Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CONTENTS
1 INTRODUCTION 4
2 HEAT PRODUCTION 6
3 HEAT SUPPLY 8
5 HEAT RECOVERY 10
6 OTHER ISSUES 12
ARCHIVED DOCUMENT
ENERGY EFFICIENCY IN SWIMMING POOLS
INTRODUCTION
This Guide has been developed INTRODUCTION Energy costs represent a substantial proportion of
to help pool centre managers Swimming pool halls are unlike any other type of the overall operating costs of a typical pool
and operators ensure that building. They house large volumes of water which usually 25%. Energy efficiency is a practical way of
energy is managed efficiently must be continuously filtered, treated and heated. reducing operating costs without lowering the
at their facilities. With the In this humid environment the fabric of the standard of service to users.
complex range of building building needs to be protected through adequate
services in these centres, and ventilation. Consequently, swimming pools Where the energy is used
their large demand on energy, consume more energy per unit area than other The energy used for different purposes in a pool
it is important that building types. For example, they use five times as hall, and the resulting costs, are shown in figure 1.
opportunities for energy and much energy per square metre as offices. Therefore
cost savings are highlighted. swimming pool design and operation call for extra Design integration
All of the technologies vigilance on the part of management. Environmental services, including pool water
discussed in this Guide have treatment, form a core element of the overall
been tried and tested, and Typically, indoor pools are in constant use they building design. The following services should be
have resulted in substantial are open almost every day of the year. They are carefully integrated into the design:
energy savings to the industry. voluminous buildings, and they: heating
contain large open areas of warm water which ventilation
are constantly being agitated by bathers or electrical services
water features pool water treatment
have constantly high internal temperatures domestic water supply.
(often up to 30C)
need substantial ventilation systems to In addition, the architectural and structural
maintain comfortable conditions, to help aspects of the building should be integrated with,
regulate evaporation from the pool surface and and serve to enhance, the energy-efficient design
to protect the fabric of the building. features of the swimming pool.
Figure 1
(a) Proportion of energy used in an indoor pool (b) Cost of energy used in an indoor pool (%)
ARCHIVED DOCUMENT 5
ENERGY EFFICIENCY IN SWIMMING POOLS
INTRODUCTION
Option appraisal
Typical annual energy use
Given a pool which is consuming more energy
(kWh/m2)
than desired as indicated by the typical energy
figures (table 1), it is important to consider ways Sports centre with pool:
in which it can be made more energy efficient.
Good Fair Poor
Assuming that all the plant is working correctly,
and the appropriate operational procedures are <510 510-745 >745
adhered to, then investment in energy efficiency
Dry sports centre:
measures must be considered. Energy efficiency
measures will also need to be considered during Good Fair Poor
refurbishment for example, when ageing plant
<290 290-410 >410
may need to be replaced or when specifying a
new pool. (Source: Energy Consumption Guide 51, Energy efficiency in
sports and recreation buildings, p2)
would be:
combined heat and power (CHP)
condensing boilers Typical pool operating costs (%)
ventilation heat recovery
variable ventilation rates Labour 35
pool water heat recovery.
Interest on capital 25-35
Each of these offer significant improvements in
energy efficiency and could produce attractive Energy 25-30
pay-back periods. However, because of the complex
nature of the energy use in a swimming pool, care Maintenance, rates and supplies 10-15
must be taken when calculating the benefits of
energy efficiency measures. If the cost-effectiveness Table 2
of each of these is taken in isolation it may give a
misleading impression of the benefits achieved measures. In the first stage the individual pay-back
when they are combined. For example, the cost- periods of each measure are calculated and the
effectiveness of a CHP system may be lessened as a most cost-effective measure selected as a priority.
consequence of reduced electrical and heating The second stage then involves the addition of
demand resulting from installing variable speed the less cost-effective measures in turn, and the
ventilation fans with heat recovery. calculation of the overall pay-back period for the
package of measures. By this means the
To ensure that the most cost-effective techniques incremental value of each measure taken in the
are selected, it is essential that the full range of context of other measures is more accurately
energy efficiency measures are investigated by a determined, and the risk of adopting measures
process of option appraisal. based on unrealistic pay-back periods is FURTHER READING
eliminated. This exercise should be carried out Energy Consumption
It is recommended that a two stage approach is in consultation with a competent building Guide 51
adopted to assess the benefits of a number of services engineer.
ARCHIVED DOCUMENT 6
ENERGY EFFICIENCY IN SWIMMING POOLS
HEAT PRODUCTION
DESIGN ISSUES
CO2 emissions per unit of delivered
Fuel
energy (kg/kWh)
The most important factors to be considered in
the selection of fuel and the means of heat
Gas 0.19
production are:
Oil 0.28
the availability and convenience of the fuel
Coal 0.32
the efficiency of the means of heat
Electricity 0.63
production
the price. (Source: Energy Consumption Guide 51, p6)
Table 3
Other factors that should influence the choice of
fuel are: Typical seasonal efficiencies* (%)
the environmental issues
the methods of handling the fuel CHP >75
the level of maintenance associated with Gas boiler 80
the fuel Condensing boiler 90
the means of production and distribution. Solid fuel 75
Oil boiler 75
Unless there is some particular local energy source Electric heaters 100 at point of
that warrants consideration (such as waste, process use (only 30% in
energy, or renewable sources such as solar or wind primary energy
power), the choice will normally be restricted to terms)
coal, oil, natural gas or bottled liquefied petroleum *Seasonal efficiency is defined as the average thermal efficiency
gas (LPG), or electricity. (For most pools, coal is over a year under all operating conditions
unlikely to be appropriate because of the Table 4
requirements of storage, handling and maintenance.)
The usual methods of producing the required
The environmental effects of different fuel heat are:
options should be taken into account (table 3). CHP units
Note that electricity is not a primary fuel but has condensing boilers
to be produced and distributed, thereby modern standard or modular boilers
entailing substantial energy loss and carbon standard boilers
dioxide (CO2) emissions. heat pumps.
The method in which the fuel is used will be the A list of typical seasonal efficiencies is given in
next determining factor in energy efficiency. table 4. CHP units produce heat and electrical
power from the same unit using a single fuel
Heat production source. The maximum efficiency of CHP units can
The main heating requirement for a swimming exceed 90% but to achieve this they need to run
pool is to heat the pool water and the pool hall air at full load for as many hours as possible
supply. The most efficient way to supply and provided there is sufficient demand for both heat
control this heat is by means of heat exchangers and electrical power. Swimming pools often
using heated water of low or medium temperature. provide the ideal circumstances for this.
ARCHIVED DOCUMENT
7
ENERGY EFFICIENCY IN SWIMMING POOLS
HEAT PRODUCTION
Condensing boilers can be particularly effective in ensure that it is being bought at the most
pool installations and payback on the extra cost beneficial tariff. Check:
can be achieved in 2-3 years when compared with the price being paid for fuels
conventional non-condensing boilers. that relevant tariffs continue to be competitive
whether there have been any changes to the
A combination of these options can be used. For pool or its method of operation.
example, CHP could fulfil the baseload
requirement, with condensing or modular boilers Heat production
to cater for the peak loads. It is essential that the heat production plant is
operated efficiently and is properly maintained. FURTHER READING
Heat pumps are probably most cost-effective as The efficiency of heat-generating plant can be Good Practice Guides 137,
part of a heat recovery/dehumidification system. reduced substantially if burners and control 144, 187; Energy
equipment are not serviced and adjusted regularly. Consumption Guide 51;
OPERATIONAL ISSUES Advice on maintenance in sports centres is given in Good Practice Case Studies
Fuel Good Practice Guide 137. CHP units in particular 43, 74, 280, 281; CIBSE CHP
Provided the type of fuel used remains the most require regular specialist servicing if they are to be Information Pack
appropriate, regular checks should be carried out to reliable and operate at maximum efficiency.
ARCHIVED DOCUMENT 8
ENERGY EFFICIENCY IN SWIMMING POOLS
HEAT SUPPLY
Shell and tube heat exchangers have traditionally It is essential that the temperature of each separate
LEGIONELLA been used in swimming pools. However, plate heat pool or water area is:
When considering energy saving exchangers are now more efficient, and are easier checked several times a day and in various
measures for domestic hot water, to control and maintain. It is important that they locations
it is essential that requirements are selected carefully and are matched to the adjusted to the optimum level for the activity
for the control of Legionella (by appropriate load (pool water is normally heated at in progress
maintaining sufficiently high a rate of 0.5C per hour). set to the lowest temperature compatible with
water temperatures) are not the comfort and satisfaction of users.
compromised. Full guidance is Domestic hot water
given in CIBSE Technical Typically there will be a considerable requirement Automatic control settings should be checked
Memorandum 13 for domestic hot water (DHW) for pre-swim and against actual temperature readings to ensure that
the relevant controls remain correctly calibrated.
ARCHIVED DOCUMENT 9
ENERGY EFFICIENCY IN SWIMMING POOLS
The pool hall air quality will be continually Variable-volume fans or variable fresh
reduced by the heat, humidity and a mixture of air/recirculation air dampers generally
chemicals which pass from the pool water by achieve this. Where air circulation
means of evaporation and heat transfer. The pool quantities are variable, care must be
hall ventilation system is usually the only means taken to ensure that, within the pool
of removing contaminants, so it is critical that it hall, the air distribution is not impaired
provides adequate ventilation. and that air quality is not reduced below
comfort levels.
Experience over many years has indicated that the
optimum balance between pool water and air OPERATIONAL ISSUES
conditions is achieved by: The ventilation system must be operated
maintaining the pool air at the same at optimum levels at all times to achieve Variable ventilation
temperature as, or slightly higher than, the maximum energy efficiency.
pool water (up to +1C) Make sure that the operation of fans, filters,
maintaining the humidity at about 60% heat exchangers and dampers remains within
relative humidity. the design specification (Good Practice Guide
137 gives details).
It is generally recommended that the air Adjust the temperature and humidity if necessary.
temperature should not exceed 30C, and that the Adjust the ventilation air supply when
relative humidity should be maintained between necessary.
50% and 70%. Cover the pool when it is not in use.
The optimum ventilation rate depends on a wide Where variable ventilation volume or partial
range of operating conditions, including: recirculation systems are employed, or there are
variations in water temperature changes in the operation or occupancy of the
water quality pool, it may be necessary to check and, where
number of bathers required, manually override any automatic control
water agitation systems for that period of operation. FURTHER READING
water features Sports Council Guidance
external conditions. Pool covers (see Good Practice Case Study 76), Notes: Swimming Pools
where available, should always be used when the building services
An effective, well-distributed and mechanically pool is unoccupied in order to minimise GPG 137, GPCS 76
controlled supply and extract system will be evaporation and allow some air recirculation or
required. This will ensure that appropriate reduced ventilation.
conditions are maintained throughout the Table 7
occupied zone and that air movement is
maintained within acceptable limits for bather
Recommended conditions
comfort. Conditions in a pool usually vary so
Air temperature: typically 30C
frequently that a prescriptive design to suit all
possible situations is not feasible. Relative humidity: 50-70%
Ventilation (general guideline): 10 litres per second per square metre of total pool
hall area (water plus wet surrounds)
4-6 air changes per hour standard use 8-10 air changes with extensive water features
Minimum 12 litres per person per second (includes all occupants)
100% fresh air operation should be available
ARCHIVED DOCUMENT 10
ENERGY EFFICIENCY IN SWIMMING POOLS
HEAT RECOVERY
Definitions DESIGN ISSUES cooler inlet air. Supply and extract routes must
Sensible heat is the heat Most of the energy load of a swimming pool is be immediately adjacent to each other.
associated with a change in used to heat the pool water and pool air. In order
temperature to control pool hall air quality large amounts of Run-around coils are probably the most
Latent heat is the heat heated moist air are expelled from the hall. Heat flexible type of heat recovery device, although
associated with a change of from pool water is also discharged during the typical efficiency is only about 60%. Two heat
state (eg condensation) backwashing of filters, or when water is dumped in exchange coils, one in the supply duct and
order to dilute with fresh make-up water. one in the extract duct, are linked by pipework
Considerable scope therefore exists for the use of carrying a heat transfer fluid. The fluid is
heat recovery systems. pumped between the two, transferring heat
from the warmer extract air stream to the
The most important means of heat recovery in a cooler inlet. The supply and extract systems
pool is usually the pool hall ventilation system. do not need to be close to each other,
making this system particularly flexible and
Sensible heat recovery devices especially suitable for refurbishment and
The simplest forms of heat reclamation systems for improvement projects.
pool hall ventilation are sensible heat recovery
devices. There are three main types. The thermal wheel system achieves heat
transfer using a rotating disc-shaped
The cross-flow heat exchanger, capable of heat-retentive honeycomb matrix, through
recovering up to 75% of the sensible heat, is which air can pass. The disc rotates through
the most efficient of the three types. It both supply and extract air streams at about
comprises a series of parallel plates between 20 rpm. Heat is transferred via the wheel from
the supply and extract ducts, which allow heat the warmer extract duct to the cooler supply
exchange from the warmer extract air to the air system. This system requires the supply
and extract ducts to be close to each other and
occupies more space than other systems. Heat
transfer efficiencies of up to 75% have been
achieved but, because of its moving parts, this
device generally requires more maintenance
than alternative types of heat recovery device.
ARCHIVED DOCUMENT 11
ENERGY EFFICIENCY IN SWIMMING POOLS
HEAT RECOVERY
ARCHIVED DOCUMENT 12
ENERGY EFFICIENCY IN SWIMMING POOLS
OTHER ISSUES
ARCHIVED DOCUMENT 13
ENERGY EFFICIENCY IN SWIMMING POOLS
EXAMPLES
Pool conditions:
pool water temperature: 29C
pool air temperature: 30C, 55%
relative humidity
operating hours: 100 per week/5200
per year.
SPENBOROUGH POOL
This pool was originally built in 1969. It
has a 33 m x 12 m main pool with a small
teaching pool of 12 m x 7 m. Substantial
programmes of energy efficiency
refurbishment work were carried out in 1988
and 1995.
Pool conditions:
main pool water temperature: 28-29C
learner pool temperature: 29-30C.
pool air: 30-32C, 60% relative humidity
operating hours: 94 per week/4888
per year.
ARCHIVED DOCUMENT 14
ENERGY EFFICIENCY IN SWIMMING POOLS
FURTHER READING
ARCHIVED DOCUMENT
15
ARCHIVED DOCUMENT
The Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions Energy Efficiency Energy Consumption Guides: compare energy use in specific
Best Practice programme provides impartial, authoritative information on energy efficiency processes, operations, plant and building types.
techniques and technologies in industry and buildings. This information is disseminated
Good Practice: promotes proven energy efficient techniques
through publications, videos and software, together with seminars, workshops and other through Guides and Case Studies.
events. Publications within the Best Practice programme are shown opposite.
New Practice: monitors first commercial applications of new
For further information on: energy efficiency measures.
Buildings-related projects contact: Industrial projects contact:
Future Practice: reports on joint R&D ventures into new energy
Enquiries Bureau Energy Efficiency Enquiries Bureau efficiency measures.
BRECSU ETSU
General Information: describes concepts and approaches yet
BRE Harwell, Oxfordshire
to be established as good practice.
Garston, Watford, WD2 7JR OX11 0RA
Tel 01923 664258 Tel 01235 436747 Fuel Efficiency Booklets: give detailed information on specific
Fax 01923 664787 Fax 01235 433066 technologies and techniques.
E-mail brecsuenq@bre.co.uk E-mail etsuenq@aeat.co.uk Introduction to Energy Efficiency: helps new energy managers
ARCHIVED DOCUMENT
Internet BRECSU http://www.bre.co.uk/brecsu/ understand the use and costs of heating, lighting etc.
Internet ETSU http://www.etsu.com/eebpp/home.htm CROWN COPYRIGHT FIRST PRINTED SEPTEMBER 1997