You are on page 1of 8

Towards a Methodology for 3D Content Models

The Reconstruction of Ancient Vaults for Maintenance and Structural Behaviour


in the logic of BIM management

Daniela Oreni, Raffaella Brumana, Branka Cuca


Department of Building Environment Science and Technology
Politecnico di Milano (POLIMI)
Milan, Italy
{daniela.oreni, raffaella.brumana, branka.cuca}@polimi.it

Abstract The aim of this paper is to identify elements that technologies: the objective is to orient the modelling
can contribute to elaborate a proper methodology for 3D processes to understand the geometric morphology, the
content model generation: the availability of advanced structural behaviour within the overall history of the
surveying technologies (Terrestrial Laser Scanner, transformation of the artefact. Potentials of enhancing 3D
Photogrammetry, Multispectral data integration) can have a content models are here discussed proposing to shift from a
great potential in generating knowledge, especially if simple surface logic to a 3D-Informative Object logic,
integrated by historical documentation on the ancient according to BIM approach [3]. Thus created 4D models
constructive technologies. In this sense the use of technological- could be managed and really used by professionals in
constructive analysis could better orient 3D Informative
everyday practice. during the project of restoration, planned
Object reconstruction. Such approach has been here applied to
conservation and maintenance programme. Different case
the vault structures: the main contribution was the
investigation of maintenance analysis and of structural studies have been considered in order to describe the
stability, supporting the comprehension of the behaviour of methodology and the results obtained on similar and
architectural elements within the overall framework of the different context. Section III illustrates the objective of
artefact. The logic of Building Information Models (BIM) addressing modelling techniques to meet the planned
approach, such as Object Content Model, has opened conservation aims, applied to the case study of the Royal
interesting scenarios to be investigated for the future, and that Villa in Monza (from here on Villa Reale): the development
could become more useful for the sites monitoring and for the of a continuous learning virtual site, implemented through
life cycle management within planned conservation processes. an open source geo-database (GeoDB), has been carried out
in an interdisciplinary framework on behalf of the Lombardy
Region. The Region has promoted and funded this initiative
Keywords - 3D Content Model, OrthoImage, Laser Scanner, with an aim to define a multi-scale methodology that could
BIM, Vault systems, Mainteinance, Structural behaviour, LCM be applied even to less famous architectural palaces in the
area, diminishing thus the costs and the investigation time.
The section IV explains the methodology of combining data
I. INTRODUCTION acquired on field through an accurate three-dimensional
survey of the vault system with historical documentation and
High geometric precision 3D models of ancient vaults thematic observation. In this manner, it is possible to
elaborated upon the exact thickness of the walls, the generate a geometric model that could derive information on
constructive materials and the arrangement of the elements, the different typologies of vault systems, on different
allow to support complex analysis on the state of constructional genesis of the vaults and on the constructive
maintenance of the buildings and on the stability of their methodologies used in the past. The two different
structures. Section II illustrates the usage of advanced constructive techniques adopted within Villa Reale have
surveying technologies and data processing, particularly been reconstructed: the case of brick block masonry cloister-
Terrestrial Laser Scanner (TLS) [1], surface analysis and vault and the case of a wooden vault of the central Dance
automatic 3D matching [2], and Multispectral Image data hall (barrel vault). The results have been used for learning,
integration, addressed to a reconstruction process able to dissemination and touristic promotion within the virtual
match geometric and thematic information. The main museum of the Villa Reale. The section V describes why the
objective of the research is to orient the representation and methodology proposed is time and cost scalable to many
data processing towards Object reconstruction useful to the objects disseminated across the region, characterized by
Life Cycle Management (LCM) of the architectural heritage. similar constructive methods. The process applied within the
The proposed methodology is based on an iterative teaching programme of Master Science Lab of Restoration
knowledge process obtained by connecting the geometric on a small palace (Palazzo Baldi Pallavicino in Cremona).
data coming from the surveys with original drawings and The case study shows a cross-relation between different data
with technological information provided by ancient manuals within a 4D-Object information model that allowed to
and joining them to better investigate the constructive enhance the comprehension of the complex result of the

978-1-4673-2565-3/12/$31.00 2012 IEEE 475


transformation across the centuries of the Palazzo Soldi. The The automatic texture acquisition [9], through Visual
case study of the vault system of the Rotonda of Besana in Modelling [10] and Virtual Reality [11], are progressively
Milan illustrates how the methodology helps the focusing on the central role of merging geometric properties
investigation of apparently familiar typology. with thematic information by multispectral data. Image
Segmentation, Spin-Images algorithms techniques, and
Potentials and critical aspect regarding the introduction of a homogeneous pattern analysis techniques will contribute to
simplified level of 3D item related to different information, feature extraction methodologies, that need to improve
is discussed in the Conclusion: the approach can contribute semantic and qualitative aspects already applied for 3D city
to overcome the production of underemployed simplified modelling [12]. The 3D vault surface model has been
models, improving the Life Cycle Management of the reconstructed using the laser scanner points (Rapidform
architecture, but it requires a deeper investigation on XO64); the 3D model reconstruction on the profiles for
complex object management and their assembling within a the Object generation has been obtained with AutoCad 3D
BIM logic. functionalities and with Rhino (case studies carried out by
II. FROM SURVEY TO SURFACE AND TOWARDS THE the students), in order to facilitate simplified object
OBJECT: 3D CONTENT INFORMATION MODEL IN A BIM generation process and elaboration within Revit BIM data
LOGIC management. In particular, 3D texturing techniques through
Multi Photo Matching algorithms [13] are on course of
The research carried out in the last decade demonstrates a development in order to test the possibility to extract 3D
progressive attention to the geometric content extraction Geotiff to be correlated to the 3D Item reconstructed form
from Laser Scans and image-based [4] surface measurement the laser scans.
for heritage documentation [5]. The algorithm
implementation [6] to obtain accurate automatic multi-image Mapping infrared data on TLS 3D models of faades and
matching, 3D reconstruction [7] and Multi Scans correlation vaults gave a lot of information on the overall object
approach [8], are progressively devoted to the Surface decoding. The objective was to obtain texturized
refinement by extracting edge and breaklines for Object architectural object items like facades, vaults, wooden
Recognition and Reconstruction (ORR). This approach horizontal structures, staircases within BIM models, in order
highlighting the potentials in representing 3D architectural to relate phenomena detection and planning purposes using
surfaces i.e. facades, intrados vault surfaces, mosaic floors, logic attribute DB (material-degree mapping, disruption,
painted walls. It seems that the context has become mature prevention, structural behaviour, building management in the
enough to increase the generation of informative objects time). The research now needs to be better oriented to
related one to the other. experiment and verify the transition from the Surface
towards a concept of an Object representation, able to
The laser scanner used for the surveys carried out upon support BIM model for different purposes: to enhance the
the following case studies is LeicaHDS6000 with an comprehension of the elements within the general model,
accuracy in the position measurement of 35mm, and in the allowing the connection to the different descriptive thematic
distance measurement of 2mm, 025m scan range, 125 database (constructive technologies, abacus of elements) in a
micro radians vertical and horizontal angle. The scans has logic of semantic content models. At the same time, some
been accurately geo-referenced on the point networks critical aspect will be represented by the assessment of the
through target tape and natural points for the cloud chaining suitability of BIM with respect to the complexity of the
using Leica Cyclone 7.1.1. The profiles and sections architectural heritage: BIM is based parametric simplified
extraction on the vaults and other elements such as external models [14] that should be further investigated when dealing
faade-walls have been processed within Leica Cloudwork. with the management of complex objects. Leica CloudWorx
Cloudworks, that is progressively addressing the logic of for Revit is a breakthrough plug-in for efficiently using as-
geospatial modelling, ensures the interoperability with BIM built point cloud data [15]. Point clouds can be directly
software such as Autodesk Revit2012. The Digital Surface imported within Revit for BIM modelling software to better
Models (DSMs) of the vault systems have been used in the support retrofitting design, construction and operations, and
case of highly decorated surfaces for the generation of lifecycle asset management of buildings.
orthoimages, starting from a photogrammetric image block
acquisition (terrain pixel acquisition: 12mm resolution (1/2 The acquisition of internal and external multiple scans
of the graphic error at the scale 1:20=2mm). geo-referenced through the Ground Control Points (GCPs)
and targets, allows to correlate and to decode the single
Cameras used were RolleiFlex6008 with focal length features reconstructed (i.e. vault, perimeter walls) and to
40mm for the first Noble floor of the central building of the relate them to the overall architecture. The reconstruction of
Villa and Canon D1, 35 and 50mm focal lenses for the the box elements of the single rooms (the wall surfaces, vault
rooms of the Noble floor in South Wing (elaboration on- surfaces, external faade) allows to generate item beginning
going). Automated image block orientation (Photomodeler from the skin-surface, that can be inherited by hierarchical
Scanner) has been imported for the orthoimage generation: aggregation of the 3D object content of geo-database spatial
a 2mm DSM has been processed from the pointclouds logic applied to the city modelling [16].
(SocetSet and Photogrammetric Lab Suite , on the rooms
of the central and north wings of the complex). The challenge here is to manage geometric-constructive
3D brick block texturized complex model within BIM Mass
objects, to explore the energetic performance of a complex

476
stratigraphic context, to implement continuous models [17], different phenomena and to exchange information in real
and finite element analysis for a better investigation of the time.
structural behaviour [18], avoiding the loss of the
informative model obtained by gathering volume and content IV. TLS AND IMAGE DATA PROCESSING FOR THE
information within an item concept. TECHNOLOGICAL CONTRUCTIVE VAULT SYSTEM ANALYSIS

III. A CONTINUOUS VIRTUAL SITE IN SUPPORT TO THE The radiometric and geometric information generated by
PLANNED CONSERVATION: THE CASE STUDY OF VILLA the Laser Scanner and Photogrammetric technologies allow
to cross relate the different information. 3D orthoimages
REALE IN MONZA
have been generated from Laser Scanner point clouds of the
The revitalization process of the Villa Reale presents few vaults system of the main halls (about 75) of the two noble
complex innovative aspects concerning the objective, the floors of the Central block and of the first noble floor of the
strategies and the instruments: this example can be South block [21]. Such a rich collection of samples (Fig.1) is
considered a relevant pilot case, within which some main now available and it could be very useful to the historians,
institutions in Italy were involved. Region Lombardy, as the and professionals conducting the analysis, planning the
owner of the large part of the complex, was the promoter of interventions of the maintenance of the decorations, plasters
conservation initiative, involving Politecnico di Milano for and stuccos, boiseries and woodwork frames. Metric-
the technical aspects and Bocconi Univeristy for economic morphologic-geometric models have been reconstructed,
issues. The problem of the economic feasibility of Villas considering the analysis of the constructive-technologies
restoration, due to the dimension and the state of adopted during the construction phases, with the aim to
degradation, need to elaborate and verify the possibility to overcome the automatic 3D mesh models generated by
connect the concept of valorisation of the cultural heritage simply using the cloud points.
and the conservation aims. It was necessary to identify the
The objective of the research was to reconstruct the
incoming terms of investment in order to foresee the private
principal different typologies of the vault systems applied at
participation both for the investments in valorisation and for
Villa Reale and to obtain an abacus to be implemented and
the management and maintenance control of the object in the
verified across the Lombardy Region territory through an
future. This approach has changed the approach of the
adaptive methodology of decoding the structures considered.
survey activities, from the design instrument within a limited
All these data are made available through an SDI [22]
temporal arc towards a logic of supporting the LCM.
developed using open source tools and published via web in
This study case highlights the innovative potentialities of terms of on line portal. The portal allows to the specialist of
the methodology of the Planned Conservation to overcome different disciplines to perform a synchronic and diachronic
the logic of restoration meant as an isolated event in time due reading across the centuries, considering each architectural
to a damage or extraordinary maintenance, in favour of complex and the territorial characteristics in order to
actions capable to exploit the economic convenience of the compare different constructive technologies adopted over
planned conservation [19]. Thus, the priority identified was different time periods. Hypothesis have been done also on
to outline a methodological process by defining an operative the shape of the wooden centrings used for the construction
model able to support the identification of sensible data and on the bricks arrangement, useful to evaluate the
and useful content models able to support such a process in structural behaviour of the vaults, together with the
the time. The objective is to define a sustainability protocol identification of geometrical anomalies, crushing and
for the management and maintenance of the heritage, to implosion areas, that can be constantly monitored and
guarantee the conservation, valorisation and control over updated limiting additional diagnostic tests.
time beginning from the survey products. The aim of these
The result of such methodology is the implementation of
actions was the development of instruments able to support
an open decoding instrument, respect to the structural
an innovative virtual site of programmed maintenance to be
aspects and the decorative apparatus. The definition of the
managed in the future, through the two technological
objectives, methodologies and operational practices and
modules developed until now, the Sircop module
guidelines requests to overcome a passive spatial reference
(Informative System to support Planned Conservation) and
and three-dimensional representation and make a shift
the e-VmV, an open source portal based on geospatial
towards an intelligent system able to manage a constant flux
services, oriented to generate progressively a Spatial Data
of different specific data within dynamic interpretative
Infrastructure (SDI) for the architectural purposes [20].
models.
The aim was to join the two developed Models within a
The aim of this approach is to generate dynamic
BIM logic, with an adaptive dynamic approach supported by
interpretative model, to define control attention threshold,
the 3D Object development for real time control, alert,
alert and alarm threshold and to identify the soils of risk
prevention and intervention programming. The results of
respects to the structural and environmental stresses, in order
survey and documentation were meant to be used to create a
to support analysis, simulations and retroactive control. The
common working space that would allow to correlate the
objective of the whole process was to develop the generation
behaviour of the single objects through the specific analysis
of large scale and high resolution models with high Level of
of each room over time (i.e. climate aspects, effective
Detail (LOD) in order to support the analysis of historical
sustainable rated load, frequencies of vibration, alteration of
constructive model, scenario simulation of the dynamic
the decorative surfaces), allowing to the experts to quantify

477
behaviour of the object and of the whole architectural genesis of the vaults and on the constructive methodologies
organism. used in the past, consenting hypothesis on the shape of the
wooden centrings used for the construction and for the bricks
arrangement. At the same time, an attempt was done to cross
this technological information with the ones derived from the
analysis of the original drawings of cross-sections used as a
guide to build up the cover structures of the rooms. In order
to reconstruct the story of the process of building we used
the instruction given by ancient manual supposedly known
by the architect Piermarini. In particular, we tried to
understand how the ancient builders have drawn and built
the wooden centrings to obtain the exact shape of the vaults
planned by the original architects drawings, starting from
the plan of the room in and from the height of the vault.
The two typical constructive technologies of vault
covering have been reconstructed: the masonry vaults (Fig.
2) and the wooden hanging vaults (Fig.3). The first one
regards many pavilion vaults that have been built up along
the XVIII and XIX century within the Villa Reale. They
were generated by crossing of two barrel vaults, with a
Figure 1. The abacus of the vault system of the Villa Reale obtained from
the laser scanner and photogrammetric surveys. Its possible to navigate
central plane ceiling in some cases. The model was
HR georeferenced orthoimages (terrain pixel, 12mm) within the open developed beginning from the provisional centring, and the
source GeoSpatial Services implemented on the website (WMS,WFS). All wooden planking on which the brick block has been
the vault are referred to their different masonry and wooden typologies superimposed along the masonry rows, thus reconstructing
(bottom). the warping and 3D brick blocks model texturing [23].
To this purpose the shape of each vault has been Considering the extrados inspections, the typologies
reconstructed upon a deeper investigation of the illustrated on the different manual of the XVIII-XIX
technological-constructive system genesis, obtained from the centuries [24], and the bibliographic references on the
theoretic constructive hypothesized and from analysis of the technological construction [25], with the geometric analysis
coeval manuals and documents. Two different situation of beginning from the elliptical vertical section generated and
extrados inspections have been identified at Villa Reale: (1) extracted from the cloud points the 3D constructive model
when was possible to access and inspect directly the extrados has been generated. Such geometric thematic information
of the vaults and (2) when the rich decorative stucco surfaces could be used for the structural analysis of the vault elements
of vaults (and the impossibility to remove the floors of the within the whole complex. In particular the reconstruction of
rooms above!), have prevented the assessment of the cross- the precise geometry of the cloister vault, started from the
sections and the investigation of the materials and their drawings of longitudinal and transversal sections of the
condition of conservation. Therefore, when possible, the square room (obtained from the laser scanner point clouds),
dimensional and geometrical data on the shape of cloister has allowed to compare the real shape with the ideal one.
vaults were analysed from constructive and structural point This possibility could be extremely useful to the experts in
of view, comparing information obtained from the survey the identification of the anomalies in the shape of the vaults
with direct observation of the extrados of the vaults. In those respect to the ideal shape of the original drawings, useful
cases the thicknesses, materials, textures masonry, metal and also for subsequent diagnostic analysis and observation of
wooden tie-beans were accurately investigated to provide an structural behaviour.
useful point of comparison for those areas where information
were not directly obtainable. The example of Villa Reale represents one of the first
experiments of a virtual working space for multidisciplinary
This method of investigation of the old structures and scientific community involved within the planned
their constructive techniques represent a reverse process of conservation process. The availability of simultaneous
knowledge, starting from the observation of the existing information, maps, surveys, virtual models, ancient
elements to virtually reconstruct hypothetic phases of documents, allows a breakthrough towards a dynamic model
construction, considering not only the geometry and the for a continuous learning system and iterative adaptive
thickness of the walls, but also the materials and the real system, guaranteeing the use of the architectural organism
arrangement of the constructive elements. over time, ensuring thus the valorisation of cultural heritage
Different hypotheses have been verified on the effective for the generations to come.
spatial geometry obtained from the first rough Triangulated
Irregular Network (TIN) model generated from the laser
scanner points crossing all the information useful to the 3D
content decoding. Through an accurate three-dimensional
survey of the structures it was possible to obtain all the basic
geometric data to derive information on the constructional

478
V. CROSSRELATIONS TO RECONSTRUCT 3D OBJECT
MODEL
The survey case study of the Palazzo Soldi in Cremona
carried out within the Master of Science Course of
Restoration (thought by Proff. A. Grimoldi, R. Brumana, D.
Del Curto), represents the application of the methodology
described in section II. It has underlined the importance in
generating virtual dynamic model space to be implemented
by the different correlated information. It can be the starting
point when constructing a 3D content BIM, enhanced to
connect the Single Object within the overall Building
organism. The geometric and thematic surveys have
highlighted the importance of diachronic 3D representation
[28], to detect different construction phases of the palace
during the centuries, as the result of progressive
incorporation of a separated block belonging to different
properties (Fig.4). The laser scanner and photogrammetric
multispectral surveys registered the merging process of
different blocks through the faade of the internal court built
to give prestige to the property unification. The enlargement
of the roof in height and along the transversal length to host
Figure 2. From cloud points to the geometric and tecnological constructive the added faade with a new groin vaults porch, probably
analysis of the masonry vault system and the 3D brick block model texture. caused the out of plumb movements and the arc relaxed in
the central part of the faade due to a loose binding of the
new faade to the existing block, performed only by using
the two end-nodes. This hypothesis is supported by the later
addition of the tie beam to the trusses, not coeval to them, to
contain the forces and thrust. Such thrust have been
increased by the replacement of the ancient precious
wooden floor structure (XIV-XV cen.) with the new vault
cover system, due to the style of that period, while . Some of
those vaults are accessible at the extrados level of the roof,
many are covered by countertops superimposed hiding the
vaults, while some are simply viewable from the intrados
only. Where possible thermal images of the intrados or
extrados surface have been acquired and integrated within
the geometric analysis, in order to define the two different
mortar pavilion vault system with the different brick block
Figure 3. The 3D constructive model of the so called wooden vault texturing, and the wooden false vaults, here also present.
system made by wooden arcs integrated by a light weight structure, that
allows to cover large areas (Ball Room,Villa Reale, Monza). One of the reconstructed vault models is here illustrated:
from the analysed structures, recursive typologies have been
The second type regards the main hall of the first Noble highlighted, allowing to simplify the analysis of the different
Floor, the Ball Room. The vaults of the hall have been vault systems, once the constructive methodology was
analysed and surveyed to reconstruct its shape in relation to comprehended. The case study is the vault facing the court
the other common constructive models. The cover was built that was originally covering the larger representative room,
as a wooden vaults, defined false vault, a typology used to and is now subdivided in three rooms and hidden by a
cover rooms of large dimensions using a light structure. The ceiling: the surveyed extrados model has been reconstructed
wooden centring, as visible from the pictures of the in order to analyse the interesting herringbone texture of the
inspections within the extrados, are not removable in this brick block obtained to cover such important dimensions,
case, but they are hanging to oblique fixed support as shown beginning from the coeval manual analysis and from the
in Fig.3. extrados images (Figg.5,6). Once modelled such vault
A kind of modern logical-virtual stereotomy, in its Objects (within RHINO), their integration was verified
ancient meaning of the art of cutting stones in the 3Dspace, within Revit in order to relate thematic information (the
(from the Greek etymology stereos-space, temno-cut), chronological phase of construction, typology of
has been experimented to construct the vaulted elements, construction, brick block pavilion vault or wooden vault, the
keystone and complex objects [26] rediscovering the ancient height, the weight, the principle forces and behaviour). This
design and providing an excellent space control [27]. could be a base to generate an object content model of the
wall related to the behaviour of the building and of the

479
Figure 4. The integration of laser scanning survey with the
technological constructive analysis of the faade texturing (IR
FLIR images) and of the vault system, allowed to reconstruct
the state of the art as a result of the different chronological soil

single elements related one to the other (vault systems, roof


beams, facade).
Each surface has been connected one to the other,
generating 3D-Obiect with a deeper informative content
about the geometry, technological construction information, Figure 5. The reconstruction of the 3D Object vault model from the
the sequence and phases of the construction. extrados surveys and the interesting herringbone of the brick block
texturing. The model object is made by the brick elements with the
different disposition.

480
Figure 7. The methodologic path to obtain the constructive geometry of the
vault module inscribed within the trapezium.

Figure 8. The 3D model generation obtained from the laser scanner vertical
and horizontal slices and the hyphotesized texture of the brick block to be
verified through InfraRed Image campaign.

The case study of the vault system of the 'Rotonda of


Besana' in Milan (once a church dedicated to Saint Michele,
XIX cent.) illustrates that the described methodology helps
the investigation of apparently easy cases and discovering
unexpected pieces of history, not examined by the literature
until now. The case of spherical vault built along the four
principal and secondary exedras of the famous complex of
Figure 6. The 3D Object model and its derived typology from the so called
volta a schifo (cut cloister vault) with harringhbone texture of the brick
Rotonda seemed apparently related to a simple spherical
block with a disposition of flat brick and brick on the edge to lighten the implant, cut by the inscribed trapezium, as usually
weight of the structure. The model is on course to be integrated within represented in historical documents, Fig.7. The analysis of
Revit with the DB. the horizontal, transversal diagonal and longitudinal slices

481
extracted from point clouds have shown an ovoid shape, with [7] F. Remondino, J. Niederoest, J., Generation of high resolution
different directions of the brick block arrangement along the mosaic for photo-realistic texture mapping of cultural heritage 3D
models Proceedings of the 5th Int.Symposium on Virtual Reality
same constructive ring, Fig.8. The impossibility to access to Archaeology and Intelligent Cultural Heritage, VAST04, Brussels,
the extrados requires deeper investigation of texture (ring or Belgium, 2004, pp.85-92.
herringbone): the Object model was generated on the [8] F. Nex, F. Rinaudo, Multi-image matching: an old and new
hypothesis of the most probable brick block texture. Further photogrammetric answer to lidar techniques. ISPRS, vol.
investigation with IR images using thermal camera are XXXVII/B5, ISSN: 1682-1750, 2008, PP. 621-626.
[9] M. Wang, H. Bai, H., F. Hu, Automatic Texture Acquisition for 3D
planned during the next months in order to enable matching Model Using Oblique Aerial Images. 1st ICINIS 2008, Wuhan,
of thus obtain thermal orthoimages with 3D scans [29]. China, 2008, pp. 495-498.
[10] M. Pollefeys, L. Van Gool, et al., Visual modeling with a hand-held
VI. CONCLUSION camera. IJCV, 59(3), 2004, pp. 207-232.
[11] R. Hartley, A. Zisserman, Multiple View Geometry in computer
The progress and implementation of 3D Object Content vision, Cambridge University Press, 2004.
Models opens stimulating possibilities in the development of [12] F. Prandi, R. Brumana, F. Fassi, Semi-Automatic Objects
4D virtual workspace for management and maintenance of Recognition in Urban Areas Based on Fuzzy Logic, Journal of
heritage in time. Hence the need to explore the potential of Geographic Information System, vol 2, 2010, pp. 55-62 (ISSN
Print: 2151-1950, ISSN Online: 2151-1969, DOI:
these models, based on the box-systems and surveyed using 10.4236/jgis.2010.22011).
lasers and photogrammetry, to obtain systems of continuous [13] M. Previtali, L. Barazzetti, M. Scaioni, Multi-step and multi-photo
learning in which dynamic behaviour of architecture heritage matching for accurate 3D reconstruction. (pp.1-6). In: Int. Archives of
could be monitored. Providing the context to data of different Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences,
types is no longer the final phase of heterogeneous Munich, 2011.
[14] G. Lee, R. Sacks, C.E. Eastman, Specifying parametric building
information synthesis, but it is becoming a working tool that object behaviour (BOB) for a building information modeling system.
recognises the construction of geometric and technological 2006. Automation in Construction 15 (2006) 758-776, Elsevier.
manufacturing models as valid support for the monitoring of [15] P. Tang, D. Huber, B. Akinci, R. Lipman, (2011). A. Lytle,
degradation and of structural behaviour. Methods and Automatic reconstruction of as-built building information models
from laser-scanned point clouds. A review of related techniques,
simplified techniques used to generate BIM oriented Automation in Construction, Vol. 19(7), pp. 829-843.
modelling need further investigation in terms of [16] R. Brumana, F. Fassi, F. Prandi. Definition of the 3D content and
interoperability and sustainability. BIM applied to the Built geometric level of congruence of numeric cartography, Lecture notes
Heritage, Laser BIM based surveying, Energy Efficiency in Geoinformation and Cartography, Springer LNG&C Berlin,
simulations, structural behaviour, finite element analysis Germany, 2006, pp. 185- 194b.
[17] P.B. Loureno, J.G. Rots, J. Blaauwendraad, Continuum model for
modelling, thermal dispersion modelling are only few topics masonry: parameter estimation and validation, Journal of structural
that represent new fields of investigation. 3D models and the engineering, ASCE, 124(6), 1998, pp. 642-652.
knowledge of technological constructive geometries can [18] L. Binda, P. Condoleo, A. Taliercio (2009). Restoration of Hindu
provide an essential contribution to better understanding of temples in M Son, Viet Nam: experimental investigation, modelling
theses topic, generating adaptive iterative finite elements and proposal for intervention JOURNAL OF STRUCTURAL
ENGINEERING, pp. 437- 442, 3.
where generation of vault content models described here [19] AA.VV, La Conservazione programmata del patrimonio storico-
could be an excellent starting point. architettonico. Linee Guida per il piano di manutenzione e il
consuntivo scientifico, N.Cannada Bartoli e S.Della Torre, (a cura
ACKNOWLEDGMENT di), Regione Lombardia- IReR, Guerini e Associati, Milano 2003.
[20] R. Brumana, F. Fassi, B. Cuca, D. Oreni, Remote virtual access to
Our special acknowledgment goes to the Lombardy 3D Photogrammetry: e-vmv virtual museum of the Villa Reale in
Region for supporting the surveys and methodological Monza, VSMM08, Cyprus 2008.
approach. To Proff. A. Grimoldi and L. Binda for their [21] F. Fassi, C. Achilla, R. Brumana, H. Tuncer, Application of mixed
scientific knowledge of technological and constructive technique for the 3D modelling of the Noble floor of the Real Villa in
Monza, ISPRS, XXXVI-5/C53, 2007, pp. 758-763.
analysis during survey, and to the Master courses students [22] B. Cuca, D. Oreni, R. Brumana, Open Source meets preventive
for testing the methodology in such a didactic path. conservation: web based tools for preventive conservation of
architectural heritage, PreCoach2011 (International Conference on
REFERENCES Preventive Conservation of Architectural Heritage), 29-30 ottobre
[1] M. Lemmens, (2007), Terrestrial Laser Scanners, GIM-Int., no.21(8). 2011, Proceedings, pp.55-67, Nanjing, China.
[2] D. Akca, A. Gruen, (2007), Generalized least squares multiple 3D [23] G. Guarini, Architettura civile, Il Polifilo, Milano, 1968.
surface matching, in Proc. of the ISPRS WS Laser Scanning 2007, [24] A. Becchi, F. Foce, Degli archi e delle volte: arte del costruire tra
vol. XXXVI, PART 3 /W52, ISSN 1682-1777, Espoo Finlandia, pp. meccanica e stereotomia Venezia, Marsilio 2002.
1-7, CD. [25] G. Sithole, 2008. Detection of Bricks in a Masonry Wall., ISPRS, vol.
[3] C. Eastman, P. Teicholz, R. Sacks, K. Liston, (2008). BIM 37(B5), pp. 567-572.
Handbook, A guide to Building Information Modeling for owners, [26] G. A. Breymann, trad. It. F. Vallardi, Trattato generale di costruzioni
managers, designers, engineers, and contractors, Hoboken, N.J.: John civili, Milano, 1884, vol. I Costruzioni in pietra e strutture murali, Di
Wiley & Sons. Baio Editore, 1985, pp.3-182, and G.A.Breymann, ArchiVolte
[4] K. Kraus (2008) Photogrammetry Geometry from Images and Laser Cupole, Roma - Dedalo 1995.
Scans, Walter de Gruyter, Berlin, Germany. [27] G. Carbonara, Atlante del Restauro, tomo I, UTET, Torino 2004, pp.
[5] F. Remondino, F. Menna, F, Image-based surface measurement for 210-235 et Trattato di restauro architettonico, vol.II, UTET, Torino
close-range heritage documentation, IAPRSSIS, 37(5/W1), 2008, [28] G. Guidi, M. Russo (2009). Diachronic representation of ancient
pp.199-206. buildings: studies on the San Giovanni in Conca Basilica in Milan.
[6] L. Barazzetti, F. Remondino, M. Scaioni (2010). Orientation and 3D Disegnare con (ISSN:1828-5961), pp. 69- 80, 2.
modelling from markerless terrestrial images: combining accuracy [29] M.I. Alba, L. Barazzetti, M. Scaioni, E. Rosina, M.Previtali (2011).
with automation PHOTOGRAMMETRIC RECORD, pp. 356- 381. Mapping infrared data on terrestrial laser scanning 3D models of
buildings, REMOTE SENSING (ISSN:2072-4292), pp. 1847- 1870.

482

You might also like