Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com/)
CLICKFORFULLSITE(http://www.themalaymailonline.com)
(4)People
UnfriendedYou
DiscoverWhoUnfriendedYouNow!
100%FreeandEasytoFindOut.Goto
unfriendtracker.me
MALAYSIA(/MALAYSIA)
WomanwinsRM300,000inlandmark
caseondiscriminationoverpregnancy
BYBOOSULYN
Published:November10,201403:55PMGMT+8
SHARETHISARTICLE
5820 124 10 60 4
(fromleft)NoorfadillaAhmadSaikin,lawyerHoneyTan,pupilArinaOng,Noorfadilla'shusband
Izwan,andlawyerJoachimXavier,afterthejudgementattheShahAlamHighCourt.Picture
courtesyofHoneyTan
KUALALUMPUR,Nov10Inalandmarkcase,theShahAlamHighCourttoday
awardedawomanRM300,000indamagesforbreachofherconstitutionalrighttogender
equalityafterthegovernmentrefusedtoemployherasatemporaryteacherwhenshe
becamepregnant.
Thegovernmentwasalsoorderedtopay32yearoldNoorfadillaAhmadSaikin
RM12,907.68forlossofearnings,RM2,296.10forlossofEPF(EmployeesProvident
Fund),RM912.71forlossofEPFdividends,aswellasRM25,000forpainandsuffering,
andRM5,000incosts.
ItisonesmallstepforNoorfadilla,butonegiantleapforwomensrightsinMalaysia,
NoorfadillaslawyerHoneyTantoldMalayMailOnline.
Therehaveneverbeendamagespaidforbreachofconstitutionalrightsbeforethis.This
decisionhasmadegreatinroadsintothedevelopmentofMalaysianjurisprudenceinthe
areaofhumanrightslaw,sheadded.
TansaidthecourthadawardedNoorfadilla,ahomemakerwithfourchildren,damagesfor
breachofArticle8(2)oftheFederalConstitutionthatprohibitsgenderdiscrimination.
Noorfadillasuedthegovernmentin2010afterHuluLangatdistricteducationofficers
revokedherappointmentin2009asatemporaryteacheronamonthtomonthbasisupon
discoveringherpregnancy.
TheShahAlamHighCourtruledin2011thatthegovernmenthaddiscriminatedagainst
Noorfadillaand,inalandmarkdecision,heldthattheUnitedNationsConventiononthe
EliminationofAllFormsofDiscriminationagainstWomen(Cedaw)hadtheforceoflawin
Malaysiaasthecountryhadaccededtothehumanrightstreatyin1995.
TansaidthegovernmentappealedagainsttheHighCourtdecisionbutwithdrewitatthe
lastminute.TheCourtofAppealthenorderedRM5,000incosts.
ThelawyeralsonotedthatwhileNoorfadillahadwonhercaseagainstthegovernment,
Malaysiancourtsrefusetoholdprivateactorslikecompaniesliableforbreachof
constitutionalrights,referringtotheBeatriceFernandezcaseinwhichaformerMalaysia
Airlinesflightstewardesssuedtheairlinewhenitfiredheraftershebecamepregnantand
refusedtoresign.
Todate,thecourtsarefollowingthedecisioninBeatriceFernandezthatheldthatcitizens
canonlybringaclaimforbreachofconstitutionalrightsifthepartydoingthe
discriminationisapublicauthority,saidTan.
Inthisrespect,Malaysiaisfailinginitsduediligencedutytoensurethatprivateactorsbe
punished,andtoenableclaimantstobecompensatedforsuchbreaches,sheadded.
In2005,theFederalCourtupheldtheCourtofAppealsdecisionintheBeatrice
FernandezcasethattheFederalConstitutionprotectedonesfundamentalrightsfrom
beingviolatedonlybythestate.
SHARETHISARTICLE
5820 124 10 60 4
COMMENTS(2)(HTTP://WWW.THEMALAYMAILONLINE.COM/MALAYSIA/ARTICLE/WOMAN
WINSRM300000INLANDMARKCASEONDISCRIMINATIONOVERPREGNANCY#IDC
CONTAINER)
Sortby: Date Rating LastActivity Login
Loginorsignup(https://www.intensedebate.com/signup)nowtocomment.
(https://www.intensedebate.com/people/vanguardkl) 16hoursago +2
vanguardkl(https://www.intensedebate.com/people/vanguardkl) 59p
UnbelievablewhenreferringtoBeatricecase.Anyprivateactorcaninfringeonconstitutionalrights?
Unacceptable
Reply Report
Reply Report
utm_medium=referral&utm_content=organicthumbnailsa:BelowArticleOrganicThumbnails:)
(http://trk.jajstrk.com/a2a911f5027643b1932833099b5bef4a?
utm_medium=referral&utm_content=organicthumbnailsa:BelowArticleOrganicThumbnails:)
a=476801&s1=10058012024&s2=3974&utm_source=taboola&utm_medium=referral&s4=themalaymailonline)
LondonFuneralDirectorsInAnUproarAfterFactsExposed
CoverMyFuneral
(http://trk.jajstrk.com/a2a911f5027643b1932833099b5bef4a?
a=476801&s1=10058012024&s2=3974&utm_source=taboola&utm_medium=referral&s4=themalaymailonline)
(http://www.stylebistro.com/Best+Dressed+at+the+2015+Met+Gala?utm_source=tabo&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=TaboSB
UKDesktopSpecials2015MetGala02&utm_content=themalaymailonline&utm_term=https%3A%2F%2Fconsole.brax
cdn.com%2F6155da88269a4fa7bd973babbe51ae91.jpg)
HerDressDroppedJawsAtThe2015MetGala
StyleBistro
(http://www.stylebistro.com/Best+Dressed+at+the+2015+Met+Gala?utm_source=tabo&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=TaboSB
UKDesktopSpecials2015MetGala02&utm_content=themalaymailonline&utm_term=https%3A%2F%2Fconsole.brax
cdn.com%2F6155da88269a4fa7bd973babbe51ae91.jpg)
(http://www.readersdigest.co.uk/er5?storycode=TBIO&utm_source=taboola&utm_medium=referral)
Over60withaninterestonlymortgage?Readthisforasolution
Reader'sDigestEquityRelease
(http://www.readersdigest.co.uk/er5?storycode=TBIO&utm_source=taboola&utm_medium=referral)
(http://www.fuzzfix.com/theintensemomentalionsneaksuponasleepingleopard/?
utm_medium=referral&utm_source=taboola&utm_campaign=themalaymailonline&utm_content=https%3A%2F%2Fconsole.brax
cdn.com%2Fcreatives%2Fa41237a75aad4be2a2876bfe1138fc6c%2F4_4b500e240736d1bae311471c0c60532d.png)
LionStalkingSleepingLeopardGetsUnexpectedSurprise
ReadNowonFuzzfix
(http://www.fuzzfix.com/theintensemomentalionsneaksuponasleepingleopard/?
utm_medium=referral&utm_source=taboola&utm_campaign=themalaymailonline&utm_content=https%3A%2F%2Fconsole.brax
cdn.com%2Fcreatives%2Fa41237a75aad4be2a2876bfe1138fc6c%2F4_4b500e240736d1bae311471c0c60532d.png)
OPEC'sLoss,YourGain
ThisCouldBetheDeathofOPEC,ButGreat
ForYou.WeHave3OilStocksPoisedto
ExplodeGotosubscribe.energyandcapital.com
(http://www.themalaymailonline.com/malaysia/article/malaysiaasiamayturntochinaasuncertaintyloomsovertrumpsforeignpo)
Malaysia,AsiamayturntoChinaasuncertaintyloomsoverTrumpsforeignpolicy
(http://www.themalaymailonline.com/malaysia/article/malaysiaasiamayturntochinaasuncertaintyloomsovertrumpsforeignpo)
(http://www.themalaymailonline.com/drive/article/anothergamechangerfromhondathebrvcrossover)
TheBRVcrossover:AnothergamechangerfromHonda?
(http://www.themalaymailonline.com/drive/article/anothergamechangerfromhondathebrvcrossover)
(http://www.themalaymailonline.com/money/article/ringgitquotedat4.26702750againstusdollar)
Ringgitquotedat4.2670/2750againstUSdollar
(http://www.themalaymailonline.com/money/article/ringgitquotedat4.26702750againstusdollar)
(http://www.themalaymailonline.com/malaysia/article/sarawakianchristianroneeyrebitfinallygetsnewicwithoutislam)
SarawakianChristianRoneeyRebitfinallygetsnewICwithoutIslam
(http://www.themalaymailonline.com/malaysia/article/sarawakianchristianroneeyrebitfinallygetsnewicwithoutislam)
(http://popup.taboola.com/en/?template=colorbox&utm_source=themalaymailonline&utm_medium=referral&utm_content=thumbnailsa:BelowArticleSponsoredThumbnails:)
RELATEDARTICLE
InJapan,morewomenfighttokeeptheirownsurname
(http://m.themalaymailonline.com/features/article/injapanmorewomenfighttokeep
theirownsurname)
Ladies,dropthemop!MostFinnssayhouseworkisforbothsexes
(http://m.themalaymailonline.com/features/article/ladiesdropthemopmostfinnssay
houseworkisforbothsexes)
WanJunaidiseesredoverdiscriminatorytablesettings
(http://m.themalaymailonline.com/malaysia/article/wanjunaidiseesredover
discriminatorytablesettings)
Redoubleeffortsforgenderequality,saysUKMassociateprof
(http://m.themalaymailonline.com/malaysia/article/redoubleeffortsforgenderequality
saysukmassociateprof)
Nothingwrongwithwealthandpower
(http://m.themalaymailonline.com/opinion/article/nothingwrongwithwealthandpower)
BalancingacareerandcaregivingisnolongerjustawomensissueCorinnaLim
(http://m.themalaymailonline.com/whatyouthink/article/balancingacareerand
caregivingisnolongerjustawomensissuecorinna)
Boycottpossible,purseequitydefendedasMiamiopens
(http://m.themalaymailonline.com/sports/article/boycottpossiblepurseequitydefended
asmiamiopens)
#AllMalePanelsareboring(http://m.themalaymailonline.com/opinion/article/allmalepanels
areboring)
GuanEngdefendswomen,tellsPASbrokenhomesusuallymensfault
(http://m.themalaymailonline.com/malaysia/article/guanengdefendswomentellspas
brokenhomesusuallymensfault)
PASroastedfordated,archaicviewthatwomenbelongathome
(http://m.themalaymailonline.com/malaysia/article/pasroastedfordatedarchaicviewthat
womenbelongathome)
MORESTORIESFORYOU
SowhydidUMobile
sackitsCEO?
Toprevent
profiteering,court
slasheswomans...
Shafeeloses
defamationsuitafter
courtrules...
MOREONMMOTV
ReutersVideo:Trumpcallshimselfultimateoutsiderasheasksforvotes(01:37)
RepublicanpresidentialnomineeDonaldTrumpsaysHillaryClintonaspresident'would
createanunprecedentedconstitutionalcrisis'andasksvoterstosupporthimas'perhaps
theultimateoutsiderever.'Reuters
Copyright2016MalayMailOnline CLICKFORFULLSITE(http://www.themalaymailonline.com)
RecomNLocalServices(HTTP://M.THEMALAYMAILONLINE.COM/RECOMN)
PROJEKMMO(HTTP://M.THEMALAYMAILONLINE.COM/PROJEKMMO)
M (HTTP://M.THEMALAYMAILONLINE.COM/CHINESE)
MMOTV(HTTP://M.THEMALAYMAILONLINE.COM/VIDEOS)
NEWS(HTTP://M.THEMALAYMAILONLINE.COM/)
MALAYSIA(HTTP://M.THEMALAYMAILONLINE.COM/MALAYSIA)
MONEY(HTTP://M.THEMALAYMAILONLINE.COM/MONEY)
WORLD(HTTP://M.THEMALAYMAILONLINE.COM/WORLD)
LIFE(HTTP://M.THEMALAYMAILONLINE.COM/FEATURES)
SHOWBIZ(HTTP://M.THEMALAYMAILONLINE.COM/SHOWBIZ)
OPINION(HTTP://M.THEMALAYMAILONLINE.COM/OPINION)
WHATYOUTHINK(HTTP://M.THEMALAYMAILONLINE.COM/WHATYOUTHINK)
SPORTS(HTTP://M.THEMALAYMAILONLINE.COM/SPORTS)
EAT/DRINK(HTTP://M.THEMALAYMAILONLINE.COM/EATDRINK)
TRAVEL(HTTP://M.THEMALAYMAILONLINE.COM/TRAVEL)
READ(HTTP://M.THEMALAYMAILONLINE.COM/READ)
TECH/GADGETS(HTTP://M.THEMALAYMAILONLINE.COM/TECHGADGETS)
DRIVE(HTTP://M.THEMALAYMAILONLINE.COM/DRIVE)