Professional Documents
Culture Documents
the-utopian.org
1 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
2 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
3 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
4 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
5 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
6 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
7 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
8 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
9 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
10 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
11 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
they are unable 'to discern any pull from any secular
reason (133). But Habermas fails to realize that
accepting toto corde [wholeheartedly] this "objection of
Weithmanns as in my view decisive (133) ends up by
potentially legitimating all religious intolerance.
The kamikaze believer, in fact, is precisely the one who
less than any other discerns the 'pull of a secular
reason. The same is true of the believer who demands
the stake for an offensive page, or holds his daughter
prisoner because she is tempted by the Western
lifestyle, or beats her to a pulp (and sometimes kills her)
if she refuses to adapt to an arranged marriage, or as a
good Jehovahs witness lets his son who needs a
transfusion die. And why not polygamy, cannibalism,
pedophilia, the exposition of newborn babies or ritual
human sacrifice, since for millenary and grandiose
religions such practices have represented duty and
pietas?
The liberal State that protects all forms of religious life
equally (135) is therefore liberal only in this anti-secular
idiosyncrasy of Habermass. The liberal State cannot and
must not protect all the forms of life but exclusively the
constitutional freedoms of all the citizens, and therefore
forms of life (religious or otherwise) only if they are
compatible with republican democracy.
Hence, to guarantee citizens symmetrically, liberal
constitutionalism must impose an asymmetrical mental
12 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
13 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
14 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
15 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
16 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
17 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
18 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
19 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
20 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
21 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
22 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25
The Utopian Eleven Theses Against Habermas about:reader?url=http://www.the-utopian.org/...
23 of 23 25/05/2017, 11:25