where speed of resuscitation is
ratio(>0.2 g of fibrinogen: PRBC) was concomitant paramount like acute major trauma or massive
with survival to discharge after an injury.[21] One unit of haemorrhage. They provide more rapid restoration of
cryoprecipitate contains 0.25 g of fibrinogen, and this circulating volume with a smaller infused volume than
ratio can be obtained by transfusing cryoprecipitate: crystalloids. Although studies comparing synthetic
PRBC in a 1:1 ratio. In clinical practice in the ED, colloids to crystalloids confirmed that the colloid
for every ten units of PRBCs transfused, transfuse was a better volume expander and maintained or
ten units of cryoprecipitates. Shaz etal., has shown restored serum protein levels, however also confirmed
transfusion of cryoprecipitate and PRBCs in the ratio that colloids had no significant reduction in organ
of 1:1 has higher 24hour, and 30day survival after dysfunction or mortality.[20,26,27] Given the much higher
MT in trauma.[22] costs of colloids and the greater risk of renal injury
and death with them, resuscitation should focus on
PLATELETS crystalloid solutions.
The current US military resuscitation practice,[33] and stored at 4C for 5days after thawing.[36] In the
established by the Army Surgeon General, is to use ED refrigerator, thawed AB plasma is stored alongside
DCR approach as the primary resuscitation method emergency release type O blood, which allows both
in severely traumatised casualties, using 1:1:1 FFP: products(PRBCs and plasma) to be used immediately
PRBCs: Platelets. This clinical policy was developed and even concurrently when a MTP is activated.
based on a study by Perkins etal. concentrating on AMTP improves patient survival and also reduce
platelet ratios in casualties during recent conflicts, clinician stress.[11] In order for a MTP to be activated,
which evidently defined the survival benefits.[23] to avert early haemorrhagic death, it is imperative
to envisage who will need an MT. Avast majority of
Lower volume or hypotensive resuscitation stratagem trauma patients do not require a MTP to be activated
is employed in DCR, prior to haemorrhage control, in as only 2% of civilian trauma patients need an MT.[8]
order to avoid popping the clot as the blood pressure Overuse of a MTP can lead to blood products wastage
rises rapidly with resuscitation. Instead of large and also cause TRALI when administering blood
amounts of crystalloids and PRBCs very early in trauma components, mainly plasma.[37]
resuscitation, DCR methodology, replaces the lost blood
with PRBCs, plasma and platelets in the ratio of 1:1:1, It is cumbersome to predict who will require a MTP and
in order to minimise the exacerbating multifactorial when to be activated. Dente etal. in early predictors
traumainduced coagulopathy. DCR is quickly becoming of MT study reported 27% overtriage rate in whom a
the primary resuscitation technique in many trauma MTP was activated, but MT was not administered.[38]
centres in resuscitating traumatised patients.[2] The study observed that all trauma patients with a
mulitcavity or a transpelvic gunshot wound required
MASSIVE TRANSFUSION PROTOCOLS MT. In trauma patients with isolated abdomen or
thorax gunshot injuries, many patients did not require
Many hospitals implemented massive transfusion MT. Conversely, a hypotensive patient with a systolic
protocol(MTPs), as mortality improved with changes blood pressure<90 mmHg and a patient in acidosis
in blood products,[34] but the principle remains the with a base deficit more than ten units are robust
same, even though it varies between institutions prognosticators for MT.[38]
practicing MTPs. The blood bank delivers several
rounds of 1:1:1 PRBCs, FFP and platelets to the Due to practice variation at different trauma centres, a
patients once MTP is activated and will continue to do universal criteria to activate MTP may not be possible,
so until deactivated.[11] and the ultimate decision to activate a MTP relies
on the judgment and experience of the Emergency
Riskin etal. observed that with the implementation physician or trauma surgeon, who heads the trauma
of MTP, deaths from trauma have decreased team.[38]
significantly.[35] Expeditious availability of blood
products due to MTP, lead to early transfusion of FUTURE
PRBCs, which decreased the time for first plasma and
platelet transfusion, and increased survival of trauma Point of care coagulation testing
patients [Figure1].[35] Enhanced communication and A smart substitute to formuladriven methodology
organisation within MTP, empowering prompt delivery to blood transfusion in trauma is point of care(POC)
of blood packs from the blood bank was fundamental coagulation testing. POC haemoglobin, platelet
to the success of the protocol.[11] Upon arrival to the ED, count, fibrinogen level, prothrombin time,
an MTP should enable emergency physician or trauma thromboelastometry and thromboelastography
surgeon immediately to administer 1:1:1:1 ratio of are currently available and used in some trauma
PRBCs, plasma, platelets and cryoprecipitates, instead centres.[11] In majority of patients having severe
of administering PRBCs first and at a later stage giving traumatic injury, but not enough to activate a MTP,
plasma.[11] This means that in the ED, thawed plasma POC coagulation testing is now used. In trauma
has to be readily available for administration in the patients, POC coagulation testing may become a
first round of the MTP.[36] substitute to formuladriven MTPs as progress is made
in the speed and accuracy of these technologies.[11]
Thawed plasma or FFP is fresh plasma, taken from a POC testing is not yet a gold standard diagnostic test
unit of whole blood, frozen within 8 h of collection, and is not used in most hospitals. Further studies
Figure 1: Massive Transfusion Protocol (Figure 1. Stanford Massive Transfusion Protocol.[35] Reprinted from the Journal of the American
College of Surgeons, 209 (2), Daniel J. Riskin, Thomas C. Tsai, Loren Riskin, et al., Massive Transfusion Protocols: The Role of Aggressive
Resuscitation Versus Product Ratio in Mortality Reduction, 198-205, Copyright (2009), with permission from Elsevier). ABG Arterial blood
gases; CBC Complete blood count; DIC Disseminated intravascular coagulation; FFP Fresh frozen plasma; INR Internationalized
normalized ration; MTP Massive transfution protocol; PRBCs Packed red blood cells; PT Prothrombin time; PTT Partial thromboplastin
time; PLT Platelets and rFVIIa recombinant factor VII a
1:1:1 ratio, with thawed plasma, PRBCs, and platelets, USA: Copyright 2001 by Thieme Medical Publishers, Inc.;
2001.
limited use of crystalloids and rapid haemorrhage 17. BrohiK, CohenMJ, GanterMT, SchultzMJ, LeviM,
control will improve their survival. These principles MackersieRC, etal. Acute coagulopathy of trauma:
of DCR should only be utilised in resuscitation of Hypoperfusion induces systemic anticoagulation and
hyperfibrinolysis. JTrauma 2008;64:12117.
patients with haemorrhagic shock and lifethreatening 18. ShazBH, WinklerAM, JamesAB, HillyerCD, MacLeodJB.
injuries, and one should be cautious not to overuse Pathophysiology of early traumainduced coagulopathy:
DCR principles. Accurate models to predict which Emerging evidence for hemodilution and coagulation factor
depletion. JTrauma 2011;70:14017.
trauma patient will benefit from DCR and who require 19. LeyEJ, ClondMA, SrourMK, BarnajianM, MirochaJ,
MT is the need of the hour and is an area where MarguliesDR, etal. Emergency department crystalloid
resuscitation of 1.5 L or more is associated with increased
future research is required with more prospective
mortality in elderly and nonelderly trauma patients. JTrauma
randomized trials. 2011;70:398400.
20. JamesMF, MichellWL, JoubertIA, NicolAJ, NavsariaPH,
REFERENCES GillespieRS. Resuscitation with hydroxyethyl starch
improves renal function and lactate clearance in penetrating
trauma in a randomized controlled study: The FIRST
1. HolcombJB, McMullinNR, PearseL, CarusoJ, WadeCE,
trial(Fluids in Resuscitation of Severe Trauma). Br J Anaesth
OetjenGerdesL, etal. Causes of death in U.S. special 2011;107:693702.
operations forces in the global war on terrorism: 20012004. 21. StingerHK, SpinellaPC, PerkinsJG, GrathwohlKW, SalinasJ,
Ann Surg 2007;245:98691. MartiniWZ, etal. The ratio of fibrinogen to red cells transfused
2. HolcombJB. Optimal use of blood products in severely injured affects survival in casualties receiving massive transfusions at
trauma patients. Hematology Am Soc Hematol Educ Program an army combat support hospital. JTrauma 2008;64:S7985.
2010;2010:4659. 22. ShazBH, DenteCJ, NicholasJ, MacLeodJB, YoungAN,
3. CothrenCC, MooreEE, HedegaardHB, MengK. Epidemiology EasleyK, etal. Increased number of coagulation products in
of urban trauma deaths: A comprehensive reassessment relationship to red blood cell products transfused improves
10years later. World J Surg 2007;31:150711. mortality in trauma patients. Transfusion 2010;50:493500.
4. GruenRL, JurkovichGJ, McIntyreLK, FoyHM, MaierRV. 23. PerkinsJG, CapAP, SpinellaPC, BlackbourneLH,
Patterns of errors contributing to trauma mortality: Lessons GrathwohlKW, RepineTB, etal. An evaluation of the impact of
learned from 2,594 deaths. Ann Surg 2006;244:37180. apheresis platelets used in the setting of massively transfused
5. EspositoTJ, SanddalTL, ReynoldsSA, SanddalND. Effect trauma patients. JTrauma 2009;66:S7784.
of a voluntary trauma system on preventable death and 24. SpinellaPC. Warm fresh whole blood transfusion for severe
inappropriate care in a rural state. JTrauma 2003;54:6639. hemorrhage: U.S. military and potential civilian applications.
6. MaegeleM, LeferingR, YucelN, TjardesT, RixenD, PaffrathT, Crit Care Med 2008;36:S3405.
etal. Early coagulopathy in multiple injury: An analysis 25. ArmandR, HessJR. Treating coagulopathy in trauma patients.
from the German trauma registry on 8724patients. Injury Transfus Med Rev 2003;17:22331.
2007;38:298304. 26. MarikPE, IglesiasJ, MainiB. Gastric intramucosal pH
7. HolcombJB, JenkinsD, RheeP, JohannigmanJ, MahoneyP, changes after volume replacement with hydroxyethyl starch
MehtaS, etal. Damage control resuscitation: Directly or crystalloid in patients undergoing elective abdominal aortic
addressing the early coagulopathy of trauma. JTrauma aneurysm repair. JCrit Care 1997;12:515.
2007;62:30710. 27. ShatneyCH, DeepikaK, MilitelloPR, MajerusTC, DawsonRB.
8. ComoJJ, DuttonRP, ScaleaTM, EdelmanBB, HessJR. Blood Efficacy of hetastarch in the resuscitation of patients with
transfusion rates in the care of acute trauma. Transfusion multisystem trauma and shock. Arch Surg 1983;118:8049.
2004;44:80913. 28. ShakurH, RobertsI, BautistaR, CaballeroJ, CoatsT, etal.
9. MaloneDL, HessJR, FingerhutA. Massive transfusion Effects of tranexamic acid on death, vascular occlusive events,
practices around the globe and a suggestion for a common and blood transfusion in trauma patients with significant
massive transfusion protocol. JTrauma 2006;60:S916. haemorrhage(CRASH2): Arandomised, placebocontrolled
10. SpinellaPC, PerkinsJG, GrathwohlKW, BeekleyAC, trial. Lancet 2010;376:2332.
HolcombJB. Warm fresh whole blood is independently 29. FiechtnerBK, NuttallGA, JohnsonME, DongY,
associated with improved survival for patients with SujirattanawimolN, Oliver WC Jr, etal. Plasma tranexamic
combatrelated traumatic injuries. JTrauma 2009;66:S6976. acid concentrations during cardiopulmonary bypass. Anesth
11. MillerTE. New evidence in trauma resuscitationis 1:1:1 the Analg 2001;92:11316.
answer? Perioper Med(Lond) 2013;2:13. 30. HorrowJC, Van RiperDF, StrongMD, GrunewaldKE,
12. MooreFA, McKinleyBA, MooreEE. The next generation in ParmetJL. The doseresponse relationship of tranexamic acid.
shock resuscitation. Lancet 2004;363:198896. Anesthesiology 1995;82:38392.
13. CottonBA, GuyJS, Morris JA Jr, AbumradNN. The cellular, 31. BorgmanMA, SpinellaPC, PerkinsJG, GrathwohlKW, RepineT,
metabolic, and systemic consequences of aggressive fluid BeekleyAC, etal. The ratio of blood products transfused
resuscitation strategies. Shock 2006;26:11521. affects mortality in patients receiving massive transfusions at
14. National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute Acute Respiratory a combat support hospital. JTrauma 2007;63:80513.
Distress Syndrome(ARDS) Clinical Trials Network, 32. HolcombJB, WadeCE, MichalekJE, ChisholmGB, ZarzabalLA,
WiedemannHP, WheelerAP, BernardGR, ThompsonBT, SchreiberMA, etal. Increased plasma and platelet to red blood
HaydenD, etal. Comparison of two fluidmanagement cell ratios improves outcome in 466 massively transfused
strategies in acute lung injury. NEngl J Med 2006;354:256475. civilian trauma patients. Ann Surg 2008;248:44758.
15. EddyVA, Morris JA Jr, CullinaneDC. Hypothermia, 33. Impact of policy change on US army combat transfusion
coagulopathy, and acidosis. Surg Clin North Am practices. Available from: http://www.usaisr.amedd.army.mil/
2000;80:84554. cpgs/DmgCntrlResus0903.pdf.[Last accessed on 2014 July 01].
16. Disseminated intravascular coagulation in trauma patients. 34. SchusterKM, DavisKA, LuiFY, MaerzLL, KaplanLJ. The
Seminars in Thrombosis and Haemostasis. NewYork, NY, status of massive transfusion protocols in United States
trauma centers: Massive transfusion or massive confusion? 37. LinY, SawCL, HannachB, GoldmanM. Transfusionrelated
Transfusion 2010;50:154551. acute lung injury prevention measures and their impact at
35. RiskinDJ, TsaiTC, RiskinL, HernandezBoussardT, PurtillM, Canadian Blood Services. Transfusion 2012;52:56774.
MaggioPM, etal. Massive transfusion protocols: The role 38. DenteCJ, ShazBH, NicholasJM, HarrisRS, WyrzykowskiAD,
of aggressive resuscitation versus product ratio in mortality FickeBW, etal. Early predictors of massive transfusion in
reduction. JAm Coll Surg 2009;209:198205. patients sustaining torso gunshot wounds in a civilian level I
36. MuradMH, StubbsJR, GandhiMJ, WangAT, PaulA, ErwinPJ, trauma center. JTrauma 2010;68:298304.
etal. The effect of plasma transfusion on morbidity and
mortality: A systematic review and metaanalysis. Transfusion
Source of Support: Nil, Conflict of Interest: None declared
2010;50:137083.