Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jonathan Aquino
Mx. Cody
English 5
5/19/17
The Ouroboros Known as Identity
I perceive gender as an endless process one endures during which they are what they are
which itself is molded by the experiences, interests, and feelings of the given individual until
what they are is altered by a given experience which the mind processes and responds to
resulting in a different perception of what they were initially. Our class discussions on the nature
of gender and sex, in combination with readings given to us, give more clarity to the
distinguishing the two apart but ultimately leave more questions than answers. Personally, I
identify as a male but recognize that growing up I have attained qualities that are part of my
identity which do not exclusively adhere to the male persona and that these same qualities will
not affect my future perception of my own gender. A persons identity may also find its way into
ones writing by taking numerous forms like characters and emotions brought on by the
experiences of the characters while also shaping the writing of a given person by conveying the
struggles and ideals they experience through their story. Even as I type now, the concept of ones
own gender is hard to put a concrete definition on because it is part of identity which itself is
something too mobile for one to solidify in mere words. Im going to try and express this as best
as I can.
First, our class discussions and readings on the nature of gender and sex allow one to
distinguish between the two but leave more questions than answers. At the beginning of the year
our class analyzed a handout detailing the difference between gender and sex by West and
Zimmerman. Sex itself is something based on an individuals genitals or socially agreed upon
biological material (West and Zimmerman 127). Gender, however, is something someone
identifies as and falls on a spectrum with the two extremes being masculine and feminine.
Aquino 2
Further in-class discussion on gender revealed it is part of ones identity and opens up a plethora
of questions. What is gender? I think of gender as an endless process one endures during which
one forms an identity from their experiences, interests, and values, but this identity eventually
alters itself to a varying degree because of new experiences that bring about thoughts and
feelings which result in a somewhat new frame of mind. This connection to identity and process
of using experiences as beacons for self-discovery and change bring about another question. If
gender itself is reliant on something as dynamic as thoughts birthed from experiences, does that
mean gender can never really be held to ones personal set definition? Is it something we
ourselves can never completely understand? I believe we walk away from any experience with
something that changes our identity and we pit our thoughts and past experiences against new
ones in hopes of uncovering something new about ourselves or about something around us. The
change itself, mind you, can vary from minute to immense. All these questions surround gender
and speak to its ambiguity which bring to light so much more to consider about gender than one
might take at face value. In short, the class discussions and readings on the nature of gender and
sex allows one to distinguish between the two but leaves more questions than answers.
I personally identify as a male but recognize that growing up I have developed qualities
that are part of my identity which do not exclusively adhere to the male persona and that these
same qualities will not affect my future perception of my own gender. The stereotypes or master
narratives of gender would have one believe many things about being a man or woman. For
example, a man is believed to hide their emotions and take pleasure in being strong or proving
their strength whereas a woman is believed to be very emotional and derive pleasure from
being elegant or practicing obedience. Stereotypes also deem certain occupations and activities
appropriate and belittle those who stray from their gender-charged occupations. One prime
example would be cross dressing because using makeup and wearing clothing opposite of ones
Aquino 3
gender is something that leads people to believe an individual is less masculine or feminine
which, according to some, is wrong. This exact mindset can very much be seen in Stone Butch
Blues when Jess is belittled at the doctors office for not looking feminine enough (Feinberg 235-
236). The fact that she needed to look a certain way to be granted service demonstrates the
hostility given to those defying gender norms because Jess didnt look like a woman and was
almost turned away because of that. This leads me to my own thoughts on stereotypes and my
identity.
In my eyes, such master narratives are meaningless. The annoying hubris that
accompanies these stereotypes gives people a reason to demean others which is why I detest
them. I would say as a child was when I valued how I was gendered. My brain seemed to
consider strength and masculinity the same which is why I took fencing classes. This image
would be a good representation of my identity at the time because it shows that I valued skill
with a blade and sought to prove masculinity using that skill (Verhasselt, Mathias Lion Knight).
However, after X amount of years, I became a teenager and found that my interests lay
elsewhere. The value I once had for masculinity had diminished in a way. Shaving certain parts
of my body, plucking eyebrows, and having conversations about inner thoughts and emotions
were things I enjoyed which conveys I didnt mind stepping out of my gender norms. I believe
for one high school project I even went in full drag and had no problem running around campus
dressed as the opposite gender. A good way to convey my comfort in stepping out of gender
norms would be for me to refer to a Buzzfeed video. The Buzzfeed video shows men getting
facials (0:00:00-0:7:59). I would like people to acknowledge that the activity of getting a facial is
one usually associated with women, but these guys dont seem bothered by getting one. It speaks
to my identity because the men in this video arent shy about doing things considered less
masculine which itself demonstrates self-confidence through their decision to get a facial
Aquino 4
treatment. This confidence and acceptance of things considered outside ones gender are qualities
I carry to this day. Currently, I hold both my masculine and feminine qualities close yet I feel my
identity is incomplete. I have a good sense of who I am, but I feel like what I know about myself
now pales in comparison to what I have to discover. The final and most honest way to convey my
identity is through music. A piece known as The Lonely Shepherd conveys how I see myself now
through the thoughts conjured by its rhythm (0:00:00-0:04:25). Its gentle, calming, and docile
much like myself, but the melody also uses its rhythm to convey the long road one walks in an
effort to find oneself and their identity. One could even compare it to a solemn wave goodbye as
one sets off on a journey. In summation, I believe my gender will stay dominantly masculine
while maintaining those feminine qualities that are a part of me and do consider stereotypes and
like characters and emotions brought on by the experiences of the characters while also shaping
the writing of a given person by conveying the struggles and ideals they experience through their
story. One excellent example of this would be Harvey Milk and how his identity influences his
writing. He states in his speech that Without hope, not only are the gays, but the blacks, the
seniors, the handicapped, the us-es. The us-es will give up (Transcript: Hear Harvey Milk's
The Hope Speech.). When one considers that Harvey Milk was indeed gay, they find that his
identity as a gay man did influence his writing as demonstrated through his inclusion of gays in
his speech. This inclusion is important because Harvey Milk was gay and wanted to use his
privilege as a candidate to uplift the gay community as well as other communities. Another
example would be my own writing and how I implemented parts of my identity into it. My three
characters Clod, Sylvia, and Abel are all imbedded with pieces of me. Abel possesses my
ambition to create and nurture beautiful things. Clod holds my lack of interest in obeying the
Aquino 5
gender-charged practices currently dominating society. Sylvia has my respect for and willingness
to defend individuality. This insertion of my traits into characters is an excellent way of showing
facets of ones identity but also serves as an opportunity to give others a glimpse of another
persons perspective. Leslie Feinbergs character Jess makes a fine example of this. Reading
about Jess struggle to find happiness in herself through identity was eye opening. It seemed that
even after taking her hormone injections to look more masculine, Jess still couldnt find
happiness but found something I perceived as far more valuable. To have people see you as one
thing and then switch their perspective about you reveals more about the consequences then
rewards which is something I found interesting. Leslie Feinberg did a really good job trying to
capture the anguish and feeling of being utterly alone that someone in the process of molding
their gender might feel in earlier times. In short, identity may also find its way into a persons
writing by taking numerous forms like characters and emotions brought on by the experiences of
the characters while also shaping the writing of a given person by conveying the thoughts and
form an identity from experiences, interests, and values which itself is changes to a varying
degree as a result of new thoughts brought on by experiences. Class discussions on the nature of
gender and sex, in combination with readings given to us, give more clarity to the distinguishing
the two apart but ultimately leave more questions than answers. Personally, I identify as a male
but recognize that growing up I have attained qualities that are part of my identity which do not
exclusively adhere to the male persona and that these same qualities will not affect my future
perception of my own gender. Ones own identity may also manifest in ones writing by taking
numerous forms like characters and emotions brought on by the experiences of the characters
while also shaping the writing of a given person by conveying the struggles and ideals they
Aquino 6
experience through their story. This paper may be over but my quest in trying to understand all
parts of my identity is something that will continue and likely never end.
Works cited
BuzzFeedVideo. The Try Guys Give Each Other Facials. YouTube. Commentary by Zachary
Kornfeld, Ned Fulmer, Keith Habersberger, and Eugene Yang. 6 May. 2017,
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zN8tfxdaSQI
Feinberg, Leslie. Stone Butch Blues: a Novel. New York, Leslie Feinberg, 2014.
Transcript: Hear Harvey Milk's The Hope Speech. Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, 4 Mar. 2014,
www.mfa.org/exhibitions/amalia-pica/transcript-harvey-milks-the-hope-speech. Accessed
28 Mar. 2017.
West, Candace and Zimmerman, H., Don. Doing Gender. Gender and Society. 1 (1987): 125.
http://mv.cgsociety.org/art/photoshop-lion-knight-879150
Villada, Antonio. The Lonely Shepherd (Kill Bill Soundtrack) Gheorghe Zamfir. YouTube.
v=1qsgBF7ZIsk