Professional Documents
Culture Documents
renewable energy
investor landscape
About the Research
This report analyses the strategies, return requirements and activities of the main investor
classes in Europes renewable energy sector. It was written by Global Capital Finance in
collaboration with Clean Energy Pipeline. All transaction data used in this report is based on
deals tracked in Clean Energy Pipelines deal databases.
Foreword
The renewable energy market has come of age. For the first time it looks likely that renewable energy investments will exceed traditional
power generation investments in the coming years. Rising from humble beginnings, initially often politically motivated, the industry has
grown to be a major force throughout the world.
There are many obvious reasons for this, not least the broad recognition that we have to preserve our natural resources. In addition, many
projects are now being developed on economic merit alone without subsidies. However, we believe one of the most important factors
driving growth in this sector is the improvement of professional standards in the industry.
While small onshore wind farms, local biomass plants and solar PV plants can often be completed with basic engineering skills, more
complex, larger plants require major engineering capabilities. Compared to an onshore wind farm, an offshore wind farm looks very
challenging, but compared to offshore drilling, it looks very manageable. With larger transactions it is also possible to apply financial
structuring techniques, and now, after appropriate professional standards have become common, even smaller transactions can be
executed more efficiently.
While Global Capital Finance remains active in all subsectors of infrastructure, renewable energy has been our strategic focus since 2005.
Overall we have completed more than 50 asset based M&A transactions with a total value in excess of 3 billion covering wind, offshore
wind, solar PV, biomass, waste to energy and hydroelectric power plants.
We advise developers who are seeking equity and debt, sellers during the divestiture process, and investors during the acquisition process
worldwide, but the core of our business remains Europe.
European investors were first to embrace the opportunities in the sector. Today, investments in renewable energy assets are widely
accepted by institutional investors as a sensible portfolio component combining low risk and attractive returns. In the more mature
European markets there is already significant secondary sales activity. Sure, there are growing pains and changing regulatory frameworks,
but ultimately there will be a professional, stable and mature market for many years to come. The path to sustainability is irreversible.
We very much appreciate the contribution of the interviewees and Clean Energy Pipeline to this report. We hope you find it interesting and
we welcome your feedback.
Juergen Moessner
President, Global Capital Finance
Global Capital Finance
Contents
2 Executive summary
4 Major utilities
7 Municipal utilities
20 Germany
22 UK
24 Scandinavia
DONG Energy 210 MW Westermost Rough offshore 50% 581 million Marubeni, UK Green Mar-14
A/S wind farm Investment Bank
RWE 576 MW Gwynt y Mr offshore wind 10% 266 million UK Green Investment Mar-14
farm Bank
DONG Energy 630 MW London Array offshore wind 25% 3.1 billion La Caisse de dpt et Jan-14
A/S farm placement du Qubec
GDF Suez SA Futures Energies Investissement 50% Undisclosed, although Predica (subsidiary Dec-13
Holding (subsidiary of GDF Suez), which will enable GDF SUEZ of Crdit Agricole
operates 440 MW of installed onshore to reduce its net debt Assurances)
wind capacity by some 400 million
EDF 144 MW Fallago wind farm Majority Undisclosed Hermes GPE Dec-13
GDF Suez SA National Power International Holdings 50% Undisclosed Marubeni Corp Aug-13
B.V. (GDF Suezs Portuguese thermal and
renewable energy assets, which has a
combined capacity of 3.3 GW)
DONG Energy Kraftgrden AB, owner of seven 26% 2.4 billion Voimapiha Aug-13
A/S hydro plants along the Swedish river
Indalslven with an overall capacity of
626 MW
DONG Energy DONG Energy's Danish onshore wind 100% 102 million SE, PFA Jun-13
A/S business, which operates 196 MW of
operating across 80 locations and a 23
MW development stage project
GDF Suez SA IP Maestrale Investments (GDF Suez's 80% 859 million ERG SpA Feb-13
Italian wind business, which has a
capacity of 636 MW)
Iberdrola SA Iberdrola Renewables Polska (Iberdrola's 75% 271 million Energa, Polska Grupa Feb-13
Polish renewable energy business, which Energetyczna (PGE)
operates a 184.5 MW portfolio of five
wind farms and a development pipeline)
DONG Energy DONG Energys Polish onshore wind 100% 231 million Energa, Polska Grupa Feb-13
A/S business, including 112 MW of operating Energetyczna (PGE)
capacity, 220 MW of construction stage
projects and 555 MW of pre-construction
stage projects
SSE plc 79.5 MW portfolio of onshore wind farms 100% 163 million Greencoat Capital Feb-13
Iberdrola SA Iberdrola Renovables France (operating 100% 400 million MEAG (asset Dec-12
32 onshore wind farms in France totalling management arm of
321 MW) Munich Re), General
Electric, EDF Energies
Nouvelles
Note: The above table only shows divestments of large portfolios of renewable energy assets. It does not include the many divestments of individual
projects.
Source: Clean Energy Pipeline
Thomas Schnorrenberg
IR and PR Manager
Capital Stage
Marubeni Corp, UK Green 50% 210MW Westermost Rough offshore wind project Mar-14 605 million
Investment Bank operational (UK)
Mitsubishi Corp, Barclays 100% London Array phase one transmission project Sep-13 553 million
Infrastructure Funds operational (UK)
Mitsubishi Corp 100% 56MW portfolio of operating solar PV capacity (France) Aug-13 Undisclosed
Marubeni Corp 50% National Power (3.3GW of operating gas, coal and Aug-13 Undisclosed
renewable energy capacity Portugal)
Sumitomo Corp 39% and 165MW Belwind project (39% operational) and Jul-13 100 million
33% 216MW Northwind wind farm (33% construction
stage) (Belgium)
Mitsubishi Corp, Innovation Joint 85% Solar Holding, owner of a 42MW portfolio of Mar-13 Undisclosed
Network of Japan (INCJ), Solar stake operational solar plants (Italy)
Ventures
Mitsubishi Corp 50% 55MW Tranche 1 of the Toul-Rosires solar project Jan-13 Undisclosed
operational (France)
Mitsubishi Corp 50% 129MW Eneco Luchterduinen offshore wind farm Jan-13 Undisclosed
pre-construction (The Netherlands)
Investment stage: All asset stages, although investing at the Ming Yang Wind Power Group announced in November 2013 that it will
development stage is preferred. supply turbines and provide EPC services for a 200 MW wind farm in
Romania, representing the largest ever export of a Chinese wind turbine
Holding length: Long term (10-20 years).
manufacturer. A month later, Xinjiang Goldwind Science & Technology
Level of engagement: Investments with partners or in joint secured an EPC contract to build a 50 MW wind farm in Romania as
ventures with strong industrial players; constructing and well.
operating experience is preferred. This can include co-investment
with other Japanese trading houses.
OEMs typically do not plan to be long-
Ticket size: Varies significantly from small investments of
10-20 million to much larger investments in offshore wind.
term holders of assets and seek an exit
Geographic focus: All of Europe, with a preference for stable after commissioning, or one to two years
regulatory regimes. into operations. To expedite the capital
Use of leverage: Non-recourse debt is often used in countries recycling process, they often start the sales
where project finance is available. In some cases, debt is provided
by Japanese banks.
process during the construction phase.
We want well-governed, well-regulated markets, explained things such as innovative thermal technologies for the conversion
Peter Dixon, Founding Partner and Technical Director at Glennmont of biomass and offshore wind off the radar. Our investments are
Partners. We dont want to take sovereign risk, which gives us a typically leveraged. We made 14 investments from the first fund, and
bias towards the better governed regulatory regimes of western all but three were leveraged.
Europe. We are pretty focused in terms of technology. We will only
invest in proven technologies. By proven, we mean that there must
already be many fully operational applications in place that have Pension funds and life insurance
achieved project finance where the OEM is in a position to offer very
robust performance guarantees against the technology. This puts
companies, the typical investors in these
funds, are building up their renewable
energy investment expertise and are
Infrastructure funds
therefore increasingly focusing on direct
Return expectations: 6%-15% p.a. depending on technology investments.
and market.
Investment stage: Assets at late construction or operational
stage. Comprehensive risk mitigation is required when investing Investment trends
at the development or early construction stage. With their ability to invest large sums into illiquid assets over the
long term with relatively moderate return expectations, infrastructure
Holding length: Typically hold-to-maturity approach, meaning
funds for many years have been the most active investor group
investments can be held for 20-25 years. Assets are sometimes
in renewable energy assets. However, the business models of
divested earlier if yield expectations are not met or if the strategic
infrastructure funds and private equity funds are under pressure.
focus of the fund changes.
Pension funds and life insurance companies, the typical investors
Level of engagement: Passive investors, typically investing in in these funds, are building up their renewable energy investment
partnerships with experienced operators, such as utilities. expertise and are therefore increasingly focusing on direct
Ticket size: 10-30 million, although ticket sizes have increased investments.
in recent years as fund sizes increased. A plethora of strict regulatory requirements for funds and fund
Geographic focus: Mature markets with stable regulatory investors has also created significant obstacles to continued
regimes (Germany, France, Scandinavia, the UK, and Ireland). participation in this sector, including the implementation of the
Alternative Investment Fund Manager (AIFM) EU guidelines into
national laws, as well as Basel III and Solvency II requirements. As
Landmark European renewable energy investments by pension funds and insurance companies
PensionDanmark, through infrastructure 67% 900 MW DolWin3 offshore wind grid 384 million Feb-14
fund manager Copenhagen Infrastructure connection
Partners
Gothaer Versicherung Undisclosed Juwi Renewable IPP, owner of a 450 150 million Jan-14
MW portfolio of solar PV and onshore
wind capacity
Predica (subsidiary of Crdit Agricole 50% Futures Energies Investissement Undisclosed, Dec-13
Assurances) Holding (subsidiary of GDF Suez), which although will enable
operates 440 MW of installed onshore GDF SUEZ to reduce
wind capacity its net debt by some
400 million
Allianz Capital Partners (alternative asset 100% 100 MW portfolio of three onshore Undisclosed Jun-13
investment platform for Allianz) wind farms, including a 76.5 MW
project in Germany and two projects in
France totalling 23.5 MW
MEAG (asset management arm of Munich 100% Iberdrola Renovables France (operating 400 million Dec-12
Re), General Electric, EDF Energies 32 onshore wind farms in France
Nouvelles totalling 321 MW)
Aviva Investors (asset management arm of 100% 23 MW portfolio of over 7,000 UK 126 million Aug-12
Aviva) residential solar PV assets
Irish Infrastructure Fund, asset management 75% 104 MW portfolio of ten onshore wind 200 million Jun-12
arm of Irish Life & Permanent PLC farms in the Republic of Ireland and
Northern Ireland
PensionDanmark A/S, PKA A/S 50% 400 MW Anholt offshore wind farm 900 million Mar-11
YieldCos are attractive to investors as they offer an inflation-linked yield Strong focus on yield, leading to little or no leverage
that, in the current low-interest environment, is more attractive than Careful adherence to the investment mandate /
mainstream fixed income instruments such as bonds. Most YieldCos prospectus
offer initial yields of 6% that increase in line with inflation.
Investors require lower returns than other investors,
The investment strategies of the six largest YieldCos currently operating leading to higher prices paid to acquire assets
in Europe Greencoat UK Wind, TRIG, Foresight Solar Fund, Bluefield
Solar Income Fund, John Laing Environmental Assets Group and Investments have low risk tolerance
NextEnergy Solar Fund - are outlined in the table below:
UK YieldCos
John Laing Environmental Assets Group Total funds raised: 160 million
Description Asset portfolio
John Laing Environmental Assets Group (JLEN) raised 160 million UK: 44.4 MW onshore wind farm portfolio
through an IPO on the London Stock Exchange in March 2014. (Hall Farm - 24.6 MW, Bilsthorpe - 10.2 MW, Castle Pill and Ferndale - 9.6 MW)
Upon completion of the IPO, it completed the acquisition of seven UK: 24.5 MW solar PV portfolio
environmental infrastructure assets, six from the John Laing Group. John (Amber Solar Park - 9.8 MW, Branden Solar Project - 14.7 MW)
Laing Investments Ltd holds 39.7% of the voting rights attached to the UK: Waste Treatment Portfolio
share capital of the company. Unlike other YieldCos, JLEN will invest in (D&G Waste, ELWA Waste)
Total installed wind capacity at the end of 2013 Total installed solar PV capacity at the end of 2013
REST OF EUROPE
REST OF EUROPE GREECE
9%
22% GERMANY BELGIUM 3%
28% UK
4%
4% GERMANY
FRANCE 6% 45%
PORTUGAL 4%
DENMARK 4% 7%
SPAIN
7%
FRANCE 19%
7% SPAIN 22%
9%
ITALY ITALY
UK
MWh
10% 20,000
Off-take prices for operating renewable energy projects are currently fixed
8% 16,000
through the EEG. However, in September 2013 the newly formed CDU and
SPD coalition government commenced a process to reform the EEG, in 6% 12,000
which it will likely introduce an element of market and pricing risk. This 4% 8,000
is a direct result of the massive growth in wind and solar capacity in the 2% 4,000
past five years, which has resulted in negative pricing during times of 0% 0
high wind speeds and solar irradiation.
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
12
13
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
Investing in onshore wind under the new EEG will be more complicated Equity IRR Market Maturity
as a tender process will be introduced from 2017, explained Kay
Dahlke, Managing Director at Thuega. This may create opportunities for 2005-2013
Two 5 MW solar PV projects Solar 40 3.61% 27 Nov-12 Independent Matrix Pension Insurance
located in Somerset Power million years Debt Capital Property Corporation
Generation Markets Fund
5 MW Westmill solar PV Westmill 12 N/A 23.5 Feb-13 Investec Bank Investec Lancashire County
project located in Oxfordshire Solar Coop million years Bank Council Pension Fund
Sweden Norway
Sweden introduced a support scheme for renewable energy in 2003, Norway adopted a green certificate mechanism in 2012, at which point
making it the first Scandinavian country to do so. Driven by innovation 537 MW of onshore wind was installed. That same year, 166 MW was
in turbine structures, such as higher hub heights and larger rotor newly installed, indicating it is unlikely Norway will achieve its 2020
diameters, wind projects have become significantly more economically EU Directive. Norway and Sweden have a joint goal to produce 26.4
viable to the extent that 4,470 MW of onshore wind capacity was TWh of renewable electricity by 2020, with each country producing 13.2
installed at the end of 2013, making it Europes eighth largest, and TWh.
Scandinavias largest, onshore wind market.
Most projects in Norway have been developed by Statkraft or municipal
However, decreasing electricity and certificate prices resulted in a 15% utilities. Municipal utilities own significant project pipelines, but do
decrease in installed wind capacity to 724 MW in 2013. Nonetheless, not have the necessary capital for deployment. They are also not
the volume of wind capacity installed in 2013 was the fourth largest accustomed to partnering with co-investors that are not other utilities
in Europe, behind Germany, the UK and Poland, demonstrating that and are less flexible when it comes to financing structures. In addition,
investors have long term faith in Swedens wind market. This optimism most projects are relatively large (>75MW), which thus excludes small
is partly driven by the expectation that electricity prices in Scandinavia and mid-sized investors.
will increase to price levels of continental Europe over the next decade.
Finland
Finland introduced a market premium renewable energy support scheme
Most projects in Norway have been
in 2011, which provides price and market certainty in a similar way to a
developed by Statkraft or municipal feed-in tariff. The subsidy mechanism is capped at 2,500 MW, although
the government is currently discussing increasing this. Only 2 MW of
utilities. Municipal utilities own significant
wind capacity had been installed when the subsidy was introduced.
project pipelines, but do not have the Some 550 MW is expected to be operational by the end of 2014. Most
necessary capital for deployment. projects are under 30 MW in size due to permitting requirements for
larger projects.
globalcapitalfinance.com
The information contained herein is of a general nature and is not intended to address the circumstances of any particular individual or entity. Although we endeavor to provide accurate and timely
information, there can be no guarantee that such information is accurate as of the date it is received or that it will continue to be accurate in the future. No one should act on such information without
appropriate professional advice after a thorough examination of the particular situation.