Professional Documents
Culture Documents
COURT OF APPEALS
MANILA
CORAZON GALLARDO,
Petitioner-Appellant.
FILOMENA TORRELINO,
Oppositor-Appellee
X -----------------------------------------X
APPELLANTS BRIEF
2. On January 27, 2015, after trial on the merits, the Regional Trial Court,
Branch 160, Pasig City, issued an order the dispositive portion of which to read as
follows:
A copy of such Decision is hereto attached as Annex A and made integral part
hereof.
4. On October 16, 2015 the Honorable Court issued an Order denying the
Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit. A copy of such Order is hereto attached
as Annex C and made integral part hereof.
5. On May 13, 2016, undersigned counsel received a notice from this
Honorable Court requiring him to submit one (1) original copy and two (2) copies with
annexes of legible printed Appellants Brief within forty-five (45) days from receipt
thereof or until June 28, 2016 to file the same, however, in view of the complex legal
issues involved in connection with this case requiring certified records, there is a
need to extend the submission until August 13, 2016.
THE PARTIES
10. Said Decedent left an estate in the form of undivided hereditary interest
in a real property located in San Juan, Metro-Manila, with an area of One Hundred
Eighty (180) Square Meters, Belonging to her parents Agustin Torrelino and Candida
Villaruz covered by TCT No. 402563. A copy of such TCT is hereto attached as
Annex E and made integral part hereof.
ISSUES
11. The only issue submitted for the resolution of this Appeal:
ARGUMENT/DISCUSSION
2
12. With all due respect to this Honorable Court, Petitioner reiterates the
allegation contained in its Petition and Motion for Reconsideration of the above-
mentioned decision for the grounds:
13. Based on the decision of the Honorable Court of Regional Trial Court
Branch 160 of Pasig City dated January 27, 2015, The Court finds that the Oppositor
did not question the existence of the subject real estate mortgage; in fact the
authenticity and due execution of the deed of real estate mortgage has been clearly
identified and proven by the petitioner, hence, the said deed of real estate mortgage
is thus presumed VALID.
14. Hence, the continued inaction of oppositor and his co-siblings and heirs
of the late Spouses Torrelino cannot and must not continuously prejudice the
right of herein petitioner who only gratuitously offered financial help to their sibling,
the late Eufemia Torrelino.
15. It was also acknowledge in the said decision that herein petitioner is not
expressly disqualified from being appointed as an administrator, On the other hand,
herein oppositor and his co-siblings has evidently neglected their duty to seek
appointment and process the settlement of estate of their parent and thus
continuously prejudicing the rights of petitioner. The RTC court of general jurisdiction
has jurisdiction to settle issues in the case and to settle once and for all the matters
from the Complaint. Thus, in the case of Ching vs. Hon. Rodriguez 1, the Court held
that RTC, in the exercise of its general jurisdiction, cannot be restrained from taking
cognizance of respondents Complaint and Amended Complaint as the issues raised
and the prayers indicated therein are matters which need not be threshed out in a
special proceeding.
16. The Petitioner-Appellant has been prejudiced and has been paid for
more than 10 years -- 14 years to be exact, hence in the substantial interest of
justice appeals to the kindness of the Honorable Court to reconsider the Decision
dated 27 January 2015.
PRAYER
1
Ramon S. Ching and Po Wing vs. Hon. Jansen R, Rodriguez, et.al, G.R. No. 192828, November 28, 2011.
3
Other reliefs just and equitable under the premises are likewise prayed for.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED.
City of San Jose Del Monte, Bulacan for the City of Manila, July 26, 2016.
By:
Copy furnished:
EXPLANATION
This is to respectfully explain that copy of the foregoing motion was served to
the Regional Trial Court and appellees counsel through registered mail with return
card due to time, distance and lack of personnel to effect personal service.